As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

September 1898

13 articles

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A civil engineer recounts to a New York Sun reporter his experiences surveying in the Tug River country years earlier, describing the wary mountaineers and the fortified home of clan patriarch Devil Anse Hatfield. He recalls a tale of two railroad detectives who, targeted by a Hatfield ambush, outwitted their pursuers by riding directly to Devil Anse's house for protection under the code of hospitality.

The Evening Times · 2 September 1898 · page 3

THE HATFIELDS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A journalist describes travel through feud country, noting poor marksmanship with rifles despite reputation, and the practice of ambush killing called 'taking a bush to a man.' The piece generalizes about feuds including Hatfield-McCoy, noting young men seek reputation through killing and most participants don't know the original cause of the conflict.

The Evening Times · 2 September 1898 · page 3

THE HATFIELDS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

This article speculates on the historical and cultural roots of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, tracing settlers back to post-Revolutionary War outlaws who moved into the Cumberland Gap region. It describes the primitive, irreligious, and violent character of the Tug River mountain people, including an anecdote about a man shooting at a train engineer.

The Evening Times · 2 September 1898 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

A civil engineer recounts his experiences surveying in the Tug River country, describing mountaineer suspicion of outsiders and hospitality customs. He relates an anecdote of two railroad detectives who evaded a Hatfield ambush by riding directly to Devil Anse Hatfield's fortified home and claiming his protection as guests.

El Paso Daily Herald · 10 September 1898 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE HATFIELDS AT HOME.

A Land Where Human Life is Cheap and the Marksmanship is Poor.

See moreSee less

"When I went with a surveying party into the Tug river country, in West Virginia, several years ago, there was doubt as to whether the natives would let us stay," said F. C. Albright, a civil engineer. "In general it was taken for granted by the mountaineers that any stranger who crossed the dead line, where the mountain district begins, was an enemy, a revenue officer or sheriff, whom it was their duty to pot for the public safety. But shortly before our coming the United States marshals had made some impression on the district and inspired a respect for government. The mountaineers regarded our surveys and railroad building as part of the government, and accordingly did not molest us.

"All are hospitable, and, like the Arab, the mountaineer regards the stranger who has eaten his salt as being under his protection. This brings me to a story of Devil Anse Hatfield and two of our railroad detectives. Devil Anse, as you probably have heard, is the patriarch and leader of the Hatfield clan. He lives in his fortified house on Island Creek with six or seven armed men always there as guard. Somehow the two detectives had got the ill will of the Hatfields, and an ambush was laid for them. The detectives got wind of it. They knew the country and the people and decided on the only thing that they could do. Leaving the road, they made a detour behind the men in ambush, and rode straight to the house of Devil Anse Hatfield. As luck would have it the old man was away, perhaps superintending the ambush, and they got to the house and within the door without being fired at. They set their rifles in a corner, hung their belts and pistols against the wall, sat down and asked for something to eat. When Devil Anse came back the woman had fed the detectives, and as they had eaten bread beneath his roof there was nothing for the old man to do but to play host with the best grace he could show. He made the best of the matter and gave the men the best supper and breakfast that the house afforded, and fed their horses. The next morning he sent them with a guide by an out-of-the-way part of the country.

"'He'll see you safe,' said Devil Anse at parting. 'If you took the main trail you'd likely meet some of my folks and I reckon they'd turn their guns loose without stopping to ask where you've been.'

"With all their readiness to shoot I found that in this country, where every man is supposed to carry a revolver and a Winchester rifle, the men are not good marksmen with either of these weapons. With the old-fashioned, long-barrelled squirrel rifle, using a rest, the mountaineer can draw a fine bead and bark a squirrel on a high limb with a great deal of certainty. But using a Winchester in a mix-up, such as is apt to occur when hostile factions come together on court days, he pumps away a great deal of ammunition for every man that falls. When he starts deliberately out to kill a man he always plans to shoot him from an ambuscade. This he calls taking a bush to a man. Not to be a partisan in one of the border feuds -- there are half a dozen along the line, some more inveterate and bloody than the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta -- is to be a man of small consideration in the community. The very young men are the worst. One of these is apt to think that he is of no account until he has got his man. He kills somebody of another clan to establish his reputation, and so keeps alive the feud.

"Few men that take part in the feuds have any idea how the quarrel started and what were the rights and wrongs in the matter. That a man is named McCoy or Hatfield is reason enough in the minds of any partisan opponent for killing him if a good chance offers. It is probable that some of the feuds date back to the end of the last century when the whites first settled in the mountains. They were pirates and outlaws generally, the tradition runs, who, after the revolutionary war, found the settled part of Virginia too warm for them and were forced westward until, entering the mountains by way of Cumberland Gap, they found a region where they could remain. They are not a religious people. In summer or autumn an open-air meeting is sometimes held in a meadow or in a grove. It is well attended -- too well, indeed, for almost invariably it ends in a fight, with shooting and somebody hurt. Mormons are active in this region and have made many proselytes. They do not preach nor do the converts adopt the polygamous features of the faith.

"The primitiveness of some of the people in the Tug river region is almost beyond belief. During the building of the Norfolk and Northern railroad the engineer of a passing construction train was hailed by a native, who asked him to stop and take him aboard. As the train continued on the fellow looked surprised and then indignant.

"'I'll teach you manners,' he said, and opened fire on the engineer with his Winchester. The engineer threw open the throttle, and he and the fireman dodged between the locomotive and tender, where they stayed until the train got out of range. Such happenings, repeated in one or another form, lent variety and excitement to railroad construction in this country, where the missionary had not arrived and the school master was not abroad."

-- New York Sun.

See the clipping

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

A traveler recounts a tale of two railroad detectives who, fleeing an ambush by Hatfield men, sought refuge in Devil Anse Hatfield's house and were protected under mountain hospitality customs once fed there. The piece also describes mountaineer gun culture, marksmanship, and feuding customs in the region.

El Paso Daily Herald · 10 September 1898 · page 8

THE HATFIELDS AT HOME.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

El Paso Daily Herald · El Paso, Tex.

This report describes the general character of feuding mountaineers, including their marksmanship, preference for ambush killing, and lack of religion. It offers background on the origins of mountain clans from post-Revolutionary War outlaws and includes an anecdote about a native shooting at a train engineer.

El Paso Daily Herald · 10 September 1898 · page 8

THE HATFIELDS AT HOME.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The report states that Tom Hatfield, a key figure in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, died while working as a day laborer on a farm in East Athens, New York, after being exiled from West Virginia. It notes he had previously worked at oil fields in Bradford, where his wife and baby had died, and that it took time for locals to learn his true identity.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 13 September 1898 · page 1

In der Fremde gestorben.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Huntington Advertiser · Huntington, W. Va.

A dispatch reports that Tom Hatfield, a member of the West Virginia Hatfield family whose feud with the McCoys became nationally famous, died near Athens, Pennsylvania after years working as a laborer under disguised identity. The account describes his poverty, the deaths of his wife and daughter, and the sentimental keepsakes he carried.

The Huntington Advertiser · 16 September 1898 · page 1

TOM HATFIELD DEAD. PASSED AWAY ON A FARM IN TOWANDA, PENNSYLVANIA.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Wheeling newspaper describes a running street fight that escalated into a shooting in which members of the McLaughlin party were killed, with the killers calmly surrendering afterward. The report notes the absence of police throughout and remarks that the affair had begun to resemble a Hatfield-McCoy style feud.

Wheeling Register · 17 September 1898 · page 8

WHERE WERE THE POLICE?

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · Mt. Sterling, Ky.

The article reports that Tom Hatfield, described as the last surviving principal of the Hatfield-McCoy feud and heir of 'Devil Anse' Hatfield, died peacefully in Towanda, Pennsylvania after being driven from Kentucky by the law. It recounts his quiet life as a laborer under a hidden identity, the deaths of his wife and daughter, and frames his passing as the symbolic end of the feud's violence.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Mt. Sterling Advocate · 20 September 1898 · page 1

HATFIELD DIES A PEACEFUL DEATH. Driven Out of Kentucky, He Expires in Pennsylvania.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · and 4 other papers

A Chicago Inter Ocean reporter recounts a story about two railroad detectives who, learning of an ambush, outwitted it by seeking shelter and food at Devil Anse Hatfield's fortified home. Bound by mountain hospitality customs, Hatfield was obliged to feed and protect them despite being their intended enemy, even guiding them safely out of the territory the next morning.

Griggs Courier · 22 September 1898 · page 7

HOW DEVIL ANSE WAS FOOLED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 4 papers
  • Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · 29 September 1898
  • The Republican · Oakland, Md. · 6 October 1898
  • The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D. · 15 October 1898
  • The Florence Tribune · Florence, Ariz · 29 October 1898

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

A West Virginia regiment marching to Gettysburg for monument dedication ceremonies includes about twenty Hatfields from Mingo County in Company K, nicknamed the 'Hatfield Rangers' due to their notorious feud with the McCoys. A corporal among them, credited with six deaths, declines to discuss the feud and insists the family seeks no further trouble.

Shepherdstown Register · 22 September 1898 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A civil engineer recounts a tale of two railroad detectives who, having learned the Hatfields planned to ambush them, instead rode straight to Devil Anse Hatfield's fortified home and sought refuge there under mountain hospitality customs. The story frames Devil Anse as the patriarch of a feared, armed clan guarding his home on Island Creek.

Evening Journal · 29 September 1898 · page 5

HOW DEVIL ANSE WAS FOOLED

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come