As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

June 1899

3 articles

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This sports column compares the records of Jeffries and Fitzsimmons ahead of their upcoming bout, using common opponents like Sharkey and Ruhlin as a gauge. It recalls that Wyatt Earp, refereeing the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, had controversially ruled a foul against Fitzsimmons after he knocked Sharkey out.

The Anaconda Standard · 4 June 1899 · page 20 · transcribed from the page image

As the sporting man puts it, "Records are well enough in their way, but frequently they don't weigh much."

That pretty fairly states the case with reference to Bob Fitzsimmons and Jim Jeffries, who will battle for the championship of the world in the building of the Coney Island Athletic club on Friday, June 9. Besides the purse of $20,000 which has been hung up by the organization, and the side bet, the amount of which is not given, it is said that the men will also receive a percentage from the exhibition of the moving pictures which will be taken during the progress of the "argument."

See moreSee less

It almost goes without saying that a champion has a better record, on paper at least, than the man who is anxious to usurp his title. And thus it is in the present case. Jeffries has really done nothing so far to warrant the assumption that he is able to whip Fitzsimmons. The possibility of his winning is predicated upon the fact that he has youth, strength and size on his side, and that Fitzsimmons, having been out of the ring for more than two years, may have taken a long slide in the direction of the "sere and yellow" all unknown to himself.

While efforts to gauge the relative merits of two prospective fistic disputants through the medium of men whom they have both met are seldom of value, it is the only course possible in the present instance. Sharkey is the one man to whom a line may be drawn from both directions. Jeffries fought Sharkey 20 rounds and won the decision on points, although it is generally conceded that the sailor was not hurt in the slightest degree and was in a condition to go on indefinitely when the bout expired by limitation. Again, Jeffries met Gus Ruhlin, the "Akron Giant," in a 20-round go, which resulted in a draw, the honors being easy, according to the testimony of the best judges present. But Sharkey put Ruhlin out with a single smash in the first round when he encountered Madden's would-be champion. Sharkey, on the other hand, was obliged to quit when he ran up against Fitzsimmon's fists, although Wyatt Earp, the referee, decided that Fitz had committed a foul.

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Boxer Tom Sharkey, discussing a potential match with champion Jeffries, mentions that Jeffries disparages Wyatt Earp's refereeing decision in an earlier fight. Sharkey counters by noting he also received an unfavorable decision from referee Alex Greggains.

The Record-Union · 12 June 1899 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

THE SAILOR PUGILIST. Sharkey Says He Will Meet Jefries in the Ring at Any Time. PASO ROBLES, June 11.—Tom Sharkey is sojourning here, having come to the springs ten days ago. In the course

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

In an interview about a potential fight with Jeffries, boxer Tom Sharkey recalls Wyatt Earp's disputed decision as referee in an earlier Fitzsimmons bout, using it to dismiss Jeffries' complaints. He contrasts it with a decision against him by referee Alex Greggains.

The San Francisco Call · 12 June 1899 · page 2

Western cities, leaving 1 for his home In Los Angeles on June 20. He will remain with his parents for three weeks, return ing to New York in time to sail for Eu rope on August L The Califomian will give exhibitions in the Alhamhra in Lon don and in Music Hall in Paris. On his return to the United States in Septem ber he will fight Sharkey If the sailor pu filist complies with the conditions named y him in connection with the match. Otherwise the champion will make his debut as an actor, appearing in a play entitled "A Rough River."

See moreSee less

PASO ROBLES, June 11.— In an inter view to-night at his quarters In Paso Robies Hotel Sharkey said concerning Jeffries' challenge: "I will meet him anywhere with the club offering tne largest purse, San Fran cisco preferred. 1 have as many friends in California as Jeffries has and I believe I can get a square deal - San Francisco. I am ready to post my forfeit any time and will fight in six weeks. Jeffries will not lean all over me as he did in his fight wirh old man Fitzsimmons. He talks about Wyatt Earp's decision, but he for about the time Alex Greggains put it all over me in his decision. T will meet him under Marquis of Queensberry rules, which call for a 24-foot ring. I want no 18-foot ring; no championship tight is ever held in an 18-foot ring. Jeffrie? wants all the purse or none, but before he wanted a 7.". and 2ii per cent division. But I'll ac commodate him; the whole purse to the winner suits me. I never felt better nor keener for a fight, and whenever Jeffries is ready I am ann my forfeit is ready to back my statement."

See the clipping