As the Papers Told It

The American Buffalo · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

The Bison Society

January 1906 – February 1914

In January 1906 the papers reported a meeting at the New York Zoological Park that founded the American Bison Society, with Theodore Roosevelt as its honorary president. The government made a range in Oklahoma’s Wichita Mountains and shipped buffalo to it from New York; Canada bought the largest herd left, on the Flathead reservation in Montana, for $150,000; and Congress made a national bison range in Montana. By 1912 the society counted 2,760 in North America. In 1913 the buffalo went on the nickel, and the next year the last great private herd in the West, Scotty Philip’s at Fort Pierre, was put up for sale.

The American Bison Society is founded

Meeting in the Bronx, naturalists organize the American Bison Society with President Roosevelt as honorary president and plan to ask Congress for bison reservations, since fewer than 1,000 remain in America outside zoological gardens. Secretary Ernest Harold Baynes has trained two baby bulls to the yoke to show the animal’s commercial worth; meanwhile owners are tempted to sell, with a robe bringing $150 to $200.

The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash. · and 2 other papers

The Evening Statesman · 16 January 1906 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

SOCIETY TO SAVE BISON

Plans of Organization Supported by President Roosevelt.

See moreSee less

MOVEMENT STARTED AT NEW YORK

Congress Will Be Appealed to For an Appropriation to Provide Reservations For Maintaining Herds of Buffalo—American Mammal's Commercial as Well as Sentimental Value to Be Urged.

Supported by President Roosevelt and by the leading naturalists of the country, the American Bison society was organized recently at a meeting in the New York zoological gardens, Bronx park, says the New York Post. The object of the founders is to secure government and individual aid in preserving the bison, which is rapidly becoming extinct in the land where once his breed roved the plains by millions.

After securing as large a membership and as many contributions as possible, the society will appeal to congress for an appropriation large enough to provide one or more bison reservations—great tracts of land on which the animals may flourish and multiply. At present there are less than 1,000 of them in America outside of zoological gardens, and the owners are private citizens without enclosures of sufficient size to give a buffalo the range he needs. If the government will undertake the solution of the problem, say the naturalists, there will be no difficulty in warding off the destruction of the finest animals now existing.

At the meeting in the Bronx, Mr. Roosevelt was chosen honorary president of the society. He had agreed previously to accept the office on condition the active list should be composed of the proper men, and ever since the plan was broached to him by Ernest Harold Baynes he has been enthusiastic over its outcome. The other officers elected were William P. Hornaday, president; Professor Charles S. Minot of Harvard university and President A. A. Anderson of the Campfire Club of America, vice presidents; Ernest Harold Baynes, secretary, and Edward Seymour, treasurer.

Speaking of the reasons for the movement to save the bison, Mr. Baynes described several experiments he had made to prove that the animals were superior to domestic cattle as draft beasts. He borrowed two baby bulls from the Corbins, who own a herd of 160 head in New Hampshire, and trained them to the yoke. Within a few months they were entirely serviceable and could give points in pulling a load to any oxen of their own age. They were also drilled in single harness, and throughout their rearing were cared for like ordinary calves.

Once the government has acquired a herd and started to increase its numbers along proper lines, Mr. Baynes says, the bison's commercial value to the United States will become established. Besides promising well as a draft animal, the buffalo furnishes meat that cannot be surpassed and fur robes that for certain purposes cannot be equaled by those from any other creature. With the breed systematically maintained there could be a large output from time to time for these uses, the animals being distributed throughout the country as fast as they overflowed their reservations.

Of the sentimental reasons for saving the bison much has been said, but hitherto no practical step has been taken for his preservation. Every one knows how his progenitors, when there were millions of them, served the western pioneers for food when no other food was obtainable and gave winter clothing to the first settlers when a buffalo hide was the most easily procured and often the only covering to be had. Even if they were of no commercial worth, as Mr. Baynes says, Americans who know of their part in the country's history should not like to see them effaced from the earth.

The danger that the private herds will disintegrate may not be immediate, but it is certain the strength of the breed will gradually diminish unless the animals can have the freedom and wide range their natures require. Besides the herd in New Hampshire, there are large ones in Montana and Texas and smaller ones in other western states. The Montana herd, owned by a half Indian named Pablo, is said to be the largest, numbering 225. It is not known, however, that these are all full blooded. The "cattalo," which is half domestic cattle and half wild buffalo, has come to be a common animal in the herds, and some owners have made a special effort to raise these crosses, which are noted for their valuable hides.

In addition to the weakening of the bison from being shut into small inclosures, his owners are hastening his end by selling an occasional head or hide. A buffalo robe these days brings from $150 to $200. A head, well mounted, costs $800 or $900 in a taxidermist's shop. It is no small temptation to the owner when a buyer drops in once or twice a year and offers him fancy prices for a few of the animals.

Mr. Baynes says the appeal to congress for a reservation and an appropriation will be made as soon as possible. In the meantime a committee will confer with President Roosevelt.

See the clipping

A game park in the Wichita Mountains

An Oregon paper describes the game preserve the government is making in Oklahoma’s Wichita Mountains, 57,120 acres set apart by act of Congress in the old hunting grounds of the Comanche and Kiowa. Deer, antelope, bear, beaver, quail and wild turkeys are to be protected, and in time, it hopes, large herds of buffalo will roam the plains again, ‘within the reservation.’

The Athena Press · Athena, Or. · and 3 other papers

The Athena Press · 29 January 1907 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

NATIONAL GAME PARK.

Nearly 60,000 acres in one natural game preserve! Such is the new enterprise which the national government is establishing in Oklahoma. As far back as tribal tradition runs the Wichita mountain region has been the favorite hunting grounds of the Comanche and Kiowa Indians, drawn thither by abundance of game and delightful climate. But now game, like the Indians, is largely a thing of the past.

See moreSee less

It is proposed to reproduce in this splendid natural park all the best species of game animals and birds that once made the great West the hunter's paradise. Deer, antelope, bear, the otter and beaver, quail and doves, prairie chickens and wild turkeys will be given protection and encouraged to increase and multiply. Probably the most interesting feature of the undertaking will be an effort to have, in the course of years, large herds of buffalo again roaming the plains—within the reservation—as they did before the pitiless warfare upon them was carried so nearly to the point of extermination. When the plans now under way are carried out Oklahoma will be able to boast, in this Wichita mountain game reserve, one of the finest natural game parks in the country.

Naturalists who have visited the region unite in saying that the preserve, without question, can be made one of the most successful in the United States. The 57,120 acres of land set apart by act of Congress for this purpose lies in the rugged embrace of mountains that attain an altitude of 2,700 feet above sea level, from whose summits one may behold the marvelous expanse of plains rolling westward to the Rocky mountains and southward to the Rio Grande del Norte.

To the east the country is broken by timbered streams, many of them splendid water courses, between which are fertile prairies and ever increasing hills that merge finally into the bastions of the beautiful Ozarks in Arkansas and Missouri. From the north, as far as the Dominion of Canada and stretching southward to the Gulf of Mexico, there sweeps past the Wichitas the mighty pathway of the plains, rich in nutritious grasses, over which grazed in the earlier days the migratory herds of buffalo and deer. The climate is mild and dry, although snow whitens the tops of the mountains in winter. In summer the peaks swim in a sea of purple haze. The average rainfall is about twenty-nine inches and the annual mean temperature close to 60 degrees. Seldom does the temperature go below zero.

See the clipping

The Flathead herd goes to Canada

Helena watches part of ‘the largest herd of buffalo in the world’ change railroads on its way to Canada, held up while cars damaged by vicious bulls are repaired. The Canadian government paid $150,000 for the herd, about 400 head and perhaps 500 with calves, bought at Ravalli on the Flathead reservation, and will let it run free in a 10,000-acre park near Lamont.

Camas Prairie Chronicle · Cottonwood, Idaho · and 6 other papers

CorrectionThis set right an article from 14 days earlier.

Camas Prairie Chronicle · 14 June 1907 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

BUFFALO FOR CANADA.

Taken From Flathead Reservation in Montana, Where they Ranged.

See moreSee less

Residents of Helena were given an opportunity recently to witness the partial shipment of the largest herd of buffalo in the world, which were transferred from the Northern Pacific to the Great Northern, en route to its future home in Canada. The bison were being shipped by special train, and were detained there long enough to repair several cars, which vicious bulls had damaged in their effort to regain freedom. The herd was recently purchased at Ravalli on the Flathead reservation by the Canadian government, and will be placed in a park near Edmonton. The remainder of the herd will be shipped the latter part of August.

It is not known how many there are in the herd, but it is estimated that there are about 400. It is thought that there may possibly be 500, with the calves.

The Canadian government paid $150,000 for the herd and will place them in the government park near Lamont, which is about 40 miles east of Edmonton. This park contains 10,000 acres, and the buffalo will be allowed to run free in it. The government has 80 buffaloes in the park already.

The purpose of the Canadian government in buying the animals was to put them in this park and protect them, so as to keep them from being exterminated. The animals are all thoroughbreds.

See the clipping

Frank Rush takes charge of the government’s buffalo

In one line, an Arkansas paper reports that Frank Rush, ‘the cowboy naturalist,’ is taking charge of the government’s herd of buffalo in New York, ready to take them to a national forest in Oklahoma.

The Mountain Echo · Yellville, Ark. · and 2 other papers

The Mountain Echo · 11 October 1907 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Frank Rush, the cowboy naturalist, takes charge of the government's herd of buffalo in New York preparatory to taking them to national forest in Oklahoma.

See the clipping

A national range for Montana

A Topeka paper backs Senator Dixon’s bill for a permanent national bison range in Montana; the American Bison Society stands ready to give the government a herd once the range is fenced. ‘The slaughter of the buffalo,’ it says, ‘has been a miracle of wanton and prodigal cruelty.’

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Topeka State Journal · 7 May 1908 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

TO PRESERVE THE BUFFALO. Sentiment throughout the country is and has been favorable to any reasonable means for averting the extinction of the American bison, or buffalo. Hitherto all efforts in this direction have been upon individual initiative and without anything like concerted effort. Naturally they have failed, although much has been accomplished in the way of retarding the inevitable and today there are perhaps no buffalo outside of captivity. But the few that remain are rapidly passing, for this noble animal does not thrive unless free to roam at will. There is, therefore, unanswerable logic in support of Senator Dixon's bill to establish a permanent national bison range in Montana, where there is plenty of suitable land in the public domain and climatic and other conditions admirably adapted to the purpose. The American bison society stands ready to present the government with a small herd of animals in case the range is established and fenced in, so that the passage of the bill is really all that is necessary to accomplish the object which the lovers of the buffalo have in mind.

The slaughter of the buffalo has been a miracle of wanton and prodigal cruelty. "Sportsmen" have shot down thousands merely for the delight of killing. Hunters have exterminated herd after herd for the hides, which within a generation were almost a drug on the market.

See moreSee less

It is neither possible nor desirable to reproduce those herds, which as late as the early fifties were a menace to the western ranchman and farmer, but there is an economic and commercial value in the buffalo which more than justifies vigorous efforts to protect and propagate the species. Apart from this, and almost as compelling in its appeal, is a certain justifiable sentiment. He is distinctly an American animal. He is associated intimately with all those traditions that have to do with the subjugation of this continent. His place in the history of arduous pioneer days is so assured and prominent that our patriotic instincts demand his preservation. Senator Dixon's bill, therefore, appeals so forcibly to American interest and American sentiment that one is justified in hoping there will be no decided opposition to it from any quarter in congress.

See the clipping

The bison range is chosen

The Montana bison range, for which Congress gave $40,000, will be on the Flathead reservation north of the Jocko river, as Professor Morton J. Elrod recommended: about 12,800 acres. Only $10,000 goes to fences and sheds; $30,000 goes to the landowners, many of them Indians. The paper names the late Austin Corbin, who fenced 6,000 acres in New Hampshire, as the first to spend money saving the bison.

The Beaver Herald · Beaver, Okla. · and 2 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Beaver Herald · 14 January 1909 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

NEW BISON RANGE

IS ESTABLISHED ON FLATHEAD INDIAN RESERVATION.

See moreSee less

Government to Persist in Its Efforts to Preserve the Historic Buffalo from Extinction.

The bison range in the Flathead Indian reservation in Montana, to establish which congress at its last session appropriated $40,000, has been selected. The location of the range is the one recommended by Prof. Morton J. Elrod of the University of Montana, after he had carefully examined several parts of the country. It lies directly north of the Jocko river near the towns of Ravalli and Jocko. Approximately 12,800 acres are embraced in the tract, which will be fenced in a substantial manner under the direction of the engineering department of the United States forest service.

Of the $40,000 appropriated only $10,000 will be available for fencing

A Herd of Buffalo.

the range and constructing the shelter sheds and other buildings necessary for the proper maintenance and care of the bison. The remaining $30,000 will be paid to the owners of the land, many of whom are Indians. Funds for the purchase of bison are being raised under the auspices of the Amer-

Slaughtering the Buffalo—A Typical Scene of West a Few Years Ago.

ican Bison society, which was largely instrumental in securing the appropriation.

The first person to spend actual money in the effort to preserve the American bison from total extinction was the late Austin Corbin, who many years ago fenced some 6,000 acres at Blue Mountain Park, N. H., and secured a herd of bison. The Corbin herd became in course of time the inspiration of the national movement which is now furthered by the American Bison society. This society, of which President Roosevelt is honorary president, and William T. Hornaday, director of the New York Zoological park, is president, was founded in 1904, and the Montana bison range is directly the results of its efforts.

Details of the management of the herd in the new national bison range will be worked out as soon as the herd is purchased, when the construction work on fences and buildings will also be begun.

See the clipping

Canadian cowboys to round up 300 buffalo

A Winnipeg dispatch reports Canadian cowboys gathering at Lethbridge, Alberta, to go into Montana and round up 300 buffalo, the rest of the big herd Canada bought two years ago, which ‘burst a corral and got away’ last summer just before shipment. Canada expects to assemble the largest herd in America this summer in a park at Elk Island.

Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · and 5 other papers

Gilpin Observer · 13 May 1909 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Will Round Up Buffalo. Winnipeg, Man.—Canadian cowboys have gathered at Lethbridge, Alberta, preparatory to leaving for Montana to assist in rounding up 300 buffalo, the remainder of the big herd purchased two years ago by the Canadian government and which burst a corral and got away last summer on the eve of their shipment. This summer Canada will have a park at Elk Island, in which the largest herd of buffalo in America will be assembled.

See the clipping

Rapid City wants Scotty Philip’s herd

Scotty Philip of Fort Pierre wants to sell his herd of 280, said to be the largest in the country, and Rapid City business men see a tourist attraction in it. They propose that the government buy the herd if Rapid City provides for its keep, and Congressman Martin has taken up the question in Washington.

Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D. · and 3 other papers

Union County Courier · 7 April 1910 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

GOVERNMENT ASKED TO BUY BISON HERD

Rapid City, April 6.—A buffalo herd of national reputation as an attraction for tourists this summer, is a strong possibility for Rapid City. Recently, it was announced that "Scotty" Philip, of Fort Pierre, desired to sell his herd of 280 head, said to be the largest extant in this country. Business men at once saw the possibility for such an attraction here and opened communication with Mr. Philip. It is proposed to ask the government for an appropriation to buy the herd on condition that Rapid City provides for maintenance. Congressman Martin has taken up the question at Washington.

See the clipping

The Bison Society counts 2,760

The American Bison Society’s fourth annual report counts 2,760 buffalo in North America, the Evening Star reports, among them a herd of 918 in Canada’s Buffalo Park near Wainwright and a wild band of ‘wood buffalo’ north of Great Slave lake that wolves are thinning. Montana’s national bison range has grown from thirty-seven to fifty-one head, and buffalo now live in twenty-seven states.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 18 days earlier.

Evening Star · 8 January 1912 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

BUFFALO ON INCREASE IN THE UNITED STATES

They Now Number Nearly 3,000 in Whole of North America.

See moreSee less

Buffalo are on the increase in the United States. Of course, they are not buffalo at all, but, strictly speaking, American bison. However, they have been known as buffalo so long that the American Bison Society is facing a hopeless task when it tries to have them called by their right name.

The main thing is that they are on the increase. According to the fourth annual report of the society, just published, there are now 2,760 of them in North America. This includes a great herd of 1,000 established in Canada by the Canadian government, largely through the efforts of Earl Grey. This is not the only herd controlled by the Canadian government. There are now twenty-seven head in the Banff, Alta Park; sixty-one in the Elk Island Park, and a big herd of 918 in what is now known in Canada as the Buffalo Park. This is near Wainwright, on the line of the Grand Trunk road. It is an old buffalo grazing ground and there have been fenced in about 102 square miles. This is provided with a good game fence and a fire-guard strip of plowed land twenty feet wide on each side of the fence.

One Wild Band.

In addition to the captive buffalo owned by the Canadian government, there is a wild band known as "wood buffalo" north of the Great Slave lake. This herd is estimated at from 300 to 1,000. It has been somewhat decimated by wolves. The Canadian government offered a bounty on the wolves, but the Indians, owing to a tribal superstition, would not kill them, and the government sent a trapper and a biological student into the region to kill off the wolves so far as possible.

The United States government has established a national bison range on the Flathead Indian reservation in Montana and this has increased in the past two years from thirty-seven to fifty-one head. There are now buffalo, either wild or captive, in twenty-seven of the states, and an effort is being made by the Bison Society to secure the formation of a state bison range in each one of the states where the animals will thrive.

See the clipping

The buffalo nickel goes into circulation

The new nickel, with the American bison on one side and the American Indian on the other, is to go into general circulation on Saturday, and banks have already applied for more than 2,000,000. It replaces the Goddess of Liberty nickel, drops the V, and was designed by James E. Fraser of New York; the Philadelphia mint is stamping them at 120 a minute.

The Daily Missoulian · Missoula, Mont. · and 4 other papers

The Daily Missoulian · 25 February 1913 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

NEW COIN TO BE OUT SATURDAY

TREASURY DEPARTMENT ANNOUNCES MILLIONS HAVE BEEN REQUISITIONED.

See moreSee less

Washington, Feb. 24.—The new nickel of Indian head and buffalo design will be put into general circulation on Saturday. Already the treasury department has received applications from banks for more than 2,000,000 of the new coins.

The new nickel soon to take the place of the Goddess of Liberty nickel, which has been in use for many years, will have the American bison on one side and on the other the American Indian. There will be no "V." Instead will be the bison, under which appears the words "five cents" and "e pluribus unum."

In design it will be truly American. It was designed by James E. Fraser, of New York.

The mint at Philadelphia has begun the stamping out of the coins at the rate of 120 a minute.

See the clipping

The last great herd may go to Canada

Since the United States government does not want the whole herd, the bulk of the Scotty Phillip estate’s buffalo at Fort Pierre will likely go to the Canadian government, ‘lost for all time to the states.’ The Gettysburg dispatch recalls hunters taking only tongue and hide, a boat reaching Chamberlain filled with dried tongues, and the herd’s start in orphan calves caught by a rancher named Dupree.

The Tabor Independent · Tabor, S.D. · and 2 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Tabor Independent · 19 February 1914 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

BUFFALO TONGUE WAS SOLD BY BOAT LOADS NOT MANY YEARS AGO

Reminiscences Brought Out by Effort to Sell Last Great American Herd.

See moreSee less

Gettysburg, S. D., Feb. 16.—Because the United States government does not want the entire herd of buffalo of the Scotty Phillip's estate at Fort Pierre, it is likely that the bulk of the herd will be sold to the Canadian government. This famous herd of buffalo will be lost for all time to the states.

The herd now numbers 70 yearlings, 55 head of 2-year-olds, and 275 head of 3-year-olds and older. Fifteen head have already been sold to the United States government for the Wind Cave National park near Hot Springs, S. D. Carson Williams of Sioux City and John Sloat of Gettysburg are arranging the sale of the buffaloes for the administrators of the estate of Scotty Phillip of Fort Pierre.

Prior to 1876 buffalo were plentiful in South Dakota, particularly near the Missouri river and Black Hills. The Sioux under Sitting Bull, in 1876, went on the warpath and the massacre of Custer at the Little Big Horn followed. The Sioux then became outlaws and wandered north, driving the buffalo before then through North Dakota and Montana. In the summer of 1880, the Sioux surrendered and returned to South Dakota. The buffalo also returned to their native homes.

The only part of the buffalo that hunters used in flush times were the tongue and the hide. A Chamberlain paper, published in 1881, told of a boat that arrived at that city filled with dried buffalo tongues.

The rest of the carcass of the buffalo were left to rot on the prairies. The hides were sold to the traders.

The last wild buffalo was shot by E. F. Gross in Potter county in 1883. Mr. Gross came unexpectedly upon the buffalo and shot it with a horse pistol.

This last large herd of buffalo was organized by a rancher named Dupree living near the Cheyenne river, who captured some of the orphan buffalo calves, their mothers having been killed by hunters. He turned these calves onto his ranch and soon had a large herd of several hundred head. Scotty Phillip later purchased the herd and it has remained on the 13,000 acre ranch near Fort Pierre until now, when it is to be dispersed.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: Saving the Remnant