Arizona Citizen · Tucson, Ariz.
The article reports that Sheriff Brady and George Windman were shot dead at Lincoln, that Kid (alias Antrim) was wounded by Mathews while retrieving Brady's dropped rifle, and that McSween, Robert Widerman and W. P. Shields were arrested and held at Stanton.
Arizona Citizen · 26 April 1878 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
CIVIL WAR IN NEW MEXICO.
Reign of Terror in Lincoln County!
See moreSee less
The Mesilla Valley Independent inform us that affairs have reached a critical condition in Lincoln county. On Monday 1st instant, at the town of Lincoln, Sheriff Brady while walking towards the court-house in the plaza, was fired upon by a party of men posted on McSween's house, and instantly killed. George Windman was shot and killed same time. When Brady fell he dropped his rifle. Kid, alias Antrim, who it appears, was one of the attacking party ran out to secure it. He was fired upon by Mathews and wounded. McSween, Robert Widerman and W. P. Shields were subsequently arrested and taken to Stanton where they are held as prisoners.
On Thursday the 4th instant a party of fourteen regulators under command of Richard Brewer rode up to the Indian agency and Blazer's mill and dismounted and asked for food. Godfrey, the Indian agent, told them they might have dinner, which they partook of, leaving two of their party outside. While they were still inside a man named Roberts, whom they were in search of, rode up. He was evidently unaware that this party were inside and inquired if a posse had been there. He immediately discovered that he had committed a fatal mistake and indicated a disposition to sell his life dearly. Frank Coe came out and sat down by Roberts outside the house, and engaged him in conversation. In the meantime the balance of the party scattered out and disposed themselves, so as to obtain a cross fire on Roberts. Suddenly Coe sprang to one side, leaving Roberts standing alone, and the firing commenced. It is not positively known who fired the first shot. Roberts was shot in the side, the ball traversing the bowels and inflicting a fatal wound. He however, shot one of the attacking party, named Middleton, through the lungs. George Coe was shot through the hand and Bowder was slightly wounded in the side.
Roberts then took shelter in Doctor Blazer's room, barricaded the doors with matrasses, &c., and made a desperate fight, not for his life, for he was already a dead man to all intents. Brewer, who was very much engaged, ordered Dr. Blazer and Maj. Godfrey to turn Roberts out. This they refused to do. Brewer then threatened to burn the house unless the wounded man was turned over to him. Mrs. Godfrey pleaded with Brewer for the life of Roberts, who was a stranger to her, but without avail. Finding that the inmates of the house could not be persuaded or intimidated into turning Roberts over, Brewer proceeded to the sawmill, about one hundred and twenty-five yards from the door of the room in which Roberts had taken shelter, and getting behind a saw-log glanced over it at the door. Roberts caught a glimpse of the top Brewer's head and fired, the ball entering Brewer's eye, killing him instantly.
The band left shortly afterwards, taking with them Middleton, who is perhaps fatally wounded, and leaving Brewer's body, which was buried by Dr. Blazer and Maj. Godfrey the next day. Roberts died the following day.