The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.
A newspaper sports column listing famous boxing upsets recalls how Wyatt Earp, refereeing the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout in 1896, awarded Sharkey the win on a foul despite Fitzsimmons being the heavy favorite. The piece notes Fitzsimmons later beat Sharkey legitimately in a rematch at Coney Island.
The Evening Times · 11 June 1910 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
rooms. Sharkey-Fitz Fight. "Another tremendous fistic upset happened when Wyatt Earp handed Tom Sharkey the decision over Bob Fitzsimmons back in 1896. That fight took place one year prior to Fitz' victory over Corbett. Bob was at his best. Sharkey, a youngster, was just becoming prominent as a fighter. Fitz figured a 1 to 10 shot and there was a ton of money bet on him at short odds. Earp's decision was costly to Fitz' followers. Fitz was always Sharkey's master and knocked him stiff in the second round of their fight at Coney Island.
See moreSee less
But that didn't get anything for the boys who backed Fitz to win the night Earp handed Sharkey the decision on a foul. "Another heavily backed favorite who gave the fight fans an awful bumping was Terry McGovern, who lost to Young Corbett. McGovern was supposed to be invincible. He had gone down the line and whipped everything of his weight in the world. W. H. Rothwell, a Denver boxer, who called himself Young Corbett, was thought to be mentally unbalanced