As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

May 1895

3 articles

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A Kansas City Journal piece marks the 22nd anniversary of the Bender murders' discovery, noting the crimes are famous in name but poorly understood in detail by most Kansans. It recounts the Benders' 1872 arrival in Labette County and settlement on a homestead near Cherryvale, setting up a fuller retelling of the case.

The Indianapolis Journal · 31 May 1895 · page 7

THE BENDER MURDERS TERRIBLE KANSAS CRIME RECALLED BY AN ANNIVERSARY

Fanilly's Disappearance. Kansas City Journal. Twenty-two years ago to-day Kansas was shocked from center to circumference by the discovery of the "Bender murders." It is more than probable that Kansas does not contain a child of ten years who is en tirely uninformed as to the general fact that jx. series of atrocious murders were once committed somewhere, by somebody, and that they are always spoken of as the "Bender murders." But, on the other hand, it is doubtful If any considerable number of Kansas people could relate any thing like a connected story of the crimes.

See moreSee less

Old things become new In time, and Inter est never flags in a thrice-told tale If the plot Is only thrilling enough. The "Bender murders" have few If any parallels in history. The series of mon ster crimes were committed In the midst of a peaceful, happy and prosperous coun try neighborhood. Human blood was spilled like water for a few paltry dollars, tr even for so small a price as the poor clothing worn by the murdered travelers. "Ven geance Is mine, salth the Lord," and now, from the lapse of years, it appears that all hope of human retribution must be con soled with that pledge , of the hereafter, for every effort to search out the mur derers and bring them to justice has re sulted in failure. The Benders drifted Into Labette county, from whither no one ever knew, early in the spring of 1872, and at once sought and "entered" a government homestead a few miles out from the town of Cherryvale. They chose a level bit of prairie land in a narrow valley, along which ran the rrain traveled road leading from Fort Scott, Osage Mission and other points to Inde pendence, the seat of the United States land office. They plowed up a few acres, planted a few fruit trees and constructed a low. one-story frame house, about 14x21 feet In dimensions. This house was divided by a thin board partition, and underneath the rear part was dug a cellar about four feet deep, which had no stairway, but which could be entered by a trap door In the floor of the rear room. The front room was fitted with rough shelves, and con tained a small stock of supplies, while across the front of the outside a straggling sign announced that groceries were for sale within, and that entertainment could foe hod for man or beast. The road ran within a few feet of the front door, and It was understood that the Benders did quite a thriving business with the many wayfarers who were constantly passing to and fro. There were four persons in this family of murderers, two men and two women. Old man Bender was a German and could not speak a word of English. He was a morose and savage vlsaged man who seldom spoke, even In his own tongue. His wife 'was also German, but she had mastered enough English to attend to the store. Next came Kate Bender, the only daughter of the old

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 1 other paper

This 1895 article recounts how the Bender family arrived in Labette County in spring 1872, built a small house doubling as a store and inn along a well-traveled road, and describes the four family members—old man Bender, his wife, daughter Kate, and hired man John Geiger. It notes that the murders apparently began soon after they settled, though neighbors suspected nothing at the time.

The Indianapolis Journal · 31 May 1895 · page 7

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb. · 8 May 1908

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A newspaper looking back on the case describes the Bender family's arrival and the string of unexplained disappearances that began almost as soon as they settled on their claim in 1872. It quotes an earlier local writer detailing several named victims who vanished while traveling, before any suspicion fell on the Benders.

The Indianapolis Journal · 31 May 1895 · page 7

LOST NO TIME. Though none suspicioned this family of being wholesale murderers, it is evident that they commenced their awful work almost Immediately after locating upon the claim. During the fall of 1S72 and through the winter and spring succeeding a number of person disappeared as completely as though carried from the face of the earth. Search revealed nothing of their where abouts, and while the people met together and shook their heads ominously and talked all manner of theories, not a breath of suspicion was wafted toward the Benders.

See the clipping