As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

March 1901

2 articles

The Aegis & Intelligencer · Bel Air, Md.

A survivor recalls a shootout near Stone's ranch where Exelby's gang was ambushed, resulting in multiple deaths including Jack O'Hara and Exelby himself. He claims Billy the Kid took part in the fight and was later killed alone by Fred Williams weeks afterward.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 188 days later.

Wrong

The Aegis & Intelligencer · 1 March 1901 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

THE EXELBY OUTLAWS.

halt we opened fire.

"We had hardly pulled a trigger when the bullets began to whistle around us from the other side of the gully, and we woke to the fact that Billy the Kid, who had staid behind in the saloon to fix his

See the clipping

White Oaks Eagle · White Oaks, N.M.

The report recounts Billy the Kid's violent reputation, including his role in the Lincoln County War and the killings of Brady, Carlisle, Bell, and Olinger, before praising Sheriff Pat Garrett's cunning and bravery in finally capturing and killing him. It calls for the public to reward Garrett monetarily for his service.

White Oaks Eagle · 7 March 1901 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Too much credit cannot be acceeded to Mr. Garrett, for his successful work at the time when we least suspected what he was doing, we find him quietly laying his plans and making certain the capture of the most daring and dangerous character on record.

It is needless to say that much ingenuity, discretion and good judgment was required to effect what Mr. G. did. The "Kid" had those near him who gave him all the assistance they could, in warning him of danger, and of the presence of strangers, and suspicious persons.

See moreSee less

But with these odds against him and with the fact staring him in the face, that he was after the worst type of a man, who would not be taken alive, Mr. Garrett ventured all. It is not

See the clipping