As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

January 1907

3 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report discusses the shortage of competent boxing referees and names George Siler of Chicago as the best remaining active one, citing his recent handling of the Gans-Nelson fight. It also references the past trials of other referees including Wyatt Earp and John Dolly, noting their checkered reputations in officiating prizefights.

The Sun · 6 January 1907 · page 33

GEORGE SILER OF CHICAGO CONSIDERED THE BEST

Well el Potted Pote at A te t the te Rniet RBN at Well Wr at Hennt HOB HOBett n nNt Nt sad a cool 001 IlradedTribulations ItedTbulaUoR of oflloncxt oflleneat r rleRet lloncxt leRet Jena OM Kelly Kel and al Boldant Bldn of ofW erfU stWyatt W Wyatt fU > att Earp ErG John Dolly Dal a Former Star StarGood 8tarOood StarOood Oood competent cmptent boxing boxn rofereei referee rre arescarce ore orescarce a la scarce nowadays noways Of the men active tivein tiveinpdn In Inpresiding inpresiding presiding pdn over the championship glove gloveflghta slve slvefht glovefights fights fht during d the last lt chponp ten tn or fifteen ft yearsOeorge years yearsGeorge eas easOele

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

This sports feature surveys famous boxing referees like George Siler and Tim Hurst, recounting the Corbett-Sullivan title fight and other championship bouts. Wyatt Earp is named in the subheadline as a notably 'bad' ring official, though the surviving text cuts off before detailing his refereeing history.

Los Angeles Herald · 13 January 1907 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

GREAT REFEREES VERY SCARCE STIRRING SCENE WHEN JOHN L WENT DOWN

Earp Bad M[a]n of the Squared Circle

Good, competent boxing referees are scarce nowadays. Of the men active in presiding over the championship glove fights during the last ten or fifteen years George Siler of Chicago is

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The article recalls Wyatt Earp's refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in San Francisco, where he awarded the bout to Sharkey on a foul call that onlookers branded 'highway robbery.' It claims Earp carried a gun into the ring and had been instructed in advance to favor Sharkey, implying the fight was fixed.

Los Angeles Herald · 13 January 1907 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Referee Saves Corbett

It was the Corbett-Sharkey fight at the Lenox Athletic club several years later that gave Kelly a black eye in the estimation of ring followers. When Corbett, beaten to a standstill, had his second, Con McVey, jump into the ring in the tenth round to save him. Kelly should have decided Sharkey the winner then and there on a foul under the strict wording of the rules. Kelly, and don't depend on me to help you escape it!" Sharkey knocked the Kid out in the tenth round.

See moreSee less

Honest John Kelly was another well known referee, but he was always in hot water. Kelly, once a National league baseball umpire and a good one, too, went down to Jacksonville to referee the Corbett-Mitchell fight.

When John got into the ring he saw in the crowd some of the toughest customers in the world. They had guns in their hip pockets and were well supplied with whisky and money which they bet on Corbett. Kelly was introduced to the mob and looked nervous.

Corbett Fouls Mitchell

Corbett, trained to the hour, had a personal grudge against Mitchell and was ready to fly off at a tangent. Mitchell knew this and was also fully aware that he was in for a good beating, as the Englishman at that time had entered the back number class.

So as soon as the fight was under way Mitchell began to apply all sorts of vile epithets to Corbett, which soon made the latter fairly crazy with rage. In a sharp mixup in the second round Mitchell fell to the floor. Corbett, a perfect wild man, landed a punch on the Englishman's head while the latter was still down, committing a clean cut foul.

"Foul! Foul!" yelled the men in Mitchell's corner and the crowd leaped up in an uproar. All eyes were on Kelly. He saw whisky bottles and guns brandished on all sides and he lost no time in arriving at the conclu[sion that no foul had been committed]

ring with a c[illegible] He had receiv[illegible] the fight to Sh[illegible] was there wit[illegible] proper time ar[illegible]

When Sharf[illegible] agony Earp d[illegible] and jumped o[illegible] wild scene. Bu[illegible] to intercept hi[m] of Earp since.

WITH $60,0[illegible] ON [illegible]

NEW YOR[K] in securities a[illegible] mond I. Blakes[illegible] sau street, ma[illegible] and machinery[illegible] tor's theater, and Broadway[illegible] Watson Raine, gineer, at wor[illegible] turned over the[illegible] him he would[illegible] about $20,000[illegible] legacy from [illegible] Raine's mothe[r] holder of Can[illegible] leaving one-fo[illegible] engineer.

Raine took t[illegible] year's explana[illegible] kept right on from 7 to 5 o'c[illegible] told his employ[illegible] to act as eng[illegible] until he dies [illegible] guns brandished on all sides and he lost no time in arriving at the conclusion that no foul had been committed. This ruling saved Corbett and also the money that had been wagered on him. Kelly told some friends afterward that he was lucky to get out of Jacksonville alive.

Referee Saves Corbett

It was the Corbett-Sharkey fight at the Lenox Athletic club several years later that gave Kelly a black eye in the estimation of ring followers. When Corbett, beaten to a standstill, had his second, Con McVey, jump into the ring in the tenth round to save him. Kelly should have decided Sharkey the winner then and there on a foul under the strict wording of the rules. Kelly,

See the clipping