As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

October 1923

3 articles

South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.

The article recounts Wyatt Earp's controversial 1896 refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, where Earp stopped the bout in the eighth round and awarded Sharkey the win on a foul. Amid the furious crowd's reaction, Earp drew his gun and left the ring safely.

South Bend News-Times · 20 October 1923 · page 14 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

FITZSIMMONS ENDED THIS CRUDE FIGHT IN VERY SHORT ORDER By NEA Service: PORTLAND, Oct. 19.—Tom Sharkey, sailor heavyweight, was tougher than whale steak and as game as they made 'em. He was an ac-

See the clipping

The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.

A 1923 sports retrospective recounts how Wyatt Earp, acting as referee, controversially awarded Sharkey a win on a foul after Fitzsimmons battered him, provoking an angry crowd that Earp held off with a drawn pistol. The piece frames this as revenge fuel for a rematch in which Fitzsimmons knocked out Sharkey.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 18 days later.

Wrong

The Seattle Star · 23 October 1923 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

Fitz Put Over K.O. in Hurry

Sharkey, a newcomer, had been attracting considerable attention, and the educated dough was riding on him.

Wyatt Earp, Frisco bad man and notorious gun expert, was the referee. Earp was in there to protect the gamblers' investment. Fitz battered the inexperienced Sharkey into fragments. It was simply a question of how many rounds Sharkey could endure the punishment he was absorbing.

See moreSee less

In the eighth round, with the sailor

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A newspaper piece promotes a William S. Hart film about Wild Bill Hickok and Calamity Jane, claiming a legendary 'peace commission' of gunmen including Hickok, Masterson, Earp, Bassett, Tilghman, Short, and Holliday cleaned up Dodge City together. It romanticizes western history, citing Hickok's death in Deadwood in 1876 and his connection to Custer and Calamity Jane.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 144 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 28 October 1923 · page 48 · transcribed from the page image

and his friends believe he has scored a substantial success.

oric Picture.

See moreSee less

the picturesque character of Gen. Custer adds historical interest to the picture. The latter and Hickok were friends, as attested by Elizabeth Custer in her book, "Tenting on the Plains." The dramatic story is laid in Dodge City, Kan., which has gone down in history, as "the toughest town in the west." At that place the picture will reveal the famous "peace commission," composed of the greatest gunmen that ever lived—"Wild Bill" Hickok, Bat Masterson, Wyatt Earp, Charlie Bassett and Bill Tighlman, Luke Short and Doc Holliday. It is a matter of history that "Wild Bill" Hickok put away his guns after reigning as marshal of three Kansas towns because he had to kill so many bad men in the line of duty. Only at the demand of Bat Masterson did he refill his holsters to help clean up Dodge City. The ensuing "fight of the water barrels" was the greatest gun fight known to western history.

Bret Harte immortalized Salomy Jane, but it has remained for William S. Hart to dig up the historical facts necessary to immortalize Calamity Jane, the woman who loved "Wild Bill" Hickok. She lies buried beside him at Deadwood, where he was killed in 1876.

See the clipping