Worcester Daily Press · Worcester, Mass.
This report records a session of the U.S. House of Representatives covering numerous bills, including one to tax buffalo hides which was referred to the committee of the whole. The bulk of the passage concerns unrelated legislative matters like tariffs, war debts, and the Geneva arbitration award debate.
Worcester Daily Press · 11 June 1874 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
FORTY-THIRD CONGRESS. FIRST SESSION.
WASHINGTON, June 10.
See moreSee less
Senate.
Mr. Sherman of Ohio presented petitions from New York and elsewhere in reference to the tax on leaf tobacco. Referred to the finance committee.
The moiety bill was then proceeded with, the question being on the motion of Mr. Conkling to amend the 29th section so as to provide that the bill shall not affect any suits or proceedings hereafter brought under existing laws.
Mr. Carpenter held that informers had vested rights which Congress could not take away, and for this reason he would vote for the amendment.
Mr. Saulsbury said these informers had become odious to the country and every trace of them should be wiped out.
Pending discussion Mr. Morton asked to take up the conference report on the currency bill. Objected to. Mr. Conkling presented the petition of Shepherd Knapp, Hatch & Foote, and 268 firms of bankers, brokers, etc., against the imposition of a tax on sales of coin and stocks. Referred to the finance committee.
Discussion on the moiety bill was continued at much length, during which customs detectives were attacked by some Senators and defended by others.
Mr. Sargent moved to amend the 12th section by striking out the penalty therein, and fixing a fine not exceeding $5000 or less than $500, or be imprisoned two years or over. Adopted.
Mr. Wright moved to insert the fifth section stricken out in committee of the whole, which provided for an examination of books and papers by order of a court.
Mr. Bayard moved to amend the section by allowing any merchant or agent to be present at any examination made by the attorney provided by the section. Adopted.
Mr. Bayard moved a further amendment to authorize the owner of any books to retain the custody of them except when under actual examination in court. Adopted.
Mr. Wright's amendment as amended was then agreed to and the bill was then passed—yeas 39, nays 3. The negative votes were Messrs. Flanagan, Howe and Pease.
The Senate then adjourned.
House of Representatives.
An hour after the reading of the journal having been assigned to the ways and means committee, and the regular order being demanded, Mr. Beck of Kentucky reported a bill for the relief of owners and purchasers of land in the insurrectionary states, and for district taxes. Referred to the committee of the whole.
Mr. Burchard of Illinois reported a bill for the relief of Messrs. Smith and Matthews of Illinois. Passed.
Mr. Roberts of New York reported a bill to admit free of duty merchandise sunk for over two years and afterwards recovered. Passed.
Mr. Foster of Ohio reported a bill to admit photographic and lithographic prints, views, &c., imported for scientific purposes, and not for sale. Referred to the committee of the whole.
Mr. Dawes then reported adversely upon a very large number of bills, with the recommendation that they be laid on the table. Objection was made to the tabling of some of them, and these were referred to the committee of the whole, as follows:
Bill declaratory of the meaning of the 39th section of the act of June 6, 1872, to reduce internal taxes and for other purposes; the bill to authorize the issue of 3.65 convertible bonds and reduce interest on the public debt; the bill to tax incomes over $3,000; the bill to repeal the duty on salt, and the bill to tax buffalo hides.
Mr. Dawes reported favorably the bill to amend section 1 of the act of May 17, 1872, in relation to abatement and repayment of taxes on distilled spirits in bond, destroyed by casualty. Passed.
Mr. Dawes also reported a bill to remit duties on certain goods destroyed by fire at the late great conflagration in Boston. Referred to the committee of the whole.
Mr. Wheeler of New York, from the conference committee, made a report on the army appropriation bill, which was concurred in.
The Geneva award bill then came up as unfinished business of yesterday.
Mr. Bass of New York argued that an award should be made to those who were declared by the tribunal at Geneva to be the losers.
Mr. Wilson of Indiana said the United States did not go to Geneva as the attorney for the claimants, but in its sovereign capacity, and had the right to use just such means as she saw fit to establish a claim on Great Britain. The money belonged to the United States, secured in the manner named, according to her sovereign will. He then argued that insurance companies had been remunerated from the war premiums, and that those who paid these premiums were in equity and justice the ones to be awarded to the amount of their losses.
Mr. Eldridge of Illinois argued that the money awarded at Geneva and paid by Great Britain should be covered into the treasury of the United States as the money of the nation. The complaint was that Great Britain had violated the neutrality law, and the award was made not for the damage done to vessels, but because of her wrong as a nation to the United States as a nation, and hence the fund was a national one.
Mr. Kellogg of Connecticut said he looked upon this subject as a question of common honor, decency and justice, whether the government would pay the money to those for whom it was collected. He cared not whether the losers were insurance companies or individuals; it was a violation of arbitration to distribute it otherwise.
Mr. Frye said the question had resolved itself into a fight between the insurance companies, mostly located in New York, and the people of the country. He charged upon Great Britian a motive in desiring to cripple our commerce when we were rapidly going on to the mastery of the seas. He scouted the idea that this country went to Geneva as a claim agent for New York insurance companies, without even a contingent fee. He commented in strong terms upon the power of insurance companies with their agents in every city, and the power to send their lawyers to the Geneva tribunals, and afterwards as their lobbyists on the floor of the House.
Mr. Tremain asked what authority he had for stating that Mr. Evarts was the attorney for the underwriters at Geneva.
Mr. Butler of Mississippi—His own statement before the judiciary committee.
Mr. Tremain said he had sent a letter here yesterday, denying it.
Mr. Butler—If he was here and made that statement I would throw it back to him.
Mr. Kellogg—He could not make the statement here. You could refuse to allow him.
Mr. Butler—I would not refuse him; I do not come from Connecticut. [Laughter.]
Mr. Frye continued his remarks in favor of the distribution of the award to the payers of war risks.
Mr. Butler demanded the previous question, and after much opposition obtained the floor, and said it must be the wealth and influence of the ring of insurance companies in New York, Boston, Philadelphia and Baltimore which could induce the gentleman from Vermont (Mr. Poland) to violate all rules of the House and endeavor to take him (Butler) off the floor, after he had listened two hours to the piteous appeal for the insurance companies. Mr. Butler concluded by advocating the bill of the majority as a simple measure of justice to the claimants.
Mr. Starkweather condemned the course of his colleague, Mr. Kellogg, in advocating the payment of insurance companies.
The question was then taken on the amendment offered by Mr. Frye of Maine to strike out the proviso admitting mutual insurance companies to a share of the award. All other amendments were rejected.
Mr. Poland's substitute was then rejected—yeas 92, nays 140.
The bill as reported by the committee was amended by 132 yeas to 101 nays, and the House adjourned.