As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

January 1928

12 articles

Paris Express · Paris, Ark.

This article reflects on legendary frontier peace officers like Pat Garrett, Bill Tilghman, Wyatt Earp, and Bat Masterson, noting how most who lived by the six-shooter also died by it. It recalls that Garrett killed Billy the Kid before himself being shot down decades later.

Paris Express · 5 January 1928 · page 5

his book, is a paraphrase of saying that “they who take t shall perish by the sword.” he puts it, "The six-shonter, lives of nine-tenths of all th of the Wild West" And most equally true of th who took upthesix-shor fense of the law. Of th/ famous peace officers w knew, three went dow smoking six-shooter. brief career as “prine eers” ended abruptly in shot down from was beadweod, S. D. Ne ter of a century after 1 killed Billy the Kid, ’ shot and killed. Afte as a peace officer “went out” as he i “in smoke and wit He was snot la anS town in 1924 Uy a

See the clipping

The Brooksville Journal · Brooksville, Fla.

This 1928 article discusses a new book, 'Hands Up: Stories of the Six-Gun Fighters of the Old Wild West,' based on the recollections of an old-timer named Sutton. It portrays Billy the Kid as a remorseless killer responsible for 21 murders in his short life, contrasting him with lawmen like Wild Bill Hickok and Pat Garrett who used their guns for order rather than crime.

The Brooksville Journal · 5 January 1928 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

By ELMO SCOTT WATSON

life of the notorious Billy the , "not solely for the reason that new him well but simply that I d not see a man murdered from

as he explains it. B[ut] fo[r]

See moreSee less

[th]at he saved Billy from being [i]n the back, the author of "Hands has no illusions about that [you]g outlaw. "If ever a man de [serve]d killing, it was Billy the Kid, [he sa]ys, "He was a human tiger, the [cold] pitiless killer of that period. [Hi]s short life of twenty-one years [he k]illed twenty-one men, and the [most] of those killings were murders in cold blood."

[Th]us this old-timer shows a refresh lack of maudlin sentimentality [for] those killers which colors the [writi]ngs of -others who have chron [icled] their dark deeds, the same type [of] misplaced sympathy which saves [the n]ecks of so many murderers to

He knew many of them—Jesse [Jam]es, Cherokee Bill, Bill Doolin,

See the clipping

The Brooksville Journal · Brooksville, Fla.

This article reflects on frontier figures like Wild Bill Hickok, Pat Garrett, Billy Tilghman, and Bat Masterson, noting that most died violently by the gun they lived by. It references Billy the Kid's death at Garrett's hands and Garrett's own later killing nearly 25 years after.

The Brooksville Journal · 5 January 1928 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

was shot down from behind in Deadwood, S. D. Nearly a quarter of a century after Pat Garrett had killed Billy the Kid, he himself was shot and killed. After fifty-one years as a peace officer Billy Tilghman "went out" as he had hoped to do "in smoke and with his boots on." He was shot in an Oklahoma oil boom town in 1924 by a man whom he had arrested and was taking to the police station. Only Bat Masterson, who left the Wild West years ago to become a New York newspaper man, died peacefully "with his boots off."

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This is a newspaper book review column listing new publications, including 'The Authentic Life of Billy the Kid' by Pat F. Garrett, edited by Maurice Garland Fulton, published by Macmillan Co. The entry is a brief bibliographic citation among many other unrelated book titles.

Evening Star · 8 January 1928 · page 40

THE AUTHENTIC LIFE OF BILLY THE KID. By Pat F. Garrett. Edited by Maurice Garland Ful ton. New York: The Macmillan Co. THE CHANGING SOUTH By ’Wil liam J. Robertson. New York:

See the clipping

The Tri-County News · Grand Rapids, Ohio

A 1928 review of the book 'Hands Up!' describes author Sutton's firsthand accounts of Old West outlaws, including a dance where he saved Billy the Kid from being shot in the back. The review highlights Sutton's unsentimental view of Billy the Kid as a remorseless killer who murdered twenty-one men in his short life, contrasting him with lawmen like Wild Bill Hickok and Pat Garrett.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Tri-County News · 11 January 1928 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

GROUP OF OLD-TIME COWBOYS

Sutton one night at a dance to save the life of the notorious Billy the Kid, "not solely for the reason that I knew him well but simply that I could not see a man murdered from behind," as he explains it. But for all that he saved Billy from being shot in the back, the author of "Hands Up!" has no illusions about that young outlaw. "If ever a man deserved killing, it was Billy the Kid he says, "He was a human tiger, the most pitiless killer of that period. In his short life of twenty-one years he killed twenty-one men, and the most of those killings were murders done in cold blood."

See moreSee less

Thus this old-timer shows a refreshing lack of maudlin sentimentality for those killers which colors the writings of others who have chronicled their dark deeds, the same type of misplaced sympathy which saves the necks of so many murderers today. He knew many of them—Jesse James, Cherokee Bill, Bill Doolin Crescent Sam, Belle Starr, the Dalton boys, the Jennings gang, Henry Starr Blacked-faced Charley and Arkansas Tom—and, knowing them and the environment which shaped their destinies, he can account for what they were and what they did. But he does not glorify their crimes. He may have admired them for what good qualities they did possess, but he admires more the type of gunman who drew his six-shooter in the cause of law and order. "Nearly all those peace officers of the old frontier were likable men, but there was nothing maudlin or irresolute about them They knew that death was the only penalty that would curb those wild men of the border, and when it was necessary to inflict it they did not hesitate," says Sutton. Such were Wild Bill Hickok, whom he characterizes as "unquestionably the fastest and surest man with a six-shooter that the West ever knew." Bat Masterson, Pat Garrett and Billy Tilghman. It was men of this type who used the six-shooter as an "instrument of civilization."

"Fill your hand!" was the remark that Wild Bill made when he "got the drop on" a bad man from Texas who had come up the trail to Hays City, Kan., where Bill was marshal, with the announced intention of spilling the Hickok blood. For the border code extended to these exponents of law and order when they set about arresting a desperado and made them "give the other fellow a chance, even when it was exceedingly dangerous to do so." One of the reasons they were willing to do so was explained to

See the clipping

The Tri-County News · Grand Rapids, Ohio

This 1928 newspaper item discusses a book by Sutton reminiscing about frontier figures like Masterson, Luke Short, Wyatt Earp, and others, noting that most outlaws and many lawmen died violently by the gun. It recounts Wild Bill Hickok's murder in 1876, Pat Garrett's killing of Billy the Kid followed by Garrett's own murder decades later, and Billy Tilghman's shooting death in 1924, contrasting these with Bat Masterson's peaceful death.

The Tri-County News · 11 January 1928 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

was shot down from behind in Deadwood, S. D. Nearly a quarter of a century after Pat Garrett had killed Billy the Kid, he himself was shot and killed. After fifty-one years as a peace officer Billy Tilghman "went out" as he had hoped to do "in smoke and with his boots on." He was shot in an Oklahoma oil boom town in 1924 by a man whom he had arrested and was taking to the police station. Only Bat Masterson, who left the Wild West years ago to become a New York newspaper man died peacefully "with his boots off."

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

A humor column includes a brief joke exchange mentioning 'Billy the Kid, the famous Arizona desperado,' who allegedly killed 19 men before age 21. The joke punchline shifts to asking what kind of car he drove, playing on anachronism for comic effect.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 17 January 1928 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BARBS

He: Yes, my father has contributed very much to the raising of the working classes. She: Is he a socialist? He: No, he makes alarm clocks.

He: Billy the Kid, the famous Arizona desperado, killed 19 men be

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

A local Tucson theater troupe presented Mrs. V. V. Erdlit's dramatized version of 'The Saga of Billy the Kid' by Byrnes. Several Douglas residents, including Mr. and Mrs. James East, traveled to Tucson to see the performance.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 17 January 1928 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Play Given In Tucson Last night in Tucson, Mrs. V. V. Erdlit's dramatized version of "The Saga of Billy the Kid," by Byrnes, was presented by local talent. Mr. and Mrs. James East and several other parties of Douglas people motored over to see it.

Brody on Buying Trip Bernard Brody, proprietor of the Men's Shop, left Sunday for New

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

A dramatized version of 'The Saga of Billy the Kid,' written by Mrs. J.J.P. Erdlets (Viola Vivian), was performed in Tucson to benefit the Temple of Music and Art's mortgage debt. The amateur production, directed by Erdlets with ballet direction by Mrs. George Cumberpatch, was praised by the community for bringing new participants to the stage.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 22 January 1928 · page 14 · transcribed from the page image

TUCSON SEES PLAY VERSION OF STORY BY DOUGLAS WOMAN

The dramatized version of "The Saga of Billy the Kid," by Mrs. J. J. P. Erdlets, (Viola Vivian) was presented at two performances this past week in Tucson, at the Temple of Music and Art.

The play was given by Mrs. Erdlets for the benefit of the debt on the Temple of Music in Tucson and the people of Tucson have expressed their appreciation of the untiring effort, time, money and thought expended on the production by Mrs. Erdlets. Quoting a statement made by a member of the board of the Saturday Morning Music Club—"We are more than appreciative that one whose home is not even in Tucson should take the time and have the interest in us that Miss Vivian (Mrs. Erdlets) has shown. She gathered together for her production of 'Billy the Kid' people who had never before been on the stage; she got cooperation for the Temple which had never been given before from various sources which are now being won over to the work being done here."

See moreSee less

Mrs. Erdlets directed the production as well as writing the drama. She was assisted in the direction of the ballet by Mrs. George Cumberpatch. During the past four or five weeks Mrs. Erdlets has been working on "Billy the Kid," giving her time to the preparation of the play for the benefit which was the first to aid in raising the mortgages on the Temple of Music. During the last three weeks of her stay in Tucson, Mrs. Erdlets was the house guest of Mrs. Simon Heineman, who aided in the production.

While the production was entirely amateur in cast it was pronounced to

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

A women's club pageant in Tucson featured James H. East as honor guest, described as the only living member of the posse that captured Billy the Kid. The article repeats the legendary claim that the outlaw had killed 27 men by age 21.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 22 January 1928 · page 14 · transcribed from the page image

so arranged that only one scene was visible to the eye at a time, gradually diffusing and fading into the distance and an entirely different scene presenting itself as if it were a dream in reality. The actual painting on the gauze was accomplished by Mrs. Erdlets and Mrs. Laura Ostrander, Art supervisor, of whose efforts Mrs. Erdlets expressed her appreciation. Honor Guest James H. East of 843 10th street, was the honor guest of both performances. Mr. East is the only living member of the posse that captured Billy the Kid, the youthful bandit, who at the age of 21 had killed 27 men. Mrs. East accompanied Mr. East to Tucson and they were honored by numerous social functions while there. PATRONESSES

See the clipping

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

The Dispatch retracts its earlier statement that a play staged in Tucson by Mrs. J. J. P. Erdlets was a dramatization of 'The Saga of Billy the Kid.' It clarifies that she drew her material from facts supplied by James East of Douglas, the last living member of the posse that captured Billy the Kid.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 24 January 1928 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

BEGGING YOUR PARDON It was erroneously stated in a recent issue of the Douglas Daily Dispatch that the play presented in Tucson by Mrs. J. J. P. Erdlets (Viola Vivian) was a dramatized version of "The Saga of Billy the Kid."

Mrs. Erdlets gathered most of her material and data for her play from facts supplied her by James East of Douglas, who is the only living member of the posse who captured Billy the Kid.

See moreSee less

You'll find it in Dispatch want-ads.

See the clipping

The Buffalo Bulletin · Buffalo, Wyo.

A 1928 serialized memoir by a frontier army officer recounts rampant horse thieving and banditry across the western territories in the late 1870s. It lists Billy the Kid alongside Jesse and Frank James and other notorious outlaws who terrorized settlers and defied authorities.

The Buffalo Bulletin · 26 January 1928 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CHAPTER XLVII

After Horse Thieves and Holdups The fall of 1876 and the three years following were noteworthy on account of the wholesale thieving that was going on in the territories. It just seemed as if all the thieves in the universe had been turned loose in Nebraska, Wyoming, Oregon, Idaho, Montana and Dakota. They had no regard for property or human life, and were, in my opinion, infinitely worse than the Indians ever were. Among the more notorious characters who infested the great west in the years referred to were the James boys—Jesse and Frank—and their gang; Billy the Kid, Cully, Bill Zimmerman, Tom Reece, Phoenix, Odell, Jerry

See the clipping