As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

December 1903

6 articles

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

The report recounts a tale of Wyatt Earp, once a famed Western gunfighter, going to Dawson City in the Klondike and causing trouble in saloons while drunk. A small Canadian Mounted Police officer confronted him and demanded he surrender his gun, with Earp initially responding defiantly.

Lewiston Evening Teller · 4 December 1903 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TAMED WYATT EARP Western Bad Man Cowed in Dawson City by Member of Canada Police

Since Wyatt Earp, once famous as a gun fighter in Arizona and California, went up into the Klondike very little

See the clipping

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

The story describes Wyatt Earp getting drunk and shooting up saloons and faro banks in Dawson, Yukon, until a small Northwest Mounted Police officer calmly demands his gun. Earp fires wildly at the ceiling but is ultimately cowed by the officer's unflappable politeness and insistence that he surrender or bury the weapon.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 212 days later.

Wrong

Lewiston Evening Teller · 4 December 1903 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Since Wyatt Earp, once famous as a gun fighter in Arizona and California, went up into the Klondike very little has been heard of him by the outside world. Earp was never a man who could easily be tamed says the New York Sun, consequently a story told of his suppression a few weeks ago by a diminutive cockney member of the Canada mounted police will be interesting to some of his friends here.

"Earp drifted into Dawson several months ago full of a determination to get action," said a San Francisco man to some of Earp's old western friends the other night. He discarded his store clothes, get himself a flannel shirt, a pair of leather trousers and a sombrero, stuck a gun in his belt, loaded up on bad whisky and went around the saloons and faro banks ballyragging everybody who would stand for his game, and taking a few shots at some men who resented it.

See moreSee less

"Well, the fact that Earp was hitting it up got to the ears of a little five-foot cockney member of the Canada mounted police, one of whose duties it was to see that Dawson behaved itself. Now, Earp didn't know much about the Canada mounted police and the manner of men who compose it.

"Therefore when he was interrupted in the gentle amusement of clearing out a faro bank in Dawson one night by this little chap coming up to him with a request that he give him his gun, he opened his mouth and his eyes very wide, swore a mighty round of oaths and asked the little fellow in riding boots and cap if he wanted to visit hades at once or wait a few hourse.

"Earp was somewhat surprised when the little fellow simply smiled politely and said:

"'You must give me the gun or bury it, sir,' and extended his hand for the weapon.

"Earp swore some more, but not quite so eloquently, for all the while the little man was smiling calmly in his face. Finally, Earp, clean flustered by the situation pulled his gun from his belt and fired it three times into

See the clipping

The Cook County Herald · Grand Marais, Minn.

The article recounts a secondhand story about Wyatt Earp allegedly causing trouble in Dawson City saloons before being confronted and subdued by a small Canadian Mounted Police officer. The tale is presented as having been relayed by a San Francisco man to Earp's old friends.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Cook County Herald · 19 December 1903 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

TAMED WYATT EARP WESTERN BAD MAN COWED IN DAWSON CITY

Since Wyatt Earp, once famous as a gun fighter in Arizona and California, went up into the Klondike very little has been heard of him by the outside world. Earp was never a man who could easily be tamed, consequently a story told of his suppression a few weeks ago by a diminutive cockney member of the Canada mounted police will be interesting to some of his friends here.

"Earp drifted into Dawson several months ago full of a determination to get action," said a San Francisco man to some of Earp's old Western friends the other night. He discarded his store clothes, got himself a flannel shirt, a pair of leather trousers and a sombrero, stuck a gun in his belt, loaded up on bad whisky and went around the saloons and faro banks ballyragging everybody who would stand for his game, and taking a few shots at some men who resented it.

See moreSee less

"Well, the fact that Earp was hitting it up got to the ears of a little five-foot cockney member of the Canada mounted police, one of whose duties it was to see that Dawson behaved itself. Now, Earp didn't know much about the Canada mounted police and the manner of men who compose it.

"Therefore when he was interrupted in the gentle amusement of cleaning out a faro bank in Dawson one night by this little chap coming up to him with a request that he give him his gun, he opened his mouth and his eyes very wide, swore a mighty round of oaths and asked the little fellow in riding boots and cap if he wanted to visit hades at once or wait a few hours.

"Earp was somewhat surprised when the little fellow simply smiled politely and said:

"'You must give me the gun or bury it, sir,' and extended his hand for the weapon.

"Earp swore some more, but not quite so eloquently, for all the while the little man was smiling calmly in his face. Finally, Earp, clean flustered by the situation pulled his gun from his belt and fired it three times into the ceiling, whereupon the little man, still smiling said:

"'Now, you'll have to bury it or I'll have to take it away from you, sir.'

"'Take my gun away from me!' roared Earp.

"'Exactly,' said the little man. 'Maybe you doubt I'll do it, sir?'

"The witnesses of this colloquy did not know what to expect from Earp, but they knew what would happen pretty soon if Earp became defiant, because in Dawson people know what to expect from the Canadian mounted police. They knew, too, that this little cockney had squelched every bad man who had ever come into Dawson, and they didn't doubt that he would attend to Earp.

"However, a crisis was averted by Earp's putting his gun back into his belt and starting to leave the place. Just as he got to the door the policeman walked over and tapped him on the shoulder.

"'I beg your pardon, sir,' he said, 'but if you come out with a gun in sight to-morrow, I shall have to take it away from you.'

"Earp turned purple with rage, but he had no nerve left when he confronted that politely smiling face. He roared a few oaths back at the amused crowd in the gambling house, and then went to the Golden Lion saloon, where he took a few drinks and proceeded to tell what he would do the next day when the cockney tried to take his gun.

"'Why, I'll blow him full of holes,' he said.

"'Yes,' said a listener, 'but when you put a hole in him you put a hole in the British empire, which it will fill with two men. If you kill them, four will take their places. In the end, Earp, you will have the whole British army here if necessary just to put you out. Better let him alone.'

"The next day, Earp, very sober and very thoughtful, appeared on the streets of Dawson in the store clothes he came to town with. Almost the first person he struck was the cockney, who had evidently been waiting for him, prepared to take his gun away if he showed it. As soon as he saw Earp he stepped up very politely and said:

"'Thank you, sir,' and then turned on his heel.

"Earp hasn't been deuce high as a bad man in Dawson since that incident. Incidentally, I might say, if he had elected to mix it up with the cockney he'd be sleeping under an epitaph to-night; for of all the real tough men I ever saw, either for or against law and order, those Canada mounted police are the limit."—New York Sun.

See the clipping

The Cook County Herald · Grand Marais, Minn.

The article recounts a story of Wyatt Earp in Dawson City being confronted by a polite but firm Northwest Mounted Police officer over carrying a gun. After bluster and threats, Earp backs down the next day, and the piece claims he lost his reputation as a tough man in Dawson after the incident.

The Cook County Herald · 19 December 1903 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

DAWSON CITY.

Since Wyatt Earp, once famous as a gun fighter in Arizona and California, went up into the Klondike very little has been heard of him by the outside world. Earp was never a man who could easily be tamed, consequently a story told of his suppression a few weeks ago by a diminutive cockney member of the Canada mounted police will be interesting to some of his friends here.

"Earp drifted into Dawson several months ago full of a determination to get action," said a San Francisco man to some of Earp's old Western friends the other night. He discarded his store clothes, got himself a flannel shirt, a pair of leather trousers and a sombrero, stuck a gun in his belt, loaded up on bad whisky and went around the saloons and faro banks ballyragging everybody who would stand for his game, and taking a few shots at some men who resented it.

See moreSee less

"Well, the fact that Earp was hitting it up got to the ears of a little five-foot cockney member of the Canada mounted police, one of whose duties it was to see that Dawson behaved itself. Now, Earp didn't know much about the Canada mounted police and the manner of men who compose it.

"Therefore when he was interrupted in the gentle amusement of cleaning out a faro bank in Dawson one night by this little chap coming up to him with a request that he give him his gun, he opened his mouth and his eyes very wide, swore a mighty round of oaths and asked the little fellow in riding boots and cap if he wanted to visit hades at once or wait a few hours.

"Earp was somewhat surprised when the little fellow simply smiled politely and said: "'You must give me the gun or bury it, sir,' and extended his hand for the weapon. "Earp swore some more, but not quite so eloquently, for all the while the little man was smiling calmly in his face. Finally, Earp, clean flustered by the situation pulled his gun from his belt and fired it three times into the ceiling, whereupon the little man, still smiling said: "'Now, you'll have to bury it or I'll have to take it away from you, sir.' "'Take my gun away from me!' roared Earp. "'Exactly,' said the little man. 'Maybe you doubt I'll do it, sir?' "The witnesses of this colloquy did not know what to expect from Earp, but they knew what would happen pretty soon if Earp became defiant, because in Dawson people know what to expect from the Canadian mounted police. They knew, too, that this little cockney had squelched every bad man who had ever come into Dawson, and they didn't doubt that he would attend to Earp.

"However, a crisis was averted by Earp's putting his gun back into his belt and starting to leave the place. Just as he got to the door the policeman walked over and tapped him on the shoulder. "'I beg your pardon, sir,' he said, 'but if you come out with a gun in sight to-morrow, I shall have to take it away from you.' "Earp turned purple with rage, but he had no nerve left when he confronted that politely smiling face. He roared a few oaths back at the amused crowd in the gambling house, and then went to the Golden Lion saloon, where he took a few drinks and proceeded to tell what he would do the next day when the cockney tried to take his gun. "'Why, I'll blow him full of holes,' he said. "'Yes,' said a listener, 'but when you put a hole in him you put a hole in the British empire, which it will fill with two men. If you kill them, four will take their places. In the end, Earp, you will have the whole British army here if necessary just to put you out. Better let him alone.' "The next day, Earp, very sober and very thoughtful, appeared on the streets of Dawson in the store clothes he came to town with. Almost the first person he struck was the cockney, who had evidently been waiting for him, prepared to take his gun away if he showed it. As soon as he saw Earp he stepped up very politely and said: "'Thank you, sir,' and then turned on his heel. "Earp hasn't been deuce high as a bad man in Dawson since that incident. Incidentally, I might say, if he had elected to mix it up with the cockney he'd be sleeping under an epitaph to-night; for of all the real tough men I ever saw, either for or against law and order, those Canada mounted police are the limit."—New York Sun.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Butte Inter Mountain · Butte, Mont.

A reader's query asks how many times Sharkey and Fitzsimmons fought, prompting a recap of their two bouts. The response recounts the 1896 San Francisco fight in which referee Wyatt Earp disqualified Fitzsimmons for a foul after Sharkey went the distance.

The Butte Inter Mountain · 21 December 1903 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

SPORT GOSSIP

used the same pattern as that drawn by Maud S., and was five pounds heavier. It is understood Lou Dillon will make another attempt at a record next summer and will use a sulky exactly like the one used by Maud S.

To settle a bet, please state when and how often Sharkey and Fitzsimmons fought. —Subscriber. Twice. December 2, 1896, Mechanics' pavilion, San Francisco. Fitz to stop Sharkey in 10 rounds or forfeit a purse of $10,000. Sharkey went out in eight rounds, but Wyatt Earp disqualified Fitz on a foul. August 24, 1900, Coney Island. Fitz knocked out Sharkey in two rounds.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A San Francisco sports commentary about a proposed Sharkey-Munroe boxing match mentions in passing that Wyatt Earp once gave a corrupt decision favoring Sharkey over Fitzsimmons in San Francisco. The writer uses this old scandal to needle Sharkey's reluctance to fight in that city again.

The Indianapolis Journal · 26 December 1903 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

MUNROE AND SHARKEY SAN FRANCISCO, Dec. 25.--"Tom" Sharkey is matched with "Jack" Munroe, but the conditions of the match bar any of the San Francisco clubs from bidding for the contest. Sharkey had this inserted. Says "Alex." Greggains: "He says he wants none of 'Frisco. It was in 'Frisco that Wyatt Earp handed Sharkey a decision over Fitzsimmons. It was the rawest kind of a steal. But Sharkey evidently has grown more scrupulous, and he perhaps believes that he might get the better of it here and for that reason refuses to fight here.

See moreSee less

But where will he and Munroe come together if it isn't in this city? And that would, perhaps, be as long as any one would care to look at a pair of stiffs fight. This fellow Munroe has succeeded in digging up more buried fighters to meet him than any man ever identified with the game."

See the clipping