As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

March 1899

35 articles

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

This brief biographical sketch of General Otis, commander at Manila, notes his Civil War service and wounds, and mentions he gained experience 'punishing Sitting Bull after the Custer massacre.' It praises his legal background and discipline as reassuring for his current role fighting Aguinaldo in the Philippines.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 4 March 1899 · page 4

Otis, the Lawyer and General. The administration reposes great confidence in General Otis. It is little feared that he will make any mistakes at Manila either as an interpreter of international law or as a commander. General Otis is almost sixty years old. He entered the army during the civil war as a captain in the One Hundred and Fortieth New York Volunteers, was brev eted twice in the Virginia campaign for gallant services, was severely wounded in one of the James river engagements, became a lieutenant-colonel in the regular army in 18G6, and while punishing Sitting Bull after the Custer massacre, gained some experience which has been useful in his dealings with Aguinaldo.

See moreSee less

He is a strict disciplinarian and his troops are never surprised. He "svas a lawyer before he became a soldier, and he presided over the Carter court-martial with ability which excited the admiration of all the attorneys who appeared in the case.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Captain William Conway recalls serving under then-Colonel Otis shortly after the Custer massacre, describing the pursuit of Sitting Bull to the Canadian border and Otis's hands-on leadership in camp. The account also recounts a separate incident where Otis's wagon train was attacked by Sioux warriors en route to reinforce General Miles.

Omaha Daily Bee · 4 March 1899 · page 9

In the Indian campaigns In the west , relates lates many Interesting anecdotes concerning his old chief. "The first time I served j with General Otis , " said the captain to a j New York World reporter , "he was a colonel - onel In the Twenty-second Infantry , just after the Custer massacre. Our command

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A veteran named Dad Evans recounts a colorful anecdote about a deserter, Red Brennan, captured with a Sioux prisoner named Rain-in-the-Face before the Battle of the Little Bighorn. The story claims the prisoner's guard was mysteriously murdered and mutilated, implying Rain-in-the-Face escaped with help from a Sioux woman.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 16 days earlier.

The Saint Paul Globe · 5 March 1899 · page 32

TROOPER TALES-RED BRENNAN OF THE SEVENTH. Dad Evans told the tale. He is an old cay- ; alryman, born with a saddle between his thighs— a soldier by temperament, and a man , instinctively. Old Dad has served 30 years, but he was so miserable away from the troop that they took him back in spite of his dimmed eyes and chalky joints. Rebellion memories are rampant in Dad Evans' mind. He was a tough little bow lepg-ed cavalryman then. A dozen Indian fights are shown on his discharge papers. And then he was one of those boys who left their horses back in the States and pushed up the sand-soaked hills in front of Santiago, the one coveted.

See moreSee less

But there is one scene which Old Dad's eyes looked upon when they were not dim — a scene which appears again when his pipe is lit and his bunk is comfortable— a scene and a story, which Dad Evans does not tell except at the canteen, when his month's pay flows with his words. Then he will tell you about Rain-in-theFace, the ugliest of the Sioux, and the crafti est of red men, and about the deserter from tho ranks of Uncle Sam's horsemen who was chained to him. He will tell you how Indians fight, how impish was the fury of their squaws, how terrible their numbers. And all cavalrymen forget the glasses in their hands, while Dad Evans tells how the field looked when he helped to bury the dead of Custer's band way out in Montana on that hot June day. Ask any old cavalryman what kind of a fpllow was the Michigan man whom the Sioux called Yellow Hair. He was a soldier they will say, not an indulgent officer, but one who feared nothing living or dead. It was Custer who declared: "Give me my regiment and I will lick the whole Sioux Nation*'-' Custer was tingling to make his name il- ' lustrious when he uttered those words. He ! was confident, experienced-^, soldier bornj He did not think that his regiment of horse^ ' men would ever be called the "Unlucky Seventh." But all this has been committed to memory by school children. Here is the story of Red Brennan, deserter, once in I troop of Custer's command, and long since dead — the .story which Dad Evans tells. It is a true story, for Dad Evans, who saw it en acted, says so. Brennan was a bad man. His worst ene mies were whisky and himself. His bunk was deserted one morning at reveille roll call, and his troop was detached to hunt him up. The boys found him in a cave, to which they were led by an Indian scout. Brennan was help lessly obfuscated, probably through the me dium of unmellowed corn juice. The Indian scout shuffled about the cave feeling and smelling things. There were puzzling cir cumstances about. Some one had been in the cave with Brennan, but the identity of this party was an opaque mystery. Nothing but a can of bear's grease was found. Squaws make their braids shiny with bear's grease. A soldier suggested that Kate Poison Water had perhaps taken Brennan for her paramour. When the prisoner staggered out of stupor he was chained to Rain-in-the-Face. sub chief of the Sioux. At first he uttered a. se ries of ejaculations that would have plunged an army mule into hysterics. ****** Kate Poison Water was a sort of De Stael among the Sioux. She was a serpent in cun ning, a tigress in strength and agility — a Sioux squaw in general deviltry. It developed that Rain-in-the-Face knew her. Custer was in a land ridden with redmen. He had no near reserve. It was not a time for courtmarshals. Red Brennan ate and slept but did not become chummy with the rising buck. They were together until the day when Reno took part of the regiment and branched off to the south. Rain-in-the-Face was taken with Reno, while Brennan re joined his troop in Custer's division. It is the needless to say in whose command was Dad Evans, for had he been with Reno he would never have sipped canteen beer and told stories these times, nor would he have climbed Cuban hills under Mauser fire. The guard in charge of the Sioux prisoner was murdered in the night. It was done so quietly that the sentry, walking his post 50 yards away, heard no sound and saw noth ing. Then Dad Evans told of a way the body was mutilated— so horrible were his words that we turned away shuddering. "Only a squaw does the trick," Evans ex plained. We thought Kate Poison Water had made possible the escape of Rain-in-theFace, because of the manner of the deed. This idea grew upon us. Meanwhile that day of history dawned. Custer's command was four miles from Reno's camp. Every trooper felt there were hordes of redmen in the surrounding foothills. Not a white man guessed their numbers. The Indian scouts were puzzled by cross trails. They huggtd the vanguard and could not be nujshed ahead. The troopers wp" attentive

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

This report narrates Reno's command advancing at dawn after a courier's report of Custer's death, describing the eerie silence, signs of battle, and the grim discovery of the slaughtered troopers atop the hill. The prose is highly literary and dramatized, emphasizing horror, smell, and visual details of the massacre scene.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Washington Weekly Post, 28 February 1899, The Washington Weekly Post, 28 February 1899.

The Saint Paul Globe · 5 March 1899 · page 32

A HAUNTING PAST

The body of a trooper, gashed, perforated and dismembered, was strewn across the line j of march. Hard and unsmiling were the faces of Reno's cavalrymen now. Signals from high points brought back no answer from Custer's coips. The troops paused again to cover up red stains upon the earth. The words of the courier were believed par tially now. Great and awful thoughts were ' crawling into the soldiers' minds. Where was Yellow Hair, the intrepid, the invincible? Where were the friends of yesterday? I More blood in the path. Tainted was the air that men breathed and ghastly white ' their faces.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This passage recounts the career of an army officer named Otis, detailing his Civil War service and later campaigns against Plains Indians following the 1876 Custer massacre. It describes his actions commanding troops near the Yellowstone and Powder Rivers, including a running battle defending a wagon train against a large Sioux force near Glendive, Montana.

The Sun · 5 March 1899 · page 15

for ho wns seveieiy wounded in tho buttle ot Chanel House, near Petersburg, Va. Oct. 1. lrUl-l Ills wound wns so severe that ho was not subseutiontly returned to duty, nnd ho was honorably dUcliarged from the voluuteor ser vico.tan. '-'4, 1M'.". bearing with him the bre vets of Colonel and llrigadiut-Oeiiernl for "gal lant und moritorioushervlce"nt rJpottshania mid Clmpol Unu-t', Vtt. Ou tlio organization ot the Twenty-second Iieglmentof Infant ty of the regular itrmy from 11 battalion of tlm Thirteenth, Otis was ap pointed Lieutenant-Colonel of tho new regi ment, his commission dating July -8.

See moreSee less

lrkut. Ou Match 'J. 1SII7. he locelved the brevet of Colonel In tho regular army for g.tllnntser viec.it SpottHVlvnnlit. On tho death of Col. (ieorgo Sykes of tho Twentieth Infantry, at Port JliovMi, Tov.., Oils wits nniiolnted Colonel, and assumed command of tlio Twentieth at loit llrowti March ill. ISM) Prom lcM7 to 1KS1 lie served autipat tlio Indians. . At the time of tlio Custer massacre. In Octo ber. ItsTtl, otle, who was tltcLleutennnt-Colo-lielofthe

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

In a Washington lunacy hearing on E.H.R. Peters' mental competency, witness Kernan testified Peters claimed to have fought at Little Bighorn and personally signaled Major Reno to aid Custer. The report notes that while most of Peters' other extraordinary claims proved true, this particular Custer massacre claim was found to be false.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Evening Times · 9 March 1899 · page 1

PETERS LUNACY HEARING

Tickets on rale Vatmda and Sundav, March Perry, O T., March 9 Two hundred negroes 31 and 12, good to nlntn until Xlcmila, JUrth IS All trams except Congressional Limited. will leave Oklahoma todav for Liberia Die lie maf.lO.U e-aulO.11,12 m trees ait furnituid railroad faxes. eitv. When in New Orleans, he said the pupils of Peters' ees were ver much con tracted and upon examination in court, he added, they are in the same condition now " Peters is said to have told Kernan that he was present and took part in the fight which resulted in the Custer massacre, and that while the battle vas going on he, Peters, signaled to Major Reno to come to Custei s assistance Kernan stated that he held Newman the New Orleans lpwyer, responsible for Ins

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

During lunacy proceedings against Mr. Peters in Washington, witnesses testified to his erratic, delusional statements, including claims that he had taken part in the Custer fight and signaled Major Reno to advance. Other testimony described his paranoid behavior, threats, and bizarre conduct while being watched by police and acquaintances.

The Times · 10 March 1899 · page 3

was made detailing the extravagance of Peters sa)ings and doings, Mrs. Peters would smile, while her husband would take note of it Mis3 Hannum, at whose in stance the piocefdlngs were instltut d, was also present during the ela). The first witness called was Peter J. Kernan a member of the Secret Service Bureau of the New Orle-ans police forte. He said that at the request of Attorney Newman he was detailed to wa;eh Mr. Peters and accompan) him during the stay of the latter in New Orleans. According to the witness Mr Peters was night) In his conversation (I) lug from one subject to another He declared to the witness that he had been in the Custer fight, when he had signaled Major Reno "to come up " .He also said he had killed a negro or an Indian on one o-easi.,n and cut up or sold the body.

See moreSee less

Continuing, Mr Kernan told the jury that while in New Orleans Mr. Peters repeatedly said some one was after him

See the clipping

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

The article recounts a detailed first-person narrative of the Little Bighorn battle, including Custer's famous charge and final words, before revealing it comes from George Benjamin, a man claiming to be a survivor. It notes skepticism was warranted since no survivors of Custer's immediate command were ever confirmed, attributing the delay in his story to captivity and trauma.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Mitchell Capital · 10 March 1899 · page 8

ENTERTAINING RE Ml N ICENCtS OK THE WAR. Graphic Account of MirririB Scenes Witnessed on tlu? IJatttcfiebl and in Cam i— Veterans of the Rebel lion Ke cite Kx peri en ccs of Thrill ins Nat lire. 1 George Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, claims to have been with Custer ai the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Although it was sup posed that there was no survivor of the massacre. Benjamin's story bears marks of truthfulness, and the fact that lie was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tor tures long prevented his experience from being made known.

See moreSee less

"In the spring of bSTti." says Benja min. "1 was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June v/e were camped on Clark's Creek, and as we were gel ting short of supplies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for slipper, leaving Stone in camp. When we returned we found him dead and horribly mutilated. Wo knew at once that the Indians were on the warpath, and that we'd better get out. So we started at once for Foster's ranch, but when we reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Ev ery man, woman and child on the ranch had been murdered, and all the bodies had been mutilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cat tle driven off. Wo started for Cheyenne to give warning of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer's men. They asked us to join in the pur suit and I consented gladly, but my partner. Kelly, decided, to go on to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his body, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. "We broke camp on June 111. and Ma jor Reno scouted the trail lo the Rose bud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. (Millions was or lered to cross the Yellowstone near the mouth of the Big Horn and meet Gen. "lister at the mouth of the Big Horn on June liti. On Jui... the trail of the Indians was scouted twenty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night a council was held, and the troop:? left the Rose bud and marched up Dirty Woman's Creek toward 1he Big Horn ten miles, and went into cam]), as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops were in saddle soon after daybreak, and about S o'clock the lirst Indians were scon by the scouts from tlie lop of the divide. The men were in great spirits because tliey had -ome upon the Indians at last, although the evident indications were that, we were outnumbered ten to one. Captain Bonteon was sent toward some hills on the right, to scout the Indians and ob tain a view of the country. With him he took three companies oT the Seventh Cavalry. Our command then moved on on' mile further, and Major Reno was sent to the left, with orders to skirmish and drive the enemy if found. Tlie main body was to protect or re-en force him, as required. Captain Mc Dougal was in charge of the pack train, and was left with one company one mile from where Reno left us. Oil ahead of us were groat clouds of dust, which semed to indicate that the main body of Indians was on the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and children out of the way for tlie threatened battle. Gen. (.'uster, with the other four companies, started for this commotion and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. then fell back to the second bot tom, where we were dismounted to ex amine our lirearins and prepare for the battle. Tlii' signal to mount was given, and Gen. Custer at the head, with his hat in one hand, pointed to ihe Indians with the other, and cried out: 'There they are. boys. God bless you all. and follow me!' We charged on a dead run, but when we reached the river we dis mounted. and every fourth man held the horses of the other three. Gen. Ouster it'd the advance with his aids, Bos!oil Custer, his younger brother, and Artie Ren], his nephew, by his side. Lieut. Tom Cu-der. his other brother, and ('apt. Calhoun, his broth er-in-law, were ai th.' front with their commands. "At first we niel but few Indians, and they ouh kiy gave way before us. But soon they swan-mi upon us from every direction. They came upon us from front and nar and Hank, and ev ery ravine and every bush and tree seemed alive will: them. Wo soon knew that we were doomed, and we fought" as men tight oniy raider :cli circum stances. A perfect storm of arrows anil bullets was pouring upon us from ev ery side, but wo forghl our way back to our horsis. mounted, and in our struggle to reach the blnil's we left the greater portion of our men dead or Wounded on tlie field. But ion Indians Went down for every white man who fell. The eompanie,-: of ('.'apt. Calhoun and Lieut. Crittenden were thrown across our Hank to protect our retreat. "Gen. (.'uster was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof, (.'apt. Keogh's company was ex posed to the fiercest lire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as if we were hours making that retreat of a quarter of a mile. We made our last stand on a little knoll, which we reach ed with only seventeen men out of our entire command. "There the first thing we did was to shoot our horses, so as to make a breastwork behind which we could fight. Gen. Custer and his brother Tom and Lieut. Cook were among the last to fall. Ouster died with his revolver in his lefL and his saber in his right hand, with a dozen dead Indians piled around liim. And, indeed, almost every •. man that Iiitle knoll went down THINGS WORTH KNOWING. 011

See the clipping

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

A man named Benjamin claims to have been captured by Indians and to have witnessed Custer's last stand, describing the final retreat and death of Custer, his brother, and others on the knoll. The account is presented decades after the battle as the story of a supposed sole survivor, previously silenced by his captivity and resulting madness.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Mitchell Capital · 10 March 1899 · page 8

ENTERTAINING RE Ml N ICENCtS OK THE WAR. Graphic Account of MirririB Scenes Witnessed on tlu? IJatttcfiebl and in Cam i— Veterans of the Rebel lion Ke cite Kx peri en ccs of Thrill ins Nat lire. 1 George Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, claims to have been with Custer ai the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Although it was sup posed that there was no survivor of the massacre. Benjamin's story bears marks of truthfulness, and the fact that lie was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tor tures long prevented his experience from being made known.

See moreSee less

"In the spring of bSTti." says Benja min. "1 was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June v/e were camped on Clark's Creek, and as we were gel ting short of supplies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for slipper, leaving Stone in camp. When we returned we found him dead and horribly mutilated. Wo knew at once that the Indians were on the warpath, and that we'd better get out. So we started at once for Foster's ranch, but when we reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Ev ery man, woman and child on the ranch had been murdered, and all the bodies had been mutilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cat tle driven off. Wo started for Cheyenne to give warning of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer's men. They asked us to join in the pur suit and I consented gladly, but my partner. Kelly, decided, to go on to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his body, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. "We broke camp on June 111. and Ma jor Reno scouted the trail lo the Rose bud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. (Millions was or lered to cross the Yellowstone near the mouth of the Big Horn and meet Gen. "lister at the mouth of the Big Horn on June liti. On Jui... the trail of the Indians was scouted twenty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night a council was held, and the troop:? left the Rose bud and marched up Dirty Woman's Creek toward 1he Big Horn ten miles, and went into cam]), as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops were in saddle soon after daybreak, and about S o'clock the lirst Indians were scon by the scouts from tlie lop of the divide. The men were in great spirits because tliey had -ome upon the Indians at last, although the evident indications were that, we were outnumbered ten to one. Captain Bonteon was sent toward some hills on the right, to scout the Indians and ob tain a view of the country. With him he took three companies oT the Seventh Cavalry. Our command then moved on on' mile further, and Major Reno was sent to the left, with orders to skirmish and drive the enemy if found. Tlie main body was to protect or re-en force him, as required. Captain Mc Dougal was in charge of the pack train, and was left with one company one mile from where Reno left us. Oil ahead of us were groat clouds of dust, which semed to indicate that the main body of Indians was on the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and children out of the way for tlie threatened battle. Gen. (.'uster, with the other four companies, started for this commotion and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. then fell back to the second bot tom, where we were dismounted to ex amine our lirearins and prepare for the battle. Tlii' signal to mount was given, and Gen. Custer at the head, with his hat in one hand, pointed to ihe Indians with the other, and cried out: 'There they are. boys. God bless you all. and follow me!' We charged on a dead run, but when we reached the river we dis mounted. and every fourth man held the horses of the other three. Gen. Ouster it'd the advance with his aids, Bos!oil Custer, his younger brother, and Artie Ren], his nephew, by his side. Lieut. Tom Cu-der. his other brother, and ('apt. Calhoun, his broth er-in-law, were ai th.' front with their commands. "At first we niel but few Indians, and they ouh kiy gave way before us. But soon they swan-mi upon us from every direction. They came upon us from front and nar and Hank, and ev ery ravine and every bush and tree seemed alive will: them. Wo soon knew that we were doomed, and we fought" as men tight oniy raider :cli circum stances. A perfect storm of arrows anil bullets was pouring upon us from ev ery side, but wo forghl our way back to our horsis. mounted, and in our struggle to reach the blnil's we left the greater portion of our men dead or Wounded on tlie field. But ion Indians Went down for every white man who fell. The eompanie,-: of ('.'apt. Calhoun and Lieut. Crittenden were thrown across our Hank to protect our retreat. "Gen. (.'uster was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof, (.'apt. Keogh's company was ex posed to the fiercest lire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as if we were hours making that retreat of a quarter of a mile. We made our last stand on a little knoll, which we reach ed with only seventeen men out of our entire command. "There the first thing we did was to shoot our horses, so as to make a breastwork behind which we could fight. Gen. Custer and his brother Tom and Lieut. Cook were among the last to fall. Ouster died with his revolver in his lefL and his saber in his right hand, with a dozen dead Indians piled around liim. And, indeed, almost every •. man that Iiitle knoll went down THINGS WORTH KNOWING. 011

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.

A man claiming to have been part of Custer's command describes the desperate final stand, Custer's death, and his own capture and torture by Indians afterward. The account includes graphic details of Reynolds the scout, the deaths of Custer and his brother, and prolonged torture of captives including the narrator.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

The Mitchell Capital · 10 March 1899 · page 8

man that Iiitle knoll went down 011 with jusl such a heap of red bodies around him. Charley Reynolds, a scout, and as brave a man as ever lived, brought down an Indian at every shot, and as lie fell he emptied his re volver still with a steady hand. The Indians were armed, in addition to their bows and arrows, with the best guns 10 be had. "Before we went into bat lie Trum peter Marl in was sent back with or1 ders to ("apt. McDoitgal and ('apt. Benteen to hurry forward with their

See the clipping

Kentucky Irish American · Louisville, Ky.

This passage is a biographical retrospective on Colonel Elwell Otis's military career, published decades after the events. It mentions 'the Custer massacre' of October 1876 only as a timestamp before detailing Otis's own 1876 campaigns against Sioux forces along the Yellowstone, including the famous episode of a warning letter left by Sitting Bull's band.

Kentucky Irish American · 11 March 1899 · page 1

Twentieth at Fort Browfl March 31, 1880. From 1807 to 1881 he birved against the Indians. A At the time of the Custer massacre, in October, 1870, Otis,, whoiwas the Lieuten ant Colonel of the Twenty-second, on duty at the lake postspn our northern frontier, was ordered tothe front in com mand of six companies of the regiment. While passing down the Yellowstont his command was attackea by the Indians near the mouth of the Powder river. The troops were lauded find the enemy driven into the hills, Uieir camp being burned.

See moreSee less

On August 7j 1870, Col. Otis joined Gen. Terry and inarched with him up the Rosebud to reinforce the columns of Gen. Crook, finally taking post at Glendive, Mon. A -wagon train sent from that post, under an escort of four com panies of infantry October 10, 1870, was attacked by a heavy force of Indians and

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark. · and 1 other paper

A soldier recounts being wounded while delivering Custer's orders to Major Reno during the battle, then surviving the three-day siege on the hilltop. He describes the despair of the surrounded troops upon realizing Custer's command had been wiped out, followed by General Terry's arrival with relief forces.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 12 March 1899 · page 6

heard In your life. We soon learned s were worn by In dians, and were those undoubtedly of Custer's men, “This was our first knowledge of the fate which had overtaken him and his command. Our hearts again sank and hope almost deserted us. Soon, how ever, the Indians were seen to be leav ing, and a few hours later General Terry came up with relief and re-en forcements. As Sitting Bull split up

See the clipping

Also printed 3 more times, in 2 papers
  • Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark. · 29 December 1898
  • · · 5 April 1899
  • Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark. · 10 April 1899

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

A man named William H. McGee recounts being Custer's orderly on June 25, 1876, claiming he was sent back to Reno with orders just before Custer's command was wiped out. He asserts he is the only living survivor of the unit that rode forward with Custer that day.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 12 March 1899 · page 6

IS THE ONLY SURVIVOR

Was With Custer the Day He Was Killed and Narrowly Missed His Command’s hate. Oenernl Rlikn' Uet&ftrkKbU linvcrf~ Ro<t* Across dq Op«n rii lii Fndrr l!ip I -re (if Kiglit HundrmJ Iiulinnn A Sight Never t» lie Forgolton—Kcmilteil (u UU 1'tomo* tiou to a Brlgadtereltlp. To a group of friends*the other even ing. William H. McGee, recalled some interesting reminiscences of the Cus ter massacre and of the fight in the Bear Paw, when General Miles captur ed the Nez Pereea Indiana under Chief Joseph. Mr. McGee was General Custer’s or derly on the day of the massacre and Is the last man now living who saw that officer and is also the only sur vivor of the command with which fas ter went forward, when lie left Major Reno on that fateful morning of June 25, 1876.

See moreSee less

"Yes," said Vie, “I was with Custer the day he was killed. I was his order ly that day and narrowly missed the tragic fate he and his command met at the hands of Sitting Bull and his horde of Indians. ! am the only sur vivor of the command with which Cus ter started out that morning, and owe iny life to the fact that just, a few moments before the Sioux fell on him, he sent me back to Major Reno with orders to the latter. About 9 o'clock one morning the command halted and Custer and Reno held a^onsultation, I was only a few feet away qa they were talking, being Custer’s .orderly that day. “They compared their watches, arid a moment later Custer’s command was on its way to the point where it met with annihilation. When we were, I, should judge, about a mile from Reno, Custer turned to me and said: “Orderly, do you think you can lind the way back to Major Reno?" *'I replied: ‘Yes, sir.’ “‘Go as quickly »s you can,’ be said, | ‘to Major Reno; give him my compli- ! ments and tell him to wait 20 minutes ! more. He will understand that. 1 guess you will have to remain with him.’ “It was that order that saved me from a grave out in Montana. “As I wheeled my horse to go back he recalled me, and calling up the reg imental trumpeter, gave him practical ly the same instructions and further remarked to us. pointing in the direc tion of Reno’s command, 'If you cut across there you may find it smoother going. If you prefer the trail, however, you may go that way, and use your own judgment.' “We started, the trumpeter and my self. We had only gone 300 or 400 yards when he said to me: ‘Mack, which way are you going?’ “ ‘Back over the trail, of course,’ 1 answered. “He had gotten it Into his head thst Custer had told us to cut across, and I argued with him in vain that the route .was left to our discretion. IIS wouldn’t have it that way, and starting off alone, remarked: ‘Good-by, Mack; we’ll see who gets to Reno first.’ The move cost him his life. lie had gone only about 600 yards when 1 heard sev eral shots in his direction. He had evidently run right into the Indians, and, as I afterwards learned, they had riddled him with bullets. “By this time I could hear constant firing, both in the direction of Custer and Reno. I was getting over the ground as fast as my horse could car ry me, and I had a fine horse, too. Just as I got in sight of Reno’s command I ran right into a bunch of red devils. They were not more than 30 yards away, and instantly I could hear the ‘nine:’ and whistling of bullets all around me. I was probably within 120 yards of Reno's command. One ball struck my horse in the withers, and he went down. I fell over his head, but fortunately my arm slipped through the reins and left me holding the horse. "He got up at once, and as 1 threw Try right leg over the saddle another ball hit him, first passing through the calf of my right leg. It pierced my horse’s lungs. He jumped forward and carried me within (10 yards of Major Reno, where he dropped dead. I jump. €*1 as he was falling and ran the rest of the way. There was a, frightful din at this time, and as I saluted Major Reno he bent his head to hear my message. I repeated the orders of Cus ter, and he said: "* ‘Orderly, too late now. Take care of yourself.’ "Reno was then whipped and was be ing pressed back on the hill, where for three days the command was sur rounded and endured suffering which is indescribable. "The firing was hot and continuous. "We did not know what had become of Custer, and were expecting he would come to our relief. Shortly after we got up on the hill we heard three vol leys in his direction, a signal for aid, but we were powerless to respond, and could not go to him, although he was but little over a mile away. *©n the morning of the third day we saw a body of men in soldiers’ uni forms In the distance. We mistook thea for relief coming to us. Such a cheer and yell as went up from the im soldifrs on that hlli you never

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

In a court sanity hearing, witness Eugene Peters recounts his life story including service in the Army Signal Corps, mentioning he repaired telegraph wires carrying reports of the Custer massacre. He clarifies that earlier testimony was misconstrued to suggest he claimed to have been with Custer himself signaling for reinforcements, when he merely worked on the wires transmitting news of the event.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

Evening Star · 15 March 1899 · page 2

man." Datlea In Sljsnal Service. Mr. Peters toldof his doings In Phila delphia, Texas and other places In the sig nal corps. At the time of the Custer mas sacre he repaired certain wires over which reports of the affair were transmitted. Somo reference to this recently, so said Mr. Peters, had been misconstrued probably by ceruil! of the witnesses In the case, and on It was evidently based the statements that he had alleged he was with Custer at the time of the massacre and signaled for re

See the clipping

The Sioux County Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

A crippled miner named George Benjamin claims to have been present at the Little Bighorn massacre, saying he was captured and tortured by Indians, which kept his story from surfacing earlier. He recounts prospecting in the Black Hills, discovering mutilated bodies of settlers, and joining Custer's pursuit before the battle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Mitchell Capital, 10 March 1899, The Mitchell Capital, 10 March 1899.

The Sioux County Journal · 16 March 1899 · page 5

SOLDIERS' STORIES. ENTERTAINING REMINISCENCES OF THE WAR.

ENTERTAINING REMINICENCES OF THE WAR. OraaWa Aecoant mt Btirrlast Witaaaaed mm tha Battlalala ass is Cass p-Veterans mt tmm belltaa Ka eita Experiences of Thrilllsisr Natare. George Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, claims to bave been with Custer at the massacre at tbe Little Big Horn. Although it was sup- ! posed that there was no survivor of the ' massacre, Benjamin's story bears marks of truthfulness, and tbe fact that he waa held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tor ture long prevented hi experience from being made known.

See moreSee less

"In the spring of 1876," says Benja min, "I was prospecting In tbe Black Hills for gold with two otherminers named Stone and Kelly. In June we were camped on Clark's Creek, and as we were getting short of supplies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for supper, leaving Stone in camp. WTben we returned we found him dead and horribly mutilated. We knew at once that the Indians were on the warpath, and that we'd better get out. So we started ut once for Foster's ranch, but wben we reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Ev ery man, woman and child on the ranch had been murdered, and all the bodies had been mutilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cat tle driven off. We started ror Cheyenne to give warning of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer's men. Tbey asked us to join in the pur suit and 1 consented gladly, but my partner, Kelly, decided to go ou to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his Ixidy, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. "We broke camp on June 10, and Ma jor Reno scouted the trail to the Rose bud and struck a fresh trail where tbe Indians had crossed. Glblions was or dered to cross the Yellowstone uear the mouth of the Big Horn and meet Gen. Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June 2t. Ou June 24 the trail of tbe Indians was scouted twenty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night n council waa held, and the troops left the Rose bud and marched up Dirty Woman's Creek toward tbe Big Horn ten miles and went Into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops were in saddle soon after daybreak, and about 8 o'clock the first Indians were seen by the scouts from the top of the divide. The men were in great spirits because they had come upon the Indians at last, although me evident indications were that we were outnumbered ten to one. Captain Benteen was sent toward some hills on the right to scout the Indians and ob tain a view of the country. With him he took three companies of the Seveuth Cavalry. Our command then moved on oue mile further, and Maior Reno was sent to the left, with orders to skirmish ami drive the enemy If found. The main liody was to protect or re-enforce him, as required. Captain He Dougal was iu charge of Ihe pack train, and was left with one comtianv oue mile from where Reno left us. On ahead of us were great clouds of dust, which setued to Indicate that the main body of Indians was ou the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and children out of the way for the threatened battle. Gen. Custer, with the other four .-ompuuies, started for this commotion and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. We then fell back to the second bot tom, where we were dismounted to ex amine our firearms and prepare for the buttle. The signal to mount was given, and Gen. Custer at the head, with bis bat In oue hand, pointed to the Indians with the other, and cried out: 'There they are, boys. God bless you all. and follow met' We charged on a dead run, but when we reached the river we dis mounted, and every fourth man held the horses of the other three. (Jen. Custer led the advance with his aids. Boston Custer, bis younger brother. and Artie Reed, bis nephew, by bis side. Lieut. Tom Custer, his other brother, and Capl. Calhoun, his broth-jer-in-law. were at the front with their commands. "At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way liefore us. But smpii they swarmed upon us from every direction. They came upon us from front and rear and flunk, and ev ery ravine and every bush, and tree seemed alive w ith ibem. We soon knew that we were doomed, and we fought as men light only under such clrcuni sinnces. A perfect storm of arrow's and bullets was pouring upon us from ev ery side, but we fought our way back to our horses, mounied. and lu our slriiggle to leach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the tield. But ten Indians went down for every white man who fell. The companies of Capt. Calhoun and Lieut. Crittenden were thrown across our (lank to protect our retreat. "Gen. Custer was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof, ('apt. Keogb's company was ex posed to the fiercest fire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as If we were hours making that retreat of. n quarter of a mile. We made our last stand ou a little knoll, which we reach ed with only seventeen men out of our entire command. "There ihe first thing we did was to shoot our horses, so as to make a breastwork behind which we could light. Gen. Custer and his brother Tom and Lieut. Cook were among (he laat to fall. Custer died with bis revolver in bis left and his saber In his right band, with a doxen dead Indians piled around him. And, Indeed, almost every

See the clipping

The Sioux County Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

A newspaper article from 1899 purports to be the first-person account of a soldier who survived Custer's final battle at Little Bighorn, describing the chaotic retreat, the deaths of Custer and his officers, and his own wounding and capture by Indians. The narrative gives vivid details of the last stand on the knoll and claims the survivor was later found alive among the dead.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Sioux County Journal · 16 March 1899 · page 5

ENTERTAINING REMINICENCES OF THE WAR. OraaWa Aecoant mt Btirrlast Witaaaaed mm tha Battlalala ass is Cass p-Veterans mt tmm belltaa Ka eita Experiences of Thrilllsisr Natare. George Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, claims to bave been with Custer at the massacre at tbe Little Big Horn. Although it was sup- ! posed that there was no survivor of the ' massacre, Benjamin's story bears marks of truthfulness, and tbe fact that he waa held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tor ture long prevented hi experience from being made known.

See moreSee less

"In the spring of 1876," says Benja min, "I was prospecting In tbe Black Hills for gold with two otherminers named Stone and Kelly. In June we were camped on Clark's Creek, and as we were getting short of supplies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for supper, leaving Stone in camp. WTben we returned we found him dead and horribly mutilated. We knew at once that the Indians were on the warpath, and that we'd better get out. So we started ut once for Foster's ranch, but wben we reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Ev ery man, woman and child on the ranch had been murdered, and all the bodies had been mutilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cat tle driven off. We started ror Cheyenne to give warning of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer's men. Tbey asked us to join in the pur suit and 1 consented gladly, but my partner, Kelly, decided to go ou to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his Ixidy, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. "We broke camp on June 10, and Ma jor Reno scouted the trail to the Rose bud and struck a fresh trail where tbe Indians had crossed. Glblions was or dered to cross the Yellowstone uear the mouth of the Big Horn and meet Gen. Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June 2t. Ou June 24 the trail of tbe Indians was scouted twenty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night n council waa held, and the troops left the Rose bud and marched up Dirty Woman's Creek toward tbe Big Horn ten miles and went Into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops were in saddle soon after daybreak, and about 8 o'clock the first Indians were seen by the scouts from the top of the divide. The men were in great spirits because they had come upon the Indians at last, although me evident indications were that we were outnumbered ten to one. Captain Benteen was sent toward some hills on the right to scout the Indians and ob tain a view of the country. With him he took three companies of the Seveuth Cavalry. Our command then moved on oue mile further, and Maior Reno was sent to the left, with orders to skirmish ami drive the enemy If found. The main liody was to protect or re-enforce him, as required. Captain He Dougal was iu charge of Ihe pack train, and was left with one comtianv oue mile from where Reno left us. On ahead of us were great clouds of dust, which setued to Indicate that the main body of Indians was ou the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and children out of the way for the threatened battle. Gen. Custer, with the other four .-ompuuies, started for this commotion and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. We then fell back to the second bot tom, where we were dismounted to ex amine our firearms and prepare for the buttle. The signal to mount was given, and Gen. Custer at the head, with bis bat In oue hand, pointed to the Indians with the other, and cried out: 'There they are, boys. God bless you all. and follow met' We charged on a dead run, but when we reached the river we dis mounted, and every fourth man held the horses of the other three. (Jen. Custer led the advance with his aids. Boston Custer, bis younger brother. and Artie Reed, bis nephew, by bis side. Lieut. Tom Custer, his other brother, and Capl. Calhoun, his broth-jer-in-law. were at the front with their commands. "At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way liefore us. But smpii they swarmed upon us from every direction. They came upon us from front and rear and flunk, and ev ery ravine and every bush, and tree seemed alive w ith ibem. We soon knew that we were doomed, and we fought as men light only under such clrcuni sinnces. A perfect storm of arrow's and bullets was pouring upon us from ev ery side, but we fought our way back to our horses, mounied. and lu our slriiggle to leach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the tield. But ten Indians went down for every white man who fell. The companies of Capt. Calhoun and Lieut. Crittenden were thrown across our (lank to protect our retreat. "Gen. Custer was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof, ('apt. Keogb's company was ex posed to the fiercest fire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as If we were hours making that retreat of. n quarter of a mile. We made our last stand ou a little knoll, which we reach ed with only seventeen men out of our entire command. "There ihe first thing we did was to shoot our horses, so as to make a breastwork behind which we could light. Gen. Custer and his brother Tom and Lieut. Cook were among (he laat to fall. Custer died with bis revolver in bis left and his saber In his right band, with a doxen dead Indians piled around him. And, Indeed, almost every

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Dakota Chief · Gann Valley, S.D.

A Watertown collector, Col. L. D. Lyon, owns an 1872-dated Sharps breech-loading rifle taken from a Sioux man at Standing Rock Agency. The man claimed the weapon had done deadly work in the Custer massacre.

The Dakota Chief · 16 March 1899 · page 2

Collecting Frontier Relics. Col. L. 1). Lyon of Watertown, has in his collection of frontier relics an old time Sharps breech-loading rifle bearing date of IS.' 2. The weapon was taken from an un ruly Sioux at Standing I!oe!: Agency, who said the old firearm did deadly execution in the Custer massacre. Couldn’t Stay Apart At the December term of court at Fred erick Elvia Schoen was granted a divorce from her husband, Adolph. The couple settled their differences a few days ago. and have now been married to each other for the second time.

See the clipping

The State Rights Democrat · Albany, Oregon

A Captain Allison gave a college lecture on Indian customs and recounted the Battle of the Little Big Horn, dating it to June 30 and claiming Custer's entire command was killed. He attributed Custer's defeat to the cowardice of Major Reno, who allegedly disobeyed orders.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The State Rights Democrat · 17 March 1899 · page 1

4 75 Owine to tbe rain the attendance at U 53 CapU Allison's lecture yesterday evening 10 00 was small, but it was rreatir enioved br 6 00 all present. After telling of tbe manners 17 12 and customs of the Indians he d;acrwd 1 1 85 1 the battle of ttie Little Biir Horn on June 30 OOi 1-9 in which Uen. Custer and all 20 00 1 bis men were killed. His defest was owing to the cowardice of Maj. Reno, S 00 2 CO

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The report recounts two frontier legends of the North-West Mounted Police: a sergeant forcing Chief Piapot to break camp, and Sergeant McDonald facing down Sitting Bull at Wood Mountain after the Custer fight. Both stories celebrate the lone Mountie's nerve against overwhelming numbers of warriors.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Morning News · 19 March 1899 · page 20

WOOD MOUNTAIN POLICE

thrilling stories or nohth \\ LSTLKN MOt NTF.II I*Ol.U K. Monn Tiuv Korre of 7170 Men Con trols Territory Nearly n* I.nrjte ms Enrope—They Ire Hitt. Fcnrlwu Fetlons—l il l lgli I lug Time Tcr rifics sa\ae —Hoys' Two Men < o y 111red u Hu ml n-d Indians—Out niftlUK MIHoe Hull— tilvenlnre of Hilt Jack Loll in*— A Fierce llattle in a l*o|tlnr Thicket—Moral Kltect of a Hcdcoat Victoria. B. C., March W.—A liny force of 7Su men, ihe North western Mounter Po lice of Canada. guards and comrolp a ter ritory nearly as large as the-whole of Eu rope.

See moreSee less

They are lag, powerful men physi cally, most of them of sturdy Scotch or Irish extraction, and the moral force of the brilliant id tunic which they wear is a minor revelation of the method by whicu the tiny British isles govern an empire Although there are thousands of Indians, El.d half-hreeda moie dangerous than In dians, and rough, reckless in,tiers, and out laws, in their domain they ridthe plains arid climb the mountains and keep the peace of the third of a continent. In 1*73 150 men were sent to Manitoba fiom Eastern t'anadu. That was tin be ginning of the Northwes.erri Mounted Po lice. Dur.ng Kiel's rebellion they num bered I.UOO. At present there are in the Northwest territories .".4S; in tinYukon let. Toe-re art three div sons, each with head quarters near :he Polled Siate-s line. i-.aJi division has outputs, with from two to ten men each. It has also a superintend ent and two inspectors. Above them are the commissioner and assistant eommis lloner. Two extra inspectors act respec tively as paymaster and quartermaster lor the who.ee force. Pay is not munificent. The commissioner gels $2,600 a year, his assistant |l,tiuo, sutler in undents $1,400, In siwotors, surgeons and veterinary surgeons H.OiXl each, petty officers from $3 to S') cents a day, and eons tables—the title of enlisted men—so to 75 cents a day. Full dress uniform is a scarlet runic, with yellow facings, blue cloth breeches with yellow stripes, while helmet, cavalry boots and cavalry overcoat. For winter they havn fur coats and moccasins. A serviceable khaki uniform and cowboy hat is used for tough work on the prairie In summer. The mission of t itese scarlet-coated guardians is pcae-e. Here are lllitstralons: They perhaps picture the method. Two Men Against n Hundred. When Piapot, rest.ess, quarrelsome, drink-loving, and his swarthy, hawk-faced following, spread their circle of smoke tanned tepees near the construction line of the Canadian Pacific Hallway, beyond Swift Current, there was inaugurated the preliminary of a massacre, or whatever form of entertainment the brain of Pia pot migat devise. Then the railway management sent a remonstrance to the Powers. The I eu terant governor issued an order; and two polieem n rode forth carrying her majes ty's commands. Not a brigade, nor n troop; the officer bearing the written order was but a sergeant. With him was one constable; that was the force that was to move this turbulent tribe from good hunt ing ground to a secluded spot miles away-. Piapot refused to move. The sergeant calmly gave him fifteen minutes In which to begin striking camp. Result. fWleen minutes of abuse. The Indians screamed defiance at the sergeant, and fired their guns under his charger's nose as they cir cled abojt him in Iheir pony spirit war dance. When the fifteen minutes were up, the. sergeant threw his picket line to the eon stable, dismounted, walked over lo Chi f Piapot'w tepee and calmly knocked the key pole out. All the warriors rushed for their guns, ami one of the biggest bluffs on record was played by the redskin. But the sergeant continued method cul ly knocking key poles out and Piapot sow that Ihe game was up. He must either kill the sergeant-stick his knife in the heart of Ihe whole British nation—or give up and move away. He chose the latter coarse, for Piapot had brains. Sitting null Outwitted. After the killing of Custer, Silling Bull became a more or less orderly tenant of her majesty, the Queen. With 800 lodges he camped at Wood mountain, just over the border from Montana, An arrow's flight away was the Northwestern Mount id Police post One morning the police found six dead Saltaux Indians, scalped in approved Sioux fashion. A seventh Sal taux, still alive, had seen Ihe killing. The police buried the dead Indians anil took the living one 10 their post. With characteristic cheek, Sitting Bull came, ai-companied by chiefs and warriors, to demand the seventh Saltaux. In Wood mountain there were twenty policemen backing Sergt. McDonald. With the chief there were at least 500 warriors. Sit ting Bull threw his squat figure from his pony and thrust the muxs’, of his gun into Sergt. McDonald's stomach. McDon ald was typical of the force. He pushed the gun one side and told the chiefs to step inside the gate, stack their arms and come inside the shack for a pow wow. They demurred; the sergeant was firm Outside it was play day in Bedlam. The young bucks rode and whooped and fired their guns. "Send your men away,'* said the ser geant to Sitting Bull. Sitting Bull de murred. "Send them away!" repeated the ser geant. “if you have authority." Sitting Bui! and his chiefs made toward the door, but there were Interruptions— red-roated objections. And outside in the yard the chief’s rifles were stacked. Sitting Bull, like Piapot, had brains. The bucks were sent away. Then the sergeant persuaded the chiefs to listen further—mainly by force of the red-coated arguments he had brought to tx-ar. "Tar ry here, my brothers," he said, "until I send Constable Colllr.s and two others of my tmn to arrest the murderers. The Baltaux are subjects of the Queen. We cannot allow them to he killed for the fun of the thing.” Adventure of lllg Jack Collins. Then big Jack Collins—wild Irishman and ail Ihe rest of it—went over to the Sioux camps and arses ted three. The bucks jostled and shoved them, fired pis tols over their heads, but big Jack and his comrades hung on to tlieir prisoners and worked their way to the post, with no sign of annoyance until a big buck spat In Collin's face. A big mutton-leg fist shol out, and the Sioux lay like a crushed moccasin al Jack's feet. "Take that, ye black baste!" he hissed between clenched teeth; "an’ ye’ve made mo disobey orders, ye foul fiend!" Then he marched his prisoners into the post, nnd reported himsclt for misconduct In striking an Indian. Duck lake is the "Tenderloin district" of the prairie provinces. It lies a hundred mips north of ltegina. the capital of the territories East year four while men and three Indians lay there dead, that the peace broken by one Indian outlaw might be whole again. Almighty Voice, son of John Sounding Sky. was hungry. He killed a cow. not his own, therefore a sergeant and a half breed guide rode out to bring him before a magistrate. They came upon him In

See the clipping

Missouri Valley Times · Missouri Valley, Iowa

The report describes Sitting Bull's grave in the Fort Yates military cemetery as marked only by a broken, vandalized wooden headboard reading 'No. 54. Sitting Bull, Indian.' It credits him as the mastermind who planned the 'deathtrap' of Little Bighorn that destroyed Custer's command.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Missouri Valley Times · 23 March 1899 · page 5

ACCESSORIES OF WORSHIP. Th. Manner In Which Inoen.e, Rellea nnd Offering. Began to Be Used. The use of incense in churchcs was forbidden as a heathen custom till tbe fifth century. The use of holy water was equally denounced as a practice of the pagan priests of Home and of the ritual of Isis. The asperging of Julian in Gaul by a priest is perhaps the ear liest instance of the introduction of this corruption, which beeame a source of superstition in the fifth century, says Blackwood'a Magazine. The won der-working power of the relics of mar tyrs began to be believed toward the close of the fourth century and almost immediately after we find complaint made of the sale of forged relics, both in the east and in the west.

See moreSee less

The sale of relics was forbidden by Theodosius, yet they constantly in creased in numbers end in importance until the holy table was converted into an altar to hold them. In the fifth cen tury also ex voto offerings began to be hung on church walls—a custom which was of heathen origin. The use of lights, which, as above said, was for bidden in the second century in the daytime, crept in in the fifth century. The Mithraic altars had much earlier supported candles, but these may have become necessary in underground chapels. Jerome wrote that it was slanderous to say that wax tapers were burned "in clear light," but Paulinus of Nola, in 307 A. D., so decorated his church on festivals. Sitting Bull'. Grave. A broken wooden headboard and a neglected mound of earth in the Port Yates (X. 1).) military cemetery mark the resting place of Sitting Hull, the great Sioux medicine man whose wily brain jrianned the deathtrap of the Lit tle Big Horn Into which (Jen. Custer's command tell. On the broken head board is written: "No. 54. Sitting Bull, Indian." Relic hunters have cut most of the headboard away. Jernaalem,'. Fall front Glory. Jerusalem is nownothing but.a shad ow of the magnificent city of ancient times. It is about three miles in cir-. mountain.

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · and 2 other papers

The report describes Sitting Bull's grave in the Fort Yates, N.D. military cemetery, marked by a broken wooden headboard reading 'No. 54. Sitting Bull, Indian.' It notes that relic hunters have cut away most of the headboard, and credits him with having planned the 'deathtrap' at the Little Big Horn that destroyed Custer's command.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Griggs Courier · 23 March 1899 · page 6

IT is said that Budyard Kipling never carried any money with him when he was in Brattleboro, his wife attending to everything in the financial line, and he is said to have placed under her control even his own income, which has been estimated at over 820,000 a year. One day when he had no tobac co he asked his coachman to buy him a ping, and said to him: "You can col lect of Mrs. Kippling." A BROKEN wooden headboard and ft neglected mound of earth in the Ft. Yates (N.

See moreSee less

D.) military cemetery mark the resting place of Sitting Bull, the great Sioux medicine man, whose wily brain planned the deathtrap of the Lit tle Big Horn into which Oen. Custer's command felL On the broken head board is written: "No. 54. Sitting Bull, Indian." Belie hunters have out most of the headboard away. I^J deep-sea sounding records are A

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Perrysburg Journal · Perrysburg, Ohio · 25 March 1899
  • The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D. · 15 April 1899

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

A filler item marks '30 years ago today' with a claim that Custer and the Seventh Cavalry were surrounded by Satanta, Lone Wolf, and Little Raven between Forts Hays and Cobb in Kansas, warning of a bloody Indian war. This is a vague, miscast historical aside unrelated to the actual Little Bighorn battle of June 1876.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Laramie Republican · 23 March 1899 · page 4

| dance of the series tomorrow night at I < I North Star hall. The millinery’ displays in the dry* goods stores are showing fine and would do credit to a place much larger than Laramie. Don’t forget the card party this even ing at G. A. R. hall, given'by* the ladies of the Fraternal Union of America. The game will be high-five. An interesting literary and musical program will be given tomorrow even ing at the Baptist church. It will be found elsewhere in this pa-per. Two large steam shovels arrived in Laramie today and will be taken west for use by Kilpatrick Bros, on the rail road grading on the cut-off lines.

See moreSee less

W. C. Wilson, a freight brakeman, had) a thumb mashed at Red Buttes last night, while making a coupling. It is likely that he will lose the finger. A 250-horse power marine steam high-pressure boiler, 60x20 feet, has been received at the rolling mills from Denver and has been set up in place of one of the old boilers. The Birthday club will meet at the home of Mrs. James Mathison, corner' Sixth and Custer, tomorrow afternoon, to celebrate the anniversaries of Mrs. Mathison and Mrs. John Baillie. F. H. Eggleston, the druggist, will change his location in a few days and has rented the store in the Balch block formerly occupied by Mrs. Mollie In gersoll. Mr. Eggleston expects jp be in the new store by April 15t"h. Another stonm has. been raging in the mountains west of Laramie. The North park stage has been delayed nearly two days and twenty-two inches of snow fell on the top of the range be tween Woods Landing and Pinkbam ton. F. O. Harrison went out to his ranch on Rock creek today. Mr. Harrison said that he had about 2,000 head of rattle on his ranch and put up 2,500 tons of hwy. His cattle had been well cared for this winter during the storm and his losses were very small and he still had 600 tons of hay left. Thirty years ago today General Custer and the greater part of the Seventh cavalry were corraled by San tana. Ix>ne Wolf and Little Raven be tween Forts Hayes and Cobb in Kan sas. Most of his men were dismounted. Everything ailong the border pointed to a bloody Indian war.—Sun-Leader. Mr. andi Mrs. G. E. Tucker have tak < n "the home of Mr. and Mrs. Wim. Ma li oney on Fremont street for a short time during the absence of Mrs. Ma honey and family, who are visiting in. California. Mr. Tucker is one of the clerks in the office of the Un ion Pacific engineer who of the construction work being done here. The citizens of Laramie will be pleas ed to hear that Manager H. E. Root has arranged with Manager Ed. M. Bayliss to bring his wonderful electrical pro duction of the Battle of Manila to the Opera House on Monday and Tuesday, March 27 and 28. Laramie people who saw t'his show at the Omaha exposition promounce it a fine exhibition. The great Russian pianist, Leopold Godowsky, who is now touring the country, will give a recital in Denver

See the clipping

The Worcester Spy · Worcester, Mass.

A retrospective newspaper article lauds General Nelson Miles's military career, citing his pursuit of Sitting Bull after Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn as an example of his innovative tactics. It also recounts his later campaigns against Chief Joseph, Geronimo, and in the Spanish-American War.

The Worcester Spy · 24 March 1899 · page 3

After the terrible massacre of Gen. Custer on the Little Big Horn. Gen. Miles was sent to subjugate Sitting Bull. He started on a mid-winter cam paign something entirely new in In dian warfare, and succeeded in driving him across the border into Canada. Ho was soon obliged to recross the line and forced to surrender. The part Gen. Mlles took in the Span ish war. where he was commander-In chief of the army, is well known. Ha was not sent to Santiago until a crisis had arrived. Then bo was the one man looked to in this emergency.

See moreSee less

He was sent by the president with full power to do what he thought best, and ar riving there ho Immediately brought order out of chaos and obliged the Spanish commander to surrender. Im mediately after this ho was sent to Porto Rico.

See the clipping

New York Journal and Advertiser · New York, N.Y.

A veteran testifying in the 1899 army 'embalmed beef' investigation is noted as a Little Bighorn survivor who served with Reno's troop and was wounded there. The bulk of the testimony concerns spoiled rations fed to troops during the Puerto Rico campaign, with the Custer battle mentioned only as background on the witness.

New York Journal and Advertiser · 25 March 1899 · page 2

K TESTIMONY IN THE Duly is a veteran Indian fighter. hftving!p< | served with distinction iinder Major IlenojN' m Troop E, Seventh Cavalry, at pi rhi battle of Little Big Horn, where | liienernl Custer's entire command was de-.pl j strayed by tlie Sioux 011 June 2C>, 1870. ja ; Hilly was sliot through the ueek ami bears 01 the sears to this day. He was a bugler di and owes Ills life to the fact Mint 011 that ''j 1 ill-fated day he, in company with four nj others, was detailed to escort the pack u train.

See moreSee less

, Daly says that the rations served to the;tl troops in the recent l'orto Rico campaign Is' .were far worse tlluin those given tne!fr" j sold'ers in tlie Indian wars. i Upon the breaking out of the war Paly A , enlisted in Company K, First Kentucky| ! Regiment, in Louisville. On account of |

See the clipping

The Appeal · Saint Paul, Minn.

This 1899 article recounts General Otis's exploits as a colonel in the Twenty-second Infantry following the Custer massacre, describing his leadership during a two-day fight with Indians and a pursuit of Sitting Bull to the Canadian border. It praises his bravery, work ethic, and ability to win the respect of skeptical West Point officers through personal example.

The Appeal · 25 March 1899 · page 1

The first time I served with Gen. Otis be was a colonel in the Twenty-second iinfantrv, just after the Custer massacre. Our command was sent to reinforce Col. on .the Yellowstone. We started in pursuit .of Sitting Bull and did not give np the chase .until we had pursued him

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A Minnesota newspaper rallies support for American troops in the Philippines by invoking a lineage of heroic American military stands, including Custer's death at Little Bighorn. It also criticizes the War Department for impugning the Fifteenth Minnesota regiment's officers without formal inquiry before muster-out.

The Saint Paul Globe · 26 March 1899 · page 4

EVERY MAN A HERO

Indian wars thttt intervened between then and the bom bardment of Sumter. They were braye — both annies — at Gettysburg, Shiloh, Donelson, Coal Harbor and Auii etam. The heroic stand at Thermopylae is eQialed by the bravery of the men who rode with Custer into the valley of death on the Little Big Horn. Men came back from the charge of the Light Brigade at Balaklava and lived to rehearse the story. Custer's men died with him. American generalship and American heroism were just as conspicuous at San Juan and El Caney.

See moreSee less

and today a portion of the same invincible troops are prosecuting, near Manila, one of the most magnificent active campaigns re corded in history. It is the recent testimony of Gen. Charles King that our boys do not fully comprehend tbe meaning of the word "halt." And what is then impossible in the face of au army of which every man is a hero?

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

This report details the military career of Colonel Egbert, who died from wounds received at San Juan Hill, noting his earlier service with the Twelfth Infantry during Indian campaigns including Little Bighorn. It mentions Custer's death there only in passing as part of Egbert's biographical background.

The Times · 27 March 1899 · page 2

COL. HARRY C. EGBERT.

Colonel Egbert was with tho Twelfth in most of the Important Indian cam paigns. Including the battle of Little Big Horn, where General Custer and so many

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

A book review column describes the April issue of Ainslee's Magazine, highlighting an article about Indian picture-writing that tells the story of the Custer Massacre from the Native perspective. It also lists other articles in the issue, including pieces on the Secret Service, Joseph Choate, and fiction contributions.

The Jersey City News · 27 March 1899 · page 2

NEW PUBLICATIONS. Aiuslee’s Magazine For April. '‘Ainslee’s Magazine” for April has a distinct flavor of original investigation and discovery. The editors have thought it timely to present to the public the man who built the wonderful, fast-sail ing Oregon, Irving 'M. Scott. In the same number is a curious article by J. R. Nieholls-Kyle on some Indian picture writing recently discovered, which tells the story of the Custer Massacre as it appeared to the Indians. The strange and intricate workings of the United States Secret Service have been studied and mastered by Mr.

See moreSee less

Arthur Henry, who contributes to the magazine the story of this great system. There are other articles of interest, no tably a graphic study of Joseph H. Choate, by Theodore Dreiser, and a paper by Chauncev M. Depew upon “What the Twentieth Century Offers to the Young American.” Fiction by William I.e Queux, W. W. Jacobs (writer of humor ous sailor stories), and Richard Marsh complete the number.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This is a publisher's advertisement for Ainslee's Magazine listing upcoming articles, including one on Indian picture writing depicting Custer's massacre and other events of the Indian wars. It is not a news report but a promotional listing of magazine contents.

The Sun · 27 March 1899 · page 5

Peace and in War." I The valuable and largely unpublished story of the Secret Service n II during the late war and much of fascinating detail which has come to n II pass in time of peace are here graphically told and illustrated from rare 11 , 11 photographs By Arthur Henry '' H II ;j "Indian Picture Writing." j h Custer's massacre and countless other important events which H 11 happened during the Indian wars are here shown by the paintings H 11 made by the Indians themselves, giving an article of unique interest and " ' J most original illustration.

See moreSee less

. . By J. R. Nicholls-Kyle H 4 , H I "The Hermit of Rue Madame." ' ll A unique and absorbing story, dealing with the life in the Latin n II Quarter of Paris and the strange adventure of a student there. n II By William Le Queux h !! "Three at Table." I I A vivid and exciting story bv the author of "Many Cargoes," " : !' and one of the best we have yet had from his pen. " J By W. W. Jacobs ' I! " The Loom of Destiny." II A story of child life, told with great sympathy and insight into " j human nature by a new write.', . . Arthur J. Stringer ' Ii II ' j "The Real Choate," bv Theodore Dreiser. "A Silent WitH j ness," by Richard Marsh. "The Big Bell of Burmah," by E. W. ' May. Topics of the Theatie. Books and their makers. .. ; 10 cents a Copy, $1.00 per Year. ; - I Street & Smith, Publishers, 81 Fulton Street, New York I ' i KW. -Srottl.li Clana and Turtan.i" Klplina'a tlAHIXE IXTELLK1EXCB. 'Heel In llfliu I'll AIT, nil I'.lhav.

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

A books-and-magazines column previews Ainslee's Magazine for April 1899, highlighting an article on Indian Picture Writing that includes translated pictographs depicting the Indians' side of Custer's 'massacre' and the battle of Little Big Horn. It also notes other articles in the issue, including pieces on the USS Oregon's builder and secret service work.

The Scranton Tribune · 28 March 1899 · page 4

LITERARY NOTES

specimens depleting tho Indians' sldo of Custer's massacre havo been gathered and translated. They form a vivid abor iginal account of putts of the. Indian life and of the battle of Little Big Horn. Tho story Is 0110 of wonderful human Interest. There Is an nrtlclo on "Seciet Service In

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A man calling himself Dr. Dakota Ray, real name M. F. Chamberlain, was arrested for bigamy after his first wife exposed him; he ran traveling Indian shows and claimed to have known Sitting Bull and Rain-in-the-Face, who he said fought Custer at Little Big Horn. The article recounts his arrest in Woodstock, Virginia, and transfer to Staunton to face charges.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Richmond Dispatch · 28 March 1899 · page 2

do fad he, hug been allowed steadily to tention, and the “tye of work and prices . “ate, although it bas turned into will be sure to ple=se you. ' ly-dressed woman of about 28 years, She is tall and willowy, and wears fine clothes, She says her maiden name was Mary Pauline Pate, and Toledo is her home, where live her mother and sisters and a brother, who is an official in the | city government; that in 1864, when she was a member of an opera company, she met Dr.

See moreSee less

Ray, whose real name is M. F. Chamberlain, at Dallas, Tex... where he was at a fair with his medicines, and that after a two weeks’ courtship they were married at her boarding-house by a justice of the peace, there being two other witnesseg present, but the names of these ghe is unable now to recall; that since that time they have lived together, at one time spending six months at Lex ington, Ky. Dr. Ray is an Illinois man. who, as she says, was adopted into the Sioux tribe at an early age. He claims to have known well Sitting Bull and Rain-in-the-Face, the big braves who butchered Custer and his men at Little Big Horn in 1878. He was proprie tor of an Indian show at Ch'cago on the Midway, and later at the Atlanta Fx position had thirty-seven Indians. He is a striking-looking figure, with flowing locks and with his tan sombrero and sweeping tan-colored coat-talils, The Commonwealth arrested him yes. terday in Shenandoah on two charges— bigamy and unlawful living—so that should the first charge fail ft will strengthen the prosecution in {ts plea that his life with his travelllng com panion wag an unlawful one, 2 Policeman Simpson went to Woodstock

See the clipping

Missouri Valley Times · Missouri Valley, Iowa

A broken wooden headboard and neglected mound in the Fort Yates military cemetery mark Sitting Bull's grave, the Sioux medicine man blamed for planning Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn. Relic hunters have cut away most of the headboard.

Missouri Valley Times · 30 March 1899 · page 5

Yates (N. 'D.) military cemetery mark ths resting place of Sitting Bull, the great Sioux medicine man whose wily brain planned the deathtrap of the Lit tle Big Horn into which Gen. Custer's command tell. On tbe broken head board is written: "Sf' Si. Sitting Bull, Indian." Reiio hunters have cut most of the headboard'away. Jerusalem's Fall front Glorr* Jerusalem is nownothlng but a shad ow of the magnificent city of ancient times. It is about three miles in cir cumference, aiid is situated on a rock arawtals.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The report describes the deteriorating grave site of Sitting Bull at Fort Yates military cemetery, noting a broken headboard reading 'No. 54. Sitting Bull, Indian.' It credits Sitting Bull's planning as the cause of the Little Bighorn disaster that destroyed Custer's command.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

San Antonio Daily Light · 30 March 1899 · page 7

Sitting Bull's Grave

ACCESSORIES OF WORSHIP. The Manner in Which Incense,Hellen and Offering* Brnan to Be Used. The use of incense in churches was forbidden as a heathen custom till the fifth century. The use of holy water was equally denounced as a practice of the pagan priests of Rome and of the ritual of Isis. The asperging of Julian in Gaul by a priest is perhaps the ear liest instance of the introduction of this corruption, which became a source of superstition in the fifth century, says Blackwood's Magazine. The won der-working power of the relics of mar tyrs began to be believed toward the close of the fourth century and almost immediately after we find complaint made of the sale of forged relics, both in the east and in the west.

See moreSee less

The sale of relics was forbidden by Theodosius, yet they constantly in creased in numbersand in importance until the holy table was converted into an. altar to hold them. In the fifth cen tury also ex voto offerings began to bo hung on church walls —a custom which was of heathen origin. The use of lights, which, as above said, was for bidden in the second century in the daytime, crept in in the fifth century. The Mithraio altars had much earlier supported candles, but these may have become necessary in underground chapels. Jerome wrote that it was slanderous to say that wax tapers were burned “in clear light,” but Paulinus of Nola, in 307 A. D., so decorated his church on festivals. Sitting Bull'* Grave. A broken wooden headboard and a neglected mound of earth in the Fort Yates (N. D.) military cemetery mark the resting place of Sitting Bull, the great Sioux medicine man whose wily brain planned the deathtrap of the Lit tle Big Horn into which Gen. Custer’s command fell. On the broken head board is written: “No. 54. Sitting Bull, Indian.” Relic hunters have cut' most of the headboard away. Jerusalem.'* Fall from Glory. Jerusalem is now-nothing but.a shad ow of the magnificent city of ancient times. It is about three miles in cir cumference, and is situated on a rock mountain. A SIGNIFICANT EVENT. Impressive Departure »r the Troop ship Grant for the Philip pine lalnnd*. An unwonted event took place in New York harbor lately. A great steamship, belonging to the United States government, liad been trans formed into a model troopship, that it might be used permanently as a mili tary transport. It was laden heavily with soldiers of the regular army, who were to be carried! by it to the Medi terranean sea, en route to the Philip pine islands, says Youth’s Companions This ship—renamed the Grant—bore, besides her 1,800 troops and crew, Gen. Lawton and. a staff of officers. Be amendatory thereof. fore she left on her long ocean voy age she steamed up the North river to a point opposite the tomb of Gen. Grant, There she fired a salute of 21 guns, and her bands slowly and sol em-niy played the national anthem. No circumstance of pomp, no empha sis of official recognition, were omitted in the dispatch of this ship. The sec retary of war stood on her deck when she fired her farewell guns at the base of the great general’s tomb. The sol diers were in uniform as on dresa pa rade, and the huge ship and its crowd ed decks was an impressive representa tive of national power. Not without similar ostentation is she to steam over waters once plowed by the gal leys o£ Roman and, Carthaginian sol diers. She carries large guns with which to fire salutes and exact them in return. Her significance is not to escape observation. Behind her on the great Saxon high road around the earth follow two more ships of like character, the Sherman and the Sheridan, both model trans ports, each bearing, as she does, nearly 2,000 American soldiers, and guns to awaken the echoes of the Mediterra nean and the Red seas. any and all bids.

See the clipping

The Burke County News · Morganton, N.C.

Charlie Bobo, a U.S. Army soldier, killed a police official in Havana, Cuba, was court-martialed, and sentenced to death by firing squad. His stepfather D. A. Knipe, described as the sole survivor of the Custer Massacre, traveled to consult Senator Pritchard in an effort to save Bobo's life.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Burke County News · 31 March 1899 · page 1

TRYING TO SAVE BOBO. Mr. Knipe, Who Alone Escaped from the Custer Massacre. Seek ing Clemency for His Step Son in Cuba. Charlie Bobo, a member of the regu lar army, is in serious trouble at Havana, Cuba. He killed a chief policeman there, and has been court martialed and sentenced to be shot. His step-father, Mr. D. A. Knipe, who lives in McDowell county, went to Asheville recently te consult Senator Pritchard, and a strong effort is being made to save the young man's life. The Marion correspondent of the Char-

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

The report announces the funeral of Mrs. Kelly, an Irish-born widow of Sergeant Kelly who was killed in the Custer massacre of 1876. It details her later life in Bismarck and Winona, her property, and her surviving descendants.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 31 March 1899 · page 5

SOLDIER'S WIDOW.

Mrs. Ellen Kelly of Winona died at that place on February 25. 1899. On Sunday her remains were removed to Bismarck, her old home, and buried in the family plot at the Catholic cemetery by her daughter, Mrs. Nellie Purcell, who came from California for that purpose. Mrs. Kelly was born in Ireland and came to this country when quite young. She was 63 years of age at the time of her death, and was the widow of Sergeant Kelly who was killed in the Custer massacre in 1876. Mrs. Kelly then came to Bismarck where she resided until the town Of Winona was founded.

See moreSee less

She was one of the first settlers there, owning con­ siderable property. Mrs. Kelly was the mother of three daughters—Mary Carey, and Mrs. Susan Pitts, wife of Major Pitts of Winona, both of whom are deceased, and Nellie, wife of James Purcell. the only surviving one. One of the grand­ daughters, Miss Alma Pitts, is the wife of Sergeant Havelick, who has ren-

See the clipping