As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

February 1883

21 articles

The Evening Critic · Washington, D.C.

The Star Route trial resumed with postmaster Clement A. Lownsby testifying about mail service to Miles City, Fort Keogh, and Fort Custer. He described Indian attacks on mail carriers in 1878-1880, including killings and stolen stock, illustrating the dangerous conditions on the frontier mail routes.

The Evening Critic · 15 February 1883 · page 1

STAR ROUTE TRIAL TO-DAY

the matter. Clement A. Lownsb), postmaster at Ills marck, took tho Btand and was cross examined l) Mr. Wilson, Ho said that when this route was established tlm mall to Miles City, Tort Keogh and Iort Custer was sont over this route, and when tho Paclllo Railroad was b tilt as tarasOlondlne then all ot tho Moutina mall went over this route. Togoarouul by Helena to Miles city would tako fourteon or fifteen clays and to go by tho way ot Hutord would tako ten days. Iu July, 1878, Morris Knno was attacked hlle carrying Ihe mall and several shots put through his wagon.

See moreSee less

In May, 1SS0, ten cmployos wero shot and six hord of stock run off. In July following 1 rcoz", n mall carrier, was kllfod. About Juuo and

See the clipping

The Evening Critic · Washington, D.C.

A witness describes severe winter conditions in 1878 that delayed mail delivery between Bismarck and Miles City, referencing the Custer massacre only as a date marker for when Miles City was founded. The defendant Rerdell then announces in court that he will abandon his defense and cooperate with the government.

The Evening Critic · 15 February 1883 · page 1

ot the visit ot lnspcctoi Chllds, and It weighed 210 pounds, Tho countty since July, 1878, had been settling up, but mostly along the rivers. Miles City was established In tho win ter of 1877, nttci tho Custer massacre. It poueu j,rjuu voios at tiro lascciocuou. 'That would make It about 3,000 Inhabit ants, " said Judgo WHon. "I think that some of them voted often," answered the witness. "The) voted on tho modern, Improved plan," adued the Judge. , In December, 1870, tho witness rocelved tho following; "In cno of nbsoluto failure, Bismarck to Miles City, employ tomporoD.sorvice atrato not exceeding 409,000 rer anuum and report action. Tiios. J, URVDV," Tlio witness nnswered ns follows: .

See the clipping

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Seven years after the battle, General James S. Brisbin lectured in Montana claiming Custer disobeyed General Terry's orders and that the massacre was an unnecessary sacrifice driven by Custer's ambition. Brisbin, who succeeded Custer in command, also publicly exonerated Major Reno of blame.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 20 February 1883 · page 1

The Custer Massacre

PROVED SET OF -ABSTRACT AND SEARCH BOOKS, prepared by Daniel St. Clair Steevens, w 'j<i'__' '" < continued and put in working condiAbstracts of Title to any In or tract of land in the . city or county of Sacramento made at reduced rates. fel7-tf E. I. ROBINSON, Searcher of Records. • WHiw iijuwnmil iini in 1 1 1' in iii i in mill 'in <mm t r instructions from General Terry, it was prob able that he and his command would be liv ing to-day. The death of Custer and hip men was a useless and unnecessary sacrifice, brought on by Cu-ter'd dojire far glory and promotion.

See moreSee less

He read from documents to prove his position, and exonerated Rsna from all blame in the battle of Little Big Horn. As General Brhbin was the next cavalry effiear in ratk to Cueter, and succeeded Custer when he fell, hU remarks produced a great sensation. The Flooded Districts.

See the clipping

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

The report recalls how in 1876 Col. McKenzie, acting under Gen. Crook's orders, disarmed and dismounted the Red Cloud and Red Leaf Sioux bands at Chadron Creek for suspected complicity in the Custer massacre, confiscating 705 horses that were later sold. The Secretary of the Interior now recommends Congress appropriate $14,100 to reimburse the Indians for the loss of their horses.

National Republican (Washington City) · 20 February 1883 · page 5

Old licit Clomla Pontes Ill 1670 Col McKcuzIe uctlng under orders from Gen Crook arrested disarmed and dis mounted tho Itccl Cloud nnd Bed Leaf bands of Sioux at Chadron crook for nctlvo sym pathy and suspected complicity with tha Sit ting Hull Sioux In tlio Custer massacre Seven hundred and flvo horses wero taken

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

General James S. Brisbin lectured in Billings, Montana, arguing that Custer would likely have survived had he obeyed General Terry's instructions. He called Custer's death a needless sacrifice driven by personal ambition, and cleared Reno of any blame.

New-York Tribune · 20 February 1883 · page 1

—————— esses GENERAL BRISEIN ON CUSTER'S DEATH. Mires Crry, M. T., Feb. 19.—General James 8, Brisoin lectured at Billings on *aturday night. In the course of his lecture he said that if General Custer had obeved the instructions from General Terry it was prob. able that be aud his command would be living to-day. Ulie death of Custer sud bis men was a useless and unpecessary sacritice brought by Custer’s desire for glory aud prowotivn, He read documents to prove his position and exouerated Reno from all blawe. I —

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Speaking at Billings, General James S. Brisbin said Custer's death and that of his men resulted from Custer disobeying General Terry's orders in pursuit of personal glory and promotion. Brisbin, next in cavalry rank after Custer, cited documents to support his claim and fully exonerated Major Reno of blame in the battle.

The Indianapolis Journal · 20 February 1883 · page 1

Custer’s Sacrifice for Glory and Promotion. Miles City, M. TANARUS., Feb. 19. — General Jas. S. Brisbin lectured at Billings on Saturday night. In the course of his lecture he referred to the Custer massacre, and said if General Custer had obeyed .his instructions from General Terry, it was probable he and his command would be living to-day. The death of Custer and his men was a useless and unnecessary sacrifice brought about by Custer’s desire for glory and promotion. He read documents to prove his position, and exonerated Reno from all blame in the battle of Little Big horn. As General Brisbin was the next cav alry officer in rank to Custer, and succeeded when he fell, his remarks produced a great sensation.

See the clipping

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

At a lecture in Billings, Montana, Gen. James S. Brisbin argued that Custer's disobedience of Gen. Terry's orders caused the needless deaths of Custer and his command, attributing the disaster to Custer's ambition for glory. Brisbin, who ranked next to Custer and succeeded him after his death, exonerated Major Reno from blame in the battle.

Daily Globe · 20 February 1883 · page 4

THE LITTLE BIG HORN. * A Brother Officer Ce nsures the Dead Cus ter. Miles City, Mont., Feb. 19. — James S. Brisbin lectured at Billings Saturday night to a packed house. In the course of the lecture he referred to the Custer mas sacre, and said if Gen. Custer had obeyed the instructions from Gen. Terry it was probable that he and his ° command would be living to-day. . The death of Gen. .. Custer and his men was a useless and unnecessary - sacri fice, brought on by Custer's desire for glory and promotion.

See moreSee less

He read documents to prove his. position and exonerated Reno from all blame in the battle of the Little Big Horn. As General Brisbin was the next cavalry officer in rank to Custer and succeeded Custer when he fell, his remarks produced a great sensation.

See the clipping

The Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont.

At a lecture in Billings, Gen. James S. Brisbin argued that Custer brought disaster on himself and his men by disobeying Gen. Terry's orders in pursuit of glory, calling the deaths unnecessary. Brisbin, who ranked just below Custer and succeeded him in command, used documents to clear Maj. Reno of any blame for the Little Bighorn defeat.

The Semi-Weekly Miner · 21 February 1883 · page 3

Miles City, M. T., Feb. 11—Gan. James fl. Brisbtn lectured at Billings on Saturday night, and In tto coarea of the lecture he refered to tto Cra ter massacre nnd mid that If Gen. Custer bad obeyed instructions from Gen, Terry, it is probable to and hin command would to living to-day. The death of Custer and hla men was n ra al eM and nnneeeamry anerifiea brought by Carter's desire for glory and promotion. He road doeuasente to prove his praitiM and exonerated Reno from all btamwin tto tattle of the Little Big Horn. As GemBrisbin was next cavalry ofltoer ia rank to Custer and who sneeeedrd Crater when be fell, hi* remarks produced a grant sensation.

See the clipping

Seattle Daily Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash.

At a lecture in Billings, General James Brisbane argued that Custer's disobedience of Terry's orders, driven by desire for glory, caused the needless deaths at Little Bighorn. He presented documents to support his claim and publicly exonerated Major Reno of blame.

Seattle Daily Post-Intelligencer · 21 February 1883 · page 3

CUM mt Caster's Death. MILES Cm, Mont., Feb. 20.—General James U. Brisbane lectured at Billings last Saturday night, la course of his lecture he referred to the Custer mas sacre, and said that if Gen. Caster had obeyed the instructions from General Terry it was probable that he and his men would be living today. The death of Caster and his men was a useless and unnecessary sacrifice, brought on by Custer's desire for glory and promotion. Ue read documents to prove his asser tion, and exonerated Reno from all blame in the battle of Little Big Horn. As General Brisbane was the noxt cav alry ollicer in rank to Custer, and suc ceeded Custer when he fell, his remarks produced a great sensation.

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

A frontier scout named Huntly writes to dispute Buffalo Bill Cody's claim that General Custer committed suicide, asserting Cody never even witnessed the battle and was elsewhere at the time. Huntly instead claims Custer died fighting bravely but was doomed by Major Reno's cowardice, and that no 'massacre' occurred.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 February 1883 · page 4

The Kind of a Man Buffalo Bill Is.

Black Hills, writes a letter to the Miles City journal concerning the death of General Custer, and com pletely refuses the story gotten up by that long-haired fraud and imposition, Buffalo Bill, who says that the noble Custer committed suicide. Huntly also gives his opinion

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

A plainsman interviewed by the Black Hills Times insists Buffalo Bill Cody never saw the Custer battlefield and exaggerates his scouting record. He claims Custer attacked the Sioux camp and was defeated due to Reno's cowardice, not a massacre, and asserts no one truly knows how Custer died.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 21 February 1883 · page 4

Huntly also gives his opinion of the New York Weekly hero in plain and unmistakable language and pronounces him n. g. In this Huntly does not stand alone, as this is the unanimous senti ment of every western man who is at all acquainted with the his tory of this section of the terri tories. Huntly says: “I have been re quested to write the Journal what I know of General Custer’s death and my knowledge of William Cody. In 1876 I was with Gen eral Crook, on Goose creek, when the Custer fight occurred.

See moreSee less

Cody was with General Merritt, on Platte river somewhere; Cody never saw the Custer battle ground; he cannot speak the In dian language, that I am sure of; he joined us with Merritt’s com mand, on Goose creek, and we met General Terry, on the Rose bud, and marched in company to the mouth of Powder river; there Cody left the command and went to the states; he has been there ever since, I believe; ae a scout and prairie man he is seventy-five degrees below nothing. I have talked to the Sioux about the death of Custer; they knew noth ing about him only that he was killed; there was no massacre about the fight; Custer attacked the camp and got cleaned up through the cowardice of Reno; General Custer was a favorite with all prairie men; too goorf a man to be killed in the manner he was; for my part I believe Custer was killed in battle, fight ing like a little devil, and likely fell long before the battle ended; Curley, the only survivor, a Crow Indian, knows nothing about Cus ter’s death. I do not believe there is a man living, red or white, who knows how Custer died.”—Black Hills Times. A Bailor in the congregation, thinking the preaeher was too slow in making his point, shouted: “Come, sir, crowd a lirtlo more sail there.” The preacher pleas antly replied : I will as soon as I have weathered this point.” The sailor and the congregation smiled satisfaction. A Stockton, Cal., Chinaman thought to make himself “solid” with the Christian mistress who had tried to bring him into the fold by telling her: ‘!Me heap likee God; me heap likee Jesus.” “So you love Christ, do you?” asked the interested lady. “No,” cried the heathen, emphatically. “Heap love God; heap love Jesus; no care fo’ Chlist!” De KHne’a Great Nerve Restorer is tbe marvel of the age for all nerve dis eases. All file stopi>ed free. Send to 931 Arch street, Philadelphia, Pa. Skinny Men. “Wells’ Health Renewer” restores health and vigor, cures Dyspepsia, Im potence, Sexual Debility. 81. Don’t Die in the House. “Rough on Rats” clears out rata, mice, roaches, bed-bugs, flies, ants, molee, chipmunks, gophers. 15c. For Thick Heads, Heavy ntomachs, bilious cohditions, Wells’ May apple pills, anti-bilious, cathartic. 10 and 25c.

See the clipping

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont.

General James Brisbin, who ranked next to Custer, lectured in Billings arguing Custer's disobedience caused the massacre, driven by his desire for glory and promotion. Brisbin presented documents exonerating Major Reno of blame for the Little Bighorn defeat.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Cheyenne Daily Leader, 21 February 1883, The Cheyenne Daily Leader, 21 February 1883.

Helena Weekly Herald · 22 February 1883 · page 6

Miles City, M. T., February 19.—General James Brisbin lectured at Billings Saturday night. In the course of his lecture he re ferred to the Custer massacre, and said that if General Custer had obeyed the orders of command would be living to-day. 3 death of Custer and his men was a u 3 and unnecessary sacrifice brought by ter's desire for glory and promotion, read documents to prove his position exonerated Reno from all blame in the bat tle of the Little Big Horn. As General Brisbin was the next cavalry officer in rank to Custer, and succeeded him when he fell, his remarks produced a great sensation.

See moreSee less

Floods ou the Continent. Chicago, February 18.— Rufus Hatch ca bles to the Tribune from London as follows : The press dispatches received here from the United States, though meagre, show that the floods in the Ohio valley are appalling, but they are local compared with the universal inundation on the continent. The floods in Austria carry havoc, destruction and ruina tion, and the present distress in its general tenor and widespread nature are unprece dented. The news from Germany particn larly is of a most pitiable nature. Died. New York, February 14.—Ex-Governor Edwin D. Morgan died at 8 o'clock this morning. St. Louis, February 14.—Wagner, £he great composer, is dead. Vienna, February M.^The Lirar Mar cello and the city authorities are arranging a public funeral for Wagner. Memphis, February 18.—John Q. Rut ledge, author of "The Dreamy Eyes that Haunt me Still," and numerous other songs, died this afternoon.

See the clipping

The Billings Herald · Billings, Mont.

A speaker (General Brisbin) recalls his 1875-76 service at Fort Ellis, Montana, including the rescue of Major Pease's besieged party near the mouth of the Big Horn and the subsequent march with Gibbon's forces along the Yellowstone to link up with Terry, Custer, and Crook. The account details reconnaissance by scout Muggins Taylor and the movements of troops leading up to the campaign against Sitting Bull's forces.

The Billings Herald · 22 February 1883 · page 1

Yellowstone and hold the Indians till the arrival of Gen. Terry, who, with Custer and Crook, were com ing from Fort Lincoln to carry on I * I

See the clipping

The Billings Herald · Billings, Mont.

A lecturer describes the movements of Terry, Custer, Gibbon, and Brisbin along the Yellowstone and Rosebud rivers before the battle, including Brisbin's perilous skiff journey to find Terry. The account culminates in Terry's written order to Custer on June 21, 1876, directing him toward the Little Big Horn.

The Billings Herald · 22 February 1883 · page 1

"veiling in a small skiff with a party ' of seven men. They hoped by diligent rowing aided by the strong current to reach the mouth of j Powder river before morning over ! took them and there lind General I Terry. It was a perilous trip through the midst of a country held by hostile Indians. When morning came they found them selves at the mouth of Tongue river directly opposite Sitting Bull's

See the clipping

The Billings Herald · Billings, Mont.

A lecturer recounts the final days before Little Bighorn, including Terry's written order to Custer and the farewells from Gibbon and Brisbin. He speculates that had Custer followed the order's timeline exactly, he would have reached the Little Big Horn a day later and avoided disaster.

The Billings Herald · 22 February 1883 · page 1

On the 22d of June, Custer passed his regiment, the 7th Cavalry, in review before his superior officers and started on his last expedition. Before starting Gen. Brisbin yielding to the solicitations of Capt. Keogh, one of Custer's oflicers, -offered to take survice under him with his force and accompany him, but Cus ter declined and Was afterwards heard to remark that "this was a matter for the 7th Cavalry." As Gen. Gibbon bade him farewell lie told Custer, impressively, to "take plenty of time." The General did not believe that Custer went forward by forced marches, but that in his eagerness to meet the Indians lie crossed over from the Rosebud to the Little Big Horn sooner than he should have done.

See moreSee less

Gen. Terry with the balance of the force, started forward with all speed to reach the mouth of the Little Big Horn, Gen. Brisbin being in command of the march during Gibbon's temporary illness. On the afternoon of June 25th they were twelve miles from the rende zvous, with the infantry worn out with the long march over the burning earth and beneath the hot sun. The cavalry were in a little better condition, and Terry came forward and enquired of Brisbin if it were not possible to push the cavalry forward during the night. He said he had promised to be at the mouth of the Little Big Horn

See the clipping

The Billings Herald · Billings, Mont.

The item notes that a pamphlet from the Northern Pacific railroad includes a report of Gen. Brisbin's recent lecture describing the military movements before and during the battle known as the 'Custer Massacre.' It praises Brisbin's close association with the events as lending credibility to his account.

The Billings Herald · 22 February 1883 · page 2

On thc-firat page will be found a report of Gen. Brisbin's lecture, de livered last Saturday evening. It Î3 worth preservation as embody ing an account of the military movemcntc which preceded and accompanied the terrible battle that has passed into history under the name of the "Custer Massacre." Gen. Briobin'a close association with all the events he described en titles this narativc to the utmost credence and attention.

See the clipping

Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

General James S. Brisbin, who succeeded Custer in command, lectured in Billings, Montana, arguing that Custer's disobedience of General Terry's orders caused the needless deaths of his command. He attributed Custer's actions to a desire for glory and promotion, and fully exonerated Major Reno of blame in the battle.

Bismarck Tribune · 23 February 1883 · page 6

MILES CITY, Mont., Feb. 19.—Gen. James S. Brisbin lectured at Billings Saturday. Id the course of his lecture he referred to the Custer massacre,' and said if General Custer had obeyed his instructions from from General Terry, it was probable that lit}, his command and cauld be living -to-day. The death of Custer and his men was a useless ana unnecessary sacrifice, brought on by Custer's desire for glory and promotion. He read documents to prove his position, and exonerated Beno from all blame in the battle of the Big Horn. As Little Gen. Brisbin was the next officer cavalry in rank to Custer, and succeeded Custer when he fell, his remarks produced a great sensation.

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

General James Brisbin, who succeeded Custer in command after his death, lectured in Billings arguing that Custer disobeyed General Terry's instructions, leading to the unnecessary deaths of himself and his men. Brisbin attributed the disaster to Custer's desire for personal glory and promotion, and exonerated Reno of blame.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 23 February 1883 · page 1

Gen. Brlaben on the Ouster Kuiacn. MILLS CITY, Feb. 19—Gen James Bris ben lectured at Billings Saturcay. In the course of the lecture he referred to the Custer massacre and said that if General Custer had obeyed the instructions from General Terry it was probable that he and his command would be living to-day. The deaths of Custer and his men was a useless and unnecessary sacrifice, brought on by Custer's desire for glory and pro motion. He read documents to prove his position and exhonorated Bono from all blame in the battle of the Little Big Horn. As General Brisbin was the next cavalry officer in rank to Custer and sue ceeded Custer when he fell, his remarks produced a great sensation. IrisbAfiiin.

See the clipping

Northern Tribune · Cheboygan, Mich.

General Brisbin, who succeeded Custer in cavalry command, gave a lecture in Billings asserting that the Little Bighorn massacre resulted from Custer's disobedience of General Terry's orders. He presented documents to support his claims, creating a sensation among listeners.

Northern Tribune · 24 February 1883 · page 4

Gen. Brisbon, who succeeded Gen. Cus ter in the cavalry command after the battle of Little Big Horn, in which the latter was killed, has created a sensa tion by delivering at Billings, N. T., a lecture on the battle, in which he assert ed that the massacre of Custer and his men was a useless sacrifice, brought on by Custer's disobedience of Gen. Terry's orders. Gen. Brisbin read documents to

See the clipping

Lexington Weekly Intelligencer · Lexington, Mo.

General James S. Brisbine lectured in Billings, Montana, claiming Custer's disobedience of General Terry's orders and desire for glory caused the needless deaths of his command. Brisbine, who outranked Custer and succeeded him after his death, also exonerated Major Reno from blame in the battle.

Lexington Weekly Intelligencer · 24 February 1883 · page 2

Billings, M. T., Saturday night. In the course of the lecture be referred to the Custer massacre aud said if Geu. Custer had obeyed instructions from Geu. Terry it was probable be and his command would be living to day. The death of Custer aud his men was a useless aud unnecessary sacrifice, brought on by Custer's de sire lor glory and promotion. He read documents to prove his position, and exouerated Beuo trom all blame in lb battle of Little Big Horn. As Gen Brisbine was the next cavalry officer in rank to Custer and succeeded Custer when he fell, his rem irks produced great sensation.

See moreSee less

It might be as well tor Gen. Brisbiue's own reputation i he desisted from detracting from tb glory of a dead hero. Mr. Kyan's bill prohibiting the teaching of auy other liviug language than English in the public schools was national defeated in the house of representatives

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

General James S. Brisbin lectured in Billings, arguing Custer and his men died needlessly because Custer disobeyed General Terry's orders out of ambition for glory and promotion. Brisbin, who ranked next to Custer in the cavalry, exonerated Reno of all blame for the Little Bighorn disaster.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 27 February 1883 · page 3

"Grasshopper Jim" on Custer

all blame in battle of the Little Big Horn. Gen. Brisbin was next cavalry ( officer in rank te Custer when he fell. t His remarks produced a great senaa- ( tion.—Exchange. t Union Pacific Mauasement. 1 A paragraph in the report of the gov ernment directors of the Union Pacific railroad: “In view of the obstructions and delays we bad experienced, and the apparent shyness and distrust with which we had been treated, the natural effect of which was to awaken suspicion, (whatever may have been the intent,) we were agreeably surprised to find that, from all we could learn, the man agement of the road bad been prudent and wise, its affairs honestly and ably administered, its condition and pros pects good, wit i nothing to be gained from concealment or evasion, and noth ing to be feared from publicity.”

See the clipping