As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

The Herds Return

January 1917 – May 1928

In 1917 the herds on the government reservations were growing. By 1919 there were about seven thousand in North America, and Congress let the Secretary of Agriculture give surplus buffalo to cities and public institutions. The Montana range’s thirty-seven had become 296, Yellowstone’s wild herd had doubled, and in 1923 a herd nobody knew of was found in northern Canada, though a columnist insisted the bison would never ‘come back.’ In 1928 an old hide hunter remembered what a hide used to fetch.

Buffalo increasing on government reservations

The biological survey’s annual report finds the buffalo, ‘once threatened with extinction,’ increasing on government reservations. The survey keeps five big game preserves and sixty-seven bird reservations, and the report urges that land not suited to farming, including many thousand acres of marsh, be made into breeding grounds for birds and waterfowl.

The Appeal · Saint Paul, Minn. · and 3 other papers

The Appeal · 6 January 1917 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BUFFALO HERDS INCREASING. Number of Animals on Government Reservation Grows. Washington—The buffalo, once threatened with extinction, is increasing in numbers on government reservations, according to the annual report of the biological survey. Five big game preserves and sixty-seven bird reservations are maintained by the survey. The report urges that more tracts of land not suitable for agricultural purposes be converted into breeding grounds for birds. Many thousand acres of marsh land, it declares, could be turned easily into breeding grounds for waterfowl.

See the clipping

Too many bulls at Wichita

The new agricultural appropriation act lets the Secretary of Agriculture give surplus buffalo to cities and public institutions, chiefly because there are too many bulls in the herds, especially at the Wichita preserve in Oklahoma. Of about 7,000 in North America, Canada has over 3,500 and the United States over 3,000, seven times the 1889 count; private owners hold about 2,000.

Crossville Chronicle · Crossville, Tenn. · and 9 other papers

Crossville Chronicle · 8 October 1919 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

No Danger Now of Extinction of American Bison

PROVISION is made in the current agricultural appropriation act for the secretary of agriculture to give buffalo to municipalities and public institutions from any surplus which may exist in the herds now under the control of the department of agriculture. This provision is made because of the surplus of bulls in some of the department of agriculture's buffalo herds, particularly the one in the Wichita National Forest and Game Preserve, in Oklahoma, and because the department is nearing the realization of the first stage in the preservation of the species—the acquisition of at least 1,000 head of buffalo by the government.

See moreSee less

There are approximately 7,000 buffalo in North America. Canada has something over 3,500 and the total number in the United States is more than 3,000. This is about seven times the number in the United States in 1889, when the first buffalo census was taken. Individuals in the United States own approximately 2,000 of the total number in this country.

There are eight government herds, six of which are under the control of the department of agriculture. The largest herd in this country is in charge of the interior department and is located in the Yellowstone National park, where there are about 50 bisons. The Smithsonian institution now has a herd of 18 at the National Zoological park, Washington, D. C.

I'LL LOOK OUT FOR YOU-

See the clipping

Thirty-seven buffalo become 296

In the ten years since the Montana National Bison Range was established, an Arizona paper reports, the 37 buffaloes it started with have increased to 296. The range also holds 125 elk, 33 antelope and 13 mule deer, and is believed large enough to support 800 bison.

The Arizona Cattleman · Tucson, Ariz. · and 4 other papers

The Arizona Cattleman · 19 April 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WILD HERDS IN- CREASE IN DECADE

In the 10 years since the Montana National Bison Range was established the 37 buffaloes with which the herd was started have increased to 296. In addition there are on the range 125 elk (not including calves of last year), 33 antelope and 13 mule deer. It is believed that the range is large enough to support 800 bison, 400 antelope, 500 deer, and 800 elk.

See the clipping

Yellowstone’s wild herd tops one hundred

A Yellowstone Park dispatch reports a new band of about fifteen wild buffalo in the park’s southeast, proof, it says, that the wild herd is increasing, not dying out. Park authorities say there are now more than one hundred, where formerly there were about half that many. Seen within five miles of a big hotel, the band yields what is probably the first photograph of a wild buffalo. The tame herd, with forty-eight new calves, numbers 500.

The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D. · and 6 other papers

The Bismarck Tribune · 5 August 1920 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

NEW BUFFALO HERD

Bison on Increase Instead of Becoming Extinct.

See moreSee less

Yellowstone National Park Authorities Say There Are More Than 100 Wild Buffalo in Park.

Yellowstone Park, Wyo.—Convincing evidence that the wild buffalo of Yellowstone national park, the last surviving remnant of the great herds which once roamed the western plains, are on the increase, instead of dying out, as was feared, has been obtained in the discovery of a new group in the southeast portion of the park.

About fifteen animals were observed, evidently a part of the old herd, which it is thought grew so large that some of its members were forced to break away and seek new pasturage.

Definite information has been obtained by park authorities that there are now more than one hundred of the wild buffalo in the park. Formerly there were only about half that number.

When discovered, the new herd was within five miles of one of the largest hotels in the park and a snapshot was obtained of one of the animals, a fine bull, probably the first photograph ever taken of a wild buffalo.

Ordinarily the wild buffalo never are seen by tourists and only rarely by park authorities or even by the rangers who patrol the most remote sections. The appearance of the new herd close to the main lines of travel was before the season opened, and the animals apparently had been lured down from the mountain fastnesses by the abundance of spring grass on the lower levels. They disappeared into untraveled country as soon as automobiles became frequent along the highways.

Forty-eight calves have been added this year to the tame buffalo herd of the park, which now has a population of 500. Part of the tame herd has been placed in corral at Mammoth Hot Springs for the benefit of visitors.

See the clipping

A new herd, but no coming back

The Washington Times notes the surprise discovery of a new, unknown wild herd of bison in Northern Canada, with grass, water and salt licks enough. The beasts may dream of ‘coming back’ but, it says, they will not, any more than the Red Indians will; what time writes ‘stays written.’

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

The Washington Times · 21 January 1923 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A NEW, unknown wild herd of bison, much to everybody's surprise, has been discovered in Northern Canada. Grass and water are plentiful, salt licks enough, the huge beasts enjoy their ancient liberty and dream of "coming back."

They will not come back, and the Red Indians will not come back. The moving hand of time writes, and, as the Persian poet observed, what it writes stays written. When it writes: "Bison are gone, Red Indians are gone," they are GONE.

See the clipping

Gotlob Schmalsle remembers the hide hunt

A Montana paper profiles Gotlob Schmalsle of Miles City, who began killing buffalo for their hides in Kansas in 1872, when Dodge City paid from 75 cents to $3.50 a hide. Herds were too big to count, he says, so they ‘counted the buffaloes by the hour’; in the winter of 1880, on South Sunday creek, he killed and skinned 600. By 1883 the herds had vanished.

The Ronan Pioneer · Ronan, Mont. · and 1 other paper

The Ronan Pioneer · 17 May 1928 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Buffalo Hunting Paid While It Lasted But the Herds On Montana's Plains and In Its Valleys Were Practically Exterminated In Half a Dozen Years Prior to 1883, Which Marked the Decline of Miles City As the Buffalo Hide Market of the Northwest

(By "MON TANA LOU" GRILL)

See moreSee less

BEFORE the coming of adventurous trappers and hunters when all of the eastern Montana wilderness was in the exclusive possession of the red men, Tongue river valley was an Indian paradise. There were no title deeds entered of record in this vast region for the Indian led a nomadic life and established temporary abiding places wherever wild game abounded. For hundreds of years, perhaps, the primeval silences of the wooded valleys and treeless plains were unbroken save from the shouts of the aborigines as some monarch of the plain fell dead, pierced to the heart by an arrow or lance. Buffalo were plentiful. No refrigeration was necessary, for the Indian killed as his hunger required. The result was that vast herds inhabited the territory and constituted the living larder of the original dweller.

The centennial year of 1876 was the beginning of a great change. In that year and intermittently for many years before the ground where Miles City is now located was a favorite camping ground for the savage Sioux. Generation after generation of Indians, not only of the Sioux but also of the Northern Cheyennes, had come to the confluence of the Tongue and Yellowstone river to settle for awhile and live off the meat that the herds of buffalo provided.

Following in the wake of the adventurer, the hunter and trapper who went in advance of the settler, came the civilizing influences of the first waves of pioneers easing themselves out of the civilization of the east to find new homes and opportunities. The Indian resented their approach, and the buffaloes afforded a problem that was difficult of solution for the time being because of their vast numbers.

Fort Keogh Established

The resentment of the Indian was met with the establishment of Fort Keogh at the mouth of the Tongue river in the autumn of 1876, following the defeat of Custer's command on the Little Big Horn on June 25, of that year. The problem of the buffaloes was solved by the white man within eight years thereafter. The monarch of the plains became almost extinct and his complete extermination was narrowly averted.

Two years after the establishment of Fort Keogh, Miles City was moved from its old site on the banks of the Yellowstone river just outside the east line of the reservation, to its present location which had in the years before been the favorite camping grounds of the Indians. Seventy-two years before that date the Lewis and Clark expedition, descending the Yellowstone, was detained in July, 1806, at the mouth of the Tongue river while a herd of buffaloes crossed the former stream. They were the first white men known to have been in that vicinity. The wilderness they discovered and which they so vividly described, endured and continued in its primitive condition for nearly three-quarters of a century, and then suddenly disappeared before the overwhelming wave of civilization and progress.

Among the young men who came to eastern Montana over the old Chisholm trail from Texas in the late seventies was Gotlob Schmalsle, still living in Miles City. His family came to America in a sailing vessel over the Atlantic to New York, thence by land to Fort Riley, Kans. Later he lived in Clyde county, Kansas, on the Republican river. As a young man he punched cattle from Kansas to Texas and worked for a number of the large outfits. His contact with the Indians followed as the result of a raid on an English colony located on the White Rock creek in Kansas. He was mustered into a company of militia which was organized as a protection against the Indians and in 1869 was mustered out. His brother Fred was a private in the battle of the Washita that was fought with such signal success by General Custer in what is now Oklahoma.

"We counted the buffaloes by the hour instead of trying to determine how many were in a herd," he says of his experiences with the animals. "It was impossible to count them, so we stood and kept track of the hours a herd required to pass a given point. This was true of the points further south and equally true of the eastern Montana region."

Mr. Schmalsle describes the animals by saying that in the north they were called buffaloes. The bison of the south, the animal that remained more or less in that territory, was short and chunky. The southern bison was large, weighing from 1,800 to 2,000 pounds. The northern buffalo was a little lighter, weighing from 1,600 to 1,800 pounds.

Becomes Buffalo Hunter

Mr. Schmalsle had returned to the Solomon river country in the late sixties where he remained until 1873. Buffaloes were thick in that region and the hunters shot all that they could eat. It was in 1872 that he began to kill the animals for their hides. Dodge City, Kans., then on the edge of civilization, became one of the early day market centers where the price paid for hides ranged from 75 cents to $3.50, depending on the condition. A scrubby bull hide brought the former price, while a cow skin or that of a young bull brought the latter price.

It was in western Kansas that the killing of buffaloes and bison was begun on a commercial basis. Within the course of a day or two a single hunter could kill and skin an average of one hundred animals. The hides were brought in to the market every two weeks.

GOTLOB SCHMALSLE, famous buffalo hunter of eastern Montana 50 years ago. In a single winter season on South Sunday creek he killed and skinned 600 animals that he delivered to the Miles City market at prices ranging from $1.30 to $3.50 for a hide.

Becoming tired of the business of shooting buffaloes in Kansas, Mr. Schmalsle went to Texas in 1874. He was employed as a cowpuncher on the Jasper West ranch located on the Blanco river. A year later he joined the Captain Linn cattle outfit, and as a rider was engaged to gather the longhorns that were sent north into Kansas and subsequently into eastern Montana. In 1876 he went to the cantonment located on the Sweetwater which afterwards became Fort Elliott. By degrees he worked his way into the Panhandle country, thence into Wyoming where he came in contact with "California Joe" and "Texas Jack," with whom he became quite well acquainted. He met "Calamity Jane" when she was dressed as a man and driving a six-mule team. By devious routes, via the Black Hills, Fort Pierre, then back to Kansas, he reached Miles City in 1879 by way of Yankton, Dakota, to which point he went by steamer on the Missouri.

His first work in eastern Montana was driving a hack from Miles City to Fort Keogh, securing the exclusive privilege, he says, from General Miles, the commandant.

The doom of the buffalo was sealed in 1880 in eastern Montana. It was in that year that the work of exterminating the beasts began. Miles City succeeded Dodge City as a market center. While he was driving his hack back and forth between the city and the fort, Mr. Schmalsle took account of the traffic in hides against which he measured his own income. When the winter of 1880 opened he decided to turn hunter again. He spent that season in the South Sunday creek region, north of the Yellowstone and killed and skinned 600 animals.

Sees Immense Herds

Prior to the beginning of the great slaughter Mr. Schmalsle says that the buffaloes presented a scene of nothing less than a moving mass. In his earlier hunting experiences in the south, he says, they literally covered the earth like a black moving cloud. Steamers on the Missouri were stopped for the time required for a herd to cross. He had seen them in Wyoming where the Union Pacific trains were compelled to halt until the moving mass of animals had crossed the tracks.

At daybreak on South Sunday creek as soon as the light allowed the eye to follow the barrel of the buffalo gun, the valley echoed and re-echoed with the rattle of musketry. The reports of the guns could be heard on the hill tops and down in the creek bottoms. The hunters would then retrace their steps, skin the fallen beasts, roll up the hides, later haul them to camp and then unroll them and stretch them out to dry. The hides brought from $1.50 to $3.50 each on the Miles City market where they were piled high awaiting transportation to eastern consuming markets where coats and robes were manufactured from them.

There were many dealers in buffalo hides in Miles City in 1883 when the last of the herds had vanished.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: The Bison Society