As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · The full archive

August 1874

4 articles

Worcester Daily Spy · Worcester, Mass.

A Kansas newspaper correspondent's account of a bloody battle between soldiers and Osage Indians near Medicine Lodge is forwarded to Indian Affairs, but Agent Gibson's report tells a different story: Osage hunters drying buffalo meat were surrounded and disarmed by whites, and when some tried to flee, four were shot dead. The discrepancy between the sensational newspaper account and the agent's calmer account illustrates how such conflicts get exaggerated into 'Indian wars.'

Worcester Daily Spy · 21 August 1874 · page 1

HOW INDIAN WARS ARE ORIGINATED. Washington, Aug. 20.—Friend Enoch Hoag writes to the commissioners of Indian affairs, enclosing a letter printed in the Lawrence (Kan sas) Journal of the 12th inst., from r Barbour county correspondent, giving a glowing account of an encounter between the military and a band of sixty Osage Indian, on the 7th inst., near Medicine lodge, in which the writer states they killed five Indians and had one white man killed. In connection with the subject Friend Hoag forwards a report from Agent Gibson, who says a party of 20 men and 9 women, going towards the red mounds, met some men who told them a herd of buffalo was in a certain direction.

See moreSee less

They found the herd and killed several buffalo, and remained in camp two days drying the meat, when they saw a party of forty white men in the distance. Two of theOsages rode out to meet them and were surrounded and dis armed of their bows and arrows. Four more rode out and were treated in same manner. Two more then approached, but were wounded by the pril> oners and lied. The others at the same time attempted to escape and four were shot dead. The other Indians escaped. The conduct of the whites incensed the Indians greatly, and it re quired the utmost exertions of Agent Gibson to prevent war, in which labor he is still engaged.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Indian agent Enoch Hoog forwards conflicting reports about a violent encounter near Medicine Lodge: one newspaper account claims a military clash with Osage Indians killed five Indians and one white man, while Agent Gibson's separate report describes white men disarming and then shooting four Osage buffalo hunters as they tried to flee. The incident has inflamed tensions, requiring Gen. Gibson's efforts to prevent further war.

The Portland Daily Press · 21 August 1874 · page 3

dians and had one white man killed. In connection with ihe subject Friend Hoog forwards a report from Agen^Glbson, who says a party of twenty men aud nine women pio ceediug towards lied Mounds met some white men who told them a herd of buffalo was in a

See the clipping

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

A U.S. Indian agent relays an account from Osage witnesses describing how a hunting party was approached by armed men who disarmed and then shot several of them while they dried buffalo meat on the plains. The agent notes uncertainty over whether the attackers were soldiers or militia and describes efforts to calm the Osage relatives seeking revenge.

National Republican (Washington City) · 26 August 1874 · page 1

UNITED STATES INDIAN AGENCY

WITTSTATES I-C7AAOINCT, I Oxficx -ox. otcr, eta, inn, urt. f Soocft Baa J, SuptrUUndtnt of ajfoa J f lire: I hare cc-tlnaed sending roensrs to tha .plains with Imperative advlc ta coma In. Have sent d. tecuves u in vow as lo awcrta-s vos war ao seat. Learned fully yesterday of the conduct of tha Black Lair and ILIMefbands w tills on the host, aad that all were on the reservations y-ccpvao-ui twenty men ana ntn women or tno Utter band wha bid gana back toward the salt plains to procuro mors tIo meat.

See moreSee less

I had a runner sent lor tm, but ha was met by a por tion of the party. -he havo report-d to me ibis ;-enlgUirou Wa.U-a.a and several of bU friends, the followlne story: That tbis party of :?',!,tT.n-'.n n1 - wa prooe-fsd toward tno Bed Mounds, mtttl-z some whits men, who told tbem that a herd of buffalo was in a certain dlrecUos.where they went and kllle. several, and

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

Secretary Delano stated that current Indian conflicts were provoked by 'buffalo hunters and horse thieves' inciting Kiowa and Comanche warriors to war, while the tribal leadership sought peace. He outlined the administration's policy of confining Indians to reservations and punishing violations, rejecting extermination as an alternative course.

Grant County Herald · 27 August 1874 · page 1

The Opinion of Secretary Delano on the Indian Peace Policy. Secretary Delano, in conversation, said that the present Indian difficulties grew out of the acts, as he expressed it, “of Buffalo hunters and horse

See the clipping