As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

February 1900

5 articles

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A sports article about boxing matches moving to San Francisco jokes that a fight there might puzzle even 'the trained referee of the Wyatt Earp stripe,' referencing his notoriety as a boxing referee. This is a passing cultural reference rather than a direct report on Earp.

The Saint Paul Globe · 11 February 1900 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

to move at the termination of a battle. Jim and Jim are both original San Francisco products. It may puzzle even the trained referee of the Wyatt Earp stripe

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

In discussing a possible new Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout, the paper recalls their earlier famous fight, decided by referee Wyatt Earp amid an alleged foul blow from Fitzsimmons. The piece notes ongoing public demand for a rematch given the controversial outcome.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 February 1900 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

SHARKEY TO FIGHT FITZ. Sharkey has come out with a bold statement to the effect that he will make a match with Fitzsimmons, now that Jeffries is tied up with Corbett. Sharkey says he will agree to any reasonable terms named by the Cornishman. The unsatisfactory result of their battle at San Francisco, in which Referee Wyatt Earp and an alleged foul blow delivered by Fitz were the features, has caused a genral demand ever since for another meeting. Sharkey has undoubtedly improved since that memorable event, as he showed in his recent battles with Corbett and Jeffries, so that by defeating him Fitzsimmons would stick quite a feather in his cap.

See moreSee less

Sporting enthusiasts believe that if Sharkey and Fitz should come together they would draw more gate money than the coming encounter between Jeffries and Corbett, especially for the reason that there is a

See the clipping

The Evening Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A sports article about boxers Sharkey and McCoy avoiding a match with Fitzsimmons mentions that Sharkey wants a rematch with Fitzsimmons to prove the earlier contested decision, in which Wyatt Earp served as referee in San Francisco, was fair. The piece is primarily about contemporary boxing negotiations, with the Earp reference used as background context for Sharkey's motives.

The Evening Tribune · 22 February 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Accused by Sporting Men,

In making a match to fight at an early date McCoy and Sharkey are accused of dodging Fitzsimmons, who challenged both of them the other day and posted $5,000 as a guarantee of good faith. Sharkey says he will not take Fitz on because the latter wants to fight for a side stake, which is contrary to law, while McCoy declares that he wants to meet Sharkey in order to wipe out the defeat sustained at the hands of the Sailor a year ago. McCoy has repeatedly challenged Fitzsimmons for the middleweight championship, especially when Bob had other engage-

See the clipping

The Citizen · Frederick City, Md.

The report describes a card-game dispute between Jim Allison, Wyatt Earp, and Bat Masterson that nearly ended in gunplay, but Masterson proposed a shooting contest instead to settle who was right. The piece frames this as evidence of 'civilization's influence' on former Western gunfighters, recounting Masterson's reputed deadly reputation as Dodge City marshal.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Citizen · 23 February 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TWO BAD MEN.

ord as sure shots, and the lie was passed without bloodshed. The game was hearts—only for the drinks—and Allison had led a diamond. Earp played a heart on the trick, and was accused of making a misplay.

"You lie!" exclaimed Allison.

See moreSee less

In a second two hands reached for revolvers.

"Hold on, boys!" shouted Masterson. "This ain't Hassiampo Creek. We're not in a Prescott gambling house. If you want to shoot, I'll show you how to do it. If you win, Earp, Allison will have to apologize. If you win, Jim, Earp must acknowledge he's a liar."

The revolvers were not drawn. When Bat Masterson says a thing it generally goes. He filled thirty or forty graves when he was marshall of Dodge City, Kan., and both Earp and Allison were his assistants at the time. They had fought all over the Southwest with him, and they knew that he was prepared to back up any assertion that he made.

Accordingly, when Masterson led the way out of the saloon, Earp and Allison meekly followed him.

"I'm going to let you shoot," re-

See the clipping

The Citizen · Frederick City, Md.

The piece recounts an anecdote in which Bat Masterson settles a card-game dispute between Wyatt Earp and 'Allison' by having them shoot at targets in a gallery, recalling old Tombstone gunfights. The men later shoot the hat off Masterson's head as a joke before drinking champagne and resuming their card game.

The Citizen · 23 February 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TWO BAD MEN

the flying man in the heart, and the faint tingle of a bell was heard as the bullet struck. Then Earp's revolver went into action, and each of its bullets found its desired mark.

Masterson applauded the performance, and seemed to derive the utmost amusement from it.

See moreSee less

"This reminds me of old times!"

See the clipping