As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

June 1891

9 articles

Orleans County Monitor · Barton, Vt. · and 1 other paper

This item opens by noting the Hatfield-McCoy feud may or may not be over, then pivots to telling the story of the Morton-Cummins feud in Texas as an example of how feuds typically end only when one family is wiped out. It recounts how the last survivors, Dan Morton and a Cummins, finally met and agreed to stop fighting since too few were left.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Fort Worth Gazette, 26 May 1891, The Southern Herald, 29 May 1891.

Orleans County Monitor · 1 June 1891 · page 3

THE END OF A FEUD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • · · 13 June 1891

In the story →

Paper unidentified

The article speculates that the Hatfield-McCoy feud may or may not be truly over, noting that such feuds historically only end when one family is wiped out. It then illustrates this point with an anecdote about the Morton-Cummins feud in Texas, where the last survivors finally made peace.

Paper unidentified · 2 June 1891 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE END OF A FEUD.

It Usually Comes When There Are Not Enough Survivors to Take Sides.

See moreSee less

The Hatfield-McCoy feud may be over, and it may not. In all the cases ever known the feud died only when one of the families did the same. The Morton-Cummins feud in Texas belonged to this class.

The only man left of those two families now is Dan Morton. Three years ago he was dealing faro in El Paso. His face is like leather, and he is about as tough. Fear is a thing he does not know. He will probably die in his boots, because men of that sort are never pleasant to have about, and the community revolts occasionally.

But, to go back. How the thing started doesn't matter especially. Probably in the same way that it ended—in a saloon quarrel. This much is known: A Cummins shot a Morton; then the thing went on with deadly regularity until some six or seven had been killed on either side. Finally there were only two Mortons and one Cummins left. The latter had just killed one of his opponents and he lit out for other parts and kept away for a good many months.

One day Cummins came back. Everybody was offering bets that Dan Morton would shoot him on sight. Cummins thought so, too, but he had come back to try and settle the thing peaceably if he could, otherwise if it had to be. The two met in the natural course of events, and both started to reach for their guns. Cummins said his say, though, before the other got the cinch on him.

"Dan," he said, "this thing's gone far enough, an' I reckon we might as well quit. There's only me left, an' you too. Now what's the use of it, anyway?"

It struck Dan sort of reasonably, and he put up his gun.

"Believe ye're about right," he said. With that the two went into the Red Front saloon, and in another ten minutes the two were patting each other on the back, and telling each other what a pity it was they hadn't known before what good fellows they both were. They kept feeling better and better.

"An' none of it need hev happened," said Morton, "ef your Tom hadn't shot Morton."

"He didn't do it," said Cummins.

"He did."

The denial was too much for Cummins.

"You lie!" he hissed, and then in a minute all the sworn friendship of the last half hour went to the four winds and forgetfulness, and those two closed in a deadly struggle. Each was trying to reach for the other's gun. They surged all over the saloon. No one interfered for a while.

Then the other Morton, who had not trusted the newly made reconciliation, and had kept close by, stepped up to the two, and putting his pistol to Cummins' head, literally shot his head all to pieces.

And that ended the feud. The other Morton was killed shortly afterward in an ordinary quarrel, and Dan is now the only one left.—Chicago Tribune.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The article speculates that the Hatfield-McCoy feud may or may not be over, noting that historically such feuds only end when one family is wiped out. It then recounts the Texas Morton-Cummins feud as an example, where the sole survivors on each side finally agreed to stop fighting.

Connecticut Western News · 3 June 1891 · page 1

THE END OF A FEUD.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Register reporter interviews Rev. A. M. Toler, a Hatfield relative, who claims newspapers have grossly exaggerated the feud's details. Toler begins recounting the feud's origin roughly ten to twelve years earlier, starting with a daughter of Randolph.

Wheeling Register · 9 June 1891 · page 5

THE TRUE INWARDNESS OF THE LONG AND BLOODY FEUD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Rev. A. M. Toler, related to the Hatfields by marriage, gives a reporter his account of how the feud began, centering on Johnson Hatfield's relationship with a McCoy daughter and a subsequent capture and retaliation. He also begins describing the election-day quarrel involving Ellison Hatfield that led to further violence.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Wheeling Register · 9 June 1891 · page 5

THE ORIGIN OF THE FEUD

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

This 1891 article recounts the feud's early history, including the capture of a McCoy, the fatal 1882 election-day stabbing and shooting of Ellison Hatfield by McCoy brothers, and the subsequent execution of three McCoys tied to a tree. It also briefly describes a later incident where a McCoy man was shot while fleeing after whipping a woman.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Wheeling Register · 9 June 1891 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

This social notices column reports that a Mr. D. Hatfield from Logan Court House was staying at the Hotel Bohler in Wheeling. The item casually refers to 'the land of the Hatfield and McCoy business,' showing the feud was already widely known by name.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 10 June 1891 · page 5

ABOUT PEOPLE

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

A brief filler item asserts that the marriage which supposedly ended the Hatfield-McCoy feud was not a failure. It offers no names or details, treating the feud's resolution as settled fact amid a column of odd marriage anecdotes.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 19 days later.

Wrong

The Cambria Freeman · 19 June 1891 · page 4

A WOMAN IN IT.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash.

In Rosalia, Washington, a man named Goff shot and killed Whitney Hart after catching him aiming a gun through a window. Hart, who claimed descent from the Hatfields of feud fame, had previously been tried with an accomplice for wounding Goff in a dispute over a mining claim.

Pullman Herald · 26 June 1891 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come