As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

July 1906

2 articles

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis. · and 3 other papers

Fitzsimmons recounts his version of the controversial 1896 bout refereed by Wyatt Earp, claiming Sharkey faked injury after a foul decision and that Earp fled the ring with the purse. He describes later proving in court that Sharkey's camp staged the injury, though the judge ruled against him anyway.

Grant County Herald · 14 July 1906 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

FITZSIMMONS AND SHARKEY AFFAIR

When I told the story of the Sharkey fight I omitted a lot of things because I couldn't see any useful purpose in telling them. Since then, as I've said I've had a few letters and I'm going to answer those by opening the subject again. I'm going to take the Sharkey fight first, because it came first, and some of the things that occurred there had a bearing on the Carson City business.

I tried to let Wyatt Earp down easy, but it doesn't seem to be appreciated, so I'll say he acted like a yellow cur, in spite of his record. I knocked Tom Sharkey out fair and square, and Earp knew it, but when it came to announcing the decision he never made it. In fact no decision was ever rendered outside of the one I made myself. When I dropped Sharkey and he lay there like a log until his seconds picked him up, Earp merely walked over to his corner, put the check for $20,000 in the hands of Tom's seconds and walked out of the ring and out of the building.

See moreSee less

He didn't have the nerve to stay there and face the music, in spite of the fact that he wore a gun. I knew then for absolutely certain that I'd been trimmed, and it was myself who called for order and shouted to the crowd:

"The referee says I've lost on a foul, gentlemen."

All this time Tom lay like a dead man, until a certain man well known in San Francisco came down from his seat in the balcony and stooped over him, possibly five minutes after Earp had left the building. As I say, he stooped over him and his words are as plain to me now as they were then. He said:

"Put your hands on your abdomen and groan as if you were in great pain."

Those weren't the exact words, for I can't give them here, but they are close enough for all practical use. In the fog that was hanging over him Sharkey heard them, anyway, and did as he was told. He drew up his legs and his groans could be heard all over the ring. I said before that I didn't think he was in on the original play. I can say that still, but he was in on the finish to it, and did just what he was told. I know and proved later in court that the doctor the Sharkey

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 24 September 1905
  • River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 29 March 1906
  • The Virginia Enterprise · Virginia, Minn. · 25 May 1906

The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.

In a syndicated column, boxer Jim Corbett recounts financial misfortunes suffered by Bob Fitzsimmons throughout his career. He cites referee Wyatt Earp's disqualification of Fitzsimmons for an alleged foul during his fight with Tom Sharkey as one of the worst such setbacks.

The Spokane Press · 14 July 1906 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WHEN THEY HANDED POOR OLD BOB MANY AND MANY A JUICY LEMON

rived in Seattle Thursday night. Gans is there for the purpose of putting a quietus on the championship aspirations of another gentleman of color, Dave Holly and the two will meet at Pleasant Beach about July 23 or 25.

Both men will go into training at once. Gans will do all his work at Pleasant Beach while Holly will occupy the same quarters at Madison park that he used for training purposes when he fought Rufe Turner.

See moreSee less

Gans feels confident of winning and intends, after disposing of Holly, to take on Battling Nelson.

NORDYKE JOINS SAINTS.

By Jas. J. Corbett.

When Fitz cast off this mortal coil with him will go a record of financial setbacks that few fighters have experienced.

Recently I wrote a story about the unlucky John C. Heenan. Well Heenan got his from officials in the ring. With Bob Fitzsimmons such was not the case.

In the ring Bob generally managed to get what was due him. He always had a manager who could hold his own, at least while the fight was going on. But after the fight was over, many a trick and deceit have been played upon Fitz. Of course the latest of his misfortunes was the experience at

See the clipping