As the Papers Told It

Jesse James · The full archive

February 1880

25 articles

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

A dispatch reports that George Shepherd, said to be the slayer of Jesse James, traveled with a detective to Nelson County, Kentucky, seeking Frank James, but arrived too late. Frank James is believed to still be hiding in Missouri, evading detectives.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Chicago Daily Tribune · 5 February 1880 · page 8

]N. Y. Post.] li-.e extraordinary doings in Missouri con corning the death and burial of Jesse James, (he noted robber and murderer, have attracted a great deal of attention from the press, though

Clipping to come

The Bolivar Bulletin · Bolivar, Tenn.

This is a classified advertising page containing market prices and various product ads, including one offering agents payment to sell books about the lives of Jesse James and others. It reflects the commercial exploitation of the Jesse James legend through pamphlet sales rather than news reporting.

The Bolivar Bulletin · 5 February 1880 · page 4

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark.

A miscellaneous 'timely topics' column makes a passing sarcastic joke that Russian detectives can't be models of the profession since they haven't claimed to kill Jesse James, implying many have falsely claimed this. The rest of the item covers unrelated topics like a shoe found with muskrats, European military matters, and newspaper history.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Essex County Herald, 16 January 1880, The Abbeville Press and Banner, 21 January 1880.

The Osceola Times · 7 February 1880 · page 1

$17,000 te defray the cost of two eleva tors in tbe postefEco department build in?. The three-year-old boy, Freddie Lutz, one of the childrcu of the family at Uridcsburg that was sickened by eating diseased bam en last Sunday, has died. This is the second death from the same cause. "But little hope is sustained that the ethers will survive Ex-Governer Burbauk, of Dakota, new posteuice inspector, has received notice that there were leund among Jesse James

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A man calling himself Shepherd of Kansas City, who claimed to have killed outlaw Jesse James, passed through St. Louis while supposedly pursuing Frank James in Kentucky. When a hotel guest doubted his identity, he produced two revolvers from his valise to prove he was indeed 'Shepherd, of Kansas City.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 9 February 1880 · page 4

$17,000 te defray the cost of two eleva tors in tbe postefEco department build in?. The three-year-old boy, Freddie Lutz, one of the childrcu of the family at Uridcsburg that was sickened by eating diseased bam en last Sunday, has died. This is the second death from the same cause. "But little hope is sustained that the ethers will survive Ex-Governer Burbauk, of Dakota, new posteuice inspector, has received notice that there were leund among Jesse James

Clipping to come

Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.

A newspaper reporter encounters a heavily armed, one-eyed man on a train who identifies himself as George Shepherd and insists he killed Jesse James. The reporter notes Shepherd's desperate appearance and seems inclined to believe his claim of having killed James.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

Mexico Weekly Ledger · 12 February 1880 · page 3

GEO. SHEPHERD, THE DESPERADO, WHO KILLED JESSE JAMES, INTERVIEWED BY A LEDGER REPORTER

that the offending governor has done more. s : nce the killing by the Fords, than to excuse or justify it. If it be not excusable or justifia ble homicide it is somebody’s murder, and the governor has not made it more or less so by what he has said. It has a single point to it, which is whether Jesse James could have

Clipping to come

West-Jersey Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

A man calling himself Shepherd of Kansas City passed through St. Louis claiming to have killed outlaw Jesse James and was pursuing Frank James in Kentucky. When a hotel guest doubted his identity, he dramatically armed himself with two revolvers to prove his claim.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.

Wrong

West-Jersey Pioneer · 12 February 1880 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Cincinnati Daily Star · Cincinnati, Ohio

A man calling himself "Shepherd, of Kansas City" claims to have killed outlaw Jesse James and says he is chasing Frank James into Kentucky. When accused of not being the real Shepherd, he produces a belt of revolvers to prove his identity.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 7 days earlier.

Wrong

The Cincinnati Daily Star · 12 February 1880 · page 5

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · Chillicothe, Mo.

An advertisement seeks agents in Livingston County to canvass for sales of a 400-page book on the life of Frank and Jesse James, written by Hon. J. A. Dacus of St. Louis, covering their history up to January 1880. The ad promises agents can earn $40 per month and lists contact information for the publisher's representative.

Weekly Chillicothe Crisis · 19 February 1880 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Mexico Weekly Ledger · Mexico, Mo.

A short notice reports that Mrs. Jane Treloar is canvassing Mexico, Missouri for several books, including 'The Life of Frank and Jesse James,' alongside 'Mother, Home and Heaven' and 'Grant's Tour Around the World.' The piece recommends the books to local readers as worthwhile reading.

Mexico Weekly Ledger · 19 February 1880 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

A St. Louis publisher's forthcoming 400-page book on Frank and Jesse James is excerpted, recounting a previously untold chase scene after the Northfield raid in which pursuers wounded Frank James in a swamp standoff. The piece also references Annie Ralston becoming wife to one of the outlaws.

Martinsburg Independent · 21 February 1880 · page 3

THE JAMES BOYS.

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The passage narrates the James brothers' flight after the Northfield raid, including hiding in a thicket and trading for horses from an unsuspecting stranger. It then shifts to a romanticized account of Frank James's courtship and marriage to Annie Ralston, framing their relationship as a tale of outlaw romance.

Martinsburg Independent · 21 February 1880 · page 3

SWIM OR WADE THE RIVER

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A man recalls observing Cole and Robert Younger in jail and claims the physical descriptions of the two robbers who escaped Northfield do not match the James brothers. He argues authorities wrongly pursued the Jameses instead of the real culprits.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Daily Globe · 23 February 1880 · page 1

THE JAMES BOYS.

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Cincinnati Daily Star · Cincinnati, Ohio

A St. Louis report claims Jesse James spent a night in the city as the guest of an old guerrilla friend, with only a few trusted allies aware. He reportedly wrote a note dismissing George Shepherd's claim to have killed him, saying Shepherd's wound actually came from a dance.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 9 February 1880, Mexico Weekly Ledger, 12 February 1880, West-Jersey Pioneer, 12 February 1880, The Cincinnati Daily Star, 12 February 1880.

The Cincinnati Daily Star · 25 February 1880 · page 1

THE GREAT MISSOURI BUGBEAR

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · and 2 other papers

A writer to the St. Louis Republican describes firsthand encounters with the captured and dead Northfield robbers, including the Youngers and 'Charley Pitts,' arguing the physical descriptions don't match the James brothers. He suggests the two men who escaped were not Frank and Jesse James as commonly assumed.

The Worthington Advance · 26 February 1880 · page 1

FKOlI THE LAST PHOTCGIUPir HE HAD TAKEN. THE DEAD BAKDIT. o - Jesse James was the son of a Baptist preacher of prominence and eloquence in his day. The father was a native of Logan county, this state, and the mother, whose maiden name 2erelda Cole, was born in "Woodford county, about half way between Versailles and Lexington, where her father kept a hostelry known as "Cole's Tavern." On the death of her father the widow removed to the neighborhood of Stamping Ground, in Scott county, among her relatives, and there the future mother of the greatest bandit of modern times grew from childhood into girlhood, and from girlhood into womanhood, and there was married, in 1840, to Rev.

See moreSee less

Robert J. James. In the subsequent year their first child, Frank, was born, in Scott county. In 1843 the Jameses removed to Missouri, settling in Clay county, where Jesse was born in

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 23 February 1880
  • The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · 25 February 1880

The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · and 1 other paper

A witness who saw the dead and captured Northfield robbers argues that the two who escaped did not match the James brothers' descriptions. He suggests authorities wrongly pursued the James boys instead of the actual escaped robbers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 3 days earlier.

Wrong

The Worthington Advance · 26 February 1880 · page 1

FKOlI THE LAST PHOTCGIUPir HE HAD TAKEN. THE DEAD BAKDIT. o - Jesse James was the son of a Baptist preacher of prominence and eloquence in his day. The father was a native of Logan county, this state, and the mother, whose maiden name 2erelda Cole, was born in "Woodford county, about half way between Versailles and Lexington, where her father kept a hostelry known as "Cole's Tavern." On the death of her father the widow removed to the neighborhood of Stamping Ground, in Scott county, among her relatives, and there the future mother of the greatest bandit of modern times grew from childhood into girlhood, and from girlhood into womanhood, and there was married, in 1840, to Rev.

See moreSee less

Robert J. James. In the subsequent year their first child, Frank, was born, in Scott county. In 1843 the Jameses removed to Missouri, settling in Clay county, where Jesse was born in

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · 25 February 1880

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

A former Pinkerton detective named D. J. Browne discusses the controversy surrounding the Pinkerton agency's midnight raid on the James family farmhouse, disputing claims by Robert Pinkerton. Browne suggests a detective named Boyle/Allen, present when Younger brothers killed detective Lull, may shed light on betrayal accusations against Clay county citizens.

The Russellville Democrat · 26 February 1880 · page 1

HUNTING THE OUTLAWS.

Jesse, joined the band of the notorious Quantrell, when Jesse was only a lad of fourteen. At the sacking of the town oi Lawrence, Kansas, this boy-fiend .shot down women and children without compunction. He subsequently boasted that he muruered thirty-six of the citizens with his own hand. But the crowning horror of his lile occurred on Tuesday, September 17, 1861, at Mo. On the morning of that day a gang of Quantreli's band of cutthroats under Bill Anderson, galloped into this village, and after sacking the stores and plundering the houses of the citizens, waited for the coming of the train from St.

See moreSee less

Joseph, bound for St. Louis, which they stopped, made thirty-two sick feder al soldiers, who were on their way to the hospital at St. Louis descend from the train, stood them in a row, and two James boys loading his pistols as fast as they were emptied shot the last man of them to death. About the time this hellish crime was completed a company of uniqft militia, arrived,

Clipping to come

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

A former Pinkerton employee named Browne recounts the agency's failed efforts to catch the James-Younger gang, including the escape of a detective named Boyle/Allen and the disastrous 1875 Kearney raid. He claims Pinkerton himself lacked courage to lead the raid personally and that Lieutenant Linden carried it out instead, with the agency covering up its failures by blaming the Missouri community.

The Russellville Democrat · 26 February 1880 · page 1

HUNTING THE OUTLAWS

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

An advertisement seeks agents to sell a 'thrilling new book' about Frank and Jesse James, published by W.S. Bryan in St. Louis. It promises rapid sales of the illustrated volume.

The Russellville Democrat · 26 February 1880 · page 4

AJRQTJNI THE CIRCLE. . Near Midway, Lewis Howard shot tub Anderson m tne neaa nnicir ing a painful wound. They were only playing. .Governor John C. Underwood will shortlyremove to Covington to superintend his proposed paper, in Cincinnati. The maiden name of Jesse James' .mother was Zerelda Cole, and she was born near Stamping ' Ground, Scott county.. . At Glasgow, C. F. Bushong, a i.i young merchant, committed sui- . dide by blowing hisr brains out. He was under indictment by the grand , jury on the charge of setting fire to his own store. .. r Among the delinquent tax-payers reported by the Sheriff of Woodford county, we find the names 'of Henry Clay, Andrew Jackson,

Clipping to come

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A brief item states it was reported with certainty that Jesse James had spent Thursday night in St. Louis as the guest of an old guerrilla friend. He is said to have written a short letter to a newspaper denouncing the authorities.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 26 February 1880 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A dispatch from St. Louis claims it is stated positively that Jesse James spent the previous night there as the guest of an old guerrilla friend. He reportedly wrote a brief letter to a newspaper railing against the authorities.

The Salt Lake Herald · 26 February 1880 · page 4

Register of the Treasury, Bruce, ex onerates Jesse James' memory from the odium of his having been a delegate to the Chicago convention. Wolf, of Pennsylvania, is as inde pendent with his ballot as he is -with his mouth. "Wolf is emphatically a this year reform man rather than a next year re form man. Our city and county buildings are a disgrace. At the coming election the people will have an opportunity to vote for new and suitable structures. This is an era of progress. Vote yes . FU6105 in Arkansas, as in Tennessee, does not fuse.

See moreSee less

The indications are that Arthur has carried his grist to the wrong mill, and the carpetbaggers will have to play c lone hand, and get euchered as usual. __.^___ V' The Fords who killed Jesse James had

Clipping to come

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

The item claims it is positively stated that Jesse James spent Tuesday night in St. Louis as the guest of an old guerrilla friend. It also notes James wrote a brief letter to a newspaper criticizing the authorities.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 26 February 1880 · page 2

FU6105 in Arkansas, as in Tennessee, does not fuse. The indications are that Arthur has carried his grist to the wrong mill, and the carpetbaggers will have to play c lone hand, and get euchered as usual. __.^___ V' The Fords who killed Jesse James had

Clipping to come

Canton Register · Canton, Ill.

The report notes that Jesse James, previously claimed killed by a detective named Shepherd, was actually seen alive in St. Louis on the 24th. This brief item corrects the earlier false report of his death.

Canton Register · 27 February 1880 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Benton Weekly Record · Benton, Mont.

A brief item reports that Jesse James reportedly spent the previous night in St. Louis as the guest of an old guerrilla friend. It claims he wrote a letter to a local newspaper denouncing the authorities.

The Benton Weekly Record · 27 February 1880 · page 3

SCATTERING

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Grant County Herald · Big Stone City, S.D.

A writer to the St. Louis Republican recounts firsthand observations from the Northfield, Minnesota bank robbery aftermath, including seeing the bodies of slain raiders and later meeting Cole and Bob Younger in jail. He argues based on these observations that the 'James boys' were not actually present during the Northfield raid.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Grant County Herald · 28 February 1880 · page 2

THE JAMES BOYS

Ohiojstreel is like the back of a drome dary. Several business houses are "closed for repairs." The "Senate" has new glass doors so we heard. John Kaiser feeds more people than any house in the city. Gas pipes are being laid on several streets in West Sedalia . At least forty new residences are on the road to completion. The Daily Independent is worked on a Washington hand press. Arthur Stewart's mustachestill resem bles last year's peach crop. The "little village of Warsaw" is far ahead of Sedalia on a postoffice.

See moreSee less

Sedalia is one town out of a hundred that will support herself, regardless of country trade. Jim Woods claims to know Jesse James as well as anybody, and says that Jesse is still alive. Warsaw should see the cemetery at Sedalia. It shows that Sedalia people liave great respect for the dead. A new brass band has been organized out of scattering musicians. They call themselves the "Independents." Chas. Roll, in company with his wife, intends coming to Warsaw soon to take a camp fish at the Pomme de Terre. Our enterprising lumberman, Mr. S. P. Johns, has sold his residence on Third street and purchased one on Sixth and Grand avenue.

Clipping to come

The Grant County Herald · Big Stone City, S.D.

A correspondent recounts seeing Robert Younger's wounded arm and recalls that the physical descriptions given by Northfield townspeople of the two robbers who escaped did not match the Jameses. The writer states a belief, based on Cole Younger's own statement, that the James brothers were not part of the Northfield raiding party.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 49 days later.

Wrong

The Grant County Herald · 28 February 1880 · page 2

THE YOUNGER BOYS

Ohiojstreel is like the back of a drome dary. Several business houses are "closed for repairs." The "Senate" has new glass doors so we heard. John Kaiser feeds more people than any house in the city. Gas pipes are being laid on several streets in West Sedalia . At least forty new residences are on the road to completion. The Daily Independent is worked on a Washington hand press. Arthur Stewart's mustachestill resem bles last year's peach crop. The "little village of Warsaw" is far ahead of Sedalia on a postoffice.

See moreSee less

Sedalia is one town out of a hundred that will support herself, regardless of country trade. Jim Woods claims to know Jesse James as well as anybody, and says that Jesse is still alive. Warsaw should see the cemetery at Sedalia. It shows that Sedalia people liave great respect for the dead. A new brass band has been organized out of scattering musicians. They call themselves the "Independents." Chas. Roll, in company with his wife, intends coming to Warsaw soon to take a camp fish at the Pomme de Terre. Our enterprising lumberman, Mr. S. P. Johns, has sold his residence on Third street and purchased one on Sixth and Grand avenue.

Clipping to come