The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
An editorial reflects on America's nostalgia for the Old West, citing Tombstone, Arizona's 'Helldorado Week' celebration that reenacted the famous Earp-Clanton feud and a stagecoach holdup. The piece muses on the romanticism of pioneer days versus the actual brutality and crudeness of the historical frontier era.
The Bismarck Tribune · 8 November 1929 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Staging the Past
Some people wonder why America is so eager at all times to turn back in the old family album and see itself in the days of the past again. It is a passion amounting to nostalgia, in fact. It rivals the fierce pride of the present period of skyscrapers, airplanes, radio and electricity.
See moreSee less
Some of the eagerness is pure romanticism. The past is so rich in adventure, in development. The colossal, complex present, with its machine civilization, palls. There is a yearning for contact with the simplicities of the past, with the picturesqueness that has departed from life. Nothing stirs the blood of the American as much as a revival of old-time scenes, customs and events. Pageants that recall the pioneer days are dear to our hearts; we devote an absurd amount of time to the study of our forefathers' habits, diversions and conditions of life.
In Tombstone, Ariz., the other day they held a great celebration they called "Helldorado Week." For seven days they brought back to Tombstone all of its old-time glory. They kept all automobiles off of the streets, resurrecting creeky old stagecoaches and swaying buckboards instead. They opened all of the old-time bars and dance halls, shot off revolvers at all hours of the day and night, put on a replica of the famous old Earp-Clanton feud, and arranged a repetition, bloodless but exciting, of the great Modoc stagecoach holdup, which startled the west 50 years ago.
The affair drew huge crowds. Old-timers from all over the west went to Tombstone to see it. Some of them, gray-haired and stooped, had known Tombstone in the days when Arizona was young, bad and unrestrained. They had prospected for riches in its canyons and ledges surrounding the town; and some of them had become rich and some of them had got nothing but experience out of it.
But they came back, impatient to see the revival of the old days—and hundreds of the present generation came with them, to see for themselves what a western mining town was like in the boom times when the only law was the law that could be found in the muzzle of a revolver.
The thing makes interesting reading. It is a safe bet that every one of us, reading about it, felt stirred, felt wistfully regretful, somehow, that the old West had vanished so utterly.
But why? The old West was flaming and picturesque but it was also bad and brutal. If it was exciting it was also crude and harsh. It was not, in a way, civilized at all. It had the ethics of the stone age, in modern dress. Why should we want it back?
Well, perhaps it is partly because we're not quite as well satisfied with the present as we let on. We know that we're very prosperous and very busy and very "advanced"—but we can't help feeling that life hasn't quite got the savor that it might have. The men of the old west may have missed some of the things that we have, but, at any rate, they really lived. Their lives had color. They were never drab, never uninteresting.
Modern America is inspiring, busy, efficient—and, it may be, just the least bit monotonous.
Stick to the Short Skirt
The fashion-designers' struggle to encase American women in ankle-length skirts once more is proceeding right merrily. Judging from our own observations, we would say that it isn't meeting with a whole world of success—and somehow we're rather glad.
Whatever can be said about immodesty—and to our notion there isn't a great deal that needs to be said in that connection—the plain fact remains that women took to short skirts primarily because they were infinitely more comfortable and convenient than the old styles. Now, simply to force women to buy more clothes, the dress manufacturers are trying to bring the long skirt back on a flood of propaganda.
We hope they won't succeed. The woman of America today has a fine chance to prove that the old story about her being a slave of fashion isn't true.
Paul Wright Goes: A Loss
The Rev. Paul S. Wright leaves Bismarck today for his new field in Minneapolis. It is a loss which Bismarck keenly feels. Mr. Wright had endeared himself to the capital city. He was of that temperament which wins an enduring relationship, so that even when far away, his Bismarck friends and admirers will continue to cherish the impress of his rare and friendly personality.
Pastor Wright had the rare quality of winning men to himself. Even over the radio he exercised this gift. The church is largely a spiritual organization in which women are the chief supporters. Here and there, however, there are ministers who have the magnetism and the spiritual message that wins men as well. Paul S. Wright is one of these. In the personality where is found this striking power, are also to be found, per se, all the other virtues needed to round out a great and effective pulpit force.
In his wider field it is accepted as axiomatic that Bismarck's esteemed pastor will exercise the same magnetic qualities of leadership and spiritual influence as here, very likely with a broader recognition of his abilities. However, he has shown himself a very modest man. If any shadow veil his worth in his new field, it will be the shadow of his own modesty falling across the stature of his innate influence for good.
After all, a hypocrite isn't guilty of anything except synthetic piety.
Editorial Comment
To Be Senatorless (Fargo Forum)
Pennsylvania is about to have a unique distinction. With but one senator for many, many months, due to the determination of Mr. Walsh and others to keep William S. Vare from a seat in the upper house, it soon will have none—for a space of some weeks. Senator David Reed, who has handled all Pennsylvania matters, patronage, delegations, etc., besides finding time to lead the administration's tariff fight till discouraged, has accepted a place on the American delegation to the naval disarmament conference. That will take him away from the senate about the first of the year, and keep him away for quite a little spell.
He will not give up his post, of course. That is unnecessary. But his acceptance of President Hoover's appointment deprives his state of all representation in the senate at a time when some important legislation will be considered. It is not at all unlikely that one of these matters will be the tariff bill, and Pennsylvania industry has an unusually keen interest in it. To be sure, Mr. Reed has more or less given it the slip in confessing that the tariff bill is dead, a confession that really meant that it is impossible for the industrial east to get the benefits it desires in the face of strong coalition opposition, and by which he seemingly declared himself done with the whole business. But with Mr. Grundy on the ground, Mr. Reed could be moved to action and representation again so long as he remains in Washington, but once he gets to London, his voice will do the tariff seekers no good and his vote will not be taken.
So, as we have said, Pennsylvania will be in a unique and unhappy position. But there is nothing the rest of us can do about it, so she will have to make the most of it.