As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

July 1901

4 articles

The Western News · Stevensville, Mont.

The article reports that Warren Earp, called the last of a notorious stage-robbing gang led by the Earp brothers, was shot dead in an Arizona saloon by John Boyett after a long-running feud. It recounts a dramatic confrontation where Warren allegedly taunted Boyett before being killed, and claims Wyatt Earp now runs a gambling house in San Francisco.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Western News · 17 July 1901 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

KILLED MEN FOR FUN

Don't Clip the Wings. The clipping of wings is, to say the least, a cruel practice and often results in the loss or injury of our most valuable fowls is the sensible conclusion of a poultry writer in Home and Farm.

JULIAN EARP'S DUEL WITH CLAUTON.

See moreSee less

to avoid trouble with "Wicked Warren," but a few days before the final encounter Earp pressed his six-shooter against Boyett's belt, and, glaring into his eyes, said:

"You cattle-rustling coyote! If we ever meet again there'll be a killin'. Understan' that?"

There had been a feud for years between the old stage-robbing gang, of

See the clipping

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont. · and 1 other paper

This sensational 1901 account claims Warren Earp was gunned down by John Boyett after a long-running feud, embellished with invented dialogue, and portrays all four Earp brothers as leaders of a 'stage-robbing gang' at war with Tombstone cattle rustlers. It also falsely asserts Virgil Earp was killed in Tombstone and inflates the brothers' kill counts into myth.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Philipsburg Mail · 26 July 1901 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Made Tombstone's Reputation.

When the Earp brothers lived in Tombstone they did much toward making it a thrilling place of residence, for the four brothers were much in evidence thereabouts in the early '80's. In 1883, however, the community decided it had had enough of the quartet, and a solid front made up of six-shooters and Winchesters was presented to them. So they left Tombstone and migrated to Gunnison County. Finally they were run out of Gunnison, and Wyatt Earp migrated to California, while Warren clung to his native heath in Arizona.

See moreSee less

They had a sister, Jessie, who lived with them in Tombstone. She was known as the virtuous one of the family, Virgil as the oldest, Wyatt as the wisest, Julian as the bravest, and Warren as the most foolhardy. Virgil was killed in Tombstone and Julian in Gunnison.

All of the Earps were gun fighters for the love of it and men of prompt courage and bitter revenge. Each of them killed numerous men. Wyatt is credited with ten and Warren with fully as many. It used to be said in the Cochise country, round about Tombstone, that any of the Earps was fit to "pull and center" a shot in less than one-tenth of a second.

In the early '80's, when Virgil and Wyatt Earp led the stage robbers of Tombstone, "Ike" Clauton, Johnny Behan and Jack Ringo led the cattle rustlers. The Earps killed men for recreation and robbed stages for a livelihood, for there was no money in murder. The rustlers got their amusement in much the same way, but they devoted

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Western News · Stevensville, Mont. · 17 July 1901

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont. · and 1 other paper

This lurid retrospective claims the Earp brothers were themselves stage robbers in Tombstone, with Virgil as marshal secretly leading holdups in partnership with a Wells-Fargo agent while Warren posed as a guard. It paints both the Earps and their rivals as violent criminal factions locked in deadly rivalry, culminating in a tense standoff at the Birdcage Opera House.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Philipsburg Mail · 26 July 1901 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

EARP BROTHERS HOLDING UP AN ARIZONA STAGE.

Political office, too, had its charms for both factions, for, while Johnny Behan was the Democratic sheriff of Cochise County, Virgil Earp was the Republican marshal of Tombstone. And each side treated the other to many a murder.

Virgil Earp had a partnership with Barshel Williams, at that time the Wells-Fargo express agent at Tombstone. Williams would "tip off" the stages that he knew would hold the big money, and then Earp would plant his highwaymen in a convenient place and plunder the stage.

See moreSee less

Warren "Guarded" the Stage.

Warren Earp was an express stage company guard, and when his brother gave the command, "Hands up!" it was wonderful to see with what meekness the fierce-looking young guard threw up his hands. Then his brothers went through the express packages. There was never any shooting, for it was a family affair.

In these robberies the Earps often realized as much as $25,000, which they spent with a freedom that was considered royal in Tombstone. After each crime they organized themselves into a posse comitatus and received more money as a bonus for chasing themselves. In each case Virgil, the marshal, would enlist his three brothers and the notorious "Curly Bill" Earp, their cousin.

On one gala occasion in Birdcage Opera House of Tombstone, the two warring factions occupied the boxes on opposite sides of the house. When one side cheered or clapped hands, the other hissed. Sheriff Behan, "Ike" Clauton and "Jack" Ringo, with several followers, vied with the Earp brothers, "Curly Bill" and "Doc" Holliday. Whisky flowed like water, and excitement was at blood heat, when suddenly Clauton took exception to the boot of one of the Earps' followers, which reposed on the rail in front of the box. "Ike" promptly put a bullet through the offending member, and then there was bloody war. Twelve men were killed or wounded, but none of the Earps was even scratched.

Williams, the Wells-Fargo traitor, was seriously wounded in half a dozen place and, fully expecting to die, he worked up a little death-bed repentance and told how the Earps had been plundering stages and express packages for years.

This caused the Earps to fortify themselves in a small adobe hut on the

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Western News · Stevensville, Mont. · 17 July 1901

The Philipsburg Mail · Philipsburg, Mont.

The report describes the killing of Warren Earp by John Boyett in an Arizona saloon, framing the Earp brothers as a notorious stage-robbing gang in a long-running feud with cattle rustlers. It claims Wyatt Earp, the last surviving brother, now runs a tough gambling house in San Francisco.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.

Wrong

The Philipsburg Mail · 26 July 1901 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

KILLED MEN FOR FUN, WARREN EARP, OF A NOTORIOUS GANG

JULIAN EARP'S DUEL WITH CLAUTON.

to avoid trouble with "Wicked Warren," but a few days before the final encounter Earp pressed his six-shooter against Boyett's belt, and, glaring into his eyes, said:

See moreSee less

"You cattle-rustling coyote! If we ever meet again there'll be a killin'. Understan' that?"

There had been a feud for years between the old stage-robbing gang, of which the Earps were the leaders, and the cattle rustlers, of whom Boyett was one. One day Earp walked into a saloon where Boyett was drinking with some of his cattle-rustling friends.

"There's my gun, cur!" yelled Earp, tossing his Colt 45 into the air and deftly catching it again; "where's yours?"

"Ain't got it," was Boyett's reply.

See the clipping