As the Papers Told It

John Brown's Raid · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

The Trial of Capt. Brown

October – November 1859

Brown was tried at Charlestown, lying on a cot in the courtroom. The court refused a delay, he rejected the plea of insanity that a telegram from Ohio had raised, and the jury was sworn on 27 October to try him for conspiring with slaves to rebel, treason to the Commonwealth, and murder. His seized papers told of a convention at Chatham, Canada West, in May 1858 that had made him commander-in-chief under a provisional constitution. On 2 November he spoke to the court and was sentenced to hang on 2 December.

Brown's Kansas years, told as an obituary

This sketch, from the New York Herald of 19 October, follows Brown through Kansas: a son dead after a march in chains, the Pottawattomie killings (free-state men placed him forty miles away), Black Jack, a slave raid into Missouri. It writes of him as already dead, though he lived to be tried. The Kentucky birthplace it gives from report is wrong too: the Herald of 2 December says Torringford, Connecticut.

The Potter Journal · Coudersport, Pa.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Potter Journal · 27 October 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Who is Brown, the Leader? Sketch of Captain John Brown, the Leader of the Insurrection at Harper's Ferry.

[From the New York Herald, October 19.]

See moreSee less

Captain John Brown emigrated to Kansas from Central New York in the fall of 1855, and settled in the township of Ossawatomie. He was accompanied by seven sons, the youngest being old enough to earn his livelihood. The birthplace of Brown is not positively know to the writer, but report has it that he was born in Kentucky. At the time of his death he was about sixty years of age. He was about medium height, slim, muscular and possessing an iron constitution. He had blue eyes, sharp features and long gray hair, wearing a full beard.

In December, 1855, during the "Shannon war," Brown first made his appearance among the free state men at Lawrence. His entrance into the place at once attracted the attention of the people towards him. He brought a wagon-load of cavalry sabres, and was accompanied by twelve men, seven of whom were his own sons. He first exhibited his qualities at the time the free-state and pro-slavery parties, under the lead of Governor Robinson on one side, and Governor Shannon on the other, met to make a treaty of peace. After Governor Robinson had stated to the people who were gathered around the hotel the terms of the peace, Brown took the stand, uninvited, and opposed the terms of the treaty. He was in favor of ignoring all treaties and such leading men as Robinson, Lane and Lowry, and proceeding at once against the border-ruffian invaders, drive them from the soil or hang them if taken. Gen. Lowry, who was chairman of the Committee of Safety, and also commander of the free-state troops, ordered Brown under arrest. The latter made no physical resistance, but it was soon discovered that he was altogether too combustible a person to retain as a prisoner, and a compromise was made with him by the free-state men, and he was released. He was informed by the leaders of that party that his remarks were intended to undo what they were trying to accomplish by means of the treaty; that he was a stranger in Lawrence and Kansas, and ought not by his rash remarks to compromise the people of Lawrence until he had known them longer and knew them better.

One of his sons, who was elected to the legislature in February, 1856, was seized and taken from Ossawatomie to Lecompton in chains, a distance of thirty miles. His feet and hands were chained together with a large heavy chain, the size of that used upon ox teams. He was compelled to walk the whole distance beneath a burning sun. The irons wore the flesh from his ankles; he was attacked with the brain fever, was neglected and died in two or three days. He was a companion of Governor Robinson, Jenkins, (since shot by Lane), and some eight or ten others. Another son of Captain Brown was shot at Ossawatomie by a marauding party from Missouri. After the death of his first son, occasioned by the tortures and fatigue of his forced march, Brown swore vengeance upon the pro-slavery party, and it was frequently observed by the more prudent of the free-state men that he was evidently insane on the subject. He was always considered by them as a dangerous man, was never taken into their councils, and never consulted by them with reference either to their policy or movements.

The destruction of the Free-State Hotel and presses at Lawrence, in May, 1856, incited him anew to action, and he organized a small company, composed chiefly of men who had been robbed, or whose relatives had been murdered by the pro-slavery party, and at the head of this band, armed with Sharp's rifles, bowie knives and Colt's revolvers, he scoured Southern Kansas, and the name of "Old Brown" became a terror to all who opposed his will in that region. While he was thus marauding, five pro-slavery men were taken from their cabins at Pottawattomie creek, in the night time, and shot dead. The pro-slavery party charged this deed upon Old Brown, while the free-state party asserted that they could prove him in Lawrence, forty miles distant, when it happened, and that the horrid deed was perpetrated by "Buford's Georgia Ruffians," supposing that the victims were free-state men.

The news of this massacre reached Westport, Missouri, the place of rendezvous of the "border ruffians," the same evening that the Kansas Commission sent out by the United States House of Representatives arrived at that place. The excitement was intense, and was induced almost as much by the appearance of the commission as by the news of the massacre. The "ruffians" swore vengeance upon the members and officers of the commission, declaring that their blood should recompense for the slaughter at Pottawattomie creek, and but for the intercession of Mr. Oliver, the pro-slavery member of the commission, and others, it was believed that the commission would have been attacked. It was at this time that the notorious H. Clay Pate organized a band of men in the streets of Westport, Missouri, with the avowed purpose of entering the territory and capturing "Old Brown." He raised about thirty men, and went into the territory about twilight one evening, and was surprised at sunrise the next morning by "Old Brown," who was in command of nine men, armed as stated above. Pate sent a flag of truce to Brown, who advanced some rods in front of his company and ordered the flag-bearer to remain with him, and sent one of his own men to inform Pate to come himself. Pate obeyed, when Brown ordered him to lay down his arms. Pate refused to give the order to his men, when Brown drawing a revolver, informed him that he must give the order or be shot on the spot. Pate immediately surrendered up himself and men, and they were disarmed and marched into a ravine near by, and kept until liberated and sent back to Missouri by Colonel Sumner, a few days subsequently, who also ordered "Old Brown" to disband and go home. The latter agreed to do so if the Colonel would also agree to protect the settlers in that region of the territory. This was the celebrated "Battle of Black Jack Point," made famous by the "H. C. P.," Kansas correspondent of the St. Louis Republican, who was the heroic commander of the surrendering party. Captain Brown was not much heard from again until the notorious Captain Hamilton made his incursions into southern Kansas, from Missouri, in 1858, when he raised another company, and, with Captain Montgomery, drove Hamilton and his companions back to Missouri, and, marching his men into that state, took possession of one of the villages, shot one or two men, and liberated several slaves. This course of Brown was repudiated by Governor Robinson and the leaders of the free-state party, in and out of Kansas, which caused Brown to publish a letter explaining his position, in which he assumed the entire responsibility of his acts, and relieved the free-state men from any share therein. This letter was called the "Two Parallels," on account of the peculiar distinction made by the writer.

Captain Brown was a very strong believer in the doctrines of the Presbyterian church. He was fanatical on the subject of anti-slavery, and seemed to have the idea that he was specially deputed by the Almighty to liberate slaves and kill slaveholders. It was always conceded to him that he was a conscientious man, very modest in his demeanor, apparently unoffensive until the subject of slavery was introduced, when he would exhibit a feeling of indignation unparalleled. After matters subsided in Kansas, Brown intimated to some of his anti-slavery friends that he contemplated organizing an insurrection amongst the slaves in Kentucky and Tennessee. This fact becoming known to some of the leading anti-slavery men of the country, they refused him means with which to go on, and discouraged his proposed undertaking. He spent a portion of the last summer in visiting different Northern cities, and was tendered sums of money, with the understanding that he wished to secure a little farm upon which to settle in his old age. It is supposed that he employed this money thus obtained to hire the farm near Harper's Ferry, which he used as a rendezvous for the insurrectionists, and near which he so recently paid the last debt of nature.

See the clipping

From his cot, Brown spurns the insanity plea

The Herald's man at Charlestown reports the trial's opening. Brown's counsel read a telegram from Akron claiming that insanity runs in his family; Brown raises himself on his cot and rejects the plea as ‘a miserable artifice and pretext’. The court refuses a delay for counsel of his own choosing and swears the jury, and his lawyers argue that the Armory was federal ground. The report breaks off mid-sentence.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

CorrectionThis set right 5 earlier articles: Paper unidentified, 27 October 1859, The Lambertville Press, 27 October 1859, The Perrysburg Journal, 27 October 1859, Holmes County Republican, 27 October 1859, The Potter Journal, 27 October 1859.

The New York Herald · 28 October 1859 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE HARPER'S FERRY OUTBREAK.

The Trial of John Brown, Charged with Insurrection, Treason and Murder.

See moreSee less

The Opening Speeches of the Prosecution and Defence.

The Testimony of the Witnesses Against the Prisoner.

CONFESSION OF COPLAND, THE NEGRO.

Startling Revelations Forthcoming, in Which the Guilty Complicity of the Abolitionists is Clearly Proven.

MORE OF COL. HUGH FORBES' DISCLOSURES. Letter from Congressman Vallandigham.

The Conspirator Cook Delivered up to the Virginia Authorities.

Fears of an Attempt to Rescue the Prisoners.

MARINES SENT TO HARPER'S FERRY, &c., &c., &c.

CONTINUATION OF WEDNESDAY'S REPORT. CHARLESTOWN, Va., Oct, 27, 1859.

The storm and interruption of telegraphic operations prevented the getting of the latter portion of the report through yesterday.

The Court refused to postpone the trial, and the whole afternoon was occupied in obtaining a jury for the trial of Brown, who was brought into Court on a cot.

The jailor was ordered to bring Brown into Court. He found him in bed, from which he declared himself unable to rise. He was accordingly brought into Court on a cot, which was set down within the bar. The prisoner laid most of the time with his eyes closed, and the counterpane drawn up close to his chin. He is evidently not much injured, but is determined to resist the pushing of his trial by all the means in his power.

The jury were then called and sworn. The jurors were questioned as to having formed or expressed any opinion that would prevent their deciding the case impartially on the merits of the testimony.

The Court excluded those who were present at Harper's Ferry during the insurrection and saw the prisoners perpetrating the act for which they are to be tried. They were all from distant parts of the county, mostly farmers—some of them owning a few slaves and others none.

The examination was continued until twenty-four were decided by the Court and counsel to be competent jurors. Out of these twenty-four the counsel for the prisoner has a right to strike off eight, and then twelve are drawn by ballot out of the remaining sixteen. The following were the questions put to the jurors:—

Were you at Harper's Ferry on Monday or Tuesday?

How long did you remain there? Did you witness any of the proceedings for which this party is to be tried? Did you form or express any opinion from what you saw there with regard to the guilt or innocence of these people? Would that opinion disqualify you from giving these men a fair trial? Did you hear any of the evidence in this case before the Examining Court? What was your opinion based on? Was it a decided one, or was it one which would yield to evidence if the evidence was different from what you supposed? Are you sure that you can try this case impartially, from the evidence alone, without reference to anything you have heard or seen of this transaction? Have you any conscientious scruples against convicting a party of an offence to which the law assigns the punishment of death, merely because that is the penalty assigned? The following were finally fixed upon as the twelve jurors:— Richard Timberlake, Jacob J. Miller, Joseph Myers, Thomas Osborne, Thomas Watson, Jr.. George W. Boyer, Isaac Dust, John C. Wiltshire, John C. McClure, George W. Tapp, William Rightodale, William A. Martin.

The jury were not sworn on the case, but the Judge charged them not to converse upon the case or to permit others to converse with them. They were dismissed at five o'clock, and the prisoner was then carried over to the jail on his cot, and the Court adjourned till morning.

John Copland, the mulatto prisoner, from Oberlin, Ohio, has made a full confession to United States Marshals Martin, of Virginia, and Johnson, of the Northern district of Ohio. He has given the names of the parties at Oberlin who induced him to go to Harper's Ferry, who furnished the money to pay his expenses, &c. He also states that a movement of a similar character was contemplated in Kentucky at about the same time. Many persons in Northern Ohio, whose names have not been heretofore mentioned, are directly implicated. His confession is withheld from the public until the trial is over, by order of Governor Wise.

I was shown to-day by Mr. Johnson, Marshal of the Northern district of Ohio, a large number of important letters implicating Gerrit Smith, and a number of prominent men of Oberlin, Cleveland and other points in Ohio. Among these letters is also the following:—

Tribune Office, April 30, 1859.

Mr. J. H. Kagi:—

Sir—Yours is received, and we enclose our check for forty one dollars, for seven letters from Kansas and two from Ohio. Yours, &c. Horace Greeley & Co. Kagi, one of the killed, was formerly a correspondent of the Tribune, and their letter is doubtless enclosing his pay.

Among them is a letter from Captain Brown to one of his sons, dated April 16, 1859, detailing a visit to Gerrit Smith, at Peterboro', which he regarded as highly encouraging. It says that Smith gave him $180; that he also at his house received a note that he considered good for $200 more, and that Smith had written to his friends at the East, saying that $2,000 must be raised for Brown, of which he himself would agree to furnish one-fifth. There is also notice of a draft from the cashier of the New York State Bank for $100 sent him by direction of Gerrit Smith. This is dated "Albany, August 29, 1859."

Marshal Johnson desired to furnish me this mass of correspondence, but Mr. Hunter, by direction of Governor Wise, objects to its publication at present. It contains a list of officers of the provisional government, and a list of contributors to the project. Marshal Johnson left for Cleveland this evening, taking copies with him, and you may look for it in that direction.

The examination made here to-day by the United States Marshal settles the fact that this movement had long been maturing, that many prominent men in the Northern States have given money and influence in its behalf, and that when the facts are made public an unparalleled sensation may be expected.

THURSDAY'S PROCEEDINGS. CHARLESTOWN, Va., Oct. 27, 1859.

Brown was brought in walking, and laid down on his cot at full length within the bar. He looked considerably better, the swelling having left his eyes.

Senator Mason was present.

Messrs. Harding and Hunter again appeared for the Commonwealth, and Messrs. Botts and Green for the prisoner.

Mr. Botts read the following despatch, which was received this morning:—

AKRON, Ohio, Oct. 26, 1859.

To C. J. FAULKNER AND LAWSON BOTTS:—John Brown, leader of the insurrection at Harper's Ferry, and several of his family, have resided in this county many years. Insanity is hereditary in that family. His mother's sister died with it, and a daughter of that sister has been two years in the lunatic asylum. A son and daughter of his mother's brother have also been confined in the lunatic asylum, and another son of that brother is now insane and under close restraint. These facts can be conclusively proven by witnesses residing here, who will doubtless attend the trial if desired. A. H. LEWIS.

William C. Allen, telegraphic operator at the Akron office, adds to the above despatch that A. H. Lewis is a resident of that place, and his statements are entitled to implicit credit.

Mr. Botts said that on receiving the above despatch he went to the jail with his associate, Mr. Green, and read it to Brown, and is desired by the latter to say that in his father's family there has never been any insanity at all. On his mother's side there have been repeated instances of it. He adds that his first wife showed symptoms of it, which were also evident in his first and second sons by that wife. Some portions of the statements in the despatch he knew to be correct, and of other portions he is ignorant. He does not know whether his mother's sister died in the lunatic asylum, but he does believe that a daughter of that sister has been two years in the asylum. He also believes that a son and daughter of his mother's brother have been confined in an asylum, but he is not apprised of the fact that another son of that brother is now insane and in close confinement. Brown also desires his counsel to say that he does not put in the plea of insanity, and if he has been at all insane he is totally unconscious of it. Yet, he adds, that those who are most insane generally suppose that they have more reason and sanity than those around them. For himself, he disdains to put in that plea, and seeks no immunity of that kind. This movement is made totally without his approbation or concurrence, and was unknown to him till the receipt of the above despatch. Brown then raised himself up in bed and said—"I will add, if the Court will allow me, that I look upon it as a miserable artifice and pretext of those who ought to take a different course in regard to me, if they took any at all, and I view it with contempt more than otherwise. As I remarked to Mr. Green, insane prisoners, so far as my experience goes, have but little ability to judge of their own sanity; and if I am insane, of course I should think I know more than all the rest of the world. But I do not think so. I am perfectly unconscious of insanity, and I reject, so far as I am capable, any attempts to interfere in my behalf on that score."

Mr. Botts stated that he was further instructed by Mr. Brown to say that, rejecting this plea entirely, and seeking no delay for that reason, he does repeat to the Court his request made yesterday, that time be given for the foreign counsel to arrive that he has now reason to expect. Yesterday afternoon a despatch was received from Cleveland, Ohio, signed "Dan. Tilden," dated 26th October, asking Brown whether it would be of use for counsel to leave last night. To this despatch answer was returned that the jury would be sworn this morning, and that Brown desired the counsel to come at once. The telegraphic operator here stated that this despatch would be sent off at once in advance of the despatches sent by reporters, and he had learned this morning that it was sent before the storm of last night interrupted communication, and that counsel might reach here by twelve or one o'clock to-night. The course taken by Brown this morning makes it evident that he sought no postponement for the mere purpose of delay, as he rejects the plea of insanity. Still, in his opinion, he could have a fairer trial if the defence were conducted by his own counsel than if he were defended by the counsel at present here.

Mr. Hunter observed that the prisoner's counsel, having renewed the motion of yesterday for delay for a specific period, indicated and based upon information received in the form of the despatch, the question now was whether there were sufficient grounds in this additional information to change the decision announced by the Court yesterday on the same motion. If the Court did not at once deem this circumstance wholly insufficient, before the decision was made the counsel for the Commonwealth deemed it his duty to call attention to two or three matters connected with the [illegible]. [illegible] desirous to avoid forestalling the trial of this case in regard to the present prisoner at the bar, they were prepared to prove that he had made open, repeated and constant acknowledgment of everything charged against him. He had gloried in it, and we have but an exhibition of the same spirit and the same purpose in what he announced, that he would permit no defence of insanity to be put in. What does he mean by wishing delay for the purpose of having a fair trial? In a proper sense, and in the only sense in which it can be regarded by the Court, it is a fair trial according to the laws of Virginia, and the safeguards against wronging the prisoner which these laws throw around him. If the prisoner's idea of a fair trial is to have it so shaped as to produce a fairness in his conception outside of what the laws recognise, it becomes the duty of the counsel for the Commonwealth and, as he apprehended, of the Court, to resist any attempt of that kind. Considering the surrounding circumstances, to which it was unnecessary to particularly advert, there could be no right to claim delay, except so far as the prisoner could show, in a reliable form, that such delay was necessary to do justice in his particular case according to the laws and policy of the State of Virginia. In regard to the telegraph despatch read, we know not who this Mr. Lewis is. We know not whether he is to come here as counsel for the prisoner, or whether he is to head a band of desperadoes. We have a right to believe the latter as well as the former. There had been time enough since the letter for Northern counsel was mailed, last Saturday, for it to reach him and for him to arrive here ere this if he had designed coming. It was fairly inferable that he did not intend to come, and the telegraph did not say he would come. But might it not be an attempt to gain time, and learn the latest day when a rescue could be attempted? Whilst commending the earnestness and zeal of the prisoner's counsel, he must ask the Court to reject the motion and proceed with the trial at once.

Mr. Harding would be reluctant to withhold from a prisoner charged with a crime of the greatest enormity, as in the present case, anything calculated to afford him the amplest opportunity of justice; but he had able and intelligent counsel assigned him, who would see that he was fairly and impartially tried; and he therefore fully concurred with the remarks of his colleague in opposing the motion. He referred also to the fact that Brown pretended yesterday afternoon that he was unable to walk, and was brought into court on a bed; yet he walked back to jail after the close of the trial without difficulty. He thought those were mere pretences for delay, which the Court should overrule.

Mr. Green remarked that one day's delay would be sufficient to ascertain whether the expected counsel would come or not, and no prejudice could result to the Commonwealth from a small delay of that character. In reference to the new matter brought to the consideration of the Court, he did not believe the prisoner had made any acknowledgment upon which he could be convicted. All the acknowledgments, so far as he knew their character, referred to the treason, and these confessions, according to our law, are insufficient to convict a party who may have acknowledged the fact in the plainest manner to one hundred witnesses, for if that is all the evidence upon which the Commonwealth relies, the prisoner cannot be convicted, because our code provides that such confession shall be made in open court and the prisoner has denied in open court by putting in a plea of not guilty. As to sufficient time having elapsed for counsel to reach here, it was a reasonable supposition that the persons to whom Brown wrote were absent, and did not immediately receive the letter. The Commonwealth Attorney does not know who Tilden is, but he is an ex-member of Congress, and said to be a man of respectability. As to what is called Brown's sham sickness of yesterday, it should be remembered that it was not then, nor is it now, made the ground of application for delay. He did not think this trial should be hurried through for the reason that a rescue might be apprehended, for such fears were idle.

The Court stated that he must see in this case, as in any other, that a proper cause for a delay was made out before granting such an application. In the present case he could not see that the telegraphic despatch gave any assurance that the additional counsel intended to come. The prisoner is now defended by counsel who will take care that no improper evidence is adduced against him, and that all proper evidence in his behalf shall be presented. He could not see that a proper cause for delay was made out. The expected counsel might arrive before the case was closed, and could then see all the testimony which had been taken, and thus the prisoners might have the benefit of their advice, although the case now proceeds. As to the matter of insanity, it was not presented in a reliable form; instead of mere statements, we should have affidavits, or something of that character. He thought, therefore, that the jury should be sworn and the trial proceed.

The jury having been sworn to fairly and impartially try the prisoner, the Court directed that the prisoner might forego the form of standing while arraigned, if he desired it.

Mr. Botts put the inquiry to the prisoner, and he continued to lie prostrate on his cot while the long indictment, filling seven pages, was read:—

First—For conspiring with negroes to produce insurrection.

Second—For treason to the Commonwealth; and,

Third—For murder.

Mr. Harding addressed the jury. He presented the facts of the case, detailing the scenes at the Armory; the killing of the bridge keeper and the subsequent killing of citizens named in the indictment; the seizing of Lewis, Washington and M. Allstadt, with their slaves; the forming of a government within the limits of the Commonwealth; the holding the citizens as prisoners of war, and their subsequent capture. He read the law for treason, levying war against the State, giving comfort to its enemies, or establishing any other government within its limits, punishable with death; the law against advising with a slave to produce insurrection, punishable with death, and the law on the murder of citizens, punishable with death. All these charges would be distinctly proven, beyond the possibility of a doubt on the mind of the jury. He would show that the prisoner's whole object was to rob our citizens of their slaves, and carry them off by violence, and he was happy to say against the wills of the slaves—all of them having escaped and rushed back to their masters at the first opportunity. He concluded by urging the jury to cast aside all prejudices, and give the prisoner a fair and impartial trial, and not to allow their hatred of abolitionists to influence them against those who have raised the black flag on the soil of this Commonwealth.

Mr. GREEN, on the part of the prisoner, after giving the law applicable to the case, said that the jury must bear in mind that they are judges of the law and the fact, and that if they have any doubt as to law or the fact of the guilt of this prisoner, they are to give the prisoner the benefit of that doubt. On the first charge of treason, as a specific act of treason must be proven, it must be proven that he attempted to establish a separate and distinct government, and it must also be proven what was the purpose of the treasonable acts before you can convict him of that charge. If it is intended to rely on his confessions to prove treason, the law distinctly says "No conviction can be made on confessions unless made in open Court." There must be sufficient evidence to prove the charge, independent of any confessions out of the Court, and it requires two distinct witnesses to prove each and every act of treason. Second—Conspiring with slaves to rebel and make insurrection. The jury must be satisfied that such conspiracy was done within the State of Virginia and within the jurisdiction of this Court. If it was done in Maryland this Court could not punish the act; if it was done within the grounds of the Armory at Harper's Ferry, it was not done within the limits of this State—the government of the United States holding exclusive jurisdiction within said grounds. Attorney General Cushing had decided this point with regard to the Armory grounds at Harper's Ferry, which opinion was read to the jury, showing that persons residing within the limits of the Armory cannot even be taxed by Virginia, and that crime committed within said limits are punishable by the federal courts. Although the jury may doubt about the law on this subject, they must give the prisoner the benefit of that doubt upon the trial. Over murder, if committed Armory, this Court has no jurisdiction, and in the case of Mr. Beckham, if he was killed on the railroad bridge, it was committed within the State of Maryland, which State claims jurisdiction up to the Armory grounds. Although he may be guilty of murder, it must be proven that it was deliberate and premeditated murder to make it a capital offence; if otherwise, the killing was murder in the second degree, punishable wit­ imprisonment. If you have any doubt on these points you must give that doubt to the prisoner. He was satisfied the jury will not allow any outside excitement to affect them, and that they will do their duty faithfully and impartially.

Mr. Botts impressively addressed the jury. The case was an unusual one, and the crime charged in many respects unknown. The jury trial called for calm, unimpassioned deliberation, and not the seizure upon loose statements for a conviction. The jury must be above all prejudices and influences, and deliberate calmly and free of all resentment, bearing in mind that the mission of the law is not to wreak vengeance, and that the majesty of the law is best maintained when judges, counsel and jury rise above these influences. The burthen of proof is on the Commonwealth, and if she fail to substantiate her charges, you are bound to do your duty impartially, and find your verdict on the law and testimony that the Commonwealth may be able to present to you. He then proceeded to go over the same grounds taken by Mr. Green on each of the three points of the indictment, treason, insurrection and murder. It is no difference how much a jury may be convinced in their own minds of the guilt of the prisoner: it is essential that they must have proof of positive guilt in a case like this, involving both life and liberty. Mr. Botts, in reviewing the law bearing on the case, evinced a determination to avail himself of every advantage that the law allows, and to do his duty to the prisoner earnestly and faithfully. It was due to the prisoner to state that he believed himself to be actuated by the highest and noblest feelings that ever coursed through a human breast, and that his instructions were to destroy neither property nor life. They would prove by those gentlemen who were prisoners that they were treated with respect, and that they were kept in positions of safety, and that no violence was offered to them. These facts must be taken into consideration and have their due weight with the jury. Mr. HUNTER followed, stating his purpose to avoid anything by way of argument or explanation not immediately connected with the particular issue to be tried, and to march straight forward to the attainment, so far as may be in our power, of the ends of justice, by either convicting or acquitting the prisoner at the bar, with a single preliminary remark explanatory of his position here as assistant—a position which had been assigned to him by the Governor of the Commonwealth, as well as his Honor the Judge. He passed at once to a review of what was the law in reference to the case, and what he expected to be able to prove to the satisfaction of the jury:—First, as to high treason. This was probably the first case of high treason or treason against the State that had ever been tried here by our State courts, and he fervently hoped it would be the last that would ever occur; and probably in some degree, not only upon our decision, but upon our prompt decision of this case, will that result depend. He thought his friends on the other side were totally mistaken in their view that the law, as it now stands on the statute book in reference to overt acts, was either in language or substantially that contained in the constitution of the United States. On the contrary, the phraseology had been varied from that of the constitution, and, as he conceived, for a plain and palpable purpose. All the powers vested in the federal government were given with great jealousy. This was a historical fact, perfectly familiar and, consequently, while treason against the United States consists only in levying war against them, or adhering to their enemies and giving them aid and comfort, there is no provision that no person shall be convicted of treason unless upon the testimony of two witnesses, of some overt act or confession in open court. Yet the State law is more full and includes within its definition of treason the establishing without the authority of the Legislature any government within its limits separate from the existing government, or the holding or executing in such government of any office, professing allegiance or fidelity to it, or resisting the execution of laws under the color of its authority; and it goes on to declare that such treason, if proved by the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or by confession in court, shall be punished with death. Any one of these acts constitutes treason against this Commonwealth, and he believed that the prisoner had been guilty of each and all of these acts, which would be proved in the clearest manner, not by two, but by a dozen witnesses, unless limited by the act of time. The prisoner had attempted to break

See the clipping

Iowa editor: Seward did not inspire Brown

A Keokuk editorial answers the ‘doughface press’ for blaming the raid on Senator Seward's talk of an ‘irrepressible conflict’: Brown's plans, it says, were laid before Seward's Rochester speech. If words spurred him, it suggests, they were Washington's, Jefferson's and Henry Clay's, and Seward never looked beyond legislative action. On 2 December the New York Herald would still list Seward among anti-slavery leaders it said the seized papers implicated.

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

The Daily Gate City · 31 October 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

The Irrepressible Conflict. An earnest and persistent effort has been made by the doughface press to represent the recent outbreak of insane fanaticism at Harper's Ferry as the natural and necessary result of Senator Seward's doctrine of an irrepressible conflict between Freedom and Slavery. The developments in reference to Brown's conspiracy, however, show that his plans were laid before the delivery of Seward's Rochester speech. It follows, therefore, that Brown was not instigated by the sentiments of Seward, and we must look elsewhere for the treasonable incitements to the recent plot of insurrection.

In a letter of George Washington to Gen. La Fayette we have a hint at this same irrepressible conflict between freedom and slavery, in which the Father of his Country hoped and expected that freedom would triumph:

See moreSee less

"I agree with you cordially in your views in regard to negro slavery. I have long considered it a most serious evil, both socially and politically, and I should rejoice in any feasible scheme to rid our States of such a burden. The Congress of 1787 adopted an ordinance, which prohibits the existence of involuntary servitude in our North-western territory forever. I consider it a wise measure. It met with the approval and assent of nearly every member from the States more immediately interested in slave labor. The prevailing opinion in Virginia is against the spread of slavery in our new Territories, AND I TRUST WE SHALL HAVE A CONFEDRACY OF FREE STATES."

But these sentiments of Washington were more clearly developed and more strongly enforced by that great Apostle of Liberty, Thomas Jefferson, who said in his 'Notes on Virginia':

"Nothing is more certainly written in the book of fate, THAN THAT THESE PEOPLE ARE TO BE FREE; nor is it less certain that the two races equally free, cannot live in the same government. Nature, habit and opinion have drawn indelible lines of distinction between them. It is still in our power to direct the process of emancipation and deportation peaceably, and in such slow degree as that the evil will wear off insensibly, and their place be pari passu, filled up with free white laborers. If on the contrary, it is left to force itself on, human nature might shudder at the prospects held up." And again : "The whole commerce between master and slave is a continual exercise of the most unremitting despotism on the one part, and degrading submission on the other.

With what execration should the statesmen be loaded, who, permitting one-half of the citizens to trample on the rights of the other; transforms those into despots and these into enemies, destroys the morals of the one part and the amor patriæ of the other. Can the liberties of a nation be thought secure, when we have removed their only firm basis—a conviction in the minds of the people that these liberties are the gift of God. That they are violated but by his wrath. Indeed I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just, and his justice cannot sleep forever."

As Mr. Seward's speech had not been delivered when Brown formed his plan for invading Virginia, it is clear if incited by any publication, it is more probable that it was by these sentiments of noble Virginians that Brown was spurred up to his daring deeds. Moreover, Seward evidently never contemplated other than Legislative action. Hear him:

"Thus these antagonistic systems are continually coming in closer contact, and collision results. Shall I tell you what this collision means? They who think it is accidental, unnecessary, the work of interested or fanatical agitators, and therefore ephemeral, mistake the case altogether. It is an irrepressible conflict between opposing and enduring forces, and it means that the United States must and will, sooner or later, become entirely a slave-holding nation, or entirely a free-labor nation. * * * *

"If these States are again to become universally slave-holding, I do not pretend to say with what violations of the Constitution that end shall be accomplished. On the other hand, while I do confidently believe and hope that my country will yet become a land of universal freedom, I do not expect that it will be made so OTHERWISE THAN THROUGH THE ACTION OF THE SEVERAL STATES, CO-OPERATING WITH THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, AND ALL ACTING IN STRICT CONFORMITY WITH THEIR RESPECTIVE CONSTITUTIONS."

Now if the Virginians and the doughfaces are determined to damn anybody to eternal infamy for the expression of anti-slavery sentiments, we submit that in the exercise of common justice they visit their wrath upon the memory of Washington and Jefferson, citizens of their own slave State, rather than upon the living Seward who was born and nurtured in a land of liberty and early imbued with its principles.

But the authority of Henry Clay seems superior to that of Washington and Jefferson with the modern Democracy, especially that of the doughface stamp, and it may be that Brown was incited by the rousing bugle notes of that departed champion of emancipation, rather than by the cold and measured philosophy of Seward. Clay said in response to grumbling slaveholders.

"If they would repress all tendencies towards Liberty and ultimate emancipation, they must do more than put down the benevolent efforts of this society. They must go back to the era of our Liberty and Independence, and muzzle the cannon which thunders its annual joyous return. They must revive the slave trade, with all its train of atrocities. They must suppress the workings of British philanthrophy, seeking to ameliorate the condition of the unfortunate West India slaves. They must arrest the career of South American deliverance from thraldom. They must blow out the moral lights around us, extinguish that greatest torch of all, which America presents to a benighted world, pointing the way to their rights, their liberties, and their happiness. And when they have achieved all these purposes, their work will be yet incomplete. They must penetrate the hu[m]an soul, and eradicate the light of reason and the lo[v]e of liberty.— Then, and not till th[en], when [un]iversal darkness and despair prevail, can you perpetuate slavery, and repress a[ll] sympathy and all humane and benevolent [eff]orts among freemen, in behalf of the unhappy portion of our race who are doomed to bondage."

The sentiments of our Revolutionary forefathers and of the eloquent champion of the liberty and independence of Greece and the South American Republics have fallen into disrepute in this country, but it is unfair to heap all the odium of these obsolete opinions upon Mr. Seward. The light of reason and the love of liberty has not as yet been entirely eradicated from his soul, and it sometimes unfortunately finds expression in his speeches. But if the "irrepressible conflict" terminates in favor of the slaveocracy, the country will soon reach that stage "when universal darkness and despair will prevail," and all "agitation" in behalf of liberty will be repressed by the iron-heel of slaveocratic despotism. Till then let the country, North and South, bear with Mr. Seward in his mild repetition of the sentiments of Washington, Jefferson and Clay.

See the clipping

Copeland names Oberlin backers; they deny it

The Cleveland Leader prints, and attacks, the confession U.S. Marshal Johnson took from John Copeland in Charlestown jail. Copeland says Ralph and Samuel Plumb of Oberlin gave him $15 for the journey, and that until the fight began he understood only ‘running off slaves’ was intended. Both Plumbs deny giving him money. A letter from R. Plumb, declining to send money, was among Brown's papers. Copeland was hanged on 16 December.

Cleveland Morning Leader · Cleveland, Ohio

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Cleveland Morning Leader · 1 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Marshal Johnson Acting Negro Confessor?

The duties of United States Marshals under Buchanan's Administration are multifarious—They have not only to catch negroes, but to worm confessions from them when caught. Marshal Johnson, of the Northern Ohio District, has proved himself a confessor of the first water. He made a pilgrimage to the Charlestown jail, found the miserable Copeland chattering with fear in a blanket on a pallet of straw, and after giving him the comforting assurance that he must soon stretch hemp—"that there was no possible chance to save his life—that the proof was overwhelming against him, and the prisoner seemed to realize his situation," proceeded to pump him with leading questions for the very probable purpose of getting answers to implicate the men of Oberlin he had before officially labored with signal discomfiture to "crush out." Of the two negro prisoners, one of whom made Marshal Johnson his confessor, Gov. Wise, in his Richmond speech, says:

See moreSee less

"Of the two negroes, it was hard to say which seemed the most cowardly and false—The North Carolina negro offered to betray all persons involved in the affair if spared, and the Canada negro—who was, I believe, one of the members of the Provisional Congress—was a crouching craven, who lied, as Brown said, for his life."

So much by way of preface to

COPELAND'S CONFESSION.

Question—Are you John Copeland of Oberlin, and the same person that was indicted last year at Cleveland for rescuing the slave "John?"

Answer—I am.

Q. Do your parents reside in Oberlin?

A. They do.

Q. Who induced you to enter into the Harper's Ferry movement?

A. J. H. Kagi and John Brown, Jr. wrote letters to Leary at Oberlin, which I saw, and was thus induced to go into it.

Q. Who furnished you the means to come to Virginia?

A. Ralph and Samuel Plumb gave me the money—$15—to bear my expenses.

Q. What other Oberlin persons were at Harper's Ferry?

A. None but Leary and myself.

Q. Where is Leary?

A. He was killed in the river near the Rifle Works.

Q. Did you come through Cleveland?

A. Yes.

Q. On what day did you leave there?

A. The day of the October election.

Q. Where did you stop at in Cleveland?

A. I stopped at Isaac Sturtevant's, on Walnut street. Was there from Monday noon until Tuesday evening at 9 o'clock.

Q. Did Mr. and Mrs. Sturtevant know what you were going to Virginia for?

A. Mrs. Sturtevant did. She was the person who talked to me about it. I suppose Mr. S. knew it.

Q. Where did Plumb give you the money, and who was present?

A. Ralph Plumb gave it to me. Samuel Plumb and Leary were present. It was in Plumb's office at Oberlin.

Q. Did the Plumbs know where you were going?

A. Yes, and wished us good luck, and gave me the money just before leaving Monday morning.

Q. Did Charles H. Langston see you in Cleveland?

A. He did, and knew I was coming on to join Brown's company.

Q. Who directed you to go to Sturtevant's at Cleveland?

A. Leary. He was directed by John Brown, Jr., to go there.

Q. Did you hear Ralph Plumb, on the day the slave "John" was rescued, urge persons to go to Wellington, and if so, where?

A. I did. He was on the pavement in front of Watson's grocery.

Q. Have you any knowledge of an attempt to raise an insurrection in any other State or region of our country?

A. I understood that there was an intention to attempt a movement of that kind in Kentucky about the same time.

Q. Did you know from Brown or any other person that help was expected from the slaves in the neighborhood?

A. I did from Brown, that help would come from the slaves, but I did not understand at any time, until Monday morning after the fight had commenced, that any thing else than running off slaves was intended, I being at the Rifle Works, half a mile from the Engine House.

Q. Did you learn from Brown or any of the company that persons at Harper's Ferry sympathised with them, or were in any way connected with the movement?

A. From Brown I understood that there were laboring men at Harper's Ferry who wished to get rid of the slaves, and would aid in running them off.

Recollect the circumstances under which it is asserted the above replies were pumped out. The witness was in duress, and under the threat of death. Two U. S. Officials, Marshal Johnson of Ohio, and Marshal Martin of Virginia, told the "cowardly and false" negro "there was no possible chance to save his life." And yet the adroit confessor could only draw from his negro penitent that Kagi and John Brown, Jr., wrote letters to Leary at Oberlin, which he saw, and was thus induced to go into it. Into what? "Running off slaves;" for Copeland in his confession as published by Marshal Johnson, declared that he "did not understand at any time, until Monday morning after the fight had commenced, that anything else than running off slaves was intended." This shows conclusively that Marshal Johnson has made "great cry and little wool" so far as he has attempted through an extorted confession from a negro to implicate respectable citizens of Oberlin in the Harper's Ferry foray.

But the following notes from the Messrs. Plumb prove that Marshal Johnson's negro is just what Gov. Wise described him to be, or else that the confession has been concocted expressly to make a case of suspicion as is usual with government spies and informers. Marshal Johnson can take either horn of the dilemma.

CARDS FROM MESSRS. PLUMB.

OBERLIN, Oct. 31, 1859.

Ed. MORNING LEADER:—I have just been shown the National Democrat of this morning, containing a statement purporting to come from John Copeland, which, if true, would implicate me in the insurrection at Harper's Ferry.

I hasten to say that the charges therein contained are untrue. I never had a word of conversation with Copeland upon the Harper's Ferry insurrection or any other insurrection among slaves, nor did I give Copeland money for the purpose named, or for any other purpose.

Yours respectfully, RALPH PLUMB.

OBERLIN, Oct. 31, 1859.

Ed. MORNING LEADER:—I wish to add to what has been said by my brother respecting the charges purporting to have been made by Copeland, that it is not true that I ever gave money to Copeland, nor did my brother do so in my presence or to my knowledge, nor did I ever have a word of conversation with Copeland excepting when I appeared as counsel against him when he was on trial for an assault upon the Marshal of this village.

Yours, S. PLUMB.

See the clipping

Seized papers reveal the Chatham convention

The Intelligencer reprints more seized papers. A journal records a convention at Chatham, Canada West, on 8 May 1858 that adopted Brown's provisional constitution and elected him commander-in-chief, with J. H. Kagi, later killed at the Ferry, as secretary of war. Letters to ‘J. Henrie’, taken to be Kagi, speak of freight, hands and ‘coal banks’, record money from Gerrit Smith, and recommend John Copeland of Oberlin.

Daily National Intelligencer · Washington City, D.C.

Daily National Intelligencer · 3 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

A FURTHER INSTALMENT OF DOCUMENTS FROM CAPT. BROWN'S CARPET-BAG.

The Constitution of the 29th ultimo furnishes another supply of documents found among the papers of the Harper's Ferry conspirators, which we place on record, in order that the reader may have a full understanding of the initiation and progress of the conspiracy, so far as it has yet been developed, and be prepared for any explanations which they may elicit. The "J. Henrie," conspicuous throughout the plot, appears to have been J. H. Kagi, who was among the slain at Harper's Ferry.

See moreSee less

CHATHAM, (CANADA WEST,)

Saturday, May 8, 1858—10 A. M.

Convention met in pursuance to call of John Brown and others, and was called to order by Mr. Jackson, on whose motion Mr. Wm. C. Monroe was chosen president; when, on motion of Mr. Brown, Mr. J. H. Kagi was elected secretary. On motion of Mr. Delany, Mr. Brown then proceeded to state the object of the convention at length, and then to explain the general features of the plan of action in the execution of the project in view by the convention. Mr. Delany and others spoke in favor of the project and the plan, and both were agreed to by general consent.

Mr. Brown then presented a plan of organization, entitled "Provisional Constitution and Ordinances for the People of the United States," and moved the reading of the same.

Mr. Kinnard objected to the reading until an oath of secrecy be taken by each member of the convention; whereupon Mr. Delany moved that the following parole of honor be taken by all members of the convention: "I solemnly affirm that I will not in any way divulge any of the secrets of this convention, except to persons entitled to know the same, on the pain of forfeiting the respect and protection of this organization;" which motion was carried.

The President then proceeded to administer the obligation; after which

The question was taken on the reading of the plan proposed by Mr. Brown, and the same carried.

The plan was then read by the secretary; after which, on motion of Mr. Whipple, it was ordered that it be now read by articles for consideration.

The articles, from one to forty-five [illegible]

On the reading of the forty-sixth, Mr. Reynolds moved to strike out the same.

Reynolds spoke in favor, and Brown, Monroe, Owen Brown, Delany, Realf, Kinnard, and Kagi against. The question was then taken and lost, there being but one vote in the affirmative.

The article was then adopted.

The forty-seventh and forty-eighth articles, with the schedule, were then adopted in the same manner.

It was then moved by Mr. Delany that the title and preamble stand as read. Carried.

On motion of Mr. Kagi, the constitution, as a whole, was then unanimously adopted.

The convention then, at 1½ P. M., adjourned, on motion of Mr. Jackson, till 8 o'clock.

8 P. M.—Journal read and approved.

On motion of Mr. Delany, it was then ordered that those approving of the constitution as adopted sign the same; whereupon the names of all the members were appended.

After congratulatory remarks by Messrs. Kinnard and Delany, the convention, on motion of Mr. Whipple, adjourned at a quarter to four.

J. H. KAGI,

Secretary of the Convention.

The above is a journal of the Provisional Constitutional Convention held at Chatham, Canada West, May 8, 1858, as herein stated.

CHATHAM, (CANADA WEST,)

Saturday, May 8, 1858.

Six P. M.—In accordance with, and obedience to, the provisions of the schedule to the constitution for the proscribed and oppressed people "of the United States of America," to-day adopted at this place, a convention was called by the president of the convention framing that instrument, and met at the above-named hour for the purpose of electing officers to fill the offices specially established and named by said constitution.

The convention was called to order by Mr. M. R. Delany, upon whose nomination Mr. Wm. C. Monroe was chosen president, and Mr. J. H. Kagi secretary.

A committee, consisting of Messrs. Whipple, Kagi, Bell, Cook, and Monroe, was then chosen to select candidates for the various offices to be filled, for the consideration of the convention.

On reporting progress, and asking leave to sit again, that request was refused, and committee discharged.

On motion of Mr. Bell, the convention then went into the election of officers in the following manner and order:

Mr. Whipple nominated John Brown for commander-in-chief, who was, on the seconding of Mr. Delany, elected by acclamation.

Mr. Realf nominated J. H. Kagi for secretary of war, who was elected in the same manner.

On motion of Mr. Brown, the convention then adjourned to 9 A. M. on Monday, the 10th. MONDAY, MAY 10, 1858—9 A. M.—The proceedings of the convention on Saturday were read and approved.

The President announced that the business before the convention was the further election of officers.

Mr. Whipple nominated Thomas M. Kinnard for president. In a speech of some length Mr. Kinnard declined.

Mr. Anderson nominated J. W. Loguen for the same office. The nomination was afterwards withdrawn, Mr. Loguen not being present, and it being announced that he would not serve if elected.

Mr. Brown then moved to postpone the election of president for the present; carried.

The convention then went into the election of members of Congress. Messrs. Alfred M. Ellsworth and Osborn Anderson were elected.

After which the convention went into the election of secretary of state, to which office Richard Realf was chosen.

Whereupon the convention adjourned to 2½ P. M.

2½ P. M.—convention again assembled and went into a balloting for the election of treasurer and secretary of the treasury.

Owen Brown was elected as the former and George B. Gill as the latter.

The following resolution was then introduced by Mr. Brown, and unanimously passed:

"Resolved, That John Brown, J. H. Kagi, Richard Realf, L. F. Parsons, C. P. Tidd, C. Whipple. C. W. Moffit, John E. Cook, Owen Brown, Steward Taylor, Osborn Anderson, A. M. Ellsworth, Richard Richardson, W. H. Leeman, and John Lawrence be and are hereby appointed a committee to whom is delegated the power of the convention to fill by election all the offices specially named in the provisional constitution which may be vacant after the adjournment of this convention. The convention then adjourned sine die.

J. H. KAGI,

Secretary of the Convention.

Names of Members of the Convention, Written by Each Person.

Wm. Charles Monroe, president of the convention; G. J. Reynolds, J. C. Grant, A. J. Smith, James M. Jones, George B. Gill, M. F. Bailey, Wm. Lambert, S. Hunton, C. W. Moffet, John J. Jackson, J. Anderson, Alfred Whipple, James M. Bue, W. H. Leeman, Alfred M. Ellsworth, John E. Cook, Steward Taylor, James W. Purnell, George Akin, Stephen Dettin, Thomas Hickerson, John Caunel, Robinson Alexander, Richard Realf, Thomas F. Cary, Richard Richardson, L. T. Parsons, Thomas M. Kinnard, M. H. Delaney, Robert Vanvanken, Thomas M. Stringer, Charles P. Tidd, John A. Thomas, C. Whipple, J. D. Shadd, Robert Newman, Owen Brown, John Brown, J. H. Harris, Charles Smith, Simon Fislin, Isaac Holler, James Smith; J. H. Kagi, secretary of the convention.

Memorandum. J. W. Pattengell $5, Samuel Fansor $5, George Fansor $2, J. C. Thompson $3, W. H. Hull $25; total $40. J. Willetts $13, T. W. Scudder $2, Dr. (order on Griffin) $5, —— Jones $10, J. D. Adams $20—paid by Scudder, S. M. Stevens $22; total $72.

C. W. Moffit 50 cents, R. Richardson $1.50, L. F. Parsons $7, R. Realf $7; total $16.

Mem. as follows: Double eagles $15,000, eagles $5,000; total $20,000.

W. WEBER.

Memorandum—Offices Filled.

Commander-in-chief John Brown, secretary of war J. H. Kagi; members of congress Alfred M. Ellsworth, Osborne Anderson; treasurer Owen Brown, secretary of the treasury George B. Gill, (vacant,) secretary of state Richard Realf,* (vacant.)

* Brown says, an Englishman, and died on passage coming over.

WEST ANDOVER, (ASHTABULA Co., OHIO,)

Sunday Evening, August 7, 1859.

FRIEND J. H.: I leave to-morrow (Monday) for my northern tour. Have succeeded admirably in getting the freight started in good shape—in short, "all right!" Saw Mr. W. yesterday. Wm. H. L. was here a day or two since. They will start in a couple of weeks, unless they hear from you in the mean time to the contrary. Have witten you three letters before this. Have received the drafts for two hundred. The last shall probably get cashed in Rochester; perhaps at Ashtabula. If you wish to communicate with me before I return write to my wife, under cover to Mr. L., as heretofore, and she will forward to me at Chatham. I yesterday gave W. $6, which, in addition to the $20 which our friend S. gave him, will enable the three to meet their travelling expenses. Shall write you quite often while away. The first lot of freight of 15 boxes, I presume, has reached you ere this. The last (six boxes and one chest) will not be many days behind them. All well. Very truly, &c.

John Smith.

Sandusky, (Ohio,)

Saturday Evening, August 27, 1859.

Friend Henrie: I have not written since I left Syracuse, for the reason that I had nothing definite to write until within two or three days, and then was too much occupied to write. At St. C. I found none, and went on to Hamilton, where I met with several capital fellows. The coppersmith on the G. W. R. Rd. will go, but has an engagement on a steam-engine, which will hold him several weeks. I think him one of those men who must be obtained if possible. For several months he was entirely out of business, waiting, but, hearing nothing, took a job, which he cannot now leave till finished. There is at Hamilton two other men every way fitted by nature for such a place, one at least of whom will start as soon as travelling expenses can be raised. At Dr. W.'s house we formed an association, the officers consisting of chairman, secretary, and corresponding secretary, the business of which is to hunt up good workmen and raise the means among themselves to send them forward. I am in communication with this association, and can reach them all at once through their corresponding secretary; so that whatever you wish to communicate can be done through me by letter without delay. No minutes of the organization, nor of any of its proceedings, are or will be preserved in writing. I formed similar associations in Chat——, and also at B-x-t-n. At the first place (H.)

they will take hold at once and do something. At Chatham I met a hearty response. The delay since they last saw you has caused them, however, to scatter and involve themselves in business arrangements. The captain of the fire company and one other of the best has gone to Frazer river. Dick was away harvesting a number of miles from there, but what they say is on hand. Alex. had disposed of his affairs a good while since, and until within a few weeks had been waiting, but has lately resumed; thinks he can now close out by 1st November; and in the mean time, to prove his devotion, will furnish means to help on two or three himself. He can be fully relied on. Anderson, at Chat., will come on immediately. At "B—n" I found the man, the leading spirit in that affair, which you, Henrie, referred to. On Thursday night last I went with him on foot twelve miles, much of the way through mere paths, and sought out in "the bush" some of the choicest Had a meeting after 1 o'clock at night at his house. He has a wife and five children, all small, and they are living very poorly indeed—"roughing it in the bush"—but his wife is a heroine, and he will be on hand as soon as his family can be provided for. He owes about $30; says that a hundred additional would enable him to leave them comfortable for a good while. After viewing him in all points I am capable of, I have to say that I think him worth in our market as much as two or three hundred average men; and even at this rate I should rate him too low. For physical capacity, for practical judgment, for courage and moral tone, for energy, and force, and will, for an experience that would not only enable him to meet difficulty, but give confidence to overcome it, I should have to go a long way to find his equal, and, in my judgment, would be a cheap acquisition at almost any price. I shall individually make a strenuous effort to raise the means to send him on.

Mr. A——n, at Detroit, is all alive; also DeB. However, Mr. A.'s wife is very sick; he will get down there as soon as possible. Is to let me know right away, by letter, what he can do, and when. DeB. is the working man there, and a host in himself. Thompson is on hand, as soon as he can shape his affairs so that his family—a wife and one child, six months old—can be provided for. I saw friend Isaac's letter to DeB., and took a copy to send on the other associations. When at "W——v" I saw our friends from Mo.; they are all doing well, are working hard; have raised a great deal of stuff to live on. (I'm) and his family are out on a farm, about 11 miles; did not see him. They all say he is doing better probably than any of those at "W—v." They seemed anxious to do some washing, or something for me for nothing. They said ---- your —— and ---- with him that we owes um a great deal more than we can ever pay in dis world."

By the way, it is now well ascertained that the fire was caused by an incendiary or incendiaries in the interest of the tyrants, who could devise no other plan.

I go on to-night from here so as to meet the morning train for Oberlin. Shall write you very soon again. I left Mr. ——, our Syracuse friend, at Detroit, from whence he will return home, stopping at Ingersoll and London. Perhaps, on the whole, it was best I had him accompany me on this trip, yet my first ideas of him I find are correct. "He is too fat;" nor is this all—his heart is only PASSIVELY in our cause. Wherever I have been they tell me I had no need of a voucher, as my resemblance to "Isaac" would have been all sufficient. As it is, I very much regret that I spent so much money in transporting so much inert adipose matter. Now don't imagine any thing occurred to mar friendly feelings; there did not, and what I have said I wish regarded as confidential. When I get home, if there is nothing which you have laid out for me to do, I shall, as soon as I can get to it, set about raising some funds for the cause. From this on I mean to devote my whole time, if I can, in the work. Don't fail to attach to my name to that document, or those documents. You know.

If friend "Isaac" wishes me to go any where else I shall need more means, as I have only enough to get back with. In haste yours,

JOHN SMITH.

Give my warmest regards to all the fraternity. J. S.

WEST ANDOVER, (ASHTABULA CO., OHIO,)

Thursday Morning, Sept. 8, 1859. FRIEND HENRIE: I yesterday evening received yours of Friday, September 2d, and I not only hasten to reply, but hasten to lay its contents before those who are interested. Through those associations which I formed in C——, I am, through the corresponding secretaries of each, able to reach each individual member at the shortest notice by letter. I am devoting my whole time to our company business. Shall immediately go out organizing and raising funds. From what I, even, had understood I had supposed you would not think it best to commence opening the coal banks before spring, unless circumstances should make it imperative. However, I suppose the reasons are satisfactory to you, and if so, those who own smaller shares ought not to object. I hope we shall be able to get on in season some of those old miners of whom I wrote you. Shall strain every nerve to accomplish this. You may be assured that what you say to me will reach those who may be benefited thereby and those who would take stock, in the shortest possible time; so don't fail to keep me posted. My initials simply, under cover to Horace, will answer just as well, and perhaps better. Please remember this. Did the last shipment of 6 boxes and 1 chest of household goods safely arrive? How did the mining prospect seem to strike our R——r friend? In short, was his faith increased in the practicability and profit of the work, and how much stock did he take? I some think of exhibiting a specimen of the fence at Cleveland fair in October—about the first of the month, I believe, and I may direct you to write me there, in care of the friends with whom you used to board. When in Cleveland I made their acquaintance; am pleased with them. Mrs. S. thought she could do something, even though her husband was too much absorbed in other business. She might invest profitably, and would be a good stockholder. You might drop her a line, through me, if you think better than to her direct. I feel that it is all important you should have that wire from the East, and hope you will not have to make any fence without it. The specimens put up here are beautiful. Our castings cost us here not less than 8 cents per pound. If our plan succeeds I think the cost might be materially lessened.

Last night we had a smart frost; cannot say how much the corn is injured; no piece that I have seen is out the way of frost yet. There is a general dearth of news in this region. By the way, I notice through the Cleveland Leader that "old Brown" is again figuring in Kansas. Well, every dog must have his day, and he will no doubt find the end of his tether. Did you ever know of such a high-handed piece of business? However, it's just like him. The Black-Republicans—some of them may wink at such things, but I tell you, friend Henrie, he's too salt a dose for many of them to swallow, and I can already see symptoms of divisions in their ranks. We are bound to roll up a good stiff majority for our side this fall. I will send you herewith the item referred to, which I clipped from the Leader. Give best regards to all, and believe me, faithfully yours.

JOHN.

P. S. Direct to "I. B. J.," under cover to Horace, until further notice.

The following is the extract from the Leader referred to in the within letter:

"'OLD BROWN'—RELEASE OF DR. DOY.—It is intimated that Dr. Doy owes his release from prison at St. Joseph to the presence of the brave Ossawatomie Brown in Kansas. The marked coolness, firmness, sagacity, and success of the deed bespeak 'Old Brown's' work. It was planned and executed by a leader of daring character, and whose audacity in bearding the slaveholders in their den had been rendered matchless by experience. The reward of $3,000, offered some months ago by the Governor of Missouri for the capture of Captain Brown, is a tempting one, but the Missourians do not appear to be very anxious to make the special acquaintance of the hero of Black Jack, Ossawatomie, and Fort Scott."

OBERLIN, AUG. 23, 1859.

DEAR SIR: Yours of August 9th came to hand this morning, and I hasten to reply, and should have replied to your first letter before, but it was so long reaching me that I was afraid you would have left Chambersburg.

My pecuniary condition is such (having made a loss in consequence of being in jail of about $1,200 on property shipped West) that I regret to say I cannot advance the money to save your father's land. It would give me great pleasure to do this, and I am sorry I cannot.

Next, with regard to the last proposition: Our people have been drained of the last copper to pay expenses for the Oberlin trial, and are now sued by Lowe for twenty thousand dollars damages for false imprisonment. We have, in all probability, got to have another clinch with the scoundrels, and money, money, money will be needed at every step.

If I could possibly do so I would send you the required amount, but in my opinion it will not be possible to raise it. By visiting other places, and interesting other parties, it might be done, but not here. I have to go to Missouri in a few days to look after my business there, which has been left in a disastrous condition by imprisonment.

Yours, truly, R. Plumb.

J. Henrie, Esq.

The following is in Old Brown's handwriting:

Look for letters directed to John Henrie, at Chambersburg. Enquire for letters at Chambersburg for I. Smith & Sons, and write them at Harper's Ferry as soon as any does come. See Mr. Henry Watson at Chambersburg, and find out if the Tribune comes on. Have Mr. Watson and his reliable friends get ready to receive company. Get Mr. Watson to make you acquainted with his reliable friends, but do not appear to be anywise thick with them, and do not often be seen with any such man. Get Mr. Watson, if he can, to find out as trusty man or men to stop with at Hagerstown, (if any such there be,) as Mr. Thomas Henry has gone from there. Write Tidd to come to Chambersburg by Pittsburg and Harrisburg at once. He can stop off the Pittsburg road at Hudson, and go to Jason's for his trunk. Write Carpenter and Hazlett that we are all well, right, and ready as soon as we can get our boarding-house fixed, when we will write them to come on, and by what route. I will pay Hazlett the money he advanced to Anderson for expenses travelling. Find yourself a comfortable cheap boarding-house at once. Write I. Smith & Sons, at Harper's Ferry. Inquire after your four Cleveland friends and have them come on to Chambersburg if they are on the way; if not on the road have them wait till we are a little better prepared. Be careful what you write to all persons. Do not send or bring any more persons here until we advise you of our readiness to board them.

West Port, April 16, 1859.

Dear Sir: I am here waiting a conveyance to take me home; have been quite prostrated almost the whole time since you left me at John's with the difficulty in my head and ear, and with the ague in consequence. I am now some better. Had a good visit at Rochester, but did not effect much. Had a first-rate time at Peterboro;* got of Mr. S.† and others $160 nearly, and a note (which I think a good one) for $285. Mr. S. wrote to Eastern friends to make up at least $2,000, saying he was in for one-fifth the amount. I feel encouraged to believe it will soon be done, and wish you to let our folks all round understand how the prospects are. Still it will be some days (and it may be weeks) before I can get ready to return. I shall not be idle. If you have found my writing-case and papers, please forward them without delay, by express, to Henry Thompson.

Your friend,

B. J. H. Kagi, Esq.

* Gerrit Smith's residence. † Gerrit Smith.

Tribune Office, (New York,)

April 30, 1859.

Sir: Yours is received, and we enclose our check for forty-one dollars for seven letters from Kansas and two from Ohio. Yours, Horace Greeley & Co.

Mr. J. H. Kagi.

Office of Daily Morning Leader,

Cleveland, June 21, 1859.

Dear Sir: Mr. Cowles requested me to recommend to your attention the bearer of this, J. H. Kagi, Esq., who is connected with the New York Tribune, and now from Kansas. He designs to go to Buffalo by lake on one of the fine steamers you represent.

Yours, truly, J. L. Beardsley.

Mr. G. L. Heaton.

Pittsburg, (Pa.) June 23, 1859.

Dear Sir: Please inquire for a letter at Bedford, Pa. If you do not find one there, you may understand that you have got ahead of us, and will wait a little. If you have any company along, it may be just as well not to appear as fellow-travellers. We may commend prospecting before we get to Bedford.

Yours, in truth. S. Munroe.

John Henrie, Esq.

[Telegraph despatch.]

Cleveland, June 6, 1859.

(By telegraph from Boston 6th, 1859.)

He got the needful, and left three days ago. Direction unknown. J. G. H.

To J. H. Kagi. DEAR SIR: I wish you to give such explanations to our friends as to our situation here as, after advising with Owen, you will be enabled to do. We can, of course, do nothing to purpose till our freight is mostly received. You know, also, that it takes a great deal longer to start some folks than it does others. It will be distressing in many ways to have a lot of hands for many days out of employ. We must have time to get on our freight, and also to get on some who are at a distance, before calling on those who are ready and waiting. We must make up our lot of hands as near by at one and the same time as possible. Do not use much paper to put names of persons and places upon. Send back word about the price of board with you.

Respectfully, yours, J. SMITH.

JOHN HENRIE, Esq

CHAMBERSBURG, (PA.) June 30, 1859.

DEAR SIR: We leave here to-day for Harper's Ferry via Hagerstown. When you get there you had best look on the hotel register for I. Smith and Sons without making much inquiry. We shall be looking for cheap hands, near the railroad, in all probability. You can write I. Smith and Sons at Harper's Ferry should you need to do so. Yours, in truth, J. SMITH.

JOHN HENRIE, Esq.

SPRINGFIELD, August 80, 1859.

DEAR FRIEND: I enclose you a draft for fifty dollars on New York, bought with money sent by Mrs. Russell. Dr. Howe has already sent you fifty dollars, and G. S., of P., writes me that he has sent, or will send, one hundred dollars. The remainder will probably come more slowly, but I think it will come. I have sent your letter to G. S. Please acknowledge the receipt of these sums. Yours, ever, F.

Endorsed on back by Brown, "F. B. S. letter."

COLLINSVILLE, (CONN.) Aug. 27, 1859.

Your favor of the 24th is at hand. In reply I would say that I have not yet forwarded any part of the freight spoken of, but shall forward the whole the last of next week. It was all to have been ready the 10th of August, but in consequence of some delay in obtaining some malleable castings the work has been delayed, and I thought it best to send the whole at once, as it would cause me some trouble to make more than one shipment, as the work is being done several miles from this place. The man who is finishing up the work assures me that it will all be ready the last of next week. I will advise the day that I send it forward. Respectfully, yours,

CHAS. BLAIR.

Messrs. I. SMITH & SONS.

CHAMBERSBURG, SATURDAY, Sept. 3, 1859.

DEAR SIR: I have just received the enclosed letter, together with the draft for $50 mentioned therein, and have acknowledged the receipt of the same. I have also received a letter from John Smith, under date of Sandusky, August 27th. He would stop at Cleveland. Anderson at C—m, would leave immediately; one at H—n as soon as he could raise the money; the coppersmith in a few weeks. The latter has been waiting for some time, but at last made an engagement which he could not break for a few weeks. Others have to make certain provisions. John Smith intends to try to raise funds for the object. He says he is ready for any other business you may give him employment in. His money is expended. Is sorry (confidentially) that he went in company with Mr. L—; he is too fat, and takes hardly strong interest enough. I have written him.

Respectfully, —— J. Henrie.

WEST ANDOVER, (O.)

Saturday, July 28, 1859.

DEAR SIR: Your favor of July 16, enclosing a brief note from I. Smith & Co., is received. Will preserve the list; but as yet I have received no letter with instructions as to when, how, &c. Please say to Esquire Smith that I yesterday forwarded to canal at Hartstown, Pa., 11 boxes "hardware and castings" from King & Bros. They are numbered and marked thus: ‖1 to 11. "By railroad via Pittsburg and Harrisburg, I. Smith & Sons, Chambersburg, Pa."

Shall send balance hardware, &c. on Monday next. ‖8 and ‖9 are those which were on store with E. A. F. at Lindenville. Mr. Smith will remember. His household goods I shall send along as fast as possible.

The letter asking me to retain the drafts came too late. I had got them cashed. Write often, directing to John Smith, under cover to Horace Lindsley, as before. Let me know if those goods come through safely.

Please say to Mr. S. I am still ready to serve.

Very respectfully, &c. JOHN SMITH.

J. HENRIE, Esq., Chambersburg, Pa.

BROOKLYN, AUGUST 18, 1859.

$10. ESTEEMED FRIEND: I gladly avail myself of the opportunity afforded by our friend, Mr. F. Douglas, who has just called upon us, previous to his visit to you, to enclose to you for the good cause in which you are such a zealous laborer a small amount, which please accept with my most ardent wishes for its and your benefit. The visit of our mutual friend Douglass has somewhat revived my rather drooping spirits in the cause; but seeing such ambition and enterprise in him I am again encouraged with best wishes for your welfare and prosperity, and the good of your cause.

I subscribe myself your sincere friend.

MRS. E. A. GLOUCESTER.

Please write to me. With best respects to your son.

SYRACUSE, NEW YORK,

Thursday, August 17, 1859.

FRIEND HENRIE: I am here to-day, so far on my way back from Boston, whither I went on Friday last. Found our Syracuse friend there, but his engagements were such that he could not possibly leave until yesterday morning. We reached here about 12 o'clock last night. While in Boston I improved the time in making the acquaintance of those stanch friends of our friend Isaac. First called on Dr. H*—— who, though I had no letter of introduction, received me most cordially. He gave me a letter to the friend who does business on Wilk street. Went with him to his house in Medford and took dinner. The last word he said to me was, "tell friend" (Isaac) "that we have the fullest confidence in his endeavor, whatever may be the result. I have met no man on whom I think more implicit reliance may be placed." He views matters from the stand-points of reason and principle, and I think his firmness is unshakable. The friend at Concord I did not see; he was absent from home. The others here will, however, communicate with him. They were all, in short, very much gratified, and have had their faith and hopes much strengthened. Found a number of earnest and warm friends, whose sympathies and theories do not exactly harmonize, but in spite of themselves their hearts will lead their heads. Our Boston friends thought it better that our old friend from Syracuse should accompany me in my journey Northward. I shall leave in an hour or two for Rochester, where I will finish this letter. I am very glad I went to Boston, as all the friends were of the opinion that our friend "I——" was in another part of the world, if not in another sphere. Our cause is their cause in the fullest sense of the word.

* Dr. Howe.

ROCHESTER, THURSDAY EVENING,

August 17, 1859.

On my way up to our friend's house I met his son Lewis, who informs me that his father left here on Tuesday, via New York and Philadelphia, to make you a visit. Mr. L. will come on to-night in the 1.30 train, when we shall go right on North. That other young friend went on from here to visit you yesterday. He will take a more direct route. Do not know as I have any thing further to say now. My warmest regards to all our friends. Faithfully, yours, JOHN.

[Endorsed "John Smith's letter to J. Henrie."]

SYRACUSE, (N. Y.)

Thursday, August 11, 1859.

FRIEND J. HENRIE: Day before yesterday I reached Rochester. Found our "Rochester friend" absent at Niagara Falls. Yesterday he returned, and I spent remainder of the day and evening with him and Mr. E. Morton, with whom friend Isaac is acquainted.

The friend at Rochester will set out to make you a visit in a few days. He will be accompanied by that "other young man," and, if it can be brought around, also by the woman that the Syracuse friend could tell me of. The son will probably remain back for awhile. I gave "Fred'k" $22 to defray expenses. If alive and well you will see him ere long. I found him in rather low spirits—left him in high. Accidentally met at R. Mr. E. Morton. He was much pleased to hear from you; was anxious for a copy of that letter of instructions to show our friend "Pr."* who, Mr. M. says, has his whole soul absorbed in this matter. I have just made him a copy and mailed him at B., where he expects to be for two or three weeks. He wished me to say to you that he has reliable information that a certain noted colonel, whose name you are all acquainted with, is now in Italy. By the way, the impression prevails generally that a certain acquaintance of ours headed the party that visited St. J., in Mo., lately; of course I don't try to deny that which bears such ear-marks.

Came on here this morning. Friend L. gone to Boston, Mass., and also said woman. As T. does not know personally those persons in C. to whom it is necessary to have letters of introduction, and he thinks I had better get him to go with me there. I have made up my mind, notwithstanding the extra expense, to go on to Boston. L. is expected to visit C. soon any way, and his wife thinks would continue to go immediately. I think, for other reasons, also, I had better go on to Boston. Morton says our particular friend, Mr. S—n, in that city, is especially anxious to hear from you—has his heart and hand both engaged in the cause; shall try and find him. Our Rochester friend thinks the woman whom I shall see in Boston, "whose services might prove invaluable," had better be helped on. I leave this eve in 11.35 train from here; shall return as soon as possible to make my visit to C. Will write you after. So far all is well. Keep me advised as far as consistent. Fraternally yours,

JOHN SMITH. * Petersborough, Gerrit Smith's home. WEST ANDOVER, SEPT. 2, 1859. FRIEND HENRIE: I reached here day before yesterday, and have since been busy writing to "our folks" both in C.* and nearer home. Have sent off letters to De B. at D.† At C——m‡ to Buxton, and to Hamilton to Pr.§ in New York, and this morning to F. B. S. at Concord, Massachusetts. In all these letters I have forwarded the latest word from your region. Friend L——y‖ at Ob—— will be on hand soon. Mr. C. H. L——n** will do all he can here, but his health is bad. J. D. H. I did not see, but L——n thought would be right on. Mrs. Sturtevant†† is a working woman; any thing she can do she will take hold of in earnest. Write her if you can get time. James Smith is marrying a wife, "and therefore cannot come." John L——n,‡‡ brother of C. H. L., at Ob——, sympathizes strongly, and will work hard. Ralph,§§ also, I think.

I shall start out soon to try to get some means in the way; father suggested when here to help on the cause in the mean time. I wish he would remit me some means—say $25 to $30—as I had only enough left to get back with, and I have to purchase the material to winter my little stock on since I was absent and on this business during the haying season. Am greatly rejoiced that the boxes 15, freight are all through safe, as that was the most important part. Surely, as fathers says, "a good Providence seems to lead us." How was our R——r friend pleased? You say he returned; I wish to know in what "frame of mind."

Enclosed is a letter to H——e, which came under cover to me. Don't fail to keep me fully advised, as through me you can reach the faithful whereon I have been. I will write very often. My last letter I sent you from Sandusky.

Yours,

JOHN.

* Cleveland. † Detroit. ‡ Chatham. § Petersboro', Gerrit Smith's home. ‖ Leary. **Charles H. Langston. ††Of Cleveland. ‡‡John Langston. §§Ralph Plumb.

NEW YORK STATE BANK,

Albany, August 29, 1859.

SIRS: I have received with enclosure your favor of ——. I hand you herewith my draft on Mechanics' Bank, New York, for $100, in accordance with instructions from Hon. Gerrit Smith, Peterboro', New York.

Respectfully, yours,

J. H. VAN ANTWERP, Cashier.

CLEVELAND, Aug. 22, 1859.

MY DEAR J. HENRIE: I wrote you immediately on receipt of your last letter; then went up to Oberlin to see Leary; I saw Smith, Davis, and Mitchell; they all promised, and that was all. Leary wants to provide for his family, Mitchell to lay his crop by, and all make such excuses until I am disgusted with myself and the whole negro set—GOD DAM EM! If you was here your influence would do something, but the moment you are gone all my speaking don't amount to any thing. I will speak to Smith to-day. I know that Mitchell had'nt got the money, and I tried to sell my farm and every thing else to raise money, but have not raised a cent yet. Charlie Langston says "it is too bad;" but what he will do, if any thing, I don't know. I wish you would write to him, for I believe he can do more good than I. Please write to him immediately, and I will give up this thing to him. I think, however, nothing will inspire their confidence unless you come. I will, however, do all I can. Yours, J. D. H.

Charlie goes to see Leary to-day. D. Letter from "F.," dated Springfield, August 27, 1859

Extract:

"I conclude your operation will not be delayed if the money reaches you in course of the next fortnight, if you are sure of having it then. I cannot certainly perceive that you will but think so. Harriet Talman is probably in New Bedford sick; she has staid home in New England, and been a kind of missionary. God prosper you in all your works."

OBERLIN, SEPT. 8, 1859.

RESPECTED SIR: I received yours per C. H. L.,* and have delayed answering it directly until the present. I have not seen J. D. H. since I received it, but have heard from him. Nothing delays me more than want of means. I have been unhealthy for some time, but have grown quite well. I saw J. B., jr. a week ago, and received a letter from him yesterday. His statements to me were satisfactory. I have a handy man who is willing and every way competent to dig coal, but, like myself, has no tools. If the company employs him they will have to furnish him tools. His address is John Copeland, jr., Oberlin, Ohio. † He is an honest man, and will do as much labor as the common run of men. I saw Mr. P ——. ‡ I think that he can get an outfit from parties interested in our welfare in this place. If so, I shall be on as soon as I can.

Yours, sincerely, L. S. LEARY.

To J. HENRIE.

* Charles H. Langston, Oberlin rescuer.

† Now a prisoner at Charlestown.

‡ Ralph Plumb, lawyer and Oberlin rescuer.

See the clipping

What the raiders left behind at the Ferry

From Harper's Ferry on 22 October, a correspondent lists relics of the raid: letters to Charles P. Tidd from friends he takes for Quakers, urging him on; ivory tablets of memoranda taken from Kagi's body; a woman's dress perhaps meant as a disguise; even part of an insurgent's ear, kept by a tavern-keeper. He also copies from a diary of the prisoner A. D. Stephens, hanged in March 1860.

M'arthur Democrat · McArthur, Ohio

M'arthur Democrat · 3 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Letter from Harper's Ferry. HARPER'S FERRY, Oct., 22 1859. A Package of Letters from the House of Captain Cook--Deluded Females Encouraging the Fanatics--Their Bloody Purpose, &c.

Mr. D. J. Young, the efficient foreman of the rifle factory of the U. S. Armory, exhibited to the writer a large package of letters taken from the house of Cook, by Wm. H. Turk, Esq., a justice of the peace. The letters are addressed to Charles P. Tidd, Springdale, Cedar County, Iowa, one of the insurgents.

See moreSee less

Most of the letters are written in an intelligent style, the use of the pronouns by many of the writers indicating that they were members of the Society of Friends. They illustrate the morbid feeling and fanaticism which, unhappily, exists in certain portions of the Union, upon a subject with which the writers are but imperfectly acquainted. One of the letters contain seven verses, "respectfully addressed to him by his friend, the author," Esther L. Lewis, dated Newark, N. J., July 3, 1859:

"Go, brother, to thy vineyard; Go labor with thy might, In thy chosen field of labor, Till wrong yield unto right."

"Farewell, the tie that binds us, Affection's cord, is strong; But duty calls thee from us, To battle with the wrong."

Another letter from Anna, dated July 22, 1859, says: "The time draws near that we are to part, perhaps never to meet again on these mundane shores. I appreciate the feeling that prompts thee to take thy life in thy hands and go boldly forth in such a hazardous undertaking in that cause that lies near my heart. I have been thinking of the great responsibility that rests upon thee in the command of others; may thou do it with wisdom and discretion. Be noble, be dignified, and always see that the rights of women are respected and protected. I want you to make a bargain that if anything happens to either of our friends, the one that is able shall inform us of the particulars, &c."

There is another from Sarah G. Wattles, Newark, N. J., Aug. 14, 1859, a school teacher, encouraging him in his enterprise.

There are other letters exhibiting all of a mother's love, addressed to "My dear child, Charles." One of them, dated Springdale, Iowa, August 26, 1859, signed "C. Varney," says: "If thou art spared wilt thou return to us again?" If his name has been confounded with others, the deluded victim of abolitionism, who stained his hands with the blood of his fellow men, lies buried on the banks of the Shenandoah.

Another letter, in a lady's hand, is signed "Emlin," and dated "8th month 11th, 1859," says: "Press nobly on. By your instrumentality millions may have the pleasure of singing the song of liberty," &c.

Messrs. Herr & Co., exhibited to the writer several pistols and a small tin box found on the person of Capt. Kagi, secretary of war under Brown, whose body was taken out of the Shenandoah after being shot. It contained a small compass, a flint box, a knife, percussion caps, and a handsome set of ivory tablets, which were full of memoranda, as follows:

"Wrote to S. Jones--sending men off--" "Guerilla operations at Brownsville, Texas." "Leary and Copeland arrested." Thursday, "Received letter from Merriman, dated Baltimore." "Friday--sent telegram to Merriman at Baltimore."

Tuesday.--"Dimas returned to Mrs. Ritner's." "Saw Watson, and appointed meeting for Thursday eve." "Wrote Mr. Still and J. B. Jr."

The Merriman referred to above is the person who arrived at Harper's Ferry Oct., 15, and registered himself "J. F. Merriman and friend," Massachusetts. He brought with him here a heavy trunk, supposed to contain arms and ammunition, which were taken away from the depot by a son of old Brown, and probably taken to his house.--When here Merriman wrote more than a dozen letters. His face is marked with blotches, and he is supposed to have been the agent of old Brown and his associates at Chambersburg, for the supply of arms.

Mr. McDaniel, employed in the rifle factory, exhibited a shawl, bonnet, hoop skirt, and a coarse and torn calico dress, found by him at the head of a fence at the head of a ravine, three-fourths of a mile from the town. It is supposed that they had been used, or were intended to be used as a disguise by some of the insurgents.

A young lad, named Walter W. Harrington, went out into the Potomac this morning and recovered the Sharpes' rifle dropped by "Captain" Leeman, who was killed in the river.

An extraordinary memento is that possessed by Mr. J. W. Jackson, tavern-keeper, Fairfax Courthouse, Va., which is a part of the ear of one of the insurgents who was killed in the engine-house.

The prisoner, A. D. Stephens, kept a diary, which he handed to Mr. Faulke, of the Wager House. It contains the following memoranda: "October 6th, 1859, Ox Brown, 1 belt; Wm. Brown, one belt; S. Taylor, one holster; B. Coppee, one holster; S. Emperor, one belt; D. Thompson, one belt. 6th October, Ox got ashamed of his vulgar language." W.

See the clipping

A Pennsylvania paper doubts the trial's fairness

A Lewisburg paper runs the 27 October wire: the Akron telegram on insanity in Brown's family, and Brown's answer that he was not crazy and scorned the plea. Then it comments: refusing him delay and Ohio counsel of his choosing ‘looks as though the court were not so well inclined’ to give him a fair trial; there is no danger of rescue, yet some 80 men stand guard.

Union County Star and Lewisburg Chronicle · Lewisburg, Pa.

Union County Star and Lewisburg Chronicle · 4 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Refusal to Postpone Brown's Trial.

CHARLESTON Va. Oct. 27.

See moreSee less

Brown was brought into Court this morning, being able to walk, but immediately laid himself down upon his cot, at full length, within the bar. He looks considerabiy better, the swelling having left his eyes. Messrs. Harding and Hunter represent the Commonwealth and Botts and Greene the prisoner. Mr. Botts read the following despatch received this morning:

AKRON, Ohio, Oct. 27, 1859.—"To T. F. Faulkner and Lawson Botts, Charleston, Va: John Brown, leader of the insurrection at Harper's Ferry, and several of his family, have resided in this county many years. Insanity is hereditary in that family. His mother's sister died with it, and a daughter of that sister has been two years in the Lunatic Asylum. A son and daughter of his mother's brother have also been confined in the Lunatic Asylum, and another son of that brother is now insane and under close restraint. These facts can be conclusively proven by witnesses residing here, who will doubtless attend the trial, if desired. (Signed A. L. Lewis."

The telegraph operator at the Akron office, Wm. C. Allen, adds to the above despatch that A. H. Lewis is a resident of that place, and his statements are entitled to implicit credit.

Old Brown said that the despatch was partly true he knew, and as to some of it he did not know. But as for himself, he was not crazy, and scorned to take any advantage of such a plea!

His requests to postpone trial until his mind and body were in better order, and until he could get counsel from Ohio of his own choosing, were both refused. This looks as though the court were not so well inclined, as they first appeared to be, to give him a fair trial. There is no danger of any rescue, but they have had some 80 men to guard Brown and the other prisoners!

See the clipping

Cook blames Douglass; Douglass answers

A Staunton paper says the captured raider Cook blames the failure on Fred. Douglass, who was to bring a large band on the Monday, Cook says. Douglass, writing from Canada West, denies ever promising to come, though he grants he is ‘more distinguished for running than fighting’. Cook was hanged on 16 December. On the day of his own hanging, Brown told Cook he had made false statements in saying Brown sent him.

Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.

Staunton Spectator · 8 November 1859 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Cook and Fred. Douglas.—A letter from Charlestown reports Cook as saying that the Harper's Ferry enterprise only failed through the cowardice of the negro abolitionist Fred. Douglass. That individual was to have arrived at the schoolhouse with a large band early on Monday, but Cook says, "I conveyed the arms there for him, and waited till nearly night, but the coward did[n't] come."

Fred. replies to the charge of cowardice, in a letter dated Cana[da] West, Oct. 31. He says:—

See moreSee less

"I have always been more distinguished for running than fighting—and tried by the Harper's Ferry insurrection test, I am most miserably deficient in courage—even more so than Cook, when he deserted his brave old Captain and fled to the mountains. To this extent, Mr. Cook is entirely right, and will meet no contradiction from me or from anybody else. But wholly, grievously and unaccountably wrong is Mr. Cook when he asserts that I promised to be present in person at the Harper's Ferry insurrection.—Of whatever other imprudence and indiscretion I may have been guilty, I have never made a promise so rash and wild as this. The taking of Harper's Ferry was a measure never encouraged by my word or by my vote, at any time or place; my wisdom or my cowardice, has not only kept me from Harper's Ferry, but has equally kept me from making any promise to go there." The time has not come, he says, for him to make a full statement of what he knows about the affair. He has no apology for keeping out of the way of United States Marshals at this time. If he has committed any offence it was done in New York, and he is willing to be tried there; but he has "insuperable objections to be caught by the hands of Mr. Buchanan, and 'bagged' by Gov. Wise."

See the clipping

Brown speaks, and is sentenced to hang

Before a crowded court at Charlestown on 2 November, Brown denies everything but ‘the design on my part to free the slaves’, as he says he did in Missouri the winter before, and never meant murder, treason or insurrection. He is sentenced to hang in public on 2 December. Governor Wise would later tell the Virginia legislature that Brown had avowed to him a purpose to arm the slaves.

Smyrna Times · Smyrna, Del.

Smyrna Times · 10 November 1859 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SENTENCE OF JOHN BROWN—HIS SPEECH.

THE HARPER'S FERRY TROUBLE.

SENTENCE OF BROWN.

See moreSee less

CHARLESTOWN, (Va.) Nov. 2 — Messrs. Russell and Sonnat, Attorneys from Boston, reached here to-day.

Cook was brought before the Magistrate's Court, but waived an examination. He was committed for trial.

Coppee's trial was resumed. No witnesses were called for the defence. Mr. Harding opened the argument for the Commonwealth, and Messrs. Hoyt and Griswold followed for the defendant. Mr. Hunter closed for the prosecution. The speeches were of marked ability.

Mr. Griswold asked several instructions, which were all granted by the Court. The jury then retired.

SENTENCE OF JOHN BROWN—HIS SPEECH.

Brown was then brought into the Court House, which was immediately thronged.

The Court gave a decision on the motion to arrest judgment, overruling the objections made. On the objection that treason cannot be committed against a State, except by a citizen, it ruled that wherever allegiance was due, treason may be committed. Most of the States have passed laws against treason. The objections as to the form of the verdict rendered were also regarded as insufficient.

The Clerk then asked Brown whether he had anything to say why sentence should not be pronounced, when Brown stood up, and in a clear and distinct voice said:

"I have, may it please the Court, a few words to say.

"In the first place, I deny everything but what I have all along admitted, the design on my part to free the slaves. I intended certainly to have made a clean thing of that matter, as I did last winter, when I went into Missouri and there took the slaves without the snapping of a gun on either side, moved them through the country, and finally left them in Canada. I designed to have done the same thing again, on a large scale. That was all I intended; I never did intend to commit murder or treason, or to destroy property, or to excite or incite the slaves to rebellion and to make an insurrection.

"I have another objection, and that is, it is unjust that I should suffer such a penalty. Had I interferred in the manner which I admit, and which I admit has been fairly proved (for I admire the truthfulness and candor of the greater portion of the witnesses who have testified in this case,) had I so interfered in behalf of the rich, the powerful, the in'elligent, the so-called great, or in behalf of their friends, either father, mother, brother, sister, wife, or children, or any of that class, and suffered and sacrificed what I have in this interference, it would have been all right. Every man in this Court would have deemed it an act worthy of reward rather than punishment. This Court acknowledges, as I suppose, the validity of the law of God.—I see a book kissed here which I suppose to be the Bible, or at least the New Testament. That teaches me that all things whatsoever I would that men should do to me, I should do even so unto them! It teaches me further to "remember them that are in bonds as bound with them!' I endeavored to act up to that instruction. I say, I am yet too young to understand that God is any respecter of persons. I believe, that to have interfered as I have done, as I have always freely admitted I have done, in behalf of His despised poor, was no wrong, but right.—Now, if it is deemed necessary that I should forfeit my life for the furtherance of the ends of justice, and mingle my blood further with the blood of my children and with the blood of millions in this slave country, whose rights are disregarded by wicked, cruel and unjust enactments, I admit, so let it be done. Let me say one word further. I feel entirely satisfied with the treatment I have received on my trial.—Considering all the circumstances, it has been more generous than I expected, but I feel no consciousness of guilt. I have stated from the first what was my intention and what was not. I never had any design against the life of any person, nor any disposition to commit treason, or excite the slaves to rebel, or make any general insurrection. I never encouraged any man to do so, but always discouraged any idea of that kind. Let me say also, in regard to the statements made by some of those connected with me: I hear it has been stated by some of them that I have induced them to join me—but the contrary is true. I do not say this to injure them, but as regretting their weakness.—Not one joined me but of his own accord, and the greater part at their own expense. A number of them I never saw and never had a word of conversation with, till the day they came to me, and that was for the purpose I have stated."

"Now I have done."

While Brown was speaking, perfect quiet prevailed. When he had finished the Court proceeded to pronounce the sentence. After a few preliminary remarks, in which he said no reasonable doubt existed as to the prisoner's guilt, he sentenced him to be hung in public on Friday, the 2d of December.

Brown received the sentence with composure.

The only demonstration made was with the clapping of hands by one man in the crowd, who is not a resident of Jefferson county. This was promptly suppressed, and much regret was expressed by citizens at its occurrence.

THE VERDICT IN COPPEE'S CASE—GUILTY ON ALL THE COUNTS OF THE INDICTMENT.

After being out an hour, the jury in the case of Coppee returned, with a verdict declaring Coppee guilty on all the counts in the indictment.

His counsel gave notice of a motion to arrest judgment, as in Brown's case.

The Court then adjourned.

The counsel of Brown have filed exceptions to the decision of the Court in refusing an arrest of judgment, and will carry the case to the Court of Appeals at Richmond. The trial of Shields Green, one of the conspirators, was begun on Thursday. It is believed that the prisoners will all be hung on the same day. Cook, it is thought, will plead guilty, and make some important revelations.

See the clipping

Wendell Phillips calls Brown the true government

A Minnesota paper reports a Brooklyn lecture of 1 November by Wendell Phillips of Boston, who said Brown was the only true government on Virginia's soil and had ‘an infinitely better right to hang Gov. Wise than Wise had to hang him’. Tom Corwin of Ohio, on the platform, asked leave to reflect before giving his vote. In December Phillips would walk beside Mrs. Brown at the burial at North Elba.

The Weekly Pioneer and Democrat · Saint Paul, Minn. Territory

The Weekly Pioneer and Democrat · 11 November 1859 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Violent Speech of Wendell Phillips.

VIEWS OF AN ABOLITIONIST ON THE HARPER'S FERRY INSURRECTION.

See moreSee less

Wendell Phillips, of Boston, delivered a lecture in Brooklyn on the evening of Nov. 1st, in which he argued that John Brown was the only American who had acted boldly up to the true American idea and cast aside also these false and fatal wrappings of an effete conservatism, and refused to regard anything as government, or any statute as law, except those which conformed to his own sense of justice and of right. Virginia was not a state. Mr. Wise was not a governor. The Union was not a nation. All these so-called governments were organized piracies, and John Brown was to-day the only real and true government on the soil of Virginia, and had an infinitely better right to hang Gov. Wise than Wise had to hang him.

He also said: "I think you can make a better use of iron than forging it into chains; if you must have the metal, put it into Sharpe's rifles. It is a great deal better used that way than in fetters--a great deal better than a great clumsy statue of a false great man for men to kneel down and worship in a State House yard."

Tom Corwin, of Ohio, was present on the platform, and being called upon for a speech said he was there merely by accident, and begged to be allowed to reflect on what he had heard before giving his vote upon the matter.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: The Insurrection at Harper's Ferry