Alaska Sentinel · Wrangell, Alaska · and 2 other papers
Elizabeth Custer intends to build a home for impoverished literary women in memory of her husband, who died at Little Bighorn fighting the Indians thirty years earlier. She has purchased a site for the home in Bronxville, Westchester County, New York.
Alaska Sentinel · 5 November 1908 · page 2
THINGS YOU MAY NOT KNOW
Mrs. Elisabeth Custer Intends to build a home for Impoverished literary women as a memorial to her husband, who fell In the Little Big Horn light with the Indians thirty years ago. Mrs. Custer has recently bought a site for the proposed home In Broaivllle, West
Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis. · 15 August 1908
The San Juan Islander · Friday Harbor, Wash. · 5 September 1908
The San Antonio Light · San Antonio, Tex.
The report describes Lakota celebrity 'Iron Tail,' a star of Buffalo Bill's Wild West show, noting that as a young man he fought under Sitting Bull at the Battle of the Little Big Horn where Custer fell. It also mentions his fame during the show's European tour, including a meeting with Edward VII, ahead of a scheduled appointment with a mayor.
The San Antonio Light · 5 November 1908 · page 1
Greet Indian Chief Mayor Callaghan at the city hall at 10 o’clock Saturday morning. Chief “Iron Tail” is the greatest red skin celebrity extant. As a young man he fought under Sitting Bull at tho battle of the Little Big Horn, where Custer fell, and during the late tour of Europe by the Buffalo Bill Wild West show he was a great hit with
A New York newspaper reports that Walworth Henry Tappan, described as a survivor of the Custer massacre and an iron expert and mine owner, shot himself dead in a Fifth Avenue hotel, reportedly due to prolonged physical suffering. The report includes a mix-up over his identity with a bank cashier and notes his preparations to practice shooting before his death.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 9 November 1908 · page 10
SURVIVOR OF CUSTER MASSACRE ENDS LIFE
In Fifth Avenue Hotel New York. Nov. 9. Walworth Henry Tappan; survivor of the Custer massa cre, Iron expert, mine owner and spec ulator, shot himself dead in the Hotel Savoy, Fifty-ninth street and Fifth av enue. Constant? torture from the combined attack of sciatic rheumatism and neu ralgia, from which he had suffered for eighteen months, "was the supposed cause of the last act of this remarkable man. Mrs. Tappan had not seen her hus band since Friday. The first news she received of him was of his death. A rumor spread that the suicide was Walter H.
See moreSee less
Tappan. nssistant cashier of the National City bank (the Standard Oil bank). This rumor reached Vice President William A. Simonson of the bank, who hurried to the hotel after vainly , trying to call Mr. Tappan's home on the telephone. Mrs. Tappan fainted when she saw the body. "He had suffered so much, and when he did not come to our rooms I feared something was wrong." she said. On the body was found a note writ ten by Captain John F. Jenkins of Company C. Seventy-first regiment, asking the armorer to allow Mr. Tappan to use the rifle range for "tryouts." It was supposed that he wanted to practice shooting before attempting his own life. ! Mr. Tappan was fifty years old. He Is said to have made stock investments before election that netted him a small fortune. tims, j
A man named Tappan, who had twice been captured by Indians while serving with Custer, shot himself in a hotel billiard room after prolonged suffering from illness. A doctor who treated him said Tappan had often remarked that Miles should have moved faster to rescue Custer's command.
ten by Captain John F Jenkins of CompanyjC of the 71st regiment, ask ing the armorer to allow Mr. Tappan to use the rifle range for "try outs." It was supposed that he wanted to practice shooting before attempting his own life, but Dr. Peter J. Gibbons of No. 49 Park avenue, who had been treating Mr. Tsjppan, scouted this. He was an expert shot," said Dr. Gibbons. "He could hit a penny toss ed in the air. He was twice captured by the Indians while with Custer. I have often heard him say that Miles should have moved quicker to the rescue of Custer and his band.
See moreSee less
"There was no way to stop the pain which Mr. Tappan suffered, and he has been in torture for a year and a half. It seems almost Impossible that a man could suffer the torture he did and consent to live. I am not surprfsed that he killed himself. Another 'man mfs-ht hnvB iTnno En Innp ntro He was one of the most pleasant men j ever raet, and he was known all over tj,e j especially In the Iron trade." tlon that netted him a small fortune when the result became known. He leaves a wife. o
The report announces the final abandonment of Fort Keogh, Montana, which was established following the Custer massacre of June 1876, with its buildings to become Indian schools. It also notes that the U.S. government has rescinded an order to move Sitting Bull's remains from Fort Yates after Indian protests.
The National Tribune · 12 November 1908 · page 5
schools and homes for tho teachers etc Fort Keogh is the lust of the old reservations In Montana to be aban doned It was established closely fol lowing the Custer massacre in June 1876 and consisted of 57600 acres It is situated on the Yellowstone River three miles -from Miles City and the land is for the most part cleared and of a very fertile oil It will soon be opened by the Interior Department to settlers and eventually will become one of the finest farming sections in southeast Montana The detachment of troops now at Fort Keogh goes to Fort Lincoln near Bismarck N D
A dispatch from La Crosse, Wisconsin describes a funeral train passing through en route to the national cemetery at Gettysburg, carrying the exhumed remains of seventy-four soldiers killed with Custer at the Little Big Horn. The soldiers' original seventy-four battlefield tombstones were also reportedly being transported for reinterment.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
New-York Tribune · 12 November 1908 · page 14
[By Teiegraph 10 1h 1TIDURC. § La Crosse, Wis., Nov. 11.—A remarkable funeral train pased through Grand Crossing vesterday bound for the national cemetery at Gettysburg, Penn. The train contafped the bodies of seveniy four soldiers who were Killed in Custer’s last fight. at the Little Big Horn. They were buried at that place, and recently the bodies were exhumed, and are now on the way to the natiomal cemetery for reburial. Thare were also seventy-four tombstones, which marked the Custer battlefield. \
A trainload of 74 identified bodies of soldiers killed in the Custer massacre passed through Milwaukee, reportedly bound for Gettysburg National Cemetery. The gravestones that had marked their graves at the battle site were being transported along with the remains.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Star · 12 November 1908 · page 21
"Died" to Escape Hanging. OKLAHOMA CITY, November 12.?In-j stead of being dead and buried, J. A. ; Evans, noted bandit, has turned up in New Mexico, and the coffin over which; Evans* relatives mourned has been taken from, the grave and found to be filled with rocks. Evans was supposed to have ; been burled in March, 1SHK5, at the resi dence of his son on Little river, and by 1 his "death" escaped the hangman's knot. ; The coffin was burled with great solem-1 nity. While Evans, under the name of, John A.
See moreSee less
Wilson, was on a fast Santa Ke train speeding to New Mexico, and for the last two years he has lived there' unmolested. A few days ago a Seminole farmer, who was touring in New Mexico, came across Evans In real life. Sheriff Dotson of Wonoka, who started tho investigation after the report came back from New Mexico, has secured the confession of Evans" hired man, giving the whole story of Evans' mock deatli and burial and has gone to N^w Mexico with requisition papers to bring Evans back. Custer Massacre Bodies Transferred. MILWAUKEE. November Li.?A train load of corpses of victims of the Custer massacre passed through here bound for Gettysburg National cemetery. With the corpses were the gravestones which marked the graves at the scene of the massacre. The bodies removed numbered seventy-four, all that have been identified as members of the troop that was wiped out in the historic battle.
This is a chapter from a fictional serialized novel describing Custer's silent cavalry advance down a coulee toward the Sioux village, dramatizing the moments before the Last Stand. The narrative focuses on a character named Hampton and the emotional atmosphere among the troopers rather than factual reporting.
The Saratoga Sun · 12 November 1908 · page 4
CHAPTER XXXIV. The Last Stand. It was shortly after tw<s o’clock in the afternoon when that compact col umn of cavalrymen moved silently forward down the concealing coulee toward the more open ground beyond. Cubter's plan was surprise, the sudden smiting of that village in the valley from the rear by the quick charge of hls horsemen. From man to man the whispered purpose travelled down the ranks, the eager troopers greeting the welcome message with kindling eyes. It was the old way of the Seventh, and they knew It well.
See moreSee less
With Custer riding at the head of the column, and only a little to the rear of the advance scouts, his adjut (Continu ed Next Week G. H. Barkhurst and daughter Myrlie were down Saturday from Brush creek. Christmas Gilts Now ig the time to have that Christ mas Photo made. Your friends will be looking for it. Come early and give me a chance to do you good work. W. G. Pawwmore.
A funeral train carrying the remains of 74 soldiers killed in the Custer massacre passed through Wisconsin en route to Gettysburg National Cemetery for reburial. The original gravestones that had marked the bodies on the Montana battlefield were being transported along with the coffins to mark the new graves.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The San Francisco Call · 13 November 1908 · page 2
SPECIAL DISPATCH TO THE CALL LA CROSBE, Wis.. Nov. 12.— A fu neral train carrying the bodies of 74 victims of the Custer massacre in Mon tana passed through Grand Crossing yesterday, bound for Gettysburg, where they will again be buried in the na tional cemetery. With the coffins were the 74 gravestones that marked their resting places on the plain where the Irtdians attacked them. The same stones will mark the new graves in the southern cemetery. There will be a ceremony at Gettysburg when the bodies arrive for the second funeral. The train was In charge of a military escort.
A dispatch from La Crosse, Wisconsin describes a funeral train passing through Grand Crossing carrying the remains of seventy-four soldiers killed in the Custer battle, along with their original tombstones. The remains, previously buried near the battlefield, were being transported for reburial at the National Cemetery in Gettysburg.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.
Wrong
Weekly Watertown Leader · 13 November 1908 · page 6
WILL BURY CUSTER'S HEROES.
LA CROSSE, Wis.. Nov. 12.—A queer funeral train passed through Grand Crossing Tuesday bound for the National cemetery at Gettysburg. The train con tained the remains of seventy-four sol diers who were killed in the Custer bat tle. They were buried at that place and recently the remains were exhumed and are now on the way to the National cem etery at Gettysburg, where another bur ial will be had. There were also sev enty-four tombstones which were at the Custer battlefield graves.
A historian lecturing in Sioux City claims Sitting Bull was never a Sioux chief but a medicine man and priest who did not lead the attack on Custer. He says Sitting Bull merely watched from a nearby ridge while his young son relayed details of the battle to him.
The Madison Daily Leader · 14 November 1908 · page 2
Sioax City, Nov. 13.—"Sitting Bull never was chief of the Slonx Indians, said Doaue Robinson, secretary of the State Historical Society of South Da kota, in a lecture last evening before tbe Sioux City Academy of Science and Letters. "The pep"'""' conception that this famous Indian was a chief anu a warrior is a mistake," the speaker ad ded. "Sitting Bull was never a chief, much less an Indian warrior. He wan a high priest and medicineman. The very highest of the priests in the In dian religious worship. "Clever as a conjurer, a sleight, of hand man, a wonderful orator and a sbrewd statesman and diplomat.
See moreSee less
Sit ting Bull had perhaps more influence over the Indians than their greatest chief. At all times be was clever But at all times be jpposed the Chris tian religion and hated the white man. For Sitting Bull could aee^in the Chris tian religion a thing wbicb would rol bim of his power as medicine man. The famous old Indian never relent ed, although hia son has siace taken up the religion. "Many think that Sitting Bull actu ally led tbe Indians in tho famous Cus ter massacre. This is also untrue. Sitting Bull, as chief priest and medi cine man pitched his tent on a high ridge just away from the ambasb into which the troopers had leen drawn and there he made medicine. His son, One Bull, a lad of 15 years, was with him and stood outside his father's tent with a pair of field glasses and told the high priest tne details of the fight. One Bull later told me that the entire massacre from the first un til Custer's last man was slain did
A 1908 writer recounts how One Bull, Sitting Bull's 15-year-old son, watched the battle through field glasses and reported it to his father, saying the entire fight lasted only fifteen minutes with little soldier resistance. The piece also argues broken treaties and the Black Hills gold rush provoked the conflict, defending Indian actions against white encroachment.
The Madison Daily Leader · 14 November 1908 · page 2
Hills brought on the inevitable tight which was closed with the Custer massacre, and after which the Indians were scattered "Yonr military histories do not tell tbe same story that I get from the In diana. Mv tale comes direct from the Indians, who were bat youtbs when they participated in that great fight. One Indian in particular—1 cannot now call hia name~^told me that aa a 18-year-old boy he shot down three
A newspaper book review column discusses several new children's and adult books, including a patriotic jingle book depicting historical events like Custer's Last Stand, and 'Famous Cavalry Leaders' which includes a sketch of George Armstrong Custer among other military leaders. The passage is a literary review, not a direct news report on the battle itself.
The San Francisco Call · 15 November 1908 · page 7
ing the Delaware, Lee's surrender to Grant and Custer's last stand. • • :,•%; "Famous Cavalry Leaders." by Charles H. L. Johnston, la a book which will appeal to boys and adults alike. It is exactly what its title says of it. and its scope Is tremendous. Beginning *vith "Attila. the Scourge of God." th« book gives fine sketches of "Saladin." •Chevalier Bayard." "Guslavus Adol phus," "Marshal N'ey." "Joachim Mu rat," "Phil Sberldan." "George Arm strong Caster" and many others. Every one of the sketches In the book fs interesting ami some of the descriptions are thrilling. IJ Is a very useful addition to a boy's historic li
A South Dakota historian lecturing in Sioux City claims Custer, not Major Reno, was responsible for the disaster at Little Bighorn. He asserts Reno was ten miles away when the fighting began and rushed his cavalry to try to aid Custer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Evening Star · 17 November 1908 · page 11
BLAMES CUSTER FOR BATTLE.
1328 F Street. body In two. A brother of Helm has been Library committee, trustees?Angus La- ?>', arrested, he having accompanied Helm to avidson. N eS-Sn.SO nond, T. P. Culley, W. W. JPrescott. 1 the farmer's home. i i i iwcial Dispatch to The Star. J SIOT'X CITY. Iowa. Xovember 17.?A 'j| ew light was thrown on old Indian tra- ? Itlons bv Doane Robinson, secretary of ie Historical Society of South Dakota. *v is* evening when, in his lecture for the $ ead^my of Science and Letters at the !( ibrary building he declared that Sitting ull was never chief of the Sioux Injjt ians and that Cus'er was to blame for p ie massacre in which he was killed.
See moreSee less
Secretary Robinson said that Sitting 1 ull was a medicine man. but had a reater influence over those in his tribe tan the chief. He opposed the Christian X fligion because he had the foresight to Jy if* that Hb utlnnf inn V**r H->o - !(i ? j me iiiuiauo WUUJU ;y /entually rob him of his power. Despite le attitude of Sitting Bull, Rob'nson ft lid. the famous Indian's son abandoned f is father for the Christian religion.
A dispatch from Virginia reports that a funeral train carrying the remains of seventy-four soldiers killed in the Custer battle passed through Grand Crossing bound for the National Cemetery at Gettysburg. The remains, along with about forty gravestones from their original burial site, were being reinterred there.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Manitowoc Pilot · 19 November 1908 · page 2
WILL BURY CUSTER’S HEROES. Government to Inter Little Big Horn Massacre Victims at Gettyshurfg. i. \' K t (SS 1.. \\ iNov. 12 \ queer funeral train pas-ed through Grand I 'i —dug Tm-day bound for tin National . .-nietery and < ietiysln.rg. The train eon the remains of seventy foin* sol ■ I I who were 1 ilia'll in till ' 'lister bat tie. Tiny vver. buried at that place and ft eelllly the remains were \li ti nt, -. 1 ~,.,) re now mi (hi way to the .National cent '■let y tl G.
See moreSee less
tty - '.ill g, vv here .inolln r I iiv oii vv ill In bad Tin r. vv e. also . . ••uty 1-mi tomb-ioiies v lin li were at. the 'Jo :it >,.. 11 a-held -rav, -
This passage is a florid, novelistic account describing the initial Sioux and Cheyenne ambush on Custer's column, detailing the chaos, the cavalry's disciplined rally into a defensive line, and their desperate hope that Reno's reinforcements would arrive. It uses vivid, dramatic prose rather than factual reporting, describing troop positions (Calhoun, Keogh, Smith, Tom Custer) and the ebb and flow of the attack.
The Saratoga Sun · 19 November 1908 · page 3
Cine. ■ It was magnificently done. Custer ■and his troop commanders brought ■their sorely smitten men into a posi ■tlon of defense, even hurled them Cheering forward In short, swift Charges, so as to clear the front and Caln room in which to deploy. Out of Confusion emerged discipline, coaflCence, esprit de corps. ■ Safe beyond the range of the troopCrs* light carbines, the Indians, with ■heir heavier rifles, kept hurling a Constant storm of lead, hugging the Callies, and spreading out until there Cras no rear toward which the harass Cd cavalrymen could turn for safety.
See moreSee less
■Due by one, continually under a heavy ■lre, the scattered troops were formCd Into something more nearly reKembllng a battle line —Calhoun on ■he loft, then Keogh, Smith and with Tom Custer holding the , Cxtreme right. Thus they waited grim ■y for the next assault. Nor was It long delayed. Scarcely the troopers recovered, refilled ■heir depleted cartridge belts from sfeihose of their dead comrades, when ■he onslaught came. The soldiers ■ratted their coming. The short, ■brown barrelled carbines gleamed at level in the sunlight, and then forth their message of flame ■mto the very faces of those reckless , to bear such a blow. With ; of rage, the red braves ( to left and right, leaving . a dark, war-bedecked figure ly ■■g dead behind them, and many a pony akurrylng over the
The article reports on a lecture by Doane Robinson, South Dakota's historical society secretary, who argued Custer was to blame for the Little Bighorn disaster and that Reno acted sensibly by not attempting a rescue. The newspaper pushes back, accusing Robinson of making cowards into heroes and blaming the soldiers who died with Custer.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 20 November 1908 · page 10
We will sell for cash only. 00ANE ROBINSON WRONG In Recent Lecture in Sioux City lie Gets the Wronj lOnrt ot tlie Custer Battle, and Tries to Make lCeuo (lie Coward, a Hero. It was 32 years last June since the Look nation was told that Gen. Custer and part of his regiment, the 7th cavalry, had been cut to pieces in a bloody battle among the bluffs bordering the Little Big Horn river in Montana. Much has been written of that mem orable event, and many stories have been told of how it happened and of the chief actors in that bloody drama, until the cowards in that unequal strife have been made heroes and the gallant soldiers who died witli Custer are blamed for the slaughter.
See moreSee less
In a recent lecture at Sioux City by Doane Robinson, secretary of the Historical Society of this state, he discussed Sitting Bull and his quali ties as a Medicine man, and other matters reported by the Sioux City Journal, from which we quote the following: "It was Mr. Robinson's opinion, re sulting from data gathered among the Indians, that Custer was to be blamed for the massacre, and not Reno, whom military histories con demn for failing to go to Custer's aid. The distance from where Reno was entrenched to where the Custer mas sacre took place, according to the speaker, was about ten miles, and had Reno started his cavalry off at full speed the horsemen, without any Interference, could not have got half way to Custer before the entire Cus ter force of 263 men was completely wiped out. According to the stories told by the Indians Reno did the only 33ank sensible thing and is deserving of great credit. The lecture was well attended and highly enjoyed by those present." Of course Mr. Robinson Is not so much to blame for the story he tells because he has been told these things f" $ by men who didn't know the facts, yet history would have told him that Reno was the coward and Benteen 1?K disobeyed orders in refusing to move rapidly to Custer's relief. The editor of the LEADER was per sonally acquainted with every officer in the regiment from Gen. Custer down, as well as with the chief in terpreter, Fred Girard, who knew T?r*, Sitting Bull for years before that bloody June day in Montana. Girard accompanied Gen. Caster & until the command was divided about noon when the order to attack was iven. Gen. Custer told Girard to ompany Maj. Reno, as he might need his services during the approach ing battle. We shall not go into details con corning the movements of Captain Benteen or Captain McDougal, who were some distance in the rear when Custer and Reno separated, but con tine our story to an interview we bad with Fred Girard on his return to Fort Lincoln shortly after the slaugh ter, "It was about 12:30 when Gen. Cus ter ordered Reno to cross the Little Big Horn and attack the Indian vil lage in sight and that he would pass down the river and attack the Indians at the other end," said Mr. Girard to the Writer. "Reno forded the river without dif ficulty, anl we found the Indians in hasty preparation for flight. We ad vanced to a body of timber and^the order to dismount was given instead of charging the camp. When the troops were dismounted, both flanks were protected by the river, and per fectly safe from attack on flank or rear.. We advanced from the horses and took position In the timber, and every man fired from behind trees until the Indians were scattered and demoralized. If Reno had charged Diredtors them he would have saved Custer from slaughter." "When Reno ordered his men to mount and retreat not aman had been killed or even wounded, but in the confusion of retreat we lost nearly 40 men killed and wounded before the MAKES OLD! command gained the hill across the THINGS NEW river. When we began to retreat the scattered Indians picked up courage and followed us vigorously and they were all armed with rifles while the troops had carbines. From the time we crossed the river and attacked the Indians until our retreat, less than forty minutes had elapssd. Castor after tawing Bsno marched down the river about three miles be
A newspaper editor rebuts a lecture by Doane Robinson that praised Reno's caution and blamed Custer for the massacre. The editor insists, based on his own interview with interpreter Fred Girard, that Reno was a coward and Benteen disobeyed orders to relieve Custer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 20 November 1908 · page 10
We will sell for cash only. 00ANE ROBINSON WRONG In Recent Lecture in Sioux City lie Gets the Wronj lOnrt ot tlie Custer Battle, and Tries to Make lCeuo (lie Coward, a Hero. It was 32 years last June since the Look nation was told that Gen. Custer and part of his regiment, the 7th cavalry, had been cut to pieces in a bloody battle among the bluffs bordering the Little Big Horn river in Montana. Much has been written of that mem orable event, and many stories have been told of how it happened and of the chief actors in that bloody drama, until the cowards in that unequal strife have been made heroes and the gallant soldiers who died witli Custer are blamed for the slaughter.
See moreSee less
In a recent lecture at Sioux City by Doane Robinson, secretary of the Historical Society of this state, he discussed Sitting Bull and his quali ties as a Medicine man, and other matters reported by the Sioux City Journal, from which we quote the following: "It was Mr. Robinson's opinion, re sulting from data gathered among the Indians, that Custer was to be blamed for the massacre, and not Reno, whom military histories con demn for failing to go to Custer's aid. The distance from where Reno was entrenched to where the Custer mas sacre took place, according to the speaker, was about ten miles, and had Reno started his cavalry off at full speed the horsemen, without any Interference, could not have got half way to Custer before the entire Cus ter force of 263 men was completely wiped out. According to the stories told by the Indians Reno did the only 33ank sensible thing and is deserving of great credit. The lecture was well attended and highly enjoyed by those present." Of course Mr. Robinson Is not so much to blame for the story he tells because he has been told these things f" $ by men who didn't know the facts, yet history would have told him that Reno was the coward and Benteen 1?K disobeyed orders in refusing to move rapidly to Custer's relief. The editor of the LEADER was per sonally acquainted with every officer in the regiment from Gen. Custer down, as well as with the chief in terpreter, Fred Girard, who knew T?r*, Sitting Bull for years before that bloody June day in Montana. Girard accompanied Gen. Caster & until the command was divided about noon when the order to attack was iven. Gen. Custer told Girard to ompany Maj. Reno, as he might need his services during the approach ing battle. We shall not go into details con corning the movements of Captain Benteen or Captain McDougal, who were some distance in the rear when Custer and Reno separated, but con tine our story to an interview we bad with Fred Girard on his return to Fort Lincoln shortly after the slaugh ter, "It was about 12:30 when Gen. Cus ter ordered Reno to cross the Little Big Horn and attack the Indian vil lage in sight and that he would pass down the river and attack the Indians at the other end," said Mr. Girard to the Writer. "Reno forded the river without dif ficulty, anl we found the Indians in hasty preparation for flight. We ad vanced to a body of timber and^the order to dismount was given instead of charging the camp. When the troops were dismounted, both flanks were protected by the river, and per fectly safe from attack on flank or rear.. We advanced from the horses and took position In the timber, and every man fired from behind trees until the Indians were scattered and demoralized. If Reno had charged Diredtors them he would have saved Custer from slaughter." "When Reno ordered his men to mount and retreat not aman had been killed or even wounded, but in the confusion of retreat we lost nearly 40 men killed and wounded before the MAKES OLD! command gained the hill across the THINGS NEW river. When we began to retreat the scattered Indians picked up courage and followed us vigorously and they were all armed with rifles while the troops had carbines. From the time we crossed the river and attacked the Indians until our retreat, less than forty minutes had elapssd. Castor after tawing Bsno marched down the river about three miles be
An old Indian fighter named Girard recounts visiting the battlefield two days after the fight, describing how Custer's companies under Calhoun, Keogh, and Yates died in sequence while Reno remained safely on a hill. The account harshly accuses Reno of cowardice for not advancing to support Custer despite being within three miles and having no immediate threat to his own position.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.
Wrong
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 20 November 1908 · page 10
r^. $K fore the savages attacked him as lie approaclicd the river from the bluffs. By this time Reno had retreated and the Indians, quick to take advantage of the situation, massed their entire force around Custer and destroyed him and his men, although the un equal combat continued until near sundown. Reno was on the bill unmolested for over three hours while down the valley, not over three miles awaj, Custer was fighting his last grand battle, while part of his regiment was within supporting distance. Three hours before Custer was fin ished Benteen and McDougal 1 had joined Reno, but fear and cowardice held Reno rooted to the bare hill, where he retreated from no danger."
See moreSee less
Mr. Girard, an old Indian fighter and trader at Fort Buford for many years prior to this time, and a man of courage and thoroughly familiar with Indian life, thus described the hor rors of the battlefield as he saw them in company with officers of Gen. Terry's command two days after. Capt. Calhoun's company had the advance and met the Indians near the river. He had evidently been ordered to hold his ground against the savage onrush as his company had dismounted and were found dead in company formation with Calhoun and Lieut. Critenden in place in tbe rear. Capt. Keogh and his men Tell as they stood fighting on a ridge half a mile beyond Calhoun, and three quarters of a mile beyond Keogh we found the spot on which Custer and his two brothers and all the gallant souls with him had gone down to a glorious death while Reno and 380 men heard the Indian war song and answered not. Capt. Yates and his company sank in their own blood around Custer, and Captain Smith and his men and part of Captain Tom Custer's company meta similar fate in a seemingly bold dash down the slope to gain the timber on the river. Their bodies were scattered along a deep ravine through which they fought like heroes." It was on the strength of Girard's statement that the writer wrote to General Sheridan giving him the facts, upon wnich Gen. Sheridan or dered Reno court marshaled, and upon the evidence presented to the court Reno was dismissed from the service for cowardice, and this ought to convince Mr. Robinson who was the coward in that fatal encounter. Custer and his men died heroically fighting not over three miles from where Reno and 380 men were hold' ing a hill unmolested, and within bearing distance of the struggle be tween Custer and his savage foes. Mr. Robinson says Reno was ten miles distant and could have rendered no aid. As before stated Reno was not over three miles away and could bear the firing for three hours. Reno was.stupified with fear and cowardioe and he allowed his gallant chief to go down without an effort tosave him. Had Reno charged with his full force, after Benteen and McDougal came up, there is little doubt but the Indians would have retreated, because the squaws and children were in full retreat when Reno retired from th6 timber. Mr. Robinson says Reno could not have got half way to Custer before Custerand his 263 men were wiped out Custer's command was not "wiped out" until near sundown, said Chief Gaul to the writer at Bismarck, when he was returning to Standing' Rock with Sitting Bull from Canada. Chief Gaul was the real leader in that fight and as fine a looking Indian as we ever saw. Reno could have reached the Indians around Custer in thirty minutes had he so desired, and we re gret that Mr. Robinson should get these historical facts so badly mixed. Had Reno foaght as Custer fought, and had Benteen obeyed Custer's orders, the battle of tbe Little Big Horn might have proved Custer's last and greatest Indian victory. The writer never discussed the bat tle' with Benteen, but many times with Captains McDougall and Weir, both splendid soldiers. They were not free in speaking of Reno, but we hare seen the tears well up in the eyes of gallant Tom Weir as he spoke of the terrible slaughter. The writer had a talk with Rain-in the-Face at Standing Book after he
The report states that remains of victims from the Custer massacre, originally buried at the battle site, are being relocated to Gettysburg for interment in the national cemetery. It notes that 74 bodies have so far been identified as members of the famous troop.
A local news column notes that editors Hackett and Linn and historian Doane Robinson are engaged in an ongoing disagreement over who was to blame and the facts surrounding the Custer massacre. The writer jokes that since none of them agree, the public is left uncertain what to believe, hoping for a joint authoritative statement someday.
Turner County Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 5
Doane Robinson are engaged in an earnest discussion aa to the manner and blame for the Custer massacre. As no two seem to agree in regard to
James O'Sullivan, a Civil War veteran who later served in the Indian wars under General Miles, died at the Orting Soldiers' Home on November 12, 1908. The obituary notes he was with Reno's command at the time Custer was killed by the Sioux.
Aberdeen Herald · 26 November 1908 · page 5
DEATH OF OLD SOLDIER.
Thimble Club. The W. C. T. U. gave a large bo quet.of sweet peas. Mrs. Anna G. Cary and Mrs. E. Wickland each sent choice flowers. Mr. James O'Sullivan was born In Ireland, Dec. 25th. 1842, coming to America three years later. In Octo ber, ISC3, he enlisted in the 30th Regiment of Wisconsin Volunteers, and was mustered out at the close of the Civil war. He afterwards serv ed in the Indian wars under General Miles, and was with Reno at the time that Custer was killed by the Sioux.
See moreSee less
He was of a quiet, retiring dispo sition, and rarely referred to the stirring scenes of his early life. He is survivied by a widow living in Chippewa Falls, Wis., and daugh ter, Mrs. John McNamara, of this city. He died at Orting, Wash.,
The report is an obituary for David H. Pingree, a former 7th Cavalry trooper, crediting him with coining the rallying cry 'Remember Custer' and helping defeat Sitting Bull's warriors in a legendary revenge battle. It frames this as the decisive avenging of Custer's 1876 defeat at Little Bighorn.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Newtown Bee · 27 November 1908 · page 3
You remember the story in the his tory books about the massacre of Gen Custer in the Bad Lands of South Da kota, do you not? Especially you re member the stirring incident of the time when the troop who had been sent to revenge the death of the gallant lead er and capture the redskin chief, Sit tine Bull, wavered and were about to retieat before the withering fire poured out upon them from ambush, a soldier rose in his saddle and cried aloud: "Remember Custer." Only two words, but they made history. The soldiers rallied, taking these words for their battle cry and charged, inflicting the
Doane Robinson responds to newspaper criticism of his address on the Custer battle, explaining his sixteen years of research including interviews with over a hundred Indian participants. He describes gathering testimony from Gall and Rain in the Face in 1892, noting that establishing historical truth is difficult since every witness sees events from their own perspective.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 27 November 1908 · page 1
DOANE ROBINSON EXPLAINS
in the Custer Battle as Gathered Pierre, November 21st, 1008. To the Editor of the kus' Lisadek: 1 thank you for the tnarKed copy of the 2oth containing your criticism of ray address before tiie Academy (if Science and Letters. The newspapers did not report my remarks quite correct ly but the portion you quote is essen tially as I said it. Perhaps there is nothing more dif iicuit than to establish the truth of a past occurance. Every trial in a court of justice determines that, for every one sees events from his own standpoint, and views will always be divergent as viewers.
See moreSee less
It is more than sixteen years since I began to accumulate testimony upon the bat tle of Little Bighorn: I have the tes timony of more than one hundred participants, and still I would not dogmatically state that any version is strictly true. In 1892 1 spent three days with Gall, not Gaul as you print it. His Sioux name is Ta-pisa, meaning the gall of an animal, and Rain in the Face, together with more than one hundred of the warriors who fought at Little Bighorn and we went very carefully over the whole situation. Gall made the map at that time which I printed in my history of the Sioux. The warriors corrected each from Indians. akota akmwith many others. of the kadkk
A historian describes interviewing Gall, Rain in the Face, and over a hundred warriors starting in 1892, then revisiting Grand River in 1908 with a stenographer to cross-question survivors like pastor Wakutemane about disputed points. The testimony addresses Reno's conduct, the time of day of Custer's fight, and claims the battle lasted only fifteen to thirty minutes with Custer's men offering little organized resistance.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 27 November 1908 · page 1
in the Custer Battle as Gathered from Indians. other and certainly endeavored to get at the facts. Afterwards I conversed akota akmwith many others. Since I printed my story several of the kadkk criticisms have been made upon it and witli these in hand, I, this last summer, went to Grand river, taking a stenographer witli me and cross questioned many of the most reliable survivors of the Little Righorn upon the points disputed. One of the best witnesses is Mr. Wakutemane, pastor of the Congregational church at Little Eagle. The points involved were the conduct of Reno: the time of clay of the Custer tight and the length of time involved in the battle before Custer was utterly destroyed.
See moreSee less
Mr. Wakutemane is a very intelligent man and entirely reliable. He was sixteen years of age when tlie fight occured and killed two of Custer's men with a six inch pistol. He said the light occured in the middle of the afternoon and that Custer did not last more than fifteen minutes until the last soldier was dead. He admit ted that in the excitement of battle a man did not take much account of time, but that it could not, under any circumstance have been more than a half hour. That it was all over while the sun was high up in the sky, indicating from two to three o'clock. lie said Reno did the only
A researcher recounts interviewing Lakota witnesses including Wakutemane, Gall, Rain in the Face, and One Bull about the Little Bighorn battle decades later. The account defends Reno's conduct as soldierly, describes overwhelming warrior numbers separating his force from Custer's, and disputes distances and details given in earlier official reports like Terry's.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 27 November 1908 · page 1
thing a soldier could have done. That as good a trap was laid for Reno as for Custer, but he got out of it. That the theory that Custer dis mounted ids men and fought them in order was preposterous. That Cus ter's men seemed paralyzed and put up no serious resistence. He ac counted for the fact that the bodies of the men and horses were not to gether on the ground that the tirst volley was fired from rest and with good aim and the men fell from the horses which run back and were killed in the general fusilade that fol lowed.
See moreSee less
That under no circumstance could Reno have readied Custer be fore lie was destroyed, but that the Indians had looked out that the two battalions should not support each other by leaving eight hundred war riors to keep Reno busy. Gall and Rain in the Face had prev iously told ine the same story. In addition to Wakutemane, I inter viewed several other very excellent witnesses this summer, separately, and all corroborated what he said, especially One Bull, the son of Sitting Bull. I regret that 1 have not been able to visit the battle field. There is a dispute about the distance from Reno's entrenchments to the Custer field, but at the Reno court martial the undisputed testimony was that it was twelve miles. The Indians say ten miles. General Terry said in his report about three miles, but from the testimony of every one I have seen it was much further than Terry thought it to be. The Indians explain the gun fire which Reno heard at six o'clock on the evening of the 25tli as being a general celebration which they were having over their victory. While I gave my version as simply
The article reports a controversy sparked by historian Doane Robinson's version of the Custer battle, criticized by Col. Arthur Linn. It details conflicting Indian and military accounts of the battle's duration, the distance between Reno's position and Custer's, and whether Reno could have reinforced Custer.
The Aberdeen Democrat · 27 November 1908 · page 4
ABOUT THE LITTLE BIG HORN. Doane Robinson, the well-known authority on things historical, seems to have aroused a storm of criticism by his version of the Custer battle on the Little Big Horn, given in an address at Sioux City recently. Re garding this the Pierre Dakotan says: Ool. Arthur Linn, in his Dakota .Farmers' Leader devotes a couple of columns to a criticism of Doane RobReno is blamed for not going to Custer's"aidTbut the Indians declare it would have been Impossible, be cause eight hundred warriors block ed the way and because Custer was destroyed so quickly Reno could not have reached him over an unob structed road.
See moreSee less
The Indian view is that Custer's command did not last more than fifteen minutes to a half hour after the first gun was fired, while the military idea is that he fought from 2 o'clock until 6 p. m. The Indians say not a Boldier was alive at 3 p. m. Reno heard firing as late as 6 o'clock in the direction of Custer's battlefield, but the Sioux explain that this was but a celebra tion of their victory by the young men. There is a dispute about the dis tance from Reno's intrenchment to the point where Custer fell. Terry in his report said it was about three miles. The evidence in the Reno court-martial said it was twelve miles, and the Indians say that by the course. Reno would have been compelled to travel it was ten miles. The foregoing are the chief points in the contention. There is a cloud of witness on both sides. The Sioux testimony is certainly worthy of con sideration and should be given the weight to which it is entitled before arriving at a conclusion. inson's address upon the Custer bat
This piece contrasts a military historian's harsh view of Major Reno as a coward with the Sioux account, which praises Reno for avoiding an ambush trap at Little Bighorn. It notes Reno was court-martialed and acquitted but remains a controversial figure, with the Sioux narrative credited as closer to actual events.
Ills shrewdness in keeping out of the trap l%id for him. He rode into a trap and got out of it, and thoiigh the Indians laid another clever trap for him, he refused to be drawn into it. By sending the women and chil dren scurrying away as it the camp was in full retreat they drew Custer down into the ambush which proved so fatal. They went then to the up per village In view of Reno and at tempted the same ruse without suc cess.
A 1908 nostalgia column reprints trivial local news items from November-December 1878, including a visit by Emanuel Custer, father of Gen. George A. Custer, to Frostburg, Maryland. The item notes Custer's son was a Union Civil War officer who was slain with his entire command at the Little Bighorn battle against the Sioux.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Frostburg Mining Journal · 28 November 1908 · page 3
Smash, died Friday. November 23, 1878. Misses Sadie and Nannie K Mason, of Sagertown. Pa., visited their brother, Hiram Mason, of this place. A Garrett county hunter shot at 8 deer, struck 2. got none. Not much danger to deer in liis immediate neighborhood—unless one should contract blood poison by biting him. Messrs. William J. Cooper and Lincoln Albright., of this place, returned from a 2weeks cruise along the South Branch with a tring of bass weighing <SO jxmmls. I). W. Sloan, of Lnnaconing, in Scotland, was expected to reach home shortly.
See moreSee less
Dr. George Sloan, of lowa, had informed his home folks that he would spend the holidays with them. R. M. Wildermaii presented the Journal with a holiday supply of “fresh domestic mi nee-meat.” The deer which jumped into J. J. Hoblit zell’s garden the week before bad a broken, bleeding jaw. made by a shot by John H. DeMoss. Much was re|K>rted in the papers of ‘ the electric light,” a new invention. Frost burg was honored m a visit by Emanuel Custer, of Michigan. Mr. Custer was born at Cresaptown in 180(5. In 1821 he emigrated to Michigan. He was a black smith—in youth an apprentice of George Seiss. grand father of Mrs. Marx Wineland, of this place. He remembered well when coal was hauled by wagon from Eckbart to Cumberland. One of his sons, Gen. G. A. Custer, was a distinguished officer of the Union army during the Civil War, and in with his entire command was slain in the battle of the Little Big Horn River by the Sioux Indians. In Cumberland Mr. Custer was the guest of Mrs. Georgie Wil liamson, who accompanied him to Frost burg. Here both were guests of Marx Wineland. Monday, December 2d, R. C. Paul cap tured a web-footed water-fowl of the order ousters, and family anathhw, popularly known as “wild duck.” The Grant Coal and Iron Company, in charge of W. A. Monteil and Jonathan Katdiffe, expected to reach coal at an early day. J. H. Howie, superintendent of Midlothian mine. New (Central Coal Company, resigned and returned to bis old home in Scotland. At the meeting of the Fire Department Tuesday evening, November 3d, Benjamin Bowen was elected president. Thomas H. Harnill vice-president, and Theo. Gunnett sergeant at-arms Duncan J. Sloan of liOiiaconing, reported quite ill with quinsy. The Meyersdale (Pa) Comint rein! made complimentary references to James J. Hob litzell, W. T. Hohlitzcll and C. 11. Hartzell, all well know n here. At the English Lutheran parsonage Thurs day evening, December 5, 1878, Miss Nellie V. McMullen was married to Mr. George M. Porter, both of Eckhart, by Rev. P. L. Harrison. F. E. Brackett, superintendent of the Maryland Coal Company, removed from Frostburg to Lona^oning. John Gnagey. of Accident, Garrett county, shot and killed a deer without perforating the hide or milling a hair. How was it done? Inquire at the Journal office. The Reform Club organized “the other night when all around was still” by electing J. W. J. Englar, M. I)., president, D. G. Percy, vice-president, T. S. Preston secre tary, and Alexander Tennant treasurer. The last named was clubbed into tilling a ♦ l,00i)-boiid. After the president iiadspokeu half his inaugural the Club rose ami the president sat. The secretary read the 7th verse of the 7th chapter of the Heptameron. The president finished his inaugural. The Clubuskel nobody to join; its select mem bers were clubbed in. The Club has its eye on two men now. They will he seize l next Thursday night at a place and hour they think not.” Nobody knew where or when the Club met; the members didn't know themselves, except after a series of irregular rotatory displays of the heptahe lron nu meral. A club was the symbol of fraternity. W. H. Koch, C. A P. R. agent, distributed a carloal of coal to the poor. Personal. Geueral superintendent H. V. Hesse, of the Consolidation Coal Company, of this place, will attend the American Mining Congress at Pittsburg, Pa., next week—December 2-5, and it is safe to say there will lx* few in that body more capable of discussiug underground problems. Mrs. Mary J. Rank and sou, J. LindIcy, spent the latter part of the week with Mr. and Mrs. J. Fred. Dillon, at Simpson, W. Va. Mr. and Mrs. Peter Kauffman, of Lawson, Colorado, are visiting Rev. aud Mrs. (J. E. Metger. Mr. L. is a mining superintendent in the R xrky Mountains, and lives 8,000 feet above sea level. J. H. Griffith, of Raleigh, N. 0., is the guest of John W. Arnold, Loo street and Broadway. Mr. G. has not been in good health aud is here recuperating, “that,” lie says, “with good results.” Lloyd F. Taylor, formerly of this place, was a visitor to old friends here Tuesday. Miss Goldie, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Peter La miner r, is visiting Philadelphia friends. M* and Mrs. J. W. Good, of Kansas City, Mo., who have been making a tour of the east aud visiting their mother, Mis. J. W. Hausell, of Allegany Grove, left Tuesday for the west, expecting to reach their home in Kansas city next Tuesday. Miss Winona Taylor, daughter of Lloyd F. Taylor, formerly of this place, has been accepted at the Garfield Me morial Hospital*, Washington, as a stu dent in three-years course for graduate nurses. She passed all the preliminary examinations. Charles Leatham, jr., ot Uniontown. Pa., is visiting his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Leatham, of this place. Good to Her. The Fast National Bank presented Mrs. Isabella H. Campbell, widow, with a basket of choice provisions for Thanks giving aud several succeeding days. The good old lady is very grateful. Ilik'CiiNO Granted. Dastardly Act. During last Sunday night a thief or thieves entered the chicken preserves of John Tiley, residing in Grahainton, killed and carried away fifteen tine chickens, leaving the heads in the chickrn-honse. “The Majestic.” It reqnired strenuous work by George J. Wittig to get “The Majestic” ready a residence section of tin* town. . for opening Thanksgiving Day, but he succeeded, and the crowd of visitors The Sick. taking part in the sports and viewing the ball was immense. The hall is 14 feet high, 17 feet wide, and 15(5 feet long, and, with its variety of embellishments, presents a strikingly typhoid lever. fine appearance. The front portion, finished in dull golden oak, is occupied by ‘wo pool tables, au elaborate cigar-stand, and other fixtures, including toilet accom modations. The bowling-alley department, fin ished in natural wood and white-coated walls, is equipped with three alleys and the usual accompanying paraphernalia. The fhxjr throughout is white maple, altogether a wood-work accomplishment Business Locals. reflecting great credit upon the t i*te and skill of the contractors, Messrs J. John son & Son. As time proceeds George will add to both equipment and decoration all that may be lacking, if anything, and have the finest place of its class in the county
This 1908 article recounts a criminal's escape via balloon from Monroe, Michigan, noting the town's fame as Custer's childhood home. It references his death at Little Bighorn only as a widely known historical aside, not as its main subject.
The Spokane Press · 28 November 1908 · page 5
ESCAPED BY BALLOON
.ell be the title of a yellow backed ovel, written around the thrilling escape from bloodhounds of the 'aw by a man wanted by the Ohio authorities for larceny. The great getaway was made from this village, on the banks of the his oric Rivet Rasln, whose claim ta fame is that it was the home Of Gen. George Custer, whose death battle with the Indians ou the Little Big Horn Is known to