As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

March 1904

1 article

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A sports column about Tom Sharkey's boxing career cites his disputed decision win over Fitzsimmons, noting that Wyatt Earp, 'the gun fighter and general all round bad man,' was the referee who controversially awarded Sharkey the fight. The piece argues this was 'the rankest robbery ever perpetrated inside the ropes,' using it to question Sharkey's legitimate standing in the sport.

The Indianapolis Journal · 7 March 1904 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

The best example of Munroe's chances against the big champion may be furnished by the ring career of the man he has just beaten, Tom Sharkey.

There never was a fighter so lucky as the sailor. He obtained a reputation that always kept him in the foreground of championship possibility by beating such men as Fitzsimmons, Corbett and McCoy, a trio that commanded the greatest respect from ring followers.

See moreSee less

And how?

Sharkey's decision over Fitz was the rankest robbery ever perpetrated inside the ropes. Everybody knows that who knows anything of ring history. Wyatt Earp, the gun fighter and general all round "bad man," was the referee and carried through the job. No one had the nerve to dispute him.

But Sharkey went on record as having a decision over the mighty Fitzsimmons. How much he was entitled to it was shown when they met a second time and Fitz disposed of him in two rounds, knocking him out clean.

Corbett lost to Thomas on a foul. Con McVey jumped in the ring—said he didn't mean to—and again was Sharkey victor over a better man.

He certainly did knock out McCoy. But it was a fluke. McCoy was making a chopping block of him and winning as he pleased—so easily, in fact, that he was cutting up monkeyshines in the ring and one of the sailor's unaimed wallops connected with the careless "Kid's" jaw.

His one really good fight was with Jeffries at Coney Island. He went twenty-five rounds and took a terrific beating.

Suppose Munroe has the same luck?

Then, again, if comparisons count for anything Munroe comes in pretty strong. Jeffries could not put Sharkey out in twenty-five rounds. Munroe would have had the sailor on his face dead to the world in at least two more rounds of their fight in Philadelphia. Nobody who saw the fight will think otherwise.

Jeffries has improved greatly since his battle with Sharkey. No question of that.

Munroe has to absorb before he meets

See the clipping