In an 1899 report on the Philippine-American War, Colonel Cotpost praises General Otis's qualifications for frontier warfare, noting Otis served in the Big Horn expedition under General Miles just after the Custer massacre. The passage is a brief biographical aside establishing Otis's Indian-fighting credentials for the new campaign.
New-York Tribune · 7 February 1899 · page 3
afier tha Custer massacre and 1s a master of t sort of warfare. He has, in fact, written & » on Indian methods of fighting, I don’t think he'll have any trouble. Besides, he will goon : Jarge reinforcements. The 4th Infantry and battalion of the 17th which salled on the C "wr and the 20th and Infantry. which Francisco a short time ago, ought to strike er
The article argues that half-civilized peoples only understand force, not forbearance, citing US Indian wars and British colonial experience. It claims the Sioux uprising including the Custer massacre was precipitated by US withdrawal from treaty lands, which Indians interpreted as fear rather than good faith, drawing a parallel to the Philippines.
Evening Star · 8 February 1899 · page 1
MERCY LOST ON THEM
IndiaiiK KiicoariiRed by Tolerance. "When the government abandoned the old Milk river route, as it was called, through the northern Sioux country and evacuated I the lands to the Indians by treaty, it really piecipitated the whole of the great Sioux uprising that included the Custer massacre.
An American officer draws parallels between the Philippine-American War and past Indian wars, arguing that leniency is mistaken for weakness. He claims the U.S. withdrawal from the Milk River route under treaty provoked the Sioux uprising that included the Custer massacre.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 8 February 1899 · page 5
IN THE PHILIPPINES
W *\\ hen the government abandoned the old Milk river route as it was called through the Northern Sioux country, and evacuated the lands to the Indians by treaty, it really precipitated the whole of the great Sioux uprising that included the Custer massacre. Thought We Were Afraid.
An 1899 report on the Philippine-American War argues that the Sioux uprising and Custer massacre were caused by a too-lenient US Indian policy that natives mistook for fear. It draws a parallel to the Philippines, arguing a show of force there would prevent further conflict.
The Evening Tribune · 8 February 1899 · page 6
Bflwo had the same thing in India and 04, and 80 have all the Caucasian racés wherever they have had to depl with half civilized peoples. Weo loat mong mén and killed more Indiansin the west through the mild, temporiaing and supposedly Rumane policy of successive admintstrations than we ever would have lost th a few sharp, sound thrashings ad ministered in succeseive allopathic doses, Just to show the untutored savage that we meant business and would whip him firet and treat him right afterward. “When the governmaent asandoned the old Milk river route, as it was called, through the northern Stoux country and evacuated the lamnds to the Indlans by treaty, it really precipitated the whole of the great Sloux uprising that included the Custer massacre.
A newspaper commentary argues that the Sioux Wars, including the Custer massacre, were provoked by the Indians perceiving American withdrawal and restraint as weakness rather than mercy. It draws a direct parallel to the ongoing Philippine conflict, arguing forceful suppression is the only policy 'savage' peoples understand.
The Times · 8 February 1899 · page 1
LIKE INDIANS, “When the Government abandoned the old Milk River route, as it was called, through ahe Northern Sioux country, and evacuated the lands to the Indians by treaty, it really precipitated the whole of the great Sioux upr.sing that included the Custer massacre, This may sound harsh and prejudiced, but the fact was that, in spite of the treaty and pow wows, the Indians thought we withdrew from their country because we were afrald of them, and they went on burn ing abandoned military stations. and as there was nobody there to stop them and nobody cared whether they burned them or not, they went from that to the war path, and commenced wiping out settle ments outside their concession, “The case is just the same to-day in the Philippines.
See moreSee less
It is unfortunate for them that the natives cannot understand a humane policy on the part of this Gov ernment or that we intend to deal hon
The piece argues that half-civilized peoples only respect force, not forbearance, drawing a parallel between U.S. Indian wars and the Philippine-American War. It claims the Sioux uprising and the Custer massacre were caused by the U.S. abandoning the Milk River route, which Indians interpreted as fear rather than honesty.
The Salt Lake Herald · 9 February 1899 · page 2
THRASHING
When the government abandoned the old Milk River route a it was called through the northern Sioux country and evacuated the lands to the Indians an by treaty it really precipitated the whole of the great Sioux uprising that included the Custer massacre This may sound harsh and prejudicial but the fact was that in spite of the treaty and powwows the Indians thought we withdrew from their country be cause we were afraid of them and they went to burnIng abandoned mili tary stations and as there was nobody there to stop them and nobody cared whether they burned them or not they
The Semi-Weekly Messenger · Wilmington, N.C. · and 1 other paper
An army officer argues that lenient treatment of 'half-civilized' peoples is perceived as weakness, citing the Sioux wars and the Custer massacre as proof that forbearance led to greater bloodshed. He claims abandoning the 'Milk river route' and ceding land by treaty directly triggered the Sioux uprising culminating in Custer's death.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Semi-Weekly Messenger · 10 February 1899 · page 8
ARMY OFFICERS' VIEWS
The British have had the same thing in India and Africa and so have all the Caucasian races when ever they have had to deal with half-civilized peoples. We lost more men and killed more Indians in the west through the mild temporizing and supposedly hu mane policy of successive administra tions than we ever would have lost in a few sharp, sound thrashings administeredin successive allopathic doses, Just to show the untutored sav age that we meant business and would whip him first and treat him right af terward. "When the government abandoned the old Milk river route, as it was call ed, through the northern Sioux country and evacuated the lands to the Indians by treaty it really precipitated the whole of the great Sioux uprising that included the Custer massacre.
See moreSee less
This may sound harsh and prejudiced, but the fact was that in spite of the treaty and powwows, the Indians thought we withdrew from their country because we were afraid of them and they went on burning abandoned military stations, and as there was nobody there to stop them and nobody cared whether they burned them or not, they went from that to the warpath and commenced wiping out settlements outside theircon cession. "The case is just the same today in the Philippines. It is unfortunate for them that the natives can't understand a humane policy on the part of this government or that we intend to deal honestly with them. Forbearance on our part now simply means to them that we are afraid of them and the quicker we whip them, thoroughly and disabuse their minds, the sooner we can enter on an era of peaceful reconstruc tion and reform."
The Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 8 February 1899
The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont. · and 1 other paper
The article describes Bishop Hare's 25 years of missionary work among the Sioux, noting that his converts include warriors who once fought with Sitting Bull in the battle where Custer died. It portrays a transformation from warfare to Christian worship, highlighted by a large annual outdoor convocation on the South Dakota prairie.
The Philipsburg Mail · 10 February 1899 · page 7
Among the Different Tribes. it was just a quarter of a century Ago that Bishop Hare, then a young man of thirty-four, left his Philadel phia home and went out to spread the gospel among the Sioux. In these twenty-five years he has gathered a red army of the cross num bering over 5,000. In this mighty band are warriors who fought with Sitting Bull in the bloody fight where Custer lost his lire, and others who often terrorized the pioneers in the fined in the bamboo."
The Neihart Herald · Neihart, Mont. · 4 February 1899
The Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The article recounts Sitting Bull's threatening letter to Lieutenant Otis demanding supplies and his retreat, followed by Otis's tense encounter with overwhelming Indian forces shortly after the Little Bighorn battle. It then describes Otis's later role in the 1876-77 winter campaign against Crazy Horse, including the brutal Battle of Wolf Mountains fought in freezing conditions.
The Age-Herald · 15 February 1899 · page 8
“I mean all the rations you’ve got and Cj some powder. Wish you would write as soon as you can.” C Otis sent a firm reply by a scout, and 2 proceeded with his train, surrounded by the Indians^ who, for a considerable time, kept up a desultory firing. The young com mander's situation was grave. The InVn dians outnumbered his command nearly 100 21 to one, and they were in an ugly mood and i flushed with the victory on the Little Big C Horn. He was, therefore, greatly relieved when he met General Miles’ command.
See moreSee less
C General Miles complimented Otis on his 2* firmness and discretion. A less cool headed commander would have Involved Cl his troops in a battle that would no doubt ■ have ended In a massacre. Otis took a prominent part in the winter JJjj campaign of 1876-77 against Crazy Horse, n and for his meritorious services at the battle of Wolf Mountains he was promoted to colonel. That was a wonderful cam paign. Those who have seen only holiday JJjj soldiers or even troops on ordinary field - service would scarcely have recognized the 4G3 officers and enlisted men who started Jjj up the valley of the Tongue River, Mon tana, on the 29th of December, 1876. Over ^ the heavy w^oolen clothing, supplied to the gj army for winter wear, the men were fur clad from head to foot. Enormous over- ™ shoes of rubber, or of buffalo skin, flesh dn
This profile of Major General Elwell Otis recounts his Civil War service and later army career, including his role in the 1876 campaign against the Sioux following Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn. It details General Miles's command in the Yellowstone region, the building of winter cantonments, and the ongoing military operations against the Sioux that fall and winter.
The Age-Herald · 15 February 1899 · page 8
MAJOR GENERAL ELWELL S. OTIS
"Watt until you meet the Sioux.” In 1876, the year of the Custer massacre, General Miles, who was stationed at Fort Leavenworth, Kan., received orders to pro ceed with the Fifth infantry to the scene of hostilities to form a subordinate part
A Montana newspaper article mainly about chinook winds digresses to note that school textbooks once erroneously located the Custer massacre in Wyoming. It states this error persisted until Colonel Sanders protested and the legislature threatened to drop the textbook, forcing a correction.
The Anaconda Standard · 15 February 1899 · page 11
the day. By the way, this recalls the fact that the ordinary school text books are be hind the times in their explanation of the chinook wind. It is strange that the text books are so often incorrect, but that is a fact. For many years the history used in Montana schools locat ed the Custer massacre down in Wyom ing, and it was not until Colonel Sand
A newspaper interviews associates of an aged Sioux chief, White Eagle, who years earlier described Custer fighting to the last before falling to a tomahawk. The account repeats the legend that Rain-in-the-Face cut out Custer's heart and ate part of it in revenge.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.
Wrong
Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 17 February 1899 · page 7
The Kind You Have Always Bought Bears the Signature of One of Sitting Bull's Warriors. Two distinguished visitors in the city Friday was tho famous Sioux chief White Eagle and his wife. Mr. and Mrs. Whito Eagle aro camped on the river bottom about a mile from the city and came in yesterday to beg for stray scraps of meat from tho various butcher shops of the city. White Eagle was a member of Sitting Bull's famous band and was present at the Custer massacre, where he says "tho great white chief and his warriors fought as they never fought before."
See moreSee less
Sometimes when the grim old warrior is feeling particularly good-na tured he tells of tho fight very enter tainingly, but it is only very rarely that ho can bo prevailed upon to speak of it at all and yesterday when approached upon the subject he only grunted audi bly and remarked that his people had defeated the great white chief but be the Sioux language quite fluently and in one of his more talkative moods White Eagle once gave him a very interesting account of how Custer came to his death. He said that Custer and his men fought like demons to the last and that the general was the last of all the brave band to fall, lighting over the bodies of his dead comrades until a blow from a tomahawk brought his gallant re sistance to an end. White Eagle says his people believed Custer to possess some great medicine which was bullet proof and states'that they were greatly dis mayed at not being able to kill him with their rifles. He relates that after he had been killed his heart was cut out by Rain-in-the-Face whose hatred for him was intense and who is said to have eaten apiece of it to show his exultation and glut his savago desire for revenge. The abode of tho White Eagles consist of a canvas-covered frame of poles and the chief and his worthy spouse complain that it is very cold and that they are compelled to sit up all night to keep warm. Like all Indians they are im provident and at present are penniless and live on what they can beg from the stores. Whito Eagle was at the World's Fair and was one of a delegation of In dians who visited New York City and when he returned reported to his people that it would be useless to wage war against tho pale faces any longer.
At a lavish Sons of the American Revolution banquet in San Francisco, speeches on patriotism and anti-imperialism were given by prominent members. The ceremony featured Trumpeter William G. Hardy, described as perhaps the last survivor of the Custer massacre, who led the march and sounded calls during the event.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The San Francisco Call · 23 February 1899 · page 8
SOCIETY AND ITS GUESTS,
A seat at the banquet board of the Cali fornia Society of the Sons of the Ameri can Revolution last night was a glorious place. The event. In whose commemora tion the banquet was given, could not have been more fittingly celebrated in speech, song and feast, and the Sons of the American Revolution of San Fran cisco prepared both programme and feast on lines which will long be remembered. At 6 o'clock about 200 members and guests were present at the Merchants' \ Club. The affair had been elaborately ar ranged and every possible care taken to present original and unique details.
See moreSee less
Trum peter William G. Hardy, Troop B, Fourth Cavalry, U. S. A., perhaps the last sur vivor of the celebrated Custer massacre, kindly consented to assist in the even
Major William F. O'Brien, superintendent of the National Cemetery in Staunton, Virginia, died at age 88. He had served in the U.S. Army with Company K, Second Cavalry, and was with Reno during the famous Custer fight against the Indians.
The Times · 24 February 1899 · page 2
OBITUARY.
| | ebrated Custer fight with the Indians. Since Maj. O'Brien has been here he has made many warm friends, He dressed in the full uniform of the UU, 8, and parad ed with Confederate Veterans on all oc | casions, | The Stonewall Jackson Camp Confed erate Veterans will attend the funeral in | a body. The interment will be in the National Cemetery by special permission from the War Department. Maj. O’Brien leaves a son, Father O'Brien, of Fay etteville, N. C., and two daugrters. ctNaorvell Baker
This 1899 obituary for Maj. William O'Brien recounts his military career, including service under Maj. Reno at the Little Bighorn in June 1876. It states Custer's entire force of fourteen officers and 232 men was massacred when Reno and Custer were to jointly meet the Indians.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Washington Weekly Post · 28 February 1899 · page 2
DEATH OF A VETERAN
Seecial to The Fest. Staunton, Va., Feb. 22.—Maj. William O'Brien. aged sixty-nine, Superintenden® of the Staunton National Cemetery, died here to-day of brain and Kidney disease, jorn in Ireland, he early emigrated to America and enlisted in the regular army as a member of Company I, Second Cav airy. He served gallantly as a Union <oldier in the war between the States in Company K, Second Artillery. His bro ther was Killed on the Confederate side. After Appomattox he rejoined the Sec ond Cavalry and saw service on the fron tier, fighting Sitting Bull's braves.
See moreSee less
He was under Maj. Reno about Little Big Horn, where Rene and Custer, in June, 1876, were to jointly meet the Indians, and when Custer, fourteen officers, and 232 men, his whole force, were massacred, By special permission of the War De partment he will be buried in the Na tional Cemetery, and the Stonewall Brig ade Band and Stonewall Jackson Camp of Confederate Veterans will attend the fu neral in a body. Maj. O'Brien is sur vived by two daughters and a son, Father O Brien, of Fayetteville, N. C,
The report announces the death of Maj. William O'Brien, superintendent of Staunton National Cemetery, who had served under Maj. Reno near Little Big Horn in 1876. It recaps that Custer's 'whole force' of 14 officers and 232 men was massacred there.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The Washington Weekly Post · 28 February 1899 · page 2