As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

July 1907

2 articles

Tonopah Bonanza · Butler, Nev.

A folksy 1907 column uses a gossip-tree conceit to retell the story of the 1896 Sharkey vs. Fitzsimmons boxing match in San Francisco, where Wyatt Earp served as referee. It recounts the controversial foul decision against Fitzsimmons and the ensuing uproar, including hired lawyer Kowalski's efforts to defend the outcome.

Tonopah Bonanza · 27 July 1907 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

great night life in the old days of San Francisco, where there were as many suckers as the sands that run down to the sea. Yea, it was said, a sucker was born every minute. A gladiator named Sharkey, who was a son of the sea, and a son of a gun with the mitts, was mated to meet in the arena, a son of Vulcan, named Fitzsimmons, who was mighty at the forge and the bellows, not the bellows which emits the hot air of the desert, but the bellows of the blast. And the umpire, who was known in the language of the arena as the referee, was a son of a gun, and no mistake. He was Wyatt Earp, and he was from Arizona. Enough said.

The night of the meeting the arena was packed from the ringside to the roofside. The "suckers" arose tier upon tier, to say nothing of the policemen, who had the best seats in the house. Fitzsimmons, the son of Vulcan, had a great reputation. He was the champion of the ring, and all the wise ones bet their money on the blacksmith. Well, it was a fake, and the wise ones lost heavily, and those in the know, reaped a harvest of "foul" gotten money.

See moreSee less

There was a great roar made by some of the papers, and a doctor was found to make the foul of Sharkey good. Fitzsimmons hired a lawyer, who was great with the hot air, and the papers teemed with interviews, which made the copies sizzle as they slid off the press, and they sold while they were still hot. This lawyer was called Kowalski, Colonel Kowalski—not that he was a fierce warrior, but that he had once rode a horse, and was on a governor's staff. The colonel was afflicted with an ailment called the sleep disease. It was the strangest thing in the world. He would go sound asleep while at the show, or in church, or while he was conversing with one. He had been known to go to sleep at the bar while taking a drink.

But when he was awake, he made up for lost time, for he was a wonder at the bar, and he could whack out the queen's English in wonderful shape. Wyatt Earp had never been talked about as this disciple of Blackstone cracked it to him in the newspapers. The referee felt that his gun was getting rusty, and that he must shoot some one to keep up his reputation. Looking over the list of his villifiers, it occurred to him that Kowalski was the easiest mark, and then, besides, the colonel weighed 300 pounds, and as he lived in the same hotel, he would not have far to go. Accordingly, one night, when the earth was peaceful, and the moon was smiling on land and sea, he entered the elevator of the Baldwin hotel, and going to Kowalski's door softly knocked, and was bidden to enter. The colonel was alone. Ha!

"Colonel," began Mr. Earp, softly making sure that his gun was in

See the clipping

Tonopah Bonanza · Butler, Nev.

A humorous retelling describes Wyatt Earp confronting a man named Kowalski over newspaper accusations about a rigged boxing decision involving Fitzsimmons, gun drawn and ready for a showdown. The confrontation fizzles comically when Earp discovers his target has fallen asleep, snoring through the entire tense standoff, and only learns of the man's narcolepsy days later.

Tonopah Bonanza · 27 July 1907 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Arizona gun-fighter, who had many nothes on his gun, stood erect, gun in hand, looking down at his victim. He waited, and the silence was so intense, the stillness so awful, that a nickel might have been heard dropping in the slot.

A snore broke the awful stillness.

See moreSee less

The gun-fighter started back, then looked forward, and gazed into the face of Kowalski, with lowered gun and startled visage. The colonel was sound asleep.

A feeling of awe stole over Earp. He had never known of an experience like this. He looked, but there was no sign of an awakening. He thrust his gun out of sight, and quietly taking up his hat, stole softly to the door. He turned once to assure himself that he was in his right senses; then made a bolt for the corridor. He stopped at the Baldwin bar to take a jolt for his shattered nerves, and then ran all the way home and told his wife that he had met the bravest man in the world.

"I went to his room and talked

See the clipping