The New York Herald · 20 November 1859 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
RELIEF FOR THE FAMILY OF OLD BROWN. BOSTON, Nov. 19, 1859.
The meeting at the Tremont Temple this evening in behalf of the family of John Brown was fully attended. About two thousand persons were present, and the net profits will doubtless give several hundred dollars to the beneficiaries. A large number of ladies were present.
See moreSee less
The assemblage was called to order about half-past seven o'clock by Hon. John A. Andrew. He was accompanied by the Rev. J. M. Manning, of the Old South church; Rev. Dr. Neal, of the Somerset street Baptist church, and Wendell Phillips. They were received with hearty applause. The Divine blessing was invoked by Dr. Neal, who also offered up prayer for the family of Brown.
Mr. Emerson then made his appearance on the platform, and the applause was of the heartiest kind.
Mr. Andrew stated that he was present merely as a presiding officer, and would make but a few remarks, and would then announce the speakers. He referred to the letter of John Brown to Lydia Maria Child, and read that portion of it suggesting the need of aid to the writer's family. John Brown, he remarked, had fallen for an idea. Whether his course was wrong or not, Brown himself was right. The speaker sympathized with that idea, and all who did should see to it that the family of that honest man should not suffer by the loss of their natural protectors.
A letter from Rev. C. H. Hefforuth was read, declining to be present, as had been announced in the papers. His letter was hissed. He stated that he had understood both sides of the question were to be discussed. However, Mr. Andrew said, it was hardly likely that any one present thought there were two sides to the question as to whether John's Brown's family should be left to starve. Mr. Andrew made some farther remarks relative to the position of John Brown and his family and the eternal and Heaven sustained nature of the "irrepressible conflict." After stating that lithographic copies of Brown's letters to Mrs. Child had been printed and were for sale at the door at ten cents, he introduced the Rev. Mr. Manning.
Mr. Manning thought it was rather difficult to speak of the subject on hand to-night without expressing an opinion regarding the affair at Harper's Ferry. He should never have advised Brown to do what he had done. Fillibusters went to Southern lands to rescue men from Spanish tyranny, and were not molested. But Brown had interfered with home tyranny and must die. Brown was not insane. He was the sword in the hand of a Higher Power. He was the finger of God writing upon the wall of Belshazzar's palace the doom of tyrants. Mr Manning took his hearers back to the day of the Boston Massacre, when Crispus attacks the colored man fought in defence of the liberty of white men. No patriot would have advised his attack on the British soldiery. But the citizens of Boston followed his remains to the grave in long procession, and year after year celebrated the anniversary of that massacre. The last public address Joseph Warren made before he fell at Bunker Hill was on such an occasion—an address made in the very face of British bayonets, and defying intimidation. After Bunker Hill that celebration was changed to the Fourth of July. Daniel Webster said that from the day of the Boston massacre was dated the disruption of the British empire. So might it be with the death of John Brown. Should, half a century hence, its result be the freedom of the whole land, no man would find fault with the battle of Harper's Ferry—when some other Daniel Webster, at a safe distance, might say that from the moment when John Brown swung between heaven and earth, might be dated the beginning of the end of American slavery. Mr. Manning drew other parallels. The government journals of 1770 charged the trouble on the ministers stirring up the people. The patriots said that it was caused by parading British regiments in Boston. So does the slave power parade before Northern conscience the revolting wickedness of slavery. The speaker then counselled, at some length, the cherishing of love for the slaveholder while we hated slavery. Faithfulness linked with love and firm adherence to duty was the rightful path, remembering that the roots of slavery were in Northern soil as well as Southern.
Ralph Waldo Emerson was next introduced. Mr. Andrew, in introducing Mr. Emerson, said that we had just heard from the old South church, with its holy memories of patriots, and we would turn next to the battle ground of Concord. He quoted a verse of Mr. Emerson's poetry, and the whole introduction was unusually felicitious.
Mr. Emerson spoke substantially as follows:—In reference to the cause which has brought us together, the gentleman who preceded me has well said that between us, whatever our theological views, no wall of separation could here exist. That commanding event, the sequel to which has brought us together to night, eclipses all others which have occurred for a long time in our history. I am glad to see that the prevalent interest in the hero of Harper's Ferry has provoked curiosity in all parts of the country in regard to the details of his individual history. It is not wonderful that gentlemen in all parts of the country are finding threads of relationship between themselves, and he was happily a representative of the American republic. This John Brown is a farmer, the sixth in descent from Peter Brown, who came to Plymouth in sixteen hundred and twenty in the Mayflower. I say the sixth, and all the six were farmers. His grandfather, of Symsbury, Conn., was a captain in Revolutionary history. His father was largely interested in cattle, and became a contractor for the supply of beef to the army in eighteen hundred and twelve. Our Captain Brown, then a boy, with his father, was present as a witness at the surrender of Hull. Captain Brown cherished always a very high respect for his father as a man of strong character. It is probable that his estimate was just. As for Captain Brown himself he is so transparent that all men can see through him. He is a man to make himself felt wherever in the world courage and integrity are esteemed—the rarest of heroes, and yet a pure idealist. Every one who has heard him speak has been impressed alike by his simple and artless goodness and his sublime courage. He joins the high faith of the good man with the Revolutionary spirit of his grandfather. He believes in two instruments—the golden rule and the Declaration of Independence. When he was here he used in conversation these words:—"Better that a whole generation of men, women and children should pass away by violent death, than that one word of these two should be broken in this country." There is a Unionist and a strict constructionist for you. He believes in the union of American States, and he conceives that the only enemy of the Union is slavery, and for this reason, as a patriot he seeks its abolition. Governor Wise has pronounced his eulogy in a manner that does discredit to the moderation of our own timid partisans. Captain Brown's speeches to the Court have interested a nation in him. What artlessness and plainness! If he had interfered in behalf of the great or the wealthy, or the wise, he said, no one would have blamed him; but he believed that when he interfered in behalf of a poor and depised people he was doing right. What a favorite will he be in history, which plays such pranks with more temporary reputations. Nothing can resist it. If he suffers death, it is plain that he will drag certain official gentlemen into an immortality most undesirable, and of which they have already some disagreeable forebodings. Indeed it is the resolution of the Governor of Virginia to hang the man whom he says possesses the greatest integrity, truthfulness and courage that he ever met. Is that the kind of men for whom the gallows are built? No man dare believe that there exists in Virginia another man as worthy to live, as deserving of public and private honors, as this poor prisoner. But we are here to think of the relief of the family of John Brown. To my eyes, the family looks very large and in need of relief. It comprises his brave fellow sufferers in the jail, the poor fugitives who are hunted still in the mountains of Virginia and Pennsylvania, all the sympathizers in every State, and every man who loves the golden rule and the Declaration of Independence like him, and who sees the tiger instinct that threatens himself in the malignant public sentiment that exists at the South. I said, just now, that John Brown is an idealist, but he believes in his ideas to such an extent that he labored to put them all into action. He did not believe in moral suasion, but in putting things through.
We in Massachusetts fancy we are free, but it seems that we are somewhat mistaken. We have great population, great wealth, great talent—and yet life and freedom are not safe, because the judges rely on the forms of law, and do not, like John Brown, use their eyes to see the sail before the storm. They assume that the United States can protect the prisoner and his witness. The State Judges fear a collision between two belligerents, and cannot find law enough to maintain the sovereignty of the State. At a pinch they are of no more use than idiots. After a thing has been done they may wring their hands at the result, but they had better never been born. A Vermont Judge knows the laws protect with their whole power the citizen, and is worth a whole court house full of lawyers so idolatrous of forms as to let go the substance. Is any man in Massachusetts so simple as to believe that when a United States Court in Virginia, in these times of excitement, sends into the North for a witness that it wants him to slaughter and eat? Your habeas corpus may be a nuisance by taking away the right reliance of a citizen and substituting therefor a form. I hope, then, that in addition to our relief to the family of John Brown, we shall endeavor to relieve all those in whose behalf he suffers and all those who are in sympathy with him, and not forget to aid him, also, in the best way by securing freedom and independence in Massachusetts itself. Mr. Emerson spoke about twenty-three or four minutes.
Mr. Andrew then said that Mr. Emerson had not come empty handed, but had brought with him from Concord a contribution of fifty dollars. A Finance Committee was appointed to solicit further subscriptions. The Chairman next introduced Wendell Phillips, who made the closing address. The meeting throughout was enthusiastic and the speakers were frequently and loudly applauded.