As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

December 1908

20 articles

The Guthrie Daily Leader · Guthrie, Okla.

The article recounts Billy the Kid's jailbreak after killing his guards, and describes his eventual death at the hands of Pat Garrett at Fort Sumner. It also claims his body was buried in the military cemetery at Fort Stanton.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Guthrie Daily Leader · 1 December 1908 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ONLY A BOY, YET A TERROR.

shot. Then he called to an old man on the plaza to bring him a file. Filing off one of his shackles, he called for a horse. One was brought, and he escaped.

For nearly three months after that Billy the Kid led a fugitive life. Garrett dogged him patiently and finally got wind of his hiding place—the ranch of Peter Maxwell, near Fort Sumner. It was nearly midnight when Garrett and two deputies quietly approached the Maxwell hacienda. Garrett crept into the room where Maxwell was sleeping. Softly awakening the sleeper, he questioned him concerning the whereabouts of the Kid.

See moreSee less

At that moment the hunted youth sprang into the room, calling out in Spanish, "Quien va?" ("Who comes there?") It was Billy. He was unarmed, and as he reached for his rifle Garrett shot him. The body of William Bonney (Billy the Kid) was buried in the military cemetery at Fort Stanton July 15, 1881. His age at the time of his death was twenty-one years seven months. There his body is to day, though in later years a corpse was exhibited throughout the west as that of the famous young outlaw.—Harper's Weekly.

See the clipping

The Star · Reynoldsville, Pa. · and 12 other papers

The article recounts Billy the Kid's jailbreak in Lincoln, killing two guards, and his months as a fugitive before Pat Garrett tracked him to Pete Maxwell's ranch at Fort Sumner and shot him dead. It claims he was buried at Fort Stanton's military cemetery, noting a body later exhibited as his was a fraud.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 120 days earlier.

Wrong

The Star · 9 December 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Reveled In Carnage.

ONLY A BOY, YET A TERROR.

See moreSee less

This Youthful Desperado of the Southwestern Territories Was but Twenty-one When He Met Death at the Hands of Sheriff Pat Garrett.

When General Lew Wallace was governor of New Mexico and the war that raged for several years between the rival cattle companies was at its height "Billy the Kid" had reached the flood of his murderous career. He arrived in Lincoln county to take sides in the cattle warfare, known and feared in every range town and mining camp in the southwestern territories.

Pure wanton love of carnage was all that attracted him to Lincoln county. With the band of desperadoes he led he raided ranches, "shot up" towns, killed, burned houses and committed outrage after outrage with the blind recklessness of a maniac. Fear was extinct within him. He cared no more for detachments of cavalry than he did for cowering sheriffs.

Affairs in New Mexico finally came to such a pass that half the cattlemen paid the youthful desperado tribute. It was only after Pat F. Garrett was made sheriff of Lincoln county and the author of "Ben-Hur" (General Wallace) urged that fearless gun fighter and gambler to capture Billy the Kid that a determined effort was made to end his reign of terror.

The obstacles that Garrett had to encounter called for all his headlong energy and nerve. Billy had the entire countryside in a state of abject terror; friends were ready to give him timely warning of pursuit; ranchmen dared not deny him lodgment or concealment.

Pat Garrett undertook the capture in October, 1880, and on Dec. 20 he surrounded the Kid and his band in a deserted house near Stinking Springs. After a siege lasting most of the day the outlaws' ammunition was exhausted. Billy the Kid surrendered. He and his four followers, surrounded by a great force of armed men, were taken to Las Vegas and thence to Santa Fe for safe keeping.

An array of indictments charging murder confronted him. He was tried on one indictment and acquitted, then tried on another and convicted. He carried himself throughout with sneering defiance. After he had been sentenced to hang Garrett took him to Fort Stanton, near Lincoln. Two deputies armed with Winchesters were assigned to guard him in the temporary jail in the Murphy & Dolan store building.

In some mysterious fashion the Kid possessed himself of a revolver, shot down his guards, seized their weapons and appeared at the window. When another guard appeared the prisoner riddled his body with buckshot. Then he called to an old man on the plaza to bring him a file. Filing off one of his shackles, he called for a horse. One was brought, and he escaped.

For nearly three months after that Billy the Kid led a fugitive life. Garrett dogged him patiently and finally got wind of his hiding place—the ranch of Peter Maxwell, near Fort Sumner. It was nearly midnight when Garrett and two deputies quietly approached the Maxwell hacienda. Garrett crept into the room where Maxwell was sleeping. Softly awakening the sleeper, he questioned him concerning the whereabouts of the Kid.

At that moment the hunted youth sprang into the room, calling out in Spanish, "Quien va?" ("Who comes there?") It was Billy. He was unarmed, and as he reached for his rifle Garrett shot him. The body of William Bonney (Billy the Kid) was buried in the military cemetery at Fort Stanton July 15, 1881. His age at the time of his death was twenty-one years seven months. There his body is today, though in later years a corpse was exhibited throughout the west as that of the famous young outlaw.—Harper's Weekly.

None Left Alive.

"An orator," said one of our statesmen, "was addressing an assemblage of the people. He recounted the people's wrongs. Then he passionately cried:

" 'Where are America's great men? Why don't they take up the cudgel in our defense? In the face of our manifold wrongs why do they remain cold, immovable, silent?'

" 'Because they're all cast in bronze!' shouted a cynic in the rear."

Bucolic Humor.

"Hiram, why don't you speak to that city gal out there a-sittin' on the grass with her back up agin your 'No Trespassing' sign?"

"Mandy, that young woman is beneath my notice."—Boston Transcript.

But Not the "One."

Mrs. Hoyle—My husband had $100,000 when I married him. Mrs. Doyle—How much has he now? Mrs. Hoyle—Oh, he has most of the ciphers left!—Bohemian.

The Whale's Blow.

Porpoise—What is the whale blowing about? Dogfish—Oh, he got so many notices for his feat in swallowing Jonah he's been blowing ever since.—Exchange.

Progress is the real cure for an overestimate of ourselves.—Macdonald.

See the clipping

Also printed in 12 papers
  • New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn. · 4 November 1908
  • The Wahpeton Times · Wahpeton, N.D. · 5 November 1908
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 5 November 1908
  • The Monitor-Register · Woodstown, N.J. · 6 November 1908
  • · · 22 November 1908
  • The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind. · 30 November 1908
  • Amador Ledger · Jackson, Calif. · 11 December 1908
  • The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D. · 24 December 1908
  • The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon · 14 January 1909
  • Bill Barlow's Budget · Douglas, Wyo. · 3 February 1909
  • The Meeker Herald · Meeker, Colo. · 6 February 1909
  • Five Mile Beach Weekly Journal · Wildwood, N.J. · 19 February 1909

The Citizen · Honesdale, Pa.

A newspaper item describes the play 'Billy the Kid' by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, starring Frederick Santley who performs notable horsemanship, entering and exiting on horseback. The horse used in the production reportedly has an interesting history of its own.

The Citizen · 9 December 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Honesdale, her people and her industries may be familiar to other communities.

—In his new play "Billy the Kid" by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, Frederick Santley, the star, gives an ex-

See the clipping

The Citizen · Honesdale, Pa.

A newspaper item announces that the melodrama 'Billy the Kid,' starring Frederick Santley and written by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, will be performed at the Lyric theater on December 11. The piece praises the play's clever dialogue, strong situations, and well-balanced cast as one of the best of its kind touring that season.

The Citizen · 11 December 1908 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

—Hank Mathewson, of Factoryville, brother of Christy, of the Giants, has signed to pitch for the Savannah, Ga., team in 1909. Hank is a youngster, and when he was with the Giants a few years ago he was used in a pinch. He could not keep the pace and in 1907 he was sent out to the minor leagues to work his way back up again if he could. It is said that he will easily make good in Savannah and be back with the majors the next year. He played with two or three of the visiting clubs in Honesdale during the past season.

—"Billy the Kid" by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, in which Frederick Santley, is starring, this season, is reported as being one of the best plays of its kind that has gone out of New York this year. It is a melodrama but it is said to tell a concise and powerful story with a due regard to sequence so often missed by melodramatic writers. The play abounds in strong situations, the dialogue is clever and there is plenty of comedy. The production is a handsome one and the star's supporting company exceedingly well balanced. Mr. Santley is to present "Billy the Kid" at the Lyric this Friday evening, Dec. 11.

See moreSee less

—In view of the fact that the beaver colony on Crooked Creek, this county, is attracting so much attention of late, the following item, illustrating the habits and intelligence of that rare creature, may prove interesting. It comes from Kennebec, Maine:

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

Amid entertainment listings for Poli's New Theater and the Grand Opera House, a brief notice announces that a show called 'Billy the Kid' is coming soon. No further details about the production are given.

Paper unidentified · 18 December 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Mat. Sat. Seats Selling. Regular Prices.

Coming, "Billy the Kid."

See moreSee less

POLI'S NEW THEATER

ONE ENTIRE WEEK OF DEC. 14. Daily Matinees, Manager Poli Proffers LA PETIT REVUE, By CHARLES LOVENBERG.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

The report announces actor Frederic Santley's new melodrama 'Billy, the Kid,' written by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, set in New Mexico and praised for its atmospheric staging. It will play at the Grand Opera House for several performances that week.

Paper unidentified · 18 December 1908 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

and is put on the stage in an elaborate manner. The company carries everything used in the production with the exception of a very few minor "properties." The scenes of the play are all laid in New Mexico, and the authors are said to have preserved the atmosphere of the locality most admirably. Supported by an exceptionally strong company, Santley will present "Billy, the Kid," at the Grand Opera House next Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday, and Wednesday matinee.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A newspaper theater column reviews a touring production of 'Billy the Kid' starring actor Frederick Stanley, describing it as a melodramatic but consistent western play with exceptional climaxes. The item appears alongside reviews of other shows like 'Hello Bill' and vaudeville acts at Poli's theater.

The New Haven Union · 18 December 1908 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

GRAND OPERA HOUSE

"Billy the Kid," the successful western play in which the popular young actor Frederick Stanley, is starring this season, proves to be extremely well fitted to his uses. The play while medo

See the clipping

Fort Pierce News · Fort Pierce, Fla.

This passage recounts Billy the Kid's dramatic escape from the Lincoln jail, killing his guards, and his eventual death three months later at Pete Maxwell's ranch near Fort Sumner at the hands of Pat Garrett. It also describes his burial and later exhibition of his body, closing with an unrelated anecdote about a political orator.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 9 days earlier.

Fort Pierce News · 18 December 1908 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

on one of his shackles, he called for a horse. One was brought, and he escaped.

For nearly three months after that Billy the Kid led a fugitive life. Garrett dogged him patiently and finally got wind of his hiding place—the ranch of Peter Maxwell, near Fort Sumner. It was nearly midnight when Garrett and two deputies quietly approached the Maxwell hacienda. Garrett crept into the room where Maxwell was sleeping. Softly awakening the sleeper, he questioned him concerning the whereabouts of the Kid.

See moreSee less

At that moment the hunted youth sprang into the room, calling out in Spanish, "Quien va?" ("Who comes there?") It was Billy. He was unarmed, and as he reached for his rifle Garrett shot him. The body of William Bonney (Billy the Kid) was buried in the military cemetery at Fort Stanton July 15, 1881. His age at the time of his death was twenty-one years seven months. There his body is today, though in later years a corpse was exhibited throughout the west as that of the famous young outlaw.—Harper's Weekly.

None Left Alive.

"An orator," said one of our statesmen, "was addressing an assemblage of the people. He recounted the people's wrongs. Then he passionately cried:

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

An entertainment section advertisement announces the Western drama "Billy the Kid" presented by Charles H. Wnerr, starring Frederic Santley, playing Monday through Wednesday. It appears among listings for other theatrical productions including Hello Bill and Polly of the Circus.

Paper unidentified · 19 December 1908 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Sat. Sat. Seats Sellin Regular Prices.

Coming, "Billy the Kid."

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

An advertisement announces that the melodrama 'Billy, the Kid,' starring young actor Frederick Santley, is coming to the Grand Opera House as part of a wave of new Western-themed plays following hits like 'The Squaw Man' and 'Arizona.' It notes the play's scheduled performance days.

Paper unidentified · 19 December 1908 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

COMING TO GRAND

"Billy the Kid" the First of the Week—"It's Never Too Late to Mend."

See moreSee less

With the success of "The Squaw Man," "Arizona" and "The Virginian,"

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A theater listing announces that 'Billy, the Kid,' a vehicle for actor Frederick Santley, will play at the Grand Opera House for three days. The item is part of a roundup of local theatrical attractions for the holiday season.

The New Haven Union · 19 December 1908 · page 4

Winston Churchill. GRAND OPERA HOUSE. "Billy, the Kid,” which Is the vehicle that has been selected for the starring tour of the favorite young actor, Fred erick Santley, Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. Come to the Grand.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A touring stage play titled 'Billy the Kid,' written by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods and starring Frederick Santley, is advertised as the attraction at the Grand Opera House. The article describes the fictionalized plot about a young man who follows his outlaw father's path before reforming for love, with no claim to historical accuracy.

The New Haven Union · 20 December 1908 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

on the animal as well. "Billy the Kid" is to be the attraction at the Grand the first half of this week and will be offered at strictly popular prices. Matinee on Wednes

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

This is a theater advertisement listing the play 'Billy the Kid' as the attraction at the Grand Opera House, with a photo caption of Frederick Santley in the title role. The bulk of the passage actually discusses other plays and holiday shows, including a child-abduction melodrama and a Santa Claus matinee.

The New Haven Union · 20 December 1908 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

on the animal as well. "Billy the Kid" is to be the attraction at the Grand the first half of this week and will be offered at strictly popular prices. Matinee on Wednes

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Paper unidentified

This is an advertisement and brief review for a stage melodrama titled 'Billy, the Kid' by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, playing at the Grand Opera House. It describes the play as blending 'scenes from real life' into a dramatic story, part of a season of entertainment listings.

Paper unidentified · 21 December 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

GRAND OPERA HOUSE. XMAS WEEK. MONDAY, TUESDAY, WEDNESDAY. "Billy the Kid" Regular Prices. Mat. Wednesday.

THURS., XMAS DAY, SAT. THE SANTA CLAUS SHOW. "It's Never too Late to Mend."

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This is a theater advertisement announcing the melodrama 'Billy, the Kid' by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, opening at the Grand Opera House with Frederic Santley in the title role. It promotes the production as an elaborate melodrama blending scenes from real life into a strong story.

Paper unidentified · 21 December 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

AT THE GRAND.

In "Polly of the

drawn all telling the story which is full of interest. It is said to be a most excellent vehicle for Frederic Santley, who in the stellar role is reported to have a part which fits him perfectly. The management is reported to have given the play an elaborate production and to have surrounded the star with a company of exceptional merit. "Billy, the Kid," with Mr. Frederic Santley in the title role is to be the attraction at the Grand Opera House opening to-night, matinee Wednesday.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A theater column describes the melodrama 'Billy the Kid,' by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, starring Frederick Santley's company, opening for a three-day run at the Grand Opera House. The piece is advertised among other local stage attractions as blending 'scenes from real life' into a strong story.

The New Haven Union · 21 December 1908 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

days.

Scenes from real life carefully blended together into a strong story are said to be the ergo of "Billy the Kid," by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, which Frederick Santley is presenting this season. "Billy the Kid," with Mr. Santley in the title role, is to be the attraction at the Grand Opera house for three days, opening tonight.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A newspaper notice promotes the play 'Billy, the Kid' by Joseph Santley and Walter Woods, starring young actor Frederick Santley, playing at the Grand theater. The melodrama is set in four acts in New Mexico, featuring characters drawn from life with comedic elements and novel staging effects.

Paper unidentified · 23 December 1908 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

many kinds abound and there is said to be lots of comedy. The action of the play is placed in four acts, all of which are laid in New Mexico. The characters are interesting types and are for the most part drawn from life. At the head of his company of well known players and with an elaborate production, Mr. Santley is playing in "Billy, the Kid," at the Grand Opera House matinee to-day.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

An advertisement announces a theatrical production titled 'Billy the Kid' playing at the Grand Opera House over Christmas week, Monday through Wednesday at regular prices with a Wednesday matinee. The ad is surrounded by unrelated department store sale listings and other theater advertisements.

Paper unidentified · 23 December 1908 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

XMAS WEEK. MONDAY, TUESDAY, WEDNESDAY. "Billy the Kid" Regular Prices. Mat. Wednesday.

THURS., XMAS DAY, SAT. THE SANTA CLAUS SHOW.

See the clipping

The Manning Times · Manning, S.C.

This article recounts the legendary exploits of Billy the Kid during the Lincoln County cattle wars, describing him as a fearless young outlaw who terrorized New Mexico. It recounts how Sheriff Pat Garrett was finally tasked with ending his reign of terror, leading to the outlaw's death at twenty-one.

The Manning Times · 30 December 1908 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

A NOTORIOUS OUTLAW

that attracted him to Lincoln county. With the band of desperadoes he led he raided ranches, "shot up" towns, killed, burned houses and committed outrage after outrage with the blind recklessness of a maniac. Fear was extinct within him. He cared no more for detachments of cavalry than he did for cowering sheriffs.

Affairs in New Mexico finally came to such a pass that half the cattlemen paid the youthful desperado tribute. It was only after Pat F. Garrett was made sheriff of Lincoln county and the author of "Ben-Hur" (General Wallace) [u]rged that fearless gun fighter a[nd] [g]ambler to capture Billy the Kid

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

A 1908 anecdote recounts a violent poker dispute in which a chief engineer gouged out gambler Red O'Malley's eye before being stabbed to death. The tale notes that O'Malley later fled to Tucson, where he was shot dead by Billy the Kid while dealing faro.

The Laramie Republican · 30 December 1908 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

"O'Malley jumped to Tucson, where in the mid seventies he was shot to death by Billy the Kid while dealing faro bank for that indiscriminate young killer."

See the clipping