As the Papers Told It

Little Bighorn · The full archive

January 1883

11 articles

Daily Yellowstone Journal · Miles City, Mont.

At an old-timers' gathering, Mr. Graham recounts arriving in the Yellowstone valley by steamboat in August 1876, shortly after news of the Custer massacre, and describes the massed military forces under Terry, Crook, and Miles then encamped in the region. The speech is full of jocular personal anecdotes about who first set foot on shore and other old-timer rivalries.

Daily Yellowstone Journal · 3 January 1883 · page 4

mander for the purchase of three hun. dred head of horses to be used in the expedition then planned against the hostile Sioux, in the Yellowstone country. OUr completion of this duty he met Mr. Charles Brown (here present) who had just returned front the scene of the Custer massacre, and who advised him to push forward to

See the clipping

Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.

A former army scout recounts guiding Custer on a march years before Little Bighorn, describing a competition between his mule and Custer's horse. He closes by claiming Custer killed himself during the final battle, citing Indian custom of not mutilating a suicide's body as evidence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 3 January 1883 · page 1

I would find, take something better than so old mule to keep ahead of biro, I vig orously maintained that the u-uie wouid get over the sixty-five miles as quick as any horse te had, and be seemed to be satisfied when tbe post commander spoke up and conurnied what I bad said. For the first ten miles I bad to use the spurs lively to keep the General trom riding ovei me, but after crossing the bmoky Hill river and getting on into tbe Mml-bills tbe mule got bis second wind. He commenc ed to leave Custer's Kentucky tnorough bred,snd the soldier in time acknowledeed

See the clipping

Crawford Avalanche · Grayling, Mich.

A frontier scout reminisces about racing Custer on a mule to Fort Larned years before Little Bighorn. He then claims that at the battle, Custer was the only unmutilated body because Indians believed he had killed himself rather than be captured.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Crawford Avalanche · 4 January 1883 · page 1

CUSTER ON A THOROUGHBRED. Buffalo Bill tells a new story about his first ride with Custer. " In 1607," he says, " I was post guide and Kcout at Fort Hays, Kansas. Before that time I had met Gen. Custer when he was stationed at old Fort Fletcher, but I was not well acquainted with him. Owe evening early In Jnne became in to Hays with only a light escort and was on a forced march to For, Lamed which is C5 miles from the former place. At that time there were, of ourse, noia'Iroid connections.

See moreSee less

When the General expressed a wish for u guidn to accompany him, the com manding oflicer detailed me, and or ders were given to start at daylight the following morning. At the time my best lonj-distance horse was a big, mouse-colored mule, and as I heard what a lightning traveler Custer was, I knew that only my best runner wo'd do to keep ahead of the "Whirlwind," as the Indians called him. 1 thought I would be prompt and ahead of the General at daylight, but when I arriv ed he was already on the ground with his staff and orderlies. When I rodn up I noticed him eyeing the animal I was riding, and when I announce 1 1 was to be his guide he assented, but said I would have to get a better hore. It would, I would tiud, take something better than an old mule to keep ahead of him. 1 vigorously maintained that the mule would get over the 05 miles as quick as any horse he had, and he seemed to be satisfied ' when the post commander spoke up and confirmed what I said. Tor the first ten miles I had to use the spurs lively to keep the General from riding over me, but ufter crosMiig the Smoky Hill River and getting on into the sund hills the mule got his second wind. We commenced to leave Custer's Kentucky thorough bred, and the soldier in time acknowl edged that 1 was riding a pretty good horse. For a long time we kept up this rapid traveling, his escort being stattered out for miles behind, and as the country was dangerous the Gener al called a halt to let his men close up and become less convenient target for vagrant bands of Indians. When we started ugain I made up my mind to show him what a good mule to lid do, and I struck a gait which astonished him so much that he did not call for another halt. We left the escort to f.illow as best they could, and before noon the General and myself rode into Fort Larued. The escort straggled in for hours during the day. The next day 1 returned to Hays, while he took command of his regiment, and soon after had his big light at Pawnee Fork Creek. I met him frequently after that and guided him in several expedi tions. Poor Custer! 1 wus miles from him when lie killed himself. Yes, killed hini'elf! The Indiana who weie in the light of the Little Big Hoinsay Custer killed himself, and from the Indian religion I am conviueed that they are riirut. lie was the only one who was not mutilated on the bloody field, and the red warrior will not mu tilate the body of a man who takes his own life. I think that Custer fought till all his brother olficers died, anil, no Reno to support him, he then tiled by his own hand and ended the career of as brave a man as ever wore spurs.

See the clipping

Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.

A letter from a man named Huntly disputes scout William Cody's claim that Custer died by his own hand, arguing Cody never even saw the battlefield. Huntly insists Custer died fighting bravely in battle, likely early on, and that no one truly knows the details of his death.

CorrectionThis set right 7 earlier articles: Watertown Republican, 20 December 1882, The Weekly Democratic Statesman, 21 December 1882, The Canton Advocate, 28 December 1882, Wood County Reporter, 28 December 1882, Grant County Herald, 28 December 1882, Juniata Sentinel and Republican, 3 January 1883, Crawford Avalanche, 4 January 1883.

Jamestown Weekly Alert · 5 January 1883 · page 8

Haw Wen. Cn.-itei' Oi 1* A few weeks ago a man named Cody, a professed scout, published it as his be­ lief I hat. Gen. Custer died ot his own haml. Now a man named lluntly scouts the idea given out by the pretended scout, giving his view lo the M.les City Journal as lollows: 1 h-ive been requested to write tie Journal what 1 know of Gen. Custer's death, and my knowledge of William Cody. In lfc70 I was with Gen. Crook, on Goose creek, when the Custer fight occurred.

See moreSee less

Cody was with Gen. Merritt on the Platte river somewhere Cody nevet saw the Custer battle gr und. Hs I cannot speak tl*« Indian language. Que' talk the sign language that. 1 am sure of. He joined us with Merrill's command on Goi se creek, an:l we met Gen. Terry on the Rosebud, and marched in company to the mouth of Powder river. There Cody left the command and went to the States. He has been there ever since, I believe. As a scout and prairie man he is seventy-five degrees behind nothing. I have talked to the Si ux about the death of Custer, and they know nothing about lum, only that he was killed. There was no "massacrc" about the'fight. Custer attacked the camp, and got cleaned up through the cowardice of Reno. Gen. Custer was a favorite with all prairie men too good a man to be killed in the manner in which he was. For my part 1' believe Custer was kil ed in battle, fight­ ing like a "little devil," and likely fell long before the battle ended. "Curly" the only survivor, a Crow Indian, knows nothing about Custer's death. 1 do not. believe there is a man living,red or white, who knows how Custer di d. ,1 The Fargo uml shop. The business of the Fargo land oSBce for the past year was as follows:

See the clipping

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

A former scout named Hill, interviewed by a Philadelphia newspaperman, recounts reminiscences of General Custer and argues that Custer committed suicide at Little Bighorn. He bases this on the claim that Custer's body was the only one left unmutilated, which he interprets through Indian religious custom as proof of self-inflicted death.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

South Branch Intelligencer · 12 January 1883 · page 1

•vt feather J, 188 ’, |/t blr.N ON fc Ct),, Pjrl.and, .V.iins hours wlicu discovered. hvfVAt.o Hill, who is in Philadel phia, has been giving lo a newspaper man some reminiscences of General Custer, and in conclusion advanced llio | conviction that the sacrificed hero the Little Hig Horn, died by his own hand. ‘The Indiana who w«ro in tho light,’ sai l the ex-court, ‘say ho shot bimielf and from the Indian religion I am convinced I that they tr.ll the truth. lie was the only man on tlm Held who was not mu tilated, snd an Indian will not mutilate the body of a man who takes hi* own , life.

See moreSee less

1 think that Custer fought till all Ilia brother officers died, and, no Reno to support him, he then died by his own hand and ended the career of as brave a man as ever wore spurs. «•••* — L>i;.\tm from ilrnnonioniA.—• Willie Mkltom, 13 years of ago, died on Mon day evening of last week in St. Louis from tho effects of hydrophobia. Tiie boy was bitten on the ear by a dog a bont a month or six weeks ago, and the wound was cauterised and soon healed. Last Saturday tho boy complained of a soro throat and a sore fare, and symp toms of hydrophobia made the'r appear ance Saturday night, resulting fatally on Monday evening.

See the clipping

Public Ledger · Memphis, Tenn.

A letter from an old trapper and scout, published via the Miles City Journal, claims Custer died fighting rather than by suicide and that the Sioux knew nothing special about his death beyond that he was killed. The writer also denies Buffalo Bill Cody was present at the battle and asserts the 'massacre' resulted from Major Reno's cowardice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

Public Ledger · 13 January 1883 · page 2

Another Story of General Custer's Death

country cannot be ruined by wasting a offioe and blank book manufactory 13 friction of half iu o!or income. c-uuisoo street. j j ry od tho KoncOud ant'-ma-ehr j id ;C3!Epahytotben!outlioirotle".Vff. 1 There Cody left the command and went to tbe Mates. He has been thero ever since, I believe. As a soout and prairie tnanjhe is sev nty. the degrees behiud notl,ini. I ha:a talked to tbe 8ouij about thn death of Custer, and they know nothing about him, only that he was killed. There was no 'massacre' about tha tight.

See moreSee less

Cutter attacked tha camp and got cleaned up thiough the oowarioe of Keno. Gcnsral Custer was a favoiite wvtb,a!l trains men; too good a man to ba killed in the manner in whioh he was. ..Tor mv Dart. I - believa Custer was killed in battle, fighting luea little den;,' and likoly tali long before the battio ended. 'Cutlev.' the only survivor, a Crow Indian, knows nothing about Custer s death. 1 do aot bcheve there is a man living, rod or white, who knows how Luster died."

See the clipping

The Daily Gazette · Wilmington, Del.

A House committee report by Mr. Harrison recommended against restoring Major Reno, who figured in the Custer massacre, to the army. The item appears amid other Washington legislative business including appropriations and tariff bills.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Daily Gazette · 17 January 1883 · page 4

Ml With the bUl toRagulate 2RS?J Sa^ry, member» contending that educaUoW Internal revenue, and tariff bllLsow have preference. Mr. Harrison reported advene]; tk to reatore Major Reno, who figuré | Custer massacre, to the army. Mr. Plumb, from the Appropritiiotl mfttee, reported the Post Office m Roads bill and aald he would cn<J«a have it taken up at the earliest m moment. ConaideraUon of the Holiday bill «« resumed. rmtcHOHAi _

See the clipping

Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

A Miles City Journal correspondent, an old trapper and scout, writes to dispute claims about Buffalo Bill Cody's presence at the Custer battle, insisting Cody never saw the battleground and was elsewhere with Gen. Merritt. He also claims Custer died fighting bravely, was not recognized by the Sioux afterward, and that the defeat resulted from Reno's cowardice rather than a 'massacre'.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Evening Bulletin · 24 January 1883 · page 4

How Custer Fell.

Bauer and Muldoon will wrestle for $500 next Saturday night-at St. Louis. The New York police are looking for Everett Reiner, aged sixteen,of Richmond, I ml. St. Louis has sent another 15,000 marks to the Gennan flood buffers, and promises more. Ed. Hartsfield, who burglarized stores in Burkley, Tenn., last week, was caught at Cairo, Saturday night. Henry Orr, of New York, a watchman, was shot, and probably fatally, by an Ital ian, name not known. Mrs. Edward Biddle, daughter of A. J. Drexel, died at St. George Hotel, Philadelphia, of heart affection, after a long illness.

See moreSee less

Archbishop O'Brien was consecrated at Halifax. An immense congregation of clergy and laity presented an address and purses. At a low dance-house in Wai-o, Texas, Saturday night, a negro musician was killed and a white visitor mortally wounded in a row. At the mines of the Harrisburg Mining Company, Adams county, Pa., by a premature blast, four men were injured, two it is supposed fatally. It is proposed to stop female labor in the chain and nail shops in the Black Country, England. A child was starved to death while its mother was working. Queen Victoria is a large real estate owner in New York. An advance in rents by her agents is said to have changed the tenants in a large block on Broadway. At Petersburg, Va John B. Fuller, Secretary of the Mutual Insurance Comppany of Telland, Conn., died suddenly on the Northern bound train, en route home from South Carolina. Mrs. Kate Burris, wife of Dr. J. E. Burns, of East fourteenth street, New York, was arrested for disturbing Spiritualistic meetings. Her husband was present at the meeting. The woman is thought to be insane. At Providence, 31. I., the body of Mrs. Sarah Lake was found dead, near the shore of the bay, the result of intemperance and exposure. She was a native of Lakeville, Msss., and once possessed uncommon ability and refinement. At New Haven, Conn., Red Cloud received overone hundred callers, including the Mayor, college professors and prominent citizens. He did not attend church, being somewhat indisposed. He is mnch gratified with the attention showed him. How CuBler Fell. Miles City Journal. We have received a communication from Huntley from an old trapper, guide and scout, who for manv years has lived among the Indians of the Northwest. He claims that Custer died fighting that he did npt commit suicide and that the Indians did not know him after ho fell. As there are some new points in the letter which have never before been published, and we believe the writer to be sincere in what lie writes, we publish herewith a synopsis of the article. He says: "I have been requested to write the Journal what I know of Gen. Custer's death, and my knowledge of William Cody. In 1876 I was with Gen. Crook, on Goose creek, when the Custer fight occurred. Cody was with Gen. Merritt, on Platte river somewhere ; Codv never saw the Custer battle-ground. lie can not speak the Indian language,nor talk the sign language; that I am sure of. He joined us with Merritt's command on Goose creek, and we met Gen. Terry on the Rosebud and marched in company to the mouth of the Powder river. Thefo Cody left the command and went to the states. Ho has been there ever since, I believe. As a scout and prairie man ho is seventy-five degrees below nothing. I have talked to the Sioux about the death of Custer, and they know nothing about him, only that he was killed. There was no 'massacre' about the fight. Custer attacked the camp and got cleaned up through the cowardice of Reno. Gen. Custer was" a favorite with all prairie men ; too good a man to be killed in the manner in which he was. For my part, I believe Custer was killed in battle, fighting like r 'little devil,' and fell long before the battle ended. 'Curly,' the only Burvivor. a Crow Indian, knows nothing about Custer' death. I do not believe thero is a man living, red or white, "who knowa how Cluster died."

See the clipping

The Pinal Drill · Pinal City, Ariz. Territory

A scout recounts racing Custer on a mule years before Little Bighorn, then claims Custer committed suicide during the battle based on Indian customs about mutilation. He speculates Custer died by his own hand after his officers fell and Reno failed to support him.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Pinal Drill · 27 January 1883 · page 6

CUSTER ON A THOROUGHBRED. Buffalo Bill tells a stoiy about his first ride with Custer. “In 1867,” he says, “I was post guide and scout at Fort Hhys, Kansas. Before that time I had met Gen. Custer when he was stationed at old Fort Fletcher, but I was not well acquainted with him. One evening early in June he came into Hays with only a light escort and was on a forced march to Fort Larned, which is sixty-five miles from the former place. At that time there were, of course, no railroad connec tions.

See moreSee less

When the General expressed a wish for some guide to accompany him the commanding officer detailed me, and orders were given to start at daylight the following morning. At the time my best long distance horse was a big, mouse colored mule, anil as I heard what a lightning traveler Custer was I knew that only my best runner would do to keep ahead of the ‘Whirlwind,’ as the Indians called him. I thought I would be prompt and ahead of the General at daylight, but when I arrived he was already on the ground with bis staff and order lies. When I rode up I noticed him eyeing the animal I was riding and when I announced that I was to be his guide he assented, but said I would have to get a better horse. It would, I would find, take something better than an old mule to keep ahead of him. I vigorously maintained that the mule would get over the six ty-five miles as quick as any horse he had, and he seemed to be satisfied when the post commander spoke up and confirmed what 1 said. For the first ten miles I had to Use the spurs lively to keep the General from rid ing over me, but after crossing the Smoky Hill river and getting on into the sand hills the mule got his second wind. We commenced to leave Cus ter’s Kentucky thoroughbred, and the soldier in time acknowledge that I was riding a pretty good horse. For a long time we kept up this rapid traveling, his escort being scattered out for miles behind, and as the country was dangerous the General called a halt to let his men close up and become less convenient targets for vagrant bands of Indians., When we started again I made up my mind to show him what a good mule could do. and I struck a gait which aston ished him so much that he did not call for another halt. We, left the escort to follow as best they could, and before noon the General and myself rode into Fort Larned. The escort straggled in for hours during the day. The next day I returned to Hays, while he took command of his regiment and soon after bad his big fight at Pawnee Fork Creek. I met him frequently after that and guided him in several expeditions. Poor Custer! I was thirty-five miles from him when he killed himself. Yes, killed himself! The Indians who were in the light of the Little Big Horn say Custer killed himself, and from the Indian religion I am con vinced that they are right. He was the only one who was not mutilated on the bloody field, and the j-ed w ir rior will not mutilate the body of a man who takes his own life. I think that Custer fought till all bis brother officers died and, no Reno to support him, he then died by his own nand and ended the career of as brave a man as ever wore spurs.” Eastern-Peach Crop.—The enor mous estimate that was given of the peach crop this year has been liber ally verified. By the close of this season there will have been sent to Cincinnati above 15,000 baskets, and to Chicago twice as many, and about 500,000 direct to New England cities. The canners of Baltimore and Philadelphia and co-bperators located near the peach-growing sections have operated very heavily this year, using 1,500,000 baskets. Eighty evaporat ing establishments have been busy in Delaware and Maryland ever since the fruit was ready to be picked. The evaporating method has almost pushed the old custom of sun-drying to one side. In the new process, peaches can be packed in halves, with a very showy appearance, that mate rially helps sales,. The market was very short of good dried peaches since summer and, as crops are apt to alternate heavy and light, pre servers have aimed to provide for a possible short offering in 1883. It is thought that the crop of this year will equal that of the remarkable growth of 1875. In a commercial sense it certainly does, for at that time the rush of supply was very sudden. The Oyster Industry.—The can-* ningof oysters, from a small begin ning, has become one of the leading industries of America. There are upward of 8,500,0(M) bushels packed each year in the United States; of this amount about 5,000,000 bushels are put up raw in kegs and cans, 3,- 500,000 bushels cooked and hermeti cally sealed in cans. The average number of large eastern oysters in a bushel is 176, and taking the census returns for the population, there is canned each year about thirty oysters for every inhabitant in the United States." There is engaged in fishing or catching of this product about 10,500 vessels, and 50,()00 persons are employed, to whom are paid about $9,000,000 annually. The amount of money invested in this mammoth in dustry is, in round numbers, $10,000,- 000. The Grocers' Bulletin is respon sible for the above. Albert Morse migrated with his family from Virginia to Indiana, and had not been there a week before his wife evinced a desire to elope with Mr. Tully, a neighbor. Morse pro posed that Tully should take her in consideration of transporting the re mainder of the family back to their old home. This was done. CUSTER ON A THOROUGHBRED. Buffalo Bill tells a stoiy about his first ride with Custer. “In 1867,” he says, “I was post guide and scout at Fort Hhys, Kansas. Before that time I had met Gen. Custer when he was stationed at old Fort Fletcher, but I was not well acquainted with him. One evening early in June he came into Hays with only a light escort and was on a forced march to Fort Larned, which is sixty-five miles from the former place. At that time there were, of course, no railroad connec tions. When the General expressed a wish for some guide to accompany him the commanding officer detailed me, and orders were given to start at daylight the following morning. At the time my best long distance horse was a big, mouse colored mule, anil as I heard what a lightning traveler Custer was I knew that only my best runner would do to keep ahead of the ‘Whirlwind,’ as the Indians called him. I thought I would be prompt and ahead of the General at daylight, but when I arrived he was already on the ground with bis staff and order lies. When I rode up I noticed him eyeing the animal I was riding and when I announced that I was to be his guide he assented, but said I would have to get a better horse. It would, I would find, take something better than an old mule to keep ahead of him. I vigorously maintained that the mule would get over the six ty-five miles as quick as any horse he had, and he seemed to be satisfied when the post commander spoke up and confirmed what 1 said. For the first ten miles I had to Use the spurs lively to keep the General from rid ing over me, but after crossing the Smoky Hill river and getting on into the sand hills the mule got his second wind. We commenced to leave Cus ter’s Kentucky thoroughbred, and the soldier in time acknowledge that I was riding a pretty good horse. For a long time we kept up this rapid traveling, his escort being scattered out for miles behind, and as the country was dangerous the General called a halt to let his men close up and become less convenient targets for vagrant bands of Indians., When we started again I made up my mind to show him what a good mule could do. and I struck a gait which aston ished him so much that he did not call for another halt. We, left the escort to follow as best they could, and before noon the General and myself rode into Fort Larned. The escort straggled in for hours during the day. The next day I returned to Hays, while he took command of his regiment and soon after bad his big fight at Pawnee Fork Creek. I met him frequently after that and guided him in several expeditions. Poor Custer! I was thirty-five miles from him when he killed himself. Yes, killed himself! The Indians who were in the light of the Little Big Horn say Custer killed himself, and from the Indian religion I am con vinced that they are right. He was the only one who was not mutilated on the bloody field, and the j-ed w ir rior will not mutilate the body of a man who takes his own life. I think that Custer fought till all bis brother officers died and, no Reno to support him, he then died by his own nand and ended the career of as brave a man as ever wore spurs.” Eastern-Peach Crop.—The enor mous estimate that was given of the peach crop this year has been liber ally verified. By the close of this season there will have been sent to Cincinnati above 15,000 baskets, and to Chicago twice as many, and about 500,000 direct to New England cities. The canners of Baltimore and Philadelphia and co-bperators located near the peach-growing sections have operated very heavily this year, using 1,500,000 baskets. Eighty evaporat ing establishments have been busy in Delaware and Maryland ever since the fruit was ready to be picked. The evaporating method has almost pushed the old custom of sun-drying to one side. In the new process, peaches can be packed in halves, with a very showy appearance, that mate rially helps sales,. The market was very short of good dried peaches since summer and, as crops are apt to alternate heavy and light, pre servers have aimed to provide for a possible short offering in 1883. It is thought that the crop of this year will equal that of the remarkable growth of 1875. In a commercial sense it certainly does, for at that time the rush of supply was very sudden. The Oyster Industry.—The can-* ningof oysters, from a small begin ning, has become one of the leading industries of America. There are upward of 8,500,0(M) bushels packed each year in the United States; of this amount about 5,000,000 bushels are put up raw in kegs and cans, 3,- 500,000 bushels cooked and hermeti cally sealed in cans. The average number of large eastern oysters in a bushel is 176, and taking the census returns for the population, there is canned each year about thirty oysters for every inhabitant in the United States." There is engaged in fishing or catching of this product about 10,500 vessels, and 50,()00 persons are employed, to whom are paid about $9,000,000 annually. The amount of money invested in this mammoth in dustry is, in round numbers, $10,000,- 000. The Grocers' Bulletin is respon sible for the above. Albert Morse migrated with his family from Virginia to Indiana, and had not been there a week before his wife evinced a desire to elope with Mr. Tully, a neighbor. Morse pro posed that Tully should take her in consideration of transporting the re mainder of the family back to their old home. This was done. ENGLAND A CENTURY AGO. • n . c , e “ tu 7 a «o England WllH in the midst of one of the most tremendous. and widely extended contests which a nation has over sue ceMfuUy sustained. In the y Wr 1776, Congress had declared Um American Colonies free and inde pendent States, the first action be tween the King’s troops and the Colonists having taken place at Lex ington in the preceding year. France had concluded a treaty with the Americans, and acknowledged their independence on February 6, 1778 The Spaniards had joined the cause

See the clipping

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

A hunting party in camp hears their old guide Billy recount frontier stories, with mention that he was at the Lava Beds during the Modoc War and served as a scout with Custer in his final campaign. The passage is a fictional/anecdotal frame story leading into Billy's personal narrative of scouting for the army near Cherry Creek (Denver) about twenty years prior.

Hand County Press · 31 January 1883 · page 3

Captain Jack killed all the white men, and was with Custer in Ins last campaign.” “By jovc, boys!” cried Black, “we’il have a yetu out of the old

See the clipping

Hand County Press · Miller, S.D.

A letter from a trapper and scout named Huntley claims Custer died fighting rather than by suicide, and that the Indians did not recognize him after he fell. The writer also disputes William Cody's claimed presence at the battle, asserting Cody was elsewhere with Gen. Merritt's command.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Evening Bulletin, 24 January 1883, The Pinal Drill, 27 January 1883.

Hand County Press · 31 January 1883 · page 3

HOW COSTER FELL. (Miles City Journal'. We have received a commun ication from Huntley, an old trapper, guide and icout, who for many years has lived among the Indians ot the northwest. He claims that Custedied fight ing—that he did not commit sui cideand that the Indians did not know him after ho fell As there are some now' points in the letter which have never before been published, and as we be lieve the writer to be sincere in what he writes, we publish herewith a synopsis ot the article.

See moreSee less

He says: I have been requested to write the Journal what I know of Gen. Custer’s death, ami my knowledge of William Cody. In 1879 I wus with Gen. Crook, on Goose Creek, when the Custer fight occured. Cody was with Gen. Merritt on Platte river somewhere; Cody never saw the Custer battle ground. He can not speak the Indian language; nor talk the sign language, that I am sure of. lie joined us with Merrett’s command on Goose Creek, and we met Gen. Terry on tiie Rosebud, and marched in company to the mouth of Pow der river. There Cody left the command and went to the states. Lie has been there ever since, 1 believe. As a scout and ptairie man he is seventv-five degrees behind nothing. I Jmve talked to the Bioux about the death of Custer, and they know nothing abont him, only that he was killed. There was no “massa cre” about the tight. Custer attacked the camp, and got cleaned up through the coward ice of Reno. Gou. Custer was a favorite with all prairie men; too good a man to be killed in the manner in winch he was* For my part I believe Custer was killed in battle, fighting like a “little devil.” and likely fell long before the battle ended. “Curly” the only survivor, a Crow In dian, knows nothing about Cus ter’s death. I do not believe there is a man living, red or white, who knows how Custer dud.” S etc.. for Hb SB tho United States, and to obtain p&t pI7 H onto in C'Misds. England, Franca, | nLbJj | Germanr, and all otrier countries. laMtaaa Thlrfj **tt F«wr«* practice. So charge for evsnanation of mouela or draw ings. Adrien by mail free. Patents obtained tlironph na aranoticod in tho •CIKVriFIC AHEHU'AS, which has the largest clrcnlation, and is the moat influ ential newspaper of its kind published in tha world. Tho advantageaof such a notice every imteiiioa understands. This large and splendidly illustrated newa paperia published WIEKUY at 1.1.20 a year, and is admitted to be the beat paper devoted to science, mechanics, Inventions, engineering works, and othor departments of industrial progress, published in any country. Single copies by mail, 10 cent*. Sold bjr all news deal ara. . , Address, llunn A Co., publishers of ScwaM!ic American, 261 It road way, New York. Handbook abont patents mailed free.

See the clipping