Chief Justice McDonald impounded original grand jury papers in the baseball scandal after learning former state's attorney Hoyne had obtained copies before leaving office. Judge Landis vowed federal action if any evidence was found tampered with or missing.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 December 1920 · page 10
is no ‘scandal and nothing wrong.” Federal Judge K. M. Landis, baseball commissioner, when informed of the affair by President Johnson of the American league, said that if it was found any of the evidence had been tampered with or was missing, federal action would be taken against the guilty persons. ‘^Baseball is going to be cleared of gamblers and there is no one who will be allowed to interfere” said Judge Landis. v Mr. Replogle tonight said he had acted under Mr. Hoyne’s order and could not say what use had been made of the papers after they left his hands.
See moreSee less
Thomas E. Nash, atforney for George \\ eav'er, one of the White Sox players indicted on a charge of accepting a. bride in connection with the 1919 world series, said that the original evidence was in court last Friday, as he had seen it at that time.
The report discusses the state of the Chicago White Sox heading into 1921 after eight players were indicted in the gambling scandal, noting the team was 'shattered' by the grand jury action. It details specific roster gaps, including the need for a new third baseman to replace Buck Weaver and a shortstop to replace Swede Risberg.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 December 1920 · page 10
At the time that eight White Sox wore indicted and Comiskey's team was shattered, stories were pyi.ited quoting fellow magnates as stating ,hey would help out Comiskey. It was issumed from this that every club in .lie circuit would sell to Comiskey for i. fair price a first-class athlete. Maybe the magnates will get busy in lomlskey’s behalf at the coming meet ng or shortly afterward. If they do, :he Sox may go into the combat of iD21 tonsiderably patched up, but well able :o present a stout defense and a smash ng attack.
See moreSee less
But if nothing is done, ;hen the 1921 White Sox apparently are loomed to the second division. The catching staff is the only White Sox department that was not. shattered ly the grand jury action in Chicago, tt still embraces the wonderful ilay Schalk and the necessary quota of valuable assistants. But Comiskey must ?et new cogs for his machine in tt3 tvorv other division. NEEL) NEW Hi IK I) SAttVKK
With Buck Weaver, Gandil, Jackson, Felsch, Cicotte and Williams all gone due to the scandal, Comiskey must find replacements at third base, shortstop, first base, and in the pitching staff. The team's remaining players are described as mostly past their prime, leaving the Sox's pennant chances in serious doubt.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 8 December 1920 · page 10
NEED NEW THIRD SACKER
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Chief Justice McDonald seized and impounded grand jury evidence in the baseball scandal after learning that outgoing state's attorney MacLay Hoyne had obtained copies of the papers shortly before leaving office. Hoyne denied wrongdoing, saying he merely wanted copies for his own files, while the records will remain sealed until the trial of the eight indicted White Sox players.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 8 December 1920 · page 5
CHIEF JUSTICE McDONALD ORDERS GRAND JURY TRANSCRIPTS TO BE IMPOUNDED FOR USE AGAINST MEN
®d For U*o Against Man * ' (AnwtaM Km,) CHICAGO. Deo. 7—Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald sblaed arand Jury tvldence In the baseball scandal today, following discovery that copies of papers In the case had .been obtained by MacLay Hoyne. state's attorney, shortly before hla retirement from of fice {Monday. All i of the original .papers were pined over to the Judge, who ordered em Impounded by the clerk until tho its of elaht "White Sox p’ayers who lie Indicted, comd to trial, dge Robert Crowe, who succeeded Hoyne aa state's attorney, ordered nvestlgatlon after Hartley Replogle er assistant atate's attorney, who ucted the baaeball Investigation notified Judge McDonald thnt Mr.
See moreSee less
no had demanded Copies o» tbs pa •> i last Trlay. ' " r. Hoyne later said he had asked the records simply to have coplea de to ho put In the cases 1n his of for which he wss responsible and ,t the copies were there now, sealed As outgoing' state’s attorney, I was Responsible for all of the pappra,” said -Mr. Hoyne, "and I, ordered Mr. Replogle to tarn them over to my ' secretary. Mr. Replogle, as assistant state's at torney, of course, had to Alias ordered. There is no 'scandal' sad nothing wrong." Federal^Tudge Ki K. Landis, baseball commissioner, when Informed of the
Judge Landis stated that if any evidence in the Black Sox case was found to have been tampered with or was missing, federal action would be taken against those responsible. An attorney for indicted player George Weaver claimed he had seen the original evidence in court the previous Friday.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 8 December 1920 · page 5
Roanehe. Thsnksglvinfr day. affair byPreslUent’ Jo’.-n ton or tlm American League, Bald tliiit If It wan found any of tlia evidence had been tampered with or va$ mi ming federal action, wouli^ be takc'ii against 'the guilty _person*. "Bhsebgll Is. gains It be cleared of gamblers nnd there 1x^9 one who will be allowed to Interfere." said Judge Landis. Mr. Replogle tonight said he,lind acted under Mr. Hoyne's orders and could not say what use had been made of the papers after tjjey left his hands. Thomue B. Nash, attorney , for George Weaver, one of the White So., p.ayet-s Indicted on a charge , of accepting a bribe in connection with the 1>19 world series said that theoriginal evidence was in court last Friday, as ho had seen It at that time.
Chief Justice McDonald seized the grand jury evidence in the baseball scandal after learning that outgoing State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne had obtained copies before leaving office. The papers were ordered sealed until the trial of the eight indicted White Sox players, while Hoyne denied wrongdoing and Judge Landis warned of federal action if evidence had been tampered with.
Norwich Bulletin · 8 December 1920 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
SEIZED BASEBALL SCANDAL GRAND JURY EVIDENCE
Chicago, Dec. 7—Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald seized grand jury evidence in the baseball scandal today following discovery that copies of papers in the case had been obtained by Maclay Hoyne, states attorney, shortly before his retirement from office Monday.
See moreSee less
All of the original papers were turned over to the judge who ordered them impounded by the clerk until the cases of eight White Sox players who were indicted come to trial.
Judge Robert Crowe, who succeeded Mr. Hoyne as state's attorney, ordered an investigation after Hartley Replogle, former assistant state's attorney, who conducted the baseball investigation, notified Judge McDonald that Mr. Hoyne had demanded copies of the papers last Friday.
Mr. Hoyne later said he had asked for the records simply to have copies made to be put in the cases in his office, for which he was responsible and that the copies were there now, sealed up.
"As outgoing state's attorney, I was responsible for all of the papers," said Mr. Hoyne, "and I ordered Mr. Replogle to turn them over to my secretary. Mr. Replogle, as assistant state's attorney of course had to do as I ordered. There is no 'scandal' and nothing wrong."
Federal Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, baseball commissioner, when informed of the affair by President Ban Johnson of the American league, said that if it was found any of the evidence had been tampered with or was missing federal action would be taken against the guilty persons.
"Baseball is going to be cleared of gamblers and there is no one who will be allowed to interfere," said Judge Landis.
Mr. Replogle tonight said he had acted under Mr. Hoyne's orders and could not say what use had been made of the papers after they left his hands.
The attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicted on a charge of accepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 world series, said that the original evidence was in court last Friday, as he had seen it at that time.
Chief Justice McDonald impounded original grand jury papers in the World Series scandal after learning that outgoing State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne had obtained copies shortly before leaving office. The evidence will remain sealed until the trial of the eight indicted White Sox players.
New Britain Herald · 8 December 1920 · page 8
Retiring States' Attorney Hoyne. j Chicago. Dec. 8. Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald seized grand Jury evidence In the world'i series baseball scandal yesterday following discovery that copies of papers In the case had been obtained by Maclay Hoyne. State's Attorney, shortly before his retirement from office Monday. All of the original papers were turned over to the judge, who ordered then Impounded by the clerk until the case of eight White Sox players who were Indicted come to trial. Judge Robert Crowe, who succeeded Mr. Hoyne aa State's Attorney, order ed an Investigation after Hartley Replogle.
See moreSee less
former Assistant State's At torney, who conducted the baseball in vestigation, notified Judge McDonald that Mr. Hoyne had demanded copies of the papers last Friday. Mr. Hoyne later said he had asked for the records simrf y to have copies made to be put In the cases in his of fice, for which he was responsible, and that the copies were there now.sealed up. . Thomas E. Nash attorney for George Weaver, one of the WThite Sox players Indicted on a char re of accepting a bribe In connection with the 1919 world's series, said that the arlgiral evidence was In court last Friday, as he had seen It at that time.
Chief Justice McDonald seized the grand jury evidence in the Black Sox scandal after learning outgoing State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne had obtained copies before leaving office. New State's Attorney Crowe launched an investigation, while Hoyne denied wrongdoing and Judge Landis warned of federal action if evidence had been tampered with.
New-York Tribune · 8 December 1920 · page 14
Evidence in Ball Scandal Is Seized By Presiding Judge
Federal Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, baseball commissioner, when informed of the affair by President Ban Johnson of the American League said that if it was found any of the evidence had been tampered with or was missing Federal action would be taken against the guilty persons. "Baseball is going to be cleared of gamblers, and there is no one who will be allowed to interfere," said Judge Landis. Thomas E. Nash, attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicted on a charge of accepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 world's series, said that the original evidence was in court last Friday, as he had seen it at that time. ? ?. -? ? ?
Chicago prosecutor Hartley Replogle admits he gave copies of grand jury evidence, including sworn statements and exhibits, to Hoyne's secretary George Kenney before Judge McDonald ordered the rest impounded. Replogle had earlier accused Kenney of trying to help the defense of indicted White Sox players by gathering inside information on the case against them.
Evening Star · 8 December 1920 · page 28
grand jury went ahead with its work. At that time it was said that Replogle openly charged Kenney. Hoyne's secretary, with attempting to aid the defense of some of the indicted White , Sox player*! by obtaining "inside in- ' formation as to the strength of the . case against them." ' Iloync is reported as being too ill at his home to answer questions. "The I j entire dies were turned over to me." '. ! he said. "They are sealed and placed;1 : in my vault and they will remain there.
See moreSee less
There are certain statements in them I have never seen. What do I care about Ran Johnson!" Judge Landis refused to discuss the matter, and Robert K. Crowe, who has .lust succeeded Hoyne as state's ati torney. alHo declined to make any I , comment at this tim*..- Ban Johnson j' .says Hoyne is out of office and has i 1 . no business whatever with the court ' ' records, and demands to know for i ' whet reason lie secured them. '
Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald impounded the original grand jury papers in the World Series scandal after learning that retiring State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne had obtained copies before leaving office. Hoyne claimed he only wanted copies for his own files and denied any wrongdoing, while new State's Attorney Robert Crowe ordered an investigation into the matter.
The New York Herald · 8 December 1920 · page 12
Charles A. McDonald seised Grand Jury c vidence In the world's series baseball c candal to-day following discovery that optes of papers In the case had been btalned by Maclay Hoyne, State's Atorney. shortly before his retirement rom office Monday. All of the original apers were turned over to the Judge i-ho ordered them Impounded by the lerk until the cases of eight White Sox layers who were Indicted come to trial. Judge Robert Crowe, who succeeded Ir. Hoyne as State's Attorney, ordered n Investigation after Hartley Replogle, ormer Assistant State's Attorney, who
Commissioner Landis declared baseball would be cleared of gamblers and warned that federal action would follow if any evidence in the Black Sox case had been tampered with or was missing. An attorney for indicted player George Weaver disputed claims about the evidence's whereabouts, contradicting officials who had handled the grand jury documents.
The New York Herald · 8 December 1920 · page 12
and L<egendre at end. V . i Informed of the affair by Ban Johnson. president of the American League, 6aid that If It was fou?d any of the 1 evidence had been tampered with or was missing Federal action would be taken I aga nst the guilty persons, i "Baseball is going to be cleared of gamblers, and there Is no one who will I be allowed to interfere," said Judge Landls. Mr. Replogle to-night said he had i acted under Mr. Hoyne's orders and could not say what use had been made of the papers after they left his handa Thomas E.
See moreSee less
Nash, attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players Indicted on a charge of accepting a bribe .n connection with the 1919 world's series, said that the original evidence was In court last Friday, as he had seen It at that^Tme.
Chief Justice McDonald reviewed evidence after learning retiring state's attorney MacLay Hoyne had obtained copies of papers in the Black Sox case; the originals were ordered impounded until the trial of the eight indicted White Sox players. Judge Landis warned of federal action if any evidence had been tampered with or was missing.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 8 December 1920 · page 12
Papers to Files» > Chicago. Dec. 7.—Chief Justice Char : les A. McDonald reviewed the evidence ! in the baseball scandal Tuesday follow ing discovery that copies of papers in the case had been obtained by MaeLay Hoyne. state's attorney, shortly before his retirement from office on Monday. ! All of the original papers were turn ed over to the judge, who ordered them impounded by the clerk until the cases of the eight White Sox players who were indicted come to trial. Judge Robert Crowe, who succeeded Mr. Hoyne as state's attorney, ordered an investigation after Hartley former assistant state's attorney, who conduct ed the baseball investigation, notified Judge McDonald that Mr.
See moreSee less
Iloyne had demanded copies of the papers last Fri day. George T. Kenney, private secretary to Mr. Hoyne, ordered Mr. Replogle to surrended the papers, the latter told the chief justice. Mr. Replogle said he refused until Mr. Hoyne personally or dered the copies, Mr. Kenney said he gave the copies to Mr. Hoyne's stenographer to be deliver ed to Mr. Hoyne at his home. Thomas E. Nash, attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicted on a charge of accepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 world's ser ies, said that the original evidence was in court last Friday, as he had seen it at that time. Mr. Hoyne said he had asked for the records simply to put them in the cases in his office, for which he was respon sible, and that they were there now, sealed up. "There is no 'scandal' and nothing wrong," said Mr. Hoyne. Federal Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, baseball commissioner, when in formed of the affair by President Ban Johnson, of the American league, said that if it was found any of the evidence had been tampered with or was missing federal action would be taken against the guilty persons. "Baseball is going to be cleared of gamblers and no one will be allowed to interfere," said Judge Landis.
Chief Justice McDonald seized evidence in the baseball scandal after learning that former state's attorney MacLay Hoyne obtained copies of case papers shortly before leaving office. The papers were ordered impounded until the trials of the eight indicted White Sox players, amid conflicting accounts over how the copies were obtained and Hoyne's denial of any wrongdoing.
The Bismarck Tribune · 8 December 1920 · page 2
INVESTIGATION OF HOYNE STAND WILL BE MADE
Chicago. Dec. 8. Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald seized tiie evi dence in the "baseball scandal follow ing discovery that copies ot papers iii the case had been obtained by MacLay Hoyne, state's attorney, shortly before his retirement from office on Monday. All. of the original papers were turned over to the judge, who order ed them impounded by the clerk until the cases of the eight White Sox players who were indicted come to trial. Judge Robert Crowe, wtfo succeeded Mr. Hoyne as state's attorney, or dered an investigation after Hartley Iteplogle, former assistant state's at torney, who, conducted the base ball investigation, notified Judge Mc Donald that Mr.
See moreSee less
Hoyne had demand ed copies of the papers last Friday. George T. Kenney, private secre tary to Mr. ,H(jyhe, ordered Mr. Rep logle to surrender the papers, the latter told the chief justice. Mr. Replogle' said he refused until Mr. Hoyne personally ordered the copics. Mr. Kenney said he gave the copies t( -"Mr. Hoyne's stenographer to be delivered to Mr. Hoyne at his home. Tliofnas E. Nash, attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicated on a charge of ac cepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 World's series, said that the original evidence was in court lfist Friday, as he had seen it at chat time. Mr. Hoyne said he had asked for the records Mmply to put them in the cass^in his office, for which lie i-efcp$isible, and that they were there ndwf sealed up. "Therfris no 'scandal' and nothing wrong," said Mr. Hoyne.
After breaking up the scandal-tainted White Sox, Comiskey was offered help from other owners but refused gifts, insisting on paying his own way to rebuild. Despite rivals' offers, including from the Yankees, he has struggled for three months to reassemble a competitive team for 1921.
The Milwaukee Leader · 8 December 1920 · page 9
Offered Help—But. Then the moguls, altruistic to th® core, condoled with the old Roman. The White Sox would rebuild from material furnished by the other mors fortunate owners, they said. They rushed with preferred gifts to the exponent of high ideals. That was three months ago. But Comiskey is still holding the same fragments, remnants of th® wreck. He has added a few more* recruits, but he got them for cash, in the open market and he had to outbid his fellow magnates. Of course, Comiskey refused gifts. He has money and he insisted upon using it to get a new club together. But money and all, he’s having % hard time.
The report describes Comiskey's costly effort to rebuild the White Sox roster after the scandal, noting failed trade attempts for players like Joe Dugan. It also reports a dispute in which Chief Justice McDonald seized original case records after allegations that copies had been improperly taken by a former prosecutor's aide.
The Milwaukee Leader · 8 December 1920 · page 9
BY HENRY L. FARRELL.
Yanks Block Deal. Recently the notion spread that Joey Dugan would be sold by Con nie Mack and the Sox wanted him badly. But the Cankees went wildiy after him. .They offered Mack money and five or six players, but Mack wouldn’t take it. Perhaps Comiskey will get him yet, but he will have to come high for him. Three months isn’t a Jong while, | but it seems plenty long to forget.
The report notes that Cliff Brady and McMullen, among the indicted Chicago White Sox players, have been released on $10,000 bail. This reflects the ongoing legal process following the Black Sox scandal indictments.
The Ely Miner · 17 December 1920 · page 2
Bail for Accused Players. Cliff Brady, second baseman of the McMullen, two of the indicted Chicago White Sox ball players, are out on SIO,OOO bail.
Claude Williams and Joe Jackson, who confessed to throwing World Series games, return to Chicago to join other indicted players in opposing their expulsion from baseball. Buck Weaver expresses confidence he will play again, possibly with the Giants, and is consulting attorney Thomas Nash alongside fellow indicted teammates.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 20 December 1920 · page 6
WILLIAMS TO LINE UP
tine indicted player?Muck Weaver ? thinks it an absolute certainty that he will be in uniform next season; if n I with the White Sox, with the New York 'Slants. Weaver says that Met'; raw has lonir been Wis friend. He played for McGraw on a trip around the world several years au >. If f 11 nd not Kiiilty, Wituver intends! Koinu to l'r< sideut Comiskey, of ?h> Wulte Son. foi reinstatement. None i of the indicted White Sox players! has been unconditionally released, j They are und? r suspension.
See moreSee less
Weaver lias been in constant con-1 sulfation with his attorney. Thomas ! >. Nash, a former Alderman. Nash is also attorney for Itlsberu. Kred McMullin and usenr Kelsch So far as known, Williams has not vet ween a lawyer. It was reported some time athat both Williams n:>d Jackson had repudiated their con f e.^ s ion - The indicted jdavers need ail the optimism they profess to feel. First the\ must f . e the court and the .spe < lal prosecutor tinAmerican le-nuue is lute, then President ("omiskey's private ollice, and.- finally, the mili tant l.andl.,:.
An interview with 70-year-old Cal McVey, former Cincinnati Red Stockings captain, recalling his playing days and harsh conditions before gloves, and comparing old-time baseball to the modern game. He harshly condemns the indicted Chicago White Sox players, saying he'd give them 'life on the rock pile,' and recounts his own experience quitting a team over crooked players in 1871.
The West Virginian · 21 December 1920 · page 10
without gloves or protection. Though his body is now handi-1 capped the old war horse who cap-1 j tained and managed one of the I greatest ball teams of all times is! full of fire. "I'd give 'em life' on the rock pile," he snapped, speaking of the indicted Chicago White Sox play- [ ers. Incidentally it was due to crook-! ed ball players that Cal left the game. "I had two crooks on my team1 in '71 and I couldn't find 'em," he < explained, "so I quit before I'd play j on the same team with them."
See moreSee less
During his fight against crooked players McVey went to Chicago and promoted the National League organization in which the famous "Big Four"?B.'rnes, White, Spaul ding and McVey played such a prominent, part. Cal was the highest salaried player of his time. He got $4,000 a year as captain and manager of the Cincinnati Red Stockings. The next highest salary pairl on the team was $2,500. The teams only carried eleven men then. A player i had to be a star to hang on. McVey's Cincinnati team in 18Gfi wont through the entire season without a defeat, winning GS games
An interview with 70-year-old Cal McVey, a founding figure of professional baseball now crippled by rheumatism, recounts his career with the Cincinnati Red Stockings and the National League's founding. Asked about the indicted Chicago White Sox players, he says he'd give them 'life on the rock pile,' recalling how he once quit a team rather than play with crooked players.
Evening Journal · 22 December 1920 · page 15
DADDY OF OLD NATIONAL LEAGUE IS HELPLESS NOW
he snapped, speaking ««f the indicted Chicago White Sox players. Incidentally, It was due to crooked ball players that Cal left the game. "I had two crooks on my team In «1 and 1 couldn't Und 'em," he cx-1 plained. "So I quit before I'd play on the same team with them." i During his light against crook.d players, MreVv went to Chicago ami ! promoted the National l.cagt.r organ- ^ izatlon. In which the famous "Big! Four -Barnes White, Spaulding and !
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
American League president Ban Johnson and White Sox owner Charles Comiskey are feuding over who has the right to prosecute the indicted players and gamblers. The indicted players remain free, some claiming innocence and expressing hope to return to baseball, though Judge Landis vows they will never play in the majors again; Comiskey also denies rumors of selling his franchise.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 22 December 1920 · page 17
Clash on prosecution BT ITJSKRT L. FAESELL. (United Press Staff Correspondent) I "New Tork, Dec. 22 Ban John-1 son and Charles Comiskey are quarreling about the privilege of prosecuting the .indicted ball play ers and gamblers. Comiskey claims that inasmuch as the guilty players were mem bers of his club, that he is the proper one to bring them to trial Johnson claims that as presi dent of the league in which the treachery was carried out it is his duty to prosecute. Say They'll Bo Back Meanwhile the Indicted players are free and are openly stating that they'll he back is baseball next season.
See moreSee less
Buck West or has maintained his innocence tram the start Joe Jackson claims he perjured himself. Claud Williams and Swede Risberg smile rather wisely and say they're not oat of baseball. As long as Judge Landls has anything to say about the tamo, it is hardly probable that any of the "eight" will get back Into tha major leagues. When asked recently about their chances to get back into tha game, Landls almost caved a panel of his desk with a thump of his fist and shouted: "Never!" I my clnb is not for sale. the name of Comiskey." National league. ; ;
Cliff Brady, second baseman, and a player named McMullen—both indicted in the Black Sox scandal—have been released on $10,000 bail each. The brief item reports only this procedural development in the legal case against the accused players.
The Lambertville Record · 24 December 1920 · page 3
Ball for Accused Players. Cliff Brady, second baseman of the McMullen, two of the indicted Chicago White Sox ball players, are out on $10,000 bail.
A Los Angeles judge quashed indictments against Pacific Coast League players accused of fixing games, ruling the indictments did not allege a criminal act. The article notes this legal precedent could affect the pending prosecution of the eight Chicago White Sox players, several of whom had confessed while others denied wrongdoing.
New-York Tribune · 25 December 1920 · page 8
LOS ANGELES JUDGE QUASHES INDICTMENTS OF BALL PLAYERS ACCUSED OF "THROWING" GAMES
The procedure on the coast Is par- <?. ticuiarly interesting here because of ; theeffect it may have in the prosecu- ! tions of the eight players of the j Chicago White Sox, Indicted for disj honesty in connection with the play? ing ok the world's championship series I of 1919 between the Chicago Americans and the Cincinnati Nationals. In Line for Trial These eight Chicago players are now In line for trial because of the con? fessions of several of their number. The veteran pitcher, Eddie Cicotte, was the first to break down before the Cook County Grand Jury and he im?
See moreSee less
plicated the others. ilia confession subsequently was substantiated by out? fielder Joe Jackson and pitcher Lefty Williams. "Hap" Felsch is also sup? posed to have confessed. In direct contrast to these confes? sions have come the absolute denials of Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver and Risberg. The three last mentioned all
The report reviews the aftermath of the Black Sox confessions, noting Jackson, Williams, and possibly Felsch admitted involvement while Gandil, Weaver, and Risberg denied wrongdoing and claimed a frame-up. It details Comiskey's suspension of pay and World Series shares, and the looming legal battle as players threaten civil suits for recovery of withheld salaries.
New-York Tribune · 25 December 1920 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Los Angeles Judge Quashes Indictments of Ball Players Accused of "Throwing" Games
Court Ruling May Affect Plan For Big League 'Housecleaning'
See moreSee less
Decision Holds Indictments Do Not Allege a Criminal Act; Discredited Members of Chicago White Sox Have Excellent Basis for Civil Suit
By W. J. Macbeth
From Los Angeles, yesterday drifted news that may have a direct bearing on the proposed "housecleaning" of gambling, gamblers and dishonest players in the major leagues. The grand jury indictments of William ("Babe") Borton, Carl Maggert and William Rumler, alleging that they conspired to prearrange decisions in Pacific Coast League baseball games, were quashed by Judge Willis in the Los Angeles Superior Court.
Judge Willis held that the indictments did not allege a criminal act. The District Attorney's representative in court said he could not say whether new indictments would be sought until he conferred with his chief.
The procedure on the coast is particularly interesting here because of the effect it may have in the prosecutions of the eight players of the Chicago White Sox, indicted for dishonesty in connection with the playing of the world's championship series of 1919 between the Chicago Americans and the Cincinnati Nationals.
In Line for Trial
These eight Chicago players are now in line for trial because of the confessions of several of their number. The veteran pitcher, Eddie Cicotte, was the first to break down before the Cook County Grand Jury and he implicated the others. His confession subsequently was substantiated by outfielder Joe Jackson and pitcher Lefty Williams. "Hap" Felsch is also supposed to have confessed.
In direct contrast to these confessions have come the absolute denials of Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver and Risberg. The three last mentioned all along have maintained that they were "framed" by the others. Weaver, for exoneration, points to his record in the big series in question. He certainly played the most sensational ball of any party concerned and with apparent will that fooled every spectator if, indeed, he were dishonest. In that series Weaver so wormed himself into the fine opinions of critics that he came out of it heralded as the greatest third basemen in the game.
Joe Jackson, since his confession, has recanted. He says he confessed to what was not so under duress. Those who were supposedly implicated in the plot and did not admit the corn presumably are lined-up to give the civil law and organized baseball law a battle. "Buck" Weaver has gone on the stage in monologue to vindicate himself with the Chicago public.
The discredited White Sox players have an excellent angle on which to hang a civil suit. The moment they were indicted by the Cook County Grand Jury all were suspended without pay by Charles A. Comiskey. Not only were their salaries for the balance of the year withheld but also all the world's series split that accrued for finishing second in the 1920 pennant race.
Sure To Be Barred
The unconfessed and denying White Sox players under indictment are threatening legal action for the recovery of salary and bonus claims, and therein will center that delicate point raised by the Los Angeles court. The burden of proof will be thrown on the confessers and proof in such a situation is bound to be difficult if the majority stick to one story.
There is little doubt that all the White Sox players implicated will be barred from baseball, irrespective of court action. Judge Landis, the Commissioner of Baseball, has passed his word that they are through with the game. Charles A. Comiskey, their employer, is quite as positive they will never again appear in uniform.
Comiskey justly resents plain interference by the American League, which voted a fund for the prosecuting attorney of Cook County to press the indictments. He, the most active influence in ferreting out the big scandal, maintains that as it was his club which was involved chiefly, whatever financial assistance is necessary to run the culprits to earth should come from the party most directly concerned.
Since the indictments were returned by the Cook County Grand Jury political changes have been effected. It has been rumored that efforts were made by retiring officials to cloud the issue for political reasons. Fandom, however, should not worry. Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the new head of baseball government, is in a position to arrive at the truth, if anybody can. That he will do so seems an absolute certainty, the attitude of California justice notwithstanding.
The report states that Commissioner Landis has declared the implicated White Sox players through with baseball regardless of court outcomes, and owner Comiskey agrees they will never play again. It also notes political tension between Comiskey and the American League over funding the prosecution, with hope that Landis can determine the truth.
New-York Tribune · 25 December 1920 · page 8
White Sox players implicated will be tarred from baseball, irrespective of court action. Judge Landie. the Com? missioner of Baseball, has passed his word that they are through with the game. Charles A. Comiskey, their em? ployer, is quite as positive they will never again appear in uniform. Comiskey justly resents plain inter? ference by the American League, which voted a fund for the prosecuting attor? ney of Cook County to press the indict? ments. He, the most active influence in ferreting out the big scandal, main? tains that a? it was his club which was involved chiefly, whatever financial assistance is necessary to run the cul?
See moreSee less
prits to earth should come from the party most directly concerned. Since the indictments were returned by the Cook County Grand Jury politi? cal changes have heen effected. It has been rumored that efforts were mad?* by retiring officials to cloud the issue for political reasons. Fandom, how over, should not worry. Judge Kene saw Mountain Landis, the new head of Laseball government, is in a position to arrive at the truth, if anybody can. That he will do so seems an absolute certainty, the attitude of California justice notwithstanding.
This retrospective piece reflects on how the Black Sox scandal, despite being a stain on baseball, may lead to a new era of reform now that Judge Landis has been appointed commissioner. It also recaps the dramatic 1920 pennant race, including Cleveland's championship run following Ray Chapman's death after being hit by a pitch from Carl Mays.
New-York Tribune · 26 December 1920 · page 19
Sox >.<>?. indicted by the Cook Countj . ..,'. ?Jury i'?ir dishorn I the 1919 world's series championship g imt? that club played (oi ' ?p?ay ' against th ein Reds. Several i :' Ii implicated them?
The article reviews major 1920 sports events, including the revelation that the 1919 World Series had been fixed by Chicago White Sox players who accepted bribes. It notes the indictments of seven current and one former player, plus Hal Chase, Bill Burns, and Abe Attell, and the resulting suspension of the players and new league oversight under Judge Landis.
South Bend News-Times · 26 December 1920 · page 24
Tho indicted White Sox players were suspended from the club and tho team's chances for winning the pennant in a close race with Cleve land were wrecked. Cleveland won t'te American league pennant on Oct. 2 and met the Frooklyn club. National league pennant winner, in the world series on Oct. 5. Cleveland - w on tue series by taking tho seventh
Sportswriter Hugh Fullerton reports players whispering that owners will never dare prosecute the indicted White Sox, despite baseball officials voting funds to pursue the case. He also notes Buck Herzog's unresolved demand for vindication after being accused by pitcher Rube Benton of offering bribes.
The Wheeling Intelligencer · 27 December 1920 · page 7
ON THE SCREEN OF SPORT
By Hugh S. Fullerton. Baseball players, both those accused and tlioim who never have come under the slightest suspicion, are whispering anioht themselves thut the owners ot bast-ball clubs never will dare prosecute the Indicted members of the White Sox. Organized baseball, especially the American heaRim. made a .strong and unmistakable answer to the whisper during the New York meeting by. voting
The report discusses Judge Willis's view that the indicted White Sox players might not be held over for criminal prosecution, suggesting baseball's crooked play may fall outside the court's jurisdiction. It also notes a separate item about organizing a national boxing body and a jurisdictional dispute over horse height rules between British and American authorities.
The New York Herald · 29 December 1920 · page 10
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Chicago State's Attorney Robert E. Crowe announced that preliminary hearings for the eight indicted former White Sox players and others would be held within three weeks. Trials for the conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series would follow as soon as possible afterward.
Indiana Daily Times · 29 December 1920 · page 8
Baseball Scandal Trial to Be Hurried Along CHICAGO. Dec. 29—Speody trials for the eight former members of the Chicago White Sox and others indicted for*con splracy to "throw” tho 1019 world's se ries to Cincinnati, -were promised today
National League president John Heydler argues that a California court ruling preventing criminal prosecution of Pacific Coast League players for game-throwing does not apply to the indicted Chicago White Sox players. He explains the Illinois case charges criminal conspiracy to damage a business, a different legal theory than the California cases, and expresses confidence the prosecution will proceed successfully.
The New York Herald · 30 December 1920 · page 10
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
Chicago prosecutors announce they will seek extradition of indicted White Sox players and others on conspiracy charges for throwing the 1919 World Series. The case is assigned to Chief Justice McDonald, though defense attorneys may seek a change of venue due to his prior role in the grand jury probe.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 31 December 1920 · page 4
White Sox ball players, indicted on charges of throwing games in 1919 world series is conspiracy, according to an announcement today from the state's attorney's office. Conspiracy is a f -lony an 1 an extraditable of fense. Chief Justice McDonald, it was an nounced, hai drawn the assignment of the indicted White Sox players and others connected with the baeball expose. t has been intimated that attor neys representing the defense will ask a change of venue because of Judge McDonald's activity during the grand jury investigation.
Chicago's state's attorney announced that the charge against the indicted White Sox players, needed to support extradition, is conspiracy, a felony. Chief Justice McDonald was assigned the case, and defense attorneys were expected to seek a change of venue due to his prior role in the grand jury probe.
Evening Star · 31 December 1920 · page 12
SOX CAN BE SEIZED
under which it is hoped to extradite White Sox base, bill players, indicted , on charges of throwing games in j the 1919 world series, is conspiracy, ; acryirHinp1 to an nnnrtiinr-pment tndaii rroin the state's attorney's office. Conspiracy is a felony and an extraditable offense. i Chief Justice McDonald, it was an- : itounced, lias drawn the assignment . it the indicted White Sox players and j1 others connected with the base ball i expose. i It has been intimated that attor- ] neys representing the defense will j ask a change of venue in event there i [s no change made in the assignment i jf the cases before they are brought to trial.
See moreSee less
, Judge McDonald's activity during i Lhe grand jury investigation which , resulted in the indictment of the ball j players is responsible for this at>- . titude of the defendants' attorneys, j it is said. ,
Chicago's state's attorney announced that conspiracy would be the charge used to seek extradition of the White Sox players indicted for throwing the 1919 World Series. Conspiracy is noted as a felony and an extraditable offense.
Paper unidentified · 31 December 1920 · page 1
WHITESOX PLAYERS TO BE EXTRADITED ON A CHARGE OF CONSPIRACY
CHARGE OF CONSPIRACY (By Associated Press ) Chicago, Dec. 31.The charge un der which it is hoped 'to extradite the White Sox baseball players indicted on charges of throwing games in last
The report notes that Chief Justice McDonald has been assigned to handle the case involving the indicted White Sox players and others connected with the baseball scandal. Details beyond the assignment are not elaborated in this fragment.
Evening Times-Republican · 31 December 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The Chicago state attorney's office announced that conspiracy will be the charge used to seek extradition of White Sox players accused of throwing the 1919 World Series. Chief Justice McDonald has been assigned the case, and defense attorneys may seek a change of venue due to his prior role in the grand jury investigation.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 31 December 1920 · page 9
AGAINST SOX PLAYERS (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, Dec. ' 31. The charge under which it is hoped to extradite White Sox baseball players on charges of throwing games In the 1919 world's series is conspiracy, according to an nouncement today from the state at torney's office. Conspiracy is a felony and an extraditable offense. Chief Justice McDonald, it was an nounced, has -drawn the assignment of the indicted White Sox players and others connected with the bas-eball expose. It has been intimated that attor neys representing the defense, will
Chicago's state's attorney's office announced plans to extradite indicted White Sox players who are outside the state's jurisdiction, to face conspiracy charges. Chief Justice McDonald was assigned the cases, and defense attorneys were expected to seek a change of venue.
The Topeka State Journal · 31 December 1920 · page 5
SOX MUST FACE CHARGES
Extradition To Be Used To I1 Sus pects In Baseball Scandal In Chicago. Chicago, Dec. 81. The state's attor ney's office today announced plans were being made to extradite indicted White Sox players not at present with in jurisdiction of the state courts. It was said an attempt will be made! to bring them back on charges of con spiracy. ' Chief Justice McDonald, it was an nounced, has drawn the assignment of the indicted White Sox players and others connected with the f baseball expose. It has been intimated that attorneys representing the defense will ask a change of venue in event there is no change made in the assignment of the cases before they are brought to trial.
Chicago prosecutors announce that conspiracy is the charge under which they hope to extradite indicted White Sox players and others tied to the World Series fixing scandal. Chief Justice McDonald has been assigned the cases, and defense attorneys may seek a change of venue.
Grand Forks Herald · 31 December 1920 · page 5
A CONSPIRACY IS CHARGE AGAINST WHITE SOX PLAYERS
WHITE SOX PUTERS Chicago, Dec. 31.—The 'charge un der which it is hoped to extradite Whlf Sox hnp-^nl' ^iq-*rar-q j' on. charges of throwing gtimcs «he iali» woriu's se..u, uk. cording to an announcieinent today from the state's attorney office. Con spiracy is ar felony and ah extradita ble offense. Chief Justice McDonald^ it was an nounced, h^s drawn the assignment •of the indicted White Sox players and others connected with the base ball* expose. 1 It has been Intimated that attorneys representing the defense will ask a change of venue in event there is no change made in the assignment of the cases before they are brought to trial.
Chicago state's attorney's office announced conspiracy as the charge for extraditing indicted White Sox players implicated in the 1919 World Series scandal. Chief Justice McDonald was assigned the case, with defense attorneys possibly seeking a change of venue.
The Chattanooga News · 31 December 1920 · page 12
MAY EXTRADITE SOX i'hlcvgo, lec. SI The charge under hich It la hoped to extradite White x baseball players, indicted on avgea of throwing games In the 191f I lire aeries, ta conspiracy, according an announcement today from the tea attorney's office. Conspiracy is lelony and nn extraditable offense, i iiief Justice McDonald, it was sn nneed has drawn the assignment of Indicted White Sox players and h is connected with the baseball ex it has been Intimated that attorneys resenting; the defense will ask a 'Wte ot venue In event there Is no mge made In the asHiinmcnt of the .ks before Ihry are brought to trial
The Chicago state's attorney's office announced that conspiracy is the charge under which they hope to extradite the indicted White Sox players from the 1919 World Series scandal. Judge McDonald has been assigned the cases, and defense attorneys may seek a change of venue due to his role in the grand jury investigation.
Paper unidentified · 31 December 1920 · page 9
CHICAGO, Deo. 31. The charge under which it is hbped to extradite White Sox baseball players, indicted on charges of throwing games In the 1919 world's series, is conspiracy, according to an announcement today from the state's attorney's office. Conspiracy is a felony and an extra ditable offense. Chief Justice McDonald, it was an nounced, has drawn the assignment of the indicted White Sox players andpthers connected with the base ball expose. It has been Intimated that attor neys representing the defense will ask a. change of venue in event there Is no change made in the assign ment of the cases before they are brought to trial.
See moreSee less
Judge McDonald's activity during the grand Jury Investigation which resulted in the indictment of the ball players, is responsible for this attitude of the defendants' attorneys, it is said.
A sports notes column reports that Swede Risberg, former Ogden shortstop and one of the indicted Chicago White Sox players, claims he will return to the American League for the 1921 season. The item situates him among the eight men accused of throwing the 1919 World Series.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 31 December 1920 · page 8
Swede Risberg, former Ogden shortfidder In the Union association, and one of the indicted players on the I nicago White Sox team, sends word ! trout 'ho Pacific coast that ho will he back in the American league during the 1921 season, Rlsberg fl one ot , ghl men H reused Ot throwing th" 1 191 9 world series.
The Chicago state's attorney's office announced plans to extradite indicted White Sox players who are currently outside the jurisdiction of state courts. The players will reportedly be brought back to face conspiracy charges.
The Milwaukee Leader · 31 December 1920 · page 9
x Plan to Extradite Indicted White Sox CHICAGO —The state’s attorney’s office today announced plans were being made to extradite Indicted White Sox players not at present within juridiction of state courts. It