As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

November 1908

2 articles

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

A sportswriter's anecdote column claims Bat Masterson once ran Virgil Earp out of Dodge City at gunpoint, prompting Wyatt Earp to ride up to confront Masterson over it. The story is framed as an example of reckless pride, part of a larger piece on gamblers' and fighters' superstitions and legends.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Times · 26 November 1908 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

the job he started out for, and only a year afterward met so onery a death as falling from a six-mule wagon and having the wheels pass over his head.

"I also know of a very well-known bad man of the Southwest, Wyatt Earp, who deliberately and recklessly gave so noted a killer as Bat Masterson the edge on him in the heat of an extreme soreness against Masterson, who was then the marshal of Dodge City.

See moreSee less

"Bat" Masterson's "Argument"

"There were a number of the Earp boys, and one of them, Virgil, upon the occasion of a visit to Dodge, had been told by Masterson that that section was too far north for any of the Earps, and recommended Virgil Earp to get back to the cactus country quick and sudden. Masterson, in fact, enforced this recommendation at the point of one of his guns, and Virgil didn't see any sense in arguing against that kind of persuasion. So he ducked out of Dodge, but when he got down to Arizona he told his brother Wyatt, the hardest nut of that family, how Masterson had given him the hot-foot out of Dodge.

"Wyatt rode right up to Dodge to see Masterson about it. Wyatt Earp had never met Bat Masterson, but he had all kinds of contempt and scorn for the marshal of Dodge, as he had for any man who did all his slaughtering in the name of the law. He looked upon any man who got behind the screen of the law's authority to do his gun fighting as a piece of paste, and it was for the purpose of expressing this opinion to Bat Masterson that he hurried up to Dodge.

"As soon as Wyatt Earp got into Dodge he made hurried inquiry as to where he'd be able to find Masterson, and somebody told him that Bat was playing seven-up in the back room of Pack Wingate's hotel bar. Earp hiked for Wingate's like a button drummer for an early morning train. He clomped into Wingate's bar and asked the barkeep which of the two seven-up players at the table was Masterson. The barkeep nodded in the direction of the marshal. Earp got over to the seven-up table in a couple of strides. He gave the table a bang with his fist that made the cards dance, and he stuck his face within four inches of Masterson's.

How Wyatt Earp Answered It

"'You're a law-murderin' son of a coyote, Masterson,' Earp said to the marshal of Dodge, 'and for two bits and a poncho I'd take them law guns away from you and run 'em down your throat.'

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Grand Forks, N.D.

The passage recounts a legendary story of Wyatt Earp traveling to Dodge City to confront Bat Masterson after Masterson allegedly ran Earp's brother Virgil out of town. Earp reportedly disarmed himself to taunt Masterson, who backed down, reinforcing Earp's reputation as a fearless gunfighter unlike lawmen who relied on official authority.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Times · 26 November 1908 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

"Masterson looked flustered. He didn't know Earp, but he saw that the man who was talking to him was the real thing.

" 'And I'll give you this much the best of it, at that, you squaw's dog,' said Earp.

See moreSee less

"Then he deliberately pulled both guns from his belt, slammed them down on the table beside Bat Masterson, the killing marshal of Dodge, and stepped five paces back from the table, feeling of his knife.

"Far from wanting an edge, Earp was deliberately giving the edge to the man who at that time had the record for his quickness on the trigger and the number of his killings.

"But Masterson caved—it wasn't the first nor the last time he caved either.

" 'Oh, behave,' he said, weakly and hoarsely, to the infuriated Earp.

"Earp walked back to the table, picked up his guns, stuck them in his

See the clipping