As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

May 1887

9 articles

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont. · and 2 other papers

A humorous anecdote describes a storytelling contest between Col. Thomas Ochiltree and an Arkansas rival, where outlandish frontier tales are traded to see who can out-lie the other. Billy the Kid is cited alongside other invented gunslinger lore as an example of exaggerated frontier violence used to test Ochiltree's drowsy skepticism.

Helena Weekly Herald · 5 May 1887 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

COL. OCHILTREE.

thoughtfully. One man said he had seen Billy the Kid shoot two men in succession through the pockets of his ulster at a measured distance of seventy yards. Thomas' head drooped and he emitted a feeble snore. Another told a gory anecdote of Broncho

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Savannah Morning News · Savannah · 10 April 1887
  • The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands · 12 September 1887

Independent Statesman · Concord, N.H.

A man recalls his time in Dodge and claims to have known Billy the Kid, describing him as a slim, pale, blue-eyed young man who was deceptively innocent-looking but deadly with a gun. He asserts Pat Garrett did not give the Kid a fair chance when killing him, though argues Garrett was wise not to given the Kid's unmatched shooting skill.

Independent Statesman · 5 May 1887 · page 3

There was a look of great disgust on the | face of the man from Dodge the other day | when the reporter saw him, and he appeared to be dejected as well. ‘I hev ben fizurin’ on goin’ back to Dodge,” said he, “but that sclieme is busted; 1 see by the telegraph items | in the newspapers that the s’loons is all ¢losed | down there, and what is life wuth livin’ fur | whur the s’loons is all shet up? Dut that | wasz't what [ was goin’ to talk about.

See moreSee less

I was | readin’ ‘bout fellers that was handy with the gun an’ how fast tl:ey could {al the hammer, : There was something about Pat Garrett's | killin? Billy the Kid. Now 1t happened that I was down that way when the Kid was kLilled |

See the clipping

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont. · and 1 other paper

A former sheriff explains gun-fanning and trigger techniques to a reporter, boasting about his own quickdraw skills. He claims Pat Garrett fired two shots into Billy the Kid's heart before the body hit the floor.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 7 May 1887 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

QUICK ON TRIGGER. "Do all cowboys adopt this plan?" "Oh, no. Most of them cock the pistol with the left forefinger, but some prefer to leave the trigger free and with each shot apply the slight pressure of the right forefinger necessary to discharge the weapon. There is no pressure to speak of on the trigger, however, and the aim is never spoiled. With a hair trigger you have only to hold the gun straight and you'll get there. When I was sheriff down in Grant I always went around with my trigger tied back, and I never carried a self cocker.

See moreSee less

Yet I could shoot as quick as any man. If I hadn't I would not be here now. There's Pat Garrett, who used to be sheriff of Lincoln county, which he is now

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Hoof and Horn · Prescott, Ariz. · 31 March 1887

The Arizona Sentinel · Arizona City Yuma, Ariz.

A man recounts being mistakenly arrested as a pickpocket, with the arresting officer jokingly comparing him to 'Billy the Kid' due to his looks. The piece is a comic human-interest story, using the outlaw's name as a cultural byword rather than reporting on him directly.

The Arizona Sentinel · 14 May 1887 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

he hasn't got your wallet as well.

The old man was going down into his hind pocket to see if his calf-skin was safe as we left, and one or two people who were coming in had the kindness to remark that I had the look of a born thief.

See moreSee less

"Ah! you bet he has!" chuckled the officer as he gave me an affectionate look. "If I haven't got the darbies on the wrists of Billy the Kid I'm no good!"

See the clipping

Crystal River Current · Crystal, Colo.

A gunslinger describes techniques like 'fanning the hammer' and praises single-action pistols over double-action ones. He recounts how Pat Garrett killed Billy the Kid, claiming Garrett fired two shots into the Kid's heart in rapid succession before the body hit the floor.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.

Wrong

Crystal River Current · 14 May 1887 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

That's where it got its name. "Do all cowboys adopt this plan?" "O, no. Most of them cock the pistol with the left fore finger, but some prefer to leave the trigger free, and with each shot apply the slight pressure of the right fore finger necessary to discharge the weapon. There is no pressure to speak of on the trigger, however, and the aim is never spoiled. With a hair trigger you have only to hold the gun straight and you will get there. When I was sheriff, down in Grant, I always went around with my trigger tied back, and I never carried a self cocker.

See moreSee less

Yet I could shoot as quick as any man. If I hadn't I would not be here now. There's Pat Garrett, who used to be sheriff of Lincoln county, which he is now trying to cut in half so as to make Pecos county. He never carried anything but a single-acting gun. When he shot Billy the Kid he put two balls side by side into Billy's heart before the body struck the floor. The first shot killed Billy, but Pat was not taking any chances, and he was working his pistol for all it was worth. Now that second ball had to follow pretty close after the first in order to get to the same spot before Billy dropped, didn't it? That shows what a good man with a good single-acting pistol could do." "So you would just as leave put your single-acting pistol against the new

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

This is a humor column joke about a wife reading a newspaper account of a prize fight between 'Little Mouse' and 'Billy the Kid,' with her husband asking who won before she finishes the article. It is a comedic filler piece using the name 'Billy the Kid' for a fictional boxer, unrelated to the historical outlaw.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 20 May 1887 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

All the News. Wife (reading the paper)—It's disgraceful that the papers should give such prominence to prize fighting. Here is an account of a fight between the "Little Mouse" and "Billy the Kid," nearly a column long. Husband—It's worse than disgraceful. Which whipped? Wife—I don't know. I haven't finished the article yet.—New York Sun.

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A man recently arrived from Dodge recounts his memories of Billy the Kid, describing him as the fastest gunhand in the Southwest and detailing his appearance and manner. He claims to have been nearby when Pat Garrett killed the Kid and asserts Garrett gave him no fair chance, though adds Billy could have outshot anyone anyway.

Rock Island Daily Argus · 25 May 1887 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

There was a look of great disgust on the face of the man from Dodge the other day when the reporter saw him, and he appeared to be dejected as well. "I hev ben figurin' on goin' back to Dodge," said he, "but that scheme is busted; I see by the telegraph items in the newspapers that the s'loons is all closed down there, and what is life wuth livin' fur whur the s'loons is all shet up? But that wasn't what I was goin' to talk about. I was readin' 'bout fellers that was handy with the gun an' how fast they could fan the hammer.

See moreSee less

There was something about Pat Garrett's killin' Billy the Kid. Now it happened that I was down that way when the Kid was killed an' know somethin' about it, an' I know too

See the clipping

Rock Island Daily Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A man who knew Billy the Kid reminisces about his character and skill, describing him as polite but deadly. He recounts witnessing Billy kill two cowboys who ambushed him, noting Billy's uncanny speed and marksmanship.

Rock Island Daily Argus · 25 May 1887 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Kid 'cause they'd heard so much about him. That time at least the Kid wasn't to blame. He hadn't killed no relatives of their'n. It wasn't very fur frm Socorro, which wasn't much more'n a village then, an' we was in camp when the Kid an' another fellow come up. Now we wasn't overglad to see Billy 'cause he had a hard name; they said he'd kill a man if he didn't happen to be stuck on the color o' his hair an' sich like. But we wasn't goin' to let on.

See moreSee less

That little devil was so sweet on us that you'd a thought butter would a been safe in his mouth, an' that made us more uneasy than ever, though there was ten o' us an' only two o' 'em, the Kid an' the feller with him. Well, as I was sayin', we was eatin' dinner, or supper, fer it was after sundown, when two fellers rode up. The Kid had seen 'em, but he never let on an' kept on eatin' as natural as if there wasn't nobody in a hundred miles that was goin' to hurt him. THEN LET LOOSE.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A narrator recounts a secondhand anecdote of Billy the Kid calmly eating supper before killing two ambushers near Socorro, each with a single shot through the heart. The tale emphasizes his nonchalance and deadly marksmanship as part of his legendary reputation.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 15 days earlier.

The Morning News · 29 May 1887 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

An Outlaw Relates How Two Cowboys' Lights Were Put Out.

From the Omaha World.

See moreSee less

"Billy, the Kid, was, an' no mistake, a holy terror. He was one of those strange things you come across onct in a lifetime, an' while he was as smooth an' pleasant a little feller as yer could wish to 'sociate with, he filled a feller with a sort o' awe—I think that's the word. He was slim an' light-haired, an' blue-eyed, an' his face was sort o' pale; his upper teeth stuck out a little bit, an' that made him look more innocent than ever. You somehow ain't afreared of a fellow whose teeth sticks out in front. He didn't weigh very much more than 130 pounds, an' he was a pleasant companion. His eyes were rather pleasant until he got mad, an' then they shot fire.

"I seen Billy kill two men, an' he did the job up clean. They never kicked, an' they had their lights put out in grand shape. They was cowboys, an' they swore they'd kill the Kid 'cause they'd heard so much about him. That time at least the Kid wasn't to blame. He hadn't killed no relatives of their'n. It wasn't very fur f'm Socorro, which wasn't much more'n a village then, an' we was in camp when the Kid an' another fellow come up. Now we wasn't overglad to see Billy 'cause he had a hard name; they said he'd kill a man if he didn't happen to be stuck on the color o' his hair an' sich like. But we wasn't goin' to let on. That little devil was so sweet on us that you'd a thought butter would a been safe in his mouth, an' that made us more uneasy than ever, though there was ten o' us an' only two o' 'em, the Kid an' the feller with him. Well, as I was sayin', we was eatin' dinner, or supper, fer it was after sundown, when two fellers rode up. The Kid had seen 'em, but he never let on an' kept on eatin' as nateral as if there wasn't nobody in a hundred miles that was goin' to hurt him.

"When the strangers got near enough to see the faces o' the fellers eatin' one of 'em said, 'There he is,' an' without more sayin' they let loose. I never saw anybody skin around so lively as the Kid did; he skipped six or eight feet an' I thought sure he was hit 'cause I've seen fellers do the same way when they had a bullet straight through the heart; but Billy he wasn't teched. The fellers on horseback let loose twict an' then Billy he up with his gun—he had one o' the purtiest Winchesters you ever laid your eyes on—an' fired twict. It was a bullet for each man, an' he brought 'em both, each one through the heart. Billy's pardner didn't seem ticularly nervous; he sat eatin' his supper all the time, an' seemed to think that the Kid could take care o' himself. When Billy had killed the fellers he sat down again an' finished his supper, an' then rode away. As he an' his pal was goin' Billy says to us: 'I'm in a hurry or I'd help you bury those ducks.'"

See the clipping