A report on the abandonment of Fort Washakie, Wyoming, notes its historic role as the site of a major battle following the Custer massacre of June 1876, fought by General Nelson Miles against Northern Cheyennes, Arapahoes and Shoshones. It frames the fort's closing as the end of an era connected to the Indian wars of three to four decades earlier.
Omaha Daily Bee · 2 December 1908 · page 3
Orders bsva finally gone out for the aban nf Wit W a W la W v r mnA th ! transfer of the garrison of one company of tbs Eighth cavalry from that post to i Fort D. A. Russell. Wyo.. until quarter are compieiea ai r on kooiikoh, ,fo., ior the company. j With the abandonment of Fort Washakie there is extinguished the laat of the his toric forts and camp of the transmlssouri country around which clusters many great events In the Indian wars of thirty-five and forty years ago.
See moreSee less
It was In the vicinity of Fort Washakie that was fought one of the great and final battles of the Indian wars that followed the Custer massacre cf June. 1TT 8. Oeneral Neison A. Miles was in chief command of the regular troops at the time and the Indians opposing him were the Northern Cheyennes, Arapahoea and Shoshor.es. General Crook was en gaged In the farther north Black Hills country' against the escaping Sioux. The w Washakie, who la often referred to In Indian history as the double of the great chief Tecumeeh of the Shawnees of IS1.:, whom General William Henry Harrison overwhelmed' at the battle of Tippecanoe.
A 1908 newspaper column reprints a 30-years-ago item about Emanuel Custer visiting Frostburg, noting his son Gen. G.A. Custer was killed with his entire command at the Little Big Horn in 1876. The piece is local historical color unrelated to the day's news.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Republican · 3 December 1908 · page 5
j Storm, VV. Va., who purchased the | Henry Thompson farm near Kearney a 1 few months ago, was a pleasant visitor j to this office Tuesday afternoon. Mr. S. A. Kendall, of Meyersdale, Pa., spent a day or two in Oakland this j week on business. On the 19th inst. he will start for California where he ■ will spend a short time with his family who are wintering there. Mrs. H. R. Laughlin and little daugh ter, Rose Alice, went to Deer Park this | afternoon, where the little girl will re main some time as the guest of her grandparents, Dr.
See moreSee less
and Mrs. Laughlin. Her mother w,U return to the city to morrow evening. —Grafton Republican. Mr. J. Wilson Hunbird, of Cumber land, drove to Oakland Monday after noon in his new Steyen-Duryea touring car, arriving here within five hours af ter having left the starting point and returned to his home Tuesday, going by the way of the Northwestern pike, ac companied by Mr. D. E. Offutt, Sr. One of the tank cars composing the water train which is being used by the I Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Company to convey water from Oakland to points west, jumped the track at the Washing ton Spring crossing, west of town, on ! Monday, and delayed traffic for an hour or more. In the historical column “Thirty Years Ago,” appearing weekly in the Frostburg Mining Journal the following may be of interest to many Garrett countians, the principal character being a member of the Custer family well known in this county : “Frostburg was honored in a visit by Emanuel Custer, of Michigan. Mr. Custer was born at Cresaptown in 1806. In 1824 he emi grated to Michigan. He was a black smith—in youth an apprentice of George Seiss, grand father of Mrs. Marx Wine land, of this place. He remembered well when coal was hauled from Eckhart ito Cumberland by wagon. One of his sons, Gen. G. A. Custer, was a distin guished officer of the Union army during the Civil War, and in 1876 with his en tire command was slain in the battle of the Little Big Horn River by the Sioux Indians. In Cumberland Mr. Custer was the guest of Mrs. Georgie Willia a son, who accompanied him to Frostburg. Here both were guests of Marx Wine land.”
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
The article reports that Fort Washakie is being abandoned by the War Department, with its garrison transferred elsewhere. It recounts a garbled history of the fort's naming, claiming Chief Washakie led hostile Indians against US troops and was taken prisoner after a final battle following the Custer massacre.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Laramie Republican · 4 December 1908 · page 7
BY THE WAR DEPARTMENT AT LAST. Historic Post on the Grontier Has Outlived Its Usefulness And Will Be Bereft of Its Soldiery—Site of Great and Final Battle of the Noted Indian War. Orders have finally gone out for the abandonment of Fort Washakie, Wyo.. and the transfer of the garrison of one company of the Eighth cavalry from that post to Fort D. A. Russell, Wyo., until quarters are completed at Fort Robinson, Neb., for the company, says the Omaha Bee. With the aban donment of Fort Washakie there is extinguished the last of the historic forts and camps of the transmissourl country around which clusters many great events in the Indian wars of thirty-five and forty years ago.
See moreSee less
Great Final Battle. It was in the vicinity of Fort Washa kie that was fought one of the great and final battles of the Indian wars that followed the Custer massacre of June, 1876. General Nelson A. Miles was in chief command of the regular troops at the time and the Indians op posing him were the Northern Chey ennes, a Arapahoes and Shoshones. General Crook was engaged in the farther north Black Hills country against the escaping Sioux. The chief in command of the allied Indian tribes was Washakie, who is often re ferred to in Indian histo-y as the double of the great chief Tecumseh of the Shawnees of 1812, whom General
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 9 December 1908
The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va.
This item is a promotional synopsis for a sixteen-part serialized set of frontier stories by Buffalo Bill, running in the West Virginia News starting December 26, 1908. Among the adventures listed is installment 12, describing Custer's Last Fight, attributing it to Custer's desperation from humiliation and Reno's fatal indecision.
The West Virginia News · 5 December 1908 · page 5
By BUFFALO BILL
8. The Fort Phil Kearney mas sacre. Red Cloud’s defeat, in which the Indians lost 1,137 men. 9. Custer’s fight and Forsyth’s siege. Two scouts get through the Indian lines and bring relief. 10. R e c o v e r i n g a drove of horses from Indian thieves. Some thrilling experiences as chief of scouts under General Sheridan. 11. Greatest hunt of the plains. Buffalo Bill, General Custer and others teach the Grand Duke Alexis how to shoot buffalo. 12. Custer's last fight. Made desperate by humiliation. Reno’s fatal indecision.
See moreSee less
13. A lieutenant’s close call. Detached from command, he and a companion are caught in the enemy’s lines. Miraculous es cape. 14. How Buffalo Bill killed the celebrated Chief Yellow Hand in personal combat. One of the great scout’s heroic deeds. 15. One of the gamest Indian fighters. Buffalo Biil loses his shadow. General Charles King’s tribute. 16. Death of Sitting Bull. Char acteristics of the great chief. The Indians’ side of the irrepress ible conflict.
The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va. · 12 December 1908
The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va. · 19 December 1908
Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.
A 1908 advertisement for the 101 Ranch Wild West Show in Laredo describes its Native American performers, including several claimed to have taken part in the Custer fight, such as Flatiron, said to have urged warriors into battle, and three others reportedly involved in the massacre. The piece frames these figures as exotic attractions for the show's parade and performances.
Laredo Weekly Times · 6 December 1908 · page 6
while he holds a powwow Three other Indian warriors who had conspicuous parts in th* Custer massacre are members of the 10l ranch aggregation. They are Charlie-Owos the-Bog. Standing Cloud, and long Bull. They are loath to talk of the slaughter. Long
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The passage reviews Col. Cody's new book "True Tales of the Plains," describing its chapters on his meetings with Generals Sherman, Sheridan, and Custer, as well as accounts of the Custer massacre and the deaths of Yellow Hand and Sitting Bull. The reviewer praises the book as valuable firsthand historical testimony alongside its adventure stories.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 10 December 1908 · page 7
BUFFALO BILL'S HISTORY
Cody describes bis first mci'tings with Gen Sherman. Gen Sheridan and Gen Custer, the Grand Duke Alexis's buffalo bunt, the Custer mnssa-rc. the deaths of the lug chiefs Yellow Hand and Sitting Bull, ami other hair raising happenings of Indian fighting dnys. The historian will not neg lect this volume in his search for first hand testimony.
A Montana newspaper's historical sketch of pioneer John L. 'Lew' Fisco notes he was within thirty miles of Custer's battlefield at the time of the massacre but didn't learn of it until afterward. The piece recounts his life as a buffalo hunter and cowpuncher, part of a broader local history feature on old Roundup town.
The Roundup Record · 11 December 1908 · page 13
JOHN L. FISCO John L. Fisco, or Lew Fisco, as he is familiarly known, is perhaps the oldest resident of this section. He came to Montana in the seventies from Davenport, Iowa, and was within thir ty miles of Custer's battlefield at the
The Bismarck Tribune reprints a 1908 exchange of letters triggered by a Minneapolis reader's inquiry into a September 1874 letter written by then-editor Col. C. A. Lounsberry. That original letter described gold discoveries near Custer's Park by men including Ross, Reynolds, and Knappen, and noted the government's wish to keep the find quiet to avoid exciting trouble with the Indians.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 December 1908 · page 6
Dear Sir: ~~*~i I would like to get some Informa tion in regard to certain persons qten tiooed in ^letter which was published in the Bismarck Tribune ahout the I middle of September, J.874. I believe this letter was -written W "the editor of tflie Tribune, Colonel Lounsberry, and Consisted of bis view of the mat ter of finding gold in the Black Hills. In that letter Colonel Lounsberry mention® the masnes of a Mr. Ross, a 'Mr. Reynolds, a Mr. Knappen, and one other. The colonel states that all of these gentlemen found gold im tihe neighborhood of Custer's Park and
A 1908 correspondence discusses the 1874 Black Hills gold rush figures like Ross, Reynolds, and Knappen, noting Custer's secret support for gold-seekers despite orders to downplay the excitement. The writer recounts how gold specimens were shown to Grant and Congress, leading to the opening of the Black Hills, followed by the Little Bighorn expedition where Custer and Reynolds died.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 11 December 1908 · page 6
BISMARCIC DAILY TRIBUNE I. while givlng^OTery .lability to a bunch, ofiplhfrs ^iou4&coompaoied him to dia»ver gold. H. N. Ross was head of ^e ii^infng party and' aipeh, a printer employ^ on the Bismarck T^bune allowed to this par$. ^3h^rley Rey nolds andJohn Smith w$ft» of this party. It waa under&fcdod that they foiwid gold wjjiicli they, turned over, to Custer, "^ey ,sihdwed iie "colors"! and Rosa brought' considerable quartz home and, gave me a spedmen which sent to the Smithsonian Institute for analysis and their import showed about six dollars to Che ton of silver and a.
See moreSee less
trace of gold. It was 'merely a surface outcropping. In December that year, 1876, Ross' and otilfers went back from Bismarck and when they came home .they brought nearly an ounce of coarse gold from the French ^Creek region which Vl took to Washington and showed to General Grant, Secretary Belknap gad to the senate and house of representatives, rhe result wasi the opening of the Black HBlls, preceded, however, by the expedition, to the Little Big Horn, the death, of Custer, etc/ Reynolds was killed with Custer. Knappen was in mo sense a miner "or fitted for a mining region. He did Nothing with claim if he located It. Rose re turned to the Hllls with* the first par ty tihe following spring, remained there a successful miner until his dearth. Smith was a trader tshd I thtofe died at Miles City, engaged in the? liquor traffic. The particular and' where gold was ®Qund did develope in to a gold region lju&the diggings were deep platoer and^whil^-ia great deal of gold was gotten 6ut%iey were aban doned for tihe" Hidden Treasure and Homestake "region, at the head of Dead wood gudch, wihich* wsu3 exceed ingly rich placer-mining, ^he Dead wood region was not touched at the time of .the. Custer expedition, hut Crook City, only a short distance from (Continued on page .7^)' -if.: it-:. .. :-v'5 r4.
This is an advertisement for a touring stage play called 'Texas,' which features characters based on Custer and Buffalo Bill and dramatizes Custer's last stand at the Little Bighorn. The ad promotes the show's upcoming performance in Toledo, describing it as capturing a vanishing frontier era.
Perrysburg Journal · 11 December 1908 · page 4
CUSTER'S LAST FIGHT. In the history of tho United States there is no more Interesting period than that which embraces the Indian wars In our Western territory, and no more heroic figure than "General George Armstrong Custer." Another picturesque character and fearless Indian fighter, is known to the world as "Buffalo Bill." Around these two heroes of our country and Custer's
An obituary for Frank Elwin, who died at his daughter's home, recalls that he served as a messenger with General Miles at the time of the Custer massacre. The item is part of a local news roundup including other obituaries and county news.
The Colville Examiner · 12 December 1908 · page 4
Hurt Wednesday evening, after an illness of several years. He was born in Oxford, N. V., Oct. 29, 1858. He came west when a boy, and was a messenger wilh General Miles at the time of the Custer massacre. In 1883 he
This 1908 report from Pierre announces the death of Chief Hump, a Miniconjou Sioux leader who fought in several conflicts with whites including the Fort Phil Kearney campaign and the Battle of Little Bighorn in 1876. It recounts his later life as an Indian scout and policeman, his opposition to land cession efforts, his role during the Ghost Dance troubles, and his family lineage back to Black Buffalo who met Lewis and Clark.
The Madison Daily Leader · 16 December 1908 · page 4
Pierre, Dec. 15.—The death of Chief Hump, tbe Miniconyou Sioux, at bis home at Cberiy Creek station, seventy miles northwest of here, marked the passing of one of tbe last of the old time Sioux war chiefs. At the age of fi he was in conflict with ^the whites, at that time taking part in the battle of Kill Deer mountain in 1864. Later he was a follower of the noted Red loud through the Fort Phil Kearney ampaign, and was in the battle at -ittle Big Horn in 1876, at that time beinR one of the chief advisers of his ather, Fast Bull, who was one of the leaders in the campaign.
See moreSee less
But he was in the detachment detailed to hold the force of Reno, and was not in the main fight resulting in the death of Custer.
The Sioux City Journal reports the death of Chief Hump, a Miniconjou Sioux war chief, detailing his long career fighting whites from 1864 onward. It notes he fought in the detachment that held off Reno's forces at Little Bighorn in 1876, rather than in the main engagement that killed Custer.
Pierre Weekly Free Press · 17 December 1908 · page 8
SEyrsss iWAS NOTED SIOUX WARRIOR. Sioux City Journal: The death of Chief Hump, the Miniconyou Sioux,M his home in Cherry Creek station, sev enty miles northwest of Pierre, marked the passing of one of the last of the old time Sioux war chiefs. At the age of 16 he was in conflict with the whites, at that time taking part of Kill Deer mountain in 1864. Later he was a follower of the noted lied Cloud during the Fort lJhil Kearney campaign, and was in the battle at Little Big Horn in 1676,at that time being one of the chief advisers of his father, Fast Bull, who was one of the leaders in that cam paign.
See moreSee less
Hut he was in the detach men *, detailed to hold the force of Reno, and was not in the main tight resulting in the death of Custer. Shortly after this
This piece disputes a lecture by Doane Robinson, who argued Custer was not to blame for the massacre and that Reno was the coward who failed to support him. It recounts the battle's progression, claiming Reno was entrenched about ten miles from where Custer was destroyed, and that Custer's companies fought desperately in ravines and timber before being overwhelmed.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Mitchell Capital · 18 December 1908 · page 16
DOANE ROBINSON WRONG. Canton Leader.—It was 32 years last June since the nation was told that Gen. Custer and part of his regiment, the 7th cavalry, had been cut to pieces in a bloody battle among the bluffs bordering the Little Big Horn river in Montana. Much has been written of that event, and many stories have been told of how it happened and of the chief actors in that bloody drama, until the cowards in that unequal strife have been made heroes and the soldiers who died with Custer are blamed for the slaughter.
See moreSee less
In a recent lecture at Sioux City by mile beyond Calhoun, and .li r-»ouar Doane Robinson, secretary of the llisters of a mile beyond Keogh we found torical Society of this state, he di.s-jtho spot on which Custer and his two! cussed Sitting Bull and his qualities brothers and the gallant souls with! as a medicine man, and other matters him had gone down to a glorious reported by the Sioux City Journal, death while Reno and 380 men heard from which we quote the following: the Indian war souk and answered "It was Mr. Robinson's oxiinlon, renot. suiting from data gathered among "Capt. Yates and company sank the Indians, that Custer was to lio"in''t]ieir own blood around Custer, and blamed for the massacre^ and not Reno, whom military histories conpart of Captain Tom Custer's com demn for failing to go to Custer j)any met a similar fate in a seeniing aid. The distance from where Reno ]y bold dash down the slope to gain was entrenched to where the Custer ^]le timber on the river. Their bodies massacre took place, according to the were scattered along a deep ravine speaker, was about ten miles, and through which they "fought like had Reno started his cavalry off at heroes." full speed the horsemen, without any. interference, could not have got half way to Custer before the entire Custer force of 263 men was completely wiped out. According to the stories told by the Indians Reno did the only sensible thing and is deserving of .. ... great credit. The lecture was well attended and highly enjoyed by those present." Of course Mr. Robinson is not so much to blame for the story he tells because he had been told these things by men who didn't know the,ly facts, yet history would have ibim that Reno was the coward and.lng Benteen disobeyed orders in refusing faring distance of the struggle be to move rapidly ot Custer's relief. The editor of the Leader was per-| sonally acquainted with every officer, in the regiment from Gen. Custer,no aid. As before stated Reno was down, as well as the chief interpreter, over three miles away and could Fred Girard, who knew Sitting Bull jhear for years before that bloody June day in Montana. jan* Olrard accompanied Gen. Custer down without an effort to save him. until the command was divided about noon when the order to attack was given. Gen. Custer told Girard to accompany Maj. Reno, as he might need his services during the ap proaahing battle. We shall not go into details confrom the timber. cernlng the movements of Captain Mr. Robinson says Reno could not Benteen or Captain McDougal, who have got half way to Custer before were some in the rear when Custer Custer and his 263 men were wiped and Reno separated, but confine our out. Custer's command was not story to an interview we had with "wiped out" until near sundown, said Fred Girard on his return to Fort chief Gaul to the writer at Bismark Lincoln shortly after the slaughter, when he was returning to Standing "It was about 12.30 when Gen. Rock with Sitting Bull form Canada. Custer ordered Reno to cross the Lit-, chief Gaul was the real leader in tihe tie Big Horn and attack the Indian fight and as fine a looking Indian as village in sight and that he would we ever saw. Reno could have reach pass down the river and attack the ed the Indians around Custer in Indians at the other end1," said Mr.-thirty minutes had he so desired, and Girard to the writer. (we regret that Mr. Robinson should "Reno forded the river without get these historical facts so badly difficulty, and we found the Indians mixed. in hasty preparation for flight. We advanced to a body of timber and the order to dismount was given instead of charging the_ camp. When the troops were dismounted, both flanks were protected by the river and per fectly safe from attack on flank or rear. We advanced from the horses and took position in t,hc timber, and J*'1"1 every man fired from behind trees until the Indians were scattered and demoralized. If Reno had charged them he would have saved Custer from slaughter." "When Reno ordered his men to mount and retreat not a man had the-Face at Standing Rock after he been killed or even wounded, but in became a good Indian and was on the confusion of retreat we lost P°l'ce force. He did not claim that 140 men killed and wounded before the command gained the hill across Tom Custer, although he in common the river. When we began to retreat the scattered Indians picked up courage and followed us vigorously and Gen. Custer had one bullet in the they were all armed with rifles while the troops had carbines. ,not mutilated. His brother, Captain "For the time we crossed the river Custer, who arrested Rain-in-the-Face and attacked the Indians until our retreat, less than forty minutes had *n 1873, was dreadfully mutilated and elapsed. ih,s 'heart cut from the body. There "Custer after leaving Reno marched »tu« down the river about three miles before the savages attacked him as he approached the river from the bluffs. By this time Reno had retreated and the Indians quick to take advantage of the situation, massed their entire force around Custer and destroyed him and his men, although the un equal combat continued until near sundown. Reno was on the hill unmolested for over three hours while down the valley not over three miles away CusW'hen Congressman Martin as ter was fighting his last grand batsumed the vacancymade by the tie, while part of his regiment was death of the late Congressman Park withln supporting distance. Three er he received the salary of the dead hours before Custer was finished Bencongressman from the date of June teen and McDougall had joined Reno, 25, which amounted to a little over but fear and cowardice held Reno to 3,000. No wonder the democrats the bare hill where he retreated from were anxious to secure the election no danger." of their candidate for the short Mr. Girard, an old Indian fighter term. iglfpeg & and trader at Fort Buford for many years prior to this time, and a man of courage and thoroughly acquainted with Indian life, thus described the horrors of the battlefield as he saw I them in company with officers of Gen. eral Terry's command two days after.j "Capt. Calhoun's company had the advance and met the Indians near the river. He had evidently been ordered memorable to hold his ground against the savage onrush as his company had dismount ed and were found dead in company formation with Calhoun and Lieut. Critenden in place at the rear. "Capt. Koogli and his men I'eil 8s they stood fighting on a rids."- Ishr •, Captain Smith and his men and an( .s It was Qn the Btrength of Girar(1 statement that the writer wrote to Geneni) Sherldan giving hinl the ,ch upQn wh General sherldan ordered Reno court marshaled and upon the evldence presented to the court Reno was dismissed from the & service for cowardice, and this ought to be enough to convince Mr. Robi 1 son who was the. coward in the fatal encounter. Custer and his men died heroicalflShtinS n°t over three miles from to]dinhere Reno and 380 men were hold, ^molested, and witihin a h111 tween Custer and his savage foes. MrRobinson says Reno was ten ml'es disant and could have rendered firing for three hours. Reno the was stupefied with fear and cowardice allowed his gallant chief to go he Had Reno charged with, his full force after Benteen and McDougal came up, there is little doubt but the Indians would have retreated, be cause the squaws and children were in full retreat when Reno retired Had Ren(J fQUght ag Custer .s and had Beateen Qbeyed Cugter Qr ,e ders the baU Qf uttle H(jrn might haye proyed Custer,g lagt anfl •reatest Indian victory. The writer never discussed the baten, but many times tle with Bente McDougall and Weir, Captain both splendid soldiers. They 8PcaklnS °. 0t free hl of Ren ve SCen tears wel1 up ln the es °f of gallnnt Tom Weir as lle the terrible slaughter. The writer had a talk with Rainn- killed General Custer or Captain he circling Indians, fired as they with tlle aH fired to kill anyone in sight, breast and was head and one in hls billing the sutler of the regiment for Raln-in-the-Face did doubt thi® bitter'y he hated Tom Custer for his arrest and imprisonment. Raln-in-the-Face became famous for things he never did. The facts connected with Custer's bat"e generally known are not and as the writer had unusual means of learning the truth at the time from men who were under Reno, he takes this means of correcting Mr. Robin son's information "gathered among |ndjang the
A 1908 newspaper piece argues against Doane Robinson's version of the battle, praising Custer and Calhoun as heroes who died fighting while accusing Reno of cowardice and Benteen of disobeying orders. It claims Reno was court-martialed and dismissed from service for cowardice based on testimony from witnesses like Fred Girard.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Mitchell Capital · 18 December 1908 · page 16
DOANE ROBINSON WRONG. Canton Leader.—It was 32 years last June since the nation was told that Gen. Custer and part of his regiment, the 7th cavalry, had been cut to pieces in a bloody battle among the bluffs bordering the Little Big Horn river in Montana. Much has been written of that event, and many stories have been told of how it happened and of the chief actors in that bloody drama, until the cowards in that unequal strife have been made heroes and the soldiers who died with Custer are blamed for the slaughter.
See moreSee less
"It was Mr. Robinson's oxiinlon, renot. blamed for the massacre^ and not had Reno started his cavalry off at heroes." full speed the horsemen, without any. interference, could not have got half way to Custer before the entire Custer force of 263 men was completely wiped out. According to the stories told by the Indians Reno did the only sensible thing and is deserving of .. ... great credit. The lecture was well attended and highly enjoyed by those present." Of course Mr. Robinson is not so much to blame for the story he tells because he had been told these things by men who didn't know the,ly facts, yet history would have ibim that Reno was the coward and.lng to move rapidly ot Custer's relief. The editor of the Leader was per-| sonally acquainted with every officer, Fred Girard, who knew Sitting Bull jhear for years before that bloody June day in Montana. jan* until the command was divided about noon when the order to attack was given. Gen. Custer told Girard to accompany Maj. Reno, as he might need his services during the ap proaahing battle. We shall not go into details confrom the timber. difficulty, and we found the Indians mixed. in hasty preparation for flight. We advanced to a body of timber and the order to dismount was given instead of charging the_ camp. When the troops were dismounted, both flanks were protected by the river and per fectly safe from attack on flank or rear. We advanced from the horses and took position in t,hc timber, and J*'1"1 every man fired from behind trees until the Indians were scattered and demoralized. If Reno had charged them he would have saved Custer from slaughter." "When Reno ordered his men to 140 men killed and wounded before the river. When we began to retreat the scattered Indians picked up courthey were all armed with rifles while and attacked the Indians until our "Custer after leaving Reno marched »tu« down the river about three miles before the savages attacked him as he approached the river from the bluffs. By this time Reno had retreated and the Indians quick to take advantage of the situation, massed their entire force around Custer and destroyed him and his men, although the un equal combat continued until near sundown. Reno was on the hill unmolested for over three hours while down the Mr. Girard, an old Indian fighter term. iglfpeg & memorable an( ,ch upQn wh & 1 encounter. flShtinS n°t to]dinhere a h111 Mrml'es the was he ,e ders the baU tle with Bente Captain 8PcaklnS 0t free hl he with tlle aH for doubt thi® things he never did. bat"e are not |ndjang the
The report announces the death of Hump, a Minneconjou Sioux chief, at his reservation home near Cherry Creek, South Dakota, at age unclear due to OCR damage. It recounts his lineage and warrior history, noting he was present at the Little Bighorn fight but was with the detachment holding Reno's forces rather than engaging Custer's command.
Philip Weekly Review · 18 December 1908 · page 8
LAST OF A LINE OF SIOUX CHIEFS DIES AT HIS RESERVATION HOME
I'hil Kearney campaign. By the time of the campaign of I87t Hump was one of the chief advisoi^ of his father. Fast Bull, who was one of the leaders in that campaign. He was in the fight at Little Big Horn, but was with the detachment which was] holding Reno, and did not get into t-he tight with Custer. Soon after
The report details the life of Hump, a Minneconjou Sioux chief descended from Black Buffalo, who died at age 60 at his reservation home near Cherry Creek. It recounts his role fighting at Little Bighorn (with the Reno detachment, not Custer's), his later service as a government scout, and his involvement in events leading to Wounded Knee.
The Sisseton Weekly Standard · 18 December 1908 · page 12
LAST CHIEF OF SIOUX
trip up the Missouri in Jfi, and win afterward fought Ee. whites in their efforts to little the upper Missouri country. Hhen 10 years old Hiimn fought Be v.'iiites at Kildeer mountain H..18G-1, and hp followed Red Smid through the Fort Phil rearney campaign. By the time I the campaign of 187G, Hump Fas one uf the chief advisers of Is father, Fast Bu'l, who was ne of the leaders in that cam aign. He was in the fight at little Big Horn, butwas with he detachment which was hold og Reno, and die not get into he fight with Custer. Soon aft-r
The piece profiles Captain Grant P. Marsh of Bismarck, a veteran Mississippi River pilot visiting Dickinson, noting his memoirs soon to be published. It recalls that he commanded the steamboat that carried the wounded soldiers from the Custer massacre down the river.
The Dickinson Press · 19 December 1908 · page 9
Old River Captain
62 years on the Mississippi and die manuscript was acceptedtast month by the Outing Publishing Co. and will' soon be issued in book form on a royalty basis. The book promiess to bea great seller. The story of the Captain's life is full of exciting incidents. He was captain of the ship which removed the injured soldiers in the Custer massacre and cfirried them down the river. -He tells an interesting story of how he out witted the Indians on the trip. At a place in the river there was an island.
Captain Grant Marsh, who piloted the steamboat Far West that carried relief supplies and evacuated the wounded after the Little Bighorn battle in 1876, visited Dickinson in 1908. The article notes a forthcoming biography of Marsh by Joseph Mills Hanson, said to be historically accurate and expected to discredit false 'sole survivor' claims.
Bismarck Daily Tribune · 20 December 1908 · page 14
PIONEER RIVER PILOT VISITS DICKINSON
TER RELIEF BOAT IN '76. Dlckinson. Post: In Captain Grant Marsh, who arrived in the city Wed nesday from Miles City and visited here as the guest or Mr. and Mrs. H. M. Roberts until Thursday, when he returned to his home at Bismarck, Dickinson entertained one of the most'romantic characters among the central figures in the most romantic chapter of the northwest's history. Capt. Marsh etnjoys the distinction of being the master of the first steam boat, the "Key West," to explore the Yellowstone river and as 1f that was not sufficient honors, three years la ter, or in '76, commanded the "Far West," the relief skip which carried soldiers and supplies to the mouth of the Little Big Horn river and took back to Fort Lincoln the wounded from the battlefield on which Custer and his detachment met their death at the hands of Sitting Bull's braves.
A reminiscence describes being snowed into a dugout and visited by Sioux warriors led by a chief said to be the father of Rain-in-the-Face, who later killed Custer at Little Bighorn. The narrator survives on rationed food until rescued by a companion after nearly a month of isolation.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.
Wrong
The Morning Astorian · 20 December 1908 · page 10
In a later year killed General Custer at tbe memorable battle of tbe Little Big Horn. , I displayed my bandngea and related the mishap that had mad them necessary and refreshed th
A banquet at the Hotel Loyal marked the 42nd anniversary of the Fetterman massacre, attended by two survivors and General Charles Morton, who later oversaw disinterment of the ninety Fetterman dead for reburial at the Custer battleground on the Little Bighorn. Relics displayed included a recovered rifle and a scalp taken from a soldier killed by Red Cloud's band the year before the massacre.
Omaha Daily Bee · 23 December 1908 · page 8
ANNIVERSARY OF MASSACRE
United Statea army. Mr. Gibson and Mr. Petora were the only survivors of the tragic occasion, but General Morton was fifteen years later charged with the mourn ful duty of superintending the disinterment of the bodies of the ninety men killed in that affair and securing their reinterment at the Custer battleground on the Little
The Hazel Green Herald · Hazel Green, Ky. · and 9 other papers
A personal reminiscence describes being trapped in a dugout during a blizzard decades earlier, where an Indian war party led by a chief named Rain-in-the-Face (father of the famous warrior) spared the narrator's life due to a past kindness, though they stripped his supplies. The account identifies this chief's son as the Rain-in-the-Face who later killed General Custer at Little Bighorn.
The Hazel Green Herald · 24 December 1908 · page 4
I was in that place This chief was the father of the Rain In theFace who In a later year killed General Custer at the memorable battle of the Little Big Horn I displayed my bandages and related the mishap that bad made them necessary and refreshed the chiefs memory of a certain occasion when a blanket and provisions had drifted his way Rain n the Face re plied with proper gravity that he and his chums were out after scalps and confessed to designs upon mine but in consideration of auld lang syne he would spare the paleface boy Auld long sync however did pot spare the blankets and provisions and the bedizened crew stripped the dug out almost bare of supplies but I was thankful enough to see tho back of the last of them Two days later a blizzard set in I took an Inventory and found that economy considered I had food for a week but as the storm would surely delay Dave I put myself on half ra
The Sauk Centre Herald · Sauk Centre, Minn. · 17 December 1908
Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn. · 26 December 1908
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 26 December 1908
Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T. · 28 December 1908
The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont. · 30 December 1908
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 30 December 1908
Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 1 January 1909
Five Mile Beach Weekly Journal · Wildwood, N.J. · 15 January 1909
· · 6 March 1909
Five Mile Beach Weekly Journal · Wildwood, N.J. · 16 February 1917
The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.
State historian Doane Robinson responds to a critic's charge that he mischaracterized Major Reno's actions at Little Bighorn. Robinson recounts Reno's war record and the battle, then claims Reno was court-martialed and dismissed from the army for cowardice over his retreat and failure to relieve Custer.
MR. ROBINSON REPLIES State Historian Replies to the Criti cism of Col. Linn of the CmiTon Leader. BISPasS To tile Editor of the Republican: I observe you have given place to Col. Linn's criticism of mv remarks at Sioux City, under the caption, "Doane Robinson is Wrong." Per haps you will care to publish a brief statement from my point of view: Major Reno, a graduate of West Point, served throughout the war of the Rebellion with great distinction, being promoted five times lor gal lant conduct upon the battle field.
See moreSee less
After the war he served 011 the fron tier, meeting at all times with the highest approbation of his superiors, until, in 1S7G, he led a battalion of Custer's troops i.n the battle of Lit tle Big Horn. The Indian villages were strung for a distance of more than five miles along the west bank of the Little Horn, and Reno was directed to cross the stream to the west side and charge the upper vil lages, while Custer lead a battalion back to the river bluffs, down the east side to surprise and strike the lower village, the plan being to crush the savages between the two battalions. Soon after noon Reno crossed the stream and charged down the west bank, a large number 000,000. of Indiana retreated rapidly before him, and it appeared the way was easy, when suddenly he found him self surrounded by vast numbers of well armed savages, many times in excess of the little band lie led. In short lie had been neatly ambushed and believing his band doomed, if he did not retreat, lie cut bis way out, crossed the creek to the east bank and gaining the high ground hastily entrenched where he was ships besides." joined by Bentecn, with the third battalion and soon was besieged by a vastly superior force of savages who held him within his lines for more than twenty-four hours. Custer went down the oast side, opposite the lower village, rode in to an ambush and was destroyed. Reno was courtmartialed and dis missed from the service for coward Corn is up. ice in retreating in the first place and iu not going to the relief of Custer, when he readied the high ground on the east side. Reno's friends assert ed, and many have always believed it was a case where some one had to be crucified, as a vacations sacri fice for the Custer disaster, and he was made the victim. My part in the matter has simply been, with the utmost care, to col lect the testimony of many of the leadng Indians, who fought on that fatal day, and find out. their point of view, aud it was the Indian story which I told at Sioux City which pre cipitated the controversy. I have the story of Gall, the Sioux leader in the affair, of Rain in the Face, of One Bull, the son of Sifting Bull, and more than one hundred other warriors who fought there, and there is substantial agreement in all of their stories. They say they had as good an ambush laid for Reno as for Custer, but Reno got out of it, chiefly because he had better ground to work upon. That when Reno re treated and entrenched, from seven to eight hundred warriors were left to keep him from going to Custer's aid and that it would have been im possible for him to have reached Custer in any event. They testify that Custer's command was wholly annihilated in from fifteen to thirty minutes after the first shot was fired. That in the evening after the de struction of Custer, having succeeded so admirably in drawing him into an ambush, by sending the women and children away, as if the whole camp was in retreat, they tried the same tactics in view of Reno, but failed to draw him out. In short, they wholly exonerate Reno so far as they could understand the situation from their viewpoint. Personally, I know nothing of tlie record and from the Indian testif'a^med ,°yfr record and from the Indian testi mony. The Indians are the only per sons in a position to know what oc curred at the lower villages. From the manner in which the testimony was communicated to me from the character of many of the Sioux whose testimony I have, 1 have not a doubt they have told truthfully what occurred, and from a careful examination of the whole record I back." am inclined to the belief that Reno was sacrificed'.
Doane Robinson argues Reno was unfairly blamed for the Custer disaster, citing testimony from Sioux warriors like Gall, Rain in the Face, and One Bull who describe a planned ambush that trapped Custer but failed against Reno. He concludes the Indian accounts largely exonerate Reno, suggesting he was made a scapegoat.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
The Mitchell Capital · 24 December 1908 · page 11
MR. ROBINSON REPLIES State Historian Replies to the Criti cism of Col. Linn of the CmiTon Leader. BISPasS To tile Editor of the Republican: I observe you have given place to Col. Linn's criticism of mv remarks at Sioux City, under the caption, "Doane Robinson is Wrong." Per haps you will care to publish a brief statement from my point of view: Major Reno, a graduate of West Point, served throughout the war of the Rebellion with great distinction, being promoted five times lor gal lant conduct upon the battle field.
See moreSee less
After the war he served 011 the fron tier, meeting at all times with the highest approbation of his superiors, until, in 1S7G, he led a battalion of Custer's troops i.n the battle of Lit tle Big Horn. The Indian villages were strung for a distance of more than five miles along the west bank of the Little Horn, and Reno was directed to cross the stream to the west side and charge the upper vil lages, while Custer lead a battalion back to the river bluffs, down the east side to surprise and strike the lower village, the plan being to crush the savages between the two battalions. Soon after noon Reno crossed the stream and charged down the west bank, a large number 000,000. of Indiana retreated rapidly before him, and it appeared the way was easy, when suddenly he found him self surrounded by vast numbers of well armed savages, many times in excess of the little band lie led. In short lie had been neatly ambushed and believing his band doomed, if he did not retreat, lie cut bis way out, crossed the creek to the east bank and gaining the high ground hastily entrenched where he was ships besides." joined by Bentecn, with the third battalion and soon was besieged by a vastly superior force of savages who held him within his lines for more than twenty-four hours. Custer went down the oast side, opposite the lower village, rode in to an ambush and was destroyed. Reno was courtmartialed and dis missed from the service for coward Corn is up. ice in retreating in the first place and iu not going to the relief of Custer, when he readied the high ground on the east side. Reno's friends assert ed, and many have always believed it was a case where some one had to be crucified, as a vacations sacri fice for the Custer disaster, and he was made the victim. My part in the matter has simply been, with the utmost care, to col lect the testimony of many of the leadng Indians, who fought on that fatal day, and find out. their point of view, aud it was the Indian story which I told at Sioux City which pre cipitated the controversy. I have the story of Gall, the Sioux leader in the affair, of Rain in the Face, of One Bull, the son of Sifting Bull, and more than one hundred other warriors who fought there, and there is substantial agreement in all of their stories. They say they had as good an ambush laid for Reno as for Custer, but Reno got out of it, chiefly because he had better ground to work upon. That when Reno re treated and entrenched, from seven to eight hundred warriors were left to keep him from going to Custer's aid and that it would have been im possible for him to have reached Custer in any event. They testify that Custer's command was wholly annihilated in from fifteen to thirty minutes after the first shot was fired. That in the evening after the de struction of Custer, having succeeded so admirably in drawing him into an ambush, by sending the women and children away, as if the whole camp was in retreat, they tried the same tactics in view of Reno, but failed to draw him out. In short, they wholly exonerate Reno so far as they could understand the situation from their viewpoint. Personally, I know nothing of tlie record and from the Indian testif'a^med ,°yfr record and from the Indian testi mony. The Indians are the only per sons in a position to know what oc curred at the lower villages. From the manner in which the testimony was communicated to me from the character of many of the Sioux whose testimony I have, 1 have not a doubt they have told truthfully what occurred, and from a careful examination of the whole record I back." am inclined to the belief that Reno was sacrificed'.
The article describes a visit by Captain Grant Marsh, now 71, to Dickinson, recounting his famous role piloting the steamboat Far West that carried supplies to the Little Bighorn and brought back Custer's wounded. It also notes an upcoming biography of Marsh intended to definitively correct false survivor claims.
The Washburn Leader · 25 December 1908 · page 1
CAPT. MARSH IS ENTERTAINED
Firt Lincoln the wounded from tl^e battlefield on which Custer apd his detachment met their death at tne hands of Sitting Bull's braves. jcapt. Marsh, although~71 years
This is an advertisement for a serialized biography of Buffalo Bill Cody, listing chapters covering his frontier adventures including guiding generals, buffalo hunts, and Indian fights. Chapter 12 references "Custer's last fight" as one episode among many glorifying Cody's exploits with frontier military figures.
The Bowbells Tribune · 25 December 1908 · page 8
7. Riding with General Custer. How a mule outlasted a Kentucky thorobred—Two famous Indian fighteri 8. The Fort Phil Kearney massacre Red Cloud's defeat in which the Indians lost 1,137 men. 9. Custer's fight and Forsyth's siege —Two scouts get through the Indian lines and bring relief.
A large intertribal fair at the Crow agency in Montana drew over 5,000 Indians from many tribes, including veterans who had fought Custer at nearby Little Bighorn. The parade and ceremonies were described as a peaceful, philosophical embrace of change by former warriors.
The San Francisco Call · 27 December 1908 · page 5
CROW INDIANS
Little Big Horn river. At the foot bridge 15 .cent* admission to the camp ground was collected from all visitors. Svery morning at 10 o'clock the pa rade was formed. The leader ofthe
A 1908 report describes the Crow Indian fair held near the Little Bighorn battlefield, featuring gambling, craft exhibits, livestock, and horse races. It notes the presence of aging warriors who fought in the 1876 battle, including Curly, Custer's scout and the only survivor of his command, whose account of the fight was corroborated by later evidence.
The San Francisco Call · 27 December 1908 · page 5
The Ban Francisco Sunday .Call John L. Cowan NO Institution la more distinctively American than the country fair. Accordingly, the fact that the Crow Indians .have adopted tho