The Highland Weekly News · Hillsborough Hillsboro, Ohio · and 3 other papers
A peace commission offers Sitting Bull's people pardon and the same terms given to other surrendered hostiles, but the offer is rejected and the council disbands. A Minneapolis man who helped build a nearby military post describes visiting the Custer battlefield and conditions at the new fort.
The Highland Weekly News · 1 November 1877 · page 3
Bleaching Bones. [St. Paul Pioneer-Press.] Mr. Frank M. Fleming, of Minneapolis, who left here last spring to assist in building one of the new military posts on the Yellowstone River, returned home a few days since bringing some very interesting particulars in regard to the work of construction and the result of his observations at the scene of the Custer massacre on the Rosebud. The post upon which Mr. Fleming was employed during the summer is located at the mouth of the Little Big Horn, which is only eighteen miles distant from the spot where Custer and his gallant comrades met their terrible fate. Upon their first arrival at the site of the new fort the civilian mechanics had occasion to complain of the meagre allowance of
The Eaton Democrat · Eaton, Ohio · 25 October 1877
The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · 25 October 1877
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · 26 October 1877
Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.
A dispatch from Fort Walsh reports that the American peace commission sent to negotiate with Sitting Bull has met him and been abruptly dismissed, with the Sioux leader refusing to return to American soil. The report recounts Sitting Bull's rising stature after the 'Custer massacre' and his triumphant retreat to Canada as context for his defiance.
Mexico Weekly Ledger · 1 November 1877 · page 4
without striking Imic' : Walsh assur ed Sitting Bull that whatever might be said of the manner in which his people had been treabid by the Amer ican, the commissioners would not dare to set a trap for; himwhile he was on British soil. Here Ki-we-nee-pa-me-troo, the Man-with-Strong-Limbs, one of Sitting bull's head men, spoke up and said that although they did not suppose that the police would permit them to be attacked, would they be allowed to bring say 300 warriors to the conference. Maj. Walsh said if they did that the com missioners might dread treachery.
See moreSee less
Sitting Bull then asked what force the commissioners would have. Walsh said he did not know exactly,' but he had urged the commissioners by let ter not to bring a heavy escort. Per haps they would have 100 cavalry. On the other hand there would be no police ready to t ike the part of the Sioux, in case the commissioners at tacked them. On this Sitting Bull agreed to come to the conference with only his head men, thirty in number.'': These, he' said, would in no sense be an escort; they wese his advisers, and their presence wwoec essary to him. Walsh then asked him where he would put his force the interval. Sitting Bull said be wonld move them westward from Wood tnountain, so that they might be near at hand when he ac cepted the commissioners' terms and surrendered them to the troops for execution. This was said laughing ly, and his head men standing by laughed. After further parleying, Sitting Bull pledged his word to meet the commissioners at tins post, he to be accompanied by his head men only, and his force to be at least sixty miles away from the opening until two days after the clte of the inter view. Walsh in turn pledged the queen's word to keep the Indians safe from harm before, during and after the meeting, and to treat them as the qiwen's guests, supply them with one of the queen's interpreters, and see that the commissioners took no un fair advantage of them. Sitting Bull promised to reach here not later than than the 13th inst. The westward movement of the Sioux force has accordingly begun. Breaking t ump nt Wood mountain on the 11th, they pursued the Trader's road, and are now a little over eighty miles cast of here. Col. McLeod has dispatched police to show them their new camp, sixty miles southeast of here in the Dead-IIorsc valley, through which runs a small tributary ot the Ease Fork. Provi sions will be supplied them, several dog-teams having already left here with pork, tobacco and molasses. Should the conference break up with out any result being reached and it is thought Sitting Bull will not leave here this winter. thenthe police will help them to move camp either back to Wood mountain or to the north of of these hills, where the land is some what better sheltered. The commissioners are. expected on the 18th. They are being escort ed by two or three troops of the Sec ond cavalry. The c onference will Ikj attended by many loafing Indians from the Canadian tribes, who ex pect to see tobacco living in abun dance on an occasion so important, Sitting Bull's force, by actual count, consists of 1,340 souls. Traders are circulating a story to the effect that he intends to trap the commissioners and police alike and then proclaim a general Indian rising, but this is ut terly baseless. Tins police will take every p:ecaution against a surprise and are satisfied that the Sioux chief is sincere in meeting the commission ers, "just to oblige the queen," as he says. The weather is extremely cold, ranging from 20" alxove zero, as high as 30 at noon, ami down to zero almost everv nisrht, with vio lent snow blasts and piercing winds, The police are very anxious to get rid of Sitting Bull, and will use all fair means of persuasion to induce him to accept the commissioners terms. Ft. Walsa, Northwest Term-tout,
The Highland Weekly News · Hillsborough Hillsboro, Ohio
A dispatch reports that the U.S. commission led by General Terry met Sitting Bull near Fort Benton but failed to secure any agreement. Terry offered a full pardon and peaceful return if the Lakota would cease hostilities, but Sitting Bull distrusted the Americans and refused to cooperate.
The Highland Weekly News · 1 November 1877 · page 3
Conference with Sitting Bull. A Chicago Time special from the Sitting Bull Commission, Fort Worth, Northwest Territory, via Fort Benton, the 21st, savs the commission has met Sitting Bull and utterly failed to obtain any satisfaction or terms of
The item lists supposedly well-established facts to correct popular misconceptions about Custer's last stand, stating no sabers were used, Custer and officers had cropped hair, his body was not mutilated, and no warrior recognized him on the field. It's framed as a corrective for poets and artists who embellish the story.
FOR the benefit of poets, artists, and others who prefer truth, so far as it will answer their purposes. the following well established facts are given on the author ity of a distinguished army officer: 1. In Custer’s fight on the Little Big Horn there was not a saber in the command. ‘3. Custer and most of his oflicers wore their hair cropped close to the scalp. 3. The burial party reported that the re mains of Custer had not been mutilated in any manner. 4. All the Indians who have described the battle agree in the statement that Custer was not recognized by any warrior on the field.
See moreSee less
Norm JAuNsm, a lumberman in Wis conuin, had his left leg caught by the branch of a falling tree in such a manner that he could not extricate himself. While he was thus fast he saw that a huge pun ther hzuf discovered him, and, yelling vociferousl , he fortunately attracted the attention o¥ a hunter that chanced to be
A visitor (Lieut. Roe) describes revisiting the battlefield, finding skulls and bones scattered, and burying exposed remains in a mass grave. He also relays a Sioux participant's account correcting earlier newspaper illustrations, saying the fight occurred on a plateau by the river rather than in a valley.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 6 November 1877 · page 1
DEAD HEROES DISGRACED.
(Special Correspondence of The Leader.] Fort Steele, Wyo., Nov. 3. The following extracts from a pri vate letter from a member of the 2d cavalry, from one of the posts on the Big Horn, Montana, dated Oct. 14tb, are interesting, and throw additional light upon the unhappy fate of Custer and his men: “We made easy marches, had fine weather, and reached Fort McKinney on the 18th of September, where we laid over one day. On the 22d we camped on the site of old Fort Phil Kearney, the scene of the Fetterman massacre in 186 G.
See moreSee less
Nothing remains of the old fort but a few stockade posts, and the command soon used them up for fuel. On the 24th we camped at the crossing of Tongue river, and next morning Major Baker and companies B, E. and I, took the road to tho other new post. “On the 28th we passed over a large Indian trail, and entered a beautiful valley, the ground of which was liter ally covered with tepee poles and other paraphernalia of Indian make, and on maiching a few miles wc arrived at the spot where Custer and his men met their bloody fate. We reached this place after crossing tho Little Horn river, and followed a trail so narrow and winding that wc were compelled to dismount and lead our horses. On ar riving at the top of a bill we were met with the sight of graves almost as far as we could see. The ground was strewn with skulls and bones of horses, and here and there an old hat or boot could be seen protruding from the ground, marking the spot where some poor soldier had found a last resting place. “Lieut. Roe described the scene to us, he being within earshot of Custer’s command at the time of the massacre, but as he was with Reno and surronnd ed with savages, help for the brave General or his men was impossible. Reno was surrounded about a mile be low and could hear distinctly all that passed until the last of Custer’s men had perished. We collected all the skulls that were exposed and buried them in one grave. They all bore evi dence of having been perforated by a bullet, and we inferred that the men must have been lying down when kill ed, or afterwards shot through the head out of fiendish delight. It was a lamentable sight—one I should not like to see again. “The illustrations In tho papers led the people to believe that the fight oc curred in a valley, but such is not the case. There is a Sioux at this post who was in the fight, and he says that when the Indians discovered Custer advancing they concentrated their forces on a small plateau on the banks of the river, and when Custer charged them they overwhelmed and surrounded him, cutting off retreat, and before ho reached the hill not a man was left.” What a lamentable spectacle that battle-field must present! Death a certainty to every man; how des perately they must have fought and how many hasty prayers were sent up to Heaven in those few last agonizing moments! How like lightning flew the thoughts of these doomed men to mothers and dear ones far away, to whom the intelligence of their untime CONGRESSIONAL. Stealing a March in the House of Representative?. Washington, Nov. s.—Calkins, of Indiana, asked leave to offer a resolu tion adjourning the House out of res pect to the memory of tho late Senator Morton. Kelly, of Pennsylvania, objected. The nouse then proceeded to busi Louisville. ness. The following bills were introduced and referred: By Frye, To amend the law; also, To make persons charged with crimes and offenses competent Speaker. witnesses in U. S. courts. By Hewitt, Supplementary to an act carrying into effect the convention be tween the United States and China, to give the Court of Claims jurisdiction in certain cases. By Ward, Authorizing directors of national banks to declare quarterly dividends. By Hunton, For recouiputation of accounts between the United States and the several states growing out of monies expended by them in the war of 1812; also, For the construction of a bridge across the Potomac river. By Cabell, To reduce the tax on reported. manufactured tobacco. By Scales, For the transfer of the office of Indian affairs from the Interior to the War Department. By Shelby, To appropriate the cotton tax for school purposes. By Hooker, Authorizing the election of a delegate from the Indian Teritory. By Ellis, Defining tho manner in which certain land scrip may be located, and providing for the issue of patents in the name of locators. By Sayler, Relating to the execution of custom-house bonds; also, To secure ! rights of homestead settlers on public ! lands. By Banning, Amending the act rela tive to tax on cigars; also, Removing all restrictions now existing in relation to the enlistment of colored citizens in the army. By Boole, For repeal of the bankrupt law. By Young, For protecting the allu vial lands of the Mississippi from over flow. By Riddlo, Directing the transmis sion of private matter through the mails when the postage is insufficient: also, for the election of postmasters. By Whitteliome, Authorizing a treaty places. with Mexico to procure protection for the capital and labor of United States citizens which may be invested in open ing railway communication. The House passed, under suspension of the rules, Bland's bill For the re coinage of silver. It provides that there shall be coined at tho several mints of the United States, silver dol lars of weight 412$ grains Troy, of standard silver, ns provided in act of January 18, 1837, on which there shall be device and superscription provided by said act; which coin, together with all silver dollars heretofore coined by the United States of like weight and fineness shall be legal tender at their nominal value for all debts and dues, public and private, except when other wise provided by contract; and any owner of silver bullion may deposit the same at any United States coinage mint or assay office, to lx? coined into such dollars for his benefit upon the same terms and conditions as gold bul river roads. lion is deposited for coinage, under existing law. Section 2. All acts and parts of acts inconsistent with the provisions of this act are hereby re pealed. Ewing moved to suspend the rules and adopt a resolution making the bill to repeal the third section of the Re suption act the special order for to morrow, and from day to day till Tues day, 13th, at 3 o’clock, when the pre vious question shall be ordered on it and on any amendments then pending— the special order not to interfere with appropriation bills, but to be extended if necessary so as to allow five days for consideration of the bill—all amend ments meanwhile are to lx? in order. Adopted. On motion of Ward the rules were suspended and resolutions adopted that the President be respectfully requested to communicate to the House the cor respondence with the Spanish govern ment and all orders and directions of the Treasury Department to collectors of customs regarding the recent impos ition of deferential duty of fifty cents per ton on Spanish vesels entering American ports, with such information in reference thereto as ho may deem necessary; that the Secretary of the Treasury be instructed to furnish the House at the earlest practicable mo ment copies of the contract made with a certain syndicate for the negotiation of four per cent, bonds, together with copies of all papers relating thereto, and also with a statement as to the present position of such negotiations, and whether it remains in force as originally made, without modification or change. By Bland, Removing legal disabilities of women. It provides that when a woman has been admitted to practice in Superior courts she shall be allowed to practice in the U. S. Supreme court. By Buckner, For the repeal of tho Bankrupt laws; tho establishment of a national university for women in .Washington; amending the Constitu tion so as to restrict the application of the loth amendment to citizens of the United States on March 30th, 1870, or their issue, when said amendment was adopted. The purpose of the amend * inent is understood to lx? to prevent Chinese or their descendants from be coming voters. f By Willis, of New York, To promote - the education of the blind. The bill ■ proposes an appropriation of 8250,000 • to be invested in U. S. bonds as a per petual fund, the interest of which to be paid semi-annually to the trustees of - the printing house for the blind at Louisville. I Phillips introduced a bill to create postal savings banks. The Speaker announced that lie [ would bo absent to-morrow in Pennsyl vania, and that Sayler would act as Speaker. Tho House adjourned on motion of Conlcling, in respect to the memory of i Senator Morton.
This miscellaneous 1877 Montana newspaper column reports on a new drug-store counter invention, the death of Mrs. Bainsford, and the killing of two men (Hicks and A. G. Wood) by Nez Perce in the region, whose bodies were later found by General Howard's command. It briefly references Custer amid garbled OCR text but is not primarily about the Little Bighorn battle itself.
Bozeman Avant Courier · 8 November 1877 · page 3
aMjHpi and out with great <ti»s<>. Tliev CM| be pulled out or slid in from any eoner of tin* drawer, and nn'ikr era ft Is im]iossd«e toeramp them either in ,,r «'hising. The invention is a mod one. and parties who have draweis huqgon the old style will do weil to Iiave Mr. B. F. Bennett eliangt* th«*m. Tin* in vention is v«-ry simple and consists of two gTOOVes in each side of the «ira wer into whleji tongues til and on which the diawer «Hdei. Tiie comBtcris now at the painter's It Tliev eooilier drawCuster in is a on bad Iiave ibcV in It two the into Burl as
A road is being built from Etchetah to the mouth of the Musselshell River, apparently to allow rapid military movement should Sitting Bull attempt to cross back into U.S. territory from Canada. General Miles plans to use the Musselshell as his winter base with the 7th Cavalry, positioning forces to intercept Sioux crossing the border.
Bozeman Avant Courier · 8 November 1877 · page 3
j By reference to our Custer county lo- ^ By j cals j cals it will be seen that a road is bein-» l.-.i.i in « , cals It w ,|| b( , >st ^ n a ,. oa j , s | JC ,j n , r I Mr. Allen «-Htin,. tn ,, D .l„ „„i.i„.,. i head, Mr. Allen, w-riting to us on the subject, | bea<1 Mr. says: "The exact idea ot tiie authorities f rti ' J(! says: do not know, hut it is for immediate use."
See moreSee less
| ,lil " do not Very likely the object in view is to be pre- ! 01u! Very v cry v cry imeiy me oojeci in view is to he prei pared for Sitting Bull, should lie attempt i so f P * " " _ i so pared to cross Hie line. By having a road laid , - ) " l 'i to cross out Hie soldiers would not lx» delayed, but 111 wl out could make rapid marches ■ to the front, ! ° >er could should it become necessary. The follow- ' ' ^ dle should ing from the Benton Record of a late date 1 tore, ing lias lias some bearing on tin* subject. In speak ing of Gen. Miles, it says : "The General t ' ,e < ing of intends intends to make the mouth of the Muscle- ] " ,s shell shell river, instead of Fort Buford, his s base of supplies, and with the whole of ] J'ee» base the 7lh regiment of Cavah v, will remain at ,,e 1,i,s the 7lh that point during the winte**, or, if author- ' ,l *' that i'v is given him.' will camp near the boon- \ i'v is de i-'y j da v j da v J'ne and Co it' 1 !! all the Sioux that rs he
House members debate army appropriations and troop reductions, with one congressman arguing that if reinforcements had been sent in time, the Custer massacre would have been avoided. Other members disagree over proper troop levels, citing border troubles with Mexico and conflicts with Chief Joseph.
National Republican (Washington City) · 9 November 1877 · page 2
Ihu trnnrui elections had bten seut to the assistance of thnoc engaged against the Indians, the Custer massacre would have been avoided and he would havo been u living man to day. At-' WMr. H(M)1KR moved thai the cum
During a congressional debate on army appropriations and troop deployment, Representative Singleton argues that if southern troops had instead been stationed on the Indian frontier, the Custer massacre would never have occurred. The remark is a passing rhetorical reference within a broader dispute about military strength and border security with Mexico.
Worcester Daily Spy · 9 November 1877 · page 1
in the south had been ou the Indian frontier the Custer massacre never would have occurred. Mr. Frye asked Mr. Singleton whether he objected to having troops stationed in the south. Mr. Singletou replied he did not, but that lie did object to their being used for political pur
During a House debate on army appropriations, a congressman argued for maintaining troop levels given ongoing frontier conflicts, noting that Sitting Bull had retired from the country and that Chief Joseph had been captured by General Miles. The debate focused on budget allocations and troop deployment to the Texas frontier and Indian territories.
Worcester Daily Spy · 9 November 1877 · page 1
tbe army’ now? Joseph bad captured Gen. Howard and Gen. Miles bad captured Joseph. Sitting Bull had retired from the country, and there was now no use for an army of over 15,- 000. It should never be used to overawe the laboring men, for the people of that class would never be conquered by force, while the Ameri can people would always bo ou the side of the laboring men. Mr. Sparks of Illinois said the session had been called for tbe purpose of passing the just dues of the army, and the bills should therefore be promptly passed. Without action, the committee rose, and the house at^.2o adjourned.
House members debate the size of the cavalry and army appropriations bill, referencing troop levels during the campaigns against Chief Joseph and Sitting Bull. Discussion includes disputes over party responsibility for prior bill failures and proposed troop caps for future appropriations.
The Portland Daily Press · 9 November 1877 · page 2
After some further di-cussioc with Mr. Money Mr. Conger continued. Mr. Phillips of Kansas, said this morning the Adjutant General told him that from the best data the army stood at about 22,000. Nomi nally the army was 25,000 strong. He wished to ask the chairman of the Appropriation Com mittee if he desired to keep it down to the standard to which it had been reduced by Jo seph and Sitting Bull. When Gen. Gibbon at tacked Joseph he had six companies of men,
During debate on an army appropriations bill, a congressman argues that withdrawing troops from the South would not have caused problems, while another claims the Custer massacre resulted from troops being tied up in the South. The exchange is part of a broader partisan dispute over army size and the use of troops against labor riots.
The Portland Daily Press · 9 November 1877 · page 2
party. Mr. Foster—Endorsing the President. Mr. Singleton said if they endorsed the Presi dent they endorsed the Democratic party too. He thought it the troops had not been kept ia the South the Custer massacre would not have occurred.
A five-man party led by D.K. Snively spent over five months exploring the Big Horn mountains and tributaries of the Tongue and Little Horn rivers, finding no promising gold deposits. They encountered distant Sioux Indians, recovered a horse once captured by Sitting Bull, and found relics including old cabins and drainage ditches before crossing the swollen Big Horn river on a makeshift raft.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 9 November 1877 · page 2
THE PERILS OF THE BIG HORN.
•hots with them, the distance being too great. They found a large number of relics of the same character aa have been found in Law rence county, old pumps, drain ditches and a deserted cabin or two. The party found a beautiful American horse which had been captured by Sitting Bull and had afterwards gotten away. This animal, when taken by them into Ft. Custer, turned (Jut to be bet
During House debate on army appropriations in November 1877, Representative Singleton argues that if southern troops had been stationed on the Indian frontier instead, the Custer massacre would never have occurred. The exchange is part of a broader dispute over army size, with other members debating troop levels for suppressing riots versus frontier defense.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 9 November 1877 · page 1
for the remainder of the year. It is true General Sherman had remarked that if it were to be reduced to twenty thousand men it had better be disbanded. But why was that? General Sherman had been asked wheth er he thought the army should be used for the purpose of putting down riots in several of the States' and he had answered em phatically that it should be, and it was in that view that General Sherman thought the army should be increased. For himself Singleton, he wished it distinctly understood that he was opposed to a standing army for the purpose of interfering with riots in the States, at least until it should be demon strated to his mind that the State authorities were pot able to put them down.
See moreSee less
If the troops in the south bad been on the Indian frontier the Custer massacre never would
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
This report covers a House debate over army appropriations and troop strength, with members discussing whether the army should be used to suppress domestic riots. One speaker claims that if Southern troops had been stationed on the Indian frontier instead, the Custer massacre would never have occurred.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 9 November 1877 · page 1
the strike. The Committee acting on the principle that it waa to make an appropriation for the support of the army, had provided for 22,000 for four months. It was true, General Sherman had remarked that if the army were to be reduced to 20,000 it had batter be diabanded; bat why wan it? General Sherman had been s ked whether ho thought the army t should be used for the purpose of putting p down riots in the several States, and he "] had answered emphatically that it should j be; and it waa in that view that General ( lollar.
See moreSee less
Sherman thought that the army should be increased. For himself (Singleton)iie ( wished it understood that he waa opposed , to the army interfering with riota in any ( State, at least till it be demonstrated to ( him that the State authorities were not j able to put them down. If the troops in | the South had been on the Indian frontier the Custer massacre never wohld liavo . occurred. { Tho time for geueral debate having ex*
The report recounts Sitting Bull's background as a former medicine man who became war chief, detailing the Dakota people's loss of land through broken treaties since the U.S. took Minnesota territory decades earlier. It also explains the origin of his name and notes he was born around 1829 in Canadian territory, contrasting with an account from the New York Herald.
Der Wanderer · 10 November 1877 · page 3
Näheres über Sitting Bull theilt die Amerika in folgendem Artikel i sitting Bull war ein „Medizinman" ehe er als Krirgsdäuptling an dieSpitze der vereinigten Siour trat. Die Ver
This German-language article gives a biographical sketch of Sitting Bull, describing his origins, his rise as a Lakota leader, and his role in breaking the 1868 treaty blamed on Custer. It recounts his victory at Little Bighorn on June 25, 1876, his subsequent flight with followers into Canada, and his defiant refusal to negotiate with General Terry's commission.
Der Wanderer · 10 November 1877 · page 3
Siting Bull aber zog mit seinen tausend Reitern unverfolgt über die ka nadische Grenze. Am Fuße der mit Pappeln und Aborn bewachsenen Hüael, die man ge wöbnlich als Wood Mountains be zeichnet, an den Quellen des Big Mud dy Creek, nur zehn Meilen von der amerikanischen Grenzlinie, hat er seit dem ruhig gelagert. Priester wie der Abt Martin wann ibm auch dort immer willkommen. Denn er wußte, daß sie ihm noch nie einen verräterischen oder selbstsüchtigen Rath ertheilt. Als aber General Terry sich melden ließ, wollte ?r ihn zuerst gar nicht sehen.
See moreSee less
Hernach richtete er Alles darauf ein, ihn recht empfindlich zu de müthigen. Sitting Bull ist 5 Fuß 8 Zoll hoch, breitschultrig und von punlter Gesichts farbe. Sein Gewicht schätzt man auf 170 Pfund. Seine glänzend schwar zen Augen verrathen Energie und List. Seine Kleidung ist einfach, doch bei feierlicher Gelegenheit malerisch. Eine federgeschmückte Mütze von Fuchspelz. Ein schwarzes Gewand mit weißen Flecken. Eine breite blaue Wolldecke und reichgeschmückte Mocassins. Wir wollen die Insulte bier nicht wiederholen, die der erbitterte Flücht ling der amerikanischen Commission ins Gesicht schleuderte. Daß er ihr Aner bieten. einen neuen „Vertrag" abzu schließen, zurückwies, war sicherlich das Vernünftigste, was er thun konnte. Es ist lächerlich von ihm die Anzette lung eines „neuen allgemeinen India nerkrieges" zu fürchten. Denn hätte der Dakotachef Etwas der Art im Sinne, er hätte sicher den armen Jo sevh befreit, der nur 60 Meilen von ihm vier Tage lang in der Falle saß. Sitting Bull wünscht, wie er dieser Tage selber erklärt hat, in Canada das auszuüben, was man ibm in den Ver. Staaten verweigert hat auf eigenen Iagcgrünven mit feinem Volke' nach der Art der Väter zu Kausen. Major Walsh wird ihn sicherlich nicht daran hindern. Und das Ver hältniß zwischen den kanadischen Be Hörden und den Dakotas wird auch kein so gar schwieriges sein. Einmal weil die britischen Beamten alle India ner gerechter zu behandeln gewohnt sind. Und dann weil kein Stamm der Siour von den Autoritäten der .Gro ßen Muttci" jemals seines Landes be raubt oder darum betrogen ist.
A Minneapolis man returning from work on new military posts near the Little Bighorn describes visiting the Custer massacre site and reconstructs how the battle unfolded. He also recounts a provisioning dispute among civilian workers that was resolved by the commanding officer.
The Weekly Kansas Chief · 15 November 1877 · page 1
BLEACHING BONES
Bf.EACIII.SO HONEM. Miebraiag Picture at the Mrrae ( Ike Caster 31 assacre What a .UlaarapolU .Tfaa Hnrr a tbe Battle. fieta. Mr. Frank M. Fleming, of Miueapnlis, who left here last Spring, to assist in building oue of the new military posts ou the Yellowstone River, returned homo a fewdays siuce, bringing some very interesting particulars in regard to the work of construction, and tbe result of bis ob servations at the scene of tbe Custer massacre, on the Rosebud. The post upou which Mr. Fleming was em ployed during the Summer, is located at the mouth of the Little liig Horn, which is some eighteen miles from the spot where Custer and his gallant comrades met their terrible fate. Up
During House debate on army appropriations in late 1877, members argued over troop strength, with one congressman claiming the Custer massacre could have been prevented had Southern troops been stationed on the Indian frontier instead. The debate covered broader issues of army size, border patrol with Mexico, and using troops to suppress domestic riots.
The Stark County Democrat · 15 November 1877 · page 2
mainder of the year, it was true. Gen. Sherman bad said if the army was to be reduced to 20,000, it had better be dis banded, but why was it? Gen. Sherman had been asked whether he thought the army should be used for putting down riots in the several States, and he answer ed emphatically that it should be, and it waB for that reason Gen. Sherman thought the army should be increased for him self. Mr. Singleton lie wished it under stood he was opposed to the army for in terfering wnh riots 111 a State, at leant un til it should be demonstrated to Iris mind that the State authorities were unable to put them down.
See moreSee less
If the troops in the South bad been on the Indian frontier the Custer massacre never would have occurred. The time for general debate having exi pired, the clerk proceeded to read the bill by sections.
The passage reports House debate over funding and sizing the U.S. Army, including disputes over troop counts and Texas frontier deployments. It notes that Sitting Bull had retired from the country and Joseph's campaign had concluded, implying reduced need for a large army.
The Stark County Democrat · 15 November 1877 · page 2
Mr. Crittenden was unwilling to vote one dollar till he knew how.many men were in the army, and no one seemed to have that knowledge. What was the condition of the army now? Joseph had captuied Gen. Howard, and Gen. Milec had captured Joseph. Sitting Bull had retired from the country, and there was no use for an army of over 15,000. It should never be used to overawe labor ing men, for that class would never be conquered by force, while the American people would always be on the sidn of laboring men. Mr. Sparks said the session had been called for the purpose of passing just dues of the army, and the bill should there fore be promptly passed. Without action the committee arose and the House adjourned.
A letter from the Little Bighorn battlefield reports that soldiers' graves are in good condition, noting that Colonel Brackett's force reburied a few exposed skulls and bones found in September. The writer insists it is false to claim the dead lie unburied and bleaching in the sun, asserting proper burial had been maintained.
The Somerset Press · 15 November 1877 · page 1
A recent letter from the Custer battle-ground on the Little Big Horn River states that the graves of those who fell in the battle are now in good condition.
Col. Corbin of the Sitting Bull Commission relays Sitting Bull's description of the Little Bighorn fight, given during a parting conversation as the commission departed. Sitting Bull called it a fair fight rather than a massacre, describing Custer's charge, the Indians' encirclement after rallying, and Custer's refusal to surrender until his men were killed.
The Daily Intelligencer · 15 November 1877 · page 2
KANTERM STATES NEW YORK, NOV. 14—The limey Washington special says: Col. Corbin, of the Sitting Bull Commission, has re turned to Washington. The rest of the Commission will reach here on Monday next, when they will commence prep arations for their report. Corbin com municates come interesting facts in con nection with Sitticg Bull He says the Commission bad a number of pri vate interviews with Sitting Bull, acd found him to be very agreeable in his manner and a very intelligent Indian. When the Commission started on their return trip, Sitting Bull accompani.
See moreSee less
d them for a number of miles conversing freely about the business el the Com mission and of the Custer campaign. Sitting Bull repudiated the idea that Custer and his men were massacred, . and says it was a fair fight, in which the desperation of Custer aud the men under his command made it ueceasary for the Indians to kill them. He says that Custer charged upon his camp with great impetuosity, creating tem porary panic among the Indians. They soon rallied, and outnumbering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to sur round him. He says Custer and his men refused to surrender, and fought until the last man was killed. He ex pressed great admiration for Custer's bravery and that of the men who were with him, and was sorry that his re fusal to surrender made it necessary to put him to death. W hen the Indians discovered Major Reno, who command en the second division of Custer's force, they supposed it was the entire force under command of General Terry and immediately made preparations for retreat, sending their women and children forward. When Reno made his attaek the Indians began to retreat, and Sitting Bull says had Reno followed them up at that time, be might have captured the larger part of their train. Keno, however, discovering the In dians were in such force and ascertain ing the fate of Custer, fell back to the place where he entrenched himself aud from whicn be was relieved.
A reporter describes a tense interview with Sitting Bull at a Canadian fort, mediated by Major Walsh amid Sioux suspicion of treachery. Sitting Bull denies being a chief, calling himself merely 'a man,' and the account notes his influence was due to force of intellect rather than battle command, correcting the belief he directed the fight where Custer fell.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 3
"Banoe!" laid ino chief, holding out hti hand again and proaatng mine. Major Walab bar# said:?"Sitting Ball la In Iba bait mood now that 70a could possibly wish. Proceed with /oar questions and maka them aa logical as 70a can. I will aaaiat 70a and trip 70a op oecaaionall7 If 700 arc likely to Irritate him." Than the dialogue went on. I giro tt literally, "i an >0 eairr." "Yon arc a great chief," uid 1 to Sitting Bull, "but
A reporter interviews Sitting Bull, who has taken refuge in Canada after fleeing the Americans, asking him about his status among his people and his feelings toward the United States. Sitting Bull describes himself as neither chief nor soldier, explains his influence as based on being poor rather than rich, and expresses distrust of Americans while saying he wants peace.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 3
Sitting Bull's lipa curled with a proud smil* "Ob, 1 used to be a kind of a chief; but tbo Amerh cans made me go away lrom my father'* bunting ground." "You do not lore the Americans T" You should have seen this savage's lips. "I saw to-day that all the warriors around you clapped their bands and cried ont when you spokai What you said appeared to pleas* them. They liked you. They teemed to think that what you said waa right for them to say. If you are not a groat chief, why do tbcso men think so much of you?" At this Sitting Bull, wbo bad In the meantime been
In this later interview, Sitting Bull describes Custer's soldiers as exhausted and staggering when they dismounted, yet brave and quick to fight. He recounts the crossing of warriors, the exchange of fire, and admits he personally left before the battle's climax, hearing the rest only from his warriors.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 4
AS GOOD MEN AS EVER FOUGHT
AS OOOU MKS AS KVKK SOUGHT. "Your people," said Sitting Bull, extending bis right band, "were killed. I tell no lies about dead men. These men who came with too Long hair were
An Indian eyewitness describes the soldiers' orderly retreat and successive defensive stands, insisting there were no cowards on either side. This is paired with a detailed topographical reconstruction of Custer's line of retreat, mapping where Calhoun's, Keogh's, Yates', and Smith's companies fell before the final annihilation.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 4
HOW CUSTER WAS SURROUNDED
NO cow Alton OH KITUKit BIDS. "Tbey kept in pretty good order. Bomo groat chief must bavo commanded them all the while. Tbey would lull back across a coulie aud niako u Irusb staud beyond on higher ground. The map is pretty nearly right. It shows whore tbe while men slopped uud lought botoro thoy wore all killed. 1 tuink thut is right?down there to the loft, just above tbo Little Ilig Horn. There was ono party driven out thoro, away lrom tbo rest, and there a great many men wore killed.
See moreSee less
Tbo places marked on the map uro pretty nearly the places where all wore killed." "Did tbe Whole command keep ou Ugbtiug until tbo lust ? ' hvery man, so far as my people could see. There were no cowurde on either side." Cowards 1 Oao would think not. Tbo best testi mony rfom ono who has examined tbe baltio Held and tbe lino ol Custer's retreat la as follows: ? Lrom this point (tbe north bank ol tbo Llttlo Big Horn, whero Custer was force,I back by overpowering
A correspondent, aided by Major Walsh, interviews Sitting Bull more than a year after Little Bighorn about the battle's duration and Custer's final moments. Sitting Bull describes Custer as dismounted, the last to fall, firing a pistol and laughing before dying amid his men.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 4
Whero Ibis "ne terminates, near tbe river, are found the dead tneu and horses of Cap.ain Custer's company, commingled with Smith's, and tbo situation of tbo doad indicates that somo desperate atiompt was mado to make a stand near the river or to galu tbo woods, jit* ma i ion or tub no nr. 1 Inquired ol Bitting Bull ?"How long did tills big fight continue ?" "fno sun was there," he answered, pointing to within two hours from tbo western horizon. "You cannot certainly depend,'' here observed Ma J<W Walsh, "upou Sitting Hull's or any other Indian's statement In regard to tiuie or numbers Hut bis an swer, indeed all nis answers, exactly correspond with Mm replies to similar questions ol my own.
See moreSee less
H you | will proceed you will obtain from btm In a few mo rn aut* some importaut testimony.'* 1 went on to Interrogate Sitting Bull:? "Tbis Die light, then, extended through three hours?" "Through most of tbe going lorward of the suo." "Where wus the l*ong Hair tbe most ot the time?" "I Dave tulked with my people; 1 cannot Unit one Sitting Bull describes who saw the Long flair uutll just beloro he died. He did not wear his long hair as he used to wear It. His hair was line yours," said Silling Bull, playfully louchiug my forehead with his taper Sogers. -'It was short, hut It was ortho color el tbe grase when the frost comes." "Did yon hear from your people how be died? Old be die on horseback ?" "No. None of them died on horseback.'' "All were dismounted?** "Yes." "And Custer, tbe Long Hair?" and tts denizens forbear. Tits LAST TO Dl& "Well, I have understood that there were a great many brave men In that fight, and that from time to time, while It was going on, they were shot down like pigs. They could not help themselves. One by one cana He answered:? "1 do not want any flghh" ' tne officers fell I believe the Long Hair rode across once from this place down bere (meaning tbe place "You mean not now?" where Tom Cusier'e and Smith's companies were He laughed quite heartily. killed) to this place up bere (indicating the spot on tbe "No; not this winter." mup where Custer foil), but 1 am not sure about this. Any way It was said that up there whore tbe last light "You will seo." took place, wbero tbe last stand was made, the Long "When?" Hair stood like a sheaf of corn with all tbe ears fallen ?'1 cue not say." around him." "Not wounded?" at your campf" "No." "How many stood by btm?" ting Bull respondod:? "A lew. '* "When did be fall ?" "lie killed a man when be felL lis laughed." "You mean he cried out." "No, he laughed; ho bad fired bis lest Shot." "Krom a carbine?" "No, a pistol." "Did be stand up after bs first fell ?" and I bade him adiau. "He rose up on his bands and tried another shot, but his pistol would not go olT." "Was any one olse standing up when he fell down ?" "One mau was kneeling-, that was all. Hut ne died before the Long Hair. All this was far up on tbe bluffs, far away Iroiu the Sioux encampments. I did not see it, it is told to me. But It is truo."
A correspondent, aided by Major Walsh of the Canadian police, obtains an exclusive nighttime interview with Sitting Bull describing the fight in which all the white soldiers died. The report lavishes attention on Sitting Bull's appearance and the dramatic setting of the interview, presenting it as finally piercing the mystery surrounding the battle.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 6
C....r .?' V""k About tk? Kooobud Battl*. One of tlie most wildly thrilling and darkly picturesque narratives which it ever fell to a newspaper to publish appears in our columns this morning. It would be difficult to find either in history or fiction anything more romantically tragic m i s substance or more graphically vivid in ie mode of presentation than.the long; ?nd deeply interesting letter from tort a si Which occupies so much of our space, lhe time which lias elapsed since the fall of Custer and his command without a single survivor to tell the tale will soften the im pression made by a recital which is painful now and would have been torturing while the events were fresh.
See moreSee less
\ mere interview with Sitting Bull, even though it had related to subjects which do not so touch public sensibilities to the quick, would have had a curious interest when done by a competent luind. Tins singular and surprising son of the wilder ness, whose deeds have long been a terror, though his person was hardly known, ik a wonderful specimen of Indian character. If this interview had contained nothing beyond the life-like piece of portraiture with which it opens, followed by a col loquy on comparatively indifferent topics, it would have been worth the pains it has cost to get it. But besides lifting the cur tain on the appearance, dress, bearing, lan guage and personal eccentricities of this swarthy and most remarkable individual it lifts the other and thicker curtain which has hitherto concealed one of the darkest and most wildly thrilling tragedies in the whole history of Indian warfaro. The impenetra ble veil 1 of mystery which has so long hung like a pall over that terrible and fatal afternoon on the Itosebud when every white man perished has at length been penetrated. The most competent of all witnesses on the Indian side, Sitting Bull himself, tells the whole bloody story with miuute particularity. He tells it under such circumstances and amid such surroundings that if the most skilful dramatist had known all tho facts he could not have put this awful tragedy on the stage with more impressive effect. Our correspondent was indebted to Major Walsh, of the Canadian army, whose mar vellous tact has given him a great ascendancy over the Indians, for the opportunity of this picturesque interview with Sitting Bull. It took place alter nightfall of the same day on which the confer ence was held with our commissioners, when their mission was treated with so much indignant contumely by the derisive savages. The representations made by Major Walsh prevailed on Sitting Bull to consent to tho proposed talk, and he was conducted by that officer to the quarters which had been assigned to our correspond ent. No other persons were present except the interpreters and a stenographer em ployed by the representative of the IIkbaltx The portrait of Sitting Bull as he appeared by lamplight on that evening is sketched with a distinctness which almost enables us to Bee bim, a few descriptive touches bringing out, in it* and u? bleness, a picture as faithful as a photo graph, but with more life than a photograph over attains. The "eyes which gleamed like black diamonds," tho "jaw like a bull dog's," the sotting of the remarkable fea
A reporter recounts an atmospheric interview with Sitting Bull, describing his looks and manner before relating his account of the Little Bighorn fight. The piece explains how Sitting Bull misunderstood Custer's two-pronged attack plan, mistakenly believing Reno's retreating force was merely a small observation party left by Custer, which helps explain the completeness of Custer's defeat.
The New York Herald · 16 November 1877 · page 6
dog's," the sotting of the remarkable fea tures'in "the long black hair which hung far down his back, athwart his cheeks and in front of his shoulders," with the pictu resque decorations of his costume, and the native prido and ease of his manners, make an impression that cannot easily be forgotten. The far stretching wilderness which sur rounded the camp, the overhanging dark ness of night, the fresh memory of that day's abortivo conference, and the more fearful and mysterious memories going back to that fearful massacre on the Rose bud, of which Sitting Bull was the ruling spirit and whose history ho was about to relate, invested this occasion with every accessory which could contribute to heighten the interest of a narrative which makes us forgot these weird surroundings in the thrilling interest of the facts.
See moreSee less
Although the greater part of tho interview is a mere literal transcript of the questions and an swers which passed between our correspond ent and Sitting Bull it has all tho liveli ness of rapid dramatic dialogue. But such is the deep interest of tho story itself that readers will hardly think of tho manner of telling. This first description of Custer's fight on the ltosebud ministers to quite a different feeling lrom mere historical curiosity re specting a memorable event It will excite indignation that the heroic Custer and his men should have needlessly perished by a wholesale savage butchery, because he was not properly supported by lteno. A curious mistukc made by Sitting Bull both authen ticates the chief portions of his narrative and explains why the masHacre of Custer's men was so complete. Sitting Bull's error grow out of his ignorance of Custer's plan of buttle. Custer's plan was to attack the Indian camp simultane ously on two sides and thereby fill it with confusion and terror. In point of lact lteno attuclced first and wus driven back, and Custer's attuck followed after an inter val. Nothing could bo more naturul than that Sitting Bull, who knew nothing of the plan, should have misinterpreted these suc cessive attucks. He did not himself see the commander of either, und as timo enough elapsed between the two nssaults on his camp for the forco which had been employed in the first to be marched uround to the side whenco ho received the second he sup posed this hud actually been done, and that both movements wore led by Custer him self. He accordingly imagined that ltcno's coinmund, which had retreated to the heights, were on insignificunt handful left there by Custer for purposes of observation, and thought it safe to withdraw all his warriors from that side and conoentrate them uguinst Custer. On the side towurd Reno there were lolt only the squaws, chil dren and'superannuated old men of the camp, and if these had boon attacked a part of the Hioux warriors who were over whelming Custer with immense superiority of numbers would have been detached for the defence of the squaws, and the fate of the buttle might have been different. It is C....r .?' V""k About tk? Kooobud Battl*. One of tlie most wildly thrilling and darkly picturesque narratives which it ever fell to a newspaper to publish appears in our columns this morning. It would be difficult to find either in history or fiction anything more romantically tragic m i s substance or more graphically vivid in ie mode of presentation than.the long; ?nd deeply interesting letter from tort a si Which occupies so much of our space, lhe time which lias elapsed since the fall of Custer and his command without a single survivor to tell the tale will soften the im pression made by a recital which is painful now and would have been torturing while the events were fresh. \ mere interview with Sitting Bull, even though it had related to subjects which do not so touch public sensibilities to the quick, would have had a curious interest when done by a competent luind. Tins singular and surprising son of the wilder ness, whose deeds have long been a terror, though his person was hardly known, ik a wonderful specimen of Indian character. If this interview had contained nothing beyond the life-like piece of portraiture with which it opens, followed by a col loquy on comparatively indifferent topics, it would have been worth the pains it has cost to get it. But besides lifting the cur tain on the appearance, dress, bearing, lan guage and personal eccentricities of this swarthy and most remarkable individual it lifts the other and thicker curtain which has hitherto concealed one of the darkest and most wildly thrilling tragedies in the whole history of Indian warfaro. The impenetra ble veil 1 of mystery which has so long hung like a pall over that terrible and fatal afternoon on the Itosebud when every white man perished has at length been penetrated. The most competent of all witnesses on the Indian side, Sitting Bull himself, tells the whole bloody story with miuute particularity. He tells it under such circumstances and amid such surroundings that if the most skilful dramatist had known all tho facts he could not have put this awful tragedy on the stage with more impressive effect. Our correspondent was indebted to Major Walsh, of the Canadian army, whose mar vellous tact has given him a great ascendancy over the Indians, for the opportunity of this picturesque interview with Sitting Bull. It took place alter nightfall of the same day on which the confer ence was held with our commissioners, when their mission was treated with so much indignant contumely by the derisive savages. The representations made by Major Walsh prevailed on Sitting Bull to consent to tho proposed talk, and he was conducted by that officer to the quarters which had been assigned to our correspond ent. No other persons were present except the interpreters and a stenographer em ployed by the representative of the IIkbaltx The portrait of Sitting Bull as he appeared by lamplight on that evening is sketched with a distinctness which almost enables us to Bee bim, a few descriptive touches bringing out, in it* and u? bleness, a picture as faithful as a photo graph, but with more life than a photograph over attains. The "eyes which gleamed like black diamonds," tho "jaw like a bull dog's," the sotting of the remarkable fea
The New York Herald publishes an interview with Sitting Bull describing the battle, in which he says soldiers trembled and that Custer died heroically. The Herald interprets his confused account as proof Custer was let down by Reno's failure to support him.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cincinnati Daily Star · 16 November 1877 · page 1
THE FIGHT ON THE ROSEBUD.
New York, Nov. 16. The Herald this morning publishes nearly a page aud a halt iettcr irom a correspondent who inai view80 Sitting Bull, The Indian said be wag no cbiet. He gave a graphic description of tho Rose. bud fight, saying that bullets there were like humming bees, ana that soldiers shook like aspen leave. (t?n, Custer is nobly vindicated. Sitting Bull said i bat he died like a bero. The Herald in commenting on tbe narrative says thai this first description of Custei's fight on the Bosebud ministers to quite a different feeling than mere historical curiosity, respecting the memora ble event.
See moreSee less
It will excite indignation that tbe heroic Custer and bis men should nave needlessly perished by wholesale nutohery because he wits not properly supported by Reno. The curious mis take made by Bitting Bull both authen ticates the chief portion ol his narrative, and explains why tbe maseaore ol Cut ter's men was so complete. Sitting Bull's error grew cat oi n:s iguorauoe of Custei's plan of battle. Custei's plan was to attack tbe Indian camp simultaneously ou two sides, and tneiooy fill It wMi contusion and terror. Iu point ot fact, R no attuoked first and was driven bacu, and Custei's attack lollowed after an iuterval. Nothing oould be more natural than that siting Bull, who knew nothing ol the plan, should misinterpret t'icse successive attacks. He did not himself see the commander of either, and as time enough elapsed between tbe two assaults on his camp, for the force which had bean employe. i in the first no have marched around to tue side whence he received the seoond altaok, he supposed this had aoilfully teen done and that both movements were led by tbe same party. He accord 8"JS'J iuagiuod Beuo's comman j, vrhloh DAILY
This report uses Sitting Bull's account to explain Custer's original battle plan of a coordinated two-sided attack on the Indian camp, and argues that the timing gap between Reno's and Custer's assaults let Sitting Bull mistake them for one force, allowing him to concentrate all warriors against Custer. It also criticizes Reno for failing to attack when he could have divided the Sioux forces and possibly saved Custer's command.
The Cincinnati Daily Star · 16 November 1877 · page 1
FRIDAY EVENING. had retreated to the heights, were an lnslgnitloant handful left there by Cus ter for lue purpose of obsetv.itton, and thought it safe to withdraw all his war riors Irom that side and conoentrate them against Custer. On the side to wards Iteno there were leit only the squaws, children and superannuated old men of the camp, aud li these had been attaoked part of the Slouz warriors who were overwhelming Custer with im mense superiority of numbers, would have been detaohed for the defense oi the squaws, and the tat of the battle might have been dill .rein.
See moreSee less
It Is plain irom Sitting Bull's aocouut that Bono re mained perohed upon bis heights In mor tal dread of a lot of squaws and old men at a crlnoal time, wheu a vigorous at tack would have divided the warriors and would have given Custer and his men a chance (or their lives even if it bad not resulted In a defeat of tbe In dians, Chanty would suggest In behalf ofReuothat he kuew nothing of Cut ter's engugemeut, but this exouse will not hold if Sitting Bull tells the truth. He says that the noise of the firing was distinctly heard by the oolluctiou oi squaws who were confronting lleuo, and must have been heard by Bene himself. It this was so At offioer seems unexuusabie even if be had been confronted by warriors instead of squaws aud old men. Hu ought to have attacked with the utmost dash and vigor, thereby creating a di vision lor the relief ol Custer. The plan which Cutter had made tor the Rosebud was like thai which he always adopted In bis Indian lights, lie never hesitated before superior number, but always di vided his lorces aud oairied oouiusiou into the forces of the savages.
More than a year after the battle, a New York correspondent publishes an interview in which Sitting Bull narrates how Custer's exhausted soldiers were overwhelmed by Lakota and Cheyenne warriors armed with repeating rifles. He describes the chaos of the fight, the soldiers' fatigue, and praises the bravery of Custer's men while recounting the Indians' eventual victory.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 16 November 1877 · page 1
Congressional Proceedings and Other Intelligence. THE CUSTER MASSACRE. Setting Bull Tells the Story of the Deadly Encounter* Now York, Nov. 16.—Setting Bull lian been talking with a correspondent, and tell ing the story of the Custer massacre. He
This report recounts an interview-style narrative describing Custer's ('Long Hair') last stand, including vivid details of his death by pistol after being surrounded. It also references Sitting Bull's claim that only non-combatants held Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
Daily Press and Dakotaian · 16 November 1877 · page 1
Custer. CONGRESSIONAL. SENATE. Washington, Nov. 16.—After the morn ing hour, Mr. Davis of West Virginia, called up hie resolution providing for a committee to inquire into the discrepancies
More than a year after the battle, a correspondent publishes an interview with Sitting Bull describing the fighting at Little Bighorn in vivid, dramatic language. He recounts exhausted soldiers staggering off their horses, the use of repeating rifles against the army's needle guns, and the gradual destruction of Custer's command.
Public Ledger · 16 November 1877 · page 2
CUSTER. A Graphic Account of his Last Fight Told in Sitting Bull's Own Words. Reno Kept at Bay by Squaws, Men and Children.
Some of them staggered aodertbe weight of their guns, but they began to fight at once; but by this time our camps were aroused and there were plenty of war riors to meet them. They fired with needle guns; we replied with magazine guns repeating rifles." Sitting Bull
An interview recounts Sitting Bull's description of the final moments of Custer's command, describing soldiers falling back in stages until Custer ('Long Hair') made his last stand and died laughing after firing his last shot. The account also claims only women, old men, and children held Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
Public Ledger · 16 November 1877 · page 2
Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff and preventing him giving aid to Caster.
A commission visiting Sitting Bull's camp reportedly found a white prisoner, Corporal Martin Ryan of the 7th Cavalry, said to have survived the Little Bighorn battle and been adopted by Sitting Bull as a war chief and son-in-law. Muster rolls confirmed Ryan's name was on the company roster present for duty at the battle, and friendly Indians claimed other Custer soldiers might also be held captive.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Daily Gazette · 17 November 1877 · page 2
A SURVIVOR OF THE CUSTER MASSACRE BECOMES AN INDIAN CHIEF
r rom the Bolton Herald. Washington, Nov. 14.—The com mission which was sent to Sitting Bull made an important discovery in the fact that the warrior has in his the camp a white prisonea captured at the Custer massacre. Before reaching Fort alsh rumor a reached the com mission that Sitting Bull held some of Custer's men as prisoners, and after the first conference ODe of the half breed interpreters employed by Gen. Terry visited the camp, and while passing through, was accosted in Eng. lish by a person dressed and painted as a chief who said that his namo was as Martin Kyan, who was a corporal in Company 1.
See moreSee less
Seventh Cavalry, Col. KeougL's company, and been taken a prisoner at the battle of the Little a Big Horn with Custer. Inquiry ap parently substantiated his assertion and the following facts were asoer tained; Ryan's life had been spared ed by Sitting Bull himself who adopt ed him into his own family. Ryan made several attempts to escape, and but being carefully guarded was un successful, and on each occasion he was severely beaten. He has now ap parently accepted the situation, and bitting Ball has made him a war chief and married Ryan to one of his own daughters. Ryan has let hia hair grow long in Indian fashion, dresses as an lndiaD, and is known by the Sioux as the White Chief. Upon the return of the commission to ht. Paul, Gen. Terry caused the muster to rolls of Company I, Seventy Cavalry, to be examined, and found that Martin Ry an's name is borne as corporal, and that he was -present for duty when his com mand want into that fatal action of June ■J~i, 1876. It was stated by the friendly Indians that there are several others of Custer's men prisoners in Sitting Bull's camp, hut Ryan's case was the only one a which was verified. Sitting Bull was asked the question direct by Gen. Cor bin if he took any prisoners ol the Sev be enth Cavalry, and answered fiatly : It is none of your business." Sitting Bull talked considerably about the battle with to Custer, and ail he said fully confirms the of conclusions arrived at by General Terry last year when he examined the ground just after the battle. He said that at first he thought General Terry's whole army was upon him, and he had moved the his women and children and property the about four miles in retreat, when he re ceived information from his scouts that tbe it was only the Seventh Cavalry aud Long Hair (Custer), and that they were divided, and Reno had already retreated. He says he then took 4,000 warriors and res went hack and moved down on Custer iu a solid mass, and ended tiie fight right va there. He says that Loug Hair was one Mr of the very last down, and that the In ,: dians shouted and made signs to him to to surrender, but he would not, and about tiie very last of the fight he was killed. a He said that if he had captured Custer he would not have hurt him, but have kept nim in his camp. He was asked how many men he lost, but he refused to to tell the number. After a few moments, time however, he said that he lost a great ad many warriors; indeed, two for every He man that Long Hair had. In regard to He to Coiporal Ryan's case, General Terry has written a letter to the State Department through Secretary McCrary, detailing the the "old
The report revisits allegations that Major Reno withdrew his forces to safety while Custer's command was annihilated, citing a New York Herald interview with Sitting Bull as new corroborating testimony. It claims the Indians believed Reno's retreat emboldened them to attack Custer more fiercely, and criticizes the army for not investigating further given Reno's lenient treatment after a separate court-martial.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New York Herald · 17 November 1877 · page 6
Major Reno had so completely withdrawn from the fight before Custer even got into it that tho Indiaus thought thero was only one column, which had withdrawn from a first point only to advance at another. It wu8 under tho sense of encouragement given them by Reno's flight thut tho In dians assuiled Custer's command with such unusual vigor, and having destroyed it they would have destroyed Reno's also with equal thoroughness but for Terry's arrival. This new light on tho battle, confirming so absolutely what was before thought, will give now occasionfor regret that Major Reno is still an officer of the army, under a too lenient remission of his sentence for another offence.
The report describes how the Battle of Little Bighorn was long shrouded in mystery since no soldiers survived to tell what happened to Custer's force. It recounts that a scout's earlier secondhand account of the battle, obtained from a relative of Sitting Bull, has now been corroborated by Sitting Bull himself, who describes Custer's divided attack plan and suggests Reno could have saved Custer's men had he renewed his assault.
New-York Tribune · 17 November 1877 · page 5
marched, not knowing whither; bat it he were to give sich an order now, the regiments would break up like debating-elubs, when the division-beil rings. Every reginent bas a privileged company or two of one-year vol unieers, who on the strength of having paid $300, are dealt with like pets, g°t as much leave as they like, and are seldom if ever punished. These one-year volunteers nave done more to set the ordinary private grumbling { anont the evils of the conscription than any amount of Republican propaganda could have done.
See moreSee less
If the army were polled to-morrow, nincteen-twenileths of it would vote for a three years’ tert of sevice binding npon all Frenchmen, and it 1s well known that the Republicans favor tian reform. The Repabiicans have, theretore, a distivet advantage to offer the soldier in the shape of # two years’ rem ssion of his time ; whereas the system which the Conservatives npaold mv Ives a maintennuce of the one-year volantanaie, which to the logieloving and equality-loving Feenchinan seems fraught witn inignity. Events have educated the army simu. ianeously with the nation. An artist has recently published, in a French journal, an account of his Swiss sketching tour. On a beauti®nl afternoon in June, of the present vear, he left his hotel in Interlaken, went out alone with his campstool and easel, and straved as far as the foot of the Jungfrau. As he was about to begin his sketch he was startled by seeing, a few yards in front of him, a huge hear, that growled feroeionsly. He seized asix-chambered revolver and levelled it at the beast, but before he could fire, he heard the words, “ Hait! halt!” The bear sat on his hind legs and wrung his fore-paws, “What!” cried the artist, “do bears speak English i” Then holding the revolver close to the nose of the pretended beast, he demanded, * What dost thou in this aceursed costuwue i” The rogue in the bear's skin replied tuat he was werely earning nis living. He was a driver by professiun, but the s«ason had been a very bad one and he was obliged to take another trade. He had entered into a compact with a number of guides to clothe lamse!lt in a bear's skin, * Waoich I can assure you is as hot as purgatory in such weather as this,” and plant himself in one of the favorite mountain pais. ** When one of my associales coves along this rord with a toorist, I suddenly show wyself, The foreiguer is ready to die with frist, but the coilragcous guide rushes at me and drives we away, naturally receiving a very handsome douceur for his bravery in riskiug his own life in order to preserve that of his employer.” In the evening the Hear and the goide generally wet at un inn and divided the spoil. The Dear pleaded so pitecusly thine the artist did not have the heart to have him arrested. The Battle of the Little Big Horn has been shrouded 1m darkness and mystery. When Rono's troopers were rescued by Gibbon’s infantry, they scarcely knew what bad happened to Custer’s force, and it was not itil the bluffs and ravines were visited, and the wutitated remains were found, that the horrors of the wassacre were realized. Not a man was left to tell the dreadful tale. A special correspoudent, who discovered wauy of the bodies, and Lelped to bury Custer, made a diagram of the sceue of conflier, showing where the dead lay, and this, when reproduced 1n THE TRIBUNE, was, of itself, a tolerably intelligible outline of the batue. Last Summer, another TRIBUNE correspondent conversed with a scout who had married a nicce of Sitting pull, and had recelved from him an account of Custer’s death and the massacre of his eavalrymen. This version 18 now corroborated by Sitting Bull himself, who has been talking freely with a correspoident of The Herald. Custer's plan of battle was to divide his forees and to attack the Indian encampment ou two sides, while Captain Bunteen's companies remained in the rear as a reserve. Reno attweled first, but being repulsed took refuge on a ll where he was subsequently joiued by Bunteen; and there they remalued during that teriible fternvon while Cusier and Lis men were perishing, If Sitting Bull tells the truth, Reno's first attack was merely a bight skirmish, and hs force remained percioed apon the heights and facing squaws and saperapnuated warriors, when if he Lad renewed the assault in accordance with Caster’s plan he might Lave saved the lives of his gallant comrades. Leno has stated in bis offiefal report that Le Knew nothing of Custer’'s engagewent, Siiung Bull says that the sGuaws iu front of Revo beard distinctly tue sound of tue fing. Major Reno Is uot in a position to command public sympainy. He was condemued by a cont martial lust Spring for insulting a lady, aud suspended from rank and pay for two years,
A correspondent interviews Sitting Bull, who describes the battle at Little Bighorn from the Lakota perspective, noting the exhaustion of Custer's soldiers and horses. He describes the intensity of the fighting, the use of repeating rifles by his warriors against the soldiers' needle-guns, and the gradual retreat and death of the cavalrymen.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 17 November 1877 · page 2
SITTING BULL. ills Comments on (lia Custer Massacre. Nbw Vouk, Nov. Id—tilttlug Bull has been talking with a correspondent, ami telling tbo story of “the Custer massacre." ilo says; '“Tbo fight was hell. A thousand devils—tbo
An interview-style account presents Sitting Bull recounting the death of Custer, nicknamed 'Long Hair,' in dramatic detail: standing surrounded by fallen soldiers, firing his pistol until it jammed, and allegedly laughing before he died. Sitting Bull also claims only squaws, old men, and children held off Reno's forces, preventing him from aiding Custer.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 17 November 1877 · page 2
died before the Long Hair.’’ Silting Bull says there were only squaws, old men, and little children In frout of Reno, keep* log Dim In bis strung position on tbe bluff, sad preventing him giving aid to Custer.
An interview with Sitting Bull is printed in which he gives his account of the fights with Reno and Custer. He states that after driving Reno to his entrenched hill position, the Indians moved off to finish Custer, leaving only squaws and papooses facing Reno.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 17 November 1877 · page 3
SITTING HI LL. The Fight with Iteuo mid Custer* New York, November 16. Several columns of iuteiview with Sittiug Bull are printed, iu which he gives graphic accounts of the fights with Reuo and Custer. The only new item is that after the
A year after the battle, Sitting Bull describes the fight to a reporter, calling it 'hell with a thousand devils' and recounting the exhaustion of Custer's soldiers and the ferocity of the Lakota defense. He praises the bravery of the dead soldiers while describing how warriors used repeating rifles against the army's single-shot carbines.
Memphis Daily Appeal · 17 November 1877 · page 2
SITTlKr-ISUL.I Tells All he Knows About the Custer Hassaere He Says the Fight was "Hell with a Thousand Devils." New Yokk. November 16. Sitting-Bull has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story ot the (Juster massacre. He
The New York Herald published an interview with Sitting Bull describing the Rosebud/Little Bighorn fight, with vivid imagery of bullets like humming bees and soldiers shaking like aspen leaves. The Herald's commentary uses his account to imply Reno failed to properly support Custer, explaining the completeness of the massacre.
Alexandria Gazette · 17 November 1877 · page 1
Interview with Sitting Bull.
Major Reno. The Herald commenting on the narrativo says this first description of Custer\i fight on the Rosebud ministers to quite a different feeling from mere historical curiosity respecting the memorable event. It will ex - ?? . M t i .1 . * . /I ..i . . _ | cite ao indignation mat me ccroic uuster aim hia men should have needlessly perished by tlie wholesale savage butchery becauso he was not properly supported by lleno. The curious mis take made by Sitting Bull boili authenticates
This piece uses Sitting Bull's narrative to argue that Reno misunderstood the battle and could have relieved pressure on Custer by attacking the camp's undefended side. It criticizes Reno for remaining on the heights despite hearing gunfire from Custer's engagement, suggesting his inaction contributed to the massacre.
Alexandria Gazette · 17 November 1877 · page 1
the chief portions of his narrative, and explains why the massacre of Custer's men was so complete. Sitting Bull's error grew out ol hisignorance of Custer's plan of battle. Custer's plan was to attack theladian camp simultaneously on ^ two sides, and thereby till it with oonfusioD and terror. In point of fact, lleno attacked first and was driven baok, ami Custer's attack followed after an interval.-Nothing Bull, who knew nothing of the plan,should
The article questions whether Major Reno should have heard Custer's gunfire during the battle, citing Sitting Bull's claim that squaws nearby heard it. It also explains Custer's usual tactic of splitting his force to attack from two sides, suggesting this plan failed because Reno's attack and Custer's were not simultaneous.
Alexandria Gazette · 17 November 1877 · page 1
Even if lie bad been confronted by warriors instead of squaws and old men, he ought to have attacked with tho utmost dash and vigor, thero/../I.iinn n ^ i rrrtrti rtn f nr flirt rrt'irtl nl ('liclrtr uy uicauu^ ? ui*^inv/u ?w* *w ivi?w? w. ^u.-w.. The plan which Custer had made for battle was like that which he had always adopted io his
Col. Corbin of the Sitting Bull peace commission reports that Sitting Bull described the Custer battle as a fair fight rather than a massacre, saying Custer's refusal to surrender forced the Indians to kill all his men. Sitting Bull also claimed that when Indians first saw Reno's force they mistook it for Terry's entire command and prepared to retreat before Reno attacked.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 17 November 1877 · page 1
ter Massacre. Washington, Nov. 16 —Col. Corbin, of the Sitting Bull commission, has re turned to Washington. The rest of the commission will reach here on Monday next, when they will commence pre paration for their report. Corbin communicates some interesting facts in connection with Sitting Bull which have not heretofore been published. He says the commission had a number of private interviews with Sitting Bull and found him to be very agreeable in his manners and a very intelligent In dian. When the commission started on their return trip Sitting Bull accom panied them for a number of miles con versing freely about the business of the commission and of the Custer cam paign.
See moreSee less
Sitting Bull repudiated the idea that Custer and his men were mas sacred, and Bays it was a fair fight in which the desperation of Custer and the men under his command made it necessary for the Indians to kill them. Sitting Bull says Custer charged upon his camp with great impetuosity, creat ing a temporary panic among them, but the Indians* soon rallied and outnum bering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to surround him. He says Custer and his men refused to surrender and fought until the lost man was killed. He expressed great admiration for Custer's bravery and that of the men who were with him, and was sorry that his refusal to surrender made it necessary to put him to death. When the Indians discovered Major Reno, who was commanding the second divi sion of Custer’s forces, they supposed it was the entire force under command of Terry, and immediately made pre parations for retreat, sending their women and children forward. When Reno made his attack the Indians be gan to retreat, and Sitting Bull says had Reno followed them up at that time he migiit havecaptured a larger part of their train. Reno, however, discovering the Indians were in such force and ascer taining the fate of Custer, fell back to the place at which he entrenched him self, and from which he was relieved.
Sitting Bull tells commissioners it was a fair fight, not a massacre, as Custer's men refused to surrender and were overwhelmed ten-to-one after being surrounded. He also describes how the Indians initially panicked at Custer's charge but rallied, and notes Reno's forces retreated upon discovering the Indians' strength and Custer's fate.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 17 November 1877 · page 1
I SITTING BULL. XVhat the Savage Chief Says of the Cus- ' ter Massacre. Washington, Nov. 16 —Col. Corbin, of the Sitting Bull commission, has re turned to Washington. The rest of the commission will reach here on Monday next, when they will commence pre paration for their report. Corbin communicates some interesting facts in connection with Sitting Bull which have not heretofore been published. He says the commission had a number of private interviews with Sitting Bull and found him to be very agreeable in his manners and a very intelligent In dian.
See moreSee less
When the commission started on their return trip Sitting Bull accom panied them for a number of miles con versing freely about the business of the commission and of the Custer cam paign. Sitting Bull repudiated the idea that Custer and his men were mas sacred, and Bays it was a fair fight in which the desperation of Custer and the men under his command made it necessary for the Indians to kill them. Sitting Bull says Custer charged upon his camp with great impetuosity, creat ing a temporary panic among them, but the Indians* soon rallied and outnum bering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to surround him. He says Custer and his men refused to surrender and fought until the lost man was killed. He expressed great admiration for Custer's bravery and that of the men who were with him, and was sorry that his refusal to surrender made it necessary to put him to death. When the Indians discovered Major Reno, who was commanding the second divi sion of Custer’s forces, they supposed it was the entire force under command of Terry, and immediately made pre parations for retreat, sending their women and children forward. When Reno made his attack the Indians be gan to retreat, and Sitting Bull says had Reno followed them up at that time he migiit havecaptured a larger part of their train. Reno, however, discovering the Indians were in such force and ascer taining the fate of Custer, fell back to the place at which he entrenched him self, and from which he was relieved.
A New York Herald correspondent at Fort Walsh obtains a rare night-time interview with Sitting Bull about the Little Bighorn fight. The reporter notes that Sitting Bull appears to confuse Custer with Reno, believing one officer carried out both the retreat across the river and the final doomed charge.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 18 November 1877 · page 5
SITTING BULL. His Story of the Custer Slaughter.
Correspondence Xe.it York Herald. Fort Walsh, Nonuwcat Territorry, Oct 17. Through the intercession of .Maj. Walsh, Silting Bull was persuaded to hold a special conference with me, lie agreed to come, after dark, to the quarters which had been assigned to me, on the condition that nobody should be present except himself, his interlocutor, Maj. Walsh, two inter preters. and the stenographer 1 had employed for the occasion. . , . It was at this juncture that 1 began to question the great savage before me in regard to the most disastrous, most mysterious Indian battle of the century—Custer’s encounter with the Sioux on the Big Horn—trie Thermopylae of the Plains.
See moreSee less
4< tve thought we were whipped.” The testimony of Sitting Bull, which I am about to give, is the more convincing and important from the very fact of the one erroneous impression he derived as to the identity of the officer m command of tne forces which as-ailed his camp. He con founds Keno with Custer. Ho supposes that one and the same General crossed the Little Big Horn where Heno crossed, charged as Bono charged, re treated us Reno retreated back over the river, and then pursued the line of Ouster’s march, attacked as Custer attacked, and fell as Ouster fell. “Did you know the Long-Haired Chief?” I asked Sitting Bull.
An interviewer questions Sitting Bull using a battle map, asking him to clarify the sequence of attacks at Little Bighorn. Sitting Bull explains that the first attack hit the Hunkpapa camp (Reno's crossing), and clarifies that this initial attacker was mistaken for Custer but was actually Reno, with Custer's charge coming later on the north bank.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 18 November 1877 · page 5
sun is in the centre of the sky. ” CU.-TER COMMANDED. * ■ What white Chief was it who came over there against your warriors?” “The Long Hair.” ‘•Are you surer” “The Long Hair commanded." “ lint yon din nut sec him? ” “I have said that 1 never saw him.” “Did any of the duels sec him? ” “Not here, hut there.” pointing to the place where Custer charged and was repulsed on the north bank ol the Little Big Horn. •• Why do you tlunn it was the Long Hair who crossed first and charged you here at the right side of the map?” •• A Chief leads hi?
See moreSee less
warriors.” “ Was there a good sight here, on the right side of the map? Kxplain It to me. ” “It was so.” said Sitting Bull, raising his bands. “ I was lying in my lodge. Some young
A reporter questions Sitting Bull about the Little Bighorn fight, and the chief describes attacks on the village without distinguishing Reno's assault from Custer's. The journalist notes that Sitting Bull mistakenly attributes Reno's initial attack and retreat to Custer, clarifying the actual sequence of the battle.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 18 November 1877 · page 5
“Yes, the fighting men ” MISTAKING RENO FOR CUSTER. t4 Oh, we fell ban;, ant H was not what warriors call a retreat; it was to gain time. It was the Long H.ur who jetnaUd. >'y people foughl hmi here in the brush tdesnrnating the umber behind which the Indians pressed Keuoi and to fallback across here (placing Ins linger on the line of Ken t's re treat to tin* northern bluff*).” ••Sovou think that was the Long Hair whom vour people fought in that umber and who fell back atterwuni to those heights?” •MU coarse.” •*\Vh.u afterward occurred?
See moreSee less
Was there any heavy lighting after the retreat of the soldiers to the bin:':'*-?” •• Not men; not there.” 44 Where. then'*’ 44 Why, d»»wn here;” and Sitting Dull indicated with hi>*»inner the place whore Custer apnroaimed and touched the river. ••That,'* said he, “.was where the hie tight was touch!. a little biter. Af ter the Lone Hair was driven hack l«» the hinds he took this road t tracing wuh hi.- linnet the J:ne of Custers march ».n the mao', and went dovui to pec if ho could not beat us there.” I Here the reader should pause to discern the extent of Sitting Hull’s error, and to an ticipate what will presently appear to he Keuo's misconception or mistake. bitting Hull, not identifying Kcno in the whole of this engagement, makes it seem that il war Cutter who attacked, when Heno attacked in the lir-t place, and afterward moved down to resume the :is-«ult from a new position. He thus iinol unlanlv te-lides to the fact that lleno’s assault w.® a brief.* ineffectual one before his retreat lo the biufTs. and that Keim. alter his retreat, ceased on the blulis from :n:grc?si*e lighting, j JJUI.L’.-' I)CSI.'J{IJ"J'H).N OF IT ELL.
The report cites Sitting Bull's secondhand account suggesting Major Reno's early withdrawal emboldened the Indians to destroy Custer's command with greater ferocity. It also notes Reno's prior court-martial for misconduct, implying he is unworthy of sympathy regardless of the battle's circumstances.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 18 November 1877 · page 1
ROUGH ON RENO
New York, Nov. 17.—Major Reno’s conduct in the battle which resulted in the massacre of Custer’s command is severely criticised, in view of Sitting Bull’s corroboration of the suspicions excited by stories heretofore derived from scouts and friendly Indians. The Herald says: “As soon as it became possible to construct from the excited stories of participants and witnesses a connected and logical chronicle of that bloody fight, it was seen that the conduct of Major Reno called for an ex planation. Observations were made at the time tqion the circumstance that this officer, apjioiiited to co-operate in a combined advance upon the Indian po sition, did not do his whole duty.
See moreSee less
On encountering some resistance he i**r initted himself to be very easily whip ped and withdrew his force to a com paratively safe place and saved his men, within the sound of the fire that anni hilated the force with w’hicli he was to co-oi»erate. Sitting Bull now tells his story of the battle, which implies that Major Reno had so completely with drawn from the fight before Custer even got into it, that the Indians thought there was only column, which had witdrawn from a first point only to advance at another. It was un der a sense of the encouragement given, them lofrKeno’s flight that the Indians assailed Custer’s command with such unusual vigor, and having destroyed it, they would have destroyed Reno's also, with equal thoroughness, but for Ter ry's arrival. This new light on the battle confirming so absolutely what was before thought |rill give new occa sion for regret that Major Reno is still an officer of the army under a too leni ent remission of his sentence for anoth er offence. The Tribune says: “If Sitting Bull tells the truth, Reuo’s first attack was merely a light skirmish, and his force remained perched upon the height and facing the sqaw’s and superannuated warriors, when if he had renewed the assault in accordance with Custer’s plan he might have saved the lives of his gallant comrades. Reno has stated in his official leport that he knew noth ing of Custer’s engagement. Sitting Bull says that the squaws in front of Reno heard distinctly the sound of the firing. Major Reno is not in a position to command public sympathy; he was condemned hy court martial last spring for insulting a lady, and susiteuded from rank and pay for two years.*’
A charge is made that the soldiers killed in the Custer massacre have never been properly buried and their remains are still exposed on the Plains. The report suggests that if true, the government should promptly fulfill this basic duty of humanity.
The New York Herald · 19 November 1877 · page 4
Tiie Charge Is Made that the remains of tho gallant soldiers who fell in the Custer massacre have never been properly buried and ure now
This editorial reflects on Custer's final battle at Little Bighorn as a supreme act of duty and sacrifice, comparing it to history's greatest examples of selfless valor. It notes that an Indian account, published to explain the causes of the 1876 war, provided new details of the fight and even called Custer's men 'the bravest of the brave'.
The New York Herald · 19 November 1877 · page 4
arms none are brighter, more glorious, or Calculated to inspire a more profound feelj ing of sympathy with the antors than tho last battle of Custer and his men. The grim outlines of that fatal combat have been re traced in the memory of our countrymen by the story of the Indian whoso influence with his people created tho troubles that nocessij tated the war of 1876, and who gave ourx
The article reflects on Custer's last battle at Little Bighorn, referencing an Indian account that filled in missing details of the fight and praised the soldiers' bravery. It argues that now, with the full story known, a monument should be erected to honor Custer and his men.
The New York Herald · 19 November 1877 · page 4
Little Big Horn which were wanting to com plete the history of that bloody sacrifice. | Even this bitter enemy of the paleface gives his tribute of praise to Long Hair and his men, and with tho enthusiasm of a warrior calls them "tho bravest of the brave." If possible tho followers of tho gallant Custer have won even ( a higher meed of praise than their loader. For him victory would bring wide-world renown and probably rich reward. But to tho poor troopers who drew their sabros and advancod at the word of command vic tory meant scarcely anything more than hard faro and more fighting.
See moreSee less
Yet they un hesitatingly followed Custer to tho fatul battle ground and died around him to tho last man. Now that all is known that can be re garding this baud of heroes, is it not the fitting time for something to be done toward erecting a suitable monument to their memory V "When the news of the great massacre at tho Little Big Horn was first received numbers rushed into print expressing their desire to do something to perpetuate tho memory of Custer and his men ; but after a little while this enthusiasm cooled down, to bo partially revived by the obsequies of tho Gen eral at West Point. Now is tho time to revive tho subject of a monument, to col lect the necessary funds and to erect it. In dentil Custer and his men hold equal rank, and one appropriate monument should keep tho memory of their glorious deeds green in tho souls of their countrymen.
A soldier stationed near the Little Bighorn writes to the editor protesting that the enlisted men killed in the Custer massacre remain unburied over a year later, their bodies left exposed to the elements. He notes that officers' remains were removed by Sheridan's commands, but ordinary soldiers were neglected despite orders, and blames commanders for prioritizing new fort construction over proper burial.
The New York Herald · 19 November 1877 · page 6
CUSTER'S DEAD COMRADES. A PROTEST FROM A SOLDIER AT THE NEGLECT OF THEIR SEPULTURE.
A PRO'l'JLSf X'ROM A BOLDIEII AT THE NEGLECT OF 1HE1U sEPULTUEK. Bio lioKN Post, M. T.t Get 28, 1877, To tub Editok of tub Hbkauk? I roapecilully request ihut you will be kind enougn to uiuse known to tue publio through thu columns of your paper the loliowiug lasts which have come to my nonce iu rcgurd to the grout umasacre which look place over u your ugo in this vicinity, aud whiou is known a-, the "Custer Massacre:"? 1 came to tins place iast Juuo Wilu General Bueil's command, the
Major Reno, visiting Washington, is asked about Sitting Bull's claim that he panicked and retreated after seeing a camp of old men, women, and children. Reno gives his own version: ordered to attack the village, he fought on foot and horseback for about an hour before recrossing the river and taking a defensive bluff position, where Benteen's command joined him.
the creek. WHAT KISO HATS. He aays briefly that on tba morn log of tho battlo ha aeparated from Custer with s detachment of three companies and a party ot scouts, and with no further orders irom uiin than to aiuelc the villaga In the woods on the south aide ot the Ltttlo ltlg Horn. He moved off on a trot and did aa ha waa told, bolng assured that Caster would support bim. Ceptain Benteen was also orderod out with another skirmishing party ot about oue hundred men. This was In tbe forenoon, about ten o'clock.
See moreSee less
Heat tacked the village and lougbt the Indians nltout an boar, retreating to the creek aa he (ought, ana finally reoroeaed a abort disinnco below bis first lording place Having crossed be took a position on an adjacent bluff, tho Indians following and keep ing op a continuous lusllade. Hero he waa joined by Captain Benteen, who bad followed In bts trail as far as the creek, but be aaya la hie official report, seeing upou the eppoaito aide too many Sioux te encounter with safety, ba con cluded not to cross. When Benteen arrived at the ereck Major Reno was retreating, and the two made a junction at the inlrencbtncn' Indicated on the Hrrald map which accompanies Sitting Bull's story. In this Intrencbmen t Major Reno, aa senior officer commanding both detachments, leught the Indians, losing about one hundred men In all, and held his ground until relieved fcr General Crook. CUSTKR'a FLAX or OrSRATIOKS.
Reno describes being sent with three companies to attack the village, fighting for about an hour before retreating to high ground where Benteen joined him, and the combined force held out until relieved by General Crook. He offers his hypothesis that Custer tried to ford the river to support him but was blocked by difficult terrain, ending up farther downstream before his fate became unclear.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The New York Herald · 19 November 1877 · page 10
WHAT RENO SAYS
CUSTKR'a FLAX or OrSRATIOKS. He says thai il Cuater bad any more definite plan of operation* than to send oat hie detachment and cross arer lower down to support tbe attack ho was not aware of IL He pronounces aa unqualifiedly absurd tbe etory that he was to have made a Junction at any particular point. He believes, however, that Custer Intended tally to croes the creek and come to his resuc, and that he was only prevonted from doing so by a mistake in ibe topography of the country. He has reason to thick that while ho was fighting tbe Indiana In their vlllago at thdtime of the original attack Cuator heard the firing and tried to flod a way down the steep ridge that he ?truek and effect a fordtng.
See moreSee less
This, however, Caster failed to do, but came to tbe rlvor about two and a half miles below tbo rendezvous of Reno and Benteen. Subsequent examination led Major Reno to be lieve ibis to be tbe course pursued by Custer; but why Custer should have gone on down tho creek, alter fluding bis crossing checked when ha finally made the ereek, in steal of returning In the direction of the remainder or hia command, Is a question that Reno Is nnablo lo determine. His hypothesis la that he w iehed to make tor tbe mouth Of Ibe creek, a few miles, where n ateegiboat, with General Gibbon's command aboard, was aupposed to bo; but that bo soon eaeountered more Indians, was ovsrpewered. sad lost bis own life and" tbosd of tbo 268 men In hut force. a quHrrios or Tim. Major Reno aaya alao that Cueter and all of bla men were probably dead when he Joined foroea with Cap tain Benteen on tbe north bank ol the oreek. He does not consider himself any more responsible lor the kill ing ol Caster and nia men than a man in Now York would have been. On tbe othor band, be thinks that llther tbe want of a definite plan of battle or the mis take of General Cuater placed tbe attacking detach ment In serious and to some extent unneoessary Jeopardy. Ho is grieved that certain papers should charge blut with enmity toward so bravo and gallant % man as Coster. They were personal friends, he says, and were upon tbe best of terms, having been In the Military Academy at West Point together and known each other for many years. Major Reno bos very little confidence In tbe truthful ness of Sitting Dull or any other Indian, and wants no further vindication of his character as a soldier in regard to tho Little Big Horn fight than the official re ports of Generals Sherman, Crook and Terry and the ?tatamentsof tbe survivors of tbe battle.
Major Reno speculates that Custer tried to ford the river about two and a half miles below the Reno-Benteen position, possibly heading toward a supposed steamboat rendezvous, before being overwhelmed by Indians. Reno also defends himself against accusations of enmity toward Custer and expresses confidence in official reports over Indian testimony.
The New York Herald · 19 November 1877 · page 10
CUSTER'S PLAN OF OPERATIONS
Intrencbmen t Major Reno, aa senior officer commanding both detachments, leught the Indians, losing about one hundred men In all, and held his ground until relieved fcr General Crook. CUSTKR'a FLAX or OrSRATIOKS. He says thai il Cuater bad any more definite plan of operation* than to send oat hie detachment and cross arer lower down to support tbe attack ho was not aware of IL He pronounces aa unqualifiedly absurd tbe etory that he was to have made a Junction at any particular point. He believes, however, that Custer Intended tally to croes the creek and come to his resuc, and that he was only prevonted from doing so by a mistake in ibe topography of the country.
See moreSee less
He has reason to thick that while ho was fighting tbe Indiana In their vlllago at thdtime of the original attack Cuator heard the firing and tried to flod a way down the steep ridge that he ?truek and effect a fordtng. This, however, Caster failed to do, but came to tbe rlvor about two and a half miles below tbo rendezvous of Reno and Benteen. Subsequent examination led Major Reno to be lieve ibis to be tbe course pursued by Custer; but why Custer should have gone on down tho creek, alter fluding bis crossing checked when ha finally made the ereek, in steal of returning In the direction of the remainder or hia command, Is a question that Reno Is nnablo lo determine. His hypothesis la that he w iehed to make tor tbe mouth Of Ibe creek, a few miles, where n ateegiboat, with General Gibbon's command aboard, was aupposed to bo; but that bo soon eaeountered more Indians, was ovsrpewered. sad lost bis own life and" tbosd of tbo 268 men In hut force. a quHrrios or Tim. Major Reno aaya alao that Cueter and all of bla men were probably dead when he Joined foroea with Cap tain Benteen on tbe north bank ol the oreek. He does not consider himself any more responsible lor the kill ing ol Caster and nia men than a man in Now York would have been. On tbe othor band, be thinks that llther tbe want of a definite plan of battle or the mis take of General Cuater placed tbe attacking detach ment In serious and to some extent unneoessary Jeopardy. Ho is grieved that certain papers should charge blut with enmity toward so bravo and gallant % man as Coster. They were personal friends, he says, and were upon tbe best of terms, having been In the Military Academy at West Point together and known each other for many years. Major Reno bos very little confidence In tbe truthful ness of Sitting Dull or any other Indian, and wants no further vindication of his character as a soldier in regard to tho Little Big Horn fight than the official re ports of Generals Sherman, Crook and Terry and the ?tatamentsof tbe survivors of tbe battle.
A government commission investigating Sitting Bull's camp reportedly found a white prisoner, Corporal Martin Ryan of Company I, Seventh Cavalry, said to have survived the Little Bighorn massacre and been adopted by Sitting Bull, who made him a war chief and married him to his daughter. Army muster rolls confirmed Ryan had been present for duty on the day of the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 19 November 1877 · page 5
tiiolloalun ilCk-vnler. Wiibcu.so, W. Vo., Nov. 18.—The Hon. John S. Hollniun, late one of the Judges of the Su preme Court ul Appeals of West Virginia, died at his residence iu Clarksburg tbls morning. Owing to ill-health bo his seat from the Bench In J uuc, 187(1. A Survivor or the Cutler Massacre llooomes an Indian Chief. Corrupo'Ulenet potion UtrnUL Wasuinutun, D. C.| Nov. 14.—The Cotnmls •lou which wait sent to Sitting Bull mode au iui|M>rtuul discovery la the fact that the war rior haa iu hit camp a white prisoner captured ui the Cutler massacre.
See moreSee less
Before reaching Fort Walsh rumors reached tho Commission that Sitting Bull held Borne of Custer’s men as prisuud alter the first conference one of tho ball-breed Interpreters emplorcd by Ucu. Terry visited the camp, aud, while passing through, was accosted In English by a person dressed aud painted as a chid, who said that his name was Martin Uyau, who was a corporal In Com pany 1, Seventh Cavalry. Col. Keough's com pany, and bad been taken a prisoner at tho battle of tho Little Big Iloru with Custer. Inquiry apparently substantiated his assertion, and tho following facts were ascer tained: Byou’s Ufo had been spared by bitting remarxed Hint lie was prepared for such an an nouncement; but lie wa* l»y no means sanguine that such action would bo of any permanent or paramount advantage to Hie Company. “The danger Is averted, but the conditions remain the same. It la oulv removing the difficulty bv reducing it Into part*. Mr. Gould i« trot rl«l of. It la I me, but the money which paid him la bor rowed money all the same: no doubt advanced by the Directors nnd their friends. The as the White Chief, lillurc of tiic mail depends entirely on iln management. Judging by the charac ter fd the present Board I am not sanguine of Us success. The Board Is mainly composed of members of the old Board. In (act, Wall street Is largely represented on tbo Board of Directors. .Stock brokers, no doubt, are (rood business men, but they are kcot too busy with their own affairs to Iwstow the proper attention which a larjrc corporation, such as the management of a railroad, demands. I am afraid that the old slipshod policy will prevail. However, if they are honest In their professions, and they earn enough money to pay their debts. I have no doubt the road will soon bo placed In as good condition ns any other road whoso securities soil at the same price.” The Board adjourned subject to the call of the Chair, A special meeting is to bo called for asked to effect his release. the electiou of Secretary nnd Treasurer.
Major Reno, interviewed, states that Custer and his men were probably already dead by the time he joined Captain Benteen's forces. He denies personal responsibility for the disaster, faults the lack of a battle plan or Custer's own mistakes, and expresses distrust of Sitting Bull's truthfulness.
Evening Star · 19 November 1877 · page 1
Ma.iOR Reno has been interviewed, and says also that Cu-ter and all of his m>n were probably dead when he joined forces with Captain Benleen on the north bank of the cr?ek. He does Dot consider h'.m??>lf any mote responsible for the killing of Custer and his men than a man In New York w hi 1<1 have been. On the other hand, lie thinks that either the want of a detinue plan oi battle or the mistake of General Custer placed the at tacking detachment In serious and to some extent unnecessary jeopardy.
See moreSee less
He is grieved that certain p ipers should charge hlni with enmity toward so brave and gallaat a m?ri as Custer. They were personal friends, he sajs and were upon the it. st of terms. Maj. Reno?bas very little confidence in the truth fulness of Sitting Bull or any other Indian, he says. Confirmations.?Tae Senate in execu tive session to-day confirmed a large num ber ol appointments, among them b^ing those of Alorzo Bell, Ass.slant Secretary ot the Interior; Wm Morey, consul at Ceylon; Chailes O. Sbe|herd, of New York, co isuI at L?-eds; Allen Frances, of Oregon, coisul
This report reprints a newspaper correspondent's interview with Sitting Bull describing the Battle of Little Bighorn from his perspective, including vivid details of exhausted soldiers and the intensity of gunfire. The item notes the interview was telegraphed nationally by the associated press as a major news item.
Bismarck Tri-Weekly Tribune · 19 November 1877 · page 2
Custer's Death
We publish a couple in to-day's TRIBUNE. They make good reading. It is asserted as a fact that Dr. Tanner, of Minneapolis, fasted forty-two days, liv ing exclusively on cold water. For ten days he staid in his room and after that period took out door exercise. He was experimenting for the benefit of science. We hope science will be benefitted. The Dr. is o. k. and ready for another trial. Custer's Dcatlu Elsewhere we publish the Chicago Times correspondent's interview with Sitting Bull. Another correspondent, (probably a Herald man,) has also had an interview with the fugitive head devil and gets the following story of the mas sacre.
See moreSee less
This interview was sent from New York by the associated press on last Fri day and evidently regarded by that great news agency as an item worth telegraph ing the country over. Sitting Bull
Chicago Times reporter interviews Sitting Bull at Fort Walsh, who describes the final moments of Custer's troops being overwhelmed and shot down. Sitting Bull claims Custer ('Long-Hair') stood unwounded amid fallen soldiers, fired his pistol twice, and laughed before dying.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Bismarck Tri-Weekly Tribune · 19 November 1877 · page 2
SHOT DOWN LIKE PIGS.
C. S. Diehl, In Chicago Times. On the night previous to our departure from Fort Walsh, -your correspondent succeeded in gaining an interview with Sitting Bull, through the courtesy of Maj. Walsh. The interview eccu: red in
Major Reno gives his account of Little Bighorn, describing his attack, retreat to a bluff, and relief by General Gibbon. He denies responsibility for the massacre, blaming lack of a battle plan or Custer's own mistake for placing troops in jeopardy.
relieved by General Gibbon. His theory is, that, while ke was fighting the Indians in their village at the time of the original attack, Custer heard the firing, and tried to make a way down the ridge and ford the river, but Table to find a crossing-place until he reached a "wo and a half miles below the hill where the other poling ¥ companies were stationed. He thinks, furthermore, that when Captain Benteen joined him on the hill, Custer and ali his men were already dead. He does aot consider bimself responsible for the massacre, but thinks that woither the want of a definite plan of battle, or the mistake of General Custer, pinced the attacking detachment tn serions, and, to some extent, unnecessary jeopardy.”
Maj. Reno responds to implications drawn from Sitting Bull's narrative about the Rosebud/Little Bighorn fight, dismissing the Indian chief's credibility. He recounts his own actions on the day of battle, including his detachment's attack, retreat across the river, and Capt. Benteen's late arrival.
THE MYSTERIOUS BATTLE. Kcno'g Reply to Certain Inferences Drawn from Sitting Ball's Narrative. He Docs Sot Relieve in the Self-Tannted Truthfulness of Any Indian. The Recollections of Comrades a Sufficient Vindication of His Honor. A Brief Becital of His Action* on That Fatal Day. Retrial Wepateh to The Chicago Tribune. Nkw York, Not. 19.—MaJ. Bonn, visiting ■Washington, was walled upon by a Herald cor respondent concerning the implied charges made against him on account of the Rosebud light given by Sitting Bull. Ho was not dis posed to discuss the subject at any length.
See moreSee less
Ho sees no occasion for reopening the question of tinLittle Big Horn battle. That question Is well understood by the ofilcera of tho army who were engaged In It, and by their superiors under whose supervision their reports passed. Ho attaches very little Importance to the state ment of Sitting Bull, especially to that part In width the Chief says the long-haired chief, whom he supposed Reno to he, alter cross ing the Little Big Horn, became frightened at the camp of old men, squaws, and papooses. Ho says that, on the morning of the battle, he separated from Custer with a detachment of three companies and a party ot scouts, and, with no rtmrnnn orders than to attack the village In the woods on tho south side of tho Little Big Horji, ho moved olf on a trot, nnddld os he was told,' being ossured Custer would support him. Capt. Bontcen was also ordered out with anothcrsktrmlshlng party of ul»out 100 men. This was tn tho forenoon. He attackedthe village and fought tho Indians about an hour, retreating to the creek as ho fought, and finally recrossed n short distance below hts lirst tordlug-placc. Having crossed, ho look a position on an adjacent bluff, llio Indians fol lowing and keeping up a continuous fusilndo. Hero he was Joined by Copt. Bontcen, who had followed In ids track ns far os the creek, but, as he nays In his official report, seeing upon the opposite side too many Sioux to encounter with mfcly, tic concluded not lo cross. When Ben tc-un arrived at tho creek Reno was retreating, ami the two made a Junction at the Intrench ment. IN THIS INTIIBNCtIMBNT
Major Reno gives a detailed account of his attack on the village, retreat to the bluffs, and junction with Captain Benteen's forces. He speculates that Custer tried but failed to ford the river to support him, was overpowered by Sioux warriors, and died with his men before Reno and Benteen joined forces.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 November 1877 · page 2
ment. IN THIS INTIIBNCtIMBNT Reno, ns senior olllcer commanding both doUci.mcnts faced the Indians, losing about 100 men In nil, and held bis ground until relieved by Crook. Ilu says If Custer had any more ddlnite plan of operations than to send out ids detachment and cross over lower down to sup port the attack, ho was not aware of it. He pronounces an unqualifiedly absurd the story that lie wan to have made a junction at any par ticular point* lie believes, however, that Cus ter intended fully to cross thu creek and come to ids rescue, and that ho was only prevented from doing so by n mistake in the topography of the country, lie has reason to think that, while he was fighting the Indians In their village at the time of tho original at tack, Caster heard tho firing and tried to find liU way down tho steep ndge that he struck and effect a fording.
See moreSee less
This, however, Custer failed to do, but came to the river about two ami n half miles below the rendezvous of Reno and llcntccn. st'nsnqusNT examination led Reno to believe tills to bo thu course pur sued by Custer. But why Custer should have gone down the creek after finding bis crossing checked when he finally made thu creek, in stead of returning in tho direction of tho lematinler of tho command, is a ques tion Reno is unable to determine. Ills hypothesis Is that he wished to make for the mount of the creek, a few miles from where a i.Unmboat with Gen. (ilblmn's command a boon I wan supposed to be, but that ho soon encoun tered more Indians, was overpowered, and lost Ids own life and those of the men in bis force. Reno says Custer and all of his men were prob tddy dead when ho Joined forces with Cant. Rentccn on (he north Dank of the creek. lie dues not consider himself anymore responsible for the killing of Custer ami his men than a man In New York would have been. On thu other band, ho thinks either o want of u definite plan of battle, or n mistake of Gen. Custer, placed the attacking detachment in a serious and tu sumo extent unnecessary Jeopardy. ns is aniBVBU that certain papers should charge him with en mity toward so brave and gallant a man as Cus !. t. They were personal friends, he savs. and were tinou tho host of terms, having been in thu Military Academy at West I’olnt together, ami known each other for many years. Reno Ran very little confidence in the truthfulness of bitting Bull or any oilier Indian, and wants no Inrther vindication of his character ns a soldier in regard to thu Little Big Horn tight than the olllual reports of Sheridan, Crook, and Terry, and the statements of survivors of the battle.
An advertisement for a book on Custer claims his final battle account proves he was unfairly blamed, asserting that Reno and Benteen's failure to support him cost what would have been a great victory. It also references a sensational newspaper interview with Sitting Bull supposedly confirming this exculpatory version of events.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 November 1877 · page 7
THE OALLMT CUSTER NOBLY VINDICATED I “Sitting Bull ” Speaks! The account of Oen. Curicr** last great fight, aj given In «Ta|*t. ffhllUUr** MFK OK (I EVE UAL {’ISTKII, Is now proved t«» Ik* rntlrdy mrrsrr. Hat tot the cow trail r gf bl« snnordlnaio commander* Custer wnnhl litre won the most brilliant Indian victory ever achieved In this country, llsno on«I llcntccn wera kept hack for hour* by n few Mjntw«. while OiMeparxt tits otnmaml won* In too inoM de*p* rat<' batno over fmi.’til. every mnn imlntf to hl< dc.vb hratrlr.
See moreSee less
Ro fell Gnsirr. the brsveeiva* Il*t. the < hrlstifin soldier. sumumb-d hy fort, nut dying in l.t'n* *«. imM tin* men beloved. AVub hint fell lour others of hi* family. Th«* v«w V*>rk *• lf"ral«l ’* correspondent had tmost rruiarknbM Interview with Hittlbtr llnll. Id the pres ence uf Mai. Walsh, the head of the Casa llau mounted police. In which* The Karts hate all Corns On I, tad Caster's Detract* ors are fsctl l it. kvkiiv oxk simn.D hku» mi: »un; of (IK*. n STKIJ.”
In this interview, Sitting Bull explains his grievances against corrupt agents and justifies his resistance to U.S. forces. He then gives a detailed account of the Battle of the Little Bighorn, claiming Custer was reckless, was lured into a ravine and surrounded, and was shot by a warrior named Maueekolikouuah, a version he says differs from his earlier account given to a Herald correspondent.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Worcester Daily Spy · 20 November 1877 · page 2
are savages. 1 doubt that, for the reason that they commit crimes I shudder at. If they aio civilized, then their state cannot be pleasiug to the Great Spirit, for lie is just and hates mur der and cheating. My future is In his hands. Many moons have passed since 1 became a warrior among my people, but 1 can say be fore him this night’ that I have taken no life but in lair fight. The hands cf Americans are red with the blood of my poor children. Therefore i am sure the Great Spirit will aid uie and save me and tuy people from them.
See moreSee less
I think more than that. Hols just, is he not? IK* puni-hes tinguilty, dues he not? % He helps the weak; is not that like him? And does he not let the weak triumph over those who seek to hurt them? Therefore I think he will some day help me to strike the don’t mean tomorrow or next day, bat some day be fore I die. I always ask the Great Spirit to'belp me in that. I sometimes wish I were dead. That is when 1 am low in spirit. When I was on the other side I was in great sorrow. When I laid down my bead every noise of the night frightened me; my sleep was troubled. I trem bled for my children, for tbe agents were cheats. They would make my people drink fire-water, and when they quarreled with one another over tbe liquor the agents robbed them and mur dered them. Then when I, being the father of my people, struck back :d tnese wicked men, the president sent his soldiers to kill me. That was terrible. Sometimes I thought I would go and see the president. Surely he would not help murderers. He must be deceived by his head men. Ido not think the commissioners who were here the other day would deceive him 1 told them my story, and two of them said I had been treated badly, aud they would treat me well if 1 would return. But* I have heard those fair wotds so often. I caunot longer trust the Americaus. I can only fight them. 1 kn -w they have many soldiers. 1 know my people are weak. But what matters that? They are going to kill us in some way, and l think it will become us to be killed fighting. I am ready, but you see my poor people warn rest. 1 love them all. lie gave tbe follow ing account of tbe Custer tight, which it will be observed differs in impor tant particulars from that previously given to tbe Herald correspondent: It Custer bad killed all my people tbe Ameri cans would have said be bad won a great fight. I did not massacre Custer. He was a brave man, but lie bad uo caution. Custer was brave, but he was careless. He rushed upon us. We were strong. I hud five timesasmany warriors as he. We were posted well. It he had had as many soldiers as 1 had braves, aud I bad bad only as many braves as be bad soldiers, I could have beaten him all the same. I was posted well. I had the ground. He rushed upou u?. He came with a loud shout iuto the ravine. I expected it. I knew what he would do. I had heard of him. Little Current there knew him well. We were ready for him. As soon as ha rushed in we closed up the ravine. We shut him in. W hat can you do when you are shut in all round ? He rode very fast all over, sboui sug. lie wauted to ride through us. At last one of my braves, Maueekolikouuah (the Grass Eater) shot him. When he fell tbe soldiers kept on fighting, but they could uot see their way out. It was Custer's fault. Why did be take them into such a place? He*was too brave. It is better to be afraid than too brave, like Custer. I did not murder them. We thought Reuo was with Custer at first; and when Reno came along after we thought it was the chitt (Terry), and made away because we were tired. Kcuo stopped. Then we went off. My braves did not touch the dead soldiers. We went away and left them. Miles is like Custer. I lit ink he is his brother. 1 mean that he has no caution. It is not just to say that we mur dered Custer. He murdered bimseii. That is ! One of Sitting Bull’s companions added that I '*Ca?»jer was a good fighter, but a bad chief. Howard was a good chief. He was very care ! ful, Ke did no: threw away soldiers. He was careful. He did not try to do too much.” A New York paper says that "Awful" Gard ner Lin extreme poverty aod needs help. This mar. whose true name is Orvilie Gardner, was a prize fighter and a trainer who prepared for the ring some of the most noted pugilists. In le.vrv while under engagement to train Cobom, who is now in Sing Sing prison, he attended s -me religions meetings with his wife, and was led to abandon bis evil courses, and has been a well-behaved and useful man ever since. For a time he was in charge of a reformatory in New York and did a great deal of good there. He is said to have persuaded 1800 drnnkards to reform. A few years later he was stricken down with paralysis, and was for some time helpless, but i> now better and able to do some kinds of light work. He Las been orged by several i-qoot sellers to go into their employment a? a barkeeper, but has refused all s-ueh offers, though be cannot get work and is quite desti tute. He lives in Newark. j Memoins of Carlo Goldoni. Translated I from the Original French by John Black, wi:h | an essay by W. b. Howells. Boston: J. K. Os good 4b Co. Goldoni was a Venetian by birth, tii3 reformer of the Italian theatre and a most prolific author of comedies, of which he pro duced no fewer than sixteen in the course of a single year, all of which were received with ap p.'anse, except one. Such facility was not con sistent with the highest merit, and Goldoni cannot rank with Shakespeare nor with Moliere as a dramatic author, but his invention was in exhaustible, be had humor and sprigbtliness, and his style was correct aud natural. He was born early iu tbe eighteenth century and lived till near its end. His success as au author iu Italy led him to France also, and bis latter years were spent iu Paris. His autobiography is very entertaining, especially that part of it which describes liis youth and early manhood. It is written with a frankness and gaiety which are charming, and the incidents reveal a state of society which is exceedingly picturesque. This part of the book reminds one of Gil Bias, and is hardly less amusing. For sale by Putnam & Davis. Like of Vittorio Alfieri, with an essay by IV. I>. Howells. Boston: J. R. Osgood k Co. This is the latest of the series of autobi ographies edited by Mr. Howells, aud each pre ceded by a critical and biographical essay. Al fieri, one of the great Italian poets, is but little kuotvn to English readers. So far as he is known at all, it is rather as the lover, and afier war.l the husband of the Countess of Albany, the wife of the last of the Stuart pretenders, than as the poet. His autobiography and the essay ot Mr. Howells are both interesting. l*4i It lien I it ml (teueriit Holes. A North Carolina paper condemns tlie peni tentiary, saying: “it is a robber of tho gallows and of the rod, and an oppressor of the tax payer.” In November, 1876, Hinds county, Miss., gave Hayes 1474 aud Tilden 4503. On the Cth inst it cast 3877 votes for J. M. Stone, the demo cratic candidate for governor, and there wete eight scattering. Messrs. Jarrett & Palmer have made an ar rangement with ex-Mayor A. O.tkcy Hal! to de liver a series of lectures throughout the coun try, the first to be given next Monday evening in Boston. The title of the opeuiug lecture is, “What shall the Verdict be?” Mr. Hall will uext appear in Philadelphia, aud afterwards, it is promised, iu New York. Ou the 10th inst. the Galveston News said: “The Texas delegation iu tbe house of repre sentatives distinguished themselves yesterday by the stand they maintained against the re duction of the army. The action of die Texas members will meet the approval of their con stituencies in spite of the republican company in which it temporarily placed them.” Charles Francis Adams has just been safely delivered of auoiber letter concerning “fraud,’ aud is as well and as chilly as can be expected. The letter opens with tbe remark that “it is so dark today in my library that I can scarcely s ' e to write straight.” It bas been some time since Charles could see to write straight. That o.irk libraiy of his. or its owner, needs illumi unting.—•Albany Journal. NN o are told that all the evils from Pandora’s box will come upon the people of this country
In a reported interview, Sitting Bull recounts how Custer and his men were surrounded in a ravine, with Custer himself shot early by a warrior called the Grass Eater, and insists the soldiers were not murdered but that Custer brought about his own downfall through recklessness. He contrasts Custer's rashness with the caution of officers like Howard, and denies his warriors mutilated the dead.
are savages. 1 doubt that, for the reason that they commit crimes I shudder at. If they aio civilized, then their state cannot be pleasiug to the Great Spirit, for lie is just and hates mur der and cheating. My future is In his hands. Many moons have passed since 1 became a warrior among my people, but 1 can say be fore him this night’ that I have taken no life but in lair fight. The hands cf Americans are red with the blood of my poor children. Therefore i am sure the Great Spirit will aid uie and save me and tuy people from them.
See moreSee less
I think more than that. Hols just, is he not? IK* puni-hes tinguilty, dues he not? % He helps the weak; is not that like him? And does he not let the weak triumph over those who seek to hurt them? Therefore I think he will some day help me to strike the don’t mean tomorrow or next day, bat some day be fore I die. I always ask the Great Spirit to'belp me in that. I sometimes wish I were dead. That is when 1 am low in spirit. When I was on the other side I was in great sorrow. When I laid down my bead every noise of the night frightened me; my sleep was troubled. I trem bled for my children, for tbe agents were cheats. They would make my people drink fire-water, and when they quarreled with one another over tbe liquor the agents robbed them and mur dered them. Then when I, being the father of my people, struck back :d tnese wicked men, the president sent his soldiers to kill me. That was terrible. Sometimes I thought I would go and see the president. Surely he would not help murderers. He must be deceived by his head men. Ido not think the commissioners who were here the other day would deceive him 1 told them my story, and two of them said I had been treated badly, aud they would treat me well if 1 would return. But* I have heard those fair wotds so often. I caunot longer trust the Americaus. I can only fight them. 1 kn -w they have many soldiers. 1 know my people are weak. But what matters that? They are going to kill us in some way, and l think it will become us to be killed fighting. I am ready, but you see my poor people warn rest. 1 love them all. lie gave tbe follow ing account of tbe Custer tight, which it will be observed differs in impor tant particulars from that previously given to tbe Herald correspondent: It Custer bad killed all my people tbe Ameri cans would have said be bad won a great fight. I did not massacre Custer. He was a brave man, but lie bad uo caution. Custer was brave, but he was careless. He rushed upon us. We were strong. I hud five timesasmany warriors as he. We were posted well. It he had had as many soldiers as 1 had braves, aud I bad bad only as many braves as be bad soldiers, I could have beaten him all the same. I was posted well. I had the ground. He rushed upou u?. He came with a loud shout iuto the ravine. I expected it. I knew what he would do. I had heard of him. Little Current there knew him well. We were ready for him. As soon as ha rushed in we closed up the ravine. We shut him in. W hat can you do when you are shut in all round ? He rode very fast all over, sboui sug. lie wauted to ride through us. At last one of my braves, Maueekolikouuah (the Grass Eater) shot him. When he fell tbe soldiers kept on fighting, but they could uot see their way out. It was Custer's fault. Why did be take them into such a place? He*was too brave. It is better to be afraid than too brave, like Custer. I did not murder them. We thought Reuo was with Custer at first; and when Reno came along after we thought it was the chitt (Terry), and made away because we were tired. Kcuo stopped. Then we went off. My braves did not touch the dead soldiers. We went away and left them. Miles is like Custer. I lit ink he is his brother. 1 mean that he has no caution. It is not just to say that we mur dered Custer. He murdered bimseii. That is ! One of Sitting Bull’s companions added that I '*Ca?»jer was a good fighter, but a bad chief. Howard was a good chief. He was very care ! ful, Ke did no: threw away soldiers. He was careful. He did not try to do too much.” A New York paper says that "Awful" Gard ner Lin extreme poverty aod needs help. This mar. whose true name is Orvilie Gardner, was a prize fighter and a trainer who prepared for the ring some of the most noted pugilists. In le.vrv while under engagement to train Cobom, who is now in Sing Sing prison, he attended s -me religions meetings with his wife, and was led to abandon bis evil courses, and has been a well-behaved and useful man ever since. For a time he was in charge of a reformatory in New York and did a great deal of good there. He is said to have persuaded 1800 drnnkards to reform. A few years later he was stricken down with paralysis, and was for some time helpless, but i> now better and able to do some kinds of light work. He Las been orged by several i-qoot sellers to go into their employment a? a barkeeper, but has refused all s-ueh offers, though be cannot get work and is quite desti tute. He lives in Newark. j Memoins of Carlo Goldoni. Translated I from the Original French by John Black, wi:h | an essay by W. b. Howells. Boston: J. K. Os good 4b Co. Goldoni was a Venetian by birth, tii3 reformer of the Italian theatre and a most prolific author of comedies, of which he pro duced no fewer than sixteen in the course of a single year, all of which were received with ap p.'anse, except one. Such facility was not con sistent with the highest merit, and Goldoni cannot rank with Shakespeare nor with Moliere as a dramatic author, but his invention was in exhaustible, be had humor and sprigbtliness, and his style was correct aud natural. He was born early iu tbe eighteenth century and lived till near its end. His success as au author iu Italy led him to France also, and bis latter years were spent iu Paris. His autobiography is very entertaining, especially that part of it which describes liis youth and early manhood. It is written with a frankness and gaiety which are charming, and the incidents reveal a state of society which is exceedingly picturesque. This part of the book reminds one of Gil Bias, and is hardly less amusing. For sale by Putnam & Davis. Like of Vittorio Alfieri, with an essay by IV. I>. Howells. Boston: J. R. Osgood k Co. This is the latest of the series of autobi ographies edited by Mr. Howells, aud each pre ceded by a critical and biographical essay. Al fieri, one of the great Italian poets, is but little kuotvn to English readers. So far as he is known at all, it is rather as the lover, and afier war.l the husband of the Countess of Albany, the wife of the last of the Stuart pretenders, than as the poet. His autobiography and the essay ot Mr. Howells are both interesting. l*4i It lien I it ml (teueriit Holes. A North Carolina paper condemns tlie peni tentiary, saying: “it is a robber of tho gallows and of the rod, and an oppressor of the tax payer.” In November, 1876, Hinds county, Miss., gave Hayes 1474 aud Tilden 4503. On the Cth inst it cast 3877 votes for J. M. Stone, the demo cratic candidate for governor, and there wete eight scattering. Messrs. Jarrett & Palmer have made an ar rangement with ex-Mayor A. O.tkcy Hal! to de liver a series of lectures throughout the coun try, the first to be given next Monday evening in Boston. The title of the opeuiug lecture is, “What shall the Verdict be?” Mr. Hall will uext appear in Philadelphia, aud afterwards, it is promised, iu New York. Ou the 10th inst. the Galveston News said: “The Texas delegation iu tbe house of repre sentatives distinguished themselves yesterday by the stand they maintained against the re duction of the army. The action of die Texas members will meet the approval of their con stituencies in spite of the republican company in which it temporarily placed them.” Charles Francis Adams has just been safely delivered of auoiber letter concerning “fraud,’ aud is as well and as chilly as can be expected. The letter opens with tbe remark that “it is so dark today in my library that I can scarcely s ' e to write straight.” It bas been some time since Charles could see to write straight. That o.irk libraiy of his. or its owner, needs illumi unting.—•Albany Journal. NN o are told that all the evils from Pandora’s box will come upon the people of this country
A reporter interviews Sitting Bull in Canada, describing his appearance and demeanor before recording his firsthand account of the Little Bighorn battle. Sitting Bull describes being asleep when Custer's attack began, identifies Custer's horse found after the fight, and states the heaviest fighting occurred where Custer's men were wiped out before warriors turned to Reno.
Worcester Daily Press · 20 November 1877 · page 4
A TALK WITH SITTING BULL. Something About the Warrior’s Appear ance—The Custer Battle. The following is from the pen of the Chi cago Times's far-west-correspondeut: On the night previous to our departure from Fort Walsh, your correspondent suc ceeded in gaining au interview with Sitting Bull, through the courtesy of Major Walsh. The interview occurred in the quarters of one of the Canadian officers, and was lis tened to by Major Walsh, an interpreter, and a stenographic writer. I have already at tempted to describe Sitting Bull. As 1 sat aud talked to him that night I had a better opportunity to study his face and manner.
See moreSee less
11c had objected to talking with any one at first, on tbe ground that they were Ameri cans, aud it was only when Major Walsh had urged him to do so, that he consented to converse about himself. He had thrown off his blanket and fur cap, and was dressed iu the same costume in which he had ap peared before the commission. He wore a blue calico shirt specked with white dots, which was worn over his leggings. His leg gings were made of dark blue material and along their sides ran a strip ot dark red cloth. Tied loosely around his neck was a red bandana handkerchief. His long, black hair was combed as neatly as that of a woman, and was paried directly in the mid dle. In addition to other peculiarities 1 have already noted about him, in speaking to auy one he looked the person addressed fairly iu the eye, and when he laughs, he does so heartily, and all the stoicism of the savage is gone. I remember when the in terpreter told him that the white people had said that he was a white man, and had been taught in one of their schools, that he laughed, and then proceeded to tell how he had been born to be a seer among his peo ple. * * * * * * “Ask Sitting Bull if he will tell about the Cu9ter battle iu his own words.” When this had been translated to him, Sitting Bull replied simply, “I was there.” When I had asked him several questions, he said in his own words, “The white soldiers came into my camp when the sun was up. When the sun was in the center,” pointing upward, and meaning noon, “the fight stopped. Tbe white soldiers came iu two places. When the ‘Long Hair’ (Custer) came into my camp, I was in my tepee asleep. My people told me to get up, as the ‘Long Hair’ was in camp, i said ‘Ail right,’ and jumped up.” “Were your lodges tbe first ones struck?” I asked him. He replied “Yes.” I had provided myself with a map of the battle field, showing the Indian encampment aud the position of the forces under Custer and Reno during the fight. I asked him where the heavy fighting had taken place, and he pointed on the map to the place where Cus ter had fought. Through the interpreter he explained that all the fighting had taken place where Custer fell. He said that only a few warriors assaulted Reno until Custer’s men had all been killed, when they sur rounded Reno. “Ask him if auy of the young meu saw Custer when he fell.” “I do not recollect him. He was riding a horse with a whitfe face and white legs. It was a stud horse. The horse came into ray camp after the fight was over, and we knew it was the ‘Long Hair’s’ horse.” “Did the white soldiers make a brave fight?” “They did not make a brave fight.” “Ask Sitting Bull what happened after Custer first struck the Indian camp.” “When they came to the camp they came around this way,” said Sitting Bull, point ing to the map and showing the interpreter the trail taken by Custer. “When the sol diers jumped off their horses some of the horses got away, aud those that held their horses ran back, and then they wero sur rounded.” “Did tho soldiers fight well after they left the horßcs?” Sitting Bull explained that the dismount ed troops were killed aB they stood there, und pictured tbe attack made upon them by the savages by frequently clapping his hands together sharply, to illustrate the firing of the guus. He said that the soldiers who held the horses tried to get away, but were followed and killed. “Ask him how many Indians there were engaged in the fight,” I said to the inter preter. “4 did not count lliem,” replied Sitting Bull, “It was a big camp.” In speaking of the battle, Sitting Bull said that Custer at first had imprisoned a small body of Indians, and was killing them, when all the warriors centered at that place. I asked him if he knew where Custer fell. He replied: “No one knows where the ‘Lone Hair’ fell.” “Ask him,” I said to the interpreter, ‘‘if I would bo welcome if I visited his ca">p.” “You would not he welcome,” he replied. “You came with the Americans, you can go back with them.” Au lowa boy wantod to hear how bird shot sounded as it flew out of the muzzle ot a gun. Tho gun swerved, planted the shot In his ear—about 200 to the hill. Democratic Canons In the Case of Butler. Special Dispatch to the Press. Washington, Nov, 19. —The Democratic members met iu caucus this morning. All, except those who are absent from the city and paired with Republicans on important questions, were present, with the exception of the Democratic members of the commit tee on privileges and elections, which met at the same time. The advisability of bring ing up the case of Butler of South Carolina was discussed, and it was left to Mr. Thur man to make tbe motion, when, iu his de cision, it would be best to do so. It was left to him as a member of the committee on privileges and elections. The Senators in caucus all agreed that it should be called up unless some arrangement had been made iu the committee on privileges and elections which would be satisfactory to the Demo crats. The Louisiana Senatorship. Special Dispatch to the Press. Washington, Nov. 19. —The Senate com mittee on privileges aud elections met to day, and received the briefs submitted by Messrs. Spofford and Kellogg to the sub committee, which were ordered to be printed. The committee then proceeded to a consideration of the motion made by Senator Saulsbury at the last meeting of the committee, to the effect that the com mittee take up the Eustis case. After an animated discussion, Senator Cameron moved to lay Senator Saulsbury’s motion on the table until the sub-committ 30 re ported how long it would take to dispose of the Kellogg-Spofford case, aud that the reso lution be then disposed of on its merits. War on Tramps, Special Dispatch to the I'ress. Now York, Nov. 19.—Vigilance com mittees have been formed in northern Penn sylvania to protect lives and property from the hordes of tramps. There have been several lively skirmishes aud fights. Three parties were captured, and a house filled with plunder captured near Coopersburg. A fight at a limekiln between thirty tramps aud vigilantes at midnight on the 17th, iu which guns aud pistols were freely used, re sulted iu the tramps being captured, three of whom were severely wounded. They were taken to jail at Doylestown. The vigilantes were in pursuit of other outlaws last night in Lehigh and Bucks counties. TUe Freedom of Cuba. Special Dispatch to the Press. Washington, Nov. 19. —The cause of the struggling Cubans is represented here by a lady, who is making assiduous efforts to ob tain votes in both branches of Congress in favor of the freedom of Cuba. She claims that sixty-three members of the House and twenty-three Senators have pledged them selves to vote for a resolution, which is soon to be introduced for the recognition of Cu ban independence. Among the latter is Hannibal Hamlin, chairman of the commit tee on foreigu relations.
Major Reno denies claims attributed to Sitting Bull, asserting he was always a loyal friend to Custer and a fellow West Point graduate. He states he is willing to let his reputation rest on the official reports of the battle filed by Generals Crook, Terry, and Sheridan.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 20 November 1877 · page 3
Washington, November 19. Major Reno de nies the statements of Sitting Bull. He says he was always a warm friend of Custer, and with whom he wcut through West Point Academy and he is content to rest his reputation on the report of the bailie of the Rosebud or Little Big Horn, made by Generals Crook, i'eny aud Shut man.
In an interview, Sitting Bull describes the chaotic final stand of Custer's men, with soldiers falling back and making stands on higher ground as they were shot down. He gives a vivid, almost poetic account of Custer ('Long Hair') dying after firing his last shot and laughing, with only a couple of men still standing near him at the end.
The Spirit of Democracy · 20 November 1877 · page 3
"Sitting Bull says mere-were only squaws, old men ana nine couaren in front of Keoo, keeping him In bis strong position on the bluff.and preventing him from giving aid to Custer. , ,
Major Reno rejects statements attributed to Sitting Bull, insisting he was always a close friend of Custer since their West Point days. He says he is content to let his reputation rest on the official reports of the battle made by Generals Crook, Terry, and Sherman.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Providence Morning Star · 20 November 1877 · page 3
sentimeni and mouey are not so far apart after all. He has rrewnud 0o a bank in Albany a bronze medallion portrait of its presuient, in acknowledgment of the kindneas ol its vflicers and assistants, during the thirty years in wuich he has had financial relations with it. At an interview with editor Watterson, of the Lowuisville Courier-Journal, be snid the South is solid for the Dewoeracy, aml that President Hayes's effort to divide the Southern Democ racy is n lailure, and he believes that Grant will be the Republican candidate for the next Presi dency. Major Reno denies the statement of Silting Bull. He says he was always & warm f{riend with Custer, with whom be went through West Point Academy, and he is content to rest his
Reno dismisses Sitting Bull's claims that he became frightened at the Indian camp during the battle, saying little importance should be attached to them. He gives his own detailed account of the separation from Custer, the attack on the village, his retreat to the bluffs, and his junction with Benteen's command.
The Daily Intelligencer · 20 November 1877 · page 2
He believes, however, that Custer in tended to crow; the creek and come to bis refcue, aud that bs was only pre vented from doing so by a mistake in the topography of the country. He has reason to think, while he was fight ing the Indians in their village, nt tbe time of the original attack, Custer heard the firing and tried to find his way down Sleepy Ridge: that lie struck out to effect a fording place; this, however, Custer failed to do, but came to the river about two and a half miles below tbe the rendez vous of Reno and Benton.
See moreSee less
Subsequent examination led Reno to believe this to be the course pursued by Custer, but why Custer should have gone ou down the creek after finding his crossing checked, when he finally tnade the oreek, instead ot returning in the di rection of the remainder of his com mend, is a question Reno is unable to determine. His hypothesis is that he wished to make for the mouth of the creek, a few miles from where the •tcamboat (with Gen. Gibbon's com mand aboard) was supposed to be, but that he soon encountered more Indians, and was overpowered, and lost his own life aud those of the men in his force. Reno says Custer and all of his men were probably dead when he joined forces with Benton, on tbe north bank of the creek. He does not consider himself any more responsible for tbe killing of Custer and bis men than a man in New York would have been; and on the other band he thinks either a want of a definite plan of bettle, or a mistake of general Custer's placed the attacking detachment in a serious and to some extent unnecessary jeopardy. He is much grieved that certain papers should charge him with enmity towards so gallant and brave a man as Custar. They were personal friends, be says, and acre upon tbe best terms, having been in the Military Academy at West Point together and known each other for many years. Reno has very little confidence in Sitting dull or any other Indians, and wants no further vindication of his characier as a soldier in regard to the Little Big Horn tight than the official reports of Sherman, Crook and Terry, and the statements of tbe survivors of the battle. NEW YORK, NOV. 19—Tbe weather is delightful, but for the tirst time this mason tbe thermometer indicates a tem perature near tbe freezing point Cold weather is probable.
Major Reno gives his detailed version of the retreat, the fight with Benteen's support, and his theory of how Custer became cut off and was killed. He denies responsibility for Custer's death, attributing it to a topographical mistake or lack of a coordinated battle plan.
The Daily Intelligencer · 20 November 1877 · page 2
NKW YORK, NOV. 19—3:24 A. SC.— The World says that the safe in the Pifth National Bank, at the oorner of Third Avenue and Twenty-third street, was blown open at high noon on Sun day by burglars who got away with $50,000. Oakey Hall is advertised to lecture la Boeton and other cities. The Bera&fi Washington special sajs that Mqfar Baoo, while vis.ting Wash ing, was waited apon by the Herald's oarreepoadeot concerning the implied cbergss made against him in the ao ooontof the Boeebud fight giveo by Bitting Ball. He «e» not disposed to discum the sntgect at any length. He sane no oooeaion for re-opaoing the goaatioa of the Little Big Horn battle.
Major Reno states that Custer and his men were likely already dead by the time he joined Benteen's forces on the north bank of the creek. He denies greater responsibility for Custer's death than any outsider would bear, suggests Custer's own plan or mistake caused the disaster, and cites official reports as sufficient vindication of his conduct.
The Daily Intelligencer · 20 November 1877 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
A New York correspondent reports an interview with Sitting Bull describing the Little Bighorn fight, with vivid imagery of exhausted soldiers, flying bullets, and desperate fighting. Sitting Bull recounts the soldiers' collapse and retreat in poetic, secondhand detail attributed to his warriors.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 20 November 1877 · page 1
CUSTER'S LAST SHOT
; meet them. They fired with needle guns; we replied with magazine guns and repeating rifles. Sitting Bull illus trated by putting his palms together j with the rapidity of a fusilade. Our i young men rained lead across the river
An interview recounts how soldiers fell back fighting in a retreat to higher ground, with 'Long Hair' (Custer) making a last stand, laughing as he fell. Sitting Bull is quoted claiming only old men, women and children held Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 20 November 1877 · page 1
CUSTER'S LAST SHOT
i young men rained lead across the river j and drove the white braves liack, and I then they rushed across themselves, and ! then they found that they had a good | deal to do. The trouble was with the soldiers—they were so exhausted, and their horses bothered them so that they could not take aim. Some of their horses broke away from them and left them to stand and drop and die. All the men fell back fighting and drop ping. They could not fire fast enough, thougli they kept in pretty good order.
See moreSee less
They would full back across a gulch and make afresh stand beyond on high er ground. There were a great many brave men in that fight, and from time to time while it was going on they were shot down like pigs. They could not help themselves. One of the officers fell where the last fight took place, where the bast stand was made. The long hair stood like a sheaf of corn, with all the ears falling around him, not wounded, but dead.” llow many stood by him? A few. When did he fall? lie killed a man. When he fell, be laughed. You mean be cried out? No, be laughed. He bad fired bis last shot from a carbine, not a pistol. Did he stand up after he first fell? He arose upon bis bands to fire another shot, but bis pistol would not go off. Was any one else standing up when be fell down? One man was kneeling; that was all, but be died before the long hair. Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men, and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in bis strong position on the bluff and pre venting him giving aid to Custer.
A reporter relates a conversation with Sitting Bull describing the battle against Custer's exhausted soldiers, who fought bravely despite being worn out. The account ends with Custer standing amid his fallen men, killing one more foe before falling with a laugh, having fired his last shot.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Decorah-Posten · 21 November 1877 · page 1
Sitting Bull om (Custer. En Norrespondent har havt en Samtale med kitting Bull, der ud. talte sig om Kampen med General Custer saaledes. «Kimpen var paa Liv og Død; de indianske Kvindfolk lignede slyvende sFugle, og Kuglerne fløi gjennem Uusten som Bier. Vi tænkte, vi skulde faa Bank, men Sa. gerne vendte sig lidt efter lidt. Eders sfolk blev dræbte. Jeg fortæller in gen Løgn om døde Mænd: De sFolk, som kom med den Langhaarede (General Custer) var saa tapre som sfolk, der nogensinde har kjæmpet. Da de kom ridende, var deres Heste udmattede.
See moreSee less
Da Rytterne steg af, kunde de neppe staa paa sine Ben; de vaklede hid øg did, og mine unge sFolk har fortalt mig, at de bævede som Cypressens Grene i en htæik Storm. Nogle as dem syntes neppe at kunne bære sine Geværer, og dog begyndte de strax at fæegte Men nu var ogsaa vor Leir kommen paa Be-. nene, og der var fuldt op af Kri gere til at møde op mod dem Te fyurede med Naalegeværer, vi svarede med Magazingeværer og ÖRepeater». Risler. Vore unge Krigere sendte en Blyregn over Elven drev de hvide Krigere tilbage, saa styrtede de selv over og fandt, at de havde en hel Del at gjøre. Soldaterne var saa trætte, og Hestene hindrede dem i at
The article denounces as canards two supposed telegraphic speeches from Sitting Bull fabricated by New York papers, one praising British officers over Americans, another glorifying Custer while mocking Reno's men as trapped by squaws. It argues the fake speech's references to cypress trees and pigs prove it was invented, since Sitting Bull would never have known of such things.
Ottumwa Weekly Courier · 21 November 1877 · page 2
i t.i private trnnirp, but tin death of '^Uoioaugh is a matter of public con rern and tbe public has right to know if possible, beyond peradven turo that there was crime commit 110 ted. No cunning scheme carried out to hide a murder with an apprrent su icidc. .1 usticc to all concerned de mands this. TIIK Philadelphia Weekly Times, a paper calling itself independent in politics and especially a rantankerous advocate of civil service, is engaged in the very civil service laudable un undertaking of hiring all the post masters of the country to canvass for t.
See moreSee less
We have scon recently a copy of its Weekly containing an immense show bill to be posted up by civil scr ice postmasters, who engage as ageuts. It advertises as its contributors among others, the lion, ,1'arl Schurz, Gen. Jo. Johnston, Gen. Beauregard and Mrs. Stonewall Jackson. A very brief examination only, of ita political editorials is sufficient to satisfy any one that its reform and in dependence is wholly of the demo cratic stamp, brassy, but a sham.— The Ttmes is the mouth piece of Alex ander R. McClure, who bears the same relation to the republican party that Benedict Arnold did to the pat riots of the revolution. Canards from Sitting Bull are now in order. The other day the able bodied liars in New York manufactu red a telegraphic speech from him, in which the British cltizens*and officers were held up as the incarnation of honesty and bravery, while the" Americans were denounced as the personification of rascality. Of course the next day the a. b. 1. who collated and perhaps manufactured the ca nard in New York, was put to the trouble of denying the speech in toto. Friday we had from the same source and from the same inspiration, another telegraphic speech from Sit ting Bull, in which he apotheosized Custer who recklessly and unmili tarily threw away his command, and in which Reno, who gallantly fought and intelligently saved his, was ridi culed as being hemmed in by a lot of squaws. In this speech Sitting Bull speaks about Custer's command being sway ed like the cypress, and shot down like pigs. When It the intelligent readers will consider that there are cypress trees or pigs* in Sitting no Bulls bailiwick, and that be quite likely never saw or heard of either, then he will be able to fully appre ciate how thoroughly the New York concoctor of tho "tcching" speech, drew on his inner consciousness for his facts. President Hayes has been all along since his inauguration placing most important trusts in the hands of the democracy of the south he has yield ed to them as it were the key to do wholly as they please, without let or hindrance, within tho entire borders of the late Confederacy, and as hun dreds of thousands of those who vot ed for him believe, he has in doing this, abandoned his own most ardent and faithful friends in the south.— All this has the President done in his extreme desire for conciliation. In return what do we see in one singo instance alone. Not only does a democratic House, against his wish, vote to reduce the small army he commands, but they step in and trench upon his Constitutional pre rogative to command that army and command him where he shall keep that army, in part, and what duty ttkvy Wiik «Al 4Uq confidence in them the President has exhibited they make return, or At tempt to, by an invasion of the President's powers, refusing to trust him in the discharge of his well-known duties. This ia no sur prise to us. The President will be flattered by them just so long as he yields to their wishes, but to return to him like condescension where it involves anything valuable they will never do. In our general relations as citizens experience and common sense has taught that the full grown man who deliberately commits a theft may do so again, and we exer cise our confidence in that man accor dingly. We believe this principle very correct and that it will apply with equal force in politics.
In a newspaper interview, Sitting Bull describes the chaos and intensity of the fight against Custer's soldiers, calling it 'hell' and describing exhausted troopers overwhelmed by Sioux warriors. He emphasizes the soldiers' bravery even as they were cut down, attributing the outcome to superior numbers and repeating rifles.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 21 November 1877 · page 1
---------- NITTING BULL'S STORY. The Veteran Chief of the Sioux Deserlmes Few Incidents of the Custer MaIslare, NEW YORK. Nov. 16.-Sitting Bull has bein talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Ouster massacre. He says: "'Th fight was hell. A thousand devils-the squa-° were like flying birds; the bullets like hum ming-bees. We thought we were whipped
In an interview, Sitting Bull describes Custer's final moments, including his position surrounded by fallen soldiers, his failed last pistol shot, and his death. He also claims Reno was held back by only non-combatants—squaws, old men, and children.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New Orleans Daily Democrat · 21 November 1877 · page 1
SITTING BULL'S STORY.
" Did he stand ui after he first fell ?" "iHe rose up on his hands and tried anothe. shot, but his pistol would not go off," "Was any one else standing up when hefll down ?" " One man was kneeling-that was all: bathe died before the Long Hair." Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, 0ol men and little children in front of Reno. keer ing him in his strong position on the bluff a preventing him givfng aid to Custer. The Army Register. iNew York Tribune.l Five years ago the proposition of Charles Sumner to remove the names of the battles .
See moreSee less
the civil war from the regimental colors of tth regular army caused a great deal of diseueeio and provoked much hostile criticism. Now.th Secretary of War orders all mention of batt to be omitted in future issues of The Adrys Register, and the change, more importantthaa the one Mr. Sumner proposed excites no att6lt tion, and gets only a brief mention in -S Washington dispatches. Since 1862 The ter has contained, In connection --J1 the roster of each regiment, a list t
This item reports Sitting Bull's description of General Custer's final fight, claiming the soldiers were too stiff and sore from hard riding to shoot straight. It also claims Custer killed several warriors with his pistol before falling.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Canton Advocate · 21 November 1877 · page 1
—Sitting Bull gives a graphic daaerty tioa of General Custer's last fight B* says that the soldiers wan an stiff sad sore from loag aad aetata riding that they oouM barfly walk, aad ao that they conid ^ot shoot straight That Caster kfflsd aabpiiaa with Ida pistol, aad
A New York Herald correspondent reports an extended interview with Sitting Bull describing the Little Bighorn fight. Sitting Bull explains Reno attacked first and was repulsed, after which Custer's separate attack was overwhelmed once warriors were redirected against him, with Custer's exhausted men eventually dismounting and fighting on foot until none survived.
Green-Mountain Freeman · 21 November 1877 · page 2
THE CUSTER FIGHT
dtsiant by merely sending up a kite, at each end of the distance, a certain hehdit, attached to which in place of the ordinary string VV:1S a me com)Bl. w-m both kites, though eleven mile-, distant Iruin each other, touched the same current communication was established, ami mes sages were sent by means of the ordinary .uoi.-e instrument in connection with the 111 inveuieu Dy frofessor Lotunis Inn Clstki! iioHT.-A New York Ucr a,d correspondent reports a prolix inter iew w ul, hitting Hun. From his fltllle. nent of the Cusier fight, the UcraU finds that Custer's plan was to attack the J .
A fragment attributed to Sitting Bull describes Custer falling like 'a sheaf of corn' amid dead soldiers, still shooting and laughing after his last shot, then trying to fire again with a jammed pistol. Sitting Bull reportedly claims Custer was scalped because he was a great chief.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Green-Mountain Freeman · 21 November 1877 · page 2
fell, and laughed when he had fired his last sho from his pistol. Ho rose upon his hands and tried another shot, but his pisto would not go off. One man w kneeling when Custer fell, but he died be fore Custor. Sittmir. Bull savs " T scalped, because he was a great r-hle'f.
Major Reno states that Custer and his men were likely already dead when he joined Captain Benteen, and denies greater responsibility for the deaths than any outside observer. He expresses grief at suggestions of enmity toward Custer, calling him a personal friend, and dismisses the credibility of Sitting Bull's accounts.
The Daily Gazette · 22 November 1877 · page 4
Major Reno has been interviewed, and says that Custer and all of bis men were probably dead wben he joined forces with (Japt. Benteen on the north bank of the creek. , He does not consid er himself any more responsible for the killing of Duster and his men than a man in New York would have been. On the other hand, he thinks ihat either the want of a definite plan of battle or the mistake of Gen. Ouster placed the attacking detachment in seriou-' and to some extent unnecessary jeopardy. He is grieved that certain papers should charge him with enmity toward so brave and gallant a man as Custer. They were personal friends, he says, and were
This is a narrated interview describing the final moments of Custer's command, including Custer ('Long Hair') standing and firing until killed. It attributes details to Sitting Bull, including claims about who was defending the bluff position against Reno.
The Toledo Chronicle · 22 November 1877 · page 1
all: but he died before the Long Hair." Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Keno, keeping him in his strong position on the lilutf ancl«yjii'e .vfenting'hini giving aid to Custer.
A newspaper correspondent relays an interview with Sitting Bull describing the Battle of the Little Bighorn from the Lakota perspective. He describes the chaos of battle and praises the bravery of Custer's exhausted soldiers.
The Toledo Chronicle · 22 November 1877 · page 1
Sitting Ball Tells the Story of the Caster Massacre. NEW YOBS NOT. 18, SITTING Brix has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story of "The Custer Massacre." He says: The fight was hell. A thousand dev ils—the squaws—were like flying birds the bullets like humming-bees. We thought we were whipped not at first, but by and by. Afterward no. Your people were tilled. I tell no lies about dead men. These men who came with Long Hair (Custer) were as good men as ever fought. When they rode up their horses were tired and they were tired.
See moreSee less
When they got off. their horses they couft} not stand flrmly on their feet.' They swayed to and fro, so my young men have told me, like limbs of cy presses in a great wind. Some of them staggered under the weight of their :uns, but tbey began *o fight at once, by this time ut by this time our camps were arousod, and there were plenty of war*
A news roundup reports a charge that the remains of soldiers killed in the Custer massacre have never been properly buried and remain exposed on the plains. The item calls on the government to see that proper burial is carried out as a basic duty.
The Rock Island Argus · 22 November 1877 · page 2
Tee charge is made that the remains of the gallant soldiers who fell in the Custer massacre have never beenjproperly buried, and are now exposed on the plains. If
The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · and 2 other papers
This report recounts an interview with Sitting Bull describing the final moments of Custer's command, with vivid details of soldiers falling and Custer ('the Long Hair') making a last stand, firing his pistol and laughing before dying. It also claims only women, old men, and children faced Reno's force, preventing him from reinforcing Custer.
The Kenosha Telegraph · 22 November 1877 · page 3
Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men, and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff and preventing him giving aid to Custer.
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 22 November 1877
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · 23 November 1877
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.
A correspondent relays Sitting Bull's own narrative of the battle against Custer's command, describing the exhaustion of the soldiers, the ferocity of the fighting, and the gradual collapse of the troopers under Lakota and allied fire. Sitting Bull insists he speaks honestly of brave men who fought hard despite being outmatched.
Wood County Reporter · 22 November 1877 · page 1
CUSTER'S DEATH.
(Sitting Bull illustrated by putting his hands together with the rapidity of a fusilade.) Our young men rained lead across the river and drove the white
Col. Corbin reports that Sitting Bull, interviewed by the commission in Washington, gave an account of the Custer fight that largely matched the generally understood version. Sitting Bull said Custer charged a force outnumbering him ten to one and was surrounded, and claimed that had Reno not retreated, the already-wavering Indians might have been defeated.
The Manitowoc Pilot · 22 November 1877 · page 2
31 r. Julius JJuumgarten, engraver of tins city. baa just completed anew great sea! of'the I nited States., for the use of tlie State Department at Washington. Tins is the only seal made for the State Department since the original seal was made, at the foundation of the govern ment. The old seal, from the wear of I l>e new seal is of the Lest English steel, ID inches in diameter and £ ol an inch in thickness. It has a smooth surface with the exception of the tradi tional t’agle, and the words “K Pliuibua 1 num" engraved on the lace.
See moreSee less
It will be taken to Washington in a few days and attached to the machine with which it is used — Philadelphia Jjfihjir. Col. Corbin ol the Sitting Bull Com mission has arrived in Washington, and denies that the great chieftain treated the commission ungraciously. lie gave the members of the eonnnb; ion several interviews, which were interesting and important. In one of those he gave a description of the Custer massacre, whic h differed very little trom the circutu ataneea as generally understood. Custer charged Sitting Bull and his band, who outnumbered him ten to one, and was surrounded and destroyed before ho could cut bis way out. Sitting Bull says that it Reno had not retreated when he did, the Indians who were already retreating, would have been badly demoralized and lost the fight. Oiit Aiivv. I hiring the discussion on the army appropriation bit! in the House the other day, the adjutant-gener al sent in a report upon the general dis tribution of the army. This shows that the ten cavalry regiments, numbering in all about. 8,000 men, are on duty in the far Wist and Texas. The head quarters of the five artillery regiments, numbering about LVJoO men, are station
The paper notes that newspapers have widely published an alleged interview with Sitting Bull containing a sensational account of General Custer's death. It expresses strong doubt that the story is genuine, suggesting it was fabricated by whoever first published it.
The Herald. LANCASTER: Tburoday,November,lß77. The Mississippi Legislature has 154 Democrats and two members who uro not Democrats. “My policy!” Field & Leiter’s large retail establishment in Chicago was burned down last week, on Thursday. Lobs neatly $2, 000, 000. Hon. Wm. E. Smith’s official ma jority over Mallory, tor Governor, is 8, 271. Who could ask tor any thing better ? “The Elections being over and the ‘wise men of the East’ being in substantial accord, boaslless cavil should give way to a pull all to gether.”—Dubuque Times. All right; what shall we pull at ?
See moreSee less
The Russians have taken Kars and with it 10,000 prisoners and large stores Part of the army engaged in the siege and capture is now un the march to other battle grounds. Seven thousand are on the way to Plevna and others are bound for Erzeroum. The papers have profusely pub lished an alleged interview with Sitting Bull, in which he gives a sensational account of the death of General Custer. We have not the least doubt but that tbe story is wholly fabricated by its first pub lisher. WM.CooLBAuGH,the great Chicago banker, took his own life by shoot ing through the head, on Wednes day morning last week. He was a man of many good qualities, but it appears ho thought bis day of use fulness or power to do good was past and he bad no object in living longer.
Major Reno, visiting Washington, is asked about charges implied against him in Sitting Bull's account of the Little Big Horn battle. He gives his own version of events, says he attaches little importance to Sitting Bull's claims, and denies responsibility for Custer's death, blaming a lack of coordinated battle plan.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 22 November 1877 · page 1
The Major Don't Take Any Stock in the * Chief's Story. 1 Washington, Nov. 21.—Major .Reno ■ is visiting Washington, and was waited • upon by a correspondent concerning ‘ the implied charges made against him ■ in the account of the Custer fight 1 given by Sitting Bull. He was not dis ■ posed to discuss the subject at any ' length. He sees no occasion for re opening the question of the Little Big Horn battle; that question is well un derstood by the officers of the army who were engaged in it, and by their superiors under whose sui>ervision their reports passed.
See moreSee less
He attaches very lit tle importance to the statement of Sit ting Bull, especially to that part in which the chief says a long-haired chief, whom he supposed Iteno to be, after crossing the Little Big Horn, be came frightened at a camp of old men, squaws and papooses. He says that on the morning of the battle he separated from Custer with a detachment of three companies and a party of scouts, and with no further orders from him than to attack the village in the woods on the south side of the Little Big Horn. He moved off and did as he was told, being assured that Custer would supportliim. He does not consid er himself any more responsible for the killing of Custer and his men than any man in Washington would have been. On the other hand, he thinks either want of definite plan of battle or a mistake of Gen. Custer placed the at tacking detachment in serious, and to some extent, unnecessary jeopardy. He is grieved that certain papers should charge him with enmity toward so brave and gallant a man as Custer. They were personal friends, he says, and were upon the best of terms, hav ing been in the Military Academy at West Point together, and knowing each other for many years. Reno has very little confidence in Sitting Bull or any other Indian, and wants no further vindication of his character as a soldier in regard to the ; Little Big Horn fight, than the official reports of Shermau, Crook and Terry and the statements of the survivors of the battle.
Lieut. J.H. Coale of the Second Cavalry describes building Fort Custer on the Big Horn river, detailing its log construction, commanding officers, and garrisoned companies. He also notes the Yellowstone valley is rapidly settling with ranches and praises the farming potential of the region.
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 22 November 1877 · page 1
NEWS FROM THE NORTHLAND.
Pacific, Nov. 17th. IVhen Lieut. Coale left the quarters had not l»een completed, hut it was then expected that they would be occupied Nov. 15th. The new quarters, which are large, comfortable and very substan tially constructed, will accommodate eight companies. They are built of logs, first sheathed with cottonwood and then with pine, with double floors, the under one of cottonwood ami the upper of pine. Fort Custer is commanded by Gen. Buell, of the Eleventh Infantry, five companies of his regiment being now , stationed there, under Captains Sander son, Whitney, Kingsbury. Conrad and Gilbraith. There are also four com panies of the Second Cavalry at this post, under Captains Mix, Spaulding, Egan and Gregg.
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · and 4 other papers
More than a year after the battle, a correspondent reports an interview with Sitting Bull describing the Custer fight from the Lakota perspective. Sitting Bull recounts exhausted soldiers, repeating rifles overpowering needle guns, and the gradual retreat and death of Custer's men.
The True Northerner · 23 November 1877 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
THE CUSTER MASSACRE.
Graphic Account of the Fight as Told by Sitting Bull—How the Brave Custer Met His Death.
See moreSee less
Sitting Bull has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Custer massacre. He says: "The fight was hell. A thousand devils—the squaws—were like flying birds; the bullets like humming-bees. We thought we were whipped; not at first, but by and by. Afterward no. Your people were killed. I tell no lies about dead men. These men who came with the Long Hair (Custer) were as good men as ever fought. When they rode up their horses were tired and they were tired. When they got off their horses they could not stand firmly on their feet. They swayed to and fro, so my young men have told me, like limbs of cypresses in a great wind. Some of them staggered under the weight of their guns, but they began to fight at once. But by this time our camps were aroused, and there were plenty of warriors to meet them. They fired with needle guns. We replied with magazine guns—repeating rifles." Sitting Bull illustrated by patting his palms together with the rapidity of a fusilade. "Our young men rained lead across the river and drove the white braves back, and then rushed across themselves, and then they found that they had a good deal to do. The trouble was with the soldiers. They were so exhausted, and their horses bothered them so much, they could not take good aim. Some of their horses broke away from them, and left them to stand, and drop and die. All the men fell back, fighting and dropping. They could not fire fast enough, though. They kept in pretty good order. They would fall back across a gully and make a fresh stand beyond, on higher ground. There were a great many brave men in that fight, and from time to time, while it was going on, they were shot down like pigs. They could not help themselves. One of the officers fell where the last fight took place, where the last stand was made. The Long Hair stood like a sheaf of corn with all the ears fallen around him."
"Not wounded?"
"No."
"How many stood by him?"
"A few."
"When did he fall?"
"He killed a man when he fell. He laughed."
"You mean he cried out?"
"No; he laughed. He had fired his last shot."
"From a carbine?"
"No; a pistol."
"Did he stand up after he first fell?"
"He rose up on his hands and tried another shot, but his pistol would not go off."
"Was any one else standing up when he fell down?"
"One man was kneeling—that was all; but he died before the Long Hair."
Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men, and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff and preventing him giving aid to Custer.
The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · 22 November 1877
The Louisiana Democrat · Alexandria, La. · 28 November 1877
Nebraska Advertiser · Brownville, Neb. · 29 November 1877
The Pickens Sentinel · Pickens, S.C. · 29 November 1877
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory
Colonel Corbin of the Sitting Bull Commission reports private conversations with Sitting Bull, who described the Little Bighorn as a fair fight rather than a massacre. Sitting Bull said Custer's charge caused a brief panic but the Indians rallied, surrounded his outnumbered force, and killed them all after they refused to surrender, while Reno's separate force retreated upon finding the Indians in strength.
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 23 November 1877 · page 3
SITTI NG -B ULL, Washington, Nov. -14th.—Colonel Corbin, of the Sitting -Bull Commis sion, has returned to Washington. The rest of the commission will reach here on Monday next, when they will commence preparation for their re port. Corbin communicates some in teresting facts in connection with Sit ting Bull which have not heretofore been published. lie says the commis sion had a number of private inter views with Sitting Bull and found him to be very agreeable in his man ners and a very intelligent Indian. When the commission started*on their return trip Sitting 'Bull accompanied them for a number of miles, convers ing freely about the business of the commission and of the Custer cam paign.
See moreSee less
Sitting B'.ll repudiated the idea that Custer and his men were massacred, and says it was a fair fight, in which the desperation of Cus ter and the men-under his command made it necessary lor the Indians to kill them. Sitting Bull says Custer charged upon his camp with great im petuosity creating a temporary panic among them, but the Indians soon ral lied and outnumbering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to surround him. He says Custer and his men re fused to surrender, and fought until the last man was killed. He express ed great admiration for Custer's bra very and that of the men who were with him and was sorry that his refu sal to surrender made it necessary to put him to death. When the Indians discovered Major Reno, who was com manding the second division of Cus ter's'forces, they supposed it was the eritire force under command of Terry and immediately made preparations for retreat, sending their women and children forward. When Reno made his attack the Indians began to retreat and Sitting Bull savs had Reno f°l lowed them up.at that time lie might have captured-a larger part of their train. R«no, however, discovered the .. . , - , Indians were in such . force, and as ' oertaining the Cute of.Custer lell back j to the place at which he entrenched j himself, and from which lie was re iieved. An Old Fort —In Florida the old fort formerly called St. Marks, but since the . purchase from Spain, Fort Marion, is constructed of coquina stone. Thedbllowiug is an interest ing description of it: This fort is over a century «fid, hav-J ing been built in 1756 It cost wn O
An interview with Sitting Bull claims Major Reno was held back by only a small group of squaws and old men rather than confronted by strong warriors, allowing Custer's force to be wiped out. The report notes similar rumors circulated after the battle and says the matter deserves investigation by military authorities.
The Rock Island Argus · 23 November 1877 · page 2
Big I Kirn. It will be remembered that Custer divided bis forces in order to attack the Indian camp on two sides, leaving Capt BtHiteen (who was also stationed at Daven port at tin; time referred to above) in the rear with a small reserve. Reno's detach" moot made tho first assault; was driven buck end took refuge on the hills, where it was olterwards joined by Benteen, and neither took any further part in the fight. Custer went in and never came out again Reno claims in his official report that be did not know anything about Custer's engagement until long after it had ended in the terrible massacre.
See moreSee less
Sitting Bull says that the sound of the firing could be dis. tioctly heard on the hills to which Reno retreated, and that this officer, instead of being confrouted by a powerful baud or warriors, was actually held in check by a crowd of squaws and superannuated "bucks." Similar rumors, from various Hourccs, were in circulation immediately after the battle, and this repetition of them, in somewhat more definite shape, is calculated to rouse fcuspicions which ought long ago to have been hct at rest by the military authorities. Did Reno, as Sitting Bull affirms, retreat to the hills after only a trifling skirmish with the enemy? " Was he kept on the hills by a force which he might have overcome? In other words did ho fail to help Custer as he might have done at the outset, and could he have gone to his rescue later in the day? These arc questions which . demand a satisfactory answer. Maj. Reno was tried and condemned by court-martial last spring for insulting a lady, (the wile of one of the officers sta tioned with him over the river, and who made many friends in Davenport by her amiable and lady-liko deportment during her slay there,) and is now undergoing his sentence suspension from rank and pay for two years. It is to be regretted that bis behavior at the Little Big Horn could not have been officially investigated before the commission of an offence which has deprived him of popular sympathy. As matters now stand it would be unfair to accuse Lim of negligence or incapacity, aud yet his conduct is not entirely vindi cated in public estimation. "Bull pass,"said a minister in the West, recently, iu dismissing one theme of his sub ject to take up another. "Then 1 make it spadesl'.'yclled aman from the gallery, who wan dreatuiog the happy hours away in an imaginary game of euchre. It U needless to say that he went out on the next deal, being assisted by one of the doacons with a lull hand of clubs.
In an interview published over a year after the battle, Sitting Bull describes the chaos of the fight, claiming Custer's soldiers and horses arrived already exhausted and that his warriors used repeating rifles against the soldiers' needle guns. He praises the bravery of the dead soldiers while describing how his men gradually overwhelmed them.
The Ouachita Telegraph · 23 November 1877 · page 2
SITTING 'BULL'$' M'OiRY OF TlHE CUSyTERi MLASAtCR-' . NEW YOJlK, NoY. 1i, 1877, Sfuting'Balt' haq been talking wiA h.a correspondetit and telling the story of the Custer massacre. He says the fight was ,"hellathousand devils. The squaws were like flying birds the bull ets like humming. bpes. We thought we were whipped, not at first, but by and-by afterwards. No; your people were killed. I tell no lies about dead men. Those men who. came with the Long Hair were as good men as ever fought. When they, .rde. up; their horses were tired and they were tired.
See moreSee less
When they got off their -horses they could not stand firmly on their, feet, They swayed to and fro, so my youing men have told ,me, like. the limbs of cypresses in a great wind. Some of them staggered -idder" the weight of their guns, but they begas fight at once, but by this time-oitr, nps were aroused and there were plenty of war riors to meet them. 'They fired vilth needle guns, and, we replied with magazing guns and repetting.rifles."
This report relays a dramatic secondhand narrative, attributed to Sitting Bull, describing how Custer ('Long Hair') and his men made their final stand, fighting to the last man and falling one by one. It also claims that only squaws, old men, and children held Reno's force back from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Ouachita Telegraph · 23 November 1877 · page 2
CUSTER MASSACRE
lto. Police Jary. We, the undersigned committee of the Monroe Board of Trade and citizens of Ouachita perish, having our mutual not go off. Was any one else standing up when he fell down ? One malan iGvs kneeling; that was all, but he died be fore the ",Long Har." Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old nmen and little children In front of Renoo, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff, and preventing him -i - aid to Custer. DEAEl:Ie IN A ADVERTISEMENTS. that when they would get sober, tlit t there I nothing more said of t qivi the d ; e
This report recounts a secondhand, dramatized description of Custer's final moments—standing like 'a sheaf of corn,' laughing after being shot, and firing his pistol until it jammed. It also includes Sitting Bull's claim that only old men, women, and children faced Reno's troops, explaining why Reno could not reinforce Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Vicksburg Weekly Herald · 23 November 1877 · page 2
New Yonx, Nov. 10. Sitting Bull has been talking with a correspondent, and telling the ttory of tbe Custer mas sacre. He says the fight was " hell a thousand devils. Tbe tqtwt were like flying birds, tbe ballets like hamming bees. We thought we were whipped, not at first, but by-and-by, afterwards. No ; your people were killed. I tell no Ilea about dead men. Those men who came with tbe long bair were as good men as ever lougtiL When they rodo op their horses were tired and they tired.
See moreSee less
When they got off their horses tney contd not Hand firmly on tteir teet. iney twayed lo and fro, to my young men have told me, like tbe limbs of cypresses in a great wind. Some of them staggered under tbe weight or their guns, but tbey began lo fight at once, but by this time our campt were aroused, and there were plenty ot warrlort to meet tbem. They fired with needle guns, and we replied with magszino guns and repeating ri fles." Sitting Bull illustrated by putting hit palms together with the rapidity ol a fusilade. Our young men rained lead across Ihe river and drove the while braves back, aud then they rushed across themselves, and then they found that they had a good deal to do. Tbe troublo was with the soldiers. They were so exhausted and their horses bothered tbem so much they could a:t take good aim. Some of their horses broke away from them and they left them to stand and drop and die. All tbe men fell back fighting and drop ping. Tbey could not fire fast enough, they kept in pretty good order. They would fall bick across a coolie and make a fruh stand beyond on bighrr ground. There were a great many brave men iu that fight, and from time to time, while it was going on, tbey could sot help themselves. One by one the officers fell. Where the last fight took plsce, where the last stand was made, the "Long bair" stood like a sheaf of corn with all tbe ears fallen around bim. Not wounded? No. How miny stood by him? A few. Wheu did he fall? He killed a man. When he fell he laughed. Yon mean ho cried out '! No, bo laughed. He bad fired his last shot. From a carbine? No ; a pistol. Did be stand up after he first fell? Ho rose up on his hands, aud tried another shot, but bis pistol would not go off. Was any one else standing up wheu he fell down ? One man was kneeling ; that was all, but be died before the "Long bair." Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men and littlo children in front of Reno, keeping bim In bit strong posi tion on tbe bluff, and preventing him giving aid to Custer. Dr. Price's Atnerlcaa Perfantes. Dr. Price has been years perfecting these ixqulsite odors. They are not giveu a title that does not belong to them, but called just what they are, Unique Perfumes; and the makers are not Nsbamed of their naino or afraid to allot? tbem to stand on tb'lr own mer its. Burning of tbe Flltabnrg Dispatch Of fice l'lTTS.'iunii, Nov. IU. A tire in the large iron front building on Fifth av-t enue, known as tne Dispatch uuiiuing, destroyed the three upper stories. The lower portion was badly damaged by fire and water. Tbe upper story was occupied bj the Dispatch composing room, aud the type, presses, cases, and other paraphernalia of Iho bunnes, wore destroyed. Tbe third aud Icurlh floors were uaed as Lode-rooms by Odd Fellows, lied Men, and other eoci eties, and tho second floor was partially occupied by Insurance offices. Ou t lie street-floor was tho countiiic-room and husinc-s (Ti:e of the Dipach, and in ' tne rear Hie j ib omce 01 Anderson & Son. The building is considered a to tal lost. Tho Dispatch carried 125,000 lnsurau:e. The paper will issue, to morrow, having 6i en red other quarters and a new drcts. Health of Penaaoola aud Port Royal. Wa-iiimitos, Nov. IV. Cipt. Bel knap, Commandant of the Penencola Nivy Yard, reports to t ho Secretary of the Navy that the quarantine has been raised at that harbor. No case of yel low fever has been introduced into Ihe hay durlnz ihe recent hot weather. Tho Navy Department is also advised ol the ilinp .earaueo of yellow lever Ironi Purt Kjal and vicinity, and it is now pronounced by phy airi-atis cn the shoruas well, anJ navy nurxeoiis will he piTfi cily s.ifc In commuiiicaie with Pun Kijal. All quarantine regulationtmvc been removed. . m Oar ISnlly Ilrrad. We la'.iii that there is greater c:r tain'j ,,'Ml uniformity in the production of go. ut bread, bitcuit, cake, etc., in the usn 01 Dooley's 'at Powdek, aud that the articles made with it are more wholc'onic and dizestiblo than If mido with H'ty oilier kit d of yeast or baki ig pundt r. Test it by the only reliable and truthful tent, a n ial by the oven. We claim, also, that it is just as repremited, and just what tbe public expect it to be by the name under which it is told. Increased Oomsod for Stiver Coin rail. ug Iff ol Fractlonil Currency Preseuted for Redemption. Washington, Nov. 19 The Treas urers report showi a decrease of net revenue US 500,000 aud a decrease in expenilituris of nearly $19,000,000. Thin Is co.iipured with last year. IU p'Ttssu' 'in Increased iicmtnd for sil ver c in, caused by the ticccstifes of bu linm -ii tlil. HMt-oti nf )ear, it. spii'K'hiL' up, whiie the aiuunut ol frueiit tiil ciiireiicy p.c;ented for to dfi.i.i'i..n I rn Ulleu off from at) average. 01 $1,000010 a nuii'h during the liist our iuoniIh of 1 la id calondar year, to an avorugnd' lea than f 300,000 a month for the lat (our months. Sl'BrCillllK I-1' fie UtKALD.
A Chicago Times correspondent describes the 7th Cavalry, worn out from campaigning against the Nez Perce, encountered under Capt. Benteen's command at the Musselshell. He reflects on Custer's death, arguing Custer could have stopped the Nez Perce had he lived, and notes that soldiers widely credit Benteen with saving Reno's command from annihilation during the Little Bighorn fight.
Bismarck Tri-Weekly Tribune · 23 November 1877 · page 2
The Seventh Calvary's "Work. C. S. Diehl's Letter to Chicago Times. On the afternoon of the 27th the com raissioners reached the mouth of the Musselshell, where Gen. Miles crossed the river with his force when he started in pursuit of the Nez Perces. "We found the 7:h cavalry in camp at this point, under the command of Capt". Benteen. All the field officers had taken passage on a steamer and returned home several weeks previous. The com mand looked badly used up, having been in the 6eld continually since April.
See moreSee less
The horses were worn ou' those that were still i* condition for service, but nearly one-third were dis mounted, their horses having either been killed or become unfit for use by the hard campaigning and lack of for age. The 7th has had another hard year of it. The command has not been cleverly handled, and it is no disre spect to say of au old soldier who has rown gray in the service in other kinds of campaigning that be is unfit for In dian fighting. The Nez Perces could never have crossed the path of Custer if he had been at the head of the tweh hundred men, and been as near the tribe as Sturgis was. I heard one cf the young officers remark, "Well, if the old fellow had stayed at home, ar left the command with Benteen, Miles would havo lost some of the glory of the Nez Perces fight." I heard a great many older officers express the same opinion. There i3 hardly a soldier on the plains but who credits Benteen with having saved Reno's command in the Custer fight from absolute annihilation after be had commenced his retreat, and his troops had been stampeded. The 7th expected to remain in camp at the mouth of the Musselshell until the 1st inst", when they would commence the journey along the east bank of the
The item relays Sitting Bull's claim that Reno and his soldiers hid on a cliff, frightened merely by squaws and a few old men, while Custer's entire command was wiped out by the warriors. This secondhand account purports to explain Reno's retreat during the battle.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Cambria Freeman · 23 November 1877 · page 2
Lock Haven last September. According to Sitting Bull's account of the Rosebud riht, Reno and his men re mained on a cliff terrified by the prepuce of the sqriawsanda few old men, while Custer and his whole com maud were being butchered by the savages. Troy, N. Y., is excited over a child stealing case, the six year-old son of Chas. Cannon, a mechanic of that place, havine been brought to New Yoik by a friend, and having, together with the custodian, disap peaierl, leaving no trace behind. The latest sensation in the oil regions is a well near Milletstowu, which is said to be producing refined oil.
See moreSee less
It is of a green ish cas', clear as though passed through a retoit. The most remarkable thing about it is, that it has a fire test of over 110G. The '-fire fiend" had full swinjj last week, and an aggregate of sevcial million dollars' worth of property was destroyed at Chicago, Boarden City, Massachusetts, and other places, while the Pittsburgh blaze of Sunday morning adds $ o'J.OCO to the list of losses. It isn't every man cf fifty-three that can tm 11 .1 fsomersault on a rope eighty feet above the ground. A London coi ivs pomiciit who saw Bloudin recently :.t the
A New York Herald correspondent interviews Sitting Bull, who describes Custer's plan to attack from two sides and how Reno's force was repulsed first. Sitting Bull explains the Sioux mistook Reno's retreat for a mere decoy, concentrated warriors against Custer, and praises the bravery of both sides.
and one clerk. Mr. Davis intimated that he would so amend the resolution, and the Senate ad journed. Thclnslrr Ihjiii. SITTING ULLI'S STORV Ol TUE UASSVtRE. A New York Ihrald corrc-rndent re ports a prolix interview with Sitting Hull. From his statement of tho Custer fight, the llttdld finds that Custer's plan was to attack the Indian campsimultaneoiisly on two sides Reno attacked first and was driven luck, and Custer's attack followed. Sitting Bull imagined that Reno's command, which bad retreated to the heijihts, were an insignifi cant handful lelt there by Custer for obser vation, and thought it safe to withdiflw all the warriors uud concentrate against Custer.
See moreSee less
On the side toward Reno there were left only squaws, children and superan nuated men. It these had been attacked, mm of the Sioux warriors who were over whelming Custer would have been detached for the defence of the squaws, and the fate of the battle mielit have been diflcrent. Sitting Bull says the noise of the firing was distinctly heard by the squaws confront ing Reno and must have been heard by Reno himself. Sitting Bull mistook Reno for Custer and had no idea he was between tho two furees. Sittinc Bull said tbe men who came with "Long Hair" (Custer) were as good men as ever fought. When they rode up, their hordes were tired and they were urea. When tbey got ofl from their horses they could not stand firmly on their feet, but tbey becan to fiirht at once. But by this time there were plenty of warriors to meet them. When "Lonir Hair" found he was so out numbered and threatened on his flanks, be took the best course. The bugle blew lo fall back. All the men fell back fighting and dropping. They kept in pretty good order. Somo great chiet must luivc com manded them. They would fall back and make a fresh stand beyond on nignergrounu Tber were no cowards on cither "ide. -no: died on horseback. All were dismounted. Sitting Bull said he was told that Custer died Jast, standing lite a sncai oi corn wuu all the cars fallen around him. A few stood by him. He killed a man when he fell, and laughed when he had fired his last shot from his pistol. He rose upon bis hands and tried another shot, but his pistol would not go off. One man was kneeling when Custer fell, hut he died before Custer, Sitting Bull says "Long Hair" was not scalped, becauso fcp was a great ch:ct.
Sitting Bull, interviewed by a New York World correspondent at Fort Walsh, offers an account of the Little Bighorn fight that differs in key details from his earlier statement to a Herald reporter. He describes luring Custer into a ravine, surrounding his force, and claims a warrior named Maneekoli-konuah shot Custer himself.
TueCistlk Fight. Sitting Bull, in a interview with a correspondent of the New York U'orJ, ut Fort Walsh, gave the fol lowing account of the Custer fight, which will be observed differs in important partic ulars from that previously given to the IhratJ correspondent. Sitting Bull said in rciotisc to a remark in which tho fight was alluded to as a "massacre" "If Custer had killed all my people the Americans would have said ho bad won a great figlit. I d. not massacre Custer. He was a brave man. but be bad no caution. Custer was brave but he was careless. He rushed upon us,
The report recounts Sitting Bull's dramatic description of Custer's last stand, describing how Custer fell while laughing after firing his last pistol shot, surrounded by only a few men. Sitting Bull also claims that only squaws, old men and children faced Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Osceola Times · 24 November 1877 · page 1
NITTINU BULL Trll« All II? Known About (hr <*Ma|rr Sitting Bull has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Custer ma sacre. He says lite tight wax " hell with a thousand devils. Tlu wiuaws were like flying-birds : the bullets like humming-bee-- We thought we were whipperl, not at first, but by and by ; afterward, no. Your (teople were killed ; I tell no lies sltout dead men. There men who camo with the Ixmg-Hai'were as good men as ever fought. When they rode up their horses were tired, and they were tired.
See moreSee less
When they got off their horses they could not stain! firmly on their feet; they swayed to and fro—so my young man have told me—like the limits of the cyprets in a great wind. Some of them staggered under the weight ol their guns, but they began to fight at once ; but by this time our camps were aroused and there were plenty of warriors to meet them. They fired with needle guns, and we replied with magazine-guns —refieating rifles.” Sitting Bull illus trated, by putting his palms together with rapidity, of the fusilade. “Our young men rained lead across the river anti drove the white braves back, anil then they rushed across themselves, and they found that they had a good ileal to do. The trouble with the soldiers was that th«y were so exhaust.>d, and their homes bothered them so much that they could not take good aim. Nome of their horses broke away from them, nnd left | them to stand and drop and die. All the men fell back fighting nnd dropping. : I'hey could not fire fast enough, though : they kept in pretty good order, 'l liey would tall back across acoulie, ami make j a fresh stand beyond, on higher ground., : I'here were a great many brave men in j | that fight, and from tune to time, while | I it was going on they were shot down like |>igx. They could not help themselvesj t tne by one the officers fell. Where the last fight took place, where the last stand I was made, the l»ng-llair stood "k* JI sheaf of corn with all the cars fallen on, him.” “ Not wounded ? " "No.” “How many stood by hint'! ” “A few.” “ When ; did he fall ’ ’ “He killed a man M hen ■ he fell he laughed.' “ You mean he I cried out?” "No; he laughed. He ha« fired his last shot.” " From a cathine t “ •‘ No ; a pistol.” " Did he stand up after I he first fell ? ” " He rose up on his hands I and tried another shot, out hi" pt"' ol i I would not go off” “ Was anv one else standing up when he fell down” ’ , man was kneeling, that wax »"i “ ul “* I died before the Long-Hair." . I Kitting Bull says there were on y I squaws, old men and little children I front ot General Reno, keeping hjm t ! hit strong position on tbe bluff, and p j venting him giving aid to Custer. Declined with Thanka. iici-itiiew si." We are obliged to the New Art I’ublication company for one of there exquisite chromo., but we feel <™n ■ pelted to return II with the request hM
Sitting Bull, Spotted Eagle, and other chiefs in Canada reject overtures to meet an American commission seeking their return, despite pressure from Major Walsh. After days of negotiation, Sitting Bull agrees only to a token meeting at Fort Walsh, which is expected to fail regardless.
The New York Herald · 24 November 1877 · page 4
muking terms. CANADIAN KFKOKTS. It was alter this conclusion bad been reached and after word had boon sent to Major Walsh tbst tbey do. slred to be let alone that Major Walsh reoeived an ofilcial despatch from Ottawa requesting him to com municate with Sitting Bull and see II ho could not be Induced to moot the Americans. Major Walsh, accord ing to bis instructions, left tor Sitting Bull's camp, reached there on the 7th ol Ootftbor and delivered his messago, but, though courteously recoived, he was in formed that tho determination previously reached would not be a'lerod.
See moreSee less
Wlih vory great patience and diplomacy tbo Major hung around tho cafnp lor tbreo days and Snully succeeded iu getting Sitting Bull to attend at Fort Walsh nad hear wlmt Iho Commis sioners bud to say. Tho propositiou submitted by tho M ijor was lor Silting Bull to moot the Commissioners about forty miles south of Fort Walsh, just a lew yards north of tho bouudary liuo. This proposal was rejectod because it was suspected that tho Americans would prove trouoherous. Therefore Major Walsh submitted a further proposal lo hold tho meeting in side of Fori Walsb, guaranteeing personal safety nud stipulating that tho meotiug would bo a more matter ol lorm, au act of courtesy to tho "great mother," which, altor threo days' debating was aceopted. Thus tho luilure ol the mooting was mado a lorcgono con clusion. Wltr THB INDIANS MKT Tim COMMISSION.
A writer who authored Custer's biography describes how he initially accepted official reports blaming Custer's own rashness for the disaster. He now reveals correspondence suggesting the real cause may have been the timidity and disobedience of two subordinate officers.
The New York Herald · 24 November 1877 · page 4
THE DEATH OF CUSTER. WHO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE LITTLE BIG HORN DISASTER?
WHO WAS BEWONStBLE FOB TUB LITTLH BIO HORN DISABTEB? To us Eoitob or thb Hbbalo:? It hu Men the lorluuo ot the Hkrau) within the naet ifw years to bring lo light many tru.bs and ??1" mauy mysteries ol eeience aud history. The latost in stance ol your paper's enterprise happens to be one wbcb eonoeras me nearly, in common with others who admiro bravery and uoblluy ol character and aro resolute In the pursuit ol truA. Nearly oighteeu mouths ago there perished In the wllns ol the North west an officer wtoo was pronounced by General Torry lo be "tbo flower of the American army."
See moreSee less
He died in the midst ol his mon. of whom n>ne ever camo buck to tell the tale, and the mystory that shrouded bis fate seemed for a lone time to be Impenetrable. It was my lortune to be assigned ibe task ol writing t ue biography ol this ollloer?ihe lain General Custer? and I did my work to tho best of my ability. I be most d'tllcull part of that work was the ascertainment of the truth concerning the battle In which Custer and liis detachment suffered dea h. lho only pabllo record accessible was tho report ol the officers next iu command ol the Seventh cavalry, and to wUom C'ustor had assigned a duty lu the attack on tue lnd au tamp, which, on that officer's own showing, bo had laiied to perform. The secondary evidence wa? wulalned id tho reports ol ouster's superiors iu military r.init dealing with hearsay etaiements. AU tuesc reporia unituo in ascriblug Custer's death to his own rash uoss, and some charged him with disobedience of
A half-breed scout named Baptiste claimed to have met an American calling himself Sergeant Ryan of the 7th Cavalry held prisoner in Sitting Bull's camp after the Custer fight. The story was treated skeptically, as Canadian officers who visited the camp could not corroborate it, and the report notes it is likely a sensational tale.
The Iola Register · 24 November 1877 · page 4
The story was given little credence at the time, owing to its great improba bility, but it is related for what it is worth. The half-breed stated that soon after he entered the village ho was ac costed by a man in full savage costume, who addressed him in English, and.caid that he was an American, and had been captured during the Custer tight, and kept a prisoner un til that time. He stated that his name was Ryan, and that he had been a Sergeant in the 7th Cavalry. Bap tiste asked him whv he did not escape, to which he replied that he had made the attempt several times, but was re captured.
See moreSee less
Sitting-Bull interrupted the conversation, and carried Baptiste away, and he did not have an opportunity to converse with the man again. The sto ry came to the ears of Gen. Terry, who promised to investigate the matter from the information given him, and endeav or to learn whether any one answering his description had been reported as killed or missing with Custer's com mand. The Canadian officers at Fort Walsh, who had frequently visited the camp of Sitting-Bull, failed to corrobo rate the story; and nothing has been learned since to give it the slightest probability. Those who heard it from the scout, credited it to his desire to en tertain his hearers with a sensational story. Nothing could be more improb ble than that Sitting-Bull, intensely as he is known to hate Americans, should tolerate one of them in his camp. That he permitted one of Custer's band to live," is almost beyond belief. Never theless, the story came back with tho Commission, and will doubtless go the rounds of the papers. There will be as many romances about Ryan, the white chief of Sitting-Bull's Sioux, as there were a month or two ago about Osman, the American Turk.
The report describes Sitting Bull's departure from Fort Walsh to lead his people to a reservation in Canada. Before leaving, he gave a vivid, poetic account to a journalist describing the Battle of Little Bighorn and the death of Custer's soldiers.
Der Deutsche Correspondent · 24 November 1877 · page 7
Custer's Tsd. „Sitting Bull" begab sich von Fort Walfh nach feinem Lager am Wood-Mountain, um von da „fein Volk" nach der ihm von der ca nadischen Regierung angewiesenen „Reserva tion" am Red Deer-River zu führen, wo es Büffel und anderes Wild und Fische in Menge, aber auch fünf FortS und eine große Anzahl den Siovx nicht sehr halder BlackseekJndianer giebt, jo daß „Sitting Bull" und d:e Seinen keine Nahrnngssorgen haben wer den, aber Ordnung halten müssen. Bor seinem Abzüge hat „Sitting-Bull" im Gespräche mit einem Zeitungsma-me den Kamps am Little-Big>Horn und besonders den Tod Custer's auf folgende malerische Weise beschrieben: „Wie fliegende Vögel waren unsere Squaws, uud wie Hummeln flogen und summten die Kugeln.
See moreSee less
Eure Krieger wurden getödtet. Ich spreche keine Lügen über todte Männer. Die Krieger, die mit „Langhaar" gegen uns zogen, waren tapfere Männer. Als sie gegen uns heranritten, waren ihre Pferde müde und sie ebenfalls; als sie von Die Art und Weise, sich photogra phiren zu lassen. Ueber Photographie im Allgemeinen ist schon sehr viel geschrieben worden, doch ist es wohl noch Niemandem eingefallen, sich über die Verhaltungsmaßregeln, welche die zu pho tographireude Person zu beobachten hat, nä her auszulassen, obwohl gerade das Verhal ten der Person mir dem Gelingen der Pholo graphie in der innigsten Verbindung steht. Die meisten Leute werden es kaum glauben, wenn man ihnen versichert, daß bei einer Mehrzahl der Photographie'!,, welche schlecht ausfallen, nrchl elwa die Unfähigkeil des Photographen, sondern nur zu häufig die Stimmung, Naftlosigkeit und Gefallsucht der abzunehmenden Person die Schuld lragen. Der Photograph muß natürlich, soviel es in seinen Kräften stellt, diese Uebetstände beseiti gen oder ooch wenigstens zu mildern verfu chen; jedoch läßtDres die Höflichkeit, mit wel cher er ferne Kuirsen zu behandeln gezwungen ist, nichl lmmcr in genügendem Maßgabe zu. Ein Manu ist in dieser Hinsicht am Leichte sten zu lenken ijuo erlaubt dem Photographen eher, ihn in eine Stellung zu versetzen, wel che er in seiner Unerfahreuheit vielleicht nicht für die beschält; doch gibt es auch unter den Männern manche Eingebildete, welche in nachdenkenden odergar geistreich fein sollenden Posituren dargestellt fein wollen, ihren Mie nen dabei d>e Ausdrücke und ihren verschiedenen die unna lürlichslenStellungen geben wollen und, dann muß der Photograph feiue ganze Ueberre lung. dungsgabe aufbieten, um sie von ihrem lä cherlichen Vorhaben abzubringen. In B.zug aus Damen muß diese UeberreSungsgabe noch viel mehr in Auwendung gebrachr werden. Ein ungewöhnlicher Haarfchmuck, ein nichts sagendes und nicht durch natürliche Ursachen hervorgerufenes Lächeln, ein durch die unge woqnte Stellung herrührender Ausdruck des Mißbehagens, ein Verziehen oder gar eine 'versuchte Verkleinerung des Mundes, ein freundlich sein sollender, aber durch Ueberlrei.' bung dnmm werdender Ausdruck des Gesich tes, alles Diefes sind Urjachen, durch welche ein Bild verdorben wird, und über welche der Photograph wenig E-ufluß auszuüben im Stande ist. Hat sich nachher die phötogra phirte Person wieder m ihrer gewöhnlichen Weise das Haar frisirt, haben ihre Gesichts, züge wieder ihr gewohntes Aussehen ange nommen, jo ist das Bild natürlich nicht ge troffen, uns dieje Personen sind dann die Er sten, welche dem Pholographen die Schuld geben. Auch hat die Stimmung, welche die abzunehmende Person von Hauje mitbringt, sehr viel mit dem Gelingen oder Nicht Gekn» gen ihresßildeS zu thun. Befindet sich dieselbe in einer glücklichen Stimmung, jo hat der Photograph leichtes Spiel nnd braucht nur darauf zu sehen, drefeStimmung zu erhalten, nnd das Bild wird gut. Kommt die Perjon aber, von häuslichen Widerwärtigkeiten und Sorgen mißmuthig gemacht, so können weder die besten artistrjchen Anstrengungen des Pho tographen, noch die größten Bemühungen ih rerseits, ihrem Gesichte einen angenehmen Ausdruck zu geben, das Bild zu einem guten machen. . i . Den meisten Takt und Scharfsinn und die unermüdlichste Geduld erfordert jedoch das Photographien von Kindern. Tage-, ja Wochenlang zuvor wurde das Kind"auf das große Ereigniß vorbereitet. Es wurde ihm wiederholt und dringend eingeprägt, „still zu halten," „nicht bange zn fein" und „ganz ge nau Das zu thun, was der Mann sagt." Die Folge davon ist, daß das Kind sich mit innerem Beben, das durch das auf es gerich tele Instrument nicht verringert wird, hinsetzt oder stellt, steif wie ein Stock und nnt Schrecken,m Antlitz die lange erwartete Op eration besteht oder gar, durch die Ermahnun. gen anwesender Tanten, Großmütter oder Nachbarinnen verwirrt, durch schnelleZuckung oder veränderte Stellung das Bild verdirbt oder auch eine wiederholte Abnahme ilöthig macht. Kinder sollten in keiner Weise von den Eltern aus das Photographiren vorberei tet werden; die Behandlung derselben sollte ganz unb gar dem Photographen überlassen bleiben, welcher vermöge seiner Ecsahrnng be deutend besser im Stande ist, zu beurtheilen, was er zum Erfolge seiner Arbeit bedarf. Durch Beobachtung der in diesen Zeilen enthaltenen Regeln wird nicht nur die Mühe des Photographen um ein Bedeutendes ver ringert, sondern auch feinen Kuuden ein viel besser getroffenes Bild gesichert.
The report covers passage of an Army Bill setting troop strength at 25,000, criticizing congressional 'demagoguery' and timidity in the debate. It invokes the Custer massacre as proof that insufficient military numbers led to disaster, alongside domestic riots and Mexican border threats as justification for a larger standing army.
The Republican · 24 November 1877 · page 4
We may get in to a war with Mexico at any moment, and it would be a humiliating thing to have our soil invaded by such acontemptibic pow er and we utterly helpless for weeks or months before it. We have seen brave Custer die, he and his gallant
Colonel Corbin reports that Sitting Bull, interviewed during the commission's return trip, described the Little Bighorn as a fair fight rather than a massacre. Sitting Bull claimed Custer's charge caused a brief panic before the Indians rallied and surrounded his vastly outnumbered force, who fought to the last man rather than surrender.
The Republican · 24 November 1877 · page 4
Sitting Bell and Custer.— Col. Corbin, of the Sitting Bull Commis sion, communicates some interesting facts in connection with Sitting Bull, which have not heretofore been pub lished. Ho says that the commission had a number of private interviews with Sitting Bull, and found him to be very agreeable in his manners and a very intelligent Indian.- When the commission started on their return trip Sitting Bull accompanied them for a number of miles, con versing freely about the business of the commission and of the Custer campaign. Sitting Bull repudiated the idea that Gen.
See moreSee less
Custer and his men were massacred, and says it was i a fair fight, in which the desperation ! of Custer and tlie men under bis com mand made it necessary fmr the InI diaiis to kill them. Sitting Bull says Custer charged upon bis camp with great impetuosity, creating a temporary panic among them ; but the Indians soon rallied, am: out numbering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to surround him. He | says that Custer and his men refused jto surrender, and fought until the I last mail was killed. Ho expressed
In a published interview, Sitting Bull describes the chaos and intensity of the fight against Custer's men, saying the soldiers were exhausted and their horses unsteady. He insists he tells no lies about the dead, praising the bravery of the soldiers who fought despite being worn out.
American Citizen · 24 November 1877 · page 2
Sitting Bull's Story of the Caster Massacre. Sot Yokk, Nov. 10. Sitting Bull has beeu talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Custer massacre.
A dispatch reports that Major Reno, questioned about claims attributed to Sitting Bull concerning the Little Bighorn fight, declined to discuss the matter at length, saying the officers involved and their superiors already understood the facts. Reno then outlines his movements during the battle—separating from Custer, attacking the village, retreating across the river, and being joined by Captain Benteen on the bluffs.
The Northern Star · 24 November 1877 · page 1
ticulnr point. He believes. however, Itlnit Custer intended to cross the creek innd come to his rescue, and tlnit. he ‘ wns only prevented li'oiii doing so by n. niistnke in the topography ot'the coun try. He hsii reason to think. whileho
This report details Major Reno's official account of the battle, describing his retreat across the creek, his junction with Captain Benteen, and his theories about how Custer became separated and was overwhelmed. Reno speculates that Custer tried to find a crossing but was blocked by terrain and overwhelming Indian numbers, ultimately perishing with his men before Reno's own forces joined with Benteen.
The Northern Star · 24 November 1877 · page 1
in it, and lny their Silitl‘littl‘i iindirl whose Hillll‘lvlbitlll their 11 poiis passed. i lle tittiiehes very little iiiiportunmr to thol statement of Hitting Boil, ei-‘pteiuilyi Eliot [not in which the I'iiit'i nuys that the long-huired chief, whom he supposed to he Reno. utter (Towing the Little Big Horn lu-enine li'iuht. tied :it the ramp oil the old men. mount-t anul p:ippoo.~e.~,i lie siiyn tlnit on the inoriiing ot'tlie nit-1 tle he si-puruteil lioin (luster \\itli n dei tutehun-nt of three eoiiipnnies nnd ii} party of tit'nits, and with no “other orders li'oni hiiii tit-into Mind; in villuge in the Woods on the south Siilt' ol‘ the Little Big Horn. He moved oll'oti tlnit trnil and did its ordered, heingtold that
The report relays statements from Col. Corbin of the Sitting Bull commission, describing private interviews in which Sitting Bull explained his version of the Custer fight. Sitting Bull denied it was a massacre, claiming Custer attacked his camp, was surrounded by vastly superior numbers, and refused to surrender, while also praising Custer's bravery.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Puget Sound Dispatch · 24 November 1877 · page 1
VOLUME VII. —————_— A ~ The Custer Battle. Nrw YoaK, Nov. l4.—The Times’ Washington special says, Col. Corbin, of the Sitting Bull commission, has returned to Washington. The rest of the commission will reach here Monday next, when they will commence preparation for their report. Corbin communicates some interesting iacts in connec tion with Sitting Bull, which have not heretofore been pub lished. He says the commission had a number of private inter .views with Sitting Bull, and found him to be very agreeable in his manner, and a very intel ligent Indian.
See moreSee less
When the com mission started on their return trip, Sitting Bull accompanied them for a number of miles, con versing freely about the business of the commission and of the Custer campaign. Sitting Bull repudiated the idea that Custer and his men were massacred, and says it was a fair fight, in which the desperation of Custer and the men under his command madeit necessary for the Indians to kill them. Sitting Bull says Custer charged upon his camp with great impetuosity, creating a temporary panic amongst them, but the Indians soon rallied, and, outnumbering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to surround him. He says Custer and his men refused to surrender, and fought until the last man was killed. He expressed great ad miration for Custer’s bravery and that of the men who were with him, and was sorry that his refusal to surrender made it nec essary to put him to death.— When the Indians discovered Major Reno, who was command ing the second dinsion of Cus ter's forces, they supposed it,was the entire force under the com inand of Terry, and immediately made preparations for retreat, sending their women and chil dren forward. When Reno made his attack, the Indians began to retreat, and Sitting Bull says, had Reno followed them up at that time, he might have captur ed the larger part of their train. Reno, however, discovered that the indians were in such force, and ascertaining the fate of Cus ter, fell back to a place where he entrenched himself and from which he was relieved. ____.....,___ Cincinnatti Girdle :—“ And now there secm to be many re publicans who think the Presi dent is the whole government and can administer it as hepleas es, and that if he does not ad minister it as a straight repnhli can party government it ls be cause he is unfaithful to the par ty. “'Ould it not be well for these to read that much talked of but little understood docu ment, the Constitution of the United States, to see what are the powers of the Executive, and what of the Legislature, and how much power a hostile House of Representatives has to block the wheels of government, to say nothing of a questionable Senate? ” ————<-..>—-——— A FARMER having cattle tres passing upon his grass fields, posted up the following: -‘ NO - any man‘s or woman’s cows or oxen gets in these here otes, his or her tale will he cut off as the case may be. lam a Christian and pa mi taxes, but darn a man who lets his critters run luos, say I.” ' ___4.>___- “ I shouldn’t care much about the bugs,” said a thin, pale ledger to his landlady, “ but the fact is, ma’am, I hain’t got the blood to spare.” .—.——-—<-.~>—————- 'l‘he Palouse Gazette, published at Colfax, Whitman county, says that within the last two months the fer ryman st Penewaws has passed 400 families, averaging five persons to a family—lll bound for the Palouse country.
In an 1877 interview, Sitting Bull describes the Little Bighorn battle as a fair fight rather than a massacre, claiming Custer's men refused to surrender and were overwhelmed by vastly superior numbers. He also explains why Reno's retreat failed to capture the Indian camp's retreating train.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.
Wrong
Puget Sound Dispatch · 24 November 1877 · page 1
VOLUME VII. —————_— A ~ The Custer Battle. Nrw YoaK, Nov. l4.—The Times’ Washington special says, Col. Corbin, of the Sitting Bull commission, has returned to Washington. The rest of the commission will reach here Monday next, when they will commence preparation for their report. Corbin communicates some interesting iacts in connec tion with Sitting Bull, which have not heretofore been pub lished. He says the commission had a number of private inter .views with Sitting Bull, and found him to be very agreeable in his manner, and a very intel ligent Indian.
See moreSee less
When the com mission started on their return trip, Sitting Bull accompanied them for a number of miles, con versing freely about the business of the commission and of the Custer campaign. Sitting Bull repudiated the idea that Custer and his men were massacred, and says it was a fair fight, in which the desperation of Custer and the men under his command madeit necessary for the Indians to kill them. Sitting Bull says Custer charged upon his camp with great impetuosity, creating a temporary panic amongst them, but the Indians soon rallied, and, outnumbering Custer ten to one, they were enabled to surround him. He says Custer and his men refused to surrender, and fought until the last man was killed. He expressed great ad miration for Custer’s bravery and that of the men who were with him, and was sorry that his refusal to surrender made it nec essary to put him to death.— When the Indians discovered Major Reno, who was command ing the second dinsion of Cus ter's forces, they supposed it,was the entire force under the com inand of Terry, and immediately made preparations for retreat, sending their women and chil dren forward. When Reno made his attack, the Indians began to retreat, and Sitting Bull says, had Reno followed them up at that time, he might have captur ed the larger part of their train. Reno, however, discovered that the indians were in such force, and ascertaining the fate of Cus ter, fell back to a place where he entrenched himself and from which he was relieved. ____.....,___ Cincinnatti Girdle :—“ And now there secm to be many re publicans who think the Presi dent is the whole government and can administer it as hepleas es, and that if he does not ad minister it as a straight repnhli can party government it ls be cause he is unfaithful to the par ty. “'Ould it not be well for these to read that much talked of but little understood docu ment, the Constitution of the United States, to see what are the powers of the Executive, and what of the Legislature, and how much power a hostile House of Representatives has to block the wheels of government, to say nothing of a questionable Senate? ” ————<-..>—-——— A FARMER having cattle tres passing upon his grass fields, posted up the following: -‘ NO - any man‘s or woman’s cows or oxen gets in these here otes, his or her tale will he cut off as the case may be. lam a Christian and pa mi taxes, but darn a man who lets his critters run luos, say I.” ' ___4.>___- “ I shouldn’t care much about the bugs,” said a thin, pale ledger to his landlady, “ but the fact is, ma’am, I hain’t got the blood to spare.” .—.——-—<-.~>—————- 'l‘he Palouse Gazette, published at Colfax, Whitman county, says that within the last two months the fer ryman st Penewaws has passed 400 families, averaging five persons to a family—lll bound for the Palouse country.
A letter from the Little Bighorn battlefield reports that soldiers' graves are in good condition, noting that bones found scattered by Colonel Brackett's force in September were animal remains, not human. The writer insists it is wrong to claim the dead soldiers' bones lie unburied and bleaching in the sun, as they were interred with care.
The New Dominion · 24 November 1877 · page 1
It would seem that not only is the cli mate of Iceland growing so cold that grain cannot ripen there, but that of Scandinavia and Western Europe is be coming more severe. This is due, it is supposed, to the steady descent of the ice of the far North upon the shores of Iceland. It has been ascertained that the temperature of (Greenland was once much more mild than at present. Plants have been discoVerd in a fossil state there which cannot now present a sign of of life. In the Atlantic, also, ice has been found much further south than formerly. Is another ice age slowly mak ing its approach ? A recent ietter from the Custer bat tle-ground on the Little Big Horn River
Before leaving Fort Walsh for his new reservation, Sitting Bull gave a journalist a vivid account of the Little Bighorn battle, describing the exhaustion of Custer's 'Long Hair' troopers as they dismounted to fight. He said most Lakota warriors fought Custer directly while only women, old men, and children faced Reno's besieged position on the hill.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 26 November 1877 · page 7
Custer's Tod. Sitting Bull begab sich von Fort Walsh nach seinem Lager am Wood Mountain, um von da „sein Volt“ nach der ihm von der canadischen Regierung angewiesenen „Reservation“ am Red Deer River zu füh— reu, wo es Büffel und anderes Wild und Fische in Menge, aber auch fünf Forts und eine große Anzahl den Sioux nicht sehr hoider Blackfeet-Indianer giebt, so daßSit ting Bull und die Seinen keine Nahrungs sorgen haben werden, aber Ordnung hal— ten müssen. Vor seinem Abzuge hatSittingßull im Gespräch mit einem Zeitungsmanne den Kampf am Little Big Horn und besonders den Tod Custer's auf folgende malerische
A scout named Baptiste claims he met an American calling himself Sergeant Ryan of the 7th Cavalry held prisoner in Sitting Bull's camp after the Custer fight. The paper notes the story was given little credence at the time but relates it 'for what it is worth.'
Bismarck Tri-Weekly Tribune · 26 November 1877 · page 2
THE WHITE SIOUX.
Among other things Baptists related a story to tho effect that an American soldier was being kept as a prisoner in the camp of Sitting Bull. The story was given bat little.credenceiat the time, ow ing to the great improbabilityof itslbeing true but it is related now for what it is worth. The half-breed stated that soon after he entered the village he w«s accost ed by a man in full savage costume who addrassed him ia English, and said that he was an American, and had been captured during the Custer fight, and kept a prisoner until that timo.
See moreSee less
He stated that his name' was Ryanj anii that he had been a sergeant' in the Ttii cavalry. Bhptiste asked bim why bo' did not escape, to which he replied that he bad mado the attempt several times, but was recaptured. Sitting
A half-breed scout relayed a story that a captured 7th Cavalry sergeant named Ryan was being held alive in Sitting Bull's camp since the Custer fight. Investigators, including Canadian officers at Fort Walsh, could not corroborate the tale and dismissed it as an improbable sensational rumor.
Bismarck Tri-Weekly Tribune · 26 November 1877 · page 2
THE WHITE SIOUX
.T Bill inicrrupt&!~fibs cosTcrsatfon/aiid cjmfcf.Batiste a#»y, bedid not have sp opportunity to coaTorse with th* again. Xb« story camo to tho ears of Geo. Tarry, who promised to iaTMtigate tho 0 attar (ran the in formation givan to hint, and andaavor to learn whethar any one anawaring his description had been rap or ted as killed or missing, with Custer's command. The Canadian officers at Fort Walsh, who had frequently -risiied the camp of Sitting Bull, tailed to corroborate the the story and nothing tu»s l?*rn ed since to give it th* »iightest proba bility.
See moreSee less
Those who heard it !rivu the scout, credited it tt» h'» desire to enter tain his hearer* witii a sensational story. Nothing could be ir.or# iajproba ble that Sitting Bull, intansaly as ha is known to hata th-i Americans, would tolerate one of them in his camp. That he permitted one of Custer's band to live, rs almost beyond b'elief. Never tfaeie^ar-the story carnf Jiaclc with' the' cpAi.migstpn, an3 ip, is ill doubtless gQ tjoe. i'w ada of the newspapers. There vriL u*-. sPAay.romances, about ItyaR tte :nicf q/ tfce Siouxj-is there vawin-TJi« i' rwcago-aboutOsiHaiij til*- A:ii:r' ..it
A Catholic abbot recounts conversations with Sitting Bull about the Little Bighorn battle, in which Sitting Bull claims the exhausted, surprised soldiers were killed mainly with war-clubs to conserve scarce ammunition. Sitting Bull also says none of the Sioux recognized Custer during the fight and that Sioux losses were trivial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Chicago Daily Tribune · 27 November 1877 · page 7
THE CUSTER MASSACRE
The Last Ditch. Rakicakbi, 111., Nov. 23.—811 as Sutherland, of this city, la engaged lu digging a ditch seven and a half miles long, from the tract of swamp-laud hi Newton County, lud., belong ing to Uail, the Cincinnati bruwvr, to tbo Jro quuis River, in the northeastern part of Kauka kvo County, 111. The ditch will bo eighteen feet wide ut the bottom, tlurty feet wide at the tuu, and will be four feet deep. At one puinQiu wison closes.... The schr E. P. Itorcc hid her malntopmast broken off yesterday by coll Dion wl»h the schr Ellen Spry.
See moreSee less
The accident happened In the main river ...Tho Lbvl Grant had Her jib boom broken on the lambcr market yesterdav.... The prop Egyptian got aground near the mouth of the harbor, and had to lighten some of her cargo yesterday before she coaid getaway from port.... Tho canal-erhoonm Pulaski, Folger, and Nassau are among tho late arrivals from Oswego. They brought coal, Tho maater of the ael reports haring seen a norntwrof grain-carriers off Sheboygan Satorday niglit honnd down. Oman Pour*.—Honort* continue to come from all the lake porta that craft are laying tip. ...Lake trade has nearly wound tip for tho season at Toledo, but two more lumber fleet* were expect ed from Baglnaw....Tbc ileam-barge .inrvl* Lord could not eater the harbor at Ken oeba on account of low water, and returned to Milwaukee Satorday and transferred a portion of her load to too tebr C. 11. Haculey, which Teasel wiw to hare been towed to Kenosha by a tug .. The new Anchor Line tug Eric has arrived at tho port of that name, from Buffalo ... Tho prop f.'lty of 3!ontrcal has laid op at Toronto. ....The revenue cutter Ferry arrived at Buffalo last Friday.... After making another trip to Lake Huron ports and Mackinaw tho atmrs Holland and llertscby will lay up nt Cleveland.... The sriir Three Brother* ba« arrived at Cleveland and laid up at the Cleveland 31111* dock, where her cargo of 22,000 bu of wheat will he taxon out ai ro ouire<l....The achr Southwest has obtained 8l.l2!4 per ton fop a cargo of coal from sandnaky to Milwaukee, and I* now on her way up.... The stmt o»car Townauml will receive extensive repairs at Cleveland during Ibc winter.... Tho Union Com nanj’sprop Newburgl* on Jier last trip up fop the season.... The coal-dock* are barer than they have been known to be for years, and there Is verv little coal to go forward.... The schr Porter has fold tip at Milwaukee.. ..Tho senrs H, L. Watson, UttrSon, and Wayne wore wind-boatui nt Milwaukee Sun day. q her are bound down.... There were 10‘i pa tients treated at tho Marino Hospital at Clerc nml from Slay 1 to Nov. 24. The United State* pay* 04 cent* per day for each marine patient treated at the Cleveland City Hospital, open batrhwora are the trap* that catch the sailor* most, according to the Marfan Hospital Surgeon at that cltr.../l lie Toronto (Hobr of Saturday reported the harbor there a* crowded with crafts, raoatly coal laden.... The prop Gordon Campbell left Detroit Saturday night for Milwau kee wtlb I.M) lon* bf canned fm f t.... Tho steamers and coaster* IcavlngDetr'lt for Lake Huron port* are now on their laat trip*....The etram-bargn Dover ha* been repaired at Detroit, and lias left for Buffalo.. ..The •team*b*rgv Powers Is in dry dock at Detroit.... Thu tug Coe is wrecking the Kob Uoy. ashore at WanUcz.m, It is f ciucd the Bridgewater baa broken her tuck at fctOAkoy. The Custer Mitaiatro. SI, LntU* o!ub*‘l>rmrer'H, Abbot Marlin, Superior of Hie monastery In Spencer County, Indiana, Is now hi St. LouK lie was si Sluing Bull’s camp a abort time* ago, and while there nail several talks with Sitting Dull sikl other warriors about the events of tlio Caster campaign. Of the massacre the In* diaus spoke freely, not lu a boasting wav, but us a providential event onlercil by the Ureal Spirit. Their theory was that the white men were cum* lug to kill them and their squaws, bat that the Great Spirit put It in their way to comoleteiv overpower the whites and kill them. Silling Hull and his warriors sold there luid been no such light os had been described lu tne American pa* pers. The soldiers were too tired to light. Their horses were broken down hr hard travel and no food, and they had been so long In the saibllc that they were overcome by sleep. The Sioux fell upon them (lx lu one. The soldiers were completely surprised, surrounded,' terror* stricken. Their annihilation was the work of only a lew minutes. But lew shuts were fired. “Our powder was scarce," said Sitting Hull, 14 ami we killed the soldiers with our war-club-. We did this to save ammunition. Thu soldiers could not light; thev were too tired; they were killed so quick they did not have Unto to light us." Concerning Gen. Cu«icr, Sitting Bull said none ut the cloux knew him or recognized him in the tight, iie mu* killed like the rest, ami neither he nor anv of Ms olllcer* Lad tlmu to make resistance. The loss of the Sioux was trilling, the soldiers tiring only a low shots, lie nor nous of the wumur» know Custer per* soually, nor did they recognize any person ns leader of the soldiers. They did not know Custer as •• Long litur.” Neither hu nor anv other soldier bad tlma to kill the Sioux warriors. Sitting Bull and other braves were able to describe some or the dead bodies where the pecnliaritcs were marked. Abbot Martin talked to the voung warrior who killed Lieut. Sturgis. Thu Identity of Sturgis was established because lie was the only uniformed ollleer who had no heard, that was so young tliat his beard had not vet hud time to develop; certain peculiar marks on uls face and head, and articles of Jewelry taken from his clothing, which left no doubt of bis Identity. Other olllccrs were Identliled after death by similar circumstances, but the light was so quick and decisive that there was no time to distinguish the olllccrs from the men. Sitting Bull said that he hud eleven days' warn* lug of the approach of the soldiers, and that ho was fully prepared to annihilate them.
In this interview, Sitting Bull disputes earlier American newspaper accounts of the battle, claiming the exhausted, surprised soldiers put up almost no resistance and were killed with war-clubs in minutes to save ammunition. He says the Sioux did not recognize Custer during the fight and only identified bodies afterward through physical traits and jewelry.
The Last Ditch. Rakicakbi, 111., Nov. 23.—811 as Sutherland, of this city, la engaged lu digging a ditch seven and a half miles long, from the tract of swamp-laud hi Newton County, lud., belong ing to Uail, the Cincinnati bruwvr, to tbo Jro quuis River, in the northeastern part of Kauka kvo County, 111. The ditch will bo eighteen feet wide ut the bottom, tlurty feet wide at the tuu, and will be four feet deep. At one puinQiu wison closes.... The schr E. P. Itorcc hid her malntopmast broken off yesterday by coll Dion wl»h the schr Ellen Spry.
See moreSee less
The accident happened In the main river ...Tho Lbvl Grant had Her jib boom broken on the lambcr market yesterdav.... The prop Egyptian got aground near the mouth of the harbor, and had to lighten some of her cargo yesterday before she coaid getaway from port.... Tho canal-erhoonm Pulaski, Folger, and Nassau are among tho late arrivals from Oswego. They brought coal, Tho maater of the ael reports haring seen a norntwrof grain-carriers off Sheboygan Satorday niglit honnd down. Oman Pour*.—Honort* continue to come from all the lake porta that craft are laying tip. ...Lake trade has nearly wound tip for tho season at Toledo, but two more lumber fleet* were expect ed from Baglnaw....Tbc ileam-barge .inrvl* Lord could not eater the harbor at Ken oeba on account of low water, and returned to Milwaukee Satorday and transferred a portion of her load to too tebr C. 11. Haculey, which Teasel wiw to hare been towed to Kenosha by a tug .. The new Anchor Line tug Eric has arrived at tho port of that name, from Buffalo ... Tho prop f.'lty of 3!ontrcal has laid op at Toronto. ....The revenue cutter Ferry arrived at Buffalo last Friday.... After making another trip to Lake Huron ports and Mackinaw tho atmrs Holland and llertscby will lay up nt Cleveland.... The sriir Three Brother* ba« arrived at Cleveland and laid up at the Cleveland 31111* dock, where her cargo of 22,000 bu of wheat will he taxon out ai ro ouire<l....The achr Southwest has obtained 8l.l2!4 per ton fop a cargo of coal from sandnaky to Milwaukee, and I* now on her way up.... The stmt o»car Townauml will receive extensive repairs at Cleveland during Ibc winter.... Tho Union Com nanj’sprop Newburgl* on Jier last trip up fop the season.... The coal-dock* are barer than they have been known to be for years, and there Is verv little coal to go forward.... The schr Porter has fold tip at Milwaukee.. ..Tho senrs H, L. Watson, UttrSon, and Wayne wore wind-boatui nt Milwaukee Sun day. q her are bound down.... There were 10‘i pa tients treated at tho Marino Hospital at Clerc nml from Slay 1 to Nov. 24. The United State* pay* 04 cent* per day for each marine patient treated at the Cleveland City Hospital, open batrhwora are the trap* that catch the sailor* most, according to the Marfan Hospital Surgeon at that cltr.../l lie Toronto (Hobr of Saturday reported the harbor there a* crowded with crafts, raoatly coal laden.... The prop Gordon Campbell left Detroit Saturday night for Milwau kee wtlb I.M) lon* bf canned fm f t.... Tho steamers and coaster* IcavlngDetr'lt for Lake Huron port* are now on their laat trip*....The etram-bargn Dover ha* been repaired at Detroit, and lias left for Buffalo.. ..The •team*b*rgv Powers Is in dry dock at Detroit.... Thu tug Coe is wrecking the Kob Uoy. ashore at WanUcz.m, It is f ciucd the Bridgewater baa broken her tuck at fctOAkoy. The Custer Mitaiatro. SI, LntU* o!ub*‘l>rmrer'H, Abbot Marlin, Superior of Hie monastery In Spencer County, Indiana, Is now hi St. LouK lie was si Sluing Bull’s camp a abort time* ago, and while there nail several talks with Sitting Dull sikl other warriors about the events of tlio Caster campaign. Of the massacre the In* diaus spoke freely, not lu a boasting wav, but us a providential event onlercil by the Ureal Spirit. Their theory was that the white men were cum* lug to kill them and their squaws, bat that the Great Spirit put It in their way to comoleteiv overpower the whites and kill them. Silling Hull and his warriors sold there luid been no such light os had been described lu tne American pa* pers. The soldiers were too tired to light. Their horses were broken down hr hard travel and no food, and they had been so long In the saibllc that they were overcome by sleep. The Sioux fell upon them (lx lu one. The soldiers were completely surprised, surrounded,' terror* stricken. Their annihilation was the work of only a lew minutes. But lew shuts were fired. “Our powder was scarce," said Sitting Hull, 14 ami we killed the soldiers with our war-club-. We did this to save ammunition. Thu soldiers could not light; thev were too tired; they were killed so quick they did not have Unto to light us." Concerning Gen. Cu«icr, Sitting Bull said none ut the cloux knew him or recognized him in the tight, iie mu* killed like the rest, ami neither he nor anv of Ms olllcer* Lad tlmu to make resistance. The loss of the Sioux was trilling, the soldiers tiring only a low shots, lie nor nous of the wumur» know Custer per* soually, nor did they recognize any person ns leader of the soldiers. They did not know Custer as •• Long litur.” Neither hu nor anv other soldier bad tlma to kill the Sioux warriors. Sitting Bull and other braves were able to describe some or the dead bodies where the pecnliaritcs were marked. Abbot Martin talked to the voung warrior who killed Lieut. Sturgis. Thu Identity of Sturgis was established because lie was the only uniformed ollleer who had no heard, that was so young tliat his beard had not vet hud time to develop; certain peculiar marks on uls face and head, and articles of Jewelry taken from his clothing, which left no doubt of bis Identity. Other olllccrs were Identliled after death by similar circumstances, but the light was so quick and decisive that there was no time to distinguish the olllccrs from the men. Sitting Bull said that he hud eleven days' warn* lug of the approach of the soldiers, and that ho was fully prepared to annihilate them.
A government commission visiting Sitting Bull reportedly discovered a white prisoner, Corporal Martin Ryan of Company I, Seventh Cavalry, said to have survived the Little Bighorn and been adopted, married, and made a war chief by Sitting Bull. Army muster rolls confirmed Ryan's name was on the company roster for the day of the battle.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Spirit of Democracy · 27 November 1877 · page 1
SITTING BULL'S PIttSOflER, A SnrvlTor of the tnster Mamacre Becomes aa Iadlan Chief. .. -.-, f- (Boston Berald.1 , : ... ' '... Washisoton, No.: .14, The Com mission which was sent to Sitting Bull made an important discovery In the fact that tbe warrior has in his camp a white prisoner captured at the Uuster massa cre. Beiore reaching ion YVaah ru mors reached the Commission that Sit ting Bull iield some of .Custer's men as pris6Tier8,knd .'-after the first conference ne 01 ins nau-Dreea mierpreiers em ployed by Gen.
See moreSee less
Terry visited the camp, and, .while passing througb,was accosted in English by a person painted and dressed, as a chief, who said 'that his name was Martin Ryan, who was a Cor poral in Company I, Seventh Cavalry, Col. Keough's company, and had been taken a prisoner at the battle of the Lit tle. Big Horn with Custer. , Inquiry bp parentiy substantiated his assertion, and the following " facts were ascertained : Ryan's life bad been spared by Sitting Bull himself, - who adopted him into bis own family. Ryan made several attempts to escape, but being carefully guarded waa unsuccessful, and on each occasion he Was severely beaten.- He has now apparently accepted . the situation, and Sitting Bull haa made him a war chief and married Ryan to one of bis own daughters. Ryan haa let his hair grow in Indian fashion, dresses as an Indian, and IS known by the Sioux as the White Chief. ' ;;v-. . 11 i'ltl-a- ' .: It .. Upon the return of the Commission to St. Paul, Gen. Terry caused the. muster rolls of Company I, Seventh Cavalry, to oe examined, and found that Martin Ry an's name is borne as Corporal, and that be was present for duty wben his com pany went into that fatal action of ; June 25, 1878. it was stated, by the friendly Indiansthat there are several others of UusterV men prisoners la fitting Bull's camp; but "Ryaq's case was the only one which J was ; verified. ', SittingBull : was asked the question direct by Gen, Cor bin if he took any prisoners of tbe Sev enth Cavslry,and answered flatly: "That is none of your business.-"' Sitting Bull talked considerably about the battle With Custer, and ail be said fully confirma the conclusions , arrived .at by Gen. Terry last year when be examined .the ground just after' the battle." He said that at first he thought Gen. Terry's whole ar my: was upon bim, and he bad moved bis -women ;and children and property about four miles in retreat, when he re ceived, information , from his scouts that it was only the. Seventh : Cavalry snd Longhair (Custer,) - and that they were divided, 'and Reno bad already retreated. He -bays ?aa , then took4,000 Wafriors and went back and moved down on Cua ter in a Bolid mass and ended the fight right there. He says that Long Hair was one of tbe very last down, and that the Indians ; shouted and made signs to bim to surrender, but be would not, and about the very last of tbe fight he was killed. He said that if be had captured Custer be would not bave hurt him, brt have kept bim in bis camp. He was ask ed how many men be lost, but be refus ed to tell the number, After a few mo ments, however, he said that he had lost great many warriors;- indeed,' more than two for every, man Long Hair had. in regard to CorporarKyan's case, Gen. Terry haa written a letter to the State Department through Secretary McCrary. detailing tbe facts as ascertained, ' to the end that 1 the " assistance of the British Government, may be asked to effect bis release.; ''.-ao. v Atn;ifo :.'. w X.i ft. I :-.-fi 1 .. , , ..... . vii'. ; Cloves are unopened flowers of a smil) evergreen tree, that .resembles is ap pearance tne laurel or tne Day. it is native of .the Molucca or Spice islands, out nas been earned to all the warmer parts of the .world, and is -largely culti vated in the tropical, regions of Ameri ca, Tbe flowers are small in 'size and grow in large numbers in clusters at the veryehd of the branches.1 -The "cloves we use are the flowers, gathered before they are opened and whilst they are still green. After being gathered .they . are smoked by a wood fire and then dried in the sun. Each consists of two parts ; a round bead, which is the four petals or leaves Of the flo wer rolled op,inclosing a number of stocks and filaments. The other part, of the clove is terminated with four, points, '.and is, in' fact, the flower cup and the unripe seed vessel All these parts may be distinctly shown if a few leaves a-e soaked a short : time in hot water when the leaves soften and readily nnroil.r ?:,,, ttv. :?;-! -Mi. 1 i"Tbe story is told of a woman who freely used her tongue to the scandal of others, - and made - confessions to tbe priest of what she had done. ' He' gave her a ripe thistle-top, and told her to go out in various directions and scatter, the seeds one by one. Wondering at the penance, she obeyed,, and then returned and told ner contession. 10 ber amaze ment, be bade her go back' and gather the scattered seeds ; and when she ob jected that it would be impossible, be replied that it would be still more diffi cult to gather up and destroy ail evil re ports which she bad circulated' about others. Any thoughtless, careless child can scatter a handful of thistle seeds be fore the wind in-a moment, but the strongest and wisest cannot gather them again. : vr. -i , OneDonp Too many, j , A wood teamster in Detroit had some business to transact with , the occupant of a room in the top ' story of a block on Gi is wold Street, and as he reached the landing of the last flight of stairs. hie heel caught, and down . be rolled bumping from stair to stair, and unable to catch hold of anything. A lawyer leaned over the stairs as he heard the noise, and shouted, . '...... "You'll strike bottom pretty quick don't get discouraged I" "Oh,! know just where I am; I coun ted the stairs when I went up," replied the teamster. As he landed, be rubbed his bruised back, and, .looking up the stairs, he mused : "I counted fourteen steps going up, snd fifteen bumps coming . down. Something wrong with the architecture of this building." Free Prett.
The item claims that not all of Custer's men died at Little Bighorn, asserting that Indians took several prisoners who still live among them. It specifically names a Corporal Martin Ryan, said to have married Sitting Bull's daughter, become a chief, and adopted Indian dress and customs.
– Harvard College har ved Testa. mente efter afdøde Dr. Martin Paine modtaget en Gave af s100000, men Kapitalen skal ikke røres, før den er voxet saaledes, at den giver en aar lig Rente af so 000. – Ikke Alle, der fulgte General Custer paa hans Tog mod Sitting Bull, fulgte ham i Døden. Det dukker nu op, at Indianerne har taget slere Fanger, der lever blandt dem, og dette skal være ganske vist, jyvad en Korporal Martin Ryan an gaar; han har af Sitting Bull faaet hans Datter tilægte og er bleven indsat som Høvding. Han gaar klædt
In an interview published over a year after the battle, Sitting Bull describes the destruction of Custer's command, saying the soldiers fell back fighting from coulee to coulee until only a few remained around 'Long Hair.' He recounts that Custer fired his last shots with a pistol, fell laughing, tried to rise and fire again, and finally died after the pistol misfired, with only one other man still standing nearby.
The Louisiana Democrat · 28 November 1877 · page 3
THRILLING ACCOUNT O5FTIrE FIGHT. BY SITTING BULL. Sitting Bull has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Custer massacre. IIe says: ,,The fight was hell, a thousand de vils, the squaws were like flying birds, the bullets like humming bees. We thought we were whipped, not at first, but by-and-by. Afterwards, no. Your people were killed. I tell no lies about dead men. These men who came with the "Long Hair" were as good men as ever fought. When they rode up their horses were tired and they were tired.
See moreSee less
When they got off their horses they could not stand firmly on their feet. They swayed to and fro, so my young men have told me, like limbs of cypresses in a great wind. Some of them stag gered under the weight of their gnus, but they began to fight at once. But, by this time, our camps were aroused, and there were plenty of warriors to meet them. They fired with needle guns. We replied with our magazine guns, repeating rifles." Sitting Bull illustrated by putting his palms together with the rapidity of a fusilade. "Our younger men rained lead across the river, and drove the white braves back, and then they rushed across themselves, and then they found that they had a good deal to do. The trouble was with the sol diers that they were so exhausted, and their horses bothered them so much they could not take good aim. Some of their horses broke away from them, and left them to stand, abd drop, and die. All the men fell back fighting and dropping. They could not fire fast enough, though they kept in pretty good order.- They would fall back across a coulie, and make a fresh stand beyond on higher ground. "There were a great many brave men in that fight, and from time to time, while it was going on, they were shot down like pigs. They could not help themselves. One by one the officers fell. Where the last fighttook place-where the last stand was made-the 'Long Hair' stood like a sheaf of corn with all the ears fal len around him." "Not wounded?" "No." "How many stood by him?" "A few." "When did he fall?" "He killed a man. When he fell be laughed." "You mean lie cried out?" "No, he laughed. He had fired his last shot." "From a carbine?" "No, a pistol." "Did he stand up after lie first fell?" "He rose up on his hands and tried another shot, but his pistol would not go off." "Was any one else standing up when he fell down?" "One man was kneeling, that was all. But he died before the 'Long Hair.'" Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Reno keeping him in his strong position on the bluff and pre venting him from giving aid to Gen eral Custer. Deadheading on thb Newspaper. The Rome Sentinel rises to ex plain, and its language is plain, and as follows: There is no other business on which the public levies such heavy contributions as on the newspaper publishing business. An orgamnza tion is getting up some kind of fes tivities, for example. It pays for the use of the grounds, pays for re freshments, gets $2 worth of tickets and $4 worth of bills printed either at a newspaper office or somewhere else, and then expects free adverti sing from the paper to an extent ac tually worth from $2 or $3 to $10. The mere announcement of a pic-nic, sociable or festival is a matter of news, but further than that is an ad. vertisement, and ought to be paid for. The result is that a generous proportion of the profits of nearly all entertainments of this kind is money which rightfully belongs to newspa per publishers. Then, after the thing is over the managers will come in with a long string of resolutions, with which to rob the publisher of more valuable space. The truth is, that space in a newspaper represents money. It is worth money to the publisher. There is no more reason
A correspondent reports an interview with Sitting Bull at Fort Walsh in which he defends his actions, claiming Custer was reckless and was killed by a warrior called the Great Eater after being surrounded. Sitting Bull insists he did not massacre Custer's men but that Custer brought about his own defeat through overconfidence.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Watertown Republican · 28 November 1877 · page 3
SITTING DILI. Another Story from Him About the Cus ter Fight. A Fort Walsh correspondent of the World gives a detailed report of an in terview with Sitting Bull after the de parture of Gen. Terry's commissioners. The correspondent told him that the Americans accused him of murdering Custer, and he replied as follows. The Marmat. of whom bespeaks, is a young brave who was present. Sitting Bull said: “ I know they do. If Custer had killed all my people the Americans would have said he had won a great fight. I did not massacre Custer. He was a brave man, but he had no caution. The Marmot is brave, but he is cunning and cautious too. Custer was brave, but he was care
In this interview, Sitting Bull describes how his warriors surrounded Custer's men in a ravine and killed Custer, insisting the soldiers could not escape once encircled. He denies murdering the dead, blames Custer's recklessness for the defeat, and distinguishes Custer's approach from Reno's more cautious retreat.
Watertown Republican · 28 November 1877 · page 3
SITTING BULL
Eater) shot him. The Marmot would have taken him. When he* fell the soldiers kept on fighting, but they could not see their way out. It was Custer’s fault. Why did he take them into such a place? He waS too brave. It is bet ter to be afraid than too brave, like Custer. I did not murder them. We thought Reno was like Custer at first; and when Reno came along after we thought it was the chief (Terry), and made away because we were tired. Reno stopped. .Then we went oft’.
See moreSee less
My braves did not touch the dead soldiers. We went away and left them. Miles is like Custer. I think he is his brother. I mean that he has no caution. It is not just to say we murdered Custer. He murdered himself. Thajt is all.”
A Fort Walsh correspondent reports an interview with Sitting Bull after Terry's commissioners departed, in which he denies massacring Custer's men and explains the battle tactically. He claims his warriors trapped Custer in a ravine, that Custer was reckless and "too brave," and that the dead were not mutilated by his braves.
Mineral Point Tribune · 28 November 1877 · page 3
Another story from Him Vhoul the Cus ter fight. A Fort \\ al'li correspondent of tin" II ;•/</gives a detailed report of an in - terview with Sitting Hull after the de parture of Hen. Terry's commissioners. Toe eorres|H)iident told him that the Americans accused him of murdering duster, mid lie replied as follows. The Manual, of whom he speaks, is a young hrave who was present. Sitting Hull sa id: “ I know they do. If Custer had killed all my people the Am erica ns would have said he had won a great light. 1 did not massacre Custei Ile was a hrave man, hut he had no caution. The Marmot is hrave, hut he is cunning and cautions too. Custer was hrave, hut hi was care
A correspondent reports Sitting Bull's vivid description of the battle, recalling exhausted soldiers who could barely stand, being overwhelmed by Lakota warriors with repeating rifles. Sitting Bull praises the bravery of Custer's men while describing how they fell back fighting until being wiped out.
The Wichita City Eagle · 29 November 1877 · page 1
HOW CUSTER DIED
Whunthcy rode up their horses were tired and they were tired. When thoy got off their horses they could not" stand firmly on their feet. They swayed to end fro o my young men have told me like limbs of cypress in a great wind. Some of then: staggered under the weight of their guns, but they began te tight at once. But by this time our cmp were aroused, and there were plenty of warriors to meat them. They tired with needle guns. We replied with magazine guns'' (rapoating' rifl). Sitting Bull
An unnamed source (apparently drawing on an interview with Sitting Bull) describes Custer's cavalry falling back fighting, and Custer's dramatic last stand where he allegedly laughed after firing his final shot. The account also claims only squaws, old men, and children faced Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wichita City Eagle · 29 November 1877 · page 1
HOW CUSTER DIED
Sitting Bull saya there were only squaws, old men and little children iu front of Rsno, keeping him in hie strong position in the bluff, and pre venting him giving aid to Custer.
Newspapers report that Sitting Bull's own account of the battle corroborates earlier suspicions that Major Reno failed to support Custer, withdrawing his forces early and encouraging the Indians to then destroy Custer's command. The piece argues this new testimony confirms what critics had long suspected about Reno's conduct during the fight.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wichita City Eagle · 29 November 1877 · page 1
Major Reno's Condust in tha Caster Tight Criticised. Major Reno's conduct in the battlo which resulted iu tho massacre of Custer's command, is severely criti cised iu viow ot Sitting Bull's corrob oration of the suspicion excited by the stories heretofore derived from scouts and friendly Indians. The Herald says : "As soon as it became possible tocoustrtict from the excited stories of tho participants and witnesses a connected and logical chronicle of that bloody fight, it was seen that the con duct of Major Reno called explanation Observations were made at tho timo upon the sircutnstaiico that this ofllcer appointed to co-operate iu a combined advance upon the Indian position, did not do bis whole duty under his or ders, aud not only that, but discontin ued his advance altogether on encoun tering some resistance, permitted him self to bo verj easily whipped, and withdrew his force to a comparatively safe place anil saved his men, within pound of the lire that annihilated the force with which he was toco-operate Sitting Bull now tells the story of the battle which implies that Jlijor Reno had so completely withdrawn from tho light before Custer even got iuto it, that the Indians thought there was on ly one column, whicd had withdrawn from a first point only to advance at another.
See moreSee less
It was under the seine of eucouragemout given them by Reno's flight, that the Indians assailed Cus ter's command with such unusual vig or.antl having destroyed il.thej would have destroyed Reno's alo with equal thoroughness but for Terry's arrival. This new light on the battle, confirm ing so ab-"olutilj what was before thought, will give new occasion for regret that Major Reno is still an offi cer of the arinj', under a too lenient remission of his sentence for another olii'ne." Tho Tribune adds : "If Sitting Bull tells the truth, Reno's first attack was merely a slight skirmish, and hi' force remained perched upon tho heights, and facing the squaws and superaniiti-t-d warriors, when, if he hail renewed the assault, in a'iordanse with Custer's plan, he might have saved the Urea of his gallant comrade Reno has stated iu his official report that he knew nothing of Custer's engagement. Sit tiutr Bull says that Ihe squaws in front of Reno heard distinctly the souud of tho firing. Major Reno is not in :i fit posi'ion to command public sympathy. lie was condemned by a court martial last spring for insulting a lady, ami suspended from rank and pay for two vears."
A newspaper correspondent recounts an interview with Sitting Bull describing the Battle of Little Bighorn from the Lakota perspective. Sitting Bull describes exhausted soldiers arriving on tired horses, the intensity of gunfire from both sides, and the gradual retreat and destruction of Custer's men.
The Republican Journal · 29 November 1877 · page 4
How Custer Died Xi.w X «■!;k. Nov. hi. Si11'• nir Hull lias been talking with a correspondent an-i telliinr the story <*f the <'lister massacre. 11 ♦ • savs : "The light was bell, a thousand devils: the squaws were like th
A question-and-answer style account describes Custer ('Long Hair') making a final stand, falling only after running out of ammunition, and allegedly laughing as he died. Sitting Bull is also quoted claiming only non-combatants faced Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Republican Journal · 29 November 1877 · page 4
died before the Long Hair." Sitting Hull says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff and pre venting him giving aid to Custer.
A commission that traveled to meet Sitting Bull has returned to Washington and reported he was quite companionable outside formal council sessions. He reportedly gave his own account of his role in the Custer massacre, which matched the generally accepted version of events.
tracts to furnish 70,000 bags of biscuit inGEIIEIlAIi HEWS. ntir 'or the btsietred In Pletna. as Osman Pasha has opened negotiations for the surrender of that place. The official canvass shows that the vote A Cettinve. dispatcu says mat tne of Colorado on the women suffrage nuee wounded Montenegrins arriving heie flon was: For, 6,612 1 against, 143j report that on Sunday night the divlslou majority against, 7,441. of Flamenaz, moving towards Scutari, The Confederate monument at Chat found the Turkish foroes entrenched near tanooga, completed and Tcady to erect, Anamollte behind throe lines of breast was defaced beyond repair on Saturday works extending from the hills to the night by some unknown persons.
See moreSee less
Bayana, An assault was .made by 600 vninnteers. who carried the first line but. The rubber factory of L. Condor A Co., on attacking the third, found themselvos at New Haven, Conn., and the I-ort M ward Institute, at Fort Edward, N. Y., opposed to a much superior force or Turk", and were neateii uw r im iun. biimed Monday. , , Between 20 and 30 were killed and 100 ThnrtndJurr at PitUburg, ra.. in wounded, when the attack was abandon thrir rfport on the late riot, throw all the bl"ie on the State ofScers and ed. This affair snows mat tne statement fco ".-rs. TLy say thRt ditcretion on the you do not. that the rlht bank or me river u nt.reiy In tire roKcsxlon cf ths Ilnr.t-r.:-rn lj A ( r f -j in authority would have i Frr: ' : 1 r -1 cf t i nroun.l?3. iwu..y . . tltr.t h-.f way Txtwf.Ti ,.n7.T.i t- - r?. I. - - loc'j cf tC3 roof the United States, which, when ratified by three-fourths of said Legis latures, shall be valid as part or said Constitution: -'A tribunal for the decision of all con tested issues arising in tho choice of President and .Vice President shall be appointed in each State In the following manner l Not less than 12 months prior to the time fixed by law for the choice 01 electors the governor of each State shall. by the aid and advice and consent of the senate or tne tate, appoint not less tnan five persons, learned in law and other wise duly qualified, to whom shall be re ferred, in such manner as the Legislature of the State shall direct, In cases of con tested elections arising In reference to electors or President and Vice rresidenr. The tribunal so constituted shall hear and determine every such contest, and certify at least thirty days before the day on which tbe electors shall be called upon to give their vote, the decUlon therein to tbe proper returning officer or officers of the state, and also transmit an authen ticated cony thereof, under the seal of the State, to the President ot the Senate. The term of office of said tribunal shall ex pire upon the day fixed by law for the oath of office to be. taken by the Presi dent and Vice President of the United States for the term ensuing after their ap pointment." " The Sitting Bull commission have arrived at Washington. They say that out of the council Sitting Bull was a very companionable gentleman and several very interesting interviews were held with him, in which he gave an account of his part In the Custer massacre, wblch does not diner from the generally accepted reports. In the Democratic Senate caucus several speeches were made on the recent Republican caucus, and a dis position was shown to sustain the President in confirming his appoint ments. The hope was expressed by several Senators that the President would adhere to the line of conduct be had laid down for himself and had followed up to this time. The Treasury now holds $344,729,000 In bonds to secure the National bank circulation, and $14,495,500 to secure public deposits of United States bonds be posited for circulation the week ending to-day, $495,100 ; United States bonds held for circulation withdrawn for the week ending to-day. $473,600 National bank circulation outstand lng, gold notes $1,432,120, currency notes $310,152,570. An order has been issued from the Poatofllce Department to the effect that hereafter newspapers sent to regular subscribers irom tne omce 01 puuiica tlon must not be done up in old news papers or any sort of printed matter. Ir thev are they are subject to tran sient postage. This is because such wrappers are so weak as to burst open in handling with such frequency as greatly to binder, and often to pre vent, tne proper delivery or papers.
A correspondent reports an interview with Sitting Bull describing the Custer fight in vivid detail, including the exhaustion of the soldiers and the firepower of the Lakota warriors. He claims the soldiers fell back fighting, overwhelmed by better-armed, fresher warriors.
The Lake County Star · 29 November 1877 · page 3
Custer's Death
Bitting Bull has been talking with a correspondent and telling the story of the Custer massacre. He says the fight was Hell, with a thousand devils.
A secondhand narrative describes soldiers falling back in order until Custer, 'The Long Hair,' made his final stand, fighting unwounded until killed, firing his last pistol shot and laughing before dying. Sitting Bull is also quoted claiming only women, old men, and children held Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Lake County Star · 29 November 1877 · page 3
Bitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff, and pre venting him giving aid to Custer.
A correspondent interviews Sitting Bull in November 1877, who describes the chaos and exhaustion of Custer's soldiers as they dismounted and fought. He recounts how warriors with repeating rifles overwhelmed the tired cavalry using needle-guns, driving them back across a coulee.
The Redwood Gazette · 29 November 1877 · page 2
and returned here only a few weeks ago. Dudley was a single man, sober and steady in his habits, and well connected in the East.—Chicago Tribune, Nov. Id. The Custer Massacre—Sitting Bull's Story.
The passage relates a reported interview with Sitting Bull describing the last stand of 'Long Hair' (Custer), including dramatic details of his fall and death. It also claims that only squaws, old men, and children held Reno's forces back from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Redwood Gazette · 29 November 1877 · page 2
Sitting Bull -says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff, and pre venting him giving aid to Custer.
A group led by D.K. Snively returned after five months prospecting in the Big Horn Mountains and surrounding rivers, finding nothing to attract gold seekers. They encountered distant Sioux, old relics, and recovered a horse once captured by Sitting Bull.
Bozeman Avant Courier · 29 November 1877 · page 4
the parly saw five Sioux Indians, but did I not exchange shots with them, the distance being too great. They found a large number of relics of of tinsame character as have been found in in Lawrence county, ol 1 pumps, drain ditch es and a deserted cabin or two. The party found a beautiful American horse which had been captured hy Sitting Bull, and had | | afterwards got away. ^This animal, when ; ; taken hy them into Ft. Custer, turned out
This report presents a Q&A-style narrative attributed to Sitting Bull describing how 'Long Hair' (Custer) and his men fought and fell during the battle, including details of Custer's final shots and death. It also claims that only women, old men, and children held Reno's position, preventing him from aiding Custer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Nebraska Advertiser · 29 November 1877 · page 4
S. B. He killed a man. When he fell he laughed. C. You mean ho cried out. S-. B. No, he laughed. He had fir ed his last shot. C. From, a carbine ? S. B. No, a pistol. - C Did he stand up after he first fell? S. B. He rose up on his hands and tried another shot, but his pistol would not go off. C. Was any one else standing up when he fell down? S. B. One man was kneeling ; that was all, but he died before the Long Hair.
See moreSee less
Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old men and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position in the bluff and pre venting him giving aid to Custer. Infatuation of Two Children for a
In an 1877 interview, Sitting Bull describes the chaos of the Little Bighorn fight, calling it fought 'with a thousand devils' and praising the courage of Custer's exhausted soldiers. He details how the soldiers, worn out from the ride, struggled to fight effectively while his warriors used repeating rifles against their single-shot guns.
The Tiffin Tribune · 29 November 1877 · page 4
BRAVE CUSTER
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
This piece presents a theatrical, question-and-answer style retelling of Custer's death at Little Bighorn, attributed to Native American testimony filtered through Sitting Bull's account. It describes Custer ("Long Hair") making a heroic last stand, laughing as he fired his final shots before falling.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Tiffin Tribune · 29 November 1877 · page 4
preventing him from giving aid to Custer. [Editor's Drawer, in Harper's Magazine for December.] Anecdote of Lincoln. "One day," said Mr. Lincoln. wueu a ursi cam nere, i got into a fit of musing In my room, and stood
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
A commission sent to meet Sitting Bull reportedly found a white prisoner, supposedly Corporal Martin Ryan of the 7th Cavalry's Company I, said to have survived the Little Bighorn battle and been adopted, married into Sitting Bull's family, and made a war chief. Army muster rolls confirmed a Martin Ryan was indeed present for duty at the battle, lending apparent credibility to the extraordinary tale.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 29 November 1877 · page 3
Sitting Bull's White Chief
Washington, Nov. 26, 1877. Time bos dissipated ail hopes of an adjournment, and Congress has settled down for a long and tedious session. The Military Signal Service, under its chief, Gen. A. J. Myer, is growing more and more important to every branch of industry. One hundred and fifty-nine signal stations have been kept up during the year, furnishing daily reports of coming storms for the benefit of agricul? tural and commercial communities. One thousand and ninety-five synopsis and in? dication reports have been furnished to the public and the press tri-daily, re?
See moreSee less
quiring data to be telegraphed from 125 stations for each report, over 3,200 miles of wire, requiring but 80 minutes from the transraittal of the storm indications at each station to tabulate the data at the main office and give it to the public and the daily press. Eighty-six per cent, of all indications have proven correct. Cautionary signals have been maintained at 47 sea and lake ports, of which 78 per cent, have been verified. Six thousand two hundred and sixty-four "Farmers' Bulletins," or daily forecasts have beep displayed in frames at as many different post offices in cities, towns and hamlets for the benefit of all classes, announcing in each locality the weather probabilities. In every home "Old Prob's." indications and forecasts are as much a necessity and convenience as a clock. Many evenings find a party of friends in the Red Room at the White House, who drop in to make a social call on the President and Mrs. Hayes. These gath? erings are without formality, and are not unlike social calls so common in our American homes. Fickle fortune plays strange freaks. The balance of Gen. John C. Fremont's estate was recently swept away by fire! his library, furniture and pictures have all been sold, and his heroic wife, "Jessie," is earning a living as a con? tributor to Harper'a Magazine, her spare time being devoted to her new book on "Foreign Travels," soon to be put in press. Alexander Shepherd, familiarly known as "Boss" Shepherd, reputed in the past as being worth his million, in whose home?elegant and palatial?the bon ton of the Capital, the gay and the cultivated, ever had entree, overtaken by unforeseen disasters and driven into a sea of financial embarrassment, has yiel? ded to the storm, and the auctioneer's1 hammer seals the change of ownership of pictures rare and works of art from the skilled hands of the old masters. The President has declared his inten? tions on the silver question, and will not approve any measure that shall in the least impair our national credit, or com? pel the holders of government securities to receive payment of either principal or interest in a currency less valuable than gold. Those who aid the government as con? tributors to the revenue by the use of liquor or tobacco, must be gratified at the results of the business of last year as shown by the report of the Commis? sioner of Internal Revenue. Liquors paid a tax of $57,469,429.72 and tobacco $41,106,546.92, the largest sum ever re? alized from this source in any year. The Democrats are highly elated at the defection of Senators Patterson and Connover in the Kellogg case, and the Republicans pour obloquy on the head of Senator Sharon for his absence from his seat in this hour of peril to his party. Threats of expulsion are freely made. Messrs. Scudder and Bowditch, of Cambridge, Mass., under the auspices of the Hayden Surveying Expedition, in exploring for fossils in Utah and Wyom? ing, discovered a "buggy locality."? Much time was spent in the region of the South Park, and more than 7,000 insects and over 3,000 plants have al? ready been worked out of the territory strata. These new discoveries will make a most fruitful field of study for enthusi? astic naturalists. The Consular reports to the State De? partment from nearly every country show a large increase in the direct trade with the United States. It is suggested that our artisans and mechanics follow as far as possible the tastes of the people in the character of manufactures intended for sale in these various countries. The Belgian Commissioner at the Centennial has organized a company of European capitalists for the purpose of manufac? turing plate glass, the works to be loca? ted near Pittsburg, Pa. Fax. Sitting Bull's White CHiEF.--The commission which was sent to Sitting Bull made an important discovery in the fact that the warrior has in his camp a white prisoner captured at the Custer massacre. Before reaching Fort Walsh rumors reached the commission that Sit? ting Bull held some of Ouster's men as prisoners, and after the first conference one of the half-breed interpreters em
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
A report describes a corporal named Martin Ryan claimed to have been captured alive at the Little Bighorn and adopted into Sitting Bull's family, later made a war chief and married to his daughter. Army investigators found his name on the Company I muster rolls, though Sitting Bull refused to confirm or deny holding prisoners.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Anderson Intelligencer · 29 November 1877 · page 3
Davis will vote with the Democrats, and Senators Patterson and Connover, of Florida, are also pledged to vote with them; hence the vote will stand for ad? mission 37 to 86 against, if every Re? publican, except Patterson and Connover, vote against the admission. It is, there? fore, almost certain that General Butler will be admitted; and hence there has been a very great change in the appear? the office which he holds. ances with respect to this question within the past two weeks. ? Turkey has received the ultimatum f.om the Providence Tool company?-"no money, no guns."
See moreSee less
one of the half-breed interpreters em ployed by Gen. Terry visited the camp, and, while passing through was accosted in English by a person dressed and pai uted. as a chief, who said that his name was Martin Ryan, who was a corporal in company I, 7th Cavalry, Col. Keough's company, and bad been taken a prisoner at the battle of the Little Big Horn with Custer. Inquiry apparently substantiated this assertion, and the following facts were ascertained: Ryan's life had been spared by Sitting Bull himself, who adopted him into bis family. Ryan made several attempts to escape, but be? ing carefully guarded was unsuccessful, and on each occasion he was severely beaten. He has apparently accepted the situatioo, and Sitting Bull has made him a war chief and married Ryan to one of his own daughters. Ryan has let his hair grow long in Indian fashion, dresses as an Indian, and is known by the Sioux as the White Chief. Upon the return of the commission to St. Paul, General Terry caused the mus? ter rolls of Company I, Seventh Cavalry, to be examined, and found that Martin Ryan's name is borne as -corporal, and that he was present for duty when his command went into that fatal action of June 25, 1876. It was stated by the friendly Indians that there are several others of Custer's men prisoners in Sit? ting Bull's camp, but Ryan's case was the only one which was verified. Sitting Bull was asked the question direct by General Corbin if he took any prisoners of the Seventh Cavalry, and answered flatly, "That is none of your business."
A newspaper interview relates a secondhand description, attributed to Sitting Bull, of General Custer ('Long Hair') standing amid fallen soldiers at the climax of the battle, firing his pistol until it failed, and laughing as he died. Sitting Bull also claims Reno was held back from aiding Custer by only women, old men, and children.
The Pickens Sentinel · 29 November 1877 · page 4
The Death of Custer Sitting Bull has been talking with a corru6pondent, and telling the story of the Custer massacre. lie says: "T']!he fight was heill a thousand devilst The squaws were like flying birds; the bullets like humming boes. . We thought we were whipped, not at first, but by and by. Afterward no. Your people were killed. I tell no lies about dead men; those men who came with The Long Hair wore as good mon as over fought. When they rodo up, their horses wore tired, and tboy were tired.
See moreSee less
When they got off their horses they could not stand firmly on their feet. They swayed to nnd fro, so my young men have told me, like the limbs of cypress in a great wind. Some of them staggerod under the weight of their guns; but they began to fight at once. But by this time our (amps were aroused, and thei wore plenty of worriors to meet them. They fired with noodle guns; we replied with magazino guns, re peating rifles." Sitting Bull illustrated by" putting his palms together with the rapidity of a fusilado. "Our young men rained lead across the river, and drovo the white bravos back, and then they rushed across themselves, and then they found that they had a good deal to do. The trouble was, with the soldiers, that they were so exhausted, and their horses bothered them so much, that they could not take good aim. Some of their horses broke away from them, and left them to stand and drop and die. All tho men fell back fight ing and dropping. They could not fire fast enough, though they kept in pretty good order. They would fall back across a caulio and make a fresh stand beyond on higher ground. There were a great many brave men in that fight, and from time to time, while it was going on, they weoro shot down like pigs. They could not help themselves. One by one the officeors fell. W here the last fight took place, where the last stand '.ias made, Theo Long Hair stood like a sheaf of corn with all the ears fallen around him." 'Not wounded?' 'iNo.' 'How many stood by him?' 'A fe w.' 'When did ho fall?' 'liIe killed a man. When he fell ho laughed.' 'You mean ho cried out?' 'No. lHe laughed. lie hael fired his last shot.' 'From a carbine?' 'No; a pistol.' 'Did ho stand up after ho first fell?' 'Ho rose up on his hands, and tuied another shot, but his pir,tol would not go off.' 'W as any one else standing up when ho fell down?' 'Ono man was kneeling. That wvas all. But he died before The Long Unir.' Sitting Bull says there were only squaws, old meon and little children in front of Reno, keeping him in his strong position on the bluff, and pro venting him from going to aid Custer. APPR~oPRIATE NAMEs.-For a pri n~ ter's wife, Em; for a sport's wife, Bet ty; for a lawyer's wife, Sub; for a teamster's wife, Carrie; for a fishor man's wife, Netty; for a shoemaker's wife, Peggy; for a. carpenter's wife, NlattLic; for a chemist's wife, Ann lEliza; f'or an engineer's wrife, Bridg~ et; for a hatter's wife, Hattie.
The Anderson Intelligencer · Anderson Court House, S.C.
A government commission visiting Sitting Bull reportedly discovered a white prisoner from Custer's command, Corporal Martin Ryan, who had been adopted by Sitting Bull, married to his daughter, and made a war chief. Muster rolls supposedly confirmed Ryan was present at the battle, though Sitting Bull himself refused to confirm or deny holding prisoners.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Anderson Intelligencer · 29 November 1877 · page 2
SITTING BULL'S WHITE CHIEF.-T commission which was sent to Sitti Bull made an important discovery in t fact th vt the warrior has in his catnr. white prisoner, captured at the Cus massacre. Betoro reaching Fort Wa rumors reached the commission that E ting Bull held some of Custer's mer* prisoners, and after tho first conferei ono of tho half-breed interpreters e ployed by Gen. Terry visited, the eau ana while passing through was accost in English by a person dressed s painted.as a chief, wno said that his na was Martin Ryan, who was a corporal company I, 7th Cavalry, Col.
See moreSee less
Keoug company, and had been taken a prisoi at the battle of who Little Big Horn w Custer. Inquiry apparently substantia tim assertion, and the following fa vieira ascertained : Ryan's, life had ht spared by Sitting Bull himself, v adopted him into his family. R) made several attempt/ to escape, but" ing carefully guarded was unsuccessJ and on each occasion he was sever beaten. He has apparently accepted situation, and Sitting Bull has made I r? war chief and married Ryan to one his own daughters. Ryan bas let bair grow long in Indian fashion, dres as an Indian, and is known by the Sic os the White Chief. Upon tho return of tho commission St, raul. General Terry caused thc m ter rolls of Company ?, Seventh Cava! to bo examined, and found that Mai Ryan's name is borne as corporal, i that he was present for duty when command went into that fatal action Juno 25, 1876. It was stated by friondlw Tndinna that thoro ur? HOV* others bf Custer's men prisoners im I ting Bull's camp, but Ryan's case was only ono which was verified. Sitt Bull was asked the question direct General Corbin if ho took any prisor of the Seventh Cavalry, and answe flatly, "That 1B none of your business.
A newspaper correspondent interviews Sitting Bull over a year after the battle, who describes the fight as chaotic and fierce, calling it 'hell with a thousand devils.' He recounts how Custer's exhausted soldiers and horses struggled while his warriors rallied and eventually overwhelmed them.
The Home Journal · 29 November 1877 · page 1
SITTING 111 I.L Tells All He Hnna Altoul Ihe n.n-r mitwnrr. Sitting Hull has been talking with a correspondent and telling tho story of the Custer massacre. Ho says the fight was " hell with a thousand devils. The
In this interview, Sitting Bull describes the chaotic final stand where officers fell one by one until only Custer ('Long-Hair') remained standing, compared to a sheaf of corn with all its ears fallen. He details how Custer fired his last shots with a pistol, fell, tried to rise and fire again, then died laughing, surrounded by fallen soldiers.
The Home Journal · 29 November 1877 · page 1
No ; a pistol." " Did he stand up after he first fell?" " He rose upon hia hands ami tried another shot, but his pistol would not go off." " Wns anv one elso standing up when he fell down? " " no died before the Long-Hair." Sitting Bull says thero were only squaws, obi men ami nine cniiuren in front of General lieno, keeping him in liis strong position on the Itlufl", and pre venting him giving aid to Custer.
A report claims a commission sent to Sitting Bull discovered a white prisoner, supposedly Corporal Martin Ryan of Company I, Seventh Cavalry, captured at the Little Bighorn and now living as an adopted Sioux war chief. Army muster rolls reportedly confirmed Ryan's name as present for duty, lending credence to the extraordinary claim.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Kenosha Telegraph · 29 November 1877 · page 3
SINGULAR IF TRUE.
A Sly Old Fox?' At a reqent chase by the Queens coun ty huntfers, a wild fox not beiug obtaiu able, a tame one was brought into requi sition. On being loosed, the baying of the hounds and the oppressive noveltv of the situation’ struck terror into the heart of poor Reynard. He took to his heels in'right earnest and headed for the swamp without giving the grass time to grow under. ..his feet. ' Onon he (went, till his pursuers were’ left far be hind. At last, exhausted with his terror-inspired exertion, he dashed into the kitchen of a farm house.
See moreSee less
Being thoroughly domesticated, he soon man jaged to make known to the good house wife., th.at,,.he was hungry and thirsty. \ His wants. were ministered to, after ]which he stretched himself before the i fife, and fell into ’ a Soothing slumber. Meanwhile more than a score of zealous hunters were riding up and down, won dering where the fox could be. The joke leaked out, and more than one man in Queens county has remarked of late, “The fox is a sly dog—devilish sly.”— New York Sun. j”' -; SINGULAR IF TRUE. A Report That ar Survivor 6t, the Custer Massacre is in the CaipP 9*,.Sitting V i, •»’ i: . ' ? f; , The commissionwhich , was sent to’ Bull, says a e;ssondent, made an importaiit “(liscdvery in fact that the; warrior hajS i in A his camp a whiteprisoner captured Lat’; ihe : Ouster massacre. Before reaching Fort Walsh rumors reached the commission that fitting Bull ■ held some of Custer’s men as prisoners, and after the first con ference one of the-half-bheed< interpret ers employed by Gen.* Terry visited the camp, and, <v?hile passing . through, was accosted in English by a persondressed and painted ash chief, .-who, saidthat his name was Martin Ryan, who was a-corpor al in Company 1, Seventh Cavalry,, Col. Keough’s companyand had been taken a prisoner at the battle of the Little Big Horn with Custer. Inquiry apparently substantiated his assertion, .and the fol lowing facts were ascertained: Ryan’s life had been spared by Sitting Bull himself, who adopted him into his own family. Ryan made several attempts to escape, but, being carefully guarded, was unsuccessful,\ and on each occasion he was severely beaten. He has mow apparently accepted the situation, and Sitting Bull has made him a war chief, and; married Ryan to one of his own daughters. By an has let hjs hair grow long in Indian fashion, dresses as ah Indian, and is known by the Sioux as the-White Chief. . • ./L Upon the return of the commission to St. Paul, Gen. Terry caused the muster rolls of Company I, Seventh Cavalry,' to be examined, jmd . found that Martin Ryan’s name is, borne *as corporal, and that he was present, for,,dufy when his command went into that fatal action of June 25, -1876. \lt was stated by the friendly Indians thiff' there are several Others of Custer’s men prisoners in Sit ting Bull’s camp, but Ryan’s case was the only one which was Verified. Sit ting Bull was asked the question direct 1 by Gen. if he took any prisoners of the Seventh Cavalry, and answered flatly: “That is none of ■ your business. ” In regard to Corporal Ryan’s case, Gen. Terry has written a letter to the State Department through Secretary McCrary, detailing the facts as ascertained, -to the ; end that the assistance of the British Government may be asked to effect his release. Anecdote of George Washington. A cheetful view of Washington is given in a story once told by Mrs. Madison to ■ a little girl, who now repeats it in Lip pincott. “ One day in Philadelphia,” saiil Mistress Dolly Madison, I was s sitting 1 in my parlor with a very dear fribnd, Mrs. R. B. Lee, when in walked Payne Todd (her son) dressed in my cal ico bed-gown. '<■ While we were laughing at the figure he cut, the servant threw open the door, and announced General and Mrs. Washington. Whatto do with that dreadful boy I didn’t know. He could not face the Presi lent in that garb. Neither could he leave the room without meeting them, for the door they were .entering was the only one, I made him crawl quickly under a low, broad settee on which I was sitting. I had just time to arrange the, drapery when the Washingtons entered. After the courtly greeting, and the usual compli ments of the season, there came from ffnder the setfee a heavy sigh, which ev idently attracted the General’s notice. However, I only talked and laughed' a little louder, hoping to divert his atten tion, when—oh, me ’—there came an ; outcry and a kick that could not be ig nored. So I stooped down and dragged -Payne out'by the Teg.' ; Gen. Washing ton’s dignity left him for once.Laugh!' Why, he fairly roared! He nearly went into convulsions. The sight of that boy in that gowh, all so unexpected, coming wrong end first from under my seati-dt Was tOo‘ much. ” A Novel Election Bet. ■During the late political canvass a gentleman of this city, who is a strong Democrat, in the course of a political debate with a neighbor, who is a firm believer in the doctrines of the Repub lican party, made a bet with the latter that if Gen. .McClellan did not receive ■15,000 majority for Governor he would jshave himself with a dry razor —that is, brush or lather, and without a looking-glass—iipon a street'comer in a jp'ublic portion of this city, between the hours of 9 and 12 o’clock noon. ' Yesterday morning the venerable bld Democrat, being satisfied that “Little iMac’s ” majority will not reach the above (figure, took a seat on oiiebf the corners near the City Hall, took a razor out of i his pocket, and coolly ..began to comply,. ! with the terms of' the bet by shaving .himself, which operation he performed inagra-eeful and effective manner. • t The old gentleman is in his 92d.year/ and, we are informed, pot only voted for : Gen. Jackson but fought under him, he being a veteran of the war of 1812. It is rarely that a man of such an advanced age can shave himself, under the most favorable conditions, but to do so in public without a looking-glass, soap or brush, is certainty* 1 Extraordinary. He occasionally looked up and smiled, good naturedly at the groups of curious per sons who stopped to look at him. — Trenton (N J.) Free American. Twenty-four thousand dozen of eggs have just gone from Montreal to En gland in a single shipment tom of the deeper as on the shallower - ' rportions.' Eight feetbelow the surface Can .as .distinctly, as though the same distance on .uir, the.sand and shells there emitted by a' volume of water which “issues from beneath a ledge of rocks, •‘■ln shallQwer; portions similar emptons of sand and shells, indicate tbpj J resence of similar , Tut smaller small-pox. springs, while here and therein pointed b; vthegmdvmffomiAousj.tdai:k7look : ingdiole called a .natural well, Ihe depth ,of.wh .ch is soundless. “ : ' AEr ' ’ J, : Thi EWhich iuosfenllaffcts 'the beauty pf thi 5 spot is the effect.of tlm transmis sion c f light through. jthe, .water... . Hn.es as varied, and. as delic^iely’‘blended as those of the iarnboW’heem do embellish Jige sc il Upon' which the Waters rest. Qne Can c< mpare the; eiffrmicißg: coloring beMcath to nothing other, than, the mosaic floor of some grapd cathedral Palmetto leaves, egg Shells ale-bottles, suhk by tourists) who had preceded us, lay ■scattered here , and there, vested in in desceiit hues.— CindinncCti Gazette. - i dnsfi ■ ■ day.
The True Northerner · Paw Paw, Mich. · and 1 other paper
A newspaper reports that Martin Ryan, a corporal in Custer's Company I, was taken prisoner at Little Bighorn, spared and adopted by Sitting Bull, and later made a war chief married to the chief's daughter. General Terry confirms Ryan's name on the muster rolls and writes to the State Department seeking British assistance for his release, while Sitting Bull refuses to confirm or deny holding prisoners.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
The True Northerner · 30 November 1877 · page 3
SlMiULAH IF TRUE. A He port That a Survivor ot the Custer Massacre In In the Camp ot Hitting Hull. The commission which was sent to Sitting Rull, says a Washington corre spondent, made an important discovery in tho fact that the warrior has in his camp a white prisoner captured at the Custer massacre. Before reaching Fort Walsh rumors reached the commission that Sitting Rull held some of Custer's men as prisoners, and after the first con ference one of the half-breed interpret ers employed by Gen. Terry visited the camp, and, while passing through, was accosted in English by a person dressed and painted as a chief, who said that his name was Martin Ryan, who was a corpor al in Company 1, Seventh Cavalry, Col.
See moreSee less
Keouerh8 comDanv. and had been taken a prisoner at the battle of the Little Rig Horn with Custer. Inquiry apparently substantiated his assertion, and the fol lowing facts were ascertained : Ryan's life had been spared by Sitting Rull himself, whoadopted him into his own family. Ryan made several attempts to escape, but, being carefully guarded, was unsuccessful, and on each occasion he was severely beaten, ne has now apparently accepted tho situation, and Sitting Rull has made him a war chief, and married Ryan to one of his own daughters. Ryan has let his hair grow long in Indian fashion, dresses as an Indian, and is known by the Sioux as tho White Chief. Upon tho return of the commission to St Paul, Gen. Terry caused the muster rolls of Company I, Seventh Cavalry, to be examined, imd found that Martin Ryan's name is borne as corporal, and that he was present for duty when his command went into that fatal action of June 25, 1870. It was stated by the friendly Indians that there are several others of Custer's men prisoners in Sit ting Bull's camp, but Ryan's case was the only one which was verified. Sit ting Bull was asked tho question direct by Gen. Corbin if ho took any prisoners of tho Seventh Cavalry, and answered flatly: 44 That is none of your business." In regard to Corporal Ryan's case, Gen. Terry has written a letter to tho State Department through Secretary McCrary, detailing the facts as ascertained, to the end that the assistance of the Rritish Government may bo asked to effect his release. Anecdote of George Washington. A cheerf nl view of Washington is given in a story once told by Mrs. Madison to a little girl, who now repeats it in IAp pincott. 44 One day in Philadelphia," said Mistress Dolly Madison, 44 1 was sitting in my parlor with a very dear friend, Mrs. R. R. Lee, when in walked Payne Todd (her son) dressed in my cal ico bed-gown. While we wero laughing at the figure ho cut, the servant threw open the door, and announced General andMrs. Washington. Whattodowith that dreadful boy I didn't know. He could not faco the Presilent in that garb. Neither could he leave the room without meeting them, for the door they were entering was the only one. I made him crawl quickly under a low, broad settco on which I was sitting. I had just time to arrange tho drapery when tho Washingtons entered. Alter the courtly greeting, and the usual compli ments of the season, there came from under tho setteo a heavy sigh, which ev idently attracted the General's notice. However, I only talked and laughed a little louder, hoping to divert his atten tion, when oh, me ! there camo an outcry and a kick that could not bn iV. nored. So I stooped down and dragged l'ayno out by the leg. Gen. Washintr ton's dignity left him for once. Laugh ! Why, he fairly roared ! Ho nearly went into convulsions. The sight of that boy in that gown, all so unexpected, coming wrong end first from under my seat it was too much. A Jovel Election Bet. During the lato political canvass a gentleman of this city, who is a strong uemocrat, in tno ourso or a political debate with a neighbor, who is a firm nenever in the doctrines of the Ilepub licau paitv. made a bet with tho lntte mat n uen. Mcuieiian did not receive 15,000 majority for Governor ho would shave himself with a dry razor that is, without brush or lather, and without a looking-glass upon a Rtrert cornrr in public portion of this city, between tho I - -a t r. '' nours oi v and rz o clock noon. Yesterday morning the venerablo old Democrat, being satisfled that "Tittl Mac's " maioritv will not rcnh tho nl figure, took a seat on one of the corners near tho Citv Hall, took n. mnr nf f his pocket and coolly began to comply wuii uie terms oi tno bet by shaving inmseii, wnicn operation he performed m grurciui ana cuective manner. Tho old crentleman i in M 07, 1 and. wo ore informed, nnt Gen. Jackson but fought under him, lie being a veteran of tho war of 1812. It is rarely that a man of rupIi nn ndfrnnnnl ago can shave himself, under tho most favorable conditions, but to do so in public without a looking-glass, soap or brush, is certainly extraordinary. Ho occasionally looked tin and umilfvl cood naturedly at tho groups of curious per Bona who stopped to look at him. Trenton (AT. ,.) Free American. Twenty-four thousand dozn of eggs have just gone from Montreal to En i giana in a single shipment torn of the deeper as on the shallower portions, ISight feet below the surface can be seen, as distinctly as though the same distance on air, the sand and shells thero emitted by a volume of water which issues from beneath a ledge of rocks. In shallower portions similar eruptions of sand and shells indicate tho presence of similar but smaller springs, while here and there is pointed out by the guide an ommous, dark-looking hole called a natural well, the depth of which is soundless. That which most enhances the beauty of this spot is the effect of tho transmis sion of light through the water. Hues as varied and as delicately blended as those of the rainbow seem to embellish is the account : the soil upon which the waters rest. One can compare the entrancing coloring be neath to nothing other than the mosaic floor of some grand cathedral. Palmetto leaves, egg shells and ale-bottles, sunk by tourists who had preceded us, lay scattered here and there vested in iri descent hues. Cincinnati Gazette.
The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · 29 November 1877
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory
The report states that Sitting Bull's account of the Little Bighorn battle confirms earlier claims from scouts and friendly Indians that Major Reno failed to support Custer despite orders to attack in cooperation with him, even though he was close enough to hear gunfire. It notes these circumstances will be thoroughly investigated, and mentions separately that Reno was suspended from rank and pay for two years for insulting a lady.
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 30 November 1877 · page 2
---— Sitting Bull's story ot the Custer massacre confirms what the scouts and friendly Indians have told in re gard to the actions of Reno in that bloody fight. His orders were to make the attack in co operation with Custer, which he failed to do, although
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · Idaho City, Idaho Territory
The item notes that John Maguire, an actor and writer, authored a well-regarded article on the Custer massacre published in the Territorial Enterprise of Virginia City, Nevada. The piece is mentioned amid a roundup of local news and miscellany in an Idaho newspaper.
Idaho Semi-Weekly World · 30 November 1877 · page 3
, J J 01 Idaho for the Territorial Enterprise, pabl.shed at Virginia City, Nevada, and one of the leading papers of the Pacific coast. One of the best writ ten articles on the Custer massacre, an<l published in that paper, emanated fr«»m his pen. Mex who have been in the mouti tans report the ground thoroughly soaked at a considerable depth, and •covered with enough snow to prevent it frorrj freezing. This is happy news for the placer miner, as the spring's flio depends a great deal on the con -1 ■ditiun of the ground when the snow frlla. Mß Thomas Raxey, Deputy Revenue
Colonel Corbin reports that Sitting Bull, in interviews with a government commission, gave an account of the Custer battle broadly matching the commonly understood version, saying Custer charged a vastly larger force and was surrounded and destroyed. Sitting Bull also claimed that had Reno not retreated, the already-retreating Indians would have been demoralized and lost the fight.
THE IMPERISHABLE BOY. Hi* Sportive Kmluranre—An Animating [Fr.nn the KttMtoii Frre rrew.] The beat authorities among scientific persons have long conceded the fact that it is impossible to kill a boy by any of the recognized processes of demolition. He tumbles oir ehestnut trees and falls down wells with impunity; he is perfect ly happy in the midst of harrowing rail road accidents, and prematurely enthu siastic Fourth of July explosions afford him intense delight; the most persistent hook agents have done little more than discourage him, and able-bodied streaks of summer lightning have passed him by with disgust.
See moreSee less
Yesterday afternoon there was a per sistent recurrence of ominous silence und hilarious laughter among the two dozen wi murt. nirunn 01 uik r / • < / umi became bo monotonous that wo felt cnll««l upon to investigate. Wo looked, and behold ! tho boys had invented a new game, having all the elements of dangerous fun necessary to perfect en joyment. One hoy stood with his back against the wall; the next boy stooped down with his head in the first boy’s stomach; the third boy stooped witli his head ou the second boy’s back, and in this way the line of boys was continued back as far as desirable. Then all tho spare boys took a running leap in succession, and, putting their hands on the hindmost boy, jumped over as many as possible, to come down at the cud of the jump ou a boy’s neck with tho force of an infan tile pile-driver, and the next boy comes down on him in tho same way, the efforts of the jumpers beiug directed to break ing the line of the stoopers or their necks, either object appearing to be equally desirable and attainable. Tho position of the hoy agaiust the wall is one of great honor and responsibility. It requires a boy of strong stomach to enjoy the process of having the head of another boy driven into his waistband by the continued efforts of fifteen of his fellows. Sometimes the jumpers be come unbearably enthusiastic, and the boy against the wall finds it necessary to step aside to re-swallow his dinner. This gives the stooping boy a chance to distinguish himself, as his heed is jammed against the wall so hard that he feels his cars sticking out under his arms. Sometimes it happens that a i Hinall, consumptive boy gets into the line of stoopers, and when a big boy comes down on his back he breaks in ! two, and this causes a hiatus that is imj mediately tilled by the stoopers in the i rear, who sprawl on their noses and elj bows, while the remaining jumpers ca- ; vort over them like a cavalry charge. We always like to encourage little ' games of this kind. They have a sooth ing effect upon market bills, the noise outside and the undertaker. The game to which wc refer has resulted iu no mor tality so far; but it is only three days old, and we have an abiding hope. Sew England Thanksgiving. It is November. The mouth oi‘ the year when chickens ami turkeys go to roost nightly with fear and trembling, and shiver with apprehension at each approaching footstep; and as for the un happy geese, they are goose-flesh, all over with fright. The proclamation is out, and Thanks giving is at hand. Grandma has read the Governor’s primly-worded document through her steel-bowed spectacles, anti pronounced it a real “ pious ” and “ sensible ” docu ment. The last Thursday in November, as usual. She and Sally have talked over the number of kiuds of pies it will bo neces sary to have; and the momentous ques tion of roasting or broiling the chickens has been discussed, and the best way of serving up a turkey has been settled up on, and it is decided to have boiled cab bage and beets, by way of salad. Charlie is coming home from Boston, and he likes apple “ dowdy” and cream, and so that old-fashioned dish muRt have a place on the Thanksgiving dinner table. Ttien there is Sadie, who has a pecul iar fondness for baked sweet apple pud ding, and Sadie’s taste is respected and provided for accordingly. Aud Henry could eat his weight in mince pie, and Annie prefers her chick en fricasseed, and she is going to bring : the baby, and the baby is crazy after jumbles. I What a bustle and stir prevails in the old farmhouse in preparation for Thanks giving. What stewing and roasting and boiling are going on. The kitchen is redolent of the smell of meats ami savory stuffings, and >piced | pies, and luscious condiments. Egg shells strew the back yard, and the few disconsolate-looking biddies who 1 have escaped the grand slaughter, linger | forlornly around, and peek shyly at the shells, and cackle, and retire precipitate ly when they hear the sound of an open ing door anywhere. All their gay as surance of manner is gone, ami the very rooster has ceased his lordly maguifi i cence of strut, and, with his tail at half mast, sneaks around and cuts shoit his sonorous crow, and hides behind the barn whenever he sees anybody who knows about Thanksgiving approaching. Everybody is busy. Such quantities of raisins to be stoned, and such lots of currants to be picked over and washed. And it is such a job to pick over currants. Aud there is the sugar to be sifted, and the eggs to be beaten, and such wonderful pyramids of cake to construct and frost and spot with currant jelly. The night before Thanksgiving all the cupboards and pantries are crowded with the tempting good tilings, and the fam ily, tired but happy, put on their “good clothes,” and wait for the train—for, | alas! the days are over when stage | coaches brought the loved absent ones ; to the very door, and the driver got his I drink of sweet cider and his hands full i of doughnuts out of the household fund i of edibles and overflowing happiness, i Thanksgiving! Holiday long ob served and honored! Season of feasting 1 and marriages—of rejoicing aud festiv ! ity ! Happy for those who linve dear ones to come home and gather around | the board! doubly sad for those whose kindred have taken the long journey | from which [no proclamation of Thanks giving can bring them back!—Kate Thorn. Sitting’ Dull. Col. Corbin, of the Government com mission appointed to confer with Sitting Bull upon his future course and demands, has returned to Washington. He says that Sitting Bull, while very formal and ! dignified in council, did not treat the ( ; commission ungraciously in a private I way, but was very companionable, and | gave the members of the commission ' several interviews, which were interest ing and important. In one of these he gave a description of the Custer massa cre, which differed very little from the circumstances as generally understood. Custer charged Sitting Bull and his band, who outnumbered him ten to one, and was surrounded and destroyed be fore ho could cut his way out. Sitting Bull says that if Reno had not retreated when he did the Indians, who were al ready retreating, would have been badly demoralized and lost the fight. Sitting Bull accompanied the commission in a several-hours’ ride on their return journey.__ Bow the French Workman Lives. The French laborer probably gets more for his wages than any other. His food is cheaper and more nourish ing. His bouillon is the liquid essence of beef at a penny per bowl. His bread at the restaurants is thrown in without any charge, and is the best bread in the world. His hot coffee and milk is ped dled about the streets in the morning at a sou per cup. It is coffee, not slops. His half bottle of claret is thrown in at i DM1 ill costing 12 cents. For a few •entfl he may enjoy an evening’s amuse* nent at one of the many minor theaters, ivitli liis coffee free. Sixpence pnys for Society. i nicely cushioned seat at the theater. \To gallery gods, no peanuts, pipes, Petersburg. moke, ilrunkenness, yelling or howling. Phe Jardiu des Plantes, the vast gal leries aud museums of the Louvre, Hotel ‘onut of mud. I’lunv, Palace of the Luxembourg, and Versailles are free for him to enter. Art ind science hold out to him their choicest treasures at small cost, or no *ost at nil. French economy aud fru gality do not mean that constant ro reuehraeiit and self-denial which would leprive life of everything which makes t worth living for. Economy in France, more than in any other country, means i utilization of what America throws iway, hut it does not mean a pinching process of reducing life to a barren ex istenceof work and bread aud water.
The New York Herald reports that Sitting Bull's testimony corroborates earlier suspicions that Major Reno's early retreat encouraged the Indians to attack Custer's column with greater ferocity. The report criticizes Reno for withdrawing to safety while Custer's force was annihilated, and laments that he remains in the army.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The New North-West · 30 November 1877 · page 2
Another Dark Spot on a Disgraced Officer
Iiscw YORK, Nov. 17-Major Reno's con acot in the. battle which resulted In. the massacre of Custer's command is severely 3riticised in view of Bitting Bull's corrobo ration of the suspicions created by stories heretofore derived from scouts and friendly [ndtans. The Herald says as soon as it hecame possible to construct from the ex cited stories of the participants and wit nesses a connected and logical chronicle of hat bloody fight, it was seen that the oondnct of Major Reno called for an ex planation. Observations were made at the time upon the circumstance that this offi cer, appointed to co-operate in a combined advance upon the Indian position, did not do his whole duty under his advance.
See moreSee less
On encountering somnfe resistatwe he allowed himself to be easily whipped, and with drew his force to a comparatively safe place and saved his men, within sound of the fire that annihilated the force with which he was to co-operate. Sitting Bull now tells the story of the battle, which im plies that Major Reno had so completely withdrawn from the fight before Custer ever got into it, that the Indians thought there was only one column which had with drawn from the first point to attack anoth er. It was under the sense of encourage ment given them by Reno's fight that the Indians assailed Custer's command with such unusual vigor, and having destroyed it, they would have destroyed Reno's also with equal thoroughness but for Terry's arrival. This new light on the battle, con firming so absolutely what was before thought, will give new occasion for regret that Major Reno is still an officer in the army under a too lenient remission of his sentence for another offense. The Tribune says if Sitting Bull tells the truth, Reno's. first attack was merely a light skirmish, and his force remained perched upon the heights facing the squars and superannuated warriors, when, if he had renewed the assault in accordance with Custer's plan, he might have saved the lives of his gallant comrades. Reno has stated in his official report that he knew nothing of Caster's engagement. Sitting Bull says that the squaws in front of ~eano beard distinctly the sound of firing. Major Reno is not in a position to com mnand public sympathy. He was condemn ed by court martial last spring for insulting a lady, and was suspended from rank and pay for two years. Nw YonRK, Nov. 19.-The Herald's Washington special says that Major Reno is visiting Washington, and was waited upon by a correspondent of that paper con cerning the charges made against him in in the account of the Rosebud fight given by Sitting Bull. He was not disposed to discuss the subject at any length. He sees no occasion for reopening the question of the Little Big Horn battle; that question is well understood by the officers of the army who weioengaged in it and by their supe riors under whose supervision their re ports passed. He attaches very little im portance to the statement of Sitting Bull, especially to that part in which the chief says a long-haired chief, whom he suppos ed to be Reno, after crossing the Little Big Horn, became frightened at a camp of old men, squaws and papooses. He says that on the morning of the battle he sepa rated from Custer with a detachment of. three companies and a party of scouts, and with no further ordeis'from him than to attack the village in the woods on the south side of the Little BigHorn. lie moved off and did as he' wa tdid, being assured Cus ter would support him. He does not con sider himself any more responsible for the kiling of Custer and his men than' any man in New York would have been. On the other hand, he thinks either want of a definite plan of battle, or a mistake of Gen. Custer placed the attacking detachment in serious, and, to some extent unnecessary jeolpardy. Ie is grieved that certain pa pers should charge him with enmity to so brave and gallant a man as Custer. They were personal friends, he says, and were upon the best of terms, having been in the Military Academy at West Point together, and kuowing each other for many years. Ren has very little confidence in Sitting Buil oranyotrher Indian, and wants no further vindication of his character as a soldier in' regard to the Little Big Horn fight, than the official reports of Sherman, Cook and Terry, and the statements of the survivors of the battle. SThe Pittsburg Contempt Case Decided PHILADELPIIIA, November 12.-A spec ial from Pittsburg says: "The Supreme Court this morning announced its decision in the case of the attachments for Govern or Hartranft and other State officials and Gen. lirinton, to appear before the Grand Jury and testify concerning the riots. The decision of Judge Kirkpatrick granting the attachments is reversed. The Chief Justice said, in announcing this as the de cision of the. majority of the court, that no
Major Reno dismisses Sitting Bull's claims that he was frightened at a village of old men, women and children, stating he merely followed Custer's orders to attack the village. He suggests Custer may have erred in planning, but denies personal responsibility for Custer's death, citing official army reports as sufficient vindication.
The New North-West · 30 November 1877 · page 2
pay for two years. Nw YonRK, Nov. 19.-The Herald's Washington special says that Major Reno is visiting Washington, and was waited upon by a correspondent of that paper con cerning the charges made against him in in the account of the Rosebud fight given by Sitting Bull. He was not disposed to discuss the subject at any length. He sees no occasion for reopening the question of the Little Big Horn battle; that question is well understood by the officers of the army who weioengaged in it and by their supe riors under whose supervision their re ports passed.
See moreSee less
He attaches very little im portance to the statement of Sitting Bull, especially to that part in which the chief says a long-haired chief, whom he suppos ed to be Reno, after crossing the Little Big Horn, became frightened at a camp of old men, squaws and papooses. He says that on the morning of the battle he sepa rated from Custer with a detachment of. three companies and a party of scouts, and with no further ordeis'from him than to attack the village in the woods on the south side of the Little BigHorn. lie moved off and did as he' wa tdid, being assured Cus ter would support him. He does not con sider himself any more responsible for the kiling of Custer and his men than' any man in New York would have been. On the other hand, he thinks either want of a definite plan of battle, or a mistake of Gen. Custer placed the attacking detachment in serious, and, to some extent unnecessary jeolpardy. Ie is grieved that certain pa pers should charge him with enmity to so brave and gallant a man as Custer. They were personal friends, he says, and were upon the best of terms, having been in the Military Academy at West Point together, and kuowing each other for many years. Ren has very little confidence in Sitting Buil oranyotrher Indian, and wants no further vindication of his character as a soldier in' regard to the Little Big Horn fight, than the official reports of Sherman, Cook and Terry, and the statements of the survivors of the battle. SThe Pittsburg Contempt Case Decided PHILADELPIIIA, November 12.-A spec ial from Pittsburg says: "The Supreme Court this morning announced its decision in the case of the attachments for Govern or Hartranft and other State officials and Gen. lirinton, to appear before the Grand Jury and testify concerning the riots. The decision of Judge Kirkpatrick granting the attachments is reversed. The Chief Justice said, in announcing this as the de cision of the. majority of the court, that no