This report describes a large collection of Native American artifacts from seven tribes, including weapons, clothing, and ceremonial items. Among the relics displayed is a ghost-shirt said to have been worn by the medicine man who fired the first shot at Wounded Knee.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Bill Barlow's Budget · 1 December 1897 · page 5
Clark C. Green, foreman of the Carey ranches in South Dakota, left for his post of duty on Monday, after a pleasant visit with central Wyom ing friends. He is always welcome in this neck o' woods. The inimitable Harry Howard formerly of Glenrock but since of Cripple Creek, Leadville and Denver — has returned to his tirst love, and will look over our mining prospects. The Congregational Sunday school will give a free Christmas entertain moet in the church Christmas eve, December 21th, and the Sunday school will receive its annual treat.
See moreSee less
The weather the past week has been mixed —decidedly so. While the temperature has been reasonably moderate, yet it has been wet, then cold, and altogether disagreeable. At the Congregational church next Sunday morning Rev. Corbin's sub ject will be “Christian Enterprise.” Evening; “The Three Hebrew Worthies.” Charles C. Beard—the veteran plainsman who. is best known by the nickname of “Panther”—spent a few days witli us last week. Nick Schmidt and wife, of Inez, were within our gates on Saturday. Dr. Jesurun spent Thanksgiving at the SO ruuuh. from the primitive Hint-lock to the more modern revolver—some of them known to have been the property of some noted chief, and many of them found, under circumstances pointing only too plainly to massacre and midnight murder. Many genuine relics from the Custer, the Wounded
This is a magazine advertisement listing upcoming contents of McClure's Magazine, including fiction by various authors. It mentions that Hamlin Garland has gathered Indian reminiscences, including 'Two Moons' Story of the Custer Fight,' a firsthand account taken from the chief himself.
The Times · 4 December 1897 · page 7
Mr. Garland has spent many months among the Indians, gather ing their reminiscences and tradi tions. In coming numbers of the magazine will appear Two Moons' Story of the Custer Fight. This talc, taken down from the lips of the chief Two Moons, is a vivid and dramatic story.
This is a promotional item for McClure's Magazine listing upcoming content, including Hamlin Garland's 'True Indian Stories' series. It mentions that Two Moons, a Cheyenne chief, will give his firsthand account of the Custer battle, along with other Indian stories like Sitting Bull's defiance and Rising Wolf's autobiography.
This advertisement for McClure's Magazine announces forthcoming Indian narratives compiled by Hamlin Garland, including Two Moons' firsthand account of the Custer fight and stories about Sitting Bull and Rising Wolf. The piece is part of a larger promotional listing of fiction and nonfiction contributors for the magazine's upcoming issues.
Evening Star · 4 December 1897 · page 12
Two Moons' Story of the Custer Fight This tale, taken down from the lips of the chief Two Moons, is a vivid and dramatic storv'. Sitting Bull's Defiance A fine story of Sitting Bull's refusal to treat with a commissioner from the Government, and his insensibility to fine words and rich gifts.
This is a magazine advertisement from McClure's promoting upcoming features, including Hamlin Garland's 'True Indian Stories' featuring Two Moons' account of the Custer Fight and Sitting Bull's defiance of the Government. The ad also mentions other content like Lincoln reminiscences and a diver's autobiography.
New-York Tribune · 4 December 1897 · page 2
are making pictures for McCLURE'S MAGAZINE. houses, the streets, the ‘water supply, the means of transportation, the safeguards of A. B. FROST, PETER S. NEWELL, F. S. CHURCH, True Indian Stories : ceives them in the [erected city of the next century. He will show what the | life and health, and the provisions for sport and pleasure are likely to be in the Great C. D. GIBSON, C. K. LINSON, HOWARD PYLE, . KENYON COX, W. D. STEVENS, ALFRED BRENNAN. By Hamlin Garland Mr. Garland has spent many montns among the Indians, gathering their remiNew York, following out the present lines of development.
See moreSee less
: | 0000000000000 00000000000: 000000000000 000000000000: 000000000000 incoin | FREE Reminiscences, Mark Twain's Virnus ghapters of Chas, A, Danes niscences and traditions. In coming numbers of the magazine will appear : Miss Tarbell has been making considerable progress in her work upon the last | § srucies smd soemiinylti wei bitsy ati “we EEE Hk wif veal Shc Two Moons’ vivid and dramatic story of the Custer Fight Sitting Bull’ four years of Lincoln's life. The work is written entirely from the personal standfone trionine Wit DCTHE YEAR BEGINS WITH NOVEMBE | defiance to the Government. Rising Wolf, Ghost Dancer; his autobiography:
The article claims Red Cloud, not Sitting Bull, was the true strategic mastermind behind the trap that destroyed Custer's command, directing operations via couriers while feigning peace. It credits Gen. Crook's seizure of Red Cloud's war ponies with preventing him from personally joining the battle and claims Red Cloud later filed a claim for compensation.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Bottineau Courant · 4 December 1897 · page 2
GEN. J. W. FORSYTHE. (The Brave Commander Who Proved Too Much for Red Cloud.)
Rvd Cloud had mobilized a force of 800 braves and was making preparations to join Sitting Bull on tbc Little Big llorn when word was brought to Crook by a friendly Indian. Crook hesitated about interfering with Red Cloud's band as it was still on the reservation and osten sibly at peace. Under the plea of mili tary exigencies, however, be did the next best thing and confiscated all the ponies which had been gathered for the use of the warriors. This kept. Red CJoud and his men at home and pre vented them from joining Sitting Bull, and the latter got credit for conducting the campaign.
See moreSee less
It was not until after word of Cus ter's sad fate was received that Crook realized the full effect of bis timely ac tion. It was the intention of the In dians in case a junction between the forces of Red Cloud and Sitting Bull had been effected to hold their position on the Little Big Hern and conduct a long warfare against the whites. The prestige gained by the victory over Custer would have brought other tribes into the fight, and it would have been comparatively easy to make the strug gle a long and bloody one. As it was. Sitting Bull was unable to get rein forcements and had to fall back befors the army sent to avenge Custer, retreat ing across the British line. Maddened by the defeat of his plans, chafing un der Sitting Bull's stolen glory. Red Cloud was still too foxy and diplomatic to make open comprint of his real feelings. But be did not let the matter pass in silence. He filed a claim at Washington demanding pay for the ponies taken by Crook on the ground that he and his immediate followers were peaceful Indians who liad been deprived of their property without cause. Gen. Crook was called upon for an explanation, and he made it so strong and clear that the government declined to allow Red Cloud's claim, although be paid several visits to Wash ington. It was Red Cloud who drew Col. For* sythe's command Into a trap at Drexe! Mission, during the Wounded Knee campaign in 1890, and the massacre of Custer would have Undoubtedly been repeated were it not for the fact that Forsythe saw the danger he was in and just before the light began dispatched a messenger for reinforcements. These came up in time and the Indians were beaten off. The similarity in strategic methods employed at Wounded Knee and Little Big Horn convinced army men that Red Cloud planned both en gage men is. but the wily chief denied the charge, maintaining that he was a friendly Indian. WThen asked how he came to be present at the last tight he made the astonishing assertion that be was really a prisoner in the hands of the hostiles, tbey having forced him to accompany them for fear if left behind he would assist the whites. Otlicers and fcoldiers who participated in the battle say no one except Red Cloud could have bandied the warriors with such shrewd generalship and ability. Red Cloud in his early years was a drinker and broiler. One day. while on a buffalo hunt on Chugwuter creek, in Wyoming, he got drunk and'killed Little Wound, a sub-chief. Since then he has never tasted liquor. The writer uiet Red Cloud i u Omaha some years ago when he was on bis way to Washing ton to urge payment of his pony claim, on which occasion one of the mer chants of that city entertained him at an informal luncheon. Red Cloud ate heartily of the food but refused t* taste the wines or liquors. He showed his disapprobation of the custom of drinking by rising from the table and turning bis back to the company when ever liquor was passed. Lewis Ham ilton, a half-breed, who was with Red Cloud as an interpreter, was asked to ascertain the cause of the old chief's action. There was some talk in the Sioux tongue, after which Hamilton said: "Red Cloud doesn't believe in whisky drinking. He had serious trouble once when he was drunk, and has never tasted liquor since. He says men who drink are fools. He turns his back on them to show he does not like the practice." If an Indian can be handsome. Red Cloud is a handsome man. He was over 70 years of age at the time of the incident mentioned, but bore his six feet of height and 190 pounds of weight with the vigor and activity of a man of 40. His features were strong, but pleasant in outline, and in his conver sation? through nn interpreter he gave ample evidence of having a bright men tality ancLbeing well informed on many things aside from Indian affairs. Red Cloud discarded the blanket uniform many years ago. His favorite costume is a black cloth suit, white shirt with a black knotted scarf and a black slouch hat. He is neat in his manners and appearance and, were it not for his color, might pass for a well-to-do farm ev come to town for a holiday.
A theatrical review describes a Bowery variety show titled 'Madeline of Fort Reno,' featuring comic Indian chiefs, a corpulent hero, and specialty acts interspersed with a melodramatic plot. The performance culminates in a tableau depicting the dead of the Custer massacre, with General Custer and Pawnee Bill posed among the fallen as Indians dance around them.
The Sun · 7 December 1897 · page 3
sjVini swords than often graco ovea a Bowery perJ Yvllil formance. ' Will Tor four acts tho plot and the variety show IrtJ battled on even terms. Occasionally there slJvH Would bn an Indication that the stor) was to ipaA progress, nnd immediately n Klondiko blonde M would como forward towlnsomely do splits, or Wi) the rotund hero w ould draw attention to bis leop 'Ju ard skill coat or to tho fact that ho had the long ij? est revolver of tho outfit. It was full) one third 1 his circumference nt tho point where his waist nvl J once was, nnd tbutwnssK feet if an inch.
See moreSee less
In 'V the end Iho plot overcame tho specialties. This ; t was distinctly tho contest of the play, which, bo i 7 far as any secsnulng between wickedness and Tlrtne was concerned, reversed the usual rules. I , At tho flnal curtain the sti.go wus strown with i j the dead of the Custer massacre, over I whom danced real and counterfeit Ini, dlnns. In a group back of tho battlej field were shown in tableaux General v Custer, the blond contortionist. Pawnee Dill, I S and other doers of good. Whether their being 5S" irrouped thero in strong limelight meant that I thoy were doad. as following history would have it " thero, or that they were preparing to Join In a specialty to confound the butchering Sioux was t not plain. Hut other things In the piny wpre 1 not plain: perhaps the ponderous hero was tho only really evident feature. Who tho author jvas was uot disclosed. Tho title was "Made line of Fort Itcno."
An advertisement for a magazine promotes upcoming serialized content including Hamlin Garland's 'True Indian Stories,' featuring a retelling of 'The Custer Fight' from Cheyenne Chief Two Moons and a piece on Sitting Bull's defiance of U.S. commissioners. These are framed as dramatic reminiscences gathered from Indians of the West rather than news reporting.
Crawford Avalanche · 9 December 1897 · page 7
TRUE INDIAN STORIES
The Custer Fight This tale, taken down from the lips of th Chief Two Moons, is a vivid and dramatic story. Sitting Bull's Defiance A fine story of Sitting Bull's refusal to treat with a commissioner from the Government, and hia insensibility to fioe words and rich gifts.
This is a promotional listing for McClure's Magazine's upcoming content for the coming year, mentioning articles by Charles A. Dana, Rudyard Kipling, Anthony Hope, Thomas Edison, and others. Among the listed features is a piece titled 'the Custer Massacre,' alongside unrelated financial tables and farming news.
The Nebraska Independent · 9 December 1897 · page 1
Msp abhsaas Lst INavily mi sll Pans ot the Siai ImI DaatUs Caualy, II asy albtmnal t4 la a44 ta thai "las aid ehii la leaking Bus ' ta Vlrea it atll U bwiad ta lha r attlte wl lksl'tian lr saty wl1Vra ta 11. t Uat hlH Ilia biawtail tats Hia4 U4 aaly lHwa ait lbs rvpaWivaaa gaia4 tatySit, Mtaalag a ta eatf tfsk' Iks t- , ..il...- ..I m mm Tu.Un t-m tiaia:il aitJ ltairW l Ins uaaty uf tWa slat. Aaotsaf t a ill h iataraaliai. If ssaaitwrs wl 14 Waiaiatara a.
See moreSee less
Ua rtaa alia Ut tin kua, a aa laa iwlsM lat as I ll'?aa, Us WtMl Urs tl4 siasi as Kiittws Naatfar tha Comlnjr Vaar. McClures Magnetos will contain many notabls and seciul features for the coming year. Among them may be mentioned a series of reminiscences by Charles A. Dana, stories and poems by Rudyurd Kipling; Anthony Hope's New Zendu novel, and short storlos by many other noted authors. There will btf several Interesting art idles by tho great Inventor Thomas A. Kdlson. The railroad man's life by II. II. Harablin, ths Custer Massacre, a story of New York iu 1050, stories by Mark Twain, uud tales of adventure by Nausen ths artlu explorer will be leadlug and Interesting articles,
This is a subscription advertisement for McClure's Magazine listing upcoming contributors and features, including a promised serial of 'True Indian Stories' by Hamlin Garland. Among the teased contents is 'The Custer Fight,' described as a tale taken from Chief Two Moons recounting the battle, alongside other Indian reminiscences and unrelated fiction and features.
Union County Courier · 9 December 1897 · page 5
TRUE INDIAN STORIES
The Custer Fight This tale, taken down from the lips of ths" Chief Two Moons, is s vivid and dramatic story. Sitting Bull's Defiance A fine %tory of Sitting Bull's refusal to treat with a commissioner from the Government, aad his insensibility to fine words and rich gifts.
A newspaper commentary argues the Charge of the Light Brigade's casualty rate was unremarkable compared to Civil War battles, using Gettysburg regiments as examples. It references the Custer battle with Sitting Bull's braves as the greatest loss in warfare short of total annihilation.
The Owosso Times · 10 December 1897 · page 2
CHARGE OF LIGHT BRIGADE.
Michigan Infantry lost in the same battle 60 killed, 247 wounded, and 81 missing (most of them still 'missing,' and should properly be in the 'killed'); total 397, out of 496 men eugaged. or 80 per cent the greatest loss knowu In warfare less than total annihila tion, as in the Custer battle with Sitting Bull's braves.
An advertisement for McClure's Magazine announces upcoming true Indian stories by Hamlin Garland, including a dramatic account of 'The Custer Fight' taken from Chief Two Moons. It also teases other Western frontier narratives like Sitting Bull's Defiance.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 10 December 1897 · page 7
TRUE INDIAN STORIES
bers of the magazine will appear The Custer Fight This tale, taken down from the lips of the Chief Two Moons, is a vivid and dramatic story. Sitting Bull's Defiance A fine story of Sitting Bull's refusal to treat with a commissioner from the Government, and his insensibility to line words and rich gifts.
This is a McClure's Magazine advertisement listing upcoming content, including Hamlin Garland's 'True Indian Stories' series. It mentions 'The Custer Fight,' a story taken from Chief Two Moons' recollections, among other promotional content for subscribers.
Hot Springs Weekly Star · 10 December 1897 · page 9
TRUE JNDIAN STORIES By Hamlin Garland ':rHS Mr. Garland has spent many months among the Indians of the far West, gathering their reminiscences and traditions, in coming num bers of the magazine will appear The Custer Fight This tale, taken down from the lips of the Chief Two Moons, is a vivid and dramatic story.
This is a promotional advertisement for McClure's Magazine announcing upcoming content including Hamlin Garland's 'True Indian Stories,' featuring an account of 'The Custer Fight' as told by Chief Two Moons. It also lists other contributors like Rudyard Kipling and Stephen Crane for the magazine.
The Kimball Graphic · 11 December 1897 · page 3
others, TRUE INDIAN STORIES By Hamlin Garland Mr. Garland has spent many months among the Indians of the far West, gathering their reminiscences and traditions. In coming num bers of the magazine will appear The Custer Fight This tale, taken duwn from tiic lips of the Chief Two Moons, is a vivid and dramatic story. Sitting Bull's Defiance A fine story of Sitting Hull's refusal to treat
An advertisement for McClure's Magazine lists upcoming content including 'The Custer Massacre, as it came from the lips of Two Moons, an old Indian Chief, who was a participant in it.' The ad also promotes other articles and fiction, including pieces by Kipling, Mark Twain, and polar explorers.
Alexandria Gazette · 14 December 1897 · page 4
haztrds, accidents and escapes The Custer Massacre, as it came from the lips of Two Moons, an old Indian Chief, who was a participant in it. New ? ork in 1950, tho condition of life of the perfected city of tho next century, by Col Geoige E. Waring, jr.
This is a theater review describing a stage production that dramatizes events around Custer, including a courtmartial scene, a capture by Apache Indians, and General Custer's final stand. The piece is satirical in tone, mocking the melodramatic and sensationalized theatrical conventions used to portray these historical events.
The Salt Lake Herald · 19 December 1897 · page 17
In the third act the two comic sol diers are captured by the Apache In dians who are a seriousminded lot and rigidly opposed to specialties of any description They tie their cap I tives to trees and are about to put them I to the torture when the sudden arrival of General Custer and his troops puts an end to the good work This scene however should serve as a warning to a great many victims of the specialty habit who are now in town and if the management of this entertainment de sire to give a professional matinee I will tell them where to place some of their tickets The fourth act shows the death of Hartman the degradation of the wicked captain and the promotion of the fat scholarly and virtuous half breed In the fifth act General Custer makes his last gallant stand and perishes be side the brown plush horse Thus dies the best actor in the company while the comic people Princess Moonlight and the beautiful Madeline most of whom deserve death escape the mas sacre in order to appear at the very close of the piece in what is known technically as an apothesis by which is meant something like the posthu mous appearance of Little Eva Uncle Tom and Abraham Lincoln in a noc turne of cotton clouds at the finish of Uncle Toms Cabin
The obituary of William McMasters, who died in Glasgow, Montana, recounts his Civil War service and his later role in Reno's detachment at the Little Bighorn, where he was one of four volunteers who risked their lives to bring water to the wounded. He was awarded the Medal of Honor for this act of bravery.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Anaconda Standard · 20 December 1897 · page 9
WAS IN THE INDIAN WARS
Great Yafle. Dec. 19.--The death of WtIlIS MeM aters at Glasgow i ts * Pe-tei here U-ight. He was of Seotch parentage atU born in a small village of Westet a New York. When the civil war broke out he enlisted in the army of the Potoroa under command of Gen eral MeClelisG. and during the war hwas in a Satmber of the most mn portant engaeMents, conducating him self in a woatry manner. At the close of the war sad after -his discharge he enlisted a estud time and was shipped West to take part in the Indian wars.
See moreSee less
At the battle of the Little Big Horn he was in the detachment under Reno, which came too late to prevent the massacre of Custer and the soldiers in his division. When the wounded in Reno's company were suffering and dying for water, volunteers were called for who would hazard their hvtm to re lieve their comrades, and among the four fearless heroes who responded was MMasters. It meant almost certain death, but the four volunteers, laden with canteens, made the race. One of them was killed getting to the creek, another killed coming back and a third one, Dan Sullivan, severely wounded. He was sent back to his home in Illi nois and there died, and his musket is now on exhibition in the Historical so ciety of Springfield, Ill. For McMasters' bravery he was awarded a medal of honor by congress. Shortly after this he left the army and followed his trade, masonry, for a liv ing. He has resided in Glasgow for the past four years. McMasters was s6 years of age at the time of his death and possessed many warm friends in Valley county. His death came peace fully while sitting in a chair in his room. Mrs. George A. Croft has purchased the Lena Johnson place over the Bruna wick, 212% Central avenue, Great Falls, and will serve the best 25-cent meal in the city. Room and board, $26 per month. Those wishing first-class meals and rooms are Invited to call at the above address.
This is an advertisement for subscription offers from the Richmond Planet newspaper, including chromolithograph prints of famous battles available to subscribers. Among the Civil War battle scenes listed is 'Big Horn [Custer's Last Charge]', offered as a decorative print for 22x28 inch size.
Richmond Planet · 25 December 1897 · page 6
~~“ ¢ Big Horn [Custer’s Last Cha ge]. Chick:imauga. Fort P llow Massacre; Battie of Williamsburg. Battles of Winchester, Va., Olustee, Fla., Wie loo. OFFER NO. 8. charge (20 cents to be sent for tube and m:iling.) pomattox. paid. Send for circulars. ADDRESS
A crippled miner named George Benjamin claims he was present at Custer's massacre at Little Big Horn and survived after being held prisoner and tortured by Indians. A senator is helping him seek a pension and travel to Washington to tell his story.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 26 December 1897 · page 7
SAYS HE SAW CUSTER DIE. A Miner'll Tale of ilio Mn*ncre at file I,title Big Horn. Los Angeles Letter New York Sun. George Benjamin, a crippled and wound ed miner, Is on his way to Washington, where he hopes to secure a pension. He claims to have been with Custer at the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Al though it was supposed that there was no survivor of the massacre, Benjamin’s story bears marks of truthfulness, and the fact that he was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tortures long prevented his experience from being made known.
See moreSee less
Senator Stephen M. White Is taking him to Washington, and will try to get a pension for him this winter. “In the spring of 1876,” says Benjamin,"l was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June we were camped on Clark’s creek, and as we were getting short of supplies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for supper, leaving Stone In camp. When we returned we found him dead and horribly mutilated. We knew at once that the Indian* were on the war path and that we'd better get out. <So we started at once for Foster’s ranch, but when wo reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Every man, woman, and child on the ranch had been murdered, and ail the bodies had been mu tilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cattle driven off. We started for Cheyenne to give warning of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer's men. They asked us to join in the pursuit and I consented gladly, but my partner. Kelly, decided to go on to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his body, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. “We broke camp on June 16, and Maj. Reno scouted the trail to the Rosebud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. Gibbons was ordered to cross the Yellowstone near the mouth of the Big Horn and meet Gen. Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June 36. On June 21 the trail of the Indians was scouted twen ty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night a council was held, and the troops left the Rosebud and marched up Dirty Wo. man’s creek toward the Big Horn, ten miles, and went into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops were In the saddle soon after daybreak, and about 8 o’clock the first Indians were seen by the scouts from the top of the divide. Tip; men were in great spirits because they had come upon the Indians at last, although the evi dent indications were that we were out numbered ten to one. (’apt. Benteen was sent toward some hills on the right to scout the Indians and obtain a view of the country. With him he took three compa. nies of the Seventh cavalry. Our com mand then moved on one mile further, and Maj. Reno was sent to the left, with or ders to skirmish and drive the enemy if found. The main body was to protect or reinforce him, as required. Capt. McDougal was In charge of the pack (rain and was left with one company one mile from where Reno left us. On ahead of us were great clouds of dust, which seemed to indicate that the main body of Indians was on the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and children out of the way for the threatened battle. Gen. Custer, with the other four companies, started for this commotion and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. "We then fell back to the second bottom, where we were dismounted to examine our firearms and prepare for the battle. The signal to mount was given, and Gen. Cus ter at the head, with his hat in one hand, pointed to the Indians with the other and cried out: “There they are, boys. God bless you all, and follow me!” We charged on a dead run, but when we reached ihe river we dismounted, and every fourth man held the horses for the other three. Gen. Custer led the advance wilh his aides, Boston Custer, his younger brother, and Artie Reed, his nephew, by his side. Lieut. Tom Custer, his other brother, and Capt. Calhoun, his brother in-law, were at the front with their com mands. “At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way before us. But soon they, swarmed upon us from every direction. They camei upon us from the front and rear and flank and every ravine and every bush and tree seemed alive wi’h them. We soon knew that wewere doom ed, and we fought as m#h fight only un der such circumstances. A perfect storm of arrows and bullets were pouring upon us from every side, but we fought our way back to our horses, mounted, nnd In our struggle to reach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wound ed on the field. But ten Indians wont down for every white man who fell. The com panies of Capt. Calhoun and Lieut. Crit never having emerged therefrom: for this reason a chancellor refused to hear a so licitor adorned with a white waistcoast, and another Judge said “he listened with little pleasure to counsel whose legs are encased in gray trousers.” Our own Jus tice Gray refused to hear counsel whose coats wore not satisfactory to him. and while sitting in our supreme court hq once refused to receive the testimony from a laborer in his shirt sleeves, who, “peing mechanical, had dared to come abroad with (these) signs of his profession.” l*ei us hope no judge would be so auto cratic and so embody his representation of the sovereign as to object to reciprocal comments on his own raiment, and. like Emi>eror William recently, to prosecute one who spoke disrespectfully of Ills trou sers! There was a time, during Wyatt’s rebel lion. when counsel used to argue cases while "in harness.” that is. clad in com plete armor; it is doubtful if they felt more "fighting mad” than did a queen’s counsel in Canada recently when a chief ujstice compelled continuous session of court from 9to . This counsel took to munching biscuit while trying his case, for which the court did not even reprove him. Counsel are theoretically bound to use good faith toward the court in their plead ings, as in the old ease where one was punished tor stating there was a precedent while none existed, but here and in these days "everything goes.” We have not.re cently had quite such a flagrant abuse of pleading ns the one, long thought to be legendary only, but which has recently been authenticated from the records of the court of London. In this case plaintiff sei up on partnership with defendant, whereto each contributed horses aaid oth er articles necessary to deal in horses, Jewelry, etc., further alleging that they dealt with one gentleman at Hounslow Heath for a gold watch for little or no money, after small discourse with him, and detailing other transaction and deal ings to the amount of £2.000, and otherwise wording his bill like an ordinary one for accouni. It transpired that the dealings were highway robberies, wherein the “small discourse” was "Your money or your life!” When the court learned this it dismissed the bill instanter and heavily fined the plaintiff and all his counsel. Aft erward both parties and part of counsel very different. each came to some had end—in two cases, at least, to the end of the hangman’s rope. How heinous some regard contempt of court is shown by an Instance which may he legendary, too, but which yet (as some say) is proved to be true by its coming from several sources in slightly varied form. The simplest version is as follows: A sailor, having been blasphemous in open their camp. court, was Impressively charged by the state attorney with “a clear violation of the laws of God.” "Worse than that," exclaimed the judge; "it’s contempt of court!”
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper
A man recounts frontier violence by Indians before linking up with Custer's column, then narrates the army's march from the Rosebud to the divide above the Little Bighorn and the splitting of forces under Reno, Benteen, and Custer. The account, published two decades later, claims personal eyewitness knowledge of Custer's death.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 26 December 1897 · page 3
SAYS HE SAW CUSTER DIE. A Miner's Tale of the Massacre at the Little Big Horn. Los Angeles Letter in New York Sun. George Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, is on his way to Washington, where he hopes to secure a pension. He claims to have been with Custer at the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Although it W'as sup posed that there w r as no survivor of the massacre, Benjamin’s story bears marks of truthfulness, and the fact that he was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tortures long prevented his experiences from being made known.
See moreSee less
Sen ator Stephen M. White is taking him to Washington, and will try to get a pension for him this winter. ‘‘ln the spring of 1576,” says Benjamin, “I was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June we w'ere camped on Clark’s creek, and as we were getting short of sup plies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for supper, leaving Stone In camp. When w'e returned we found him dead and horri bly mutilated. We knew at once that the Indians were on the warpath, and that we’d better get out. So we started at once for Foster’s ranch, but w'hen we reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Every man, woman and child on the ranch had been murdered, and all the bodies had been mutilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cattle driven off. We started for Cheyenne to give warn ing of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer’s men. They asked us to join in the pursuit, and I consented gladly, but my partner, Kelly, decided to go on to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his body, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. “Wo broke camp on June 16 and. Major Reno scouted the trail to the Rosebud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. Gibbons was ordered to cross the Yellowstone near the mouth of the Big Horn and meet General Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June 26. On June 24 the trail of the Indians was scout ed twenty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night a council w’as held and the troops left the Rosebud and marched up Dirty Woman’s creek toward the Big Horn, ten miles, and went into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops W'ere in the saddle soon after daybreak, and about 8 o’clock the first Indians were seen by the scouts from the lop; fyf.the divide. The men were in great spirits because they had come upon the Indians at last, although the evi dent Indications were that we were out numbered ten to one. Captain Benteen was sent toward some hills on the right to scout the Indians and obtain a view of the country. With him he took three com panies of the Seventh Cavalry. Our com mand then moved on one mile farther, and Major Reno was sent to the left, with or ders to skirmish and drive the enemy if found. The main body was to protect or reinforce him, as required. Captain McDougal was in charge of the pack train and was left with one company one mile from where Reno left us. On ahead of us were great clouds of dust, which seemed to indicate that the main body of Indians was on the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and chil dren out of the way for the threatened bat tle. General Custer, with the other four companies, started for this commotion, and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. “We then fell back to the second bottom, where we were dismounted to examine our firearms and prepare for the battle. The signal to mount was given, and Gen. Custer at the head, with his hat in one hand, pointed to tho Indians with the other and cried out: ‘There they lire, boys. God bless you all and follow mo!’ We charged on a dead run, but when we reached the river we dismounted, and every fourth man held the horses of the other three. Gen. Custer led the advance with his aides, Boston Cus ter, his younger brother and Artie Reed, his nephew, by his side. Lieut. Tom Cus ter, his other brother, and Capt. Calhoun, his brother-in-law, were at the front with their commands. “At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way before us. But soon they swarmed upon us from every direc tion. They came upon us from front and rear and flank, and every ravine and every bush and tree semed alive with them. We soon knew that we were doomed, and we fought as men fight only under such cir cumstances. A perfect storm of arrows and bullets was pouring upon us from every side, but w r e fought our way back to our horses, mounted, and in our struggle to reach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the field. But ten Indians went dowm for every white man who fell. The companies of Capt. Cal houn and Lieut. Crittenden were thrown across our flank to protect our retreat. “Gen. Custer was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof. Capt. Keogh’s company was exposed to the fierc est fire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as if we were hours making that retreat of a quarter of a mile. We made our last stand on a little knoll, which we reached with only seventeen men out of our entire command. * “There the first thing-we did was to shoot our horses so as to make a breastwork be hind which we could fight. General Custer and his brother Tom and Lieutenant Cook were among the last to fall. Custer died with his revolver in his left and his saber in his right hand, with a dozen dead In dians piled around him. And, Indeed, almost every man on that little knoll weflt down with just such a heap of red bodies around him. Charley Reynolds, a scout, and as brave a man as ever lived, brought down an Indian at every shot, and as he fell he emptied his revolver still with a steady hand. The Indians were armed, in addition to their bows and arrows, with the best guns to be had. _ “Before we went into battle Trumpeter Martin was sent back with orders to Cap tain McDougal and Captain Benteen to hurry forward with their companies. Had they done so and had Reno’s men come up to reinforce us, the result might have been very different. „ , “When I shot my horse a bullet struck me In the head and I fell. In its death struggles the horse rolled over on me and protected me during the rest of the fight. When it was all over and the Indians swarmed over the knoll they chanced to see that I was still alive. They then bound me hand and foot and took me to their camp. “There they already had two other white men, prospectors, ana a young white wom an. They put these three through tortures, which I 'was compelled to witness. But I was reserved for the last, because the exe cution I had done in the fight had been noticed, and they wanted to have revenge for it. In fact, they named me ’Little Thunderer,’ and called me by that name all the time I was among them. The two pros pectors were made to run the gantlet again and again. Each time the arrows were pulled out by force and fresh ones shot Into them. One of the men finally resisted and was brained by a tomahawk. When the other became too weak to afford any more sport of that sort he was bound to a stake, a slow' fire was built on his addomen, and the bucks and squaws danced around him laughing over his death agonies. Then the woman was tortured to death. “Finally they began upon me. They tied coals of fire upon my head and left them there until I fainted. When I came to they put on fresh ones. When I refused to open
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · 26 December 1897
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
A crippled miner named George Benjamin claims to have witnessed Custer's death at Little Bighorn and seeks a pension with Senator White's help. He recounts being captured and tortured by Indians, which he says explains why his survival story is only now emerging.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 10 days later.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 26 December 1897 · page 3
SAYS HE SAW CUSTER DIE. A Miner's Tale of the Massacre at the Little Big Horn. Los Angeles Letter in New York Sun. George Benjamin, a crippled and wounded miner, is on his way to Washington, where he hopes to secure a pension. He claims to have been with Custer at the massacre at the Little Big Horn. Although it W'as sup posed that there w r as no survivor of the massacre, Benjamin’s story bears marks of truthfulness, and the fact that he was held as a prisoner by the Indians and driven crazy by their tortures long prevented his experiences from being made known.
See moreSee less
Sen ator Stephen M. White is taking him to Washington, and will try to get a pension for him this winter. ‘‘ln the spring of 1576,” says Benjamin, “I was prospecting in the Black Hills for gold with two other miners named Stone and Kelly. In June we w'ere camped on Clark’s creek, and as we were getting short of sup plies Kelly and I went out to shoot game for supper, leaving Stone In camp. When w'e returned we found him dead and horri bly mutilated. We knew at once that the Indians were on the warpath, and that we’d better get out. So we started at once for Foster’s ranch, but w'hen we reached there we found that the Indians had been ahead of us. Every man, woman and child on the ranch had been murdered, and all the bodies had been mutilated. The house had been burned and all the horses and cattle driven off. We started for Cheyenne to give warn ing of the uprising, and on the way we met a body of Custer’s men. They asked us to join in the pursuit, and I consented gladly, but my partner, Kelly, decided to go on to Cheyenne. Not long afterward we found his body, scalped and cut to pieces, only a few miles from where we parted. “Wo broke camp on June 16 and. Major Reno scouted the trail to the Rosebud and struck a fresh trail where the Indians had crossed. Gibbons was ordered to cross the Yellowstone near the mouth of the Big Horn and meet General Custer at the mouth of the Big Horn on June 26. On June 24 the trail of the Indians was scout ed twenty-eight miles up the Rosebud. That night a council w’as held and the troops left the Rosebud and marched up Dirty Woman’s creek toward the Big Horn, ten miles, and went into camp, as it was too dark to venture over the divide. The next morning the troops W'ere in the saddle soon after daybreak, and about 8 o’clock the first Indians were seen by the scouts from the lop; fyf.the divide. The men were in great spirits because they had come upon the Indians at last, although the evi dent Indications were that we were out numbered ten to one. Captain Benteen was sent toward some hills on the right to scout the Indians and obtain a view of the country. With him he took three com panies of the Seventh Cavalry. Our com mand then moved on one mile farther, and Major Reno was sent to the left, with or ders to skirmish and drive the enemy if found. The main body was to protect or reinforce him, as required. Captain McDougal was in charge of the pack train and was left with one company one mile from where Reno left us. On ahead of us were great clouds of dust, which seemed to indicate that the main body of Indians was on the run, either driving away the horses and cattle or getting the squaws and chil dren out of the way for the threatened bat tle. General Custer, with the other four companies, started for this commotion, and swung his line toward the river, hoping to cross, but found no good crossing. “We then fell back to the second bottom, where we were dismounted to examine our firearms and prepare for the battle. The signal to mount was given, and Gen. Custer at the head, with his hat in one hand, pointed to tho Indians with the other and cried out: ‘There they lire, boys. God bless you all and follow mo!’ We charged on a dead run, but when we reached the river we dismounted, and every fourth man held the horses of the other three. Gen. Custer led the advance with his aides, Boston Cus ter, his younger brother and Artie Reed, his nephew, by his side. Lieut. Tom Cus ter, his other brother, and Capt. Calhoun, his brother-in-law, were at the front with their commands. “At first we met but few Indians, and they quickly gave way before us. But soon they swarmed upon us from every direc tion. They came upon us from front and rear and flank, and every ravine and every bush and tree semed alive with them. We soon knew that we were doomed, and we fought as men fight only under such cir cumstances. A perfect storm of arrows and bullets was pouring upon us from every side, but w r e fought our way back to our horses, mounted, and in our struggle to reach the bluffs we left the greater portion of our men dead or wounded on the field. But ten Indians went dowm for every white man who fell. The companies of Capt. Cal houn and Lieut. Crittenden were thrown across our flank to protect our retreat. “Gen. Custer was everywhere, and for a time seemed bullet and arrow proof. Capt. Keogh’s company was exposed to the fierc est fire and his men were soon swept off. It seemed as if we were hours making that retreat of a quarter of a mile. We made our last stand on a little knoll, which we reached with only seventeen men out of our entire command. * “There the first thing-we did was to shoot our horses so as to make a breastwork be hind which we could fight. General Custer and his brother Tom and Lieutenant Cook were among the last to fall. Custer died with his revolver in his left and his saber in his right hand, with a dozen dead In dians piled around him. And, Indeed, almost every man on that little knoll weflt down with just such a heap of red bodies around him. Charley Reynolds, a scout, and as brave a man as ever lived, brought down an Indian at every shot, and as he fell he emptied his revolver still with a steady hand. The Indians were armed, in addition to their bows and arrows, with the best guns to be had. _ “Before we went into battle Trumpeter Martin was sent back with orders to Cap tain McDougal and Captain Benteen to hurry forward with their companies. Had they done so and had Reno’s men come up to reinforce us, the result might have been very different. „ , “When I shot my horse a bullet struck me In the head and I fell. In its death struggles the horse rolled over on me and protected me during the rest of the fight. When it was all over and the Indians swarmed over the knoll they chanced to see that I was still alive. They then bound me hand and foot and took me to their camp. “There they already had two other white men, prospectors, ana a young white wom an. They put these three through tortures, which I 'was compelled to witness. But I was reserved for the last, because the exe cution I had done in the fight had been noticed, and they wanted to have revenge for it. In fact, they named me ’Little Thunderer,’ and called me by that name all the time I was among them. The two pros pectors were made to run the gantlet again and again. Each time the arrows were pulled out by force and fresh ones shot Into them. One of the men finally resisted and was brained by a tomahawk. When the other became too weak to afford any more sport of that sort he was bound to a stake, a slow' fire was built on his addomen, and the bucks and squaws danced around him laughing over his death agonies. Then the woman was tortured to death. “Finally they began upon me. They tied coals of fire upon my head and left them there until I fainted. When I came to they put on fresh ones. When I refused to open
A new historical museum is being organized in New York's oldest public building, formerly a Revolutionary War prison for American officers. Over 2,000 relics have been promised, including battle flags, artillery, weapons, and items related to the Custer massacre and various historical figures.
New York Journal and Advertiser · 29 December 1897 · page 4
ALL MAY CONTRIBUTE TO IT
?Atlanta Constitution. Hon. Charles B. Rouss: But all her slights ignore; Dear Sir?We are the poor of this city that For through the Journal "wants" you'll is without employment, home and money Many will move on the first. Want Nothing but Death could be any worse and 4nd them as tenants? TJse Journal this is our conclusion that before the Eterml The xoad to fortune's dwr? I k "Wants." Heavens we must have a few wuuU la used in the United States service, from the flint lock to the modern rifle; specimens of projectiles; relics frohn Yorktown to Gettysburg; specimens of uniforms and equipments for both horse and foot; 1 1 T?
See moreSee less
Jinn ...n ? + nf nfiot va]ue and variety, including relics of the Custer massacre; relics of Washington, Jefferson, Adams, Gates, Lafayette, Hamilton. Jackson. Taylor, Scott, Lincoln, Grant,
A 1897 Miles City dispatch recalls the 1876 Little Bighorn massacre as the catalyst for military occupation of the Yellowstone valley. It describes the founding of Gen. Nelson Miles's cantonment at the Tongue River confluence and the subsequent civilizing of the territory, including buffalo extermination and the rise of grazing and irrigation.
Wood County Reporter · 30 December 1897 · page 6
CUSTER'S RAID RECALLED
Sioux, the most numerous and mur derous of any cf the great tribes which have ever infested our western fron tiers. The projected advance west ward of the Northern Pacific railroad had made the opening of this great valley a future probability; but the massacre of Custer’s command made it