A Labette County detective arrested Reuben Bloomfield in Danville, Illinois, charging him with the murder of Henry Route near the old Bender homestead about two years earlier. Before he could be brought back for trial, Bloomfield reportedly killed himself with strychnine shortly after his arrest.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 16 days later.
Wrong
The Emporia News · 6 February 1874 · page 2
ONE OF THE BENDER FIENDS.
able to lv before the readers. In April, 1S72. Route started with bis own team from tbe neighborhood of the Bender murders ia Labette county in company with Bloom neid, witn tns ostensible purpose
The report details the disappearance of Henry Route near the Bender murder site in 1872, the later discovery of his slashed coat and mutilated body, and the arrest of his traveling companion Bloomfield as the suspected killer. Bloomfield is said to have profited from stolen money and land obtained from Route before being apprehended near Dansville.
The Emporia News · 6 February 1874 · page 2
Time passed away and no tidinsrs came of Route whose wife vet lived 'in Vermilion Co. Sometima in the sumer Route's coat waa ound on Biz liill creek, in Labette county, cut and slashed bv a knife in several places, together with his hat, but no trace of his body. . The bat, and part of coat was sent to Mrs. Route who identified tho ana oeuevea tne coat rrom its tex ture to have been her hnahanv The body was found in Cow lev
A man named Bloomfield, when arrested, asked to change clothes and is believed to have taken poison at that time; he died before an antidote could be administered. The report further states it was now established that Bloomfield had built the Bender house, arranged the screen used to disable victims, and lived there during the murders.
The Emporia News · 6 February 1874 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The report claims a man named Bloomfield, linked to a missing Henry Route near the Bender property, fled after acting suspiciously with Route's money and team. It describes the gruesome discovery of Route's slashed clothing and scavenger-ravaged remains in Cowley county, implying Bloomfield was Bender's accomplice who later took strychnine to escape justice.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
New York Dispatch · 22 February 1874 · page 2
THE ASSISTANT OF BENDER. HE CHEATS THE GALLOWS BY TAKING STRYCHNINE.
TAKING STRYCHNINE. Henry Route lived near Cherryville, in Labette county, Kansas, and not very far from the Bend er shanty. Last Spring, Mr. Route started with his team, in .company with a man named Bloomfield, to go out west, to Cowley county, for the purpose of taking up some land. Notfi ing more was seen of Boute after he left the Bender neighborhood. But some time in May, Bloomfield returned with Route’s team, which fie said he had obtained for some land he had traded to Route in Cowley county. His con duct excited suspicion. He had been observed to fie in possession of considerable money, and
A man named Bloomfield, arrested near Danville, calmly went along with officers but secretly took strychnine and died before reaching town. The report claims it is now established that he helped build the Bender house and lived there during the murders.
r It is now established that Bloomfield was en -3 gaged in building the Bender house—arranged f the screen in front of which the victims wore placed in order to dispatch them, and was an - inmato of the house for some months during > the scenes of the terrible murders which st ; shocked the civilized world, and mado Labottl f county so notorious.