As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

November 1892

19 articles

Ceredo Advance · Ceredo, W. Va.

A Portsmouth man, C. G. Shults, is reported to own a Winchester rifle once belonging to Ellis Hatfield, described as the weapon used to murder Ellen McCoy while he was trying to rescue her aged parents from death. The piece muses whether the rifle's value is enhanced by its connection to the notorious feud.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Ceredo Advance · 2 November 1892 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A filler item recounts how a man named Hatfield met a stranger named McCoy at a Memphis hotel bar and, upon learning each other's names, simply shared another drink instead of fighting. The piece notes with relief that neither was from the feuding Kentucky families.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 10 November 1892 · page 8

When the Feud Was Forgotten

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The report states that the notorious Pike County, Kentucky desperado Phillips, who was involved in the Hatfield-McCoy feud and had allegedly killed many men, was reported killed in an affray in Logan County, West Virginia the previous Thursday. This item appears as one of several short telegraphic news briefs.

Alexandria Gazette · 12 November 1892 · page 3

TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A telegram from Charleston, West Virginia reports that Frank Phillips, a noted member of the McCoy faction from the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was shot and killed by G. G. Peters in Pike County, Kentucky. The report recalls Phillips' earlier fame as a feud participant who had killed several men.

Wheeling Register · 12 November 1892 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

This 1892 feature surveys eight major post-Civil War Kentucky feuds, including the Hatfield-McCoy war, noting that state intervention finally suppressed them. It reports that the region is now peaceful, with some feud participants dead, turned lawyers or businessmen, and the Hatfields imprisoned in the penitentiary.

Los Angeles Herald · 13 November 1892 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

PASSING OF THE FEUDS.

Last of the Tollivers, Cooleys, Hatfields and Their Kind.

See moreSee less

ALL EAST KENTUCKY IS AT PEACE.

Why the Mountainous Regions of the South Produced So Many Family Wars. The Topography Attracted That Sort of People and the War Demoralized Them.

THE Cooley gang is no more. The dispatch which gave this interesting information added this significant sentence: "People of this section [about Uniontown, Pa.] are breathing more freely now." In the Middle Ages in Italy, in the days of Saxon and Norman in England, or Gael and Saxon in Scotland, or Saxon and Celt in Ireland, this would have sounded natural enough. But why should there be a "gang" in peaceful Pennsylvania? Why feuds in Kentucky?

Well, it isn't easy to explain to a foreigner or even to an Atlantic coast Yankee, yet it is a fact that here and there in all the states which have mountainous regions, and in all the new states, a few feuds linger on in civilization's track as reminders of the barbarism of our distant forefathers. They are unique now and worthy of the newspaper reader's especial attention because of their rarity, though there was a time when they were so common that except where the station of the participants was high, as in the case of the Marmion-Douglas row, or where there was some frill of romance attached, as in the Montague-Capulet quarrel, the gossiping chroniclers of the day made no more mention of them than a newspaper nowadays does of a plain murder.

The general rule is that these feuds continue till all the desperate men on both sides are killed, or the state government comes in with overwhelming force and captures all the participants, or some peculiarly horrible tragedy creates such widespread disgust and rage that the parties to the feud abandon it and the country in a general panic. The Sutton-Taylor feud of Texas, probably the worst ever known in America, terminated in the first named way. Every man in it was killed (about a hundred in all) except John Wesley Hardin, and the state hanged him. The Hatfield-McCoy feud of Kentucky and West Virginia terminated by the second method. And the long feud in Kemper county, Miss., ended in a massacre of the Chisholm family and its supporters, which left nobody to keep up that side of the controversy.

No census has ever been taken of the feuds in eastern Kentucky. Those since the war, sufficient to interest the nation, have been eight in number. They were the Turner-Sizemore feud, in Knott county; the Strong and the Little feuds, in Breathitt county; the Martin-Tolliver war, in Rowan county; the Turner-Sowders feud, in Bell county; the Turner-Howard quarrel, in Hardin county; the Hatfield-McCoy feud, on the West Virginia border, in Pike county, and the French-Eversole war, in Perry county. They were no ten cent affairs. There was no pulling of pistols for show. The participators meant business every time. They terrorized entire counties, slew scores of people, drove hundreds more from home, broke up local courts, stood off the militia and cost the state hundreds of thousands of dollars before they were finally suppressed.

But the job was thoroughly done. There is peace through all the once disturbed region, and a recently published roll of the present condition of the survivors has about it a flavor of comedy. But the famous dead are many. Craig Tolliver is dead. Boone Logan and the Youngs are practicing law. Andy Johnson is a capitalist. The Yellow Creekers have become land speculators or gone west. Wils Jennings and the Hatfields are in the penitentiary. Joe Eversole has been killed. A saw log dispatched Jerry Little. "General" Sowders is a quiet citizen, and his old enemy, Alvis Turner, is slain. Wils Howard and Joe Henderson are awaiting trial. Talt Hall has been executed, and B. Fulton French is living quietly at Winchester, doing all that in him lies to provide legal defenses for his many old retainers who are under indictment.

To write a full and philosophical history of these feuds in the highland south would require a Buckle. The Appalachians send down a great tongue in a south southwest direction, forming a central mountain nucleus from Maryland to Alabama, from which the affluents of the Potomac and Ohio, of the Mississippi and all the streams which flow into the gulf and south Atlantic run rapidly down their rocky beds to every point of the compass. The result

THE HATFIELDS AT BAY.

is topographically a region about 400 miles wide and 800 miles long, destined by nature to be the last to be redeemed from nature's wilderness, and yet in the end to be the seat of a far more diversified industry than is possible to the lowlands.

To the region through all the century of 1760-1860 fled the criminals and the unfortunates of the more fertile lowlands. The worst class of Tories fled there after the revolution. Fraudulent and absconding debtors found refuge there. Hardy and honest hunters found their paradise there. Invalids and good men of daring natures found health and romance in the valleys. The result was a singularly varied population, and in no long time a sort of dumb war in politics and otherwise with the lowlanders. As slavery was strengthened on the fertile lands the mountaineers tended toward abolitionist views. On all economic issues they habitually opposed the lowland sentiment. And finally when the lowlands were almost unanimous for secession the mountaineers became almost unanimous for the Union.

The war "brought the thing to a head," as the local phrase goes, but the mountaineers had a few little matters of their own to settle. And they have settled them—very thoroughly for the most part. The participants, too, are settled—"planted" in fact. They made good soldiers, but didn't know when to quit fighting. From sire to son the passion for tumult and bloodshed was transmitted, and some of the most dangerous outlaws in the mountains have been boys under twenty, while most of the leaders in the greatest of the feuds have been under thirty years of age.

The Rowan county feud was the last and probably worst. It begun in an election quarrel between the Tollivers and Martins. Craig Tolliver, a blue eyed giant, led the Tolliver faction. The Martins had friends, but lacked leadership, and were almost exterminated. The Youngs were drawn into the quarrel as friends of the Tollivers, and the Logans were marked for destruction as friends of the Martins. That was Craig Tolliver's blunder, and led to his overthrow. As usual the forms of law assisted rather than hindered the crimes. Craig Tolliver had himself elected town marshal of Morehead, the county seat, and was afterward police judge. His canvass and election to the latter office show the character of the man. He made up his mind to become a candidate the day before the election, and at once notified his opponents of the fact. He also intimated that he wanted the office and intended to have it. The opposition took the hint and withdrew. Election day Tolliver took charge of the polls himself. When he closed the books in the afternoon fifty votes had been cast. Tolliver's election, it is hardly necessary to say, was unanimous. He could now issue warrants and make arrests at will. Crime followed crime with increasing brutality. The county was at Tolliver's mercy.

The state was compelled to interfere. Governor Knott invited the leaders to a conference at Louisville and a truce was effected. Down to that time the people of the rest of the state had been philosophically inclined to "let 'em fight it out among themselves;" but facts came to light which outraged the Kentuckian love of fair play and set the state in a rage. It was shown that there was no chivalry in it. Most of the killing was done from ambush. All sorts of treachery was practiced. Open fights rarely occurred, unless one side had big odds and the other side couldn't get away. Human life simply had no value, and there were hundreds of men in the mountains ready to accept employment as retainers for any man who was able to pay them for committing murder and to put up money to protect them afterward. Recently, in a trial of a murderer, one witness admitted that he had been offered $150 to kill another, but as the destined victim was "a big man in the neighborhood" he stood out for $250.

STANDING OFF A POSSE.

In 1887 Craig Tolliver had the two Logan boys assassinated by his posse. Then the county rose on him. Sheriff Hogg and Boone Logan, a cousin of the victims, led the volunteers who hunted him down and killed him and several of his followers. Now there is peace. Railroads run through Bell, Breathitt and Rowan counties. The mineral land syndicate has invaded every mountain nook. There are newspapers in Breathitt and Harlan, and three of them in Bell. The sale of whisky is forbidden by vote of the people themselves in most of the counties where feuds raged. The law is more respected, since violation of it means speedy arrest and severe punishment.

About the Pennsylvania gang there never was the slightest flavor of romance. The Cooley boys were outlaws pure and simple. They began by stealing hogs and chickens, went on to manufacture and sell illicit whisky, then fought to avoid arrest and next for revenge, and finally graduated as murderers. One by one they were killed or captured and imprisoned, till only Frank Cooley remained at large, with his pal, one Ramsey. Sheriff McCormick organized a picked posse to fight them to a finish. They got Frank surrounded and he sent five shots from his Winchester at the sheriff, but missed, though once he came so near that the wind of the ball knocked the sheriff down.

At length a bullet glanced from a stump near the outlaw and pierced his heart. Cooley staggered, and the sheriff rushed upon him and found him clinging to a sapling. In the final struggle, before he went down, Cooley discharged his Winchester twice; the bullets tore up the ground near his feet and the weapon fell out of his hands. As he lay upon the ground Sheriff McCormick spoke to him and said that he was sorry Cooley had to be killed, but that it was his own fault. The outlaw replied, "You did your duty," and a moment later he was dead. Ramsey was captured next day. A touch of comedy ended the play. On the person of Frank Cooley was found a letter from a well known dentist, which contained a request for Cooley's surrender. The dentist promised that if Cooley would surrender himself and permit himself to be delivered over to the sheriff he would get $1,200 of the reward, which he could use in defending himself in court. All the dentist asked for his trouble was $300.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A report from Charleston, W. Va., describes a shootout between followers of a Kentucky desperado named Phillips, tied to the Hatfield-McCoy feud, and a rival named G.G. Peters, with over 400 shots fired. Phillips was wounded in the thigh and lung and was believed to have died, though his death was not confirmed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Morning News · 13 November 1892 · page 2

A DESPERADO KILLED.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The report states that Frank Phillips, a notorious Kentucky desperado linked to the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was killed in a gun battle with G. G. Peters near the Pike-Logan county line. Hundreds of shots were exchanged, and Phillips reportedly died after being shot through the thigh and lung.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 13 November 1892 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

The report states that Frank Phillips, the Pike County outlaw involved in the Hatfield-McCoy war three years earlier, was killed by G. G. Peters and his followers in Lawrence County after a four-hundred-shot battle. It describes this as the end of Phillips's gang activity in the area.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 14 November 1892 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The World · Martinsburg, W. Va.

Bob Hatfield and Louisa Mullins allegedly tried to rob Jewish peddler Mose Winstein near Ben Creek on October 22, with Hatfield threatening him at gunpoint while Mullins urged him to kill the victim. Winstein claims he was rescued by John Gibson and Julius Tober before harm was done.

The World · 15 November 1892 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The World · Martinsburg, W. Va.

A desperado named Philips, wanted with a price on his head and linked to the Hatfield-McCoy feud, is reported to have died after a shootout with G. A. Peters near the Pike County, Kentucky/Logan County, West Virginia line. Hundreds of shots were exchanged before Philips was found shot through the thigh and lung, and he is believed to have died that same night.

The World · 15 November 1892 · page 1

REPORTED DEATH OF AN OUTLAW

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Breckenridge News · Cloverport, Ky.

This retrospective article surveys eight major Kentucky feuds, including the Hatfield-McCoy feud, noting their scale and death tolls compared to ordinary crime. It reflects on changing attitudes toward feuding, contrasting past leniency with current prosecution of feud leaders in court.

The Breckenridge News · 16 November 1892 · page 1

FOR GENERATIONS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Western Sentinel · Winston-Salem, N.C.

This report describes a deadly election-day brawl between the Garland and Harrell families in Mitchell County, North Carolina, unrelated to the actual Hatfield-McCoy feud. It invokes the Hatfields and McCoys only as a byword for violent family feuding, showing how famous the name had already become.

The Western Sentinel · 17 November 1892 · page 1

FIGHT AT THE POLLS. A Regular Hatfield-McCoy Time in Mitchell County.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Western Sentinel · Winston-Salem, N.C.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. reports that Frank Phillips, a notorious figure in the Hatfield-McCoy vendetta who had killed many men, was said to be dead from a feud between the Phillips and Peters factions in Logan County, Kentucky. The report is presented as unconfirmed news from the field.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 32 days later.

Wrong

The Western Sentinel · 17 November 1892 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pocahontas Times · Huntersville, W. Va.

A brief dispatch claims that Frank Phillips, a notorious member of the McCoy gang famous from the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was shot and killed by G. G. Peters in Pike County, Kentucky on a recent Tuesday. The item appears amid a jumble of unrelated local news and miscellany in the paper.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 32 days later.

Wrong

Pocahontas Times · 17 November 1892 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Penn's Grove Record · Penn's Grove, N.J.

A news digest reports that during a fierce battle in Pike County, Kentucky, a man named Phillips—described as a notorious desperado tied to the Hatfield-McCoy feud—was killed by G. G. Peters. The item notes Phillips had committed many crimes.

The Penn's Grove Record · 18 November 1892 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The item reports that Phillips, a notorious Pike County desperado involved in the Hatfield-McCoy feud with a bounty on his head and reportedly having killed many men, was said to have been killed in an affray in Logan County, West Virginia the previous Thursday. The report is presented as unconfirmed, using the phrase 'is reported to have been killed.'

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 31 days later.

Wrong

Shepherdstown Register · 18 November 1892 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wisconsin Afro-American · Milwaukee, Wis.

A traveler named Hatfield recounts meeting a stranger named McCoy in a Memphis billiard hall, neither related to the feuding Kentucky families. Instead of conflict, the two shared a friendly drink, illustrating how famous the feud names had become.

Wisconsin Afro-American · 19 November 1892 · page 3

An Interesting Meeting

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa. · and 3 other papers

This 1892 article surveys eight major Kentucky feuds, including the Hatfield-McCoy war, as part of a broader reflection on the region's history of lawlessness. It contrasts past government leniency toward feudsmen with the present prosecution of a feud leader in court, framing this as evidence of changing attitudes.

Freeland Tribune · 21 November 1892 · page 2

CONTINUED FOR GENERATIONS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me. · 2 November 1892
  • The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me. · 2 November 1892
  • Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va. · 2 November 1892

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

A Minden, Louisiana report describes a posse of 150 men hunting desperado Link Waggoner after he fatally shot William Holland, amid a separate unsolved killing of a man named Tuggle. The article notes the escalating violence 'rivals in every respect the Hatfield-McCoy feud that exists in Kentucky.'

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 24 November 1892 · page 6

A LOUISIANA VENDETTA.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come