As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

March 1910

3 articles

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A 1910 sports feature by Robert Edgren retells the story of the 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight in San Francisco, focusing on why notorious gunfighter Wyatt Earp was chosen as referee. It describes Earp's reputation and the circumstances, including disputes over hand bandages just before the bout began.

Evening Star · 13 March 1910 · page 19 · transcribed from the page image

By Robert Edgren.

Few great battles in the ring have been surrounded by so many peculiar circumstances as the fight between Tom Sharkey and Bob Fitzsimmons in San Francisco, December 2, 1896. The ins and outs of that fight and the much discussed decision are known to few men, and not one of those who know the true story has ever given the facts to the public. It is a story beginning with the stormy career of Wyatt Earp, a notorious gun fighter, last surviving member of a family that "died with its boots on," and ending with a scene in Judge Sanderson's courtroom.

See moreSee less

I happened, through a curious chain of circumstances, to achieve an intimate acquaintance with Wyatt Earp long before the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons match was made.

When the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight came along Dave Nagle had left San Francisco, and Earp was no longer a

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This passage retells the famous 1896 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing match in which Wyatt Earp served as referee under pressure from promoters backed by gun law. It narrates round-by-round action, highlighting Sharkey's repeated fouls that Earp allegedly failed to penalize, foreshadowing the controversial decision that would follow.

Evening Star · 13 March 1910 · page 19 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

SHARKEY-FITZ FIGHT

ball tickets through the Yale University post office brought the business of that office, excluding money orders, up to $30,000, the equivalent of most cities of 20,000 inhabitants.

From the Boston Herald. "The man who is tryin' with all his might to look into the future is jest a-hurtin' his eyesight for the presunt."

See moreSee less

"Mr. Speaker," he pipe voice, "there is just one thi give us and we would all a "And what is that, sir?" "They could give us a rea

fourth Sharkey fouled continually, but only succeeded in making Fitzsimmons angry. Fitz smashed Sharkey's nose with fierce right handers. The amount of punishment that Sharkey took was marvelous.

At the beginning of the fifth Fitzsimmons crushed Sharkey's nose again, and the sailor seized him about the legs and threw him violently to the floor. It was a palpable foul, but Earp did nothing. Fitzsimmons gashed Sharkey's eye with a right hander. Sharkey clinched and struck foul blows repeatedly, while the crowd yelled in anger. Earp was blind to the fouling. Fitz broke away and knocked Sharkey clean through the ropes, and then, leaning over, helped him back again gallantly. Tom barely lasted through the

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This account recounts the famous 1896 Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight where referee Wyatt Earp declared a foul against Fitzsimmons in the eighth round, despite Fitzsimmons having clearly knocked Sharkey out cold. The crowd erupted in outrage, witnesses including Olympic Club president Harrison later testified no foul had occurred, and Earp quickly fled the ring after awarding the fight and $10,000 check to Sharkey.

Evening Star · 13 March 1910 · page 19 · transcribed from the page image

the fight. had been even money that the sailor wouldn't last the seven. Just before the fight began betting commissioners had flooded the Mechanics' pavilion and circulated about among the [5,0]00 spectators offering rolls of gold coin on Sharkey to last seven rounds at even money. and to win the fight at 1 to 3. The money didn't appear until Wyatt Earp was in the ring. All through this seventh round Sharkey clasped Fitzsimmons about the legs. wrestled. struck constantly in the clinches (which was against their agreement) and fouled in a dozen ways.

See moreSee less

He should have been disqualified on a dozen different occasions. but Earp wasn't there to disqualify Sharkey. Tom was still clinching and slugging in the clinches when the round ended amid a raging tumult of protest from the spectators. Now came the eighth round. The fight had been scheduled for ten. Sharkey

See the clipping