As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

September 1879

16 articles

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A New Mexico sheriff transports a boy whose father was murdered at the alleged instigation of a woman believed to be the long-sought Kate Bender, using the alias Dora Hesser. The story recounts how the woman and two male accomplices murdered the boy's father for his money, with the body exhumed and a confession obtained from one conspirator.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Daily Globe · 1 September 1879 · page 1

THE BENDER CRIMES REVIVED BY A NEW MEXICO TRAGEDY

Flies and Other Casualties!. A NEW MEXICO TBAGEDY. Special Telegram to the Globe.] S T. LOOTS, Aug. 31Sheriff Whitehitt, of Grant county, Ne Mexico, is in St. Louis en route for Indianapolis, whither he is taking a bright niue year old boy named Josie Granger. Th lad id a nepbow of Bishop Granger, of Indianapolis, and the sheriff is confident that the boy's father, who was the bishop's brother, was mnrdered at the insti gation of none other than Kate Bender, who HJX years ago was tho most odious woman in the United State-). Th sheriff of Grait coumy s.iys Wm. G. Granger, father of tue hoy now in hia charge, married a wife in Cilifornia, and when she died moved with

See the clipping

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A woman called Dora, arrested with her son William and Parson Young for murdering an old man for his money, is increasingly believed to be the fugitive Kate Bender; she admits her real name is Kate and a former schoolmate identifies her. Silverware marked from a Kentucky hotel was found among her belongings, and she awaits trial while her young son is placed in Bishop Granger's care.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Daily Globe · 1 September 1879 · page 1

KATE BENDKB. She acknowledges that ber real name is Kate, and she knows a great deal about the Bonder murdern. A young man who went to school with Kate Bender when she wui about 1G years old, visited Dora in jail and .sitivtly identified her as Kuf-v I her trunk were touud about finCO worth of sii ^erware, most of it murked "Gait hom:e, Iteutucliy." Tb womau is still in j^ilaid Will soon be tried. Meanwhile the sheriff nteuds to give the little boy Jt ne, who is a vejy amiable and intelligent child, and who gives a cr-ipuic pcoonut of tho murder, in charge of Bishop Gianger.

See the clipping

The Cincinnati Daily Star · Cincinnati, Ohio

A newspaper brief reports that a woman believed to be notorious Kansas murderer Kate Bender has been arrested in New Mexico. She is accused, with the help of two men, of murdering her husband William F. Granger, brother of a bishop in Indianapolis.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Cincinnati Daily Star · 1 September 1879 · page 4

A wo ran believed to be the notorious Kate Bender, who committed so many mur ders in Kansas, is under arrest in New Mex ico. She, with the assistance of two men, had murdered her husband, Wm. F. Gran ger, a brother of Bishop Granger, of In

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Grant County, New Mexico sheriff claims that a woman known as Dora Rosser, implicated in the murder of William Granger, is actually the notorious Kate Bender. The report recaps the original Bender family murders in Kansas and notes it was never confirmed whether the family was lynched or escaped.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 1 September 1879 · page 1

BLOODY KATE BENDER FOUND AT LAST.

A Horrible Crime In New Mexi co Keveul* Her Whereabout*. St. August SO.—Sheriff White* hill, of <»rant county, New Mexico, is iu St. Iiouis, en route for Indianapolis. j whither he U taking a bright nine year old boy, named Joaie Granger. The lad is the nephew of Bishop (iranger, of In dianapolis, and the Sheriff is confident that the boy's father, who w as the Bishi op's brother, fit murdered at the instii gation of none other than Kate Bender, 1 who six years ago was tha most odionn i woman in the I'nited Stats, it will re quirtno effort on the part of the reader to call to mind the Bender family, who

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A woman called Dora, held in jail after being implicated in an unrelated murder plot, is increasingly believed to be Kate Bender; a childhood schoolmate reportedly identifies her, and silverware and a photograph are offered as evidence. The report details how 'Dora' and accomplices killed an old man for his money, with suspicion of her Bender identity growing afterward.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 1 September 1879 · page 1

FOUND AT LAST.

<lo the killing, the object being one ot plunder. Hh led the otfioeri to the scene of the murder, and the body wax exhumed. Since then the belief ha* been growing that Mora in Kate Ben der. She nek now ledge* that her name in Kate, and she know* a great deal about the Benders. A young man who went to school with Kale Bender when she wjw alwdit nix teen yearn old visited Dura in jnil, and positively identified her as Kate. In her trunk wan found nUxit $.*sK) worth of silver ware, most of it marked "tialt House, Kentucky."

See moreSee less

The sheriff has her picture, and it represents a woman alsiut thirty vears old, vith full, heavy fai-e, laive lower jaw, very small eyet and a month of a Virago.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A New Mexico murder case involving William Granger's killing by his son and an accomplice led to the arrest of a woman known as Dora Elesser, who had married the victim. Silverware found in her trunk prompted claims she was actually the notorious fugitive Kate Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 2 September 1879 · page 4

Fort Smith, Arkansas. A second marriage took place there, and Josle was the Issue. lie took Into his family as nurse and servant a young woman who had been a domestic in a hotel, and who went by the name of Dora Elesser. The family moved to Grant county, New Mexico, and Dora went along. The second wife died, and on the 16th of last September Grange married Dora. Just three weeks after that he was entered into the mountains by hl3 own son, William, and a man named Parson Young, and the boy fired a bullet from a need'e gun through the old man's brain.

See moreSee less

The body burled, and the murderers divided about $5,if>o. The whole party was arrested, and the old man's clothes were found chopped to nie >es. William confessed the fflflrddf and sho.veu where the body was burled. Since then Dor* has been recognized as the notorious Kate Bender. In her trunk was found about $500 woith 01 silverware marked "Gait House." <i, W. Hillman, a merchant of Lawrence, Kunsas, last December Insured his life ror $25,o<hv?for $10,000 in the New York Mutual, for $10,000 tn the New York Life and for $5,000 in the Connecticut Mutual. Last March Hlllman and J. H. Brown, his partner, broke up their busine s in Lawrence and started to ride to Wichita. On the way thither, as Brow a says, Hlllman was accldently shot and killed

See the clipping

Catoctin Clarion · Mechanicstown, Md.

A short item states that Kate Bender, of the notorious Kansas murder family, has been found and arrested in New Mexico, where she had married and settled down. It notes the nationwide excitement over her capture, referencing the ongoing manhunt for the Benders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Catoctin Clarion · 4 September 1879 · page 4

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A miscellany column reports that Kate Bender has been captured again, this time in New Mexico, and predicts she will likely be hanged for murder. The item wryly hopes this will save the cost of extraditing her.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 5 September 1879 · page 2

GENERAL NOTES.

Kate Bender has beea captured again, this time in New Mexico, where she will in all likelihood be hung for murder. It is to be hoped that the etpenre of bringing her back well be saved iu

See the clipping

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A press report relays a New Mexico sheriff's claim to have identified the notorious Kate Bender as a woman named Mrs. Dora Denenger, implicated in a murder case involving her stepson. The report presents supporting details but frames the identification as unverified, per the headline's denial.

Daily Globe · 5 September 1879 · page 1

NOT KATE BENDER. LITTLE ROCK, Ark., Sept. 4.The press agent at Fort Smith telegraphs as follows: Sheriff Whitehall, of New Mexico, claims, in the St. Louis papers, to have discovered the no torious Kate Bender in the person of the al leged murderess as Mrs. Dora Denenger. In support of his belief be adduces many plausi ble 1 a-tioa'are. Tht he is on the untiring scent, thniollowing statements will amply prove Joseph Sprak, tho former husband of said Mrs Denenger, resides in this city. He says that he married Dora HesBer-ta Dayton, Ohio, in 1868 and in 1870 moved with her to this place.'

See moreSee less

They lived here during the period of the Ben der tragedies. In 1875 he obtained a divoico from her on the ground of abandonment. She afterwards went to work as a cook for Denen ger, and in May, 1878, went with him to Nbw Mexico. She is charged with instigating Denenger son to murder his father. Willie Denenger has written here for evidence of his father's crueltyMe3f and admitted killingohis father ico Malone, wh recently by shooting him through the head. He is also aNe a ji JJ

See the clipping

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

Sheriff Whitehill describes the arrest of a gang for murdering Granger over his modest estate, found sharing a bed with bloody garments of the victim. He speculates that the female suspect, Dora, a heavyset woman of about thirty, might actually be Kate Bender, wanted for the earlier Kansas murders.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Memphis Daily Appeal · 5 September 1879 · page 1

a change ot venue trom tirant county to Don Ana county, where the jury will be all Mexicans. The trial is set for No vember, but Sheriff Whitehill has sus picion that they will be taken and lynched before he returns. The sheriff -has the por traits with him of Granger, the victim, and his alleged murderer. Dora is a great fat, coarse specimen of femininity, about thirty years old, and the sheriff says he believes she is none other than Eate Bender, associ ated in the murder of York and other travel ers in Kansas.

See moreSee less

He: says there are sixteen murderers confined in the "jail of Grant county. Mr. Whitehill leaves With Josie Granger for the east to put him in charge of his relatives. He is a bright little fellow, and was sleeping very soundly when the Jiepub Heart reporter saw him, about ten o'clock last night. The sheriff has the gold watch of the bov'a father along With him, which he will deliver to the little son when he parts with him. Josey has a good, square head, while the head of his half-brother Willy, the sher iff says, slopes to an angle over his heavy , browed eyes."

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Fort Smith press dispatch rebuts Sheriff Whitehall's claim to have found Kate Bender in a New Mexico murder suspect named Dora Hesser Deninger. It cites her ex-husband's testimony establishing her separate identity and history, including her own alleged crime of inciting her son to kill his father.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Daily Globe, 1 September 1879, Wheeling Register, 1 September 1879, Wheeling Register, 1 September 1879.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 5 September 1879 · page 1

The Notorious Kate Bender. Little Kock, September 4.?The press agent at Fort Smith telegraphs as follows: Sheriff Whitehall, of New Mexico, claims in the St. Louis papers to have discovered the notorious Kate Bender in the person of an alleged murderess, known as Mrs. Dora Hesser Donenger. Iu support ol liis belief he adduces many plausible par-' ticulars. That he is on the wrong scent, the lollowing statements will amply prove: JoBeph Sprall, the former husband ol the said Mrs. Deninger, who resides in this

See the clipping

Chariton Courier · Keytesville, Mo. · and 2 other papers

A Cincinnati Enquirer special reports that a New Mexico sheriff believes a woman known as Dora Hesser, implicated in the death of William F. Granger, is actually Kate Bender of the notorious Kansas murder family. The article recaps the Bender case and notes it has always been unclear whether the family was lynched or escaped and scattered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Chariton Courier · 6 September 1879 · page 1

lieved to be the Original Kate llender. Special to the Cincinnati Enquirer. St. Louis, August 30. Sheriff Wliile hill of Grant County, New Mexico, is in St. Louis, en route for Indianapolis, whither he is taking a bright 9-year-old boy, named Josie Granger. The lad is thenephewof Bishop Granger of Indian apolis, and the Sheriff is confident that the boy's father, who was tho Bishop's brother, was murdered at the instiga tion of none other than Kate Bender, who six years ago was the most odious woman in the United States. It will re quire no effort on the part of the reader to call to mind the Bender family, who

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas · 12 September 1879
  • Sharp County Record · Evening Shade, Ark. · 2 October 1879

Lexington Weekly Intelligencer · Lexington, Mo.

A brief newspaper note claims Kate Bender, one of the fugitive Benders, has been found again, this time in New Mexico. No details or confirmation are given.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Lexington Weekly Intelligencer · 6 September 1879 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The item reports that a false claim identifying the notorious Kate Bender as a woman named Mrs. Dora Hesse-Denger in New Mexico has been debunked, citing her actual ex-husband's account of her verified whereabouts since 1868. It notes the Bender family murderers remain undiscovered nine years after the crimes, despite numerous false sightings of Kate Bender.

CorrectionThis set right 8 earlier articles: Daily Globe, 1 September 1879, The Cincinnati Daily Star, 1 September 1879, Evening Star, 2 September 1879, Catoctin Clarion, 4 September 1879, The Iola Register, 5 September 1879, Memphis Daily Appeal, 5 September 1879, Chariton Courier, 6 September 1879, Lexington Weekly Intelligencer, 6 September 1879.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 8 September 1879 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The New Northwest · Portland, Or.

A woman arrested in Little Rock, Arkansas on suspicion of being Kate Bender of the notorious murder family has been proven to be an entirely different person. The brief item is embedded within a miscellany of unrelated general news items.

The New Northwest · 11 September 1879 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Arizona Silver Belt · Globe City, Ariz.

A reporter questions a witness who claims to recognize a woman named Mrs. Granger as Kate Bender, based on physical features and a suspicious story about retrieving a dead man's clothes. The woman denies being Kate Bender, while the sheriff dismisses rumors that the Benders have already been hanged and confirms the reward for their capture remains active.

Arizona Silver Belt · 12 September 1879 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping