Agent Miles reports that the Cheyenne, provoked by unpunished horse-thieves and loss of stolen ponies, have vowed to retaliate against buffalo hunters and border raiders rather than the government itself. He recommends separating the Cheyenne and Arapahoe, building temporary quarters, and sending additional agency staff to prevent a wider Indian war.
New-York Tribune · 10 July 1874 · page 1
THIEVES—A RECOMMENDATION
disposed, and many of them are yet so, toward the Goverment ; and it was not until they were forced to leave their reservation and agency to get rid of the porse-thicves and to reach the buffalo herds that they
Indian Affairs Superintendent Enoch Hoag writes to correct an earlier letter's claim that Agent Miles requested troops to control the Cheyennes. Hoag explains Miles actually sought police support to stop horse thieves and buffalo hunters whose unlawful killing of buffalo and theft of livestock had provoked the Indians into retaliation.
The Leavenworth Weekly Times · 16 July 1874 · page 2
INDIAN AFFAIRS
Lawbemck, Kas July 4, 1874. lion. D. R. Anthony, Editor of Timet: It is daa boh t the readers of The Times and mjself lLa a statement embraced in the Liter of "J. II. B.," written from Arkaneae C-ty, and appeuiag in Tub Times cf the 11th iast, be corrected. Said letter gives currency to tbe r.pert that Agent Miles a plied to me "some time ago for troops t help him control the Chey ennes," and that I replied that "if he c.uld not etiy then withe u; troops, 1 would send a man down there that coul '."
See moreSee less
No spflica ticn wae ev.r made t me by Ajent Miles for troops to eontrtl his Indians, but be did ask for police cr marshal force to enable him to rid the reservatioa of horse thieves, buffalo hunters aad ariuiry readers, who were
A telegram summarizes a letter from General Pope, commander of the Department of Missouri, denouncing illegal trading posts near Dodge City that sell liquor to buffalo hunters and ruffians invading Indian territory. Pope blames these unscrupulous traders for provoking violence against settlers and says he would send troops only to shut the posts down, not protect them.
The Findlay Jeffersonian · 17 July 1874 · page 2
NOT THE ONLY SUFFERERS. Gen. Pope, commanding the Depart ment of Missouri, in a recent letter to the Governor of Kansas, testifies that grog shops are producing their legiti mate fruits on the frontier, as well as in the more busy haunts of civilization. A telegram giving the wilistniice of his letter, says: General Poe says in relation to trail Ingflnusat Dodiie City who have, ill violation of law and to the incalculable injury of peaceable and honest farmers ana irontier settlers of Kansas, estab lished trading posts or rather grogshops in the "Pan Handle" of Texas, seventynve miles along the Arkansas to trade with buffalo hunters and riilllans. who have invaded the Indian countrv and
Indian Agent Miles reports to the Commissioner of Indian Affairs that troubles in the Cheyenne-Arapaho territory could have been avoided had troops been available to protect the reservation from buffalo hunters and horse thieves. He notes some chiefs attempted peace but were prevented by hostile Cheyennes, while Whirlwind's band remained friendly to whites.
Evening Star · 18 July 1874 · page 1
Indian Aobnt Miles, agent of the Chey ennes and Arrapaboes, Indian territory, re l<orts to the Commissioner 6f Indian affairs, un der date of the 10th inst., that in his opinion had he been furnished with a detachment of troops sufficient to protect the reservation rrom buffalo hunters and the continuous incursions
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A Board of Indian Commissioners committee reports forcing an agent to resign for being out of harmony with their peace-based principles, despite expressing personal kindness toward him. The report notes most tribes are prosperous and orderly, but in three southwestern agencies white intrusion, buffalo trade whiskey sales, and horse theft have led some chiefs and young men to retaliate with small war parties attacking a train, ranches, and buffalo hunters in the Texas Panhandle.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 18 July 1874 · page 1
ofllco. It is with great reeret that tho Committee have been forced to the above conclusion, and they desire in communicating it to him to assure him ol their leclings of personal kindnCBS toward him. Inlormation has been received or tho tribes under their chargo that a large proportion are in a prosperous condition. Civil order is well preserved. The schools and industrial operations are nourishing. In the throo southwestern agencies, cbieUy owing to the intrusion ot white men, who kill the buffalo trade with whisky and steal horses, some ol the chiefs and young men ol a few tribes have resolved on retaliation.
See moreSee less
Bmall war parties have attacked one train, a lew ranches and the buffalo hunters in the Panhandlo of Texas. We are hopeful that order and quiet may soon bo restored by the committee. Cyrus Bkde, Clerk pro pen.
Reports describe raids by combined Indian bands near Rawlins, prompting armed citizens to pursue them toward Wind River valley, while near Omaha, 200 Sioux attacked a mining camp at Seminole, killing one miner before military reinforcements were called in. An agency dispatch also blames unprotected reservations and buffalo hunters for provoking unrest.
Worcester Daily Press · 20 July 1874 · page 3
killed. A party of citizens, from Rawlins, Wyoming, well armed, started for Seminole yesterday, to assist the miners. Gov. Camp bell of Wyoming has telegraphed Gen. Ord for assistance from Fort Steele. Gen. Ord has ordered a company of cavalry to go at once by rail from Fort Russell. Several war parties are reported camped on Deer creek, near Fort Fetterman. A Curious Dispatch. Washington, July 13.—Agent Miles, of the Cheyenne and Arraphoes agency, writes under date of the 16th: “To-day, 1 do not hesitate to say that had we been furnished with a detachment of troops sufficient to have protected their own reservations from buffalo hunters and continuous incursions from White House thieves, all our present troubles would have been avoided.”
Indian agent Miles writes that without troops to protect reservations from buffalo hunters and horse-thieves, current troubles with the Cheyenne and Arapahoe could have been avoided. The letter, dated the 10th, blames the lack of military protection for provoking conflict.
The Portland Daily Press · 20 July 1874 · page 3
How to Make Bad Indians
How to ITIake Bad India’’*. Agent Miles of the Cheyenne and Arropa hoes agency, on tl e 10th iust., writes: ‘•To-day, 1 do not hesitate to say that had we been furnished with detachments of troops suf ncient to have prot< cted their own reservations from Buffalo hunters and continued incussions
Washington officials and Northwestern settlers disagree over whether recent disturbances are the start of a general Indian war, with settlers in Wyoming Territory believing it is. A Friends' Commission reports disturbances stem from misconduct by white buffalo hunters and whiskey sellers, not from the tribes themselves.
Wilmington Daily Commercial · 21 July 1874 · page 1
" iy that tho disturbances havo grown out of the J' 1 '* 'uduet of "white buffalo hunters and wliis Ke.v sellers," and that Sautanta and Big Tree are 1* »enable d true to their promises. The 1 *omuiI tarService, It ih the impression at the Post Offico depart "'ciit that notwithstanding the deolarod inteution "I l'n aiden t Hinckley, of the Philadelphia, Wil li Baltimore railroad, to withdraw tho mmgti from biH line ill insider his determination tho 1st proximo ho aud lot matters
Members of the Quaker Commission investigating Indian affairs reported that Cheyenne, Arapaho and some Comanche warriors were responsible for recent raids in the Southwest. They attributed the violence to young Indians retaliating against white buffalo hunters and whisky traders who had illegally entered Indian Territory, gotten Indians drunk, and stolen their possessions.
The Daily Argus · 21 July 1874 · page 1
St. Lous, July 20. Messrs. Hobbs. of Indiana ; Karle, of Massachusetts ; Tabor, of New York ; Rhodes, of Philadel phia ; and Johnson, ot Cincinnati, mem bers ot the Quaker Commission, which has control tno Indian policy, and who have been in Lawrance, Kan , to examine the condition of their agent, J. I). Miles, s.iy that KM or l.Ml Clieyetines ami .rrapalis ud a few Lmiiant-lie11 are the mn, Indians path in the Bnut'.i' a-t. lances are due to the lui faith of white buffalo hunter uu 1 whi.-ky traders, who have traiidlcntly entered the Indian territory and afier making the In dians drunk have stolen their possession and escaped This has been long endufed but now some young Indians, aggravated by repetitions and the slowness of redress, have attempted the punishment of them.
See moreSee less
New York, July 2o. Mayor Havemey er, a short time ago removed the Commis sioners of Aruioriea. and informed Gover nor lix of his acliou, giving his reasons thetefor. The Governor has declined to Con firm the action of the Mayor, and as sure him that the reasons a.-sigaed for the removal are sufficient for the continuance of the Board, and that the wer of re moval should be only exercised for grave causes.
Superintendent Enoch Hoag writes to correct an earlier Times letter claiming Agent Miles asked him for troops to control the Cheyennes. He clarifies Miles actually requested police/marshal force to remove horse thieves, buffalo hunters, and whiskey venders whose unlawful depredations—including buffalo slaughtered and left to rot—provoked the recent Indian outbreak.
Worcester Daily Spy · 21 July 1874 · page 2
liitlinn Affair*. A LETTER FROM SUPERINTENDENT IIOAG. Lawrence, Kan., July 4, 1874. Hon. D. li. Anthony, Editor Tinas: It is due both to the readers ot the Times and myself that a statement embraced iu the letter of “J. H. 8..” written from Arkansas t’ity. and ap pearing in the Times of the lltlt istst., be cor rected. Said letter gives currency to the report that Agent Miles applied to me “some time ago for troops to help him control the Cheyennes,” and that I replied that “if lie could not stay there without troops, I would send a man down there who could.” No application was over made to me hy Agent Miles for troops to con trol his Indians, but he did ask for police or marshal force to enable him to rid the reserva tion of horse thieves, buffalo hunters and whiskey venders, who were goading the Indians
Telegraphic reports describe an attack at Adobe Walls near Antelope Hills and a separate siege of 25 miners at the Seminole mines by 200-300 Indians, with troops being dispatched to help. A Quaker Commission investigating Indian Agent J. D. Miles reports only 100-150 young Cheyennes and Arapahoes are on the warpath, driven by grievances against white buffalo hunters and whisky sellers.
Helena Weekly Herald · 23 July 1874 · page 3
! hay«* been stung to seek mlress for wrongs ! j j «lone them by the xvliito buffalo hunters and j whisky sellers. The latter have frequently j J entered their b rritory, ami after getting them J j j ! |
The Highland Weekly News · Hillsborough Hillsboro, Ohio
A report describes a cavalry skirmish near Fort Fetterman and a larger three-hour battle in Lost Valley, Texas, where Kiowa, Comanche, and Apache fighters clashed with soldiers over buffalo hunting and settler encroachment. It also notes Quaker Indian agents resigning amid unrest blamed partly on whites killing buffalo and trading whiskey.
The Highland Weekly News · 23 July 1874 · page 2
Southwestern agencies, chiefly owing to the intrusion of white men who kill the buffalo trade in whisky, and steal horses, some of the chiefs and young men of a few of the tribes have resolved upon retaliation. Small war parties have attacked one train, a few ranches, and the buffalo hunters, in the panhandle of Texas. We are hopeful that order and quiet may soon be restored. Goldsmith Maid's 2:16 and 2:16,atEast Saginaw, are pronounced the two fastest heats record.
The report details correspondence between the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Secretary of War, and Indian agents regarding military measures against hostile tribes in Indian Territory. It cites the failure to protect reservation Indians from white buffalo hunters who slaughtered buffalo by the thousands and stole Indian ponies as a key cause of unrest.
The New York Herald · 26 July 1874 · page 7
SECRETARY OF WAR SAYS
of the proinilieui. causes which have led to the present stale of thing :?I-list, the ia.li.re to punish nut Comanche* according to promise lor tlie.r repeated ami I poish-nt rules ami murders la'iexas; and second, die j iitilure oi die government to protect tlie re-ervudou Indians irum the white buffalo hunters, lior-e thieves ami win-key traders, who have swaruieu over dns ituliun coon ry .luring die past wittier, slaughtering the Imrlnlo by die thou anils lor ilieir li des, and Ir ring oil large numhersoi Indian ponies io lean us. 1 oniy wish it were possible, under the luw. lor the lionorabie recretarj of war to send Ins lorces to tlm htmie. of iliose i. a auders |
Official correspondence between the Indian Commissioner, acting Interior Secretary, and Secretary of War discusses military action against hostile Indians while protecting friendly ones. The commissioner blames failures to punish Comanche raids and the government's failure to stop white buffalo hunters, horse thieves, and whisky traders from invading reservation lands as key causes of the unrest.
New Orleans Republican · 26 July 1874 · page 1
WASHINGTON
things. First—The failure to punish the Camanches, according to promise, for their repeated and persistent raids and murders in Texas; second, the failure of the gov ernment to protect the reservation Iudiaus from the white buffalo hunters, horse thieves and whisky traders, who have swarmed
The Commissioner of Indian Affairs outlines causes of unrest, citing failure to punish Comanche raids and failure to protect reservation Indians from white buffalo hunters who slaughtered buffalo by the thousands and stole Indian ponies. The Interior and War Departments exchange correspondence agreeing to strike hostile Indians while protecting friendly ones, and instruct agents to enroll friendly Indians for daily roll call.
National Republican (Washington City) · 27 July 1874 · page 4
INDIAN AFFAIRS.
come in; then oil who persist In hostility or who hove been guilty of murder should be pur. sued and punished. It Is proper In this connection that mention should be made of the prominent causes which have led to the present state of things. 1. The failure to pun ish the Cotnonchts according to premise for their repeated and persistent raids and murders lnTexss. 8. The failure of the Government to protect the reservation Inaians from the white buffalo hunters and horse thieves and whisky traders, why have swarmed over this Indian