The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Theodore Roosevelt, while campaigning in Salisbury, Maryland, greeted an old acquaintance and reminisced about his days as a Dakota deputy sheriff capturing cattle thieves. He casually remarked that one of the thieves, nicknamed Calamity Joe, was later killed by Billy the Kid.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 26 days later.
The Washington Times · 3 May 1912 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
see him again." Mr. Starr was brought in. He is a tall, straight man with a high forehead and a clear eye, and he carried in his hand a sombrero that could only have originated on the plains. It was an enthusiastic greeting.
"Well, judge," said Roosevelt, "how are you after all these years? Do you remember the time I brought the cattle thieves before you?"
See moreSee less
Then Mr. Roosevelt told the following story, showing a remarkable faculty for remembering names: "I was a deputy sheriff in the bad lands in those days, and there were three cattle thieves that had been giving us a lot of trouble. I hired two bronco mares, and went after them, and rounded them up about sixty miles from Dickinson, where the judge here was magistrate. Their names were Calamity Joe (Billy the Kid, afterward killed him, I believe), Half-breed Bill and Red. I put them in my wagon, and started to walk the sixty miles to Dickinson. I was young and hardy, and that didn't seem far them."
"Stopped at night, didn't you?" said Judge Starr.