As the Papers Told It

John Brown's Raid · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

Will Old Brown Be Hanged?

November – December 1859

Through November Virginia watched for a rescue. Dispatches warned of men arming in Ohio, the governor called out a thousand men, and Virginians were told to stay at home on the day of the hanging while some 2,000 troops guarded Charlestown. Brown’s counsel gathered affidavits of insanity in his family for a pardon, and a Pennsylvania paper charged that an anonymous warning sent to Secretary Floyd in August had been suppressed. In Boston about 2,000 people met at Tremont Temple to raise money for his family.

A dropped letter, an arrest in Memphis

An Iowa paper reports the arrest at Memphis of W. R. Palmer, charged with aiding Brown. On 22 October a traveller picked up a letter dropped on a train, addressed to ‘Capt. John Brown, Harper's Ferry, Va.,’ and signed Lawrence Thatcher; sent on by Governor Wise, it tied Palmer to a plan for a slave rising in Tennessee timed with the raid. Palmer was jailed in default of $2,500 bail.

Muscatine Weekly Journal · Muscatine, Iowa

Muscatine Weekly Journal · 18 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

A RAMIFICATION OF THE HARPER'S FERRY CONSPIRACY.—A man named W. R. Palmer has been arrested at Memphis, Tenn., charged with complicity with John Brown in the Harper's Ferry conspiracy. The circumstances attending his arrest are singular: On the 22d of October, a traveler on a railroad between New York and Philadelphia observed two letters drop out of the pocket of a man who was leaving the cars. He picked them up too late to return them to their owner, but, after discovering that one of them was addressed to "Capt. John Brown, Harper's Ferry, Va.," he sent it to Gov.

See moreSee less

Wise, who, in turn, sent it to the Governor of Tennessee. The disclosures made in the letter, which was dated Memphis, Tenn., Oct. 2, 1859, and signed by Lawrence Thatcher, clearly implicated Palmer in the attempt to incite an insurrection among the slaves of Tennessee simultaneously with old Brown's strike at Harper's Ferry. The writer of the letter professes to have had an interview with Palmer, in which he avowed that he had married a widow with a large number of slaves, for the purpose of more effectually accomplishing his work of inciting an insurrection among them. The Memphis Avalanche says the circumstances detailed in the letter agree with the facts concerning Palmer's movements. He was held to bail, in the sum of $2,500, to appear before the Circuit Court, and, in default of the amount, was committed to jail.

See the clipping

Emerson speaks for Brown's family

About two thousand people fill Boston's Tremont Temple on 19 November to raise money for Brown's family, with John A. Andrew presiding. The Rev. J. M. Manning declares Brown not insane, and Ralph Waldo Emerson, who brings fifty dollars from Concord, says Brown believes in ‘the golden rule and the Declaration of Independence’. In February Andrew would be questioned about paying for Brown's defence.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 20 November 1859 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

RELIEF FOR THE FAMILY OF OLD BROWN. BOSTON, Nov. 19, 1859.

The meeting at the Tremont Temple this evening in behalf of the family of John Brown was fully attended. About two thousand persons were present, and the net profits will doubtless give several hundred dollars to the beneficiaries. A large number of ladies were present.

See moreSee less

The assemblage was called to order about half-past seven o'clock by Hon. John A. Andrew. He was accompanied by the Rev. J. M. Manning, of the Old South church; Rev. Dr. Neal, of the Somerset street Baptist church, and Wendell Phillips. They were received with hearty applause. The Divine blessing was invoked by Dr. Neal, who also offered up prayer for the family of Brown.

Mr. Emerson then made his appearance on the platform, and the applause was of the heartiest kind.

Mr. Andrew stated that he was present merely as a presiding officer, and would make but a few remarks, and would then announce the speakers. He referred to the letter of John Brown to Lydia Maria Child, and read that portion of it suggesting the need of aid to the writer's family. John Brown, he remarked, had fallen for an idea. Whether his course was wrong or not, Brown himself was right. The speaker sympathized with that idea, and all who did should see to it that the family of that honest man should not suffer by the loss of their natural protectors.

A letter from Rev. C. H. Hefforuth was read, declining to be present, as had been announced in the papers. His letter was hissed. He stated that he had understood both sides of the question were to be discussed. However, Mr. Andrew said, it was hardly likely that any one present thought there were two sides to the question as to whether John's Brown's family should be left to starve. Mr. Andrew made some farther remarks relative to the position of John Brown and his family and the eternal and Heaven sustained nature of the "irrepressible conflict." After stating that lithographic copies of Brown's letters to Mrs. Child had been printed and were for sale at the door at ten cents, he introduced the Rev. Mr. Manning.

Mr. Manning thought it was rather difficult to speak of the subject on hand to-night without expressing an opinion regarding the affair at Harper's Ferry. He should never have advised Brown to do what he had done. Fillibusters went to Southern lands to rescue men from Spanish tyranny, and were not molested. But Brown had interfered with home tyranny and must die. Brown was not insane. He was the sword in the hand of a Higher Power. He was the finger of God writing upon the wall of Belshazzar's palace the doom of tyrants. Mr Manning took his hearers back to the day of the Boston Massacre, when Crispus attacks the colored man fought in defence of the liberty of white men. No patriot would have advised his attack on the British soldiery. But the citizens of Boston followed his remains to the grave in long procession, and year after year celebrated the anniversary of that massacre. The last public address Joseph Warren made before he fell at Bunker Hill was on such an occasion—an address made in the very face of British bayonets, and defying intimidation. After Bunker Hill that celebration was changed to the Fourth of July. Daniel Webster said that from the day of the Boston massacre was dated the disruption of the British empire. So might it be with the death of John Brown. Should, half a century hence, its result be the freedom of the whole land, no man would find fault with the battle of Harper's Ferry—when some other Daniel Webster, at a safe distance, might say that from the moment when John Brown swung between heaven and earth, might be dated the beginning of the end of American slavery. Mr. Manning drew other parallels. The government journals of 1770 charged the trouble on the ministers stirring up the people. The patriots said that it was caused by parading British regiments in Boston. So does the slave power parade before Northern conscience the revolting wickedness of slavery. The speaker then counselled, at some length, the cherishing of love for the slaveholder while we hated slavery. Faithfulness linked with love and firm adherence to duty was the rightful path, remembering that the roots of slavery were in Northern soil as well as Southern.

Ralph Waldo Emerson was next introduced. Mr. Andrew, in introducing Mr. Emerson, said that we had just heard from the old South church, with its holy memories of patriots, and we would turn next to the battle ground of Concord. He quoted a verse of Mr. Emerson's poetry, and the whole introduction was unusually felicitious.

Mr. Emerson spoke substantially as follows:—In reference to the cause which has brought us together, the gentleman who preceded me has well said that between us, whatever our theological views, no wall of separation could here exist. That commanding event, the sequel to which has brought us together to night, eclipses all others which have occurred for a long time in our history. I am glad to see that the prevalent interest in the hero of Harper's Ferry has provoked curiosity in all parts of the country in regard to the details of his individual history. It is not wonderful that gentlemen in all parts of the country are finding threads of relationship between themselves, and he was happily a representative of the American republic. This John Brown is a farmer, the sixth in descent from Peter Brown, who came to Plymouth in sixteen hundred and twenty in the Mayflower. I say the sixth, and all the six were farmers. His grandfather, of Symsbury, Conn., was a captain in Revolutionary history. His father was largely interested in cattle, and became a contractor for the supply of beef to the army in eighteen hundred and twelve. Our Captain Brown, then a boy, with his father, was present as a witness at the surrender of Hull. Captain Brown cherished always a very high respect for his father as a man of strong character. It is probable that his estimate was just. As for Captain Brown himself he is so transparent that all men can see through him. He is a man to make himself felt wherever in the world courage and integrity are esteemed—the rarest of heroes, and yet a pure idealist. Every one who has heard him speak has been impressed alike by his simple and artless goodness and his sublime courage. He joins the high faith of the good man with the Revolutionary spirit of his grandfather. He believes in two instruments—the golden rule and the Declaration of Independence. When he was here he used in conversation these words:—"Better that a whole generation of men, women and children should pass away by violent death, than that one word of these two should be broken in this country." There is a Unionist and a strict constructionist for you. He believes in the union of American States, and he conceives that the only enemy of the Union is slavery, and for this reason, as a patriot he seeks its abolition. Governor Wise has pronounced his eulogy in a manner that does discredit to the moderation of our own timid partisans. Captain Brown's speeches to the Court have interested a nation in him. What artlessness and plainness! If he had interfered in behalf of the great or the wealthy, or the wise, he said, no one would have blamed him; but he believed that when he interfered in behalf of a poor and depised people he was doing right. What a favorite will he be in history, which plays such pranks with more temporary reputations. Nothing can resist it. If he suffers death, it is plain that he will drag certain official gentlemen into an immortality most undesirable, and of which they have already some disagreeable forebodings. Indeed it is the resolution of the Governor of Virginia to hang the man whom he says possesses the greatest integrity, truthfulness and courage that he ever met. Is that the kind of men for whom the gallows are built? No man dare believe that there exists in Virginia another man as worthy to live, as deserving of public and private honors, as this poor prisoner. But we are here to think of the relief of the family of John Brown. To my eyes, the family looks very large and in need of relief. It comprises his brave fellow sufferers in the jail, the poor fugitives who are hunted still in the mountains of Virginia and Pennsylvania, all the sympathizers in every State, and every man who loves the golden rule and the Declaration of Independence like him, and who sees the tiger instinct that threatens himself in the malignant public sentiment that exists at the South. I said, just now, that John Brown is an idealist, but he believes in his ideas to such an extent that he labored to put them all into action. He did not believe in moral suasion, but in putting things through.

We in Massachusetts fancy we are free, but it seems that we are somewhat mistaken. We have great population, great wealth, great talent—and yet life and freedom are not safe, because the judges rely on the forms of law, and do not, like John Brown, use their eyes to see the sail before the storm. They assume that the United States can protect the prisoner and his witness. The State Judges fear a collision between two belligerents, and cannot find law enough to maintain the sovereignty of the State. At a pinch they are of no more use than idiots. After a thing has been done they may wring their hands at the result, but they had better never been born. A Vermont Judge knows the laws protect with their whole power the citizen, and is worth a whole court house full of lawyers so idolatrous of forms as to let go the substance. Is any man in Massachusetts so simple as to believe that when a United States Court in Virginia, in these times of excitement, sends into the North for a witness that it wants him to slaughter and eat? Your habeas corpus may be a nuisance by taking away the right reliance of a citizen and substituting therefor a form. I hope, then, that in addition to our relief to the family of John Brown, we shall endeavor to relieve all those in whose behalf he suffers and all those who are in sympathy with him, and not forget to aid him, also, in the best way by securing freedom and independence in Massachusetts itself. Mr. Emerson spoke about twenty-three or four minutes.

Mr. Andrew then said that Mr. Emerson had not come empty handed, but had brought with him from Concord a contribution of fifty dollars. A Finance Committee was appointed to solicit further subscriptions. The Chairman next introduced Wendell Phillips, who made the closing address. The meeting throughout was enthusiastic and the speakers were frequently and loudly applauded.

See the clipping

Talk of a rescue army from Ohio

A Charlestown dispatch of 21 November says calm has returned, with troops preparing a camp. It reports warnings, one from a U.S. Marshal in Ohio and one rumoured from Governor Chase, of six hundred to a thousand men arming for a rescue under John Brown, Jr. Chase later told Wise he had heard of no such preparations, and by the hanging the rescue talk was generally thought a hoax.

New-York Daily Tribune · New-York, N.Y.

New-York Daily Tribune · 22 November 1859 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

From Charlestown, Va. Charlestown, Monday, Nov. 21, 1859. Order prevails here now. The excitement of Saturday has subsided, and no suspicious parties have been discovered. Gov. Wise has received letters from intelligent and responsible parties in the North and West assuring him of the organization of bands for rescue. The presence of the military has restored composure and calmness to the public mind. The military are preparing an encampment. The Governor will return to Richmond to-morrow. We have cavalry, artillery, and infantry enough to encounter a small army of sympathizers. It is rumored that Gov.

See moreSee less

Wise has received a dispatch from Gov. Chase of Ohio, informing him that a large body of men—from six hundred to a thousand—are arming for a rescue, under command of John Brown, j.., and will undoubtedly start for Charlestown. Wise is said to have replied that if Gov. Chase allows them to cross the line, he will enter proceedings against him for treason. Also, a dispatch was received on Saturday from United States Marshal Johnson of Ohio, stating that from six hundred to a thousand men were arming for a rescue in that State. John Brown, jr., is the reported commander.

See the clipping

Brown's lawyer driven out of Charlestown

George H. Hoyt, a defence lawyer for Brown, tells how he and Mr. Jewett of Frank Leslie's paper were forced out of Charlestown, where he had returned for Brown's effects and copies of the other cases' records. Named in Mayor Green's proclamation, and blamed when a stable fire was laid to ‘Abolition emissaries’, they were told by Col. Davis, Wise's aide, that he could not protect them from a mob.

The Liberator · Boston, Mass.

The Liberator · 25 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

From the N. Y. Tribune. THE EXPULSION OF MR. HOYT FROM CHARLESTOWN.

Sir: In order that the conduct of the people and authorities of the Town of Charlestown, Va., in recently expelling Mr. Jewett, of Frank Leslie's paper, and myself from that locality, may be perfectly exposed and understood, I deem it proper to make a brief statement of the facts in the case.

See moreSee less

My return from Boston to that town was heralded by the press, and the object of my visit announced, days before I reached there. My business was known to be legitimate. I went back to do what was possible to rescue and recover the scattered effects of Capt. Brown, in order that the avails of the same might be secured to his destitute and heart-stricken family. My business also related to the copies of the records in the other cases, intending to obtain and transmit them seasonably to counsel who were to argue the exceptions in the Court of Appeals. Because I was regularly associated in the trial, and known to be actively engaged in the defence of Brown and Coppic, no man had a right to accuse me, upon bare suspicion, without a particle of evidence to confirm it, of being an agent of 'Boston Abolitionists.'

I could not fail to observe, immediately upon my return, that, where I had formerly been treated with studious civility, I had now to meet the inhospitable frown ; and where before I at least was permitted to pass without insult, I must expect offensive and opprobrious epithets, and denunciations not the least vulgar. I cannot say that I did not expect this, for, when first a sojourner in the town, I had concluded it was no genuine, but a forced civility, which allowed the counsel of John Brown to perform their sad duties unmolested. I saw a deep under-current of feeling smothered, for the time, by a desire to be rated fair, all ready, at the slightest breath, to burst into consuming madness. But, so long as their victim lay in his prison-cell, waiting his fast-approaching doom, and the decision of the higher Court, I felt certain the 'chivalry of the Old Dominion' would attempt no bodily violence to his counsel.

I had expected the copies of the record would be ready for me to bear to Washington Saturday morning, but I failed to obtain them, and had concluded to wait a later train, when the singular 'proclamation' of Mayor Green, (who, it will be remembered, was Mr. Brown's counsel in the first instance,) fell into my hands. My surprise was great when a gentleman intimated that my case was referred to in that document, and that my friend, Mr. Jewett, was also included. I sought Mr. Jewett, and found him pondering over the extraordinary production. I informed him what I had heard, and after a debate as to whether two individuals, whose business was so well known, and whose characters were privileged, had any right to take this 'notice to quit,' Mr. J. sought Col. Davis, Chairman of the body constituted and authorized by this curious paper to act in the premises, and demanded to know if it had any reference to us. Col. Davis accompanied him to my presence, and in answer to a direct interrogatory, plainly said it did. He further informed us, that, although aid-de-camp to Gov. Wise, and under instructions to preserve the peace, he had no force at his command upon which he could rely to protect us from the mob, which would certainly assemble the next day (Sunday). He was willing to lay down his life in our defence, but it could be of no avail, and conjured us, for our own sakes, and for the sake of the honor of the State of Virginia, and in consideration of the trifling personal inconvenience such a sacrifice would be to him, to leave that afternoon.

Although I had seen considerable excitement in the place during the first days of the trial and afterward, I confess I never had seen anything like the wild foment in which the town was this afternoon thrown. Some spiteful enemy had set fire to a Mr. Tate's stable, and the over-zealous, fire-eating 'chivalry' who, from the time of our first advent in the place, had striven to make our visit uncomfortable, and our efforts futile, and who had never ceased their causeless and ridiculous denunciations, eagerly took hold of the occasion to spread the report that they were 'Abolition emissaries' acting under my directions, who had set the torch to the wheat stacks and barns.

What I most feared was an attack on the jail, in which the 'military' would participate. I have some good reasons for believing that there was a band of organized desperadoes who, at one time, determined to force the jail, and lynch the prisoners. This was seasonably discovered, and prevented, by an officer in command. Now, if a mob, composed of a drunken and infuriate people, should assemble to drive obnoxious people out of the town with the genteel incidents of 'tar and feathers,' and not over fresh eggs, such a mob would be more than likely to make an attempt on that little prison-house: and, by way of parenthesis, let me say, I think the gallows a pleasanter instrument of torture and death than the torments of a Virginia mob.

Deeming it no valor, but sheer foolhardiness to brave the populace, Mr. Jewett and I packed our bags, and quitted the municipality of Charlestown, the County of Jefferson, and the gallant old Commonwealth of Virginia. At this time I do not know whether my associate, Mr. Sennott, survived the Sabbath which ensued upon our departure, or not. Being an avowed political friend of the South, he was not so unpopular as the undersigned, who never knew how to 'cotton.' It is to be hoped that those who remain or go to serve John Brown in a legal capacity, may not meet the same sort of 'hospitality' and 'courteous' treatment which the 'chivalry' bestowed upon

Yours truly, GEO. H. HOYT. National House, Washington, Nov. 16.

See the clipping

A charge that Floyd hid the warning

A Pennsylvania paper reprints the anonymous Cincinnati letter of 20 August 1859 that warned Secretary Floyd of a rising led by ‘OLD JOHN BROWN, late of Kansas’ by way of Harper's Ferry. Setting it beside the Gunpowder Plot warning, the paper fears the government let the raid come to blame Republicans in 1860. On 2 December the New York Herald reprinted a Mobile paper naming Richard Realf as its possible writer.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 25 November 1859 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

The Supressed Warning.

We refer again, for the sake of keeping the matter prominently before the public, to the anonymous warning sent to Secretary Floyd concerning the Harper's Ferry outbreak. The question will recur with fatal distinctness—Why was the letter suppressed which contained this warning? It is a vain pretence to say that the Secretary regarded it as a 'hoax.'—Why, if he so considered it, did he hide it so carefully? Why his mysterious silence and concealment? A letter regarded as a 'hoax' would naturally be shown and laughed over among friends and associates. But instead, it is carefully concealed from view until the crisis of which it gave warning had passed.

See moreSee less

But the letter itself, is the best answer to this futile plea. It bears the impress of earnestness and sincerity in every line. It names persons, places and dates, so near at hand and so easy of verification and disproof, as to forbid the idea of its being an attempt at deception. Let any man of common sense read and see if it is the sort of letter he would pronounce a 'hoax.'

CINCINNATI, August 20, 1859.

SIR:—I have lately received information of a movement of so GREAT IMPORTANCE that I feel it to be my duty to impart it to you without delay. I have discovered the existence of a secret association having for its object THE LIBERATION OF THE SLAVES AT THE SOUTH BY A GENERAL INSURRECTION. The leader of the movement is OLD JOHN BROWN, late of Kansas. He has been in Canada during the winter, drilling the negroes there, and they are only waiting his word to start for the South to assist the slaves. They have one of the leading men, a white man, in an armory in Maryland, where it is situated I have not been able to learn. As soon as everything is ready, those of their number who are in the Northern States and Canada are to come in small companies to their rendezvous, which is in the mountains in Virginia. They will pass down through Pennsylvania and Maryland, and enter Virginia at Harper's Ferry. Brown left the North about three or four weeks ago, and will ARM THE NEGROES and strike the blow in a few weeks, and so whatever is done must be done at once. They have a large quantity of arms at their rendezvous, and probably distributing them already. As I am not fully in their confidence, this is all the information I can give you. I dare not sign my name to this, but I trust that you will not disregard the warning on that account.

If Secretary Floyd chose to consider this of doubtful authority, because lacking a signature, it was nevertheless his duty, as custodian of the Government Armory at Harper's Ferry, to satisfy himself by further examination.—Had he given the slightest warning—nay, had he even told of it as something he considered a 'hoax'—the citizens of Harper's Ferry would have been on their guard, and the attack would never have been attempted.

Nor is it any answer to say that the letter was anonymous, and therefore unworthy of notice. Warnings of such events would most naturally be anonymous. The Gunpowder Plot is an instance in point. Hume's History of England thus describes the warning given in that case:

"The dreadful secret, though communicated to above twenty persons, had been religiously kept during the space of near a year and a half. Ten days before the meeting of Parliament, Lord Monteagle, a Catholic son to Lord Morley, received the following letter, which had been delivered to his servant by an unknown hand:

"My Lord:—Out of the love I bear to some of your friends, I have a care of your preservation. Therefore, I would advise you, as you tender your life, to devise some excuse to shift off your attendance at this Parliament; for God and man have conceived to punish the wickedness of this time. And think not slighty of this advertisement, but retire yourself into the country, where you may expect the event in safety. For though there be no appearance of any stir, yet, I say, they will receive a terrible blow this Parliament, and yet they shall not see who hurts them. This counsel is not to be contemned, because it may do you good and can do you no harm; for the danger is passed so soon as you burn the letter, and I hope God will give you the grace to make good use of it. unto whose holy protection I commend you."

"Monteagle knew not what to make of this letter, and though inclined to think it a foolish attempt to frighten or ridicule him, he judged it safest to carry it to the Secretary of State."

It will be observed that the length of time while the plot was maturing, the number of persons engaged in it, and the anonymous letter sent to a Government officer, singularly coincide with the incidents of John Brown's plot.

But here the parallel ends. Lord Monteagle though his warning was but vague, and though he distrusted its authenticity, instantly took measures to detect and suppress the conspiracy, while Secretary Floyd, with a much more explicit letter in his hands, gives no hint of it, does nothing to prevent it, and lets the explosion come.

And why? In Lord Monteagle's day there were no elections pending that could be influenced by silence and concealment; in our day there are.

There is much reason to fear that the letter to Secretary Floyd was wilfully suppressed—that the government, while providing against the possible success of the movement, permitted it to be made that it might charge it upon the Republicans of the North, and make party capital out of it for 1860.

If that was the purpose, it is likely to be defeated. The capital will inure to the other side.

See the clipping

A Pennsylvania editor: hang the murderer

Two days before the execution, an Ebensburg, Pennsylvania, editorial says Brown must hang. It calls him a traitor and murderer who acted ‘In the full possession of all his mental faculties’, warns that a slave rising would have meant a war of extermination, and asks why those raising money for Brown's family raise none for the families of the men killed at Harper's Ferry.

Democrat and Sentinel · Ebensburg, Pa.

Democrat and Sentinel · 30 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Sympathy for a Murderer.

Next Friday is the day appointed for the execution of John Brown the would be wholesale murderer. We cannot after calmly reviewing the facts connected with the Harper's Ferry insurrection, coincide in opinion with those who contend that he should not be hanged. We think that outraged justice and the safety of society demands the sacrifice. If such a guilty wretch is treated with compassion and lenity, and allowed to go unwhipt of justice, where will be the security for the lives and property of the citizens of the Southern States? Is he not a traitor and a murderer? Is he any better than a M'Kim, a M'Conaghy, a Jacoby or the thousands of murderers who have died on the scaffold; or rather, is he not infinitely worse? We firmly believe that since Judas Iscariot who betrayed his God to his enimies, the earth has never been polluted by a wretch more deeply immersed in guilt than John Brown. In the full possession of all his mental faculties, he deliberately planned the most extensive scheme of murder and robbery, that can anywhere be found in the history of the world. But he was not content with devising in the guilty recesses of his soul, this plan for murdering in the most cruel manner his unoffending fellow countrymen. He had the heart and the will to attempt to carry his plan into execution. He collected his "warlike stores" and his myrmidons around him near Harper's Ferry, and at the hour of midnight, took possession of the town and U. S Arsenal. A number of unoffending citizens were murdered, and the slaves were encouraged to rebel against and murder their masters. If the insurrection was a failure, if it did not result in a general insurrection of the slaves in the Southern States it was not the fault of old John Brown. He confidently believed that the slaves would respond to his call to arms as promptly as the Scottish Highlanders did to the whistle of their Chieftain. In this he was disappointed, and consequently his enterprise resulted in a disgraceful failure. If Brown's hopes had been realized; if a servile insurrection of the slaves in Maryland, Virginia, Kentucky, North Carolina, &c., had immediately followed the taking of the U. S. Arsenal at Harper's Ferry, would not in all probability, those States ere this have been converted into a desert. If the insurrection had once fairly commenced it would have been a war of extermination. The land now as bright and smiling as the garden of Eden would have been turned into a reeking wilderness, and not only stalwart men but weak women and helpless children would have been brutally murdered or exposed to insults a thousand times worse than death. No one who has perused the history of the Negro insurrection in St. Domingo will contend that the foregoing picture is overdrawn. Is it not therefore strange, that any portion of the American people can sympathize with, and even idolize as a hero, the wretch who planned and attempted to carry out the system of wholesale murder we have discribed? As soon would we sympathize with a wretch standing before us with his hands crimsoned with the blood of our brother. The Abolitionists deeply commiserate the desolation which this unfortunate event has brought to the hearth stone of John Brown's home; but where is their sympathy or pity for the families of the men that he and his myrmidons murdered at Harper's Ferry? we hear of no subscriptions for their relief.

See moreSee less

But we have been told that Brown is a brave man, and that he looks death in the face without shrinking. This surely does not entitle him to sympathy. It only shows that he was fully aware of the hazardous nature of the enterprize he had embarked in, before he attacked Harper's Ferry. He knew the stake which he risked. "Having played the game boldly, he is determined that the forfeit shall be paid manfully." He is not the first instance of a murderer facing death without shrinking. Heroism displayed in a guilty and treasonable enterprize is certainly not entitled to admiration. A brave but bad man is the worst enemy of society that can be imagined. He has the courage to execute whatever guilty scheme his mind "fatal-bent on mischief" devises. Is it possible human mind to imagine a more in[illegible] than that for which Brown [illegible] of death in Vir[illegible] [illegible]id, we think [illegible] own should be punished with the utmost rigor of the Law. Virginia would not be true to herself or the Union if she allowed such a wretch to go unpunished.

Do the men who call old John Brown a hero approve of his foray on Harper's Ferry? Do they think he was right in lighting the torch of civil war in the land, and in endeavoring to procure the murder of the white inhabitants of the Southern States? Do they think he was justifiable in murdering his fellow citizens at Harper's Ferry? If they do not, then they should not sympathize with him or contend that he should not be put to death. A traitor and murderer is unworthy of the name of hero. We think it is impossible for a man to loath and despise the treason while he loves the traitor.

See the clipping

Virginia braces for hanging day

On the eve of the hanging, a Cleveland paper calls Brown a ‘heroic martyr to Freedom’ and says the terror of 2 December will fall on Virginia's plantations, not on the gallows. It points to Governor Wise's proclamation telling people to stay home on patrol, and to General Taliaferro's warning, with 2000 troops at Charlestown, as signs that ‘the MATCH IS FAST BURNING DOWN TO THE POWDER !’

Cleveland Morning Leader · Cleveland, Ohio

Cleveland Morning Leader · 1 December 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Execution of John Brown. Friday, December 2d, will be a day of terror throughout Virginia ! John Brown will be hung with the all pomp of military circumstance at Charlestown, the Governor of the State his executioner, if not the veritable hangman. The terror will not be on the gallows where the heroic martyr to Freedom meets his fate, but on the plantations and in the homes of the people whose bondsmen Brown laid down his own life to set free. That terror is clearly foreshadowed in the proclamation of Gov.

See moreSee less

Wise who warns the people to stay at home on patrol duty on the day of execution, to protect their own property. Gen. Taliaferro, commandant of the execution forces 2000 strong at Charlestown, also by proclamation emphatically warns the people of the country to stay at home and pro ect their property, assuring them that information from reliable sources indicates that by so doing they will best consult their own interest. Why this marshaling of troops, these proclamations to the people, this patrol duty in Virginia, in hanging until dead one old man ! It is that the MATCH IS FAST BURNING DOWN TO THE POWDER !

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: The Trial of Capt. Brown