The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.
A freighter recounts meeting Billy the Kid on the trail near Fort Sumner, then finding a dead man in a saloon after the Kid's gang caroused there. The man, Jeff Grant, had secretly joined the rustlers to collect reward money but was shot by Billy during a reckless bet involving a revolver with a dud cartridge.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 25 days later.
Wrong
The Butler Weekly Times · 20 December 1894 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
"It was Billy the Kid that I had met, and he had come into Fort Sumner that morning with his gang of rustlers, Dave Rudebaugh, Tom