The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A sports history piece recounts the 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey heavyweight fight in San Francisco, where Wyatt Earp served as referee. Earp stopped the one-sided bout and awarded victory to Sharkey on a foul, despite many spectators believing no foul had occurred.
The Topeka State Journal · 2 December 1914 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
821 Kansas Avenue.
fake fight in Australia, when he laid down to Jim Hall. Later he stopped Hall in four rounds at New Orleans. After his fight with Dan Creedon, another Australian, in the Crescent City in 1894, Fitz announced his entrance into the heavyweight ranks, as a competitor for the title. He started proceedings by putting Peter Maher to sleep in the first round at Langtry, Tex., early in 1896.
See moreSee less
Then came the decisive battle with Sharkey—and Ruby Robert lost. For eight rounds Fitzsimmons bombarded the big sailor fore and aft. Although Tom was not lacking in cleverness, he was only a punching bag for nimble Bob. Fitz was already doping out schemes for investing the ten thousand, while sending the sailor sprawling with sledgehammer body blows, when the referee, Wyatt Earp, stopped the slaughter and awarded the victory to Sharkey on a foul. A lot of people present, gifted with good eyesight, openly declared there wasn't any foul—that it was only a figment of the imagination. But the referee said there was, and that settled it, and the records show the result as Fitz's first defeat.
But if Sharkey got the decision, Fitz got the glory, and he was universally declared to be the man to fight Corbett for the title. "Gentleman Jim" wasn't particularly anxious to test conclusions with Ruby Robert, but public opinion forced him to it, and in 1897, at Carson City, the great battle was staged, with what result the wise reader wots of. After losing his title to the giant Jeffries, Fitzsimmons fought Sharkey again, at Coney Island, and knocked him out in the second round. After that battle with Fitz in San Francisco, Sharkey whipped Jim Corbett, and in two long battles with Jeff came near holding his own with the big bear.