A warrant led to the arrest of eight Hatfields on McCoy complaint that they murdered Dave Stratton on May 13 near Brownstown. Though officials said Stratton fell from a train, the report suggests he was actually fleeing a U.S. Court summons and was killed either aboard the train or at a stopover, with his body placed on the tracks.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.
The item jokes that a locomotive has 'removed' one of the principals in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, sparing both families further bloodshed. It frames this accidental death as resolving the need for revenge among the McCoys and Hatfields.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 26 days later.
Wrong
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 4 June 1890 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Logan County Banner · Logan, W. Va.
This is a legal notice listing numerous tracts of land in Logan County, West Virginia, purchased from various individuals including Hatfield family members, warning all persons not to trespass on these properties. It is signed by an agent for J.D. Sheppard and threatens prosecution to the fullest extent of the law for violators.
The Logan County Banner · 5 June 1890 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.
Detective 'Kentucky Bill' Napier states that Anse Hatfield had offered money two years earlier to have Dave Stratton killed, and that Clay Bishop lured Stratton to Brownstown where he was later found dead. Napier also disputes claims that warrants against the Hatfields were sworn out for extradition purposes, saying instead they are wanted for suspected involvement in Stratton's death.
Wheeling Register · 12 June 1890 · page 1
THE DETECTIVE TALKS
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.
A detective known as 'Kentucky Bill' revealed that Anse Hatfield had offered $300 two years earlier to have Davis Stratton killed, with Clay Bishop luring him to West Virginia for the deed. He also disputes claims that warrants were issued to extradite the Hatfields to Kentucky.
Pittsburg Dispatch · 14 June 1890 · page 6
THE PRICE OF A HEAD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
A dispatch from Charleston, WV reports that earlier widely published claims of a reward offered by 'Bad Anse' Hatfield for the murderer of Dave Stratton were false, since none of the Hatfields were within sixty miles when Stratton was found dead. In an interview, Anse Hatfield states his family wants peace, has set aside their rifles for two years, but will never allow themselves to be extradited to Kentucky for trial.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 18 June 1890 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.
Detective Kentucky Bill claims Anse Hatfield had offered $300 two years earlier to have Dave Stratton killed, and that Clayton Bishop arranged to lure Stratton to his death near Brownstown. He also denies that warrants against the Hatfields were meant to extradite them to Kentucky, saying they were issued because of suspected involvement in Stratton's murder.
Martinsburg Independent · 21 June 1890 · page 4
The Killing of Dave Stratton.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Weekly Register · Point Pleasant, Va. W. Va.
A West Virginia newspaper column compares exaggerated newspaper reports about the Hatfield-McCoy feud favorably to the statements of former gubernatorial candidate Gen. Goff, calling his claims less true. It criticizes Goff for maligning the state after his 1888 election loss.
A dispatch from Huntington, W. Va. reports a fresh outbreak of feud violence in Logan county, in which Charles and James Justice (cousins of the Hatfield family) fought Hance McCoy, who was stabbed nine times but wounded both Justices with his revolver. The report also notes that Governor Fleming withdrew rewards for the capture of Frank Phillips, Jim McCoy, and nine others, fearing this might embolden the gang.