As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

November 1894

2 articles

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A group of men debate stereotypes about western desperadoes, arguing that most famous outlaws had fair hair and blue eyes rather than the dark, swarthy look of legend. Among those discussed is Billy the Kid, said to have killed one man for each of his 23 years before Pat Garrett shot him in Mexico.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Herald · 3 November 1894 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

SOMETHING ABOUT BANDITS.

but red moustache and blue eyes. King Fisher, one of the same gang, had a smaller record still, he having only killed four men, but he had similar hair and eyes, with a sandy moustache. Jim Conroy, who had the scrap with Ben Porter, the actor, and pumped lead into Maurice Barrymore by mistake, was as mild looking as a school girl, with light brown hair and blue eyes. Then there was Billy the Kid, who had a record whe[n] Pat Garrett shot

See the clipping

The Advance · Jamesburg, N.J.

A frontier preacher asks a gambler nicknamed 'Billy the Kid' to take up the church collection at a mining camp dance hall. When a miner donates only a quarter, Billy draws his revolver and insists on a full dollar, collecting handsomely from the rest of the crowd.

The Advance · 15 November 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TAKING UP A COLLECTION. "We have a certain parson," Dean Hert of Denver writes, giving his name, "whom we keep on the frontier. He is a rough diamond, and has a knack with the miners. Not long ago he went to a camp called Rico, borrowed the dance hall over the saloon for his service, 'rounded up his boys' and the hall was filled. After the sermon came the collection—a very important feature. The preacher ran his eye over his audience, and seeing a certain gambler known as 'Billy the Kid,' 'Billy,' he said, 'take up the collection.'

See moreSee less

Very much honored, Billy took his big sombrero hat, and with an important and dignified air, as was fitting for the occasion, he made his way to the front and held his hat for a young man on the foremost chair to 'donate.' "The young miner dropped in a quarter. Billy looked at it; then putting his hand under his coat-tails drew his revolver and said, with the utmost gravity, 'Young man, take that back; this here's a dollar show.' Then, with his hat and revolver, moving around the hall, he got as many dollars as there were people."

See the clipping