As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

April 1908

13 articles

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This 1908 feature reports the death of Pat Garrett, recalling his fame as the lawman who killed Billy the Kid decades earlier in New Mexico. It reflects on the vanished 'open range' era of the Old West as context for his career.

Omaha Daily Bee · 5 April 1908 · page 45 · transcribed from the page image

PASSING OF "PAT" GARRETT: Career of the Celebrated Peacemaker of the Southwest. FEARLESS FOE OF DESPERADOES. Man Who Got "Billy the Kid" and Others of His Class Falls a Victim to a Hireling's Bullet.

Another character of the "open range" days in the west has passed in the person of Patrick F. Garrett, some time captain of the Texas Rangers, a celebrity of New Mexico, and a friend of President Roosevelt. The newspapers of March 1 said that "Pat" Garrett had been shot, and the next day the incident was forgotten; at least, in this section of the country. But in New Mexico, Garrett will be remembered as the man who "put out the lights" of Billy the Kid, one of the most famous American outlaws.

Conditions in New Mexico have changed, and now one can view buttes and prairie from the observation car. The old "open range" days may be rightfully called the age of lawlessness. By the term "open

See the clipping

In the story →

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · and 1 other paper

The article reports the shooting death of Pat Garrett near Las Cruces and recalls his earlier fame for killing Billy the Kid in 1880. It repeats the legendary claim that the Kid was a 21-year-old outlaw who had killed 21 men.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Rock Island Argus · 8 April 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

ENEMY OF THE BAD

Pat Garrett, Slayer of "Billy the Kid," Has Been in Many Daring Exploits.

See moreSee less

SKILLED AS REVOLVER SHOT

How Hunter of Notorious Outlaw Who Recently Died With His Boots on, Disposed of Desperado.

Patrick F. Garrett, the former sheriff of Dona Ana county, in Texas, who was recently shot and killed by J. Wayne Brazle, a youthful ranchman, one of his tenants, near Las Cruces, N. M., in a dispute over a ranch lease, won popular fame in 1880 when he put to an end the bloody career of "Billy the Kid," the twenty-one-year-old bandit, who had killed twenty-one men "just to see them kick." For two years or more "the Kid" had been the terror of New Mexico with his thieving, marauding and his frequently recurring man killings. He had met all comers, and they were easy, but he hadn't met Pat Garrett. When he did, he erred.

Garrett had first come into notice as a foe of "bad men" in New Mexico about two years before he finally hunted down and killed the notorious "Kid," and he was anything except a green man at the game of fighting desperate criminals when the climax of his career came. Along about 1878, when Garrett was first made sheriff of Lincoln county, largely through the influence of General Lew Wallace, then governor of New Mexico, no one knew much about the young officer or of his mode of handling a gun, says the Kansas City Star. One day a friendly desperado, attracted by Garrett's innocent appearance, took him aside for a bit of counsel and advised him to go back to Texas, where there were lucid intervals of peace sometimes.

"This country is too warm for the like o' you," urged the desperado, "and you'll not last through the summer."

"Thanks," drawled Pat Garrett. "I can stand considerable heat, and I guess I'll stay."

It was said of Garrett that he could pull and shoot in about the time it takes a fly to get from under the hand that tries to catch it, and it seems to have been literally true.

Garrett gave the first demonstration of his skill with the revolver for the benefit of a western gentleman indulging in a little western saloon merriment. The gentleman, one Greenfelt, with a weakness for other men's horses, was amusing himself in a saloon making a couple of men dance by shooting at their feet. A third, whose terpsichorean skill or bashfulness had met the disapproval of the horse thief, lay on the floor with a bullet inconveniently concealed in his person when Pat Garrett casually dropped in.

"Three hands around!" whooped the horse thief, shifting his pistol toward Garrett, and almost on the last word he lunged forward on his face with a bullet through his heart. The last sound he heard in this world was Garrett's drawling comment:

"You're a poor caller."

Gave His First Demonstration.

Garrett had a number of other adventures before he finally came to the point in his life where "Billy the Kid" demanded his attention. But that time finally came. The bandit had just been out on one of his usual forays, which terminated in a saloon brawl and the ruthless killing of a man. It was the outlaw's twenty-first victim and his last.

When Garrett set out for "the Kid" he departed on no ordinary mission even for a man used to the capture and killing of border outlaws. The bandit was a wild and lawless youth, cunning, brave and dashing and as clever and fast with a gun as any man that ever trod the west, even though he was only a boy in years. Billy was both unscrupulous and cunning, albeit not without a leaven of chivalry and romance. His adventures had been numerous, and he was New Mexico's desperado hero, but Garrett didn't mind.

When the plucky sheriff overtook the bandit, "the Kid" took a look at his opponent, whom he knew immediately by repute, and decided that it was better to give up. He was tried and convicted of murder and sentenced to death. But the bandit was destined to die in another fashion than on the scaffold. Two careless deputies were outwitted, and he escaped.

A less experienced man would have gone out in pursuit while the trail was hot. Not so Garrett, who knew the ways of the desperate and wily outlaw. Instead he set out for the Maxwell ranch, near Carizzoo, in Lincoln county, where "the Kid's" sweetheart lived. Garrett and his men lay in wait until they saw a man dodge into the house under cover of the night. Garrett single handed slipped in after him and posted his men on the porch. Garrett knew Maxwell and walked to his room to ask whether the bandit had come in. Maxwell was asleep and had to be awakened. He knew nothing of "the Kid" and wasn't expecting him, but Garrett was pretty certain and on guard. He had just turned from Maxwell's bed in the darkness when "the Kid" entered the room. There was a tense moment. The bandit advanced to the bed, believing to speak to Maxwell.

"Who are they?" he asked, noticing the men on the porch.

In an instant he knew that Maxwell was not alone. The boy bandit made a quick, catlike move backward and whipped out his gun with incredible swiftness, but he was yet too slow. A bullet from Garrett's gun made him a bandit no longer. Garrett filled his own prophecy that he would die with his boots on.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut · 9 March 1908

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

This feature recounts anecdotes about Pat Garrett's gunfighting skill, including killing a horse thief in a saloon, before describing his eventual pursuit of Billy the Kid. It claims the Kid's last saloon killing was his twenty-first victim, dramatizing his reputation as a fast, dangerous outlaw.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Rock Island Argus · 8 April 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

terpsichorean skill or bashfulness had met the disapproval of the horse thief, lay on the floor with a bullet inconveniently concealed in his person when Pat Garrett casually dropped in.

"Three hands around!" whooped the horse thief, shifting his pistol toward Garrett, and almost on the last word he lunged forward on his face with a bullet through his heart. The last sound he heard in this world was Garrett's drawling comment:

See moreSee less

"You're a poor caller."

Gave His First Demonstration.

Garrett had a number of other adventures before he finally came to the point in his life where "Billy the Kid" demanded his attention. But that time finally came. The bandit had just been out on one of his usual forays, which terminated in a saloon brawl and the ruthless killing of a man. It was the outlaw's twenty-first victim and his last.

When Garrett set out for "the Kid" he departed on no ordinary mission even for a man used to the capture and killing of border outlaws. The bandit was a wild and lawless youth, cunning, brave and dashing and as clever and fast with a gun as any man that ever trod the west, even though he was only a boy in years. Billy was both unscrupulous and cunning, albeit not without a leaven of chivalry and romance. His adventures had been numerous, and he was New Mexico's desperado hero, but Garrett didn't mind.

When the plucky sheriff overtook the bandit, "the Kid" took a look at his opponent, whom he knew immediately by repute, and decided that it was better to give up. He was tried and convicted of murder and sentenced to death. But the bandit was destined to die in another fashion than on the scaffold. Two careless deputies were outwitted, and he escaped.

A less experienced man would have gone out in pursuit while the trail was hot. Not so Garrett, who knew the ways of the desperate and wily outlaw. Instead he set out for the Maxwell ranch, near Carizzoo, in Lincoln county, where "the Kid's" sweetheart lived. Garrett and his men lay in wait until they saw a man dodge into the house under cover of the night. Garrett single handed slipped in after him and posted his men on the porch. Garrett knew Maxwell and walked to his room to ask whether the bandit had come in. Maxwell was asleep and had to be awakened. He knew nothing of "the Kid" and wasn't expecting him, but Garrett was pretty certain and on guard. He had just turned from Maxwell's bed in the darkness when "the Kid" entered the room. There was a tense moment. The bandit advanced to the bed, believing to speak to Maxwell:

"Who are they?" he asked, noticing the men on the porch.

In an instant he knew that Maxwell was not alone. The boy bandit made a quick, catlike move backward and whipped out his gun with incredible swiftness, but he was yet too slow. A bullet from Garrett's gun made him a bandit no longer. Garrett filled his own prophecy that he would die with his boots on.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This is a theater advertisement/notice announcing a production of 'Faust' starring Miss Olga Verne at the New Haven theater, with a detailed plot summary of the opera. It also mentions 'Billy the Kid' as a return engagement, though no details about that production are given in this excerpt.

Paper unidentified · 18 April 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

AT THE NEW HAVEN

Miss Olga Verne in "Faust"— "Billy the Kid" in Return Engagement

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

This is a theatrical review describing the stage play 'Billy the Kid' starring Joseph Santley, touring to the New Haven theater, alongside a plot summary of 'Faust.' It praises the play's depiction of New Mexico border life and highlights a comic scene involving a morphine mix-up.

Paper unidentified · 18 April 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy the Kid."

One of the most amusing scenes in the melodrama, "Billy the Kid" which Joseph Santley is successfully presenting this season occurs in the fourth act of the play. One of the

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A newspaper theater column describes the melodrama 'Billy the Kid,' starring Joseph Santley, playing at the New Haven theater for a return engagement. It highlights a novel character type in the play, a tough dance-hall woman from the western frontier, as part of the production's appeal.

Paper unidentified · 20 April 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy the Kid."

A type practically unknown in the east is presented in the melodrama "Billy the Kid" which Joseph Santley is presenting with great success this season. The type in question is the tough specimen of femininity which is to be found only in perfection in the so-called dance hall, always attached to a saloon, in the far western country. She is bad all the way through, made so perhaps by her constant contact with the rougher element one finds in such places. But because she is outside the pale does not imply that these women are entirely devoid of everything that is good, for in the play is one, taken from real life, who does much to help

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A newspaper theater column describes Joseph Santley's touring stage production titled 'Billy the Kid,' a four-act play set in New Mexico, noting its strong cast and elaborate scenic effects. The piece reports the play's return engagement at the New Haven theater after an earlier successful run.

The New Haven Union · 21 April 1908 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

The company which has been engaged for the support of Mr. Santley is reported to be one of exceptional strength and the production of the play elaborate. "Billy the Kid," with Mr. Santley as the hero, is to come to the New Haven theater Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights this week, with matinee Saturday. This play was seen here earlier this season and scored a big success warranting a return engagement.

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A theatrical production titled 'Billy, the Kid' starring actor Joseph Santley is set to play at the New Haven theater for several nights. The piece notes the popularity of western-themed dramas and Santley's success touring popular price circuits.

The New Haven Union · 23 April 1908 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

AMUSEMENTS NEW HAVEN.

The west has furnished much material for the dramatist and plays that are typical of the west have generally met with a great deal of success. The latest play with a western atmosphere to make a bid for popular favor is called, "Billy, the Kid," and it serves as a vehicle to exploit the talents of the well known young actor, Joseph Santley. Santley has been touring the popular price circuits for several years with much profit and success and in his latest play he is said to have surpassed all his former efforts.

See moreSee less

"Billy, the Kid" will be seen at the New Haven theater tonight, Friday and Saturday nights and at the matinee Saturday.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A local newspaper reports on the successful return engagement of the melodrama "Billy, the Kid" at a New Haven theater. The piece praises the production and notes cast members including A. F. Nail as "Uncle Joe" and William A. Rolsten as "Brick-top Mike."

Paper unidentified · 24 April 1908 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

NEW HAVEN. Successful Return Engagement of "Billy, the Kid." Last Night. "Billy the Kid" played a return engagement last night and that the honor was appreciated was evidenced by

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A review describes a stage production titled 'Billy the Kid' performed at the New Haven theater, starring Joseph Santley who wrote the piece himself. The review discusses the plot involving a cowboy turned outlaw and praises Santley's performance while noting other actors had minor roles.

The New Haven Union · 24 April 1908 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

NEW HAVEN. "Billy the Kid" was the attraction at the New Haven theater last evening where Joseph Santley, the young actor, played the title role before a good sized

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

A review describes a theatrical production of 'Billy the Kid' starring Joseph Bantley, set in New Mexico with saloon and dance hall scenes. The play dramatizes a fictionalized story of frontier life, with a heroine saved from a villainous saloon master, playing to a large audience with another performance scheduled.

Paper unidentified · 25 April 1908 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy the Kid." There was another large audience at the New Haven theatre last night to see the presentation of "Billy the Kid" with Joseph Santley, the clever young actor in the stellar role. The play tells a powerful story of certain phases of the freer life of the great southwest, for the scenes of the play are all laid

See the clipping

The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.

A New Haven newspaper reports on a theatrical production of 'Billy the Kid' starring Joseph Santley, noting strong attendance, a good supporting cast, and fine scenic effects. The item appears within a roundup of local theater news covering multiple shows at different venues.

The New Haven Union · 25 April 1908 · page 7

NEW HAVEN. There was another large audience at the New Haven theater last night to see the presentation of “Billy the Kid,” with Joseph Santley, the clever young actor in the stellar role. The supporting company Is a good one and the scenic effects are fine. The play will be presented again today, matinee and night. Joseph King’s “East Lynne” com pany will appear at the New Haven theater April 30, May 1 and 2, with matinee Saturday, and has been the recipient of much flattering attention at the hands of newspaper critics.

See the clipping

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

The article reports William S. Brady's appointment as Lincoln County sheep inspector, noting he is the son of Sheriff William Brady, who was assassinated by Billy the Kid in 1878. It recounts that the Kid was later killed by Pat Garrett at Fort Sumner.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 27 April 1908 · page 8

W. S. BRADY NAMED AS SHEEP INSPECTOR

ritorial nenitentiarv .for tho nast five " 4 L. 1 1 committee announced in months, has resigned and left today mt lowu for his southern home. Me la to be aaiuroay evenings xsew Mexican. appointed sheep inspector for Lincoln Governor George Curry had tele eountr. 'Mr. nrndv is n son nt th grapnea asKing ex-uovernor m. a. late William Brady, sheriff of Linotero to represent him upon the oc coin county, during what was known casion and Attorney J. M. Hervey, Ad ns tho Lincoln county war in 1877 and Jutant General A.

See moreSee less

P. Tarkington and 1S78. and was a brave and fearless other territorial officials ably second officer. He was assassinated In the 0(1 tne effort9 ot Mayr Je DSena streets of Lincoln April 1st, 1878, by t0 ve tno visitors aa pleasant an im the notorious "Billy the Kid," who Presslon of Santa Fe as pos

See the clipping