As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

March 1906

7 articles

Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D.

A reminiscence about a 1868 poker game dispute in Benicia, California, involving faro dealer Jack Caton and a steamship chief engineer unfamiliar with local poker customs. The story mentions in passing that Caton was later shot and killed by Billy the Kid in Arizona many years afterward.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Kingsbury County Independent · 9 March 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

look it over.' "Now, in those days Jack Caton—who was shot and killed by Billy the Kid in Arizona, many years later—was about the hottest poker player on the Pacific slope. He ran faro games in most of the sizeable towns in California for the money there was in it, but he just played draw poker for fun. And he always played on the level, for he wasn't a man who cared to mix pleasure with business, and he wouldn't have found any entertainment in stacking the papers or dealing from the bottom or middle in any game that he got into just to enjoy the study of the percentages. "When I went upstairs to the poker

See the clipping

Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D.

A serialized fiction piece describes a deadly poker dispute in which a gambler named Caton kills a chief engineer over a card hand, then flees to Arizona. The narrator notes that in the 1870s Caton himself was shot dead by Billy the Kid while dealing faro bank for him.

Kingsbury County Independent · 9 March 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ribbons. "Caton jumped to Arizona, where, late in the '70s, he was shot to death by Billy the Kid, while dealing faro bank for that slender desperado."

See the clipping

Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D.

A card game argument over whether a straight flush beats a full house ends with the chief engineer gouging out Caton's eye, then being stabbed to death by Caton. The story claims Caton later fled to Arizona, where he was shot dead by Billy the Kid while dealing faro.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 6 days earlier.

Forest City Press · 15 March 1906 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

"Caton jumped to Arizona, where, late in the '70s, he was shot to death by Billy the Kid, while dealing faro bank for that slender desperado."

See the clipping

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

A 'This Date in History' column lists notable events that occurred on March 17 throughout history. Among dozens of unrelated entries, it notes that in 1882 'Billy the Kid' was captured in Minneapolis.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Lewiston Evening Teller · 17 March 1906 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THIS DATE IN HISTORY

1878—Great strike of weavers

in England.

See moreSee less

1882—"Billy the Kid" captured

in Minneapolis.

1883—Collision on Edinburgh &

Glasgow railroad at Central

station; 74 killed.

1885—One hundred and thirty-

seven miners suffocated in

Rhenish Prussia.

See the clipping

The Minneapolis Journal · Minneapolis, Minn.

A historical almanac column marking March 17 cites various past events, including the 1882 capture of 'Billy the Kid' in Minneapolis. The item is a brief one-line entry among other historical dates and events.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Minneapolis Journal · 17 March 1906 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THIS DATE IN HISTORY

1716—First person inoculated for smallpox in England.

1782—John C. Calhoun born. Died March 31. 1850.

See moreSee less

1837—Grover Cleveland born.

1863—Prince William George of Denmark elected king of Greece.

1865—Battle of Bentonville, N. C.

1871—Communist uprising in Paris.

1873—San Salvador destroyed by an earthquake.

1882—"Billy the Kid" captured in Minneapolis.

1897—Fitzsimmons defeats Corbett at Carson City.

See the clipping

Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · and 6 other papers

This is a daily historical almanac column listing notable events that occurred on March 29 across many years, including a brief line stating 'Billy the Kid' was captured in Minneapolis in 1882. It is a retrospective listing format covering dozens of unrelated historical events.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Valentine Democrat · 29 March 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

1875—Tornado devastated Rienzi, Miss.

1878—Great strike of weavers in England....O'Donovan Rossa riot in Toronto.

See moreSee less

1882—"Billy the Kid" captured in Minneapolis.

1883—Collision on Edinburgh and Glasgow railroad at Central station; seventy-four killed....Alleged attempt to assassinate Lady Florence Dixie at Windsor.

1884—Egyptian troops defeated at Khartoum....Tribal rising in Egypt from

See the clipping

Also printed in 6 papers
  • Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 29 March 1906
  • Hot Springs Weekly Star · Hot Springs, S.D. · 30 March 1906
  • Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis. · 3 April 1906
  • The Western News · Stevensville, Mont. · 2 May 1906
  • Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T. · 7 May 1906
  • The Caldwell Tribune · Caldwell, Idaho Territory Idaho · 12 May 1906

Paper unidentified

This is a newspaper almanac feature listing historical events that occurred on March 29th across many years. One entry claims 'Billy the Kid' was captured in Minneapolis in 1882.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Paper unidentified · 29 March 1906 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

1878—Great strike of weavers in England....O'Donovan Rossa riot in Toronto. 1882—"Billy the Kid" captured in Minneapolis. 1883—Collision on Edinburgh and Glasgow railroad at Central station; seventy-four killed....Alleged attempt to assassinate Lady Florence Dixie at Windsor. 1884—Egyptian troops defeated at Khartoum....Tribal rising in Egypt from

See the clipping