As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

October 1885

1 article

In the story →

Savannah Morning News · Savannah

This article describes how Pat Garret was persuaded to become Sheriff of Lincoln county, killed Billy the Kid and two others himself, and is portrayed as a tall, mild-mannered, modest hero despite his reputation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 161 days earlier.

Savannah Morning News · 29 October 1885 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

"In Lincoln county, N. M., one hears a great deal about the exploits of Billy the Kid and his gang, and how they were eventually cleaned out by Pat Garret, who was elected Sheriff for that purpose. It appears that Billy the Kid, who had killed, with Winchester and revolver, twenty-one men in that county, was the leader of a gang of thieves and murderers that stole horses and cattle as they pleased, and defied the authorities. The people finally became excited, and some of the leading men induced Pat Garret to accept the office of Sheriff.

See moreSee less

One of them told me that they obtained his consent to act by explaining to him that he was a quick, dead shot, and that the gang were afraid of him. They said: 'You can clean them out; you may get killed, but if you can get away with them you will make your reputation and fortune.' Pat Garret went to work without delay, and himself killed Billy the Kid and two of the gang, his deputies killed two more, and the rest fled from that part of the country. The result is that peace and order prevail, and Pat Garret is the hero of the county. "Having a curiosity to see the man I was one day brought face to face with him and introduced with the remark: 'This is Pat Garret.' He is a man about 6 feet 5 inches tall, with mild blue eyes and low, pleasant voice, and seemed to be too modest and backward to fight even if imposed upon. He was such an entirely different type to what my imagination pictured that I thought my friends were having a little joke at my expense, and I said to him: 'The boys are fooling me; you ain't Pat Garret.' He said, 'O I guess I am,' and then turned the conversation away from himself. There is nothing of the braggart about Pat Garret, and no one can get him to tell about what he did and how it was done except his intimate friends.

See the clipping