As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

January 1898

39 articles

The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.

A Los Angeles dispatch reports that George Benjamin, a crippled miner, claims to be the sole survivor of the Little Big Horn massacre and is traveling to Washington with Senator White to seek a pension. He recounts his story of prospecting, Indian attacks on nearby settlers, and joining Custer's men before being captured and tortured.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Indianapolis Journal, 26 December 1897, The Indianapolis Journal, 26 December 1897.

The Somerset Herald · 5 January 1898 · page 1

S MINER WHO SAW CUSTER DIE. Tlifl Sola Survivor of the Indian Mas sacre at Little Big Horn. Georg Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, Is on his way to Wash ington, where he hopes to secure a pen sion, says a Los Angeles dispatch to the New York Sun. He claims to have boeu with Custer at the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Although it was sup posed that there was no survivor of the massacre, Benjamin's story bears marks of truthfaluess, and the fact that he was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tortures long prevented his experience from being made known.

See moreSee less

Senator Stephen M. White is taking him to Washington and will try to gt a jensiou fir him this w inter. "In ;he spring of ISTo," .ys B -njs-min, ''I was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June we were camped ou Clark's Creek, and as we were g .'tting short of supplies Kelly aud I went out to shoot game for stipjH.'r, leaving Stone in camp. When we returned we found him dead aud horri bly mutilated. We knew al once t:iat the Indians were on the warpath und that we'd better get out So we started at once for roster s ranch, but whea we reached there we found that the In dians had been ahead of us. E very man, woman aud child on the rt:i;'i bad been murdered, and all the b slk-s had been mutilated. The house bud been burned and all the horses and cat tle driven ott". We started for Chey enne to give warning of the uprising, and on tlie way we met a body f Cus ter's men. They asked us to join in the pursuit, and I consented gladly, but my partner, Kelly, decided to go on to Cheyenne. Not lorg afterward, we found his b.vly, sculped and cut to piecei, only a few miles from where we parted. "We broke camp on June 13, and Major Reno scouted the trail to the Rosebud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. Gibbons was ordered to cross the Yellowstone near ! the mouth of the Big Horn and meet General Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June "!. On June 21 the trail of the ludians was scouted twenty eight miles up the Rosebud. That night council was held, and the troops left the Iisebud and marched up Dirty Woman's Creek toward the Big Horn, ten miles, aud went into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning tbe troops were in the'saddle soon afW daybreak, and about 8 o'clock the first Indians were s?en by the scouts from the top of the divide. "At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way liefore us. But they soon swarmed upon us from every direction. They came upon us from front and rear and flank, and ev ery ravine and every bush and tree seemed alive with them. We soon knew that we were d;xmed, and we fought as meu fight only under such circumstances. A perfect storm of ar rows and bullets was pouring upon us from every side, but we fought our way back to our horses, mounted, and in onr struggle to reach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the field. But ten Indi ans went down for every white man who fell. The companies of Captain Calhoun and Lieutenant Crittenden were thrown across our flank to protect our retreat. "General Custer was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof. Captain Keogh's company was exposed to the fiercest fire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as if we were hours making that retreat of a quarter of a mile. We made our last stand on a little knoll, which we reach ed with oulv seventeen men out of our entire command. "There the first thing we did was to shoot our horses, so as to make a breast work behind which we could fiht General Custer and his brother Tom and Lieutenant Cook were among the last to fall. Custer died with his re volver in his left hand and his salier iu his right hand, with a dozen dead In dians piled around him. And, indeed. almost every man on' that li tie knoll went down with just such a heap of red bodies around him. Charley Rey nolds, a scout, and as brave a man as ever lived, brought down an Indian at every shot, and as he fell he emptied his revolver still with a steady hand The Indians were armed, in addition to their bows and arrows, with the best guns to be bad. "Before we went into battle Trum peter Martin was sent back with orders to Captain McDougal and Captaiu Ben teen to hurry forward with their com panies. Had they done so, and had Reno's men come up to reinforce us, the result might have been very dif ferent "When I shot my horse a bulle struck me in the head and I fell. In its death struggles the horse rolled over on me and protected me during the rest of the fight When it was all over and the Indiaus swarmed over the knoll they chanced to see that I was still alive. They then bound me hand and foot and took me to their camp. "There they already had two other white men, prospectors, and a young white woman. They put these three through tortures, which I was compel ed to witness. But I was reserved for the last, because the execution I bad done in the fight had been noticed, and they wanted to have revenge for it In fact, they named me "Little Thundtrer," aud called me by that name all tbe time I was among them. The two prospectors were made to run the gaunt let again and again. Each time the arrows were pulled out by force and fresh ones shot into them. One of the men finally resisted and was brained with a tomahawk. When theother b came too weak to afford any more sport of that sort, he was bound to a stake, a slow fire was built on his abdomen and the bucks and squaws danced around him, laughing over hid death agonies.

See the clipping

The Somerset Herald · Somerset, Pa.

A man claims to have been with Custer's command at the Little Bighorn, describing a desperate retreat under overwhelming Indian attack culminating in a doomed last stand with only seventeen men. He also recounts earlier discovering murdered, mutilated civilians and a slain companion during the outbreak of the uprising.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Somerset Herald · 5 January 1898 · page 1

S MINER WHO SAW CUSTER DIE. Tlifl Sola Survivor of the Indian Mas sacre at Little Big Horn. Georg Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, Is on his way to Wash ington, where he hopes to secure a pen sion, says a Los Angeles dispatch to the New York Sun. He claims to have boeu with Custer at the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Although it was sup posed that there was no survivor of the massacre, Benjamin's story bears marks of truthfaluess, and the fact that he was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tortures long prevented his experience from being made known.

See moreSee less

Senator Stephen M. White is taking him to Washington and will try to gt a jensiou fir him this w inter. "In ;he spring of ISTo," .ys B -njs-min, ''I was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June we were camped ou Clark's Creek, and as we were g .'tting short of supplies Kelly aud I went out to shoot game for stipjH.'r, leaving Stone in camp. When we returned we found him dead aud horri bly mutilated. We knew al once t:iat the Indians were on the warpath und that we'd better get out So we started at once for roster s ranch, but whea we reached there we found that the In dians had been ahead of us. E very man, woman aud child on the rt:i;'i bad been murdered, and all the b slk-s had been mutilated. The house bud been burned and all the horses and cat tle driven ott". We started for Chey enne to give warning of the uprising, and on tlie way we met a body f Cus ter's men. They asked us to join in the pursuit, and I consented gladly, but my partner, Kelly, decided to go on to Cheyenne. Not lorg afterward, we found his b.vly, sculped and cut to piecei, only a few miles from where we parted. "We broke camp on June 13, and Major Reno scouted the trail to the Rosebud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. Gibbons was ordered to cross the Yellowstone near ! the mouth of the Big Horn and meet General Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June "!. On June 21 the trail of the ludians was scouted twenty eight miles up the Rosebud. That night council was held, and the troops left the Iisebud and marched up Dirty Woman's Creek toward the Big Horn, ten miles, aud went into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning tbe troops were in the'saddle soon afW daybreak, and about 8 o'clock the first Indians were s?en by the scouts from the top of the divide. "At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way liefore us. But they soon swarmed upon us from every direction. They came upon us from front and rear and flank, and ev ery ravine and every bush and tree seemed alive with them. We soon knew that we were d;xmed, and we fought as meu fight only under such circumstances. A perfect storm of ar rows and bullets was pouring upon us from every side, but we fought our way back to our horses, mounted, and in onr struggle to reach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the field. But ten Indi ans went down for every white man who fell. The companies of Captain Calhoun and Lieutenant Crittenden were thrown across our flank to protect our retreat. "General Custer was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof. Captain Keogh's company was exposed to the fiercest fire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as if we were hours making that retreat of a quarter of a mile. We made our last stand on a little knoll, which we reach ed with oulv seventeen men out of our entire command. "There the first thing we did was to shoot our horses, so as to make a breast work behind which we could fiht General Custer and his brother Tom and Lieutenant Cook were among the last to fall. Custer died with his re volver in his left hand and his salier iu his right hand, with a dozen dead In dians piled around him. And, indeed. almost every man on' that li tie knoll went down with just such a heap of red bodies around him. Charley Rey nolds, a scout, and as brave a man as ever lived, brought down an Indian at every shot, and as he fell he emptied his revolver still with a steady hand The Indians were armed, in addition to their bows and arrows, with the best guns to be bad. "Before we went into battle Trum peter Martin was sent back with orders to Captain McDougal and Captaiu Ben teen to hurry forward with their com panies. Had they done so, and had Reno's men come up to reinforce us, the result might have been very dif ferent "When I shot my horse a bulle struck me in the head and I fell. In its death struggles the horse rolled over on me and protected me during the rest of the fight When it was all over and the Indiaus swarmed over the knoll they chanced to see that I was still alive. They then bound me hand and foot and took me to their camp. "There they already had two other white men, prospectors, and a young white woman. They put these three through tortures, which I was compel ed to witness. But I was reserved for the last, because the execution I bad done in the fight had been noticed, and they wanted to have revenge for it In fact, they named me "Little Thundtrer," aud called me by that name all tbe time I was among them. The two prospectors were made to run the gaunt let again and again. Each time the arrows were pulled out by force and fresh ones shot into them. One of the men finally resisted and was brained with a tomahawk. When theother b came too weak to afford any more sport of that sort, he was bound to a stake, a slow fire was built on his abdomen and the bucks and squaws danced around him, laughing over hid death agonies.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New York Evening Journal · New York, N.Y.

A report claims a 25-year-old white woman was rescued from the Cheyenne after being held captive since the Little Bighorn massacre of 1876. The story speculates she was the orphaned child of ranchmen killed by Sitting Bull's band after they fled to Canada.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New York Evening Journal · 6 January 1898 · page 2

Justice Oleott on the Bench. William M. K. Oleott took his seat to-day as Justice of the City Court. He sat in | died and was buried u'J sea. Part I and heard the motion calendar. ennes, Who Probably Killed Her Parents. A pretty white girl, who has been a captive of the Cheyenne Indiana wince the Custer massacre, has been rescued. She can remember noth ing of her parents. Sioux Falls, S. D., Jan. fi.—Superintend ent Sherrard arrived homo yesterday from the Cheyenne Indian reservation with a* twenty-five-yenr-old white girl, who has been a prisoner among 4he Indians ever since Sitting Bull's massacre of General Custer and the Seventh Regiment In the Little Big Horn, in Montana.

See moreSee less

The girl has grown up among the Indians and knows nothing of her parents. All un usually friendly Indian called the attention of the whites to the girl, who was kept in the Interior, away from the agency people, and this led 10 her rescue. Her Parents Were Killed. She is a bright, dark, curly haired young woman, and when seen to-day could speak only n few words of English. From Indian sources it is learned that, after the massacre of Custer, Hitting Bull and his tribe of 2,000 Indians moved north into British America, and that several ranchmen and their families were killed by them. It is believed that the girl, who, for some ; unknown reason, was called Anna Russel;, was the child of one of these ranchmen. She will lie provided with a home in some ; good family as soon as possible.

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper story claims a 25-year-old white woman was rescued from the Cheyenne reservation after allegedly being held captive by Sioux since Sitting Bull's defeat of Custer in 1876. The account says she grew up among the Indians, speaks little English, and may be the orphaned child of ranchers killed by Sitting Bull's band after they fled to Canada.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Times · 7 January 1898 · page 3

CAPTIVE MAIDEN RESCUED.

THOMAS WALKER, l5l',t Trustee H16-18 blh btnw.: rurnlturesacs every Tuesday anil Friday. 10 n. in ' crocVprv Uade sales Thursdays 10 L m -DonsiFrf. Biente iccelved dally for aboveealei de4-3roo-em Md. ave. netendent Sherrard arrived homo yester day from the Cheyenne Indian reserva tion with a twenty-five-year-old white girl, who has been a prisoner among the Indians ever since Sitting Bull's massacre of General Custer and the Seventh Regiment in the Little Big Horn, In Montana.

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

This passage is a theater review discussing stage plays, including 'Northern Lights,' a war drama incorporating Custer's last stand and the Indian uprising of 1876 as dramatic elements. The review praises the play's exciting climaxes and audience reception, interspersed with advertisements for clothing.

The Times · 8 January 1898 · page 5

engagement at the Academy next Mon day night The authors, Messrs. Har kins and Barbour, have covered a wide range of characters and a plethora of dramatic material. They have used war, medicine, heredity, soldiers, In dians, the aurora borealis, Custer's

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This is a theatrical review from 1898 describing a play called 'Northern Lights' showing at the Academy of Music, which is set during the time period of the Custer massacre in Montana in 1876. The review describes the plot involving a post surgeon and his Sioux assistant, culminating in a dramatized version of the Custer incident at a fictional Fort Terry.

Evening Star · 8 January 1898 · page 24

come in this city. There will be matinees Thursday and Saturday. ACADEMY OF MUSIC?The attraction at the Academy for next week will be Harklns and Barbour's romantic war play, "North ern Lights," which was extremely well re ceived hero last season. It is an American druma, pure and simple. There is a good deal of realism about it and there is a very large element of fun. All the scenes of the play nre laid in Montana, and the time occupied is from June 0 to June 25,1876, covering the period of the Custer massacre. It was the time of

See the clipping

Worcester Morning Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass.

At a public talk, Capt. Jack Crawford entertains an audience with anecdotes from his frontier life, including claims he was one of the first into the Black Hills during the gold rush and that he narrowly missed being with Custer because he was sent to Chicago to assay gold samples. He also recounts his famous ride carrying news of a fight between Gen. Merritt's command and Indians to Fort Laramie.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Worcester Morning Daily Spy · 8 January 1898 · page 10

CAPT. "JACK" CRAWFORD.

of the first men to go into the Black Hills at the time of the gold discovery there, and the only reason he was not with Gen. Custer at the time of the massacre was because he was sent with a sample of gold to Chicago to be as sayed. Most exciting was his tale of carrying the story of the fight between the In dians and Gen. Merritt’s command, near Deadwood, to Ft. Larramie, a distance of 350 miles, how he braved death and starvation, yet succeeded in his at tempt and received commendations for so doing.

See moreSee less

Capt. Crawford, although a man con siderably over 50 and showing plainly the result of his frontier life, is plan ning to head an expedition to the Klon dike in the coming March.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A newspaper reports that a 25-year-old white woman has been rescued from the Cheyenne reservation, said to have been held captive by Sioux since Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn in 1876. She reportedly cannot recall her parents' identity, though officials hope to trace her origins.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

The Topeka State Journal · 10 January 1898 · page 2

She Had Been Their Captive Since the Custer Massacre. Sioux Falls, S. D-, Jan. 10. Superin tendent Sherrard arrived home today from the Cheyenne reservation with a 25-year-old white girl, who has been a prisoner among the Indians ever since Sitting Bull's massacre of General Cus ter and the Seventh regiment in the Little Big Horn, in Montana The girl has grown up among the In dians and knows nothing of her par ents. An unusually friendly Indian called the attention of the whites to the girl, who was kept in the interior, away from the agency people, and this led to her rescue.

See moreSee less

She is a bright, dark curly-haired woman, and when seen today could speak, only a few words of English. She distinctly remembers her parents, and a search is being made to discover their identity. From Indian sources it is learned that, after the massacre of Custer, Sitting Bull and his tribe of 2,000 Indians moved north into British America, and that several ranchmen and their families were killed by them. It is believed that the girl, who, for some unknown reason, was called Anna Russell, was the child of one of these ranchmen. She will be provided with a home in some good family as soon as possible. There is a Cass of People. Who are Injured by the use of coffee. Recently there has been placed in all the grocery stores a new preparation called GRAIN-O, made of pure era ins, that takes the place of coffee. The most delicate stomach receives it with out distress, aid but few can tell it from coffee. It does not cost over 14 as much. Children may drink It with great benefit. 15 -rents and 25 cents per package. Try it. Ask for GRAIN-O. Ballard's Snow lniment 'will enre Lame Back, Sore Throat, Wounds, Sprains, Bruises, Cuts. Old Sores. La dies, it will cure your back-ache. . Geo. W. Stansfield, 632 Kan. Ave., and Mil ler's Pharmacy, Cor. 6th an4 Topeka avenue. a

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A 1898 filler item describes a bar anecdote followed by a scene of local Indians examining a painting depicting Custer's Last Stand. One Indian pantomimes the battle to his companions, pointing out warriors, scalps, and Custer's death amid the chaos.

The Anaconda Standard · 10 January 1898 · page 3

ANACONDA NEWS. . LIIO11 TREASURES ons That Would Gladden the Heart of an Antiquarian. AGENUINE WIDOW'S MITE, A-Coin That was Current During the Tilm of Carist-A Bare aRs bethe Mendal-The Aotor's

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper theater review describes the play 'Northern Lights' at the Academy, which reenacts the Sioux campaign under Crook in the Little Big Horn Valley with soldiers, Indians, and a trained warhorse. The review focuses on the play's romantic subplot and theatrical spectacle rather than historical accuracy.

The Times · 11 January 1898 · page 6

Northern LlglilH. "Northern Lights" scintillated with great brilliance at the Academy last evening, and some of the people who saw the play last year, and some who did not, were promptly on hand. The two contingents together made a "ery good house. After the curtain went up everybody was carried back at once to the time of the Sioux campaign un der Crook, In the Little Big Horn Val ley, for there were plenty of Indians and plenty of soldiers and plenty of f.'uns and a warhorse named Queen Bess, who performed her part with great propriety and sedateness. The plot is an exciting one, and the thrills were many and deep. There

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper entertainment section advertises various theater productions in Washington, including William Calder's Company performing 'Northern Lights,' described as 'A Story of the Custer Massacre.' This is a fictionalized military drama staged for entertainment, not a news report.

The Times · 11 January 1898 · page 6

LIGHTS sixty People A Story of the Custer Massacre. Next Week The Eminent Comedian. TYM. BARKY, in "The Rising Generation." COLUMBIA Tnlght at S:i5. """ Mats. Thurs. and Sat.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report reviews a romantic military melodrama set during the Indian wars, describing its plot as centering on General Crook's 1876 campaign against Sitting Bull culminating in the Little Bighorn tragedy where Custer died. It details the cast's performances and the play's realistic staging.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Star · 11 January 1898 · page 10

en< <?. The si t no of the play Is located in Montana, and the time when General Crook made hi*, celebrated campaign against Sil ting Bull In lHTti, culminating in the trag edy rn tile Utile Big Horn, in which til gall-tnl Custer and his band lost their lives. The plot turns on the loves and scientific clinics of Sidney Sherwood, an arniv sur geon, who first commiis crime for the pur pose of satisfying his desire to gain scien tific data and later, to carry out his per sonal er.ds. The part of the hero is divided between John Swiftwind, a full-blooded Sioux Indian, who is assistant to Surgeon Sherwood, and Wallace Gray, who deserted i

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An advertisement announces William Calder's Company performing a military drama titled 'Lights' with 100 cast members, described as 'A Story of the Custer Massacre.' The show runs with Wednesday and Saturday matinees at the Academy theater.

Evening Star · 11 January 1898 · page 10

LIGHTS. A Story of the Custer Massacre. Next Week?The Emiuent Comedian. WM. BARRY, in -THE RISING GENERATION*.". jal0-20ti AT THE Cor. 10th and G sts. n.w. | 00 PEOPLE. |

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper advertisement lists the Academy theater's production of 'Northern Lights,' described as 'A Story of the Custer Massacre' and called one of the most successful modern military dramas. The ad is part of a larger entertainment listings section for Washington theaters in January 1898.

Evening Star · 12 January 1898 · page 10

LIGHTS. A Story of the Custer Massacre. Next Week?The Eminent Comedian, WM. BARRY, ? In "THE RISING GENERATION." Jn12-2utf OIJOtT THEATER. 1Q> Mat. Every Day-Every Night 10, 20. 30, 50c. High-class Vaudeville and Comedy.

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A theater advertisement promotes a sixty-person military drama billed as 'A Story of the Custer Massacre,' playing alongside other shows. It is part of a page of theater listings with no new factual reporting on the event itself.

The Times · 13 January 1898 · page 6

UGHTS A Story of the Custer Massacre. Next Week The Eminent Comedian, WM. BARRY in "The Rising Generation." HERMITS LTCEUM THEATER. ALU THIS WEElv. '. Sixty People I

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

An advertisement for the Academy theater promotes 'Northern Lights,' described as a successful modern military drama and 'A Story of the Custer Massacre.' The show runs with Wednesday and Saturday matinees, with other acts following in subsequent weeks.

Evening Star · 13 January 1898 · page 10

NORTHERN LIGHTS

LHQ1H1TS. i i A Story of the Custer Massacre. Next Week?The Eminent Cemedian. WM. BARRY, In "THE RLSINO GENERATION.** jal2-2btf [L^ERNAN'S LYCEUM THEATCR. All Tui8 Week. ? +

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The report recounts Red Cloud's life as a feared warrior and later agency leader, describing his role in frontier conflicts including the 1876 Sioux war near the Little Big Horn. It details his relationship with Indian agents, especially Dr. McGillicuddy, and his decline into old age by the 1890 Sioux campaign.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Times · 13 January 1898 · page 4

OLD RED CLOUD DYING

thee As cowardly as he was crafty, he excelled them all in plotting mis chief, but when plots ripened into war he left his associates to bear the labors of war while he courted their enemies under an assumed friendship. Perhaps his most astrocious deed was the Fort McKlnney massacre, in which over a score of United States soldiers were led into ambusli and slaughtered. That was when he was a vigorous young buck. Before this tragedy "Old Red" was a common marauder full of devilment, and it Is probable that he took many a scalp from the wagon trains then on their way to Ttah and the land of gold beyond the Rockies.

See moreSee less

But -for the last thirt years Red Cloud has led a comparatively peaceful life. While his crafty counsel was often sought by his tribesmen, and his rank among them was that of a leader, the Government did not clothe him with the dignity of chieftain, but reckoned him only as Red Cloud, powerful enough without a title and yet too dangerous to be its possessor. When the old Sioux and Cheyennes rebelled in 1S76, Red Cloud did not go on the warpath, but his heart was with the hostiles who were crimsoning the grass along the Little Big Horn with the blood of the Seventh's troopers. Because of his apparent friendship the Government built for him a two-story frame house near the Pine Ridge Atrencv buildings. His hatred of the. whites had been intensified by the

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

An advertisement for the Academy theater promotes 'Northern Lights,' described as 'the Most Successful Military Drama' and 'A Story of the Custer Massacre,' featuring a cast of sixty people. This is a commercial theatrical production rather than a news report of the actual historical event.

The Evening Times · 13 January 1898 · page 4

NORTHERN LIGHTS Sixty People A Story of the Custer Massacre. Next Week The Eminent Comedian, WM. BARRY In "The RIMng Generation." Grand Opera House KERXAX t RIFE. Mnaxerf. One Week, Commencing January 10.

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper amusements listing advertises 'Northern Lights,' billed as 'A Story of the Custer Massacre,' playing at the Academy theater at popular prices. The ad is surrounded by other theater and concert listings, including Sousa's concerts and various comedies.

The Times · 14 January 1898 · page 6

LIGHTS Sixty Poop, A St6ry of the Custer Massacre Next Week The Eminent Comedian, WM. BARRY in "The Rising Generation.'' Grand Opera House KERNAN & RIFE, Managers. One Week, Commencing January 10.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A dispatch reports that a fifteen-year-old white girl, found as a baby among a remnant of Sitting Bull's band rounded up in 1884, has been rescued and brought to Sioux Falls. The band was linked to Sitting Bull's followers after Little Bighorn, and efforts are underway to locate her parents, believed to be living in Montana.

The Indianapolis Journal · 14 January 1898 · page 7

Ago by Indian*, I* Recovered. Sioux Falls (S. D.) Dispatch in New York Herald. Anna Russell, the fifteen-year-old white girl who was rescued from the Indians and brought to this city yesterday, will be taken to her parents, if they can be found. The girl is in the Children’s Home here, and every effort is being made to locate her parents, who, it is believed, are now living in Montana. A remnant of Sitting Bull’s band of Indians was rounded up in Manitoba by the government troops in 1884 and driven to the Cheyenne River reserva tion, where the main body of the tribe, including Sitting Bull himself, had been lo cated alter the battle of Little Big Horn, when General Custer’s command was mas sacred.

See moreSee less

This was eight years after the bat

See the clipping

Washington Sentinel · Washington City, D.C.

An advertisement promotes 'Northern Lights,' described as a successful modern military drama based on a story of the Custer Massacre. It appears amid other theater listings and advertisements in a newspaper entertainment section.

Washington Sentinel · 15 January 1898 · page 2

NORTHERN LIGHTS. A story of the Custer Massacre, Next week The Eminent Comedian, WM. BARRY, in “The Rising Generation” Car OPERA HOUSE. HERNAN & RIFE, MANAGERS,

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1898 report describes plans for the Omaha exposition, including a Wild West show featuring a re-enactment of 'the Custer massacre.' The piece lists various attractions, treating the Little Bighorn battle as a staged entertainment spectacle.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 15 January 1898 · page 17

Shows containing Indian massacre.-, such : Es a re-enactment of the Custer massacre j of 1*77, and other scenes of scouting life as j they formerly took place in the west. A representation of mining at Cripple Cree.i will be given, depicting life in the minitiT I camps ami also other queer features, si.ch as the Sherman umbrella. In which passen gers are sent flying around a circle in a car which is laised to a height of 300 feet above the earth. FRANK G. CARPENTICH.

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A newspaper preview describes planned attractions for an exposition, including a Wild West-style show re-enacting the 'Custer massacre' alongside other novelty exhibits. The piece lists this among various entertainment features like Daniel Boone's cabin and Alpine scenery displays.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Saint Paul Globe · 16 January 1898 · page 18

OTHER CURIOUS FEATURES

HENRY E. DIXEY. I ians of the So-udan and other shows, some ! thing after the fashion of the Midway Plals ance of Chicago. A day in the Alps will be the title of a department showing life in Switzerland. This will be made up of real people, of paintings and of scenic effects built situation. up to represent the reality. The Alps and theiiglaciers, the toarists climbing the moun tains, etc., will ail be shewn. Then there will be shows depicting life in the West of the dime novel description, or of the Buffalo Bill order.

See moreSee less

Shows containing Indian massa cres, such as a re-enactment of the Custer massacre, of 1877, and other scenes of scout ing life as they formerly took place in the West. A representation of mining at Crip ple Creek will be given, depicting life in the mining camps and also other queer features, such as the Sherruan umbrella, in which pas sengers are sent flying around a circle in a car which is raised to a height of 303 feet above the earth. — Frank G. Carpenter. While Sister's Yoimjt Man 'Waited. "Sister's keepln' you waitin' a good while, ain't Bhe, Mr. Clancy?": "Oh, not so very, long, Bobbie." "I bet I know whit's keepin" her. I say I bet I know what's keepin' sister, Mr. Clancy." Drew. "Well, never mind, Bobbie." "Fleas is hard to* catch, ain't they, Mr. Clancy?" "I suppose bo, Bobbie." "Then I guess you'll have to wait a little longer, Mr. Clancy. Sister was playin* with my new dog today an' he's just full o' fleas." — Cleveland Plandealer.

See the clipping

Kansas City Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A report on plans for a large exposition describes various attractions including Daniel Boone's cabin, Alpine scenery, Cripple Creek mining displays, and Wild West shows depicting frontier life. Among these planned entertainments is a dramatic re-enactment of the Custer massacre, which the article dates to 1877.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Kansas City Journal · 16 January 1898 · page 20

ot the exhibition cost-comparatively little. At the' same time the government' will. prob ably send1 its wonderful collection of mod els, showing' the Indians engaged In thelr various occupations, which may form a part of this special' exhibit. Other Carious Featnres. Among "the .other queer things tohe shown wiU be Daniel Boone's"' cabin. This will be brought from Mlssourfand will oe rebuilt here. After Boons' left" Kentucky he moved to Missouri, and therespent hli last days. There wUl be a representation of the Egyptians -of the Soudan and other shows, something after the 'fashion of the Midway Plalsance of Chicago.

See moreSee less

A day In the Alps will be the title ot a department showing lite in Switzerland. This will be made up of real people, of paintings and of scenio effects built up to represent the reality. The Alps and their glaciers, the tourists, climbing the mountains, etc. will all be shown. Then there will be shows depleting life In the West of the dime novel description, or of the Buffalo BUI orden Shows containing Indian massacres, such as a re-enactment-ot' the Custer massacre of 1S77. and other scenes ot scouting life as they fonnerlytook place In the west. A representation of 'mining 'at Cripple Creek Will vbelveni''deplcUhsT life In the mining faniii. Hnu aiaa uuier-uueer inumiM nin. KCrs are sent flying around, a" clrclein: a car, -rnicn.iatraisea io anejgnt ot.suo Met above .the' earth. WRt&B. O. amPENTERwTj ;-, . " '.41. Slfjr- - J fi-.

See the clipping

Phoenix Weekly Herald · Phoenix, Ariz. Territory

The article discusses the toughness and battlefield role of cavalry horses across various wars, citing historical loss ratios between men and horses. It references the Custer massacre as an example of Sioux warriors killing soldiers' horses to prevent escape.

Phoenix Weekly Herald · 20 January 1898 · page 4

ents. horses aud so to cripple I lie I ,i--iif lln,i i 1 1 n In Pottles -vvitli lllili.-llis ,111 tilt llhlillS the horses of the regular soldiery are the first to go down liefore the savige marksmen. When the Indians sur rise a camp of white men. they dash ter the corrals and stampede tne horses if they can: but when they can not get near enough to cut the ropes, they' shoot the horses down at long range. In the Custer massacre the bloodthirsty Sioux passed by the ranks

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Representative Johnson of North Dakota opposes a $150 appropriation for a portrait of Sitting Bull, arguing his fame is undeserved. He claims Sitting Bull was merely a medicine man who stayed with the women during the Custer fight while others like Gall and Rain-in-the-Face did the actual fighting.

The Topeka State Journal · 20 January 1898 · page 2

SITTING BULL'S PORTRAIT Rep. Johnson Works and TalksAgainst an Appropriation. "Washington, Jan. 20. Representative Johnson of North Dakota does not fa vor the proposition of Senator Jones of Arkansas to appropriate $150 for a portrait of Sitting Bull. Mr. Johnson say s : "His fame rests on the reputation got without merit in connection with the Custer massacre in June, 1876. He was a medicine man and not a warrior. During the fight he was with the squaws, out of harm's way, in the rear, cooking mysterious herbs, dancing and chanting incantations to the devil. Call, Grass, Running Antelope and Raip-in-the-Face did the fighting and Sitting Bull got the glory."

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The piece reports Congressman Johnson of North Dakota ridiculing a Senate bill to purchase an oil painting of Sitting Bull, arguing he was merely a medicine man, not a warrior. It questions why Congress should honor one of those involved in the Custer massacre.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 21 January 1898 · page 2

Congressman Johnson, of North Dakota, properly ridicules a bill intro duced by Senator Jones, of Arkansas, to purchase an oil painting of Sitting Bull, whom he declares to have been a medicine man and not a warrior, and pertinently asks why we should aid m perpetuating-the memory of any of the executioners of our poor, brave fellows who were caught tn that cruel trap (the Custer massacre). The drowning of a woman who was being immersed in a West Virginia creek ought to stop the silly custom of out of door baptism in winter.

See moreSee less

This woman became unconscious from the shock of being suddenly taken into ice cold water, and sank, and being a heavy woman was dead before she coubf be gotten out. The democrats have spent considera ble time trying frantically to force congress into some action upon the Cu ban belligerencery matter. The efforts do not amount to anything, and only

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Col. William S. Brackett of Peoria denounces George Benjamin, a man claiming to be the sole survivor of Custer's 1876 massacre, as an imposter seeking a pension. Brackett says Benjamin's own story contains internal evidence proving his fraudulent pretenses.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Evening Star, 15 January 1898, The Saint Paul Globe, 16 January 1898, Kansas City Journal, 16 January 1898.

The Herald · 23 January 1898 · page 1

THE CUSTER SURVIVOR IS DENOUNCED AS AN ARRANT IMPOSTER

_____ TO THE TELEGRAPH NEWS Lee reports tranquillity at Havana; information from other sources indi cates the contrary. Heirs scattered all over the country hope to share in the distribution of the immense Clarke estate. Luetgert takes the stand and de tails his doings on the day he ie al leged to have murdered his wife. San Francisco expects a tremend ous crowd to assist in celebrating Cali fornia's golden jubilee on Monday. German court festivities greatly marred by prevalence of influenza; do mestic and foreign troubles increase. The mere mention of the name of Dreyfus in the French chamber of deputies is enough to start a free fight.

See moreSee less

England hopes the Oriental ques tion may be solved without resort to arms, but is prepared to profit in any event. Col. Brackett of Peoria, 111., says that George Benjamin's claims to be the last survivor of the Custer massa cre are false. The Japanese cruiser Chitose was launched at the Union Iron Works, San Francisco; Miss May Budd pre sides at the christening. Track Captain Brown of Berkeley finds the eastern college football teams largely made up of professionals; rac ing results; sporting news. Two senators come promptly to the rescue of the gold standard by offer ing amendments to Teller's resolution to pay bonds in silver; the day in the house given to odds and ends of legis lation. Martial law proclaimed at Fort Yu kon and the inhabitants placed on ra tions; returning miners vary greatly in their estimates of the probable out put of gold, but tha placer mines are nnmiaatinnal,lv viol.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Col. William S. Brackett declares George Benjamin's claim to be the sole survivor of Custer's command at Little Bighorn is fraudulent, citing inconsistencies in his account. Brackett notes that Custer's men fought dismounted on foot after their horses stampeded, and disputes Benjamin's claims about troop positions and casualty ratios.

The Herald · 23 January 1898 · page 1

BRANDED AS AN ARRANT IMPOSTER

Custer was surrounded by Indians, they fought their way back to their horses, mounted them, and in the struggle to reach the bluffs left the greater portion of their dead or wounded on the field. "It is now well proven that when Cus ter dismounted his men he deployed them in an irregular line of battle, dis mounted, on the top of the bluffs, and thus fought until they were exterminat ed. The bulk of Custer's horses were stampeded by the Indians early in the fight, as they were held by man No.

See moreSee less

4 of each set of fours in each company, and were never recovered. "Benjamin says ten Indians were killed for every white man who fell. This is false. "He says: 'The companies of Cal houn and Crittenden were thrown across our flank to protect our retreat.' This is also false as shown by the po sition in which the bodies of Calhoun's and Crittenden's men lay in line as they fell." Killed His Mother

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A newspaper article reprinted a New York Sun story about George Benjamin, who claimed to be the sole survivor of Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn and sought a pension. Col. William S. Brackett, a noted authority on the battle, writes to expose Benjamin as a fraud, asserting that no white man survived the fight.

The Anaconda Standard · 23 January 1898 · page 5

HIS PRETENSIONS EXPOSED

dian Massacre at Little Big Horn." Col. William S, Brackett of Peoria, Ill., who has extensive interests on the Yellowstone. and in other parts of Mon tana, and who is now in Butte, and who bis probably made a closer study of the history of the Custer battle than any other man, regards George Benja. min, the latest "sole survivor," as an impostor. He writes the Standard as follows: "In the Standard of Jan. 21st, is an article taken from the New York Sun, entitled: 'A Miner Who Saw Custer Die.

See moreSee less

The Sole Survivor of the Indian Massacre on the Little Big Horn.' An account is given-of one George Benja min of California, who is now on his way to Washington, D. C., where he hopes to secure a pension as the sole survivor of the Custer battle of June 65, 1876. "The people of Montana are, and always will be. interested in the fame of gallant Custer and his men, who died on the soil of this state. They are Interested in any new facts which shed light on the incidents of that awful field of carnage; but the people of this state are likewise interested in oppos ing any imposter, or pretender, who.

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

A newspaper correspondent exposes George Benjamin as an impostor falsely claiming to be a survivor of Custer's last stand, noting that no white man survived the fight. The writer details specific factual errors in Benjamin's account, including false claims about troop positions and casualty ratios, urging that his pension request be denied.

The Anaconda Standard · 23 January 1898 · page 5

HIS PRETENSIONS EXPOSED

"It is said that Senator Stephen M. White of California is taking this man to Washington, and will try to procure him a pension. It is with no Intent to prevent a worthy ex-soldier, or deserv ing civilian, from getting a pension, but with the desire to expose a manifest impostor, that this article is sent to the principal newspaper of this state, the people of which will ever jealously guard the name and memory of every true man, be he officer, civilian or sol dier, who was present on Custer's fatal field.

See moreSee less

"As Judge Cornelius Hedges says in an admirable historical sketch of Mon tana: 'It was on the soil of Montana, and during our centennial year. that the last great conflict between the white and red man for the possession of this country was fought to a virtual finish.' "One who falsely pretends to be the sole survivor of that conflict may very properly be exposed in the columns of a & Montana journal. "Mr. Sole Survivor Benjamin, in tellI ing his story, says that when the bat talion of five companies of cavalry commanded by Custer was surrounded by Indians they fought their way back to their horses, mounted them, and in our struggle to reach the bluffs, we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the field.' It is now well proven that when Custer dis mounted his men he deployed them in an irregular line of battle, dismounted on the top of the bluffs, and thus they fought until they were exterminated. The bulk of Custer's horses were stam peded by the Indians early in the fight, a as they were held by man No. 4 of each c set of fours in each company, and were never recovered. Benjamin says 'ten n Indians were killed for every white r man who fell.' This is false. He says: 1 'The companies of Calhoun and Critii tenden were thrown across our flank to protect our retreat.' This is also false, 8 as shown by the position in which the " bodies of Calhoun's and Crittenden's E men lay in line as they fell. 5 "He says when Custer and the last e few survivors reached the little hill d where they died, they shot their hor'ses and 'formed a breastwork behind which " we fought.' This is false, as shown by 1 the testimony of Indians in the light, Q who saw Custer and his little group die. P There were only a few dead horses it found afterward on and near that little d hill; and these were not shot by Custer I or his men, and were not used for b breastworks. Mr. Benjamin has eviY dently seen a picture by John MulE vaney, whose artistic fancy depicted iE Custer and his men on the hill in the h last rally, fighting behind a breastwork w of dead horses. Unfortunately for the vi artist and his alleged historical paint ing, no such thing occurred. But the ( principal falsehood of this man Benat jamin, and the one which exposes him, at is as to the manner of Custer's death. It He says: 'Custer died with his revolm ver in his left hand and his saber in his in right hand.' The fact is, General Cusdl ter had no saber, and the further fact is (and this is known to every officer h and man of the Seventh cavalry who pt were in that campaign) there was not at a single saber in the regiment on that campaign. United States cavalry, ofci flcers and men, when fighting Indians, st never carry sabers. Mr. Munchausen 60 Benjamin has again got his facts from 11 Mulvaney's beautiful picture, which a shows Custer with a saber in one hand and a pistol in the other. General CusCt

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

This 1898 article profiles Sergeant Frank Berwald, described as the sole survivor of Troop E's pack-train guard detail from Custer's command at the Little Bighorn in 1876. It recounts his immigration from Poland, enlistment, and service history leading up to the campaign against the Sioux.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Record-Union · 27 January 1898 · page 7

SERGT. FRANK BERWALD. He Is the Sole Survivor of the Cus ter Massacre. It is a little'more than twenty-one years since General Custer, full of hope and in the prime of life, marched from Fort Lincoln to the Rosebud Riv er in search of the Sioux Inelians. who were then on the warpath. Witnin a week the flower of his regiment—the Seventh Cavalry—lay with their com mander dead along the bluffs overlook ing the Little Big Horn Valley. Among the troops who rode to their fate on June 2">, 1 S7« >, there was none braver than Troop E.

See moreSee less

It was Custer's favorite. From this company thiee men were detailed to guard the pack train in the rear. Of these Sergeant Frank Berwald is the sole survivor. He is now attached to the hospital corps at West Point, and is a favorite with his superior officers. Sergeant Berwald's experiences in the Indian campaign are decidedly inter esting. His hairbreadth escapes from the redskins' scalping knives were many and marvelous. Born in the land which furnished Kosciusko, he came to this country in IS7O, and soon enlisted. From the recruiting rendezvous at St. Louis he was assigned to Company E of the Seventh Cavalry, and the following year went with his regiment on the Y'ellowstone expedition.' The next year saw him exploring the Black Hills, wh. re he was promoted to Sergeant, and shortly afterward was detailed to He had only been there a few days when the order came to takethe field against the Sioux, who had become dangerously bold. It was while on his way up the Rosebud that Sergeant Ber wald had his first adventure with the Svoux. He was ordered to take three men and ride cautiously among the hil's to the left of the main column. Several scouts and small details of troops were sent off in other directions. It was while Custer and his officers were debating the situation that Ser geant Berwald. who had been out do ing a little scouting on his own account, galloped up to the officers and breath lessly told them that the red-skins were coming in thousands to attack their camp. Scarcely had he told his story before the savage war whoops c ofirmed it. There was no tfrne to construct breastworks. The pack train was placed in the center, and the cav alrymen threw their horses to the ground, making breastworks of the an i finals' bodies. On rushed the savages, flushed with ! their recent victory and mad for more blood and scalps. "Let every shot kill

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The article profiles Sergeant Frank Berwald, now at West Point, recounting his dramatic Indian Wars service including the Yellowstone and Black Hills expeditions. It claims he warned Custer's officers of the approaching Sioux and describes a vivid battle scene with cavalry using dead horses as breastworks.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Record-Union · 27 January 1898 · page 7

SERGT. FRANK BERWALD. He Is the Sole Survivor of the Cus ter Massacre. It is a little'more than twenty-one years since General Custer, full of hope and in the prime of life, marched from Fort Lincoln to the Rosebud Riv er in search of the Sioux Inelians. who were then on the warpath. Witnin a week the flower of his regiment—the Seventh Cavalry—lay with their com mander dead along the bluffs overlook ing the Little Big Horn Valley. Among the troops who rode to their fate on June 2">, 1 S7« >, there was none braver than Troop E.

See moreSee less

It was Custer's favorite. From this company thiee men were detailed to guard the pack train in the rear. Of these Sergeant Frank Berwald is the sole survivor. He is now attached to the hospital corps at West Point, and is a favorite with his superior officers. Sergeant Berwald's experiences in the Indian campaign are decidedly inter esting. His hairbreadth escapes from the redskins' scalping knives were many and marvelous. Born in the land which furnished Kosciusko, he came to this country in IS7O, and soon enlisted. From the recruiting rendezvous at St. Louis he was assigned to Company E of the Seventh Cavalry, and the following year went with his regiment on the Y'ellowstone expedition.' The next year saw him exploring the Black Hills, wh. re he was promoted to Sergeant, and shortly afterward was detailed to He had only been there a few days when the order came to takethe field against the Sioux, who had become dangerously bold. It was while on his way up the Rosebud that Sergeant Ber wald had his first adventure with the Svoux. He was ordered to take three men and ride cautiously among the hil's to the left of the main column. Several scouts and small details of troops were sent off in other directions. It was while Custer and his officers were debating the situation that Ser geant Berwald. who had been out do ing a little scouting on his own account, galloped up to the officers and breath lessly told them that the red-skins were coming in thousands to attack their camp. Scarcely had he told his story before the savage war whoops c ofirmed it. There was no tfrne to construct breastworks. The pack train was placed in the center, and the cav alrymen threw their horses to the ground, making breastworks of the an i finals' bodies. On rushed the savages, flushed with ! their recent victory and mad for more blood and scalps. "Let every shot kill

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

This 1898 feature recounts Sergeant Berwald's heroism fetching water for wounded soldiers during the siege at the entrenchments, and the eventual arrival of Terry and Gibbon's relief column, followed by the grim discovery of Custer's mutilated body nearby. It also traces Berwald's later military career and a ceremonial flag presentation by a bereaved officer's mother.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Record-Union · 27 January 1898 · page 7

with joy when they saw their detlver ' ers. They rushed to the new arrivals | and With tears streaming down th?ir cheeks embraced them again and again. |Th re was not an Indian in the neigh ! borhood. T!i° troops started immedi j ately in search of Custer. His body ! was found on the bluff a few short j miles away, surrounded by tlie horribly mutilated remains of his officers, pri vates end relatives. When Berwald, with uncovered he-ad, j advanced with his men to lift the re ! mains so that they could be prepared

See the clipping

Belding Banner · Belding, Mich. · and 1 other paper

A brief item notes Private Daniel Sullivan, stationed at Fort Brady with 23 years of service, had served under Custer and narrowly avoided the famous massacre. The mention appears amid a long list of unrelated Michigan local news items.

Belding Banner · 27 January 1898 · page 2

MICHIGAN NEWS ITEMS

Reuben Strong, aged 53, a well known horseman, died at Jackson from an overdose of morphine taken sup posedly by mistake for quinine. C J. Wilder near Ithaca, lias plowed up a Lincoln badge. On sido was Lin coln's name, on the other that of Han nibal Hamlin. Tho center had rusted away. Private Daniel Sullivan, U. S. A., stationed r.t Fort Rrady, has served 23 years in the arnry. He served under Custer and barely missed the famous massacre. The trial of Owen McArron at Port Huron, on a charge of striking1 young Kilbourno Seeback a blow which caused his death, resulted in a disagree ment of the jury.

See moreSee less

Lansing has granted a right-of-way to the Lansiug, Dexter it Ann Arbor electric railway, but prescribes that tickets shall be sold eight for 25 cents inside the city limits. Large litnstone quarries are pro jected near Alpena. The United Al kali Co., which proposes to start a chemical plant at Ray City, has been figuring on the stone. New Michigan postmasters: Detour, Chippewa county, James T. Renuett; Nadeau, Menominee eouuty, Rarney Nadeau, Sr.; Swanzy, Marquette

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · 28 January 1898

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

A Washington Star report quotes Rep. Johnson of North Dakota objecting to a bill funding a painting of Sitting Bull, arguing he was a medicine man who hid with the squaws during the Little Bighorn fight rather than a warrior. Johnson instead proposes honoring Custer, or Dr. Porter, who organized evacuation of Reno's wounded after the battle.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 28 January 1898 · page 5

Sitting Bull, which provokes opposition from Representative Johnson, of North Dakota. "The idea of spenaing money to honor such a man as Sitting Bull," said he yesterday. "He one of my waB constituents. I knew him personally. I have one of the moccasins he wore when killed. His fame rests on the rep­ utation got without merit in connection with the Custer massacre in June 1876. He was a medicine man and not a war­ rior. During the fight he was with the squaws, out of barm's way, in the rear, cooking mysterious herbs, dancing and chanting incantations to the devil.

See moreSee less

Gall, Grass, Running Antelope and Rain-in the-Face did the fighting and Sitting Bull got the glory. If we are to glorify any of tbe executioners of our poor, brave fellows who were caught in that cruel trap, let us select a 'brave' who was brave. Gall is such a man. In point of physical development, too, he had the grandest head and neck I ever saw on human shoulders. As a matter of art and anthropology his picture would.be worth preserving. "But why not rather perpetuate the memory of either the General or Tom Custer, or some other brave boy in blue of tbe five companies who died to a man under the Stare and Stripes that day? "Or if the honor is to go to any medi­ cine man let UB buy a picture of gallant Dr. Porter, who successfully planned and superintended the transportation of the wounded of Reno's commond on im­ provised stretchers to the steamboat twenty-five miles from the battle-field, and then a thousand miles by water to Bismarck, N. D., the nearest place where he could get shelter and medi­ cines. The doctor is also one of my con­ stituents, and the handsomest man in Bismarck'today.'.',. wv '1 mi

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

A theatrical announcement for 'Northern Lights,' a play depicting events leading to the Custer massacre of 1876, scheduled to appear at Jacques Opera House. The ad quotes a New York World review praising it as the best American war play, alongside listings for other local shows and meetings.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 31 January 1898 · page 4

Feb 4 Henry 'Miller. Feb 2 "Northern Lights." . JACQUES OPERA HOUSE. "Northern Ligh.ts." The New York Worli'., in its criti cism of the original production said: 'Northen Lights," the latest and best of American war plays, will live longer than any of its predecessors. Tbe story is written about the incidents leading up to the Custer massacre in

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Twenty-two years after Little Bighorn, this piece revisits a controversy over which Sioux leaders deserve credit for the victory over Custer, noting Congress's debate over buying a Sitting Bull portrait. It states Sitting Bull was not actually in the battle and credits the chief Gall with leading the warriors, per accounts including Rain-in-the-Face.

The Indianapolis Journal · 31 January 1898 · page 3

Bismarck (N. D.) Letter In St. Louis GlobeDemocrat. The suggestion made in Congress a few days ago that the United States purchase a picture of the Sioux Indian chieftain Sit ting Bull as a memento of the Custer massacre, and the opposition aroused there by, it having been claimed that Sitting Bull was merely a medicine man and an unim portant factor in the famous uprising of the Sioux nation which resulted in the slaugh ter of Custer’s command, has raised an other controversy among those who lived on the frontier at the time of the massacre and were familiar with the details of the massacre from the lips of the wounded of the other commands, who were brought to Bismarck after the fight by steamboat, as to the part taken in the fight by the sev eral Indian chieftains who were leaders of the Sioux at that time.

See moreSee less

It is a peculiar fact that, although twen ty-two years have elapsed since the massa cre, and the battle, from the standpoint of the regular troops, has been discussed from every possible phase and point of view, the Indian side of the matter has never been taken up and the relative importance of the several chiefs who participated decided. At first Sitting Bull had the lion’s share of credit for having planned and executed the campaign which cost the United States so many brave soldiers. The name of Sitting Bull for years was never dissociated from the horrible details of that butchery on the Little Big Horn. But as the years passed the pendulum swung the other way, until now it is stated that Sitting Bull was only a medicine man, took no part in the struggle and remained during the fight with the squaws and children, and that he Is en titled to none of the credit for the Sioux campaign. It is difficult to get at the exact status of the fight from the Indian stand point from the fact that the chieftains re fuse to discuss the matter. There were four of them whose names are most intimately connected with the massacre—Sitting Bull, Gall, Rain-in-the-Face and John Grass. Os these four, two are dead. Sitting Bull w r as killed by an Indian policeman in the Indian uprising of 1890, and Gall died on the reser vation at Standing Rock two years ago. Both are buried there, but the grave of Sit ting Bull appears to be shunned of whites and Indians alike. It is inclosed in a rude wooden paling, and above the mound be neath which lie the remains of this wily, crafty and treacherous leader is a plain wooden board, painted white, and inscribed thereon the words, “Sitting Bull, Indian, 1890.” Rain-in-the-Face is a policeman at the agency, while John Grass is chief justice of the SG>ix tribe and sits as a court of last veBCG. in the trial of all offenses by the native tribunals. Both of them are men beyond fifty years of age, and both are stout, healthy and promise to achieve old age. Gall’s death was due, perhaps, to his exceeding corpulency, as he was a physical giant and the finest appearing Indian the Sioux tribe ever produced. SITTING BULL A MEDICINE MAN.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The article contrasts the recently deceased Gall and Sitting Bull, describing Gall as a frank warrior who led the Sioux in battle, while Sitting Bull is portrayed as a crafty medicine man who incited the tribe's passions and planned strategy without fighting. It argues Sitting Bull bears major responsibility for the Custer massacre despite not firing a shot.

The Indianapolis Journal · 31 January 1898 · page 3

SITTING BULL A MEDICINE MAN. Between Sitting Bull and Gall there was always enmity. It was not expressed, but close observers of the two men have stated that the aversion of each for the other was readily noticeable when either man spoke of the other. It is not surprising that this enmity existed, for the reason that the men were exact opposites in character. Sitting Bull was crafty, treacherous, strategic, fond of admiration, vain and boastful. Gall was frank, open, a warrior, with no taint of de ceit or treachery, brave and absolutely in different to either admiration or desta tion.

See moreSee less

There is no doubt that it w’as he who led the hosts of Sioux on the battle field when Custec'a -command was killed. He was such a leader as warriors on the field would follow to the death. But on the other hand, it is also a fact that it was Sitting Bull who inllamed the passions of the Sioux, worked upon their superstitions and made "medicine” for the campaign. The medicine man of the Indian tribe is largely responsible fur its conduct. He is not a warrior, and yet he-is more dangerous to the peace of the tribe. He brings to the warriors his dreams, his visions and the results of his incantations. He reads for them the designs of the Great Spirit. He sees in his dreams visions of untold power and wealths of glory achieved on the bat tlefield. He is a plotter, a strategist and and an exhorter. and it is he whose crafty counsels, insidious suggestions and gilded visions lead the warriors to forsake the paths of peace and seek those of war. It was in this way that Sitting Bull was an important man in the Sioux tribe. War riors were not alone needed to wage bat tle. There must be someone to rouse en thusiasm and fo-ter .‘he spirit of strife. It was Sitting Bull who did this. And so well did he do it that the entire Sioux tribe w'as a seething vortex of inflamed passions. Eefore the battle he made more “medicine.” And not alone did he make medicine, but he outlined a plan of campaign, provided for the retreat of the women and children in case of defeat, and executed a masterly retreat when hard pressed later. Those who are disposed to minimize the impor tance of Sitting Bull do not understand the nature of the Indian. He was, perhaps, more directly responsible for the Custer massacre than any other single chieftain, and yet it is stated, and probably with truth, that he did not fire a single shot dur ing the battle. But it was Gall that the Indians followed on the battlefield, once aroused by Sitting Bull. Gall was a giant, who would have made the most superb model for a statue of the Ideal Indian warrior. He was brave, gallant and a natural leader. He knew nothing of craft, nor was he an adept at stirring up men’s passions like Sitting Bull. But he was a host on the field of battle. And therein lies the part played by the tw'o men. Bull fostered the light, roused the Indians to frenzied rage and bitterness, and Gal! led them on the field. Gall was not a talkative chieftain, and after the surrender of the Sioux he sub mitted gracefully to all the requirements of surrender. He was a warrior, and after defeat he was an honorable man. At no time after the Sioux returned to the reser vation did he make one bit of trouble with the authorities. Here again the different dispositions of the two men are shown. Sitting Bull was wily, restless, dissatisfied and seeking to foment disturbance. He was the same plotter, and it was probably again owing to his influence that the uprising of IS9O was due, and his death was a relief to the authorities, although the manner of it is not considered creditable to those by whom and through whom it was accom plished.

See the clipping